Foreign Office.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

31 May 1935 · House of Commons debate on the Foreign Office (Committee of Supply) · House of Commons, Palace of Westminster, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill addressed the House of Commons in London on May 31, 1935, in a Foreign Office debate, warning that Germany's rearmament and Britain's air inferiority contradicted the optimism voiced earlier in the debate.
Main themes
German rearmament, British air inferiority to Germany, Air Locarno proposal, limitation of air armaments and manufacturing capacity, German army expansion, submarine construction, Nazi influence in central and eastern Europe, Goering's Danubian tour, Austrian independence, Italy and Abyssinia, threat to western parliamentary democracy
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,638
70th percentile
Sentences
108
67th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
11.5
39th percentile
Syntax
2.99
46th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 79%75%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Economic 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Institutional 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

108 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Until the last speech was made—a speech which, I venture to say, was the evident result of profound

1490

and anxious thought—the atmosphere of this Debate had been entirely genial. Anyone listening to the opening speeches by the right hon. Member for Darwen (Sir H. Samuel), the Foreign Secretary, and my right hon. Friend the Member for West Birmingham (Sir A. Chamberlain), would have had the feeling that everything was moving smoothly and with increasing speed towards an ever-improving situation in Europe and throughout the world. My right hon. Friend the Member for Darwen drew a very rosy picture. He spoke of all the hopeful deductions which may be drawn from the German Chancellor's speech; he spoke of the conditions of the proposed air pact; but the speech to which we have just listened showed that there is another side, and a very dark other side, to the rosy picture drawn by my right hon. Friend the Member for Darwen.

And yet I cannot say that I disagree with my right hon. Friend, to whom we are indebted, as Leader of the Liberal party, for to-day's Debate. I agree with him entirely when he says that it is impossible for us, in the world in which we live, to treat with blank distrust the utterances of the Leader of so vast a State as Germany. To represent everything that has been said by Herr Hitler as containing in it only the purposes of political manoeuvre would be, as it were, to destroy the very means of contact and of parley between one great nation and another. I agree with my right hon. Friend there.

I agree with him also in feeling that the Air Locarno, as it has been called, is in itself an eminently desirable objective towards which we should work, and which, if concluded, will be a matter of real substance and importance. I welcome, with him, any steps which may be taken to secure a limitation in air armaments—air parity being achieved at levels lower than those which are now mentioned, if that can be done. But it is not going to be very easy. I welcome it by all means. I welcome, also, and perhaps most keenly, what has been said by the German Chancellor about correcting the abuses and stigmatising the vile crime of indiscriminate bombing of civilian populations apart from the ordinary measures of war. In all this I am entirely in agreement with the kind of language which was used by the Leader of the

1491

Liberal party, and with the tone which he adopted; and, naturally the Government will be encouraged by all sections in the House to pursue these matters with patience and not without hope. But do not let us under-rate the difficulties which attach to them. There may be many more complications in what is called an Air Locarno than would appear at first sight. Still, for what it is worth,:the union of great countries which put their names to a document pledging them all to bomb the bomber is an event which everyone would hail.

Even more difficulties attend the question of the limitation of air armaments. Air armaments are not expressed merely by the air squadrons in existence, or the aeroplanes which have been made; they cannot be considered apart from the capacity to manufacture. If, for instance, there were two countries which each had 1,000 first-line aeroplanes, but one of which had the power to manufacture at the rate of 100 a month and the other at the rate of 1,000 a month, it is perfectly clear that no kind of air parity would exist between those two countries. All that would happen as the result of an air parity agreement between them would be that the actual superiority of the one with the greater manufacturing power would manifest itself a few months later than would have been the case if that disproportion had existed in first-line aircraft.

My right hon. Friend spoke of inspection and control which he regarded as essential, and indeed it obviously is. When you have first-line air strength which may be limited by agreement, and when you have to consider the relations of that first-line air strength and the manufacturing capacity, on the one hand, and a vast civil aviation, on the other hand, it is clear that the task of reaching an agreed limitation of air armaments will be attended with almost superhuman difficulties in the present state and circumstances of the world. But by all means let us pursue that path. No one can possibly complain if it is pursued with even more hope than a prosaic consideration of the facts would justify. But while I welcome all this agreeable conversation and basis of conversation, I do not think that we ought to overlook at all the real facts which abide with us. One would imagine sitting in this House

1492

to-day that the dangers were over, were in process of abating. I believe that the exact contrary is the truth, that they are steadily advancing upon us, upon Europe and upon peaceful populations of all countries from many points of view; and that no one can be certain that a time may not be reached, or when it will be reached, when events may have passed altogether out of control. We must look at the facts. Nourish your hopes, but do not overlook the realities.

The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs dropped out a phrase to-day which really is in keeping with what I call the illusion basis on which much of this discussion has proceeded. It was one of those casual phrases which nevertheless do reveal an altogether unsound presentation of the facts. He referred to countries as those with whom you feel it your absolute duty to remain on terms of air equality. Look at that. To remain on terms of air equality. We have not got air equality. Speeches are made in the country by leading Ministers saying that we have decided that we must have air equality, that we cannot accept anything less. We have not got it. We are already decidedly inferior to Germany, and, if it must be said, of course to France. All that lies before us for many months is that that inferiority becomes more and more pronounced. In the Autumn of this year, in November, when we are supposed to be 50 per cent. stronger, I hazard the melancholy prediction that we shall not be a third, possibly not a quarter, of the German air strength. What is the use of saying "the countries with whom we consider it our absolute duty to remain on terms of air equality." This is one of the terrible facts which lie before us and which will not be swept away merely by following a very natural inclination which we all have to say that it did not exist.

The German Army, already developed to 21 or 22 divisions, is working up to 36 as fast as it can, a division a month or something like that, coming into the full mobilisable capacity, tanks and the whole business. There is the Navy, and submarines have been made. Some are actually, I believe, practising, training their crews in that difficult art. Let me tell the House that submarines can be manufactured very quickly. I remember in November, 1914, arranging for Mr. Schwabb, of Bethlehem, to make 20 sub-

1493

marines in what was then believed to be the incredibly short period of six months. Although these vessels had to be shifted from the United States to a Canadian dockyard for reasons for neutrality, it was possible to put sections on the railway trucks and to deliver them in time. How do you know what progress has been made in making the necessary sections? The whole of this business is proceeding with the utmost rapidity. The arms production has the first claim on the entire industry of Germany. The necessary materials required for the production of armaments are the first charge on the German exchange. The whole of their industry is woven into the immediate readiness for war. You have a state of preparedness in German industry which was not attained by our industry until after the late War had gone on probably for two years.

Besides this, there is tremendous propaganda, beginning with the schools and going right through every grade of youth to manhood, enforced by the most vigorous and harsh sanctions at every stage. All this is taking place. It is a very nice comfortable world that we look out on here in this country. It has found an apt reflection in this Debate to-day, but it has no relation whatever to what is going forward and going steadily forward. Mark you in time of peace, in peace politics, in ordinary matters of domestic affairs and class struggles, things blow over, but in these great matters of defence and still more in the field of actual hostilities the clouds do not roll by. If the necessary measures are not taken, they turn into thunderbolts and fall on your heads. We cannot have a debate on foreign affairs, and let it pass without it being placed definitely in the minds of the Committee and from here being communicated to the country that the whole of this great process of psychological, moral, material and technical mobilisation of German war power is proceeding ceaselessly and with ever-increasing momentum.

The speech of my hon. Friend who has just spoken briefly but with interest was based on a very grim and glum contemplation of realities as he sees them. He was melancholy from many points of view. He spoke of the growing power of Germany, and it is a power based on the growth of armaments. It is the growth of German armaments which has

1494

fascinated and petrified nation after nation throughout Europe. Just look at what has happened throughout the last few weeks since we were last engaged in a serious discussion on foreign affairs. We know perfectly well that Poland continues in the German system. The Czechoslovakia elections have created a new Nazi party in Czechoslovakia, which is I believe the second party in the State. That is a very remarkable fact having regard to the energy which the German people, when inspired by the Nazi spirit, are able to exercise. The Austrian tension increases, and I agree with the hon. Gentleman that many people talk about guaranteeing the independence of Austria, but what many mean by that is guaranteeing that Austria will be kept separate from Germany, which is a different thing. You may at any time be faced with a position that the will of the Austrian people will have to be turned in a particular direction, and an adverse direction from that which our policy has hitherto proclaimed. There is the. Danubian tour of General Goering. He has been to Jugoslavia, Bulgaria and to Hungary. He has, in Hungary and Bulgaria, been renewing those old ties of comradeship and confidence which existed between them and Germany in the days of the war. I agree that with regard to Jugoslavia undoubtedly his presence has exercised a very important influence there as a counter-influence to others that may be brought to bear. Everywhere these countries are being made to look to Germany in a special way, and let me say that I read in the "Times" on 30th May a very significant telegram from Vienna dealing with this tour of General Goering, and it finished up with these words:

In the circumstances the strength and clarity of German policy gains by contrast "— that is, to the Allied policy— and the waverers among the smaller States are closely watching events.

There is the question of what are the relations between Germany and Japan. I know nothing about them but what I read in the papers, but it seems to me that that is a matter which must be in the thoughts of everyone who attempts to make an appreciation of the foreign situation. Then there are the difficulties of Italy's preoccupation with Abyssinia,

1495

with which the Lord Privy Seal has en-endeavoured to cope in a manner which has won him the admiration and respect of all parties in this House. There are the obvious stresses through which France is passing, not indeed in the matter of national defence, but in almost every other aspect of the life of that people. There is our own weakness in the air which is to become worse and worse month after month many months ahead of this critical year and of the critical year which is to follow. All this is going forward.

It is easy then for Herr Hitler and the German Government to pursue a policy which I have heard described, though not in this House, as power diplomacy, which is, for them to shape events in the channels which my hon. Friend has just described to the Committee. What a transformation has taken place in the last two or three years. Two or three years ago it was considered sentimental, intellectual, liberally - minded to speak words of encouragement and compassion, and even to speak patronisingly in respect of the German people, and to seek opportunities to make gestures to raise them up to more and greater equality with other countries. Now, when less than three years have elapsed, we see them with their grievances unredressed, with all their ambitions unsatisfied, these grievances, the redress of which must involve an obstacle to many peoples and raise no hope, with all the dangers attaching to them—now we see them continuing from strength to strength, and the whole world waits from week to week to hear what are the words which will fall from the heads of the German nation. It is a woeful transformation which has taken place, because one cannot conceive a worse situation than that a nation so armed, so animated and so disposed should find itself having to plead with its force for the reversal of many of the most earnestly desired decisions and results which were achieved in the Great War by other countries.

I will not detain the Committee further, but I felt bound to put the other side of the case. I felt that it would be folly for us, in our desire not to use language which was alarming and not to say anything which might injuriously heighten the temperature or exacerbate feelings,

1496

to act as if we were swimming in a halcyon sea, as if nothing but balmy breezes and calm weather were to be expected and everything working in the most agreeable fashion. By all means follow your lines of hope and your paths of peace, but do not close your eyes to the fact that we are entering a corridor of deepening and darkening danger and we shall have to move along it for many months and possibly for years to come. While we are in this position not only have we our own safety to consider but we have to consider also whether the Parliamentary Governments of western Europe, of which there are not many that function in the real sense of the word, are going to be able to afford to their subjects that same measure of physical security, to say nothing of national satisfaction, as is being afforded to the people of Germany by the dictatorship which has been established there. It is not only the supreme question of self-preservation that is involved in the realisation of these dangers, but there is also the human and the world cause of the preservation of free Governments and of western civilisation Against the ever-advancing forces of authority and despotism