Statements at the beginning of the advanced jurisprudence class.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

22 September 1991 · Advanced jurisprudence class

Context
Khamenei addressed advanced jurisprudence students at a seminary class resumed after a long suspension, outlining the historical and contemporary role of religious seminaries in Iran on September 22, 1991.
Main themes
Role of religious seminaries, Islamic jurisprudence, preservation of religion, clergy and scholarship, spiritual guidance of society, political influence of seminaries, Islamic Revolution, hadith and religious texts, history of Shia scholarship, future of Islamic education
Duration
~56 min
95th percentile
Words
6,728
95th percentile
Sentences
203
89th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
15.8
82nd percentile
Syntax
3.18
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 51%51%
  • Social 44%44%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

203 sentences in 43 paragraphs

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds, and peace and blessings be upon our master Muhammad and his pure family, and may the curse of Allah be upon all their enemies. Amir al-Mu'minin (peace be upon him) said:

"The true jurist is the one who does not despair the people of the mercy of Allah, nor does he make them feel hopeless of the spirit of Allah, nor does he make them feel secure from the deception of Allah."

(1)

Indeed, there are numerous hadiths with this meaning, and the essence of these hadiths is that the truth should be conveyed to the people as it is: not to discourage them with strictness and narrow-mindedness, nor to encourage them to sin by indulging in desires and following opinions that are not based on principles. The core of jurisprudence is to understand the truth of religion and the truth of the Sharia and to convey it to the people. After a relatively long period of our suspension, we are resuming this discussion, and according to the customary lessons of the seminary, today we found it necessary to present some points that, God willing, may be beneficial; both for the present audience and for anyone who becomes aware of these matters. I have noted several topics in a continuous and numbered manner that I will present.

The first point is about the role of the religious seminaries in our society; whether in the past, present, or future. This role must be studied and contemplated deeply. We specifically chose the religious seminary from the collection of the clergy because this is the field of the scholars of religion and the nurturing ground for the flourishing saplings of jurisprudence in the future. These seminaries have been able, over time, to preserve and explain the religion; if it were not for the efforts of the seminaries from the beginning until today, certainly nothing would remain of the religion and the truths of religion, and the survival of the religion is indebted to the scholarly efforts of the seminaries. They have also been able to strengthen the spirit of the people, the religious spirit of the people. From these seminaries, scholars and preachers have emerged who have preached the religion among the people and strengthened the religious spirit within them, and they have also been able to guide the thoughts of society. After the era of hadith and textualism, and from the beginning of the era of reasoning until today, which has been more than a thousand years, it has been these religious seminaries that have been able to guide the religious thoughts of the people and preserve the religion and give them a religious spirit.

Over time, these seminaries have also influenced political matters, and we see this in our past history; such as during the time of Allameh Hilli (may Allah be pleased with him), who had a mobile school and even moved students with him to various cities and regions, and before him during the time of Sheikh Tusi and his students who spread throughout the Islamic world — whether in the East or the West, such as the cities of Sham and Tripoli and other regions, or perhaps Egypt — and during the time of Sayyid Murtadha, and in times closer to our own, such as the period before Sheikh Ansari — the time of the late Kashif al-Ghita — when the seminaries were influential in the ongoing transformations of life, and then the students of Sheikh Ansari: the late Mirza Shirazi and then Akhund Khorasani and others whose roles in the events before the Constitutional Revolution and in the very issue of the Constitutional Revolution and after it until our time are well known — that is to say, one must say that not everyone knows, and unfortunately, this is one of the less researched and less worked topics; they must know; it is a well-known and documented matter — and in our time, the movement of the nation and the realization of the Islamic Revolution and the emergence of a society based on Islamic foundations was accomplished through the religious seminaries; it was the scholars of the religious seminary who were the vanguards, and the students and scholars of the religious seminary were the soldiers of that commander and that leader throughout the country, and a work was accomplished that had not been done throughout the history of Islam from the time of the first generation until today, and that is the realization of this Islamic system; in the period after the revolution until today, the presence of students and seminaries in various stages of the revolution is evident. Thus, the religious seminary has a vital role for society from various aspects, and as we mentioned, this must be contemplated; that is, those who think about this and research it and gather the necessary materials and present new ideas in this field.

The second point is that now we have a treasure of such magnitude at our disposal and in the hands of the Islamic world and the Islamic clergy. Naturally, wherever in the world such a fundamental treasure exists, they plan day and night for it; they do not remain heedless of its guidance for a moment; great scholars and experts are planning how to utilize this great treasure; what about us? How much planning do we do for our religious seminaries? Who is making this planning? What percentage of the time of the great and prominent clergy is spent on planning for the seminaries? Is there organized planning for the seminaries that is equivalent to that of a small administration in worldly affairs, or equivalent to that of a small university? Certainly not. Yes, one person may sit down to think about what issues to discuss in his class until the end of the year, how to present them, which books to refer to; [but] this is far from planning for the religious seminaries.

How many religious seminaries do we currently have in the country? Then, [regarding] the religious seminary of Qom; in this greatness, in which period of the history of Shia has such a religious seminary ever existed? Not Najaf, nor Qom, nor Isfahan, nor Mashhad, nor Tabriz, nor any of the great seminaries have witnessed the flourishing and greatness that the religious seminary of Qom has had and continues to have in our time and prior to our time. Well, this treasure of such magnitude, and the other seminaries that today, thank God, exist throughout the country — whether large seminaries like Mashhad, Isfahan, Tabriz, and some other cities, or small seminaries that exist throughout the country — who is planning for them? What percentage of our time is spent on planning? It must be said that it is almost zero! In comparison to this great value, what we do is equivalent to zero. This is the second point that we must know that we need planning for the religious seminaries. Specialized and dedicated groups must engage in planning — both being involved in this work and being dedicated to it — to sit down and regularly observe the religious seminary and its path, and plan for its tomorrow and its future; practical planning.

The third point is that in the seminaries, the essence is jurisprudence; jurisprudence must progress. Jurisprudence in its specific meaning is what we are concerned with here. Jurisprudence in its general meaning, which is awareness of religion, is not the subject of our discussion here; jurisprudence in its specific meaning, which means awareness of the science of religion and the branches of religion and the deduction of individual and social duties of humans from the collection of religious texts, which is what jurisprudence is, and it is very important. This means that a person has conditions from before birth until after death, and these conditions include his individual circumstances and personal life and include his social conditions and political, economic, and social life and the rest of his affairs. The obligations and fate of all these are determined in jurisprudence. Jurisprudence in this sense is what we mean when we refer to the subsidiary rulings. The deduction of subsidiary rulings from the principles; this is the foundation of the seminaries. Of course, when we say jurisprudence, we mean what we have mentioned; when we say jurisprudence, we mean the methodology and working style in the seminaries. This methodology of deduction is termed jurisprudence, which is also used in the words of jurists to some extent in this sense: the method of jurisprudence. The method of jurisprudence means this method of relating branches to principles and deducing from principles and the foundations of deduction — the Book, the Sunnah, reason, and consensus — and the quality of this deduction and the interaction between the evidences and the arrangement and prioritization of different evidences, which one should we refer to first; for instance, we first refer to the evidences of ijtihad, we refer to the apparent meanings, if the apparent meanings are in conflict, what should we do, if we do not have apparent meanings, when does the turn of practical principles come, which principle takes precedence over another, and so on. We call this methodology that we study in the science of principles "jurisprudence." Thus, the foundation in the religious seminaries is jurisprudence in the sense of the science that has been mentioned and the methodology of jurisprudence in the sense that has been explained.

Well, jurisprudence and jurisprudential understanding must progress in the seminaries; this progress must be in terms of depth, which must become deeper than it is. As you can see, the jurisprudence of the time of Allameh Hilli (may Allah be pleased with him) is deeper than the jurisprudence of the time of Sheikh (4); that is, it has engaged with various opinions and views and has gained a specific depth and complexity over time; the jurisprudence of, for example, Muhaqqiq Thani — Ali ibn Abd al-Ali Karaki — has more depth compared to the jurisprudence of Allameh; the jurisprudence of Sheikh in Makarim, for example, has more depth. We must increase this depth. Depth does not mean getting into corners and unnecessary details; no, it means solving the issues, applying new research methods, and through them making it deeper, which in practice, someone who is engaged in research can recognize this research method. We must deepen jurisprudence; we must avoid superficiality in jurisprudence. Our jurisprudence today must be deeper than the jurisprudence of Sheikh and the students of Sheikh and the students of the students of Sheikh, who are the great figures of our predecessors; we must not think superficially about the issues; we must add complexity and depth to our thoughts. This is one dimension of the advancement of jurisprudence.

Another dimension is the breadth and comprehensiveness of life issues, meaning we should not limit ourselves to certain chapters; those that have individual importance, not social importance, for example, the chapters on purity. If you look now, you will see how many books have been written on the chapter of purity, and how many books have been written on jihad or on the chapter of judiciary or on the chapter of limits and retributions or on the chapter of Islamic economic issues; you will find that the former is more than the latter and in some cases much more. Even some of the books of our time do not have a book on jihad; for example, the author of Hadayiq did not find it necessary to discuss jihad, which is one of the principles of Islam and Sharia — of course, Hadayiq is not the period and has deficiencies, but it has gone far beyond the point where jihad should be examined; jihad is at the end of worship and before entering into transactions and contracts — they did not discuss it. And likewise, many other jurists; it is not limited to him; many others have not discussed it: the late Narqi did not discuss it and others and others; those who have discussed it have done so very briefly and have not employed the complexities of the science, for example, in some books. Well, we must broaden it, meaning our jurisprudence must progress in terms of the breadth of the scope of jurisprudence; it must encompass all issues of life.

Today, there are many issues that are not clear to us from a jurisprudential perspective. I even want to say that there are some branches in some chapters of jurisprudence that our predecessors have addressed and stated their rulings, but the later scholars have not even discussed them; meaning today, if you refer to the comprehensive work of Sheikh (may Allah be pleased with him) or to the Tahrir of Allameh, for example, you will find more branches than in many of the books of jurists who came after them, especially those jurists who are close to our time. They give less importance to branches, while each of these branches has a role in the life of society; thus, it must be expanded. Today, our jurisprudence must thoroughly address the rulings of transactions; it must look at the rulings of leasing in a global manner, derive and explain the rulings of various types of contracts from the sacred Sharia; many of these are not clear to us today.

You see, a partnership that we do not even consider as significant can, for example, manage a banking system. Well, why should we not investigate in jurisprudential books and various chapters of jurisprudence to find ways to manage life? Thus, in terms of breadth, it must progress and expand further.

In terms of methodology, the same applies; this jurisprudential methodology that has been mentioned needs refinement, innovation, and advancement; new ideas must be applied to it so that it can be made more effective. This is also the third point, so fundamentally, jurisprudence is the essence, and jurisprudence must progress in these three areas and directions.

The fourth point is that while jurisprudence is the foundation of the matter, other Islamic sciences should not be neglected in the seminaries. For example, the Quran, the science of the Quran, the understanding of the Quran, and the familiarity with the Quran must exist as a science, a field in the seminaries; our students must memorize the Quran or at least part of it, or at least be familiar with it. How many Islamic concepts are there in the Quran, and if we want to discuss in jurisprudence, we do not think of them. This isolation of the Quran in the religious seminaries and our lack of familiarity with the Quran has created many problems for us and will continue to do so, and it will narrow our perspective.

I once mentioned in the past years — before the revolution in Mashhad — in a tafsir class to the students that unfortunately — now I look and see that it is still the same — from the beginning "May Allah support you" until the time we receive our ijtihad certificate, we can go through our studies without even once referring to the Quran; meaning our educational situation is such that if a student does not refer to the Quran even once, he can take this course from the beginning to the end and become a jurist, while not having referred to the Quran even once! Why? Because our lessons do not even pass through the Quran. Sometimes in jurisprudence, we mention some Quranic verses, for example, but not to the extent that we discuss and work on them in our narrations.

The Quran is isolated from our seminary; for example, the science of the Quran, the issues related to the Quran, and the things that are under the title of the sciences of the Quran, you see that they have become common now, and the predecessors have written many books — but fortunately, some attention is being paid to it now — or tafsir. Tafsir itself is an independent science; or hadith, familiarity with hadith, the science of hadith, understanding hadith — which delving into this science should lead to good classifications, good indexing, and good utilizations, which unfortunately we are now deprived of — or the science of rijal. There should be work and research in rijal. Although good books have been written, one still feels that there is a lot of space and a huge gap in rijal. It is from this knowledge of rijal and familiarity with rijal that we want to obtain evidence for ourselves regarding the Sunnah. There must be work done on it; or history. History is very important; even from history, one can derive jurisprudential rulings. Many jurisprudential issues are related to history. We have paid less attention to this connection and have not even discovered it. Of course, I present history as an independent science; it is an Islamic science, and there should be people who work on it; or philosophy.

Philosophy, although it is prevalent in the seminaries, must be said to be neglected. Philosophy must become widespread in the seminaries. Philosophy is not just about reading the entire book of the "Nizam" or "Asfar" from beginning to end; no, mastery in philosophy means that a person should be aware of all the philosophical thoughts present in the world, which are being presented hour by hour — philosophical thoughts are being raised — and keep ourselves prepared against erroneous and deviant philosophies, and if there is a positive point in them, we should utilize that positive point. Philosophy

If this progresses in this way, the thoughts and words of great figures, to the extent of understanding their words, do not hold much value. Philosophy should lead us to knowledge. It should lead us to complete knowledge. We must see what work is being done in the realm of knowledge.

At the human level, new thoughts, new methods, and new techniques must be introduced in the field; or new discourse in the same way. Today, the theological discussions that are raised to defend religious beliefs are different from those of the past; for example, who raises the doubts of Ibn Kamunah now? There are many doubts today in the realm of human thoughts and knowledge that the scientific communities must be aware of, and they must know how to confront them; they must always have an offensive stance. In the face of philosophies, tendencies, and religions, there must always be a state of sharpness and aggression. Therefore, these fields must be given attention in the seminaries. Specialists in these sciences must be trained, and the seminaries should not look at these matters with indifference.

Suppose in the past, if someone wanted to gain a scholarly position in the seminary, they had to engage in interpretation. A respected scholar, for instance, might be an expert in interpretation, and people benefit from his interpretation, but then, because this lesson leads him to be known as uneducated, he abandons it; I ask you, is this not a tragedy? It should be the opposite; someone should be known as a specialist in interpretation — a great professor of interpretation should have a title in the seminary — he is a specialist in philosophy; he is a specialist in theology; he is a specialist in history; such things should gain value in the seminary, just as they did in the past.

In our own time, the late Allameh Tabatabai (may God be pleased with him) was at a level that if he had limited himself to jurisprudence, he would certainly have reached the rank of a source of emulation — he was among the scholars of his time, if not more, certainly not less — he entrusted jurisprudence to those who were engaged in it. At that time in Qom, the late Ayatollah Borujerdi, with his greatness, was engaged in jurisprudence, and the teachers after him; he became engaged in philosophy and revived it in Qom after there was no significant sign of philosophy there, he revived it, trained students, initiated and expanded philosophy. Of course, before him, Imam Khomeini was known for philosophy, but within a limited circle with specific students; however, he expanded it, broadened the lessons, and devoted his life to philosophy; the seminaries should be like this. It should not be that everyone must pursue the field of jurisprudence; no, a student should know that if he pursues the field of history, interpretation, philosophy, theology, or other Islamic sciences, there is a value awaiting him; appropriate valuation will be made.

The fifth point is that the seminary must be informed of global advancements in all matters related to Islamic sciences and must align itself with them. For example, today, new concepts are being introduced in sociology that relate to the work of religious scholars. These concepts — suppose the sociological or historical concepts of Marx — come into societies and become a means for propagating materialistic and philosophical thoughts of Marx; well, Marx's social discussions or economic issues are separate from his philosophical issues; although he has chained and locked them together, they are separate categories; materialism is one category, scientific socialism regarding economics is another category; or social classes as depicted by Marx in historical transformation — which is the basis of scientific socialism — is another matter, but the same economic issues, the same social concepts affect the philosophical minds of their audiences. Then, the scientific community begins to strive and walk to confront materialism!

Well, why should we not be aware from the beginning of what is being prepared and produced in the world to be presented to human thoughts so that we can prepare ourselves from the root? Should we wait until a hundred years after Marx's death, when his thoughts have spread everywhere and entered our country, and four of our youth have become members of the Tudeh party or Marxists and denied God, and then suddenly think about writing books against their atheism? Is this correct? Is this the way? Or, if from the time when, suppose, the economic or social thoughts of Marxism or any other school — I mention Marxism as an example because today there is almost no news of Marxism in the world; today there are other things — began to take root and sprout, the scientific communities were aware and aligned themselves and advanced, they could have timely and appropriately presented the correct Islamic thoughts and not allowed themselves to be in a defensive position, always maintaining an offensive position, always having a clarifying stance. Therefore, they must align themselves with thoughts that in some way relate to Islamic issues.

Suppose the dialectical logic had emerged in the world for a long time. Hegel had appeared and created a dialectic that spread throughout the world and gradually challenged the formal and structural logic that is the basis of our reasoning; we only then thought to come and dismantle or refute dialectics! Well, this kind of approach to issues is a reactive approach. One must be familiar with global transformations so that a reactive approach does not occur, but rather an active approach arises.

The sixth point is that the seminary must become familiar with modern research styles. When we say research, we mean both in-depth research, which is what we also refer to in the seminary as research, meaning deep contemplation on a subject, and also surface research, which in European methods is referred to as research, and we call it investigation — we have no issue with naming — this is also a type of research; surface research is about searching for a subject at the surface level or going deep into it. Both types of research today have modern methods; professors sit down, guide students, collective work is done, collective research is presented; collective research is more reliable than individual research; disagreements are fewer, advancements are greater. These methods should be employed in the seminary. We have always pursued individual methods in the seminary. Even now, in my opinion, the methods are individual; that is, the lesson you observe is an individual effort; it is true that a hundred or a thousand people are sitting in the lesson, but each of them is facing the professor separately, is the audience of the professor, and then goes and engages in their own work. Even our discussions are individual work; it is strange; one day this person becomes the professor, that person becomes the student, this one is the speaker, that one is the listener; one day he becomes the speaker, this one becomes the listener; that is, it is not collaborative work, it is not collective work, it is not intellectual interaction; it is individual work. This individual work, of course, has its own merits, and the advantages of this work and this form should not be lost, but collective methods are also common in the world. Well, why should we not utilize these methods? This is another point that the seminaries should consider.

Seventh, the seminary must move towards specialization. Fortunately, work has been done now, and preliminary measures have been taken, but more seriousness is needed; there should be a timeline for how long we want to fully specialize the fields. So far, two specialized fields have emerged in Qom, apparently one is interpretation, and one is theology, but this amount of two specialized fields in one corner with two professors is not enough. Of course, this is a good first step, but specialization in the seminary must be taken seriously. With this vast level that exists, with this great work that is being done, jurisprudence should be specialized; even jurisprudence itself: transactions, worship. It is true that these are interrelated and each can affect the other, but each is a separate work, while it can have a specialist. The principles, jurisprudence, various chapters of jurisprudence, and other fields should be specialized. Specialization in the seminary must be taken seriously and the degrees of specialization.

The eighth point is that serious attention must be paid to propagation in the seminary; what does this mean? It means that planning must be done for propagation. This vast reserve in the seminary is at our disposal; all these young clerics ready to speak and propagate; is this not a small matter? Well, spontaneously and automatically, of course, students always go to various places — with invitation, without invitation, good, bad, useful, less useful, very useful; it exists — but there is no accounted product awaiting this. Why? Because there is no planning. At one time, if God forbid, a student does some propagation in a corner that does not benefit everyone, there is no one to stop it or compensate for its damage; because planning has not been done beforehand, accounting has not been done; they must sit down and calculate. Where to propagate, by whom, using which propaganda tools, what the content of that propagation should be, what the goal of that propagation is, [meaning] we propagate to create what from our audience; sometimes you want to propagate to turn your audience into a volunteer for the imposed war — which was imposed on us at the front — to go to the front under the influence of your words for a month, two months, six months; this is one way; sometimes your goal from propagation is to create a believer who will live with this faith for the rest of his life; this is another way; sometimes a seasonal issue has arisen, you want to propagate to prepare him for facing that seasonal issue; [this is also] one way. Planning is necessary; there must be a specific apparatus in the seminary for propaganda planning; it must plan, work, and prepare individuals for propagation and employ new methods in propaganda. This is another point.

Ninth, pursue the idea of the unity of religion and politics, both in jurisprudence and in practice. The gentlemen should know that the idea of separating religion from politics, as a plague, has not been completely eradicated; unfortunately, there are still those in the seminaries who think that the seminary should engage in its own work and that those involved in politics and the administration of the country should engage in their own work; at most, they should not have any opposition to each other, but that religion should serve the administration of people's lives and politics should be nourished by religion and feed off of it, has not yet settled properly in some minds. We must root this idea in the seminary, in such a way that we establish jurisprudence in this manner, meaning that the legal inference should be based on the jurisprudence of the administration of the system, not the jurisprudence of individual administration — that our jurisprudence from purity to blood money should be focused on the administration of a country, the administration of a society, the administration of a system; [meaning] even in the matter of purity, when you think about pure water or, suppose, the water of a bath, you must be aware that this will have an impact on the administration of the lives of this society, up to the chapters of transactions and the general rulings and the other chapters that exist or personal affairs, etc.; all of these must be inferred as part of the administration of a country; this will affect the inference and sometimes will create profound changes — and also in practice, we must train students for the needs of society. Well, this society needs judges; an apparatus in Qom must direct students towards training judges; it should not be that the training of judges is also entrusted to someone else. Somewhere in the seminary, students should be directed towards presence in various administrative bodies of the country; suppose all these political-ideological bodies, all these various administrations that need them.

Somewhere should direct individuals, a group, towards identifying important issues that the system needs. Today, we encounter issues in the administration of the country that are our religious and jurisprudential problems; we want answers to these, but no one is accountable; we must either sit down ourselves or see someone and ask him, or suppose that in books we say they should search and find the answer to this issue. Well, an apparatus must be ready to foresee all the problems and dilemmas of the system, think, solve, and prepare ready answers for them. This is part of the duties of the scientific seminaries; the system belongs to Islam, and Islam is what the scientific seminary has been established for.

Of course, another aspect of the unity of religion and politics is that the scientific seminaries must never remain distant from politics; students must gain political awareness. Let not the political currents of the day outpace the minds of students in the scientific seminaries. They should be present in the atmosphere and even be ahead of the time; they should have a clear political thought. Just as scholars who had clear political thoughts were beneficial. We see that a scholar, a brave and effective cleric personally, due to the lack of political thought, in a place where his existence should have been beneficial, has not been effective; he has given an opinion in one place that is contrary; he has made a diagnosis in one place regarding a person that is a wrong diagnosis and has led to major mistakes, for example, in this regard. When we did not give importance to political thought, this is how it will be. A religious scholar must have a clear, alive, and timely political thought.

Tenth, maximum attention and respect should be given to Islamic values in the seminary, for example, the value of struggle; a student who has gone to the front, spent his life in the front, should have a high value in the seminary; a student who has spent part of his life in a military organization, in a part, an organ of the organs, has served there and has kept himself away from the enthusiasm and zeal of every student, which consists of being in the seminary and studying and researching for the sake of the system's interest, should be valued. Let it not be that in the seminary, a way is taken that it is imagined that if a student goes to an organization, suppose for five years, ten years, and serves there, something is taken away from his value as a student in the seminary; no, it should be said that his value increases. Is the value of this student greater or that one who did not pay attention to this need of society and while he was needed, did not even glance and was busy studying himself? Well, it is clear that the easier path, the less troublesome path, the path of comfort is for a person to stay there and let everyone do their own work, without paying any attention. Of course, he will read a few more words, but it is not certain that he will understand more and better; I tell you this; it is not certain that he will grasp the issues better. The seminary must give importance to the struggles that students have made, to the sacrifices they have made, to their presence in the fronts, to their presence in the organs, value them, and strive to compensate for any deficiencies they have in terms of knowledge in a specific manner.

[For example] those who worked for the revolution, suppose there is a student who has risen, gone to a remote area with bad weather where naturally no one is willing to go there, for the sake of the revolution's need, the people's need, the religious need, he has gone there and stayed for six months, a year, five years. Well, the seminary must value this person; this is very valuable, compared to someone who has not taken this burden upon himself, who has not endured the cold and heat, insecurity, hunger, humiliation, danger, and being away from family, and has remained in the seminary; whose value is greater? Certainly, for those who have struggled, who have made efforts, more value should be given, and these values must be recognized.

Let’s take account. We do not say more; each has its own value. Someone may have remained in the seminary, suppose they have conducted a very prominent research; that too, of course, is another value. Islamic values must be taken into account. One of these values is preaching in dangerous places and areas in need of preaching and remote locations; another is presence on the front lines; another is presence in organizations, and such things that hold importance and value.

The eleventh point that seminaries must pay attention to is that for those students who have no income other than their stipends, new methods should be utilized; ultimately, there must be efforts made such as organizational housing, special vouchers, and, for instance, insurance and similar services; these works and services must be provided for students in seminaries so that their minds can be somewhat at ease; although this attitude of contentment and asceticism is a commendable approach of our students in the seminaries. Students should not replace this with a pursuit of comfort; they must maintain it, but at the same time, these thoughts must also be considered.

The twelfth point is that in seminaries, there must be a strong avoidance of getting involved in factional issues, which, thank God, has been observed; it should continue to be observed. Especially young students must be careful not to bring these factional, group, and opposition issues and conflicts and gossip into the seminaries, as this will lead to a complete loss in the seminaries.

The thirteenth issue is that every student should plan for their future academic and intellectual life; they should not remain aimless in the seminary. For a while, there is education; they are studying Kifayah, they want to attend advanced classes; they go to advanced classes, they want to become a jurist; very well, but they must plan for the future. Everyone has their own inclinations, everyone has their own abilities, and everyone may have a specific situation available to them; they should plan these in advance and prepare themselves. It should not be that ten years, fifteen years, or twenty years pass in the seminary, wandering aimlessly around this lesson or that lesson, becoming fossilized; neither should they be of any benefit to the people nor to themselves.

And the fourteenth point, which may be one of the most important, if not the most important of these issues, is the issue of moral refinement in the seminaries, which we have spoken about a lot and have repeatedly mentioned, so we did not want to elaborate on this. The issue of moral refinement, the issue of simple living, the issue of turning away from the adornments of the world must be taken seriously in the seminaries. It should not be that a student, just two streets away from their home to the place of study, starts thinking about a personal car. What is a car? From the beginning, the foundation of the clerical work was based on hardship and disregard for worldly adornments; it is not that we should immediately think about now having a personal car, a fancy house; no, there should be a minimum level of livelihood — of course, in a way that does not occupy the mind with those things and allows them to study comfortably and perform the necessary and expected work — but it should not be that clerical work also turns into something like some other jobs that some do: pursuing luxuries and adornments and such things. This is a very significant flaw that must be strictly prevented.

And the fifteenth issue is that in the examinations of students, which is very important, examiners must guide students away from getting bogged down in some trivial and minor tasks and details and focusing on the margins and similar things. It should not be that a student thinks that if they want to take an exam, they must, for example, focus on these details; they should know these minor details in such a way that they do not miss the main issues — now this must also be observed in lessons, but primarily in exams, which is the subject of discussion — rather, they should be directed more towards research, inquiry, free thinking, broadening the issues of concern, and innovation.

The last issue is the issue of textbooks. Our textbooks are not eternal — it was said: “Three things have no end: Risālah, Makāsib, Kifāyah” — that we must read them like this until the end; no, there was a time when there was no Risālah, there was a time when there was no Makāsib, a scholar like Sheikh was established; there was a time when there was no Kifāyah, a scholar like Akhund was established. It is not the case that we think that studying must necessarily be through these books; no, we should look for the flaws in these books, provide a flawless book; see if this arrangement of knowledge is correct or not; if we see it is not correct, find the correct form; there should be specific committees for writing books, writing new materials, introducing comparative jurisprudence in the seminary, and in summary, employing new methods in the textbooks as well.

Now, these were the remarks we wanted to make regarding the issues related to the seminaries. Although the gentlemen who are present here, many of you are far removed from these issues; since you are not in the seminary and are outside of it, we wanted these issues to exist in the intellectual atmosphere of our students. (Until, God willing, tomorrow we address the issue at hand. Tomorrow we will first briefly present the list of what we have discussed from the beginning of the book of Jihad and briefly mention some of the future discussions and then begin with the issue we are concerned with.)

And all praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds.