- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on March 22, 1937, during the Air Estimates debate, urging a settlement of Fleet Air Arm control and criticising the RAF expansion programme as less than half complete.
- Main themes
- Control of the Fleet Air Arm, principle of operational integrity, Admiralty and Air Ministry dispute, Lord Weir's reported threat to resign, Royal Air Force expansion shortfall, 44 per cent completion of the 1935 programme, skeleton squadrons, German first-line air strength, parity with Germany, Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, air defence of naval ports
- Duration
- ~22 min
- Words
- 2,687
- Sentences
- 93
- Readability
- 52
- Grade
- 12.9
- Syntax
- 3.23
- Vocabulary
- 2.02
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other93 sentences in 22 paragraphs
I should like to assure my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Hertford (Sir M. Sueter) that in any illustrative badinage which I may have used in debate, I have never had the slightest desire to reflect upon the great services which he rendered to the Navy and to the Air Force in his professional career. No one was more full of enterprise and audacity in the creation and in the implementing of ideas than he, and when I referred to him the other day, it was not in any personal sense, but only with a view to deprecating what I think are the undue claims put forward by the air, claims which really are now pushed to a point far beyond what the interests of this country warrant or indeed could sustain, claims which, taken at their full value, would seem to declare that that great source of our strength, the Navy—the battle fleet, and all the ancillary weapons and vessels in it—was obsolete, as it were brushed aside at a time when this is our main stock-in-trade, at a time when we are defenceless but for the gigantic strength of our naval force. It is against that kind of proposition, deployed not only by him but by many far less competent to speak than he, that I ventured to point out that recent experience, as far as we can measure it, in the Spanish civil war seems to show that navies have still a great deal of life in them.
2606
Curiously enough, I came across the other day a letter which was written when I first went to the Admiralty, in 1911, in which I was warned of the folly of building ironclad ships any longer, because in the next war, whenever it came, the lamentable position of Lord Fisher and Lord Charles Beresford, with their fleets, would be shown when they would be lying helplessly on the surface of the water while the deadly bombs descended in a continuous rain from the air. Well, it has not happened yet, and I am sure that one may be a good friend of the air, one may think that indeed it is the most important branch of our defences at the present time, and certainly the one to which the greatest efforts should be directed, without in the slightest degree diminishing the prestige of the Royal Navy, on which me must rely, at any rate, until our Air Force has reached some strength comparable to that of the Air Forces of European countries. Indeed, I may say that I have the greatest sympathy with my hon. and gallant Friend, and I do not think my sympathy has ever been more readily forthcoming than during the recent naval engagement which we have witnessed, when, just as the hon. and gallant Member was making head against the Dreadnought salvoes fired by the gallant Admiral of the Fleet behind me, he was so forcefully attacked in flank by the flotillas of the hon. and gallant Member for South Paddington (Vice-Admiral Taylor).
I hope that the urgency of a settlement of this question of the Fleet Air Arm is realised both by the Government and by the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence. It is all very well for the gallant Admiral opposite to say, "You must not raise these matters, because they only make ill will." What he means by that is that only his view must be expressed and that the opposite view must never find expression. But nothing will prevent this controversy going forward. It will go forward steadily until it is settled, and I do not believe that it is at all incapable of settlement. I hope it may be settled by the application of some clear principle and by drawing the necessary line of division in accordance with that principle. I have never thought for a moment that the Fleet Air Arm would be a rival of the Royal Air Force. It is more like divisional cavalry compared to a cavalry
2607
division—something like that proportion. You must give to the Fleet an air service over which it has full control, and which is intimately associated with it and with its special uses. I tried to suggest the other day what the line should be.
Certainly, I am no friend to extravagant claims on the part of the Admiralty. In my view, the Fleet should have only that air service which it requires for operations from ships of war at vessels floating on the blue water, and I would certainly give it the whole of the recruitment and training for that particular limited service. It seems to me that that is absolutely necessary if we are to have satisfaction and proper responsibility. I would urge that just as much on account of the Air Force as on account of the Fleet Air Arm. At the present time an enormous effort of expansion is being made. A great number of squadrons are skeleton squadrons, and above all things they want the leaven of experienced air pilots and air officers, men of several years' standing, men who have had the Cranwell course, the professional element, which is absolutely necessary when an enormous process of dilution and expansion is going forward. Owing to this unhappy controversy, the two Departments are fighting each other so keenly in time of peace —it is the only war that is going on at the present time—that I am informed that the Air Ministry, in their natural desire to placate the Admiralty and to give them satisfaction if they can, are taking an undue proportion of the most experienced officers and sending them to the Fleet Air Arm.
There is another function for these officers, a function which is most urgently needed. If hon. Members will take the trouble to find out about the condition of the different squadrons, they will see how important it is to have senior men, or men, at any rate, of three or four years' service, with these great numbers of new pilots who have been taken on. It would be an enormous benefit to the Royal Air Force if the Fleet Air Arm were self-supporting and developed from the Navy by itself. We should have a new addition to the air resources of this island and not a diminution. In no way would the authority and prestige of the
2608
Air Force suffer from such a division. The principle which should be applied may be called the principle of operational integrity, for want of a better term. You must give the Navy all that it requires and the kind that it requires, but only for its specific and highly specialised functions. The application of a similar principle would naturally be the key to the arrangements which should be made for the defence of fortified naval harbours and the defence of London. Under whomsoever the Air Defence of naval ports may be placed, it cannot be placed under the Navy, because it is seldom there; it moves from one port to the other. Therefore, it must be given to some other authority.
It would seem to me, therefore, that perhaps the application of this principle in two directions at the same time might afford a means of satisfying both the contending parties. If we could in some way bring to an end this tiresome, long-drawn controversy, in which so much feeling has been insinuated, it would enable a happy and satisfactory solution to he reached. Therefore, I hope that we are going to have this inquiry and that the Minister will come to a conclusion. I do not believe that there will be any difficulty in deciding particular hard cases, certain border-line cases. They will have to be decided. There are ways, in every matter of this kind, certain border-line cases, but in principle, if you simply give to the Navy what it requires for the naval operations that I have spoken of, reserving to the Air Force the whole control of air war in its larger sense, I believe that an arrangement could he come to which would be beneficial to both Services and to the Defence of the country.
I was a little disturbed to see a statement and to hear it referred to in debate that Lord Weir had threatened to resign, and that in consequence there had been a change in the procedure to be adopted by the Government on which the Government had already decided. We were told that there was to be a Committee and the names of the Committee had become public knowledge. They were Lord Halifax and the Minister of Education under the Presidency of the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence—a worthy, competent, pious trio who, I should think, could be absolutely relied upon to give a thoroughly righteous verdict upon this
2609
technical question. When all this was settled, it was stated that Lord Weir said he would resign unless it was altered. We are told that it was altered and that my right hon. Friend, the Minister for the Coordination of Defence, is to have another one of those conferences with the Chiefs of Staffs of the three Services which, I suppose, have been going on continuously since he took office and which have never moved one inch from the condition of deadlock. I hope that right hon. Friend will clear up the difficulties of this question and will remove from the minds of the public and the House any idea that the Government would be deflected from their course by any threat of resignation. I do not quite understand how a man who has no official position, except that of an adviser, and no official responsibility, has anything in particular to resign, but anyhow, I do not think this matter ought to be settled by threats of resignation on the one hand or the other. I should highly deprecate, and so would the House, any similar threats of resignation from the Lords of the Admiralty. We cannot have that. The matter has to be settled in a reasonable manner by authority after hearing the arguments fully. I have the greatest regard for Lord Weir and well know the value of the services he has rendered, and I hope that we shall hear from the Minister a statement which will show that these newspaper reports are without any foundation.
That is all I wanted to say upon the subject of the Fleet Air Arm, but I cannot sit down without referring to the general progress which the Air Force is making in its expansion programme. I would be the last to under-rate the enormous difficulties of a scheme of this scale undertaken so late in the day and having necessarily to be pressed forward at extraordinary speed. In addition, it is right to remember the great dislocation which was involved in the movements to the Mediterranean, which took place at the end of 1935. One must, however, take the actual facts from the published figures. In 1935, when this expansion was decided upon, the so-called Metropolitan Air Force—you could hardly select a more misleading new term to describe it—or Home Defence Force, which would be a much better name, consisted of 52 squadrons. It was proposed to raise it by the 31st of this month to 123 squadrons, that is to say,
2610
an increase of 71 squadrons was to be made in that period. Actually, we are told, we have now 100, but that is obviously not true, because 22 of them are upon a skeleton basis; they each consist of only a single flight. However, some credit should be given for that force. As there are three flights to a squadron, these skeleton squadrons are equal to seven squadrons. Adding them to the 78, we have a total of 85 altogether. Deducting the 54 which were in existence two years ago, we have an increase of 31 squadrons out of the 71 which were promised should be added. Forty squadrons have not yet even approached the skeleton formation stage.
Therefore, we are bound to take note of the fact, which has been given to us candidly by the Air Ministry, that the programme of expansion is substantially less than half completed by the date promised—something like 44 per cent. only has been accomplished. I would not attempt to throw any blame on the new Secretary of State, who has worked himself as hard as any man and who has employed his distinguished talents on this question. But still, the fact remains that less than half the programme has been carried out by the date promised. This is the only date about which promises have been made. On all the rest of the vast programmes which have been going forward, the Government have been well advised not to give any dates. They have never said that such and such a stage will be completed at a certain hour. Consequently it is always possible to say that everything is going forward according to schedule. The schedule never having been written in the first instance in any definite sense, it is always capable of modification. In regard to the expansion of the Air Force, it was a decision taken at an earlier period than that of the general expansion of the Defence forces. A definite date was fixed, and we find that less than half of what was hoped for by that time has been accomplished.
I hope and trust that we must not take such a figure of 44 per cent. as typical of other programmes or hopes which are going forward behind the scenes and about which we have no definite details. If the full programme of the expansion of the Royal Air Force projected in 1935 had been executed by the 31st of this March, and we had 1,500 machines in 123 squadrons, then I assert that it would
2611
still not have meant parity with the leading air Power within striking air distance of these shores, nor anything like it. My right hon. Friend and the Prime Minister contradicted me the other day—well, it was in November, six months ago, but time passes so quickly that it makes one feel how remorselessly the months slip away—when I said that the very minimum strength of the German effective fighting air force was 1,500 first-line machines. They said that the real number was substantially below that. I cannot accept that statement; I do not believe it. Of course, I do not challenge the bona fides of those who made that statement, but I cannot believe that it represents the true position; or indeed that 1,500 was in November an excessive figure, because it was probably far below the mark, and the increase which has taken place since must certainly have raised the effective fighting force of Germany to a figure which at the very least is more than 1,700 or 1,800 machines capable of going into action and being continuously maintained in action during the course of a war.
I contend, therefore, that every effort should be made to catch up this lag, because evidently the conditions which the Government thought two years ago would be necessary for our safety have not been maintained and are not being maintained; but there is one thing which I do hope that my right hon. Friend will enjoin upon the Air Ministry. On no account should they try to make paper squadrons merely to maintain an idea of parity in Parliament or the country. We all know that they are trying their utmost now, and if things are not what they hoped or what we hoped, it is no longer suitable or necessary to use reproaches upon the matter. Let the Air Ministry address themselves solely to the military merits of the problem, and not endeavour to form a single squadron, for the sake of saying they have got so many, before it would be natural to form it in the ordinary course of their departmental duty.
