- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on 27 July 1937, in the debate on the salary of the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, urging practical air defence preparations and criticising delay and complacency.
- Main themes
- Debate on the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence, passive defence against air attack, protection of vital war-making points, deterrence by armed associations of nations, gap between paper plans and practical preparation, Fleet Air Arm delay, complacency over defence readiness, air terror against civilians, defence production, scientific research on air defence
- Duration
- ~16 min
- Words
- 1,972
- Sentences
- 56
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 15.2
- Syntax
- 3.57
- Vocabulary
- 2.03
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other56 sentences in 16 paragraphs
I was very glad that the House so generally welcomed the Ruling of the Chair in favour of giving a broad latitude to a Debate upon the salary of the Minister for the Co-ordination of Defence. Now that there are three Arms and the civilian Departments are so closely involved in Defence, whether they deal with food or with the control of the civil population, it is especially important that there should be several occasions in the course of the year when the House can deal with the problem of Defence in its general and in its national aspects. Of course, it would be an obvious abuse of such a valuable opportunity if topics were debated in a way which would be much better suited to the special Votes of the various Departments concerned, and would be a great waste of so valuable an opportunity as is presented when the Minister comes forward and is able to speak with equal freedom on the whole of the three Services and on their inter-relations, as well as the general Defence problem affecting the civilian Departments.
These are great responsibilities to fall upon my right hon. Friend, and his two private secretaries and three lady typists—very serious and grave responsibilities. I admire very much the phlegm and the physique which have enabled him to support them with so much composure and such an air of well-being. Still responsibilities are very often brought home to people when there are failures, and very often those failures are apparent only when peace-time policies come into contact with realities. I remember a story of Marshal Joffre who, after the War was over, was asked by a lady: "Now, tell me, Marshal, who was really responsible for winning the battle of the Marne? "The Marshal said, "Madam, that is a mystery which will never be solved, but I can tell you who would have been responsible for losing it, supposing it had been lost." I do not repeat that tale in any way to strike a knell which might echo in the ears of my right hon. Friend, but it is undoubtedly the fact that the House and the country look to him and to his office to give a general review of all questions of national Defence, and to present that view as the deputy of the
2923
Prime Minister and with the authority of the Government as a whole. I feel, like the spokesman of the Opposition, that we are all indebted to the right hon. Gentleman the Member for Caithness (Sir A. Sinclair) for enabling this Debate to take place. He has facilities, as the head of an organised entity, for bringing topics before the House of Commons which is certainly denied to any one on this side of the House except a Minister. Therefore we are all the more grateful to him when he gives us a day for the discussion of these extremely intricate and important questions, upon which modern thought is unhappily more and more concentrating.
Upon this general question of passive defence and the relative power of defence and attack in the air, I would venture to express the hope that, important as it is, it would not be possible to find security merely by the development of passive defence. You cannot roof the world in, and you cannot provide protection everywhere. You must rely, in the first place, upon the deterrent of counter measures and upon the deterrent of large associations of nations which, if they are properly armed, will restrain an aggressor from a violent outrage from the air. You must rely upon the active function, but it is true that, all other things being equal, the nation which has good arrangements for dealing with the civil population under air attack will have a considerable advantage over the nation which has very small or poor arrangements for that purpose.
I will venture to say, although it may not be a very popular thing to say, that I hope the Government, whose resources are so very meagre and slender and inadequate to the purpose in hand, will concentrate those resources first of all upon protecting the vital points of our warmaking capacity, our harbours, feeding points, power stations, munition factories and mobilisation centres, and so forth. It is only after those have been adequately provided for that the much larger and, in some ways, insoluble problem, under present conditions, of protecting the civilian population, can arise. I say "insoluble under present conditions," because wonderful ideas are alive in the field of scientific research. If one could be sure that 10, or perhaps eight, or even seven years of peace lay before the world,
2924
I would hazard the opinion which I have indicated before, that the ground will master the air, and that the problem of the marauding aeroplane, slaughtering indiscriminately the civilian population, not merely attacking focal points, but seeking to blackmail nations out of their liberties by an act of mass terrorism, that horrible apparition which has been reserved for our age to see, will have passed away as a menace, from the civilised world.
Unhappily, those six, seven, eight or nine years are years of great anxiety and crisis for the world, and it may well be that the civilisation of the future and the continuation of our civilisation may depend upon whether or not peace can be maintained until the power of defending all communities from these indiscriminate and piratical attacks against the civilian population has been fully regained. Why, about 300 years ago, when a man was studying aviation and trying to make a flying machine—he was a priest—he abandoned those studies because, he said, "if ever this succeeds there is no city in any country which would not be an object of horrible assaults." What was regarded with horror in the Middle Ages, and certainly in the last 300 years, is now accepted as an arid commonplace by all the polite staff officers, and even by the politicians and philosophers of civilised Europe at the present time. We have certainly discovered this great secret of the air at a time when the human race has shown that its virtues do not unfit it to receive such a splendid gift.
My right hon. Friend the Member for Caithness—we are on the same side today, and, therefore, I may depart from the Parliamentary convention and call him my right hon. Friend—asked, in the vary careful speech that he made, a large number of questions of the Minister for Co-ordination of Defence, and I hope that, even though those questions cannot be answered in debate, my right hon. Friend the Minister will go through them in the Report with his pencil and note all the different specific points which have been raised. I know what answer he is going to give to all of them. He is going to say that all these matters have been very carefully studied, that he has examined them all. I have not the slightest doubt that they have all been examined, but I must point out that there is all the difference in the world between studying
2925
a question, having a plan on paper or a report of a committee in a pigeonhole, and having any practical measures which will enable that plan to be put into operation in an emergency. There is a gulf between the two. Take the question of moving the population, or of opening the western ports for the feeding of this island. Plans may be made for that, but, unless you have a large number of people marked down in the different districts, with the full booklet of their duties, trained in them, rehearsed in them, each of them on the moment able to go to his place with an adequate staff of subordinates around him, so that the whole matter becomes vital and concrete, and passes out of theory into life and action—unless you have that, your paper scheme will never be any shield or protection, or at least, in all probability, not until after the emergency against which it is designed has either passed away or the attack has achieved its fell purpose.
I do not propose to ask the Minister to tell us his scheme for dealing with the vexed problem of the Fleet Air Arm, because I understand that he has already made his plans and presented them to the Cabinet, and that it is not until Thursday next that he hopes to be in a position to make a statement. I trust, however, that he will be in a position to make a statement on Thursday next. It is really distressing that this matter should have flapped in the wind for so long. It is 18 months since it became a very prominent question in the House; it is 12 months, I remember, since I made upon it almost exactly the same speech that I am making now. Now we have come to a period of great and real emergency and of immense preparations, and there ought to be a decision. Four months ago my right hon. Friend, who had already been studying this matter for a long time, said he would set to work to give a decision. Now he has given a decision. It will be discreditable—I use that word deliberately—if the Government show themselves incapable of reaching a coherent decision on a matter of this kind after all this time, holding up the whole spirit and efficiency of these two Services in one very important aspect. I know that there may be an equipoise of argument, and an equipoise of influential people, but if you are not able to come to a decision and enforce your will and have it obeyed on one side
2926
or the other here, you may well find it very difficult to enforce your will on a well armed enemy, supposing, which God forfend, you should ever be called upon to defend us against one.
Neither will I attempt to ask any question about the general problem of air defence or of the Air Service. I really do not feel, though I have spoken about it in the past, that I should like to discuss the Air Service except in a secret session, and, as that is not granted, I shall certainly not attempt at persent to enter upon a technical examination of that subject, quite apart from the fact that, if I went too far into it, you, Mr. Deputy-Speaker, would very rightly correct me. But I would venture to say this, which is general and applies to all the Departments equally, and to the Minister who co-ordinates them. I am astounded at the optimism and complacency with which the position of our defence is now written and spoken of from one end of the country to another. I cannot see the slightest ground for the kind of statements which I notice in the newspapers. I read very carefully the statements made by Ministers on this matter, and I am glad to be able to confess that in most cases they seem to me, literally at any rate, to have a perfectly recognisable contact with truth. But the danger is that, while the statements made by Ministers are very carefully selected, and very often safeguarded by covering phrases and refinements which escape the public reports, a much broader effect is presented in the headlines of the newspapers, and is definitely misleading. For instance, the other day my right hon. Friend made a statement in which he indicated—I am not attempting to quote him verbatim—that in one large sphere of his production he had reached the peak of production, that the factories were proceeding at their full limits in accordance with the war programme—
