Statements at the meeting with the members of the Supreme Council of the World Forum for Proximity of Islamic Schools of Thought.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

23 September 1991 · Meeting with the members of the Supreme Council of the World Forum for Proximity of Islamic Schools of Thought

Context
Khamenei addressed the Supreme Council of the World Forum for Proximity of Islamic Schools of Thought in September 1991, urging Muslim unity and inter-sectarian reconciliation.
Main themes
Islamic unity, Shia-Sunni reconciliation, proximity of Islamic schools of thought, sectarian conflict, Muslim solidarity, role of external enemies in Muslim division, Islamic governance and sovereignty, interfaith jurisprudential dialogue, historical sectarian manipulation
Duration
~15 min
51st percentile
Words
1,779
51st percentile
Sentences
60
40th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
14.0
67th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.23
56th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 55%50%
  • Ceremonial 22%20%
  • Geopolitical 16%15%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

60 sentences in 16 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful

(1)

First of all, we welcome everyone and congratulate you on the blessed birth of the noble Prophet of Islam (peace be upon him and his family). I view this event as a gateway to a new world and a new stage. Truly, the situation of Muslims in terms of religious contradictions and differences is regrettable. Many valuable scientific and intellectual forces of Muslims throughout history have been spent in conflict with one another. Let there be no misunderstanding; if someone makes a scientific effort to prove their faith, I do not reject that. Both Shia and Sunni, as well as any believer of any sect, have the right to prove their own path — this is something else — we do not reject that. What we reject is the effort to oppose, to crush, to insult, to deny the existence of the other side; this is wrong. In a scientific discussion, it is natural that everyone has a belief, and proving that belief means denying other beliefs; reasoning for one's own belief is a rebuttal of another's reasoning; all of this is meaningful, understandable, and bearable — such discussions always expand and deepen the realm of thought and advance it — there is no obstacle to that. However, when two groups, both belonging to Islam and both believing in the same fundamental principles, line up against each other to obliterate or harm or insult one another, this is a tragedy; we must prevent this.

As far as I can remember, throughout history, religious conflicts and wars among Muslims have been orchestrated by the powerful. From the time of the Abbasids and the wars that occurred between the newly established theological schools of that era, and the mutual massacres where sometimes one caliph supported one idea and sometimes another caliph supported another idea, up to later times, hands have always incited the supporters of different Islamic beliefs against each other. If these hands had not been there, they would have lived together in peace and tranquility for years without any problems. An example of this is the Islamic countries where different Islamic sects live together; one example is Iran, another is Iraq, and there are other countries as well. When did they line up against each other? When did the people and the believers fight each other? In any case, we must put the past in the protective cover of forgetfulness and consider it as if it never existed.

In the present time, efforts are being made to ensure that Muslims are not united and work against each other. These efforts have intensified especially at a time when the need for unity among Muslims is greater than ever, and it is very close to reality that the motivation behind these efforts by the enemies is to prevent the realization of the aspirations of Islam's dominance and governance, which is now approaching practical stages. It is natural that if Islam is to gain sovereignty and Muslims want to adhere to Islam in the Islamic world, it is not possible with these differences. The most catastrophic obstacle to the sovereignty and dominance of Islam is to incite Muslims against each other within Islamic societies; whether in one country or in multiple Islamic countries; what difference does it make? If today the press of one country starts attacking one sect of Islam, the press of another country will reciprocally attack their sect — this means bringing political disputes into the realm of religious thought and using the backing of religious thought and fanaticism to incite groups against each other — this is the greatest obstacle to Muslims thinking about the dominance of Islam and being able to realize it.

Therefore, today "approximation" is an urgent goal; a divine purpose; a vital thought that must be pursued. This is a temporal void, and more than at any other time, we must fill it. Blessed are those who can fill the void of their time; who understand the moment's desire and fulfill it. Some actions, if taken at a specific moment, are beneficial, and if not taken at that moment, they may not have that benefit. Today, the Islamic world is in need of this approximation.

In this approximation, as has been repeatedly stated, the aim is for Islamic sects to come closer together; both in terms of thought, where perhaps some of the perceptions of sects about each other may lead to a good conclusion through discussion and negotiation; perhaps some misunderstandings may be resolved; perhaps some beliefs may be moderated, and some thoughts may genuinely come closer together; this, of course, if achieved, is much better than any other form and at the very least emphasizes the commonalities — the least benefit of these discussions and negotiations will be — and avoids the discussion of divisive issues. This is at the level of thought and belief.

At the level of jurisprudence, exchanging views among different sects will lead to close or even unified fatwas in many jurisprudential matters. Some Islamic sects have significant research and advancements in certain jurisprudential areas, and others can benefit from them. Innovations sometimes in some Islamic rulings and interpretations from the Quran and Sunnah may be available to some Islamic sects that others will use, leading to fatwas that are close to or shared among them. We sometimes see a fatwa from one sect being quoted while that fatwa is an unusual one in that sect. The followers of that sect may avoid that fatwa or not insist on it. Why do we not seek to find common fatwas?

And ultimately, perhaps more importantly than all the results of approximation, is practical approximation, meaning cooperation among Muslims with the exclusion of sectarian ideological separations; and this is very possible and easily achievable if the enemies allow it and if we are wise. We have repeatedly seen this among ourselves and in other communities, especially after the victory of the Islamic Revolution. Shia and Sunni brothers sit next to each other and discuss practical issues, political matters, and issues related to the fate of Islam in such a way that they do not even remember what their sect is and what the other’s sect is. We have always observed this feeling in ourselves and have seen it in many of our associates from various sects.

So these are the three stages; both in the stage of belief, in the stage of jurisprudential rulings, and in the stage of practical cooperation. And what guarantees these is that, firstly, they look intelligently at the enemy's conspiracy, and secondly, they think more about those aspects of Islam that guarantee this approximation.

At the forefront of the activities of the late Ayatollah Borujerdi (may God have mercy on him) for approximation — as I have heard and to some extent know — was attention to the Hadith of Thaqalayn, which is agreed upon among different Islamic sects and has been transmitted repeatedly — in the same way that Shia have narrated it, it is also found in the books of our Sunni brothers; although they have narrated it in a different form — in any case, they should make this the focal point, meaning the issue of the Ahl al-Bayt, which is accepted by all Muslims, and all Muslims have affection for them and hold a religious belief in them; each in their own way. And similarly, one can find in Islam various instances from Islamic texts that can serve as the foundations for approximation. In practice, this assembly should create research groups — whether under the university that will hopefully be established or in other forms — to be able to research and examine the discussable issues of approximation.

Of course, one of the tasks that must be undertaken is the effort to prevent the dissemination of divisive works; whether in the Shia environment or in the Sunni environment. Works are currently being written, money is being spent to create animosity and hatred; well, we must try to prevent these if we can. They are published everywhere; we do not say that they are not published in Iran at all; no, unfortunately, there are instances observed in Iran as well; divisive, hatred-inducing works are published from both sides. One of the points of attention for this assembly should be that they discuss religious matters, write multiple books, present their desired arguments in their books — this is another topic — but they should not publish works that cause division, that incite hatred, that deepen animosity. There should be a focus on how this assembly can appropriately oversee and monitor this matter. I receive various books from different parts of the world that clearly show that some people have been striving to write these books to create hatred and discord and concern. Now that in the Islamic Republic, thank God, the flag of Islam and the Quran is raised high, and now that the slogans are Islamic and attractive, they are trying to instill animosity towards this country, this nation, and this government in the hearts of Muslim brothers in various parts of the world; they write books specifically for this purpose; the enemy is not sitting idle.

In any case, we seek the success of you all from God Almighty. I sincerely thank the dear brothers who have endeavored to form this central council, especially Mr. Vaez-Zadeh, who dedicates his effort, thought, life, and labor to this path, and all those who cooperate with you. I humbly and earnestly ask God Almighty to assist you and enable you to walk this path with steadfastness and strength, and may we see the results of it, God willing, in the near future, and perhaps the results of your work will also reach the souls of those who first established the House of Approximation fifty or sixty years ago, as they took the first step, and virtue is for those who precede;

(5)

we are following in their footsteps, but now that was one style of work, this may be another style; that was in a condition that focused more on scientific and intellectual issues, today the conditions are different because politics has unfortunately intervened in this matter to a great extent; back then, political hands did not create such divisiveness, today there are many motivations for political powers and political elites; hence, they are doing a lot of work, and naturally, new elements have emerged today. I pray for you all. God willing, convey our greetings to the rest of the attendees.

And peace be upon you and God's mercy and blessings.