- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on May 30, 1935, during debate on the India Bill's interpretation clause, challenging the Government's 'Federated State' wording and urging it to drop the words.
- Main themes
- Meaning of 'Federated State' in the Government's amendment, Indian States and the 50 per cent. federation threshold, sequential accession of Princely States, impossibility of a State resiling, propaganda for and against accession, delay before federation is established, draftsmen's wording and the Under-Secretary's explanation, India Bill interpretation clause, Government of India Bill
- Duration
- ~6 min
- Words
- 716
- Sentences
- 26
- Readability
- 49
- Grade
- 12.9
- Syntax
- 3.47
- Vocabulary
- 2.13
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other26 sentences in 7 paragraphs
I am not excluding my hon. Friend. On the contrary, the procedure enables the point to be ventilated on two separate occasions: first on the general question, and, second, after the Amendment to the proposed Amendment in my hon. Friend's name has been moved. Although I am anxious not to stand in his way or in any way to lengthen the proceedings, I should like to conclude the very brief remarks I was going to make before we come to the more direct and serious issue which the Amendment to the proposed Amendment raises. I want to know what the words of the Government's Amendment can possibly mean. How can any State be deemed to have become a Federated State unless a Federation has been established? I suppose that the Government are contemplating that they will erect the States into the Federation one by one. All the force and power of the Executive here and in India will be concentrated on the Indian States in an intensive manner one after another, like we sometimes see the agents from many parts of the country employed in a by-election. Then when gradually a certain number of these States have been, as it were, fixed, settled, brought into the group, the Secretary of State for India or my right hon. Friend, in whatever office he may then be occupying, will be watching anxiously the barometer rising. Every month these intensive methods will have enabled another State to become a Federated State pending the establishment of Federation, and then, as the number approaches the 50 per cent. limit the excitement will be really quite intense. No one knows how long will intervene before this period is reached,
1326
but one can imagine the feelings of emotion which will arise in the Government up to this level.
I gather that no State which has agreed to Federate will be allowed to—may I say—rat—to go back on its decision to secede. Let us use the peculiar terminology of this Bill and say that no State will be allowed to resile. Indeed, the excitement would be almost intolerable if some were being added at one end and others were dropping out at the other end. One can imagine propaganda being attempted on both sides, and that while one body of gentlemen in India possessed of great official power will be putting the greatest pressure on the States to come in to make the 50 per cent. quota, other gentlemen will be advising them most strongly to stay out. Consequently, we may believe that this period will be a very lengthy one, possibly lasting four or five years before the actual majority has been scraped together, and the desire of the Princes to enter Federation has become fully manifest to the world. It seems to me a very reasonable thing—indeed, only a reasonable reassurance—that when a State has agreed to be a Federated State it shall not be deemed to be Federated unless the whole deal goes through. I think that is very natural, and what I want to know is why should there be any exception to the rule— unless the context of the reference otherwise requires.
The only explanation given by the Under-Secretary was when he said that it was for the joy of the draftsmen. Far be it from me, or for any of my friends, to wish to withhold from a laborious, faithful and most competent body of public servants any meed of satisfaction, any personal indulgence in draught-refreshing liquid which their exertions may lead them to require, and to which their character certainly entitles them. All the same, when the Bill at this stage is definitely leaving our control cumbered with the addition of words to which no explanation can be assigned, except the one which has been given, and for which there is no justification except this desire to indulge the draftsmen, I do trust that the Government will not insist upon these words. If on reflection in another place they find that they are absolutely necessary, there is the place to insert them. We really cannot use a serious vehicle
1327
like this India Bill merely for distributing fleeting pleasurable emotions among our public officials, and I hope that the Government will not persist in these words.
