- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons, London, on June 5, 1935, on the Third Reading of the Government of India Bill, arguing that the Bill gave neither good government nor Indian consent.
- Main themes
- Government of India Bill Third Reading, Conservative opposition to the Bill, indirect election to the Federal Legislature, Princes' offer and the 50 per cent. quota, opinion of the Indian Civil Service, law and order and disqualification of terrorists, Lancashire cotton trade and the Indian tariff, Select Committee on Witnesses report and the Secretary of State, consent versus good government, population growth and British guidance in India
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,185
- Sentences
- 221
- Readability
- 56
- Grade
- 11.2
- Syntax
- 3.06
- Vocabulary
- 2.07
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other221 sentences in 51 paragraphs
The speech of the hon. Member for Bodmin (Mr. Isaac Foot) was divided into three parts. In the first part, he showed his usual contempt for the opinions of any minority except the minority to which he himself belongs. In the last part he led us into such cloudy and mysterious heights that one felt that even the most impressive quotation, which like so many of the right hon. Member's quotations have frequently drawn a meed of popular applause, fell far short of the requirements of the picture he was drawing. The rest of his speech was, in fact, one of the most damaging attacks I have heard delivered on the Bill. Point after point was rammed home with merciless persistency by the hon. Member. All the vices of indirect election and the injury it would do to the future Government of India were repeated in the most vehement fashion. We were told how great would be the difficulties of carrying out an election with 5,000 candidates to be found by a people, many of whom are very little advanced in the scale of modern politics. We were told of the enormous number of voters who will have to be handled and that when the election is over and the new assemblies are working that they will not accept the Bill, and that if they in any way consent to work it it will be only to use it as a lever to extract more. The term "Swaraj" may be interpreted by many of the men who will have the power in India in a manner
1909
which stops at nothing short of absolute independence. The hon. Member concluded by saying how greatly Indians, exposed to these trials and dangers, would stand in need of our sympathies. We shall all agree with him in that. If these misgivings and criticisms are the only support which the hon. Member can give to the Bill, except a somewhat inconsistent vote in the Lobby, I cannot congratulate the Government on the prodigious efforts they have made to win his applause.
We are now at the end of these prolonged debates. It has been a very prolonged fight, and a very uneven fight. We have had a great deal against us. All the forces of the National Government, and all the machinery, prestige, and loyalties of the Conservative party, used contrary to its instincts and traditions. We have had the Socialist and Liberal parties supporting the Bill, except that it does not go far enough for them. All the weight of their opinion, if they would like me to assign due weight to it, has been added to the current against us. All the social influence and political patronage, and power of the Government here and in India, the whole of the vast majority in this House, collected in 1931 on the impulse of a great emergency, on a wave of patriotism and a great desire expressed by the people that Britain should be honourable and strong; all this has been thrown against us. Even now, when I have hardly finished dealing with the hon. Member for Bodmin I understand that the right hon. Member for Sparkbrook (Mr. Amery) is sharpening up his Birmingham pencil for his rejoinder with his approved vigour.
I am ready to admit that these forces have proved too strong for us. Our consolation is that we have tried our best, that we have not left undone anything we could have done to place the resistance to this policy before the people of the country. The hon. and gallant Member for Bournemouth (Sir H. Croft) and I have worked together for five long years and have been ready to sacrifice our time and labour, and, I am sorry to say, in some cases personal friendships, in order that we might do what we consider, arid still consider, to be no more than our duty. I am glad that these long debates in this House are now coming to an end and that they have not been inflamed or complicated by any conflict
1910
about procedure. We came to an arrangement about procedure and the minority have no reason to complain of the time allotted or that they have not been able to state their case with the fullest freedom of debate that could be desired. And I think we may all join in congratulating the Chairman of Committees—if it is not presumptuous to speak in that way of an officer of the House who has assisted us so much—and to congratulate also, I must add, the Chief Whip, who has played a great part in devising this plan for regulating our procedure. We may join in congratulating them on what may well be an invaluable revival of old English Parliamentary customs.
But there my compliments and tributes come to an abrupt conclusion. Speaking for the Conservative minority which voted 80 against the Second Reading and which represents, even under the hardest test that could be applied, at least one-third of the Conservative party in the country, I am bound to state that cur views have not received the slightest consideration from His Majesty's Government. I suppose that if we had been a handful, a baker's dozen of Socialist refugees, great attention would have been paid to our opinions. I remember the great attention that was paid to the opinions of even one single Socialist Member of the Government—Mr. Snowden as he was then, and Viscount Snowden as he now is—when the land taxes were actually kept on for two whole years against the wishes of the great majority of the House simply in order not to hurt the feelings of so eminent a recruit from the Socialist ranks. But being what you are pleased to call Tory Die-hards our feelings and wishes can be safely brushed aside. However, the fact remains that our differences of principle and method upon this Bill are in no way diminished.
Our opposition is not in the slightest way mitigated by anything that has occurred. We must say that we remain quite unreconciled, except to the fact that you are carrying this Measure over our heads. Indeed, in all my Parliamentary experience I never knew a Measure where the gulf between Members of the same party and between men who have so much in common in the work they have to do in the future, as well as in their sentiments and relationship,
1911
has remained so profound and so unbridged. The processes of argument which usually lead to some understanding and which if not developed effectively upon the Floor of the House at any rate make it easy for people to talk over these matters outside— these processes of argument, though employed with so much patience and elaboration, only led many of us to the feeling that on this subject we no longer talked the same language. In our view not one of the main arguments against this Bill—some of which we have set forth in the Amendment on the Order Paper—has been met or even attempted to be met. Ministers have made speeches denying the validity of the arguments or traversing them by counter-assertions, and in every division they have brought in about 200 gentlemen who have definitely made up their minds, not that this Bill is a good one, but that it would be a good thing to put it through and get it out of the way. I said I would pay no more tributes, but I must pay one more to the Chief Whip. He certainly deserves congratulations, not only for his part in evolving this procedure but on other counts as well. The Secretary of State has had the support of several able colleagues on the Front Bench—and particularly the Under-Secretary, who has distinguished himself greatly and has established a Parliamentary reputation of a high order. He has had many able colleagues to assist him on that Bench, but there was one colleague whose powers of dialectic, whose forcible eloquence, whose power to raise in people's minds the most weighty considerations, at any rate must not be overlooked. I do not know whether you could say of the Chief Whip that he was a flower to blush unseen, but certainly he has not wasted his fragrance upon the desert air.
It was clear after this Bill had been in Committee for 10 or is days that there never would arise any situation or any issue upon which any majority of these two hundred steady-voting gentlemen would be won over to any accommodation or where any compromise could be reached. But I think a heavy responsibility rests upon them. Many of them may not be here after the General Election. Nobody knows indeed who will be here. But they will have in after life
1912
to watch the fortunes and the consequences of what the hon. Member for Bodmin described as this enormous and incalculable experiment. They will watch the results of the experiment to which they have committed the British Empire. If disaster comes, if grave evils and deepening confusion follow, they will not be able to forget the part they have played, and a moral responsibility will always rest upon them to the end of their days. At any rate, they have had their way. Perhaps it is better so. If a far-reaching and memorable departure of this character is to be taken, it is better that those who make it should not share their responsibility with others. It is better that they should put the stamp of their decision on our affairs nakedly, bluntly and in its integral character.
I am only going to recapitulate briefly on this Third Reading some of the salient points to which we feel no adequate answer has been made. First of all, there was the Princes' offer. The Lord President of the Council used that offer, quoting the Foreign Secretary's speech, at the Queen's Hall Conference of his party—a most decisive and critical turningpoint—in order to carry conviction and obtain assent to his views. Everyone, I think, will admit there was not very much in the Princes' offer. Whether you will succeed by all the arts you are employing, and will employ no doubt, in making up a 50 per cent. quota of these Princes, even with the terms that those who come in are to vote for all the rest after a certain period, and after all these financial inducements and improvements of the State revenues—whtether you will succeed in securing this 50 per cent. quota I admit is a matter of argument. But surely, when we were told that we were in the presence of an offer from the Princes which we should be taking a step of the gravest responsibility by rejecting, something more than this reluctant attitude on their part might have been expected.
Even now I venture to hazard the opinion that the Princes of India will not come in and that the 50 per cent. quota will not be achieved. I base this upon the fact that I do not believe that the Princes of India will set themselves against the opinion of their compatriots, particularly the Congress Party. When the original conversations took place five
1913
years ago the Congress Party were urging the Princes to come forward into Federation, but now their whole pressure is in the opposite direction. It is far that reason that the Princes have raised this question of Paramountcy, which has nothing to do with the Bill. They have raised it to have a dyke or bulwark between them—and they are setting up all manner of points of legal difference. It is markedly significant that the Government, staking everything on the offer of the Princes, now have _ to announce through the mouth of the Secretary of State that there is no question of the Princes being called together to say whether they will come in or not. The Bill is to be put on the shelf, in the hope that gradually some of the Princes, one at a time, may 'be persuaded to go and sign their names upon the roll. So much for the offer of the Princes.
Then there was the question of the opinion of the Indian Civil Service. Here again my right hon. Friend the Lord President of the Council took the responsibility of using very strong language. It has been quoted before, but I will quote it again. Speaking at Bewdley on 29t,h April, 1933, he said:
I have no doubt, from inquiries I have made, that the overwhelming balance of opinion in the Civil Service is in favour of these reforms. Can we turn down the views of the men on the spot and the men responsible for the -tremendous task of governing India to-day?
I think it was a bad thing at that early stage of the controversy to introduce the opinions of the civil servants in India into this matter. We have been sometimes blamed for speaking on this subject, but when the matter was introduced as an important part of the controversy it was impossible that others should not seek to challenge that opinion and take the opposite view. We think that the facts do not bear out the assertion of the Lord President of the Council. We believe that, although a number of the leading people in the Civil Service, especially those most closely in contact with the Government, are no doubt ranked among the supporters of the Bill, the lower down you go in the Service and the more you go to the subordinate ranks, to the people who actually will have to come into contact with the results, the more you find that they view with the very gravest misgivings, and at the best with resignation arid acquiescence, the great changes that
1914
are going to take place in their status, in their relation to the Indian masses, in the influence they will have in their districts, and in the character of the masters and superiors under whom they will be called upon to serve. Here again one has some proof, because the Government thought it necessary for the whole of these Indian civil servants to be allowed to terminate their services at any time upon proportionate pensions— which certainly was a step absolutely necessitated by feelings so wide in that Service that the conditions under which in future they would have to discharge their work would be well-nigh impossible and intolerable. Very great injury has been done I think to the Indian Civil Service. But let me say that I hope and trust that throughout this country there will be no slackening in the desire of young Englishmen to come forward and present their services and to compete in the examinations held for this purpose; and, if they are successful, I hope they will choose the Indian station, because there is the point of danger where their greatest efforts will be needed in the years to come.
Then there is the question of law and order. We have heard a great deal about handing over the police in the Provinces, but the Government have decided to do so under certain restrictions. I am going to use only one argument on this subject. It is difficult to find one that has not been used before, but I do not think that this has been used. It is a very simple illustration of the dangers of the step which the Government have taken, and also it presents in the most conclusive manner an admission that they knew of these dangers. Let the House call its mind back to Clause 26, paragraph (e), which prescribes that men who have been convicted of any offence by a court in British India or in a State which is a Federated State and sentenced to transportation or imprisonment for not less than two years, will not be eligible to be elected to the Federal Legislature. That is the proposal. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State, in speaking on the subject gave reasons for this. Some of us have doubts about it. We made inquiries, and in response my right hon. Friend used very striking phrases. He said:
I made it my business, upon the request of the Joint Select Committee, to inquire the views of the Government of
1915
India and of the Provincial Governments. I found that, without exception, they were all strongly in favour of a disqualification of this kind remaining, provided that there also remained the dispensing power. Particularly did I find the Government of Bengal very definite upon the question.— [OFFICIAL REPORT, 12th March, 1935; col. 780, Vol. 299.]
Then he spoke of the fear that really dangerous terrorists, people who have been guilty of serious crimes, not civil disobedience, might be picked out and set up as candidates and make their way into the Federal Legislature in spite of these crimes, and even, as sometimes happened in Ireland, might be elected because of the crimes committed. This is not a case of a new and ignorant electorate getting excited, because under the system of indirect election it is the Provincial Legislatures which have to co-opt members of the Federal Government. Therefore, we see that all the Governors of all the Provinces in India found it necessary to press the Secretary of State to insert in the Bill a provision that dangerous terrorists will not be eligible, after they have served their sentences, for membership of the Federal Legislature, and they thought that unless these statutory provisions are placed in the Bill there is a danger that the Provincial Legislatures will elect such persons.
There is the admission of what really may be the character of some of these Provincial Legislatures. And yet it is to these bodies, whom you find it necessary to prevent by express legislation chosing dangerous terrorists, that you are to hand over the whole control of law and order, and the lives not only of our white fellow-countrymen, but also the justice which is meted out to the broad mass of the Indian people. I do not wonder at all that your misgivings have prompted you in this case to withhold the control of the secret police from these bodies whom you are entrusting with this responsibility.
Then there is the question of British trade. What of British trade, and what of Lancashire I speak with a disadvantage in this matter, because I have done my best for three years to arouse the people of Lancashire to the dangers with which their livelihood is threatened by the treatment of their trade under this Bill, and I admit that I had not
1916
received any effective or powerful response. I admit my failure. But let me ask to-day, what safeguard, what satisfaction has Lancashire received? I am not aware of anything that has been conceded to it. We have reached this concluding stage of the Bill, and all sorts of suggestions that were put forward and amendments moved and safeguards introduced have proved utterly illusory and vain, and to-day we are parting with our sovereignty, and altering the sovereignty, which was still intact in spite of the Fiscal Convention. We are not allowed to make any claims on account of the defence we give to India at the cost of our soldiers' lives, nor for the credit we have given her, which has enabled her to build up her economic system. None of that is to be held as a valid claim for asking even for preferential treatment. The Clare Lees-Moody agreement and negotiations and mission. What has happened to that now? It is not worth the paper it was written on, little though there was written upon the paper. Lancashire is going to embark upon its future relations with India on the basis of a 25 per cent. tariff as a starting point. And what chance is there of reducing that?
The expense of the new Constitution will alone throw an additional heavy burden upon the already exiguous revenue, the hard-pressed revenue of India. Apart from all invidious political emotions, the practical case, on revenue grounds, will always be able to be employed against any substantial reduction of the tariff. Lancashire may choose to kiss the rod. Lancashire Members and electors may feel that it is their duty, in the circumstances, not to put forward a view which concerns them particularly. But it seems to me a most astounding thing, in a county 10 per cent, of whose members are unemployed, whose chimneys are so often smokeless, whose offices are to let, whose factories are derelict, or even the machinery of the factories have already been shipped to some Eastern country where there is cheap labour. It seems remarkable that from a county of that kind a single member should vote for a Bill of this character, with no protection or safeguards of any kind inserted on Lancashire's account.
I must say a word or two about the presentation of the Lancashire case. My
1917
right hon. Friend the Secretary of State yesterday, very crudely I thought, referred to mares' nests. It was, I thought, specially unfortunate that he should do that on the very day when the report of the Select Committee on Witnesses was available to Members of the House. That report, while expressed in most courteous terms and veiled in legal and diplomatic language, nevertheless absolutely destroys the foundation on which the Committee of Privileges acquitted the right hon. Gentleman—absolutely. This far-fetched distinction between judicial and non-judicial, this attempt to draw a distinction between evidence of fact and evidence of opinion. I am not proposing to go on with that subject now, because we shall have to 'debate it at length, and I hope to submit a more detailed argument to the House upon the subject; but I will quote the final paragraph in the report, because it directly illustrates the point I am making. The Committee say:
They think it desirable to affirm the principle that any document received by the officers of any Committee of the House as a communication to the Committee, including any advanced summary of evidence submitted by a witness, becomes the property of the Committee and should not be withdrawn or altered without the knowledge and approval of the Committee.
They suggest that provision to this effect might usefully be made in the Standing Orders of the House. There is your mare's nest. I say it was inappropriate—I will use no harder word about this transaction than my right hon. Friend did—for him to put the pressure he did upon the Lancashire people. It was still more inappropriate for him to induce Lord Derby to go where he knew himself he should not have ventured any further, and it was inappropriate for him Ito sit still in the Joint Select Committee and hear this bowdlerised and emasculated evidence poured out by the chosen members of the Manchester Chamber of Commerce, when he knew very well from the beginning what their real opinion was. The right hon. Gentleman is, we hear, soon to be translated elsewhere. He will take with him, if that be true, many great and powerful gifts, but I hope he will leave behind one or two things which some of us have noticed during the long period we have been fighting him over this Bill.
1918
The right hon. Gentleman yesterday endeavoured to confront us with what is, after all, a very trite dilemma. He said, in effect, "Are you or are you not in favour of self-determination? If you are not in favour of self-determination, why do you reproach us with not having Indian consent for our Bill?" That is the argument which has been put. We have heard it echoed and re-echoed from every part of the House. The Attorney-General during the Debates in Committee was put up to take the high line against my noble Friend the Member for Oxford University (Lord H. Cecil), who suggested that the Indian Assembly ought to be consulted before this Bill was imposed upon them. The Attorney-General took the high line to this effect: How derogatory for the British Parliament that it should be suggested that they should have to consult an Indian Assembly. But the Secretary of State and the Socialist Government—they were both connected with the inception of this policy—set out five years ago to make a settlement by agreement. They told us again and again that consent was indispensable. When I made some suggestions on the Joint Select Committee they ruled them out because they would not be agreed to; consent would not be forthcoming.
It was for this reason that the late Socialist Government deserted the Simon Statutory Commission. It was for this reason that the Round Table Conference was set up in the hope of getting consent. It was for this reason that Mr. Gandhi was coaxed and wheedled over here to take his place at the Round Table. It was for this reason that the Indian moderates were so carefully nursed and picked for that position on the Joint Select Committee. It was for this reason that the Indian Liberals were always held up before us and every effort made to win their support, before unfortunately they were all thrown out of Parliament at the first election after the proposals of the Government were known. How can anyone suppose that if the Government thought they could get a vote or confidence on this Bill from the Indian Legislative Assembly they would not jump at it to-morrow? Of course, they would, just as they would jump at getting a formal acceptance by a body of Princes if they would come in. But they cannot get it and they know they cannot get it, and therefore they have shifted their
1919
ground. They have failed in the whole original impulse and purpose with which they started and now they say, "We are legislating from on high. We are imposing a settlement. What is it to us what the Indians think? If they like it—good. If they do not like it, so much the worse for them. We have to give them what is for their good. We have to play the angel, and impose our superior wisdom on them and give them exactly what we think is for their good, no more and no less."
Surely, then, we are entitled to examine the question from this point of view: Is this really for the good of Indians? Is what you are offering India now for India's good? If there never had been any question of winning assent if there never had been any chance of a settlement with the geographical abstraction called India, is it conceivable that we should be confronted with these proposals? No. These proposals are the rejected addresses of the Government, and in my opinion they bear no relation to the kind of proposal which would have been put forward if the merits and the merits alone had animated the Imperial Parliament in making this plan. Either a scheme must make for better government or it must command the agreement of those for whom it is devised. Either we must have a good system or we must have acceptance. Our case is that His Majesty's Government now have neither. They have reconciled themselves to a vast degeneration in the quality and character of British administration in India, but they have not attained the peace and harmony which come from the active consent and co-operation of those for whom their gifts are designed.
Everyone has the worst of both worlds. The Indian politicians and the Indian people have the worst of both worlds, because they get a poorer administrative service in forms which they dislike—and say they dislike—even more than they do the present system. The Government have the worst of both worlds, because, in their argument, they can neither claim to provide good government nor government by consent. All, then, that we have is an inferior form of government, federal and provincial, which encounters almost universal reprobation. In the name of liberty you have done what
1920
liberty disowns. In the name of theoretical progress, you have opened the door to practical retrogression. In the name of appeasement and the popular will, you have prescribed a course of endless irritation. In response to Indian public opinion, you have supplied what all Indians—all shades of Indian public opinion—repudiate. Whatever may be said about the Constitution being fixed and unalterable, as you declare it to be, it is certainly not final and not enduring. In so far as so vast an instrument of government is worked at all—and I agree with the hon. Gentleman opposite that it will be worked—in so far as it is worked, it will be worked only that it may be changed. You have unsettled everything. You have settled nothing. Those whom you have sought to conciliate are those whom you have most offended. Those to whom your mission is most necessary are those whom you have most entirely abandoned. Those on whom you have to count most are those whom you are teaching least of all to count on you.
We must ask one final question—the greatest of all these questions. Does this Bill mean a broadening of Indian life, a widening and elevation of Indian thought? Does it mean that the Indian toiler when he rises to his daily task will have a better chance of, in the words of the American Constitution. "life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness"? India is a country, almost a continent, which responded to the influence of British peace, order and justice and all the applications of modern science, only by an increase of population. There has been a tremendous increase of population there. New wealth, new food, new facilities for locomotion, new hygiene, new canals, improvements in forestry and agriculture have not made the Indian masses better off. They have only brought into being in the last 50 years 100,000,000 more souls in India. A gigantic population has remained, upon the whole, at a very low level of human subsistence, but has become much more numerous.
Such a vast helpless mass requires extra British guidance, higher efficiency of government, more British civil servants and a stricter and more vigorous administration in all technical matters. All you offer them are liberal formulas, administrative relaxation and decline. The huge
1921
machine of Indian government is to be allowed to slow down, just at the time when the inhabitants of India have multiplied far beyond the limit of their basic food supply, just at the time when they require, above all things, a far higher measure of disinterested and enlightened autocracy. Just at that very time you offer this bouquet of faded flowers of Victorian Liberalism which, however admirable in themselves, have nothing to do with Asia and are being universally derided and discarded throughout the continent of Europe.
