- Context
- Churchill spoke in the House of Commons in London on July 27, 1937, during a debate on supply, pressing ministers on the unstated goals of rearmament and questioning reported guns at Gibraltar.
- Main themes
- Undefined government rearmament goal, secrecy over scale of forces, German armament spending, Goering's descending hammers, continental rearmament, air force comparability claim, newspaper glosses on ministerial statements, guns at Gibraltar, Coué-ism and ministerial optimism, Under-Secretary's inadequate reply
- Duration
- ~6 min
- Words
- 717
- Sentences
- 37
- Readability
- 69
- Grade
- 8.1
- Syntax
- 3.05
- Vocabulary
- 1.96
Source: Historic Hansard (UK Parliament) ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other37 sentences in 9 paragraphs
My right hon. Friend is quite right to state his case at a minimum, but, if he said anything like that, I must point out that we do not know what is the standard at which he is aiming. We are not being told what are the forces which are being prepared, or the scale, except only in respect of the air programme, and, consequently, as we do not
2927
know what is the goal, or what is the prescribed speed and what are the stages by which we are to reach that goal, we naturally cannot judge at all whether the progress is satisfactory or not. It is no doubt true that we are, as I think my right hon. Friend did say, getting stronger every day. That may be the cause of his buoyancy, of his Coué-ism. He is able to rise in the morning and say:
On every day, in every way, I get better and better.
The question is, how much? In these matters quantity counts enormously, and, of course, everything is relative. While my right hon. Friend is marshalling his forces and increasing ours, the tremendous work of armament is proceeding abroad. We have forgotten all about that. I think it was 12 months ago that I pointed out that German was spending at the rate of £1,000,000,000 a year. All that is going on. Here and there there may be some impediment through lack of raw materials, but the whole process is continuing. The great hammers, as General Goering has said, are descending ceaselessly; mountains of ammunition and machine guns and cannon of every kind are flowing out. Ever larger armies are being raised, and behind those armies stand enormous martial populations, all under discipline, all armed, but not yet formed into regular organised units. Pray do not let us forget that, while we ourselves are making great exertions, the whole vast process of Continental rearmament is still at its fullest possible compass.
I read in the papers the other day that my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister had stated that our Air Force was comparable with any other Air Force. There was a tremendous headline. I rubbed my eyes at such a statement. But, when I came to look at what my right hon. Friend had actually said, I saw how carefully he had guarded himself, and that before this phrase there were two other phrases—in the quality of its machines and of its pilots our Air Force was comparable with any other Air Force. That is a very different statement. It is true that there is the factor of numbers, and, of course, numbers do count in the horrid sphere of force. All this I say in order to emphasise the necessity that Ministers should not in any way encourage newspapers to put a gloss upon their statements—in fact they should discourage
2928
them from putting a gloss upon their statements, which, read in their literal text, may possibly be justified.
I myself have been a sufferer recently from the love of newspapers for broad effects. I do not at all dislike the idea of broad effects, but erroneous effects are to be deprecated. The House will remember that last week I raised the question of the guns said to have been mounted at Gibraltar. I dare say it will be within the recollection of the House that I put the whole matter interrogatively, asking, is it true that there are guns there which could do this? And I said that, if there were guns in these positions, then the consequences would be so-and-so. But the "if" and the interrogative character were swept away, and what I have seen is a statement that I declared that there were guns in these positions which could do these things. I never said that. I want, however, to know a little more about the position there, and about those guns. We had a reply from the Under-Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, but the hour was late and the Noble Lord was not able to give any reasonable account of the position. We ask what guns are there; where are they; where did they come from; what is their purpose; can they in fact command the harbour; can they in fact—
