Revenue Departments.

United Kingdom Winston Churchill · Member of Parliament for Epping

7 March 1934 · House of Commons debate · House of Commons, London, United Kingdom

Context
Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on March 7, 1934, on the Report stage of a Resolution, arguing that the £1,500,000 grant to India was linked to the Government's Indian constitutional reform scheme.
Main themes
£1,500,000 grant-in-aid to India, Secretary of State for India's Federal Home Rule scheme, Joint Committee evidence, Capitation Tribunal award, Indian defence costs as an Imperial burden, Treasury and India Office negotiations, Chancellor of the Exchequer, Indian expeditions and training facilities, Government Whips and the Commons, Indian constitutional reform
Duration
~10 min
34th percentile
Words
1,170
34th percentile
Sentences
44
28th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
12.6
52nd percentile
Syntax
3.14
65th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
15th percentile

Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 54%48%
  • Economic 33%30%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 3%2%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

44 sentences in 15 paragraphs

During the course of the Debate yesterday I ventured to hazard a suggestion that the Secretary of State for India had been influenced in fixing the scale of this grant by the need of procuring additional funds in order to carry out his policy of giving Federal Home Rule to India, and finding the money for this democratic experiment in India. I was not at that moment in

1979

possession of the quotation of his evidence before the Joint Committee which would support that assertion. I therefore did not make the case with the fullness that I should have been justified in doing. I have since looked up the quotation, with the aid of the admirable index of the evidence before the Joint Committee, and I find that the impression that I had is fully borne out. There is not the slightest doubt that the Secretary of State had in mind the use of this contribution, this additional grant-in-aid of £1,500,000 which we are now to Vote for the purpose of carrying forward this Federal Home Rule Scheme in India. A discussion arose in the Joint Committee about the present financial position of India, what money was available, and very severe and careful examination of the position was undertaken by the hon. Gentleman who is now the Deputy-Leader of the Opposition. Among other questions he asked this:

Have you considered at all the possibility of any part of the burden of defence being taken over as an Imperial burden.

The hon. Member asked whether the right hon. Gentleman had in view any relief from this quarter, or words to that effect. The Secretary of State said:

It is a question, of course, that has constantly been discussed between India and Great Britain for many years and is one of the questions that will emerge out of the Capitation Tribunal decision. I would prefer, if Major Attlee will allow me to do so, to wait until the autumn when I should hope to be able to make a fuller statement of the results of the Capitation Tribunal than I can to-day.

Then a further question was raised as to whether other parts of the Empire paid less, to which the Secretary of State replied:

Major Attlee is raising a very big and a very controversial issue, upon which there has been a discussion for generations. What I can tell him, however, is that this was one of the issues referred to the Capitation Tribunal, composed, as he will remember, of impartial British and Indian judges, and I should hope to be able to make an announcement on the subject when we resume our discussions in the autumn.

That the right hon. Gentleman's hope was not fruitless and that he was justified in his hope was shown by what occurred. The tribunal fixed no figure and gave no award. It merely indicated that there should be a contribution of some kind. That was enough for the

1980

Secretary of State. That was what he had been counting upon. He was then able to go to the Chancellor of the Exchequer and demand from him, as colleague to colleague and as one man in a confederation with another, the means of supplying the finances necessary to bring his home rule scheme into operation. I expect there was a very hard tussle between the Secretary of State and the Chancellor of the Exchequer and that the Chancellor consoled himself by thinking that he had got out of it as cheaply as he could when he gave £1,500,000. The award of the tribunal could perfectly well have been satisfied by £130,000 or simply remitting the other half of the sea transport as was done 20 years ago, but the Secretary of State required this money as a make-weight, and as grist to his mill for bringing his home rule scheme into operation. He demanded and procured from the Chancellor of the Exchequer this £1,500,000, but he would have been very glad to have got more, because even that does not give him as much as he requires. That is my view and I say it is directly connected.

I see it stated in a newspaper which belongs to the Government Press—for they still have some Press left—that it was an unworthy suggestion to say that this demand for £1,500,000 had anything whatever to do with the Indian constitutional reform. I have exposed to the House to-night on the Report stage of this Resolution the direct link and the absolute proof, which no one can dispute. You may try to explain it away and wrap it up in a cloud of words, but there is not the slightest doubt that the hope of the Secretary of State was to obtain a substantial refreshment from this source for his scheme, and he has undoubtedly obtained it. I have indicated how I think the figure was fixed, by this hugger-mugger discussion between the India Office and the Treasury, with the War Office intervening.

But we had an alternative suggestion put before us last night by the Secretary of State as to how he worked out the scheme. He took all the expeditions in which India had assisted the Empire for the last 60 years. He took them all in and said there was so much due on that account. He also looked at the admirable training facilities afforded to our

1981

troops by the large expanses of the Indian plains, and said that there was so much due on that account. How much for each one he did not mention, but, adding them together—the expeditions from the sixties to the present day and these training facilities—he suddenly informed us that the answer was £1,500,000. Of course, anyone who knows anything about the working of the Governmental system knows it was nothing to do with these expeditions and training facilities, but what the Chancellor of the Exchequer thought was the least he could get off with. He did get off, in my opinion, with a very severe mauling such as no other occupant of that office would have tolerated in the last 30 years in regard to this issue. This £1,500,000 which is provided was aimed at and struggled for and fought for as part of the necessary provision for the home rule scheme of the right hon. Gentleman. He is getting it now as a burden for ever fixed upon the people of this country, and, although I do not expect for one moment that the House of Commons, which is the guardian of the public purse, is going to worry about such a bagatelle as £1,500,000 when the Government Whips are on the other side, yet I venture to say that in bringing this matter to the attention of Parliament and to the attention of the country, we have exposed one of the most disagreeable phases of the under-workings which are bringing forward this Indian policy to a conclusion which will be permanently disastrous to our interests.