Statements at the beginning of the advanced jurisprudence class.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

5 September 1995 · Advanced jurisprudence class

Context
Khamenei addressed students at the opening of an advanced Islamic jurisprudence class in Iran in September 1995, presenting an ethical hadith on detachment from worldly desires.
Main themes
Detachment from worldly desires, Islamic ethics and hadith studies, advanced jurisprudence, hadith chain of narration, divine guidance to Moses, love of the world as spiritual danger, envy and wealth, obedience and falsehood, Shia hadith scholarship
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,250
92nd percentile
Sentences
235
92nd percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.13
64th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
44th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 55%53%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Economic 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

235 sentences in 31 paragraphs

In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

At the beginning of my speech, for the sake of blessing and good fortune, I present an ethical hadith:

“Ali ibn Ibrahim, from his father, from Ibn Mahbub, from some of his companions, from Ibn Abi Ya'fur, said: I heard Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) say: When Allah, the Exalted, spoke to Moses (peace be upon him): O Moses, do not lean towards the world as the oppressors lean, nor take it as a father and mother. O Moses, if I had left you to yourself to look after yourself, then the love of the world and its allure would have overwhelmed you. O Moses, compete in good deeds with your people and strive to be ahead of them in it, for good is like its name. Leave behind what you are rich enough to do without in this world, and do not let your eyes look upon every captivated by it and entrusted to himself; and know that every temptation begins with the love of the world, and do not envy anyone for their wealth, for with great wealth comes great sins due to the obligations of rights, and do not envy anyone for the people's approval of him, until you know that Allah is pleased with him. And do not envy a creature for the people's obedience to him, for the obedience of the people to him and their following him in falsehood is destruction for him and for those who follow him.”

The chain of narration is disconnected, but apparently, in the hadiths that convey wisdom, ethics, and truths for humanity, it is not clear that a disconnection is harmful. It does not carry a legal ruling that one must seek evidence for and say that one cannot rely on a disconnected report. These are truths that, when observed, one sees their correctness, credibility, and authenticity embedded within them. It is evident that these are either certainly the words of the infallible (peace be upon him) or derived from the words of those great figures. Therefore, the disconnection in the chain of this hadith should not create the slightest doubt or suspicion in accepting the content of this hadith.

Of course, aside from this disconnection, the narrators of the chain are also highly trustworthy and of great stature: “Ali ibn Ibrahim” and “Ibrahim ibn Hashim,” which is well known. “Ibn Mahbub” is also “Hasan ibn Mahbub Sarad,” one of the trustworthy and great figures, and according to all accounts, he is among the companions of consensus. “Ibn Abi Ya'fur” is the same esteemed man from whom this hadith is narrated: “By Allah, if I were to split a pomegranate in half and say this is forbidden and this is permissible, I would testify that what I said is permissible is permissible and that what I said is forbidden is forbidden.” He is also the one to whom the Imam said twice in response: “May Allah have mercy on you.” After his death, Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him) wrote a letter to “Mufaddal” in Kufa to give him the agency that “Abdullah ibn Abi Ya'fur” previously held. In that letter, several times after mentioning the name “Abdullah ibn Abi Ya'fur,” the Imam says: “May Allah's blessings be upon him!”

He said, I heard Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him) say in what Allah, the Exalted, spoke to Moses (peace be upon him). It is evident that the Lord of the Worlds wants to convey the highest truths and wisdom to His great and noble Prophet. In this passage, the expression “revealed” is not used; rather, the term “spoke” is employed. Perhaps this is because the Lord of the Worlds is conveying a very important matter in a whisper-like dialogue with Moses (peace be upon him): “O Moses, do not lean towards the world as the oppressors lean.” “Leaning” means a heartfelt inclination and spiritual reliance, which, if we were to translate it into contemporary Persian, seems to be best expressed as “giving your heart.” Thus, it can be translated as: “Do not give your heart to the world as the oppressors have given their hearts to it.” If there is no attachment to the world, a person does not commit injustice and does not harm the servants of God. Committing injustice signifies the utmost desire and inclination towards the world.

“And do not lean towards those who have taken it as a father and mother.” Those who have taken the world as their father and mother—meaning all their thoughts are on the world, and they do not think of anything else nor show inclination towards anything else—are like a child who seeks refuge in his parents and thinks of nothing else. “O Moses, if I had left you to yourself to look after yourself, then the love of the world and its allure would have overwhelmed you.” “To look after yourself” is different from “to look at it.” Looking at the world is not a blameworthy act; thinking about the world is blameworthy. O Moses! If I had left you to your own devices to think about the world, then the love and beauty of the world would have overwhelmed you.

I would like to point out that in this hadith and similar hadiths, the term “world” does not refer to the earth and its possessions, or to the development and engagement in people's affairs, and similar activities; rather, it refers to the manifestations of the world (wealth, status, and position) that a person desires for himself. Therefore, anything from the divine blessings on earth, the beauties, pleasures, and livelihoods that pertain to the self and are desired for oneself is considered “the world” in the expressions of the hadith and is blameworthy. It is evident that the more a person thinks about and engages with the world, the more his desire and longing for it increases, and when he turns away from the world, gradually his love for it diminishes. The intent of this narration and similar ones is not that a person should abandon activity and effort in life and go sit in a corner of the house. Some have thought this way and for years—indeed, some for centuries—have adopted a wrong approach that has led to isolation and withdrawal from activities and efforts in life, attributing it to Islam. Therefore, the meaning of “the world” is not this erroneous interpretation.

“O Moses, compete in good deeds with your people and strive to be ahead of them in it.” In good deeds, compete with your people. Competing means a state of eager rivalry that a person develops towards something. “And strive to be ahead of them in it,” means to be ahead of all in good deeds. “For good is like its name.” “Good” is as good as its name. Apparently, it refers to good deeds, public acts of kindness, helping believers, unity, worship of the Lord, and asceticism in the world, and other good qualities. The term “good” also has a comparative meaning that indicates superiority. It states: Good deeds are like their name and are better than anything else. The good deeds that a person performs are better than anything that comes to mind. If you visit the sick, if you do kindness to a believer, if you cooperate in works, if you seek knowledge, if you disregard the world, if you engage in jihad in the way of Allah, or enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong, and if you perform the worship of God; all of these are good deeds. These deeds are better than anything that comes to mind, such as wealth, children, status, and other various values. Both the late Majlisi and the author of Tuhaf al-Uqul provide several interpretations, one of which is this very interpretation. They offer other interpretations as well, but this interpretation seems to be the most certain.

“And leave behind what you are rich enough to do without in this world.” Leave behind that which you do not need from the world and is not among your necessities and is excessive. “And do not let your eyes look upon every captivated by it.” This phrase can be read in several ways: “And do not let your eye look,” where “eye” is the subject of “look”; meaning do not let your eye gaze. Or “And do not let your eye show,” meaning do not display it to your eye. Or “Do not let your eye look,” which could be construed as “Do not look with your eye” or “Do not let your eye gaze,” meaning do not present it to your eye. “Upon every captivated by it.” Those who are captivated by the world and enchanted by it, “and entrusted to himself,” and someone who has been left to himself or to his own devices, and divine support and guidance has been taken from him, “And know that every temptation begins with the love of the world.” All temptations begin with the love of the world. The reality is just that. When we look at the world, we see that throughout history, the root of all temptations and misguidance, and the places where truth and falsehood have mixed, lies in the love of the world. There have been those who, due to their love for the world, status, and affection for family and friends, have initiated actions that led to turmoil. Truly, this subject is one of those remarkable pieces of wisdom. Wherever you look in the world, you see it is just so.

“And do not envy anyone for their wealth.” Do not envy those who have great wealth. This is one of the afflictions that some weak-minded individuals experience in life, and they envy others for their grand houses, abundant luxuries, and numerous possessions! “For with great wealth comes great sins due to the obligations of rights.” When wealth increases, obligations also increase, and for this reason, sins also multiply. It becomes clear that when obligations increase, a person cannot fulfill them; otherwise, if he could fulfill them, there would be no sin involved. This is provided that the wealth is acquired through lawful means. If it is through unlawful means, it will have a worse form. Of course, there is also a possibility that the hadith refers to the accumulation of wealth through unlawful means; that is, when a person acquires wealth that is not lawful, he must have trampled upon many rights to obtain that wealth. “And do not envy anyone for the people's approval of him.” Do not envy someone who is liked by the people or has their affection, “until you know that Allah is pleased with him.” If Allah is pleased with someone, then envy him; but if people love someone and chant slogans for him and gather around him and show affection and closeness to him, do not envy him. How do you know; perhaps, God forbid, there is a flaw or corruption in his essence that displeases Allah. In that case, the people's approval will not benefit him. Truly, the approval of the people—if it is real—what benefit does it have? “And do not envy a creature for the people's obedience to him.” If you see that people obey someone and accept his commands and will, there is still no place for envy. “For the obedience of the people to him and their following him in falsehood is destruction for him and for those who follow him.” If the people's following him—God forbid—is not based on truth, it is a source of destruction for him and for those who follow him. May Allah, the Exalted, protect us, by the sanctity of our infallibles, from following and being followed in falsehood and not bring us into that state.

If this narration had no chain of transmission at all, its high wisdoms, which are beyond any doubt, would still guide us. These instructions are divine and Islamic teachings, and it is appropriate to adhere to them. The reason I chose this narration is that today our society is in a condition where it must be reminded of the hadiths of asceticism. In Nahj al-Balagha, much has been said about asceticism; however, this does not indicate that asceticism is the highest obligation of a person; no. In some places, asceticism is higher, and in other places, jihad, worship, and the pursuit of knowledge are higher. The timing indicates that today is a time when we must call society to asceticism; because it is moving towards wealth, and wealth is increasing in the country, and it is a place where those who are worldly can acquire wealth through various means and obtain it “through unlawful means,” and even if the accumulation of wealth is through lawful means, they may become captivated by the world and suffer the adverse consequences of temptation; especially in the religious seminaries and the areas where clerics, scholars, students, and the learned live.

The matter I present to you today begins with obvious and clear premises and reaches an obvious and clear conclusion; however, in my opinion—as a student and a responsible person in the Islamic Republic and as a believer in the mission of scholars in the religious and worldly affairs of the people—this obvious conclusion from these obvious premises has not been acted upon as it should be. Of course, good work has been done: “And do not deprive people of their due.” A person should not violate the rights of those who have worked hard and labored. Honestly, a lot has been done; however, what needs to be done is several times more than what has been done so far.

The first obvious premise is the necessity of activities and efforts of the religious seminaries. The reason for the activities of the religious seminaries, which today the most important and esteemed among them is the Qom seminary and some other major seminaries in Iran, such as the Mashhad seminary and others, and God willing, the Najaf seminary (when it is freed from the clutches of the wicked and oppressors); firstly, it is the need of the Islamic government, which has not had a government with these characteristics, based on religious laws and regulations, since the time of Amir al-Mu'minin and Imam al-Hasan (peace be upon them). This is the first time a government has been established based on the Quran, and an Islamic society—with all the problems and hardships that this work has entailed and continues to entail—has come into existence. This divine system and government, for action, firstly needs Islamic knowledge and regulations. Secondly, in some areas, there are individuals needed to manage certain affairs of this system, and these two needs must be met by the seminaries. Of course, this does not mean that all affairs or important matters must be handled by scholars; no. All believers, righteous individuals, thinkers, and researchers have their own places. There are specialists in various fields in the country who carry out these tasks. Some tasks must be undertaken by the scholars of religion; these individuals must also be trained by the religious seminaries. Therefore, if the needs of the Islamic community and government and its establishment are raised, the religious seminaries must meet them. If a society becomes irreligious, it will naturally not feel the need for scholars; however, when a society is religious, it feels the need for scholars and teachers of ethics, religion, and knowledge.

If we had scholars in the past who spoke or wrote or addressed doubts or conveyed knowledge, today we need several times that number with high qualities. Books, pamphlets, magazines, and media are needed to undertake this mission and write and speak about religion, knowledge, and ethics. There are those who are inclined to study; they should benefit from these. There are also those who utilize media; the media should also benefit from these. Scholars of religion must prepare writings related to Islamic knowledge, whether in the form of books and pamphlets or in the form of magazines and various publications, so that artists can create films based on them or produce various programs.

The third necessity for the activities of the religious seminaries is the need of intellectuals and youth. These are the groups that face doubts. Everywhere, the first audience for doubts are intellectuals and thinkers, who are often among the youth and educated individuals. Many people do not encounter doubts. They have faith and live a good life according to their faith. Those who are inclined to study confront the world and speak about the essence of religion, Islam, its knowledge, as well as the principles, branches, and history of religion, and they constantly propagate doubts. There must be individuals to dispel these doubts. The responsibility for providing these individuals lies with the religious seminaries. Of course, those outside the seminaries may be able to perform this task; however, the main responsibility, honestly, lies with the religious seminaries and scholars of religion. They are the first ones who must dispel doubts.

The fourth necessity is the need of Muslim communities and new Muslims. Observe today how many people around the world are turning to Islam; both those who were Muslims but did not know Islam as a message of life and only knew it as a collection of rituals and bowing and prostrating and sitting in the corner of the mosque, and those who were not previously Muslims. Today, Islam is presented as a message of life and a response to social dilemmas, as well as a way to escape the problems of the 20th and 21st centuries that are approaching. They view Islam in this light and are turning to it. Today, in Western countries, including the United States and major European countries, Islam is rapidly growing. This is not the claim of a preacher who has heard something and is saying it; no. I say this based on accurate information that many individuals in Christian and Western countries have turned to Islam. They have recognized Islam and have questions about it and want to know this religion.

Young, good, pure, educated, talented, and outstanding individuals from Europe, who have converted to Islam at their universities, come to us seeking guidance on Islamic issues. Who should guide them? Who should go there, reside among them, and teach them religion and ethics? Who should send them books? Who should clarify the issues for them? The answer to all these questions is related to the religious seminaries. Many non-Muslim communities have shown interest in Islam - even if they have not converted - but they want to know what Islam is that has established this great system, formed a government, confronted superpowers, fears no one, and manages the world; a religion that enters the field of life and is not affected by the necessities, pressures, fears, tremors, and weaknesses of other governments. Who should articulate this religion? Should we wait for the illiterate or those who have no knowledge of Islam and have only learned about it from others to go there!?

I knew individuals who spoke about Islamic issues out of belief and reasoning. They knew no more than ten hadiths, had not read a single hadith book from beginning to end, and had never contemplated the Quran even once; rather, they had heard things from others and then adapted them to their own minds, weaving together their own narratives about Islam! Should these people speak about Islam, or should the scholars of God and religious scholars, those who have deep engagement with religious issues and are experts and specialists in their work?

The fifth need is for the seminaries to have teachers, researchers, authors, and specialists in various fields. Thankfully, this matter is being addressed in the seminaries. There are researchers, teachers, specialists, and great scholars who are ready to work; however, if you look at the seminaries twenty years from now, you will see that those who are present are few. Look closely at the next twenty years and see what we need; then you will realize that the great figures who are currently present in the seminaries are limited in number. One of our most important needs is this. The seminaries must aim to cultivate researchers and scholars to meet this need.

Thus, the first point is to establish the need for an active seminary, and the second point is that there has always been motivation to oppose the seminaries. The Qajar kings opposed the scholars and seminaries and regarded the seminaries' individuals as part of the great scholars' army. They opposed the scholars because the scholars intervened in their affairs. If they wanted to sign the Reji contract and have relations with the English, or if they wanted to marry two sisters, the scholars would not allow it and would stand against them. Later, during the Pahlavi era, the situation changed. Since the time of Reza Khan, fundamental motivations entered the scene, and the West - especially England - aimed to completely seize Iran. This takeover was either in the form of establishing a truly English government - which they could not achieve - or forming an Iranian government while having all its affairs in their hands. The second path was chosen, and the Pahlavi government was established based on this decision, with Reza Khan coming to power.

If you see that all the respectable people of Iran oppose Reza Khan, it is because he was a lowly, uneducated person who had never heard of religion and had never tasted its essence. He was raised in an illiterate, careless family, far from religious knowledge, and when he grew up, he wandered among coffee houses, taverns, and ruffians. Reza Khan was not someone who had anything to do with religion. His disposition was ready to oppose religion - with the intention of overthrowing it. There are weak-minded, ill-intentioned, and ill-tasting individuals who sometimes praise Reza Khan's so-called developmental works, saying for example that he built railroads and established security! One should ask them whether the construction of railroads and the establishment of security was for the people or for foreign powers!? Who benefited from these so-called developmental works? In reality, Reza Khan was a tool that the English brought into the scene to dismantle the religious system in Iran. For this reason, in 1935, he banned the wearing of turbans and the presence of clergy in society, dismantled the seminaries, and forced the clergy into seclusion. When he left and his son - Mohammad Reza - came to power and took control, he had the same intention and pursued the same goal and path - albeit in more modern and advanced forms - until the day the revolution succeeded.

The Pahlavi regime was overthrown; however, the motivations for opposing the seminaries continue to exist. The regime of the United States, which supported Mohammad Reza from the coup of August 19 until the victory of the revolution and acted against religion, today, through some of its agents - who may not even be aware of it themselves - is engaged in diminishing and insulting religion, religious scholars, and seminaries. During Reza Khan's time, to discredit the clergy, he would say: the clergy are parasites; meaning they do not engage in manual labor or administrative work, yet continue their lives. With his limited intellect, he thought that if someone did not trade in the market, or did not work with a shovel, or did not go to an office and did not find a job, they should not eat bread, and if they did, they were parasites! Because he did not believe in the mission of religion, he made such statements and did not recognize the work of a religious scholar.

Today, some people express the same sentiment in different words. Those who educate the people, work hard for them, make them religious, and increase their guidance, providing the ground for the realization of the noble verse "Guide us on the straight path," are the people of religion and guidance and are considered the guides of this path. They write books, teach lessons, work hard, and earn a modest living. How much do the students of the seminary benefit from the world? The salary of a capable student in Qom - which is the highest of the seminaries - is not even half of the salary of a laborer who works with a shovel. Their income is less than the minimum administrative salary. With this situation, can we say that our clergy earn their bread through religion!? Is this not oppression, injustice, and unfairness? Our government is Islamic, and there is freedom of expression in it, and these statements, which are made out of unfairness, have been raised in this free atmosphere.

Of course, I do not mean that we should respond to every word or quarrel; no. The point is that you should know that there are many and widespread motivations for opposing the seminaries. Some of those who have such motivations do not even realize what they are doing. They do not have bad intentions, but they do not realize what consequences their words and actions have. In the seminaries themselves, there have always been motivations to weaken the seminaries, and there are currently motivations to weaken them. A young student whose life in the seminary is not good is forced to turn his back on the seminary to make a living. The seminary cultivates one person, develops their talents, and brings them to academic ranks; then, when the time comes to benefit from them, they find that the door of a certain office or academic center is open for teaching. They are forced to go there and get involved in work. It cannot be said that this work is forbidden. After all, necessity and need exist, and some individuals do this; however, this act is turning their back on the seminary. Of course, I do not mean those who take on a task for the system and carry it out. No; they should come and take charge of the assigned matters. I mean those who turn their backs on the seminary and do not perform religious work. So, see that there are motivations for diminishing, weakening, and insulting both outside and inside the seminary.

We are here with those immense needs and these fragile hostilities accompanied by schemes and ill will. What should the seminary do? The answer is that it should utilize the resources it has and build itself in the best and most precise way. Not a single bit of the resources of the seminary, the majority of which is human resources, should be wasted. Not a single hour of a student's or teacher's lesson should be wasted, useless, or unrelated to those needs. A student studying in the seminary should move in the direction of fulfilling one of the needs and addressing one of the necessities; that is, they should prepare themselves either for internal or external needs, for authorship or research, for teaching or education. Thankfully, in recent years, very important work has been done in this regard, and I must thank the Supreme Council and the management of the seminary. A lot of effort has been made in the seminary of Qom, and much has been attempted; however, what remains and has not yet been accomplished is several times more than what has been done so far. This movement should not slow down; rather, it should gain more speed, resilience, and correctness day by day, and if work is going wrong or slowly in one place, it should be corrected and expedited.

The great figures at the head of the Supreme Council of the seminary should look at the world and the country and see what needs exist and how these needs can be met and how individuals who address these needs can be trained. If we need books, then we need authors. How is a good author trained? Their training method should be included in the seminary's programs. If we want proficient missionaries - not just five, ten, or a hundred, but thousands of missionaries - who can carry out this work in every corner of the world; what conditions are necessary for their training? How are these conditions met in a person, and by what factors? These matters should be included in the planning. It should be examined which subjects are excessive and unnecessary, so they can be removed. The courses should be structured in such a way that if someone can complete part of several courses, that amount should be beneficial for them. The notion that one must spend twenty or twenty-five years in the seminary is not true. Some needs can be met by staying in the seminary for four years. Some needs can be met by staying for ten years. Others may require fifteen years, and some may even require twenty years in the seminary. Why should we unnecessarily keep someone who can address part of our needs with four or five years of study in the seminary for ten years? We must plan and bring individuals to this level. We should grant privileges and make it clear what needs each person can fulfill.

The seminary should provide certification and validation. I have mentioned this point once again. The certification of ijtihad is one of the things that has existed in the seminary since ancient times; it is still a very good thing today. Some gentlemen think that if we want to evaluate a student's studies, we must say that this level of study in the seminary is equivalent to a certain university degree - for example, a bachelor's, master's, or doctoral degree. There is no need to do this. The subjects of the seminary are one thing, and university subjects are another. Of course, this may be necessary in its own place. For example, this person may want to work in some administrative offices that require a degree. Naturally, they should know how much this individual's degree is worth. However, the needs of the seminary go beyond this. We need various clergy at different levels with different specializations and abilities. Talents vary. Talents should be recognized, lessons should be studied, courses should be differentiated, and young scholars in the seminary should be utilized; because many blessings will come from this group.

The seminary should operate like a factory that supplies the needs of society, regularly producing its output, which consists of researchers, missionaries, teachers, authors, and various classes of clergy. The seminary should plan and specify how many suitable missionaries will be trained for various regions of the world and within the country in five years. It should also have organized and systematic planning in the areas of Quranic issues, interpretation, and other seminary sciences, as well as training teachers for universities and Islamic knowledge courses, and training researchers and authors to respond to and counter doubts.

We hope that, God willing, the Almighty grants success to the esteemed gentlemen and great scholars and that they may be included in the attention and pure prayers of the Awaited Savior, may our souls be sacrificed for him. God willing, the work will be done in the best way so that the seminary can find a form that meets the needs of this time as quickly as possible.

Praise be to God, the Lord of the worlds.