Statements at the opening ceremony of the International Congress of Imam Reza (peace be upon him) in Mashhad.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

19 July 1986 · International Congress of Imam Reza (peace be upon him) · Mashhad, Iran

Context
Khamenei addressed the opening ceremony of the International Congress of Imam Reza in Mashhad on July 19, 1986, exploring the political dimensions of the Shia Imams' lives.
Main themes
Imam Reza and the Shia Imams, political struggle in the lives of the Imams, unity of the Imamate across 250 years, historical estrangement of the Imams, Islamic leadership and divine government, Shia theology and jurisprudence, lessons from Imams' lives, monotheism and establishment of divine rule, Minor Occultation, tactical conduct in long-term movements
Duration
~120 min
99th percentile
Words
14,349
99th percentile
Sentences
335
96th percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
17.8
93rd percentile
Syntax
3.51
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.53
96th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 47%41%
  • Institutional 35%31%
  • Geopolitical 11%10%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

335 sentences in 102 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

All praise is due to God, the Lord of the worlds, and may God’s blessings be upon our master and prophet, Abu al-Qasim Muhammad, and upon his pure and chosen family, the infallible guides, especially the remaining one of God on the earth.

One of the long-standing wishes in this community is being fulfilled. The estrangement of the Imams (peace be upon them) did not end with the lifetime of these great figures; rather, for centuries, the lack of attention to important and perhaps fundamental aspects of their lives has continued their historical estrangement. Certainly, the books and writings throughout these centuries possess unparalleled value because they have managed to leave a collection of narrations regarding the lives of these great figures as a legacy for future generations. However, the element of acute political struggle, which constitutes the continuous line of the lives of the Imams of guidance (peace be upon them) over 250 years, has been lost among the narrations, hadiths, and biographies that focus on their scientific and spiritual aspects. We must learn from the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them) as lessons and examples, not merely as glorious and valuable memories; and this is not possible without paying attention to the political methods and conduct of these great figures.

Personally, I have developed an interest in this aspect of the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them), and it is worth mentioning that this thought first occurred to me in the year 1350 during a difficult period of trial and testing. Although I had previously regarded the Imams as great fighters who sacrificed themselves for the elevation of the word of monotheism and the establishment of a divine government, the point that suddenly became clear to me at that time was that the lives of these great figures, despite apparent differences—some even felt contradictions among certain aspects of this life—are, in total, a continuous and long movement that begins in the year 11 of the Hijra and continues for 250 years, concluding in the year 260, which marks the beginning of the Minor Occultation. These great figures are one unit, one personality; there can be no doubt that their goal and direction are the same. Therefore, instead of analyzing the life of Imam Hasan al-Mujtaba (peace be upon him) separately, the life of Imam Husayn (peace be upon him) separately, and the life of Imam Zain al-Abidin (peace be upon him) separately—so as not to fall into the dangerous mistake of thinking that the conduct of these three Imams is contradictory due to their apparent differences—we should imagine a single human being who lived for 250 years, who embarked on a path in the year 11 of the Hijra and continued along this path until the year 260 of the Hijra. All the actions of this great and infallible human being will be understandable and justifiable from this perspective. Any human being endowed with reason and wisdom, even if not infallible, will have tactics and situational choices in a long-term movement; sometimes it may be necessary to move quickly, and sometimes slowly; at times, it may even be necessary to engage in a wise retreat, but that retreat, from the perspective of those who understand his knowledge and wisdom and his goal-oriented nature, is considered a forward movement. With this view, the life of Amir al-Mu'minin, the life of Imam al-Mujtaba, the life of Abu Abdullah, and the lives of the other eight Imams, up to the year 260, constitute a continuous movement; I realized this in that year and entered into the study of their lives with this perspective, and upon further reflection, this thought was confirmed.

Of course, discussing this matter cannot be contained within a single session, but considering that the continuous lives of these noble and infallible figures from the family of the Messenger of God are accompanied by a political orientation, it is worthy of being addressed as a separate chapter, and today I will focus on this matter. In last year’s message, I referred to the acute political struggle in the lives of the Imams and in the life of the eighth Imam; today, God willing, I would like to elaborate on this statement.

First of all, what do we mean by political struggle, or acute political struggle, that we attribute to the Imams (peace be upon them)? It means that the struggles of the infallible Imams (peace be upon them) were not merely scientific, doctrinal, and theological struggles, such as the theological debates you observe in the history of Islam during this period—like the Mu'tazila, the Ash'ariyya, and others; the purpose of the Imams in these gatherings and lessons of hadith and the transmission of knowledge and the explanation of laws was not solely to definitively establish a theological or jurisprudential school to which they were affiliated and to clarify their opponents. Rather, it was something beyond this; nor was it a military struggle like that which one observes in the history of the Imams, in the life of Zayd and his descendants, and also among the descendants of al-Hasan and some of the family of al-Ja'far and others; the Imams (peace be upon them) did not engage in that struggle either. However, let me point out here—if we have time later, I will elaborate—that they did not entirely disapprove of it; some were criticized for reasons other than the act of armed struggle, while others were fully supported, and in some cases, they participated in a supportive role; "I would have liked that the Khawarij from the family of Muhammad had risen, and I would have provided for their families." They provided financial assistance, support in reputation, sheltering, and similar acts; however, they themselves, as the Imams (peace be upon them)—the lineage we know—did not engage in armed struggle and could not do so. Political struggle is neither the first nor the second; it is a struggle with a political goal; what is that political goal? It is the establishment of an Islamic government, or as we say, an Alawite government.

From the moment of the death of the Messenger of God until the year 260, the Imams sought to establish a divine government in the Islamic community; this is the essence of the claim. Of course, we cannot say that they wanted to establish an Islamic government in their own time, meaning that each Imam sought to establish it during his own time; rather, there were mid-term and long-term futures, and in some cases, even short-term ones. For example, during the time of Imam al-Mujtaba (peace be upon him), in our view, the effort to create an Islamic government was aimed at the near future; Imam al-Mujtaba, in response to Musayyib ibn Najabah and others who asked why he remained silent, said: "And if I know, perhaps it is a trial for you and a temporary enjoyment." And during the time of Imam Zain al-Abidin, in my opinion, it was aimed at the mid-term future—there are evidences and materials regarding this that I will present—and during the time of Imam al-Baqir (peace be upon him), it is highly likely that it was aimed at the short-term future, and after the martyrdom of the eighth Imam (peace be upon him), it was likely aimed at the long-term future. The efforts were for which future? They varied, but they were always present; this is the meaning of political struggle. All the actions of the Imams (peace be upon them)—aside from those spiritual and moral actions related to the elevation of a person's soul and his closeness to God—namely lessons, hadith, knowledge, theology, debates with scientific opponents, political opponents, exile, support for one group and rejection of another, are all in this line; it is for the purpose of establishing an Islamic government. This is the claim.

Of course, as Mr. Tabasi pointed out, yes, this matter has been and will be a subject of disagreement; I do not insist that my understanding and interpretation be accepted; I insist that this thread be given careful attention and that the lives of the Imams be re-evaluated. The effort we have made over the past few years has been to substantiate this matter regarding both the collective Imams (peace be upon them) and each individual of these great figures with acceptable reasons; of course, some of the reasons are general, such as the fact that we know that Imamate is a continuation of Prophethood, and the Prophet is the first Imam—"Indeed, the Messenger of God was the Imam," as stated by Imam al-Sadiq (peace be upon him)—and the Messenger of God rose to establish a system of justice and divine truth and created that system through his persistent struggles and protected it as long as he was alive; thus, the Imam, who is the successor of the Prophet, cannot remain oblivious to such a system. This is a general argument that can certainly be pursued with extensive discussion and attention to various points. Some of the reasons are also derived from the words of the Imams (peace be upon them) or from the methods and conduct of their lives, which, given this point and with awareness of this orientation, all make sense. The truth is that a certain amount of attention to this meaning can be aided by the conditions and circumstances, just as it was for us at that time; in the dark cell of the prison, one could truly understand the reason and meaning of the greeting to "the one who is tortured in the depths of prisons and the darkness of dungeons, with legs crushed by the shackles." And, in any case, this is the orientation and line we wish to discuss a little, and I will present my mental interpretations in this grand and esteemed assembly.

As I mentioned, if we want to specify the element of political struggle, it is neither what is observed in theological struggles nor what is seen in armed struggles. For those who are well-acquainted with the history of the second century of the Hijra and have studied the movements of the Abbasids from the years before 100 Hijra until 132, which marks the beginning of the Abbasid rule, I can liken the acute political struggle in the lives of the Imams to what is observed in the lives of the Abbasids; of course, if someone has not studied the lives of the Abbasids and their struggles and their call, this analogy will not be clear and articulate for them. There is a similar situation in the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them), but with essential differences in the goals of the Abbasids and the Imams and in their methods and in their personalities; however, the shape of the work and the plan of action are quite similar. Therefore, we see that in some places, these two movements become intertwined, meaning that the Abbasids, due to the similarity of their methods, their propaganda, and their call with the family of Ali, in regions far from Hijaz and Iraq, portray themselves as the same line as the family of Ali; even the "Mussawadah," which was worn by the black-clad individuals at the beginning of the Abbasid call in Khurasan and Ray, claimed, "This black is the mourning of the family of Muhammad and the martyrs of Karbala and Zayd and Yahya." They claimed that this is the mourning attire of the family of Muhammad and the mourning of the martyrs of Karbala and the mourning of Zayd and Yahya, and even some of their leaders thought they were working for the family of Ali. Such a movement existed in the lives of the Imams, but as we said, with three essential differences in goals, methods, and personalities. This is the meaning of political struggle in the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them).

I find it necessary to first outline the overall struggle of the Imams, and then we will return to some of the manifestations of this struggle in the words of the Imams (peace be upon them). The overall outline during the three initial Imams, namely Amir al-Mu'minin, Imam al-Mujtaba, and Sayyid al-Shuhada, I will currently leave aside, as there has been much discussion about them, and almost no one doubts that in their movement there exists a political orientation and political goal; we will start from the time of Imam Zain al-Abidin. In my opinion, from the time of Imam Zain al-Abidin, that is, from the year 61 Hijra until the year 260—which is 200 years—we have three stages: one stage from the year 61 to the year 135, which is the beginning of the caliphate of Mansur al-Abbasi; in this stage, the movement begins from a certain point, gradually gains quality, depth, and expansion, and peaks until the year 135. The year 135, which is the year of the death of al-Saffah and the caliphate of Mansur, changes the situation; problems arise that halt and suspend many advancements. In a political struggle, such things occur, and we have observed a similar stage in our own time. Another stage is from the year 135 to the year 202 or 203, which is the year of the martyrdom of Imam al-Ridha; this is another stage where the movement and struggle begin from a point higher than that of the year 61 and deeper and broader than that, but with new problems, and gradually it peaks, expands, and comes closer to victory until the year of the martyrdom of the eighth Imam, which is either the year 202, 203, or 204, and it is likely to be 203; and here again, the movement comes to a halt. With the departure of Ma'mun to Baghdad in the year 204 and the beginning of the Ma'muni caliphate, which is one of the very difficult chapters in the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them), a new chapter begins, which is the chapter of the trials of the Imams; although the expansion of Shi'ism during those days was greater than ever, in my belief, the trials of the Imams during those days were also greater than ever; and this is the period in which, in my opinion, the efforts and struggles are for the long term, meaning that the Imams do not strive for anything until the Minor Occultation but rather prepare the groundwork for the future, and this period continues from the year 204 until the year 260, which is the year of the martyrdom of Imam al-Askari (peace be upon him) and the beginning of the Minor Occultation. These are the three periods; each of these three periods has its own characteristics, which I will briefly outline.

The first period, which is the period of Imam Zain al-Abidin (peace be upon him), begins with great difficulty. The event of Karbala shook the foundations of Shi'ism and indeed the entire Islamic world; killing, persecution, and torture had a history, but the killing of the Prophet's son and the captivity of the Prophet's family, taking them from city to city, and displaying the head of the beloved Fatimah on a spear, when there were still those who had seen the Prophet's kiss on those lips, was something that astonished the Islamic world; no one believed it would come to this. If the poem attributed to Lady Zainab (peace be upon her) is correct, which says:

"I did not imagine, O my heart's companion,

That this was predestined and written,"

it points to this, and this is the perception of all people. Suddenly, it was felt that the politics had changed; the severity was greater than what had been previously imagined; unimaginable things were conceived and executed; thus, a severe terror gripped the entire Islamic world, except for Kufa, and that too only by the grace of the Tawabin and later by the grace of Mukhtar; otherwise, in Medina and other parts of the Islamic world, and even in Mecca—despite Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr having risen after a while—there was an unprecedented terror resulting from the event of Karbala. In Kufa and Iraq, although the movement of the Tawabin in the years 64 and 65—which is apparently the year of the martyrdom of the Tawabin—created a fresh atmosphere in the suffocating environment of Iraq, the martyrdom of all of them until the end again intensified the atmosphere of terror and repression; and after the enemies of the Umayyad regime, namely Mukhtar and Mus'ab ibn Zubayr, fell upon each other, and Abdullah ibn al-Zubayr from Mecca could not tolerate Mukhtar, who was supportive of the Ahl al-Bayt, and Mukhtar was killed by Mus'ab, this terror and fear increased, and hopes diminished, and finally, when Abd al-Malik came to power, the entire Islamic world fell under the control of the Banu Umayyah with great power; and Abd al-Malik ruled powerfully for 21 years.

Of course, it is necessary to specifically mention the incident of Harrah in the year 64, which was the attack of Muslim ibn Uqbah on Medina, which further increased the terror and caused the Ahl al-Bayt to fall into estrangement. The summary of the incident is that Yazid appointed a young, inexperienced commander from Syria over Medina; in order to win the hearts of the people of Medina, he invited a number of them to go meet Yazid in Syria; they went and met Yazid in Syria; Yazid gave them a large reward—fifty thousand dirhams and a hundred thousand dirhams—but these individuals, who were either companions or descendants of companions, upon seeing Yazid's regime, became even more angry and resentful towards him; they returned to Medina, and Abdullah ibn Hanthalah al-Ghasil al-Mala'ika claimed leadership and revolted, declaring Medina independent from the central government; they sent Muslim ibn Uqbah, and he brought about such a catastrophe in Medina that in the history books, this incident forms a sorrowful and lamentable chapter; this also further caused the people to feel terror and fear. This was the terror that dominated the Islamic world.

Another factor that emerged alongside this terror was the intellectual decline of the people throughout the Islamic world, which stemmed from the neglect of religious teachings over the past twenty years. As the teachings of religion, the education of faith, the interpretation of verses, and the articulation of truths from the Prophet's tongue became neglected in the twenty years following the year 40 AH, the people had become severely hollow and empty in terms of beliefs and the foundations of faith. When one examines the lives of the people of that era under the microscope of various historical accounts, this becomes clear; of course, there were scholars, reciters, and narrators, about whom I will also speak, but the general populace had fallen into a state of disbelief, weakness, and severe disruption of faith. It had reached a point where even some agents of the caliphate questioned prophethood. It is recorded in books that Khalid ibn Abdullah al-Qasri, who was one of the very lowly and despicable agents of the Umayyads, used to say that the caliphate is superior to prophethood; he would provide reasoning, for example, asking: which is better? A caliph, a man in his family, or a messenger to his companions? It is clear that the one you place as your successor in your home is closer to you than the one you send for a message to a place. Well, it is evident that the one you place in your home as your caliph is closer to you, so the caliph of God—who they did not even refer to as the caliph of the Messenger of God—"the caliph of God" is superior to the Messenger of God; this is what Khalid ibn Abdullah al-Qasri said, and others said the same. In the poetry of the poets of the Umayyad and Abbasid periods, I found that from the time of Abd al-Malik, the expression "the caliph of God" has been repeated so much in poetry that one forgets that the caliph is also the caliph of the Prophet; this continued until the time of the Abbasids. In the poetry of Bashar, he says: "Rise and see that the caliph of God is between the lute and the flute";

"O Umayyads, awaken from your long slumber,

Indeed, the caliph is Jacob ibn Dawood.

Your caliphate has been lost, O people, so seek

The caliph of God between the lute and the flute."

Even when he wanted to mock the caliph, he still referred to him as the caliph of God; and everywhere in the poetry of the famous poets of that time, such as Jarir, Farazdaq, and Kuthayyir, among others—there were hundreds of famous and great poets at that time—when they spoke in praise of the caliph, it was the caliph of God, not the caliph of the Messenger of God; this is one example. The beliefs of the people had become so weak even regarding religious foundations, and the morals of the people had severely deteriorated.

In my study of the book "Aghani" by Abu al-Faraj, I noticed a point: that in these years around eighty and ninety, and almost fifty or sixty years after that, the greatest singers, musicians, and debauchers of the Islamic world were either from Medina or Mecca! Whenever the caliph in Syria felt a longing for music and wanted a singer or musician, he would send for the famous singers and musicians from Medina or Mecca; the worst and most debauched poets were in Mecca and Medina; the place of the revelation of the Prophet and the birthplace of Islam had become a center of vice and corruption. It is good for us to know about these matters regarding Medina and Mecca; unfortunately, in the works we have, there is no trace of such things, and this is a reality that existed. I will present an example of the prevalence of corruption and vice; there was a poet in Mecca named Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a; he was among the shameless, unrestrained poets, and of course at the peak of power and poetic art; he died; now the stories of Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a and what they did in Mecca are a significant chapter in the tragic history of that time, where they mocked Mecca, the pilgrimage, and the stoning of the devils:

"With a wrist adorned when I stoned,

And a hand stained, I adorned with my beauty.

By God, I do not know, even if I were aware,

Whether I stoned with seven or with eight."

This is what we have read in the "Mughani," and it belongs to these places; at the time of stoning the devil!

The narrator recounts that when Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a died, there was public mourning in Medina, and people were weeping in the streets of Medina; wherever I went, groups of young men and women were standing and lamenting the death of Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a in Mecca; I came across a young maid who was going about her business, for example, carrying a bucket to fetch water, and she was crying and weeping over the death of Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a and lamenting; she reached a group of young men; they asked her why she was crying so much. She said, "Well, because this man has died and left us." One said, "Do not grieve; there is another poet in Mecca who has said this poem"—Harith ibn Khalid al-Makhzumi, who had also been a governor of Mecca for a time under these same caliphs of Syria; he was one of those poets who, like Umar ibn Abi Rabi'a, was shameless and unrestrained—and began to recite one of the poems of that Makhzumi poet; when she listened to this poem, the maid wiped her tears and said: "Praise be to God who did not leave His sanctuary empty;" finally, if one goes, another comes in his place; this was the moral state of the people of Medina.

You see many stories from the night gatherings of Mecca and Medina, not only among the lower classes, but among all kinds of people; a wretched, hungry beggar like Ash'ab al-Tamma' who was a poet and a jester, and ordinary people from the streets and markets, and this maid and others, up to the well-known sons of the Quraysh and even Banu Hashim, whom I will not name; many well-known figures among the sons of Quraysh—both their women and men—were among those who were immersed in this vice. During the governorship of this Makhzumi, Aisha bint Talha came and was performing the pilgrimage; he was interested in her; when the call to prayer was announced, that lady sent a message saying to delay the call to prayer until her pilgrimage was completed; he ordered that the afternoon prayer call not be made; he was criticized for saying that for the sake of a woman performing the pilgrimage, he would delay the prayer of the people? He said, "By God, if her pilgrimage lasted until tomorrow morning, I would say do not make the call to prayer;" this was the state of that time.

Well, this intellectual state, this state of moral corruption;

the state of political corruption is another factor. Most of the prominent figures were deeply entrenched in the material desires that were fulfilled by the men of the government. A prominent figure like Muhammad ibn Shihab al-Zuhri, who at one time was a student of Imam Zain al-Abidin, became affiliated with the regime; that famous letter of Imam Zain al-Abidin to Muhammad ibn Shihab al-Zuhri—which is recorded in "Tuhaf al-Uqul" and other places—is a letter for history that shows what dependencies existed for prominent figures. There were many like Muhammad ibn Shihab. A saying that the late Majlisi (may God be pleased with him) quotes from Ibn Abi al-Hadid is very good to mention; first, Majlisi (may God have mercy on him) in "Bihar" narrates from Jabir—who is apparently Jabir ibn Abdullah—that Imam Zain al-Abidin said: "We do not know how to deal with the people; if we tell them what we heard from the Messenger of God, they laugh, and if we remain silent, we are not able to." When we narrate from the Messenger of God, the people not only do not accept it, but they laugh! Then he recounts an incident where the Imam narrated a hadith to a group, and someone among them mocked and did not accept that hadith; then regarding Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib and Zuhri, he says they were among the deviants—of course, I do not accept this regarding Sa'id ibn al-Musayyib; there are other reasons that he was among the disciples of the Imam, but regarding Zuhri and many others, it is the same—then Ibn Abi al-Hadid enumerates many prominent figures and men of that time who were all deviated from the Ahl al-Bayt; then he narrates from Imam Zain al-Abidin (peace be upon him) who said: "There are not twenty men in all of Mecca and Medina who love us." This was the state of the time of Imam Zain al-Abidin when he wanted to begin this great work. And this is the same period that Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him) later said: "The people turned away after Husayn except for three." After the event of Ashura, only three remained. This hadith names three: Abu Khalid al-Kabuli, Yahya ibn Umm al-Tawil, and Jubayr ibn Mut'im, of whom Allameh al-Shushtari suggests that Jubayr ibn Mut'im is incorrect and it is Hakim ibn Jubayr ibn Mut'im; in some narrations or perhaps in some accounts—which I do not remember correctly now and unfortunately could not refer to—Muhammad ibn Jubayr ibn Mut'im is mentioned; three people. Of course, in "Bihar" there are narrations that mention four people; in some narrations, five people are mentioned, and all of these can be reconciled with each other; this is the state of Imam Zain al-Abidin (peace be upon him) who, in such a barren context, engages in his work.

Now what should Imam Zain al-Abidin do? If Imam Zain al-Abidin wants to pursue that goal, three responsibilities rest upon him: First, he must teach the religious knowledge to the people of his time. If we want to establish an Islamic government, it is impossible to hope for such a government without having acquainted the people with religious knowledge; therefore, the first task is to teach religious knowledge to the people.

The second task is that especially the issue of Imamate, which has become a neglected issue and is completely distant from people's minds or has been misinterpreted, must be reconstructed in the minds of the people; what does Imamate mean? Who should be the Imam? What conditions does the Imam have? This is another task; after all, the society had an Imam, Abd al-Malik was the Imam, and the people considered him the Imam, the leader of the society.

Of course, later in the discussion of the Imam, I will mention that the understanding we have had over the past two or three centuries of the meaning of the Imam is completely different from the understanding that existed for the Imam in the early days of Islam; both supporters and opponents understood the Imam in the same way that we understand today in the era of the Islamic Republic, meaning the Imam of the nation, the Imam of the people, the ruler of religion and the world. Our understanding of the Imam over the past two or three centuries has been something else; our understanding has been that the society has one person who collects taxes from the people, leads them to war, calls them to peace, manages the affairs of the people, establishes government offices, forms a government, expands and contracts, and is called the ruler; and there is another person on the other side who corrects the religion of the people, corrects the beliefs of the people, corrects the recitation of the people's prayers—whatever his efforts may be—and is called the scholar, and the Imam in his time is that scholar; the caliph did his job, and he also corrected the religion of the people or the morals of the people; our understanding of the Imam is this, while in the early days of Islam, everyone's understanding of the Imam was different from this, meaning the leader of the society, but the leader of both religion and the world. The Umayyads also claimed this, the Abbasids also claimed this; those intoxicated, immersed in pleasures and amusements also claimed this; they also considered themselves the Imams, and if God wills, if we reach that point and have time, I will speak on this matter.

In any case, the society had an Imam; his Imam was Abd al-Malik. Imam Zain al-Abidin had to explain and clarify to the people the meaning of Imamate, the direction of Imamate, the conditions of Imamate, those things that the Imam must have, and those things without which no one can be an Imam.

And thirdly, he must say, "I am the Imam," meaning that the one who must be in that position is me; these are the three tasks that Imam Zain al-Abidin had to perform. Most of Imam Zain al-Abidin's efforts were spent on that first task because, as we said, the context was such that the issue of "I am the Imam" did not come up; the religion of the people had to be corrected, the morals of the people had to be corrected, the people had to be pulled out of this quagmire of corruption, and the spiritual orientation—which is the essence of religion and the main spirit of religion—had to be revived in society; therefore, when you look, you see that all of Imam Zain al-Abidin's life and words are about asceticism, for example: "Indeed, the sign of the ascetics in this world is their desire for it," and so on, which begins in a lengthy and detailed speech; although in this speech, there is also a reference to those goals we mentioned. Or "Is there not a free man who leaves this filth for its people? There is no price for your souls except paradise, so do not sell them for anything else," which is from Imam Zain al-Abidin.

Most of Imam Zain al-Abidin's words are about asceticism, most of them are about knowledge, but the knowledge is also presented in the form of supplication; because, as we said, the oppression in that era and the unsuitability of the time did not allow Imam Zain al-Abidin to speak openly and clearly with those people; not only did the regimes not allow it, but the people also did not want it; the society was a society that was unworthy, corrupt, and wasted, which needed to be rebuilt. From the year 61 to 95, the 34 years of Imam Zain al-Abidin's life passed in this manner. Of course, as time went on, the situation improved; thus, in the same hadith of "the people turned away after Husayn," it continues: "Then the people joined and increased," later the people joined; and we see that this is indeed the case, and when the time of Imam al-Baqir arrives—which I will mention—the situation had changed; this was due to the 35 years of effort by Imam Zain al-Abidin.

In the words of Imam Zain al-Abidin, there is also attention to cadre-building. In the noble book "Tuhaf al-Uqul," several lengthy statements from Imam Zain al-Abidin are narrated. Unfortunately, I did not have time to look at other books, and if there are other examples of these words from Imam Zain al-Abidin, I do not think there are many; there are short words, but lengthy words, like those two or three detailed hadiths that are narrated in "Tuhaf al-Uqul," I do not think there are others. The tone of these hadiths and the address of these hadiths indicate the work that Imam Zain al-Abidin was doing; one of these is clearly addressed to the general public; it begins with "O people" and starts with "O people"; in this address, there is a reminder of Islamic knowledge; the Imam in this detailed hadith states that when a person is placed in the grave, he is asked about his Lord, about his Prophet, about his world, and about his Imam; this is a gentle and soft tone that suits the general public who were within the scope of Imam Zain al-Abidin's teachings; however, there is another hadith that begins differently, and its content also indicates that it is for the elite; it begins like this: "May God protect us and you from the plots of the oppressors, the malice of the envious, and the wrath of the tyrants; let not the tyrants tempt you." This is not for the general public; it is clear that it is for a specific group. It can be inferred that the Imam, during this time or in different periods and years, or with different groups, had two or three types of discourse and teachings; some were like that, some were like this; in some, there is a reference to the ruling regime and the tyrants of the time, while in others, only generalities and Islamic issues are addressed and nothing more.

This is the life of Imam Zain al-Abidin, who over these 35 years gradually pulls the oblivious and uninformed people from the clutches of desires on one side, and the dominance of tyrannical regimes on the other side, and the snare of the bad scholars dependent on the regimes on another side, and saves them from that dark and gloomy environment, and altogether creates a group of faithful, interested, and righteous individuals who can become a foundation for future works; this is the life of Imam Zain al-Abidin. Of course, the details of that noble life deserve a separate discussion that I have addressed, and I have spoken for hours about the life of Imam Zain al-Abidin; at this moment, more than this cannot fit into our current discussion.

Then it is the turn of Imam Baqir; the life of Imam Baqir continues along the same line, but the situation has improved. There, too, are the teachings of religion and Islamic knowledge, but first of all, the people no longer have that indifference and lack of affection towards the family of the Prophet. When Imam Baqir enters the mosque of Medina, a group of people are always gathered around him, surrounding him and benefiting from him. A person says, "I saw Imam Baqir in the mosque of Medina - and around him were the people of Khorasan and others" - while people from distant lands, from Khorasan and places not close to here, have come and surrounded the Imam. This indicates that the propaganda is spreading like waves throughout the Islamic world, and the hearts of people in distant places are becoming attached to the Ahlulbayt. In another narration, it is mentioned, "The people of Iraq surrounded him," and the people of Iraq were sitting at his side and had taken him among themselves, and the Imam was discussing issues of halal and haram with them.

The great scholars of the time study under Imam Baqir and benefit from him. A well-known figure like Ikrimah, a student of Ibn Abbas, when he comes to Imam Baqir to hear hadith from him - perhaps also to test him - his hands tremble and he falls into the embrace of the Imam. Then he himself is astonished and says, "O son of the Messenger of Allah! I have seen great figures like Ibn Abbas and heard hadith from them, but I have never experienced this state that has come over me in your presence." And see how clearly Imam Baqir responds, saying, "Woe to you, O servant of the people of Sham! You are in the presence of the greatness of spirituality, which is why you are compelled to tremble." Someone like Abu Hanifah, who is among the jurists and great figures of the time, comes to Imam Baqir and learns the knowledge and rulings of religion from him, and many other scholars are among the students of Imam Baqir, and the scientific reputation of Imam Baqir spreads throughout the world, earning him the title "Baqir al-Uloom."

So see; the social situation and the emotional state of the people and their respect for the Imams during the time of Imam Baqir have changed, they have differed. Accordingly, we see that the political movement of Imam Baqir is also more vigorous; that is, Imam Sajjad, in confronting Abdul Malik, does not have a direct confrontation, harsh words, or statements that could be taken as evidence of opposition. Abdul Malik would write letters to Imam Sajjad about certain topics, and the Imam would respond; of course, the response of the son of the Prophet is always a strong, firm, and crushing reply, but it is not confrontational in that way. However, in the case of Imam Baqir (peace be upon him), it is not like that; the movement of Imam Baqir is such that Hisham ibn Abdul Malik feels fear and sees that he must keep the Imam under surveillance and wants to bring him to Sham. Of course, Imam Sajjad was also taken to Sham during his Imamate - after that first time - in chains and similar conditions, but the situation there is different, and Imam Sajjad always dealt with more caution. However, in the case of Imam Baqir, we see a sharper tone in his speech. I have seen several narrations regarding the discussions of Imam Baqir (peace be upon him) with his companions that indicate a call to governance, caliphate, and Imamate, and even a promise of the future, which I will present a few examples of, God willing.

Now one narration, this narration is in Bihar, which states that the house of Abu Ja'far was full of people; an old man came and leaned on a staff or something like that; he came and greeted the Imam and expressed his affection and love, and then sat next to the Imam and said, "By God, I truly love you and I love those who love you, and by God, I do not love you and I do not love those who love you for any worldly gain, and I truly hate your enemy and disassociate myself from him, and by God, I do not hate him and disassociate myself from him for any personal grievance between me and him. By God, I make lawful your lawful and I make unlawful your unlawful, and I await your command. Do you hope that I, may God make me your sacrifice?" This means, do you hope that I will see your time? Because I am waiting for your command, meaning I am waiting for the arrival of your governance. The command - this command, your command - means governance; in the expressions of that era, both in the expressions between the Imams and the companions of the Imams, as well as their opponents and enemies - for example, Harun indicates, "By God, if you dispute with me over this command..." - meaning the caliphate, meaning the Imamate; "your command" means your caliphate; undoubtedly, this expression is meant in this sense. He comes and asks whether you hope that I will reach that day and see that day; so Abu Ja'far (peace be upon him) said, "Come here, come here until I seat him next to me." Then he said, "O old man, my father Ali ibn al-Husayn (peace be upon him) was approached by a man who asked him about something similar to what you have asked me." The Imam narrates from Imam Sajjad, and we do not find this in the narrations of Imam Sajjad; it can certainly be understood that if Imam Sajjad had said this in a large gathering, it would have reached the ears of others and us as well, but what Imam Sajjad likely said in secret, here Imam Baqir openly states. Then, he narrates from his father that he said, "If you die, you will return to the Messenger of Allah and to Ali and to Hasan and to Husayn and to Ali ibn al-Husayn, and your heart will be delighted and your soul will be cooled, and your eyes will be comforted, and you will be welcomed with spirit and fragrance among the noble scribes... And if you live, you will see what God will grant you that will please your eyes, and you will be with us in the highest rank." They do not leave him hopeless; they say if you die - since he was old - you will be with the Prophet and so on, and if you remain, you will be with us; such expressions are found in the words of Imam Baqir.

But the point I wanted to make about the life of Imam Baqir is that, first of all, in one narration from Imam Baqir (peace be upon him), a time is specified for the emergence, and this is something remarkable; the hadith is in Al-Kafi; from Abu Hamzah al-Thumali with a high chain, he said, "I heard Abu Ja'far (peace be upon him) say, 'O Thabit, indeed God, Blessed and Exalted, had appointed this matter in the seventies.'" It was determined that the divine government would be established in the year seventy; "When Hussein (peace be upon him) was killed, the wrath of God, Blessed and Exalted, intensified against the people of the earth, so He delayed it to forty and one hundred." He said, "We informed you, and you spread the hadith, and you uncovered the veil of secrecy, and God did not set a time for it after that with us, and God erases what He wills and establishes, and with Him is the Mother of the Book." Abu Hamzah says: "I mentioned this to Abu Abdillah (peace be upon him), and he said, 'It was indeed like that.'" The year 140 is during the life of Imam Sadiq; this is the same thing that I thought before I even saw this hadith, that the establishment of a government that Imam Sajjad works for and Imam Baqir works for would fall during the time of Imam Sadiq; the death of Imam Sadiq is in the year 148, and here the year [of government establishment] is determined to be 140; 140 means after 135, which I previously mentioned that in 135, Mansur comes to power; if Mansur had not come to power, or if the Abbasid incident had not occurred, the ordinary divine decree was that in the year 140, the divine government and Islamic government should come to power, and the Imams were working in this way; now, this is another discussion about whether this future was anticipated and awaited by the Imams, and I do not have a discussion; this is a separate discussion and one of the separate chapters of this discussion, and I do not know how long I will have the opportunity and how long you will have the opportunity to listen; if I reach it, it is among the notes I have brought with me that we will discuss separately; right now, my talk is about the situation of Imam Baqir (peace be upon him) who, in that era, explicitly states and expresses that in the year 140 it was supposed to [establish a government], we told you, you disclosed it, and God Almighty delayed it, and He did not tell us, and we do not tell you. This is one of the characteristics of the era of Imam Baqir.

One more sentence about the life of Imam Baqir; of course, discussing the life of Imam Baqir requires hours of continuous discussion to get a picture of the life of that Imam; I have also discussed this matter for hours separately and extensively; in summary, the life of that Imam is one in which the struggle is clearer, but it is not an acute armed struggle. Zayd ibn Ali, the brother of Imam Baqir, refers to Imam Baqir, and the Imam says do not rise up; it has been seen that some insult Zayd, saying that he did not heed the words of the Imam - who said do not rise up - while Imam Baqir, when he said do not rise up, he listened and did not rise up; when he consulted with Imam Sadiq, the Imam did not say do not rise up, the Imam encouraged him to rise up, and after Zayd was martyred, Imam Sadiq wished that he had been among those who were with him; therefore, Zayd should not be subjected to this neglect and lack of kindness. The Imam did not accept armed uprising and did not accept it, but the political struggle is clearly evident, meaning it seems that this struggle is one that can be understood; someone looking at the time of Imam Sajjad does not feel the struggle, while in the life of Imam Baqir, this feeling is present.

After that, when the life of this great man comes to an end, we see that he continues his struggle with that incident of Mina; "You will mourn for me for ten years in Mina," they must mourn for Imam Baqir for ten years in Mina; this is a continuation of the same struggle. Mourning for Imam Baqir, especially in Mina, for what purpose? In the lives of the Imams (peace be upon them), where mourning is encouraged, it is for Imam Hussein (peace be upon him), which has solid, certain, and definitive narrations; why, when Imam Reza was moving, he gathered some people to mourn for him, which was a completely political and purposeful movement, but regarding [mourning for] their martyrdom, I do not remember any other place except for Imam Baqir (peace be upon him), where the Imam bequeaths and sets aside eight hundred dirhams from his wealth for this purpose in Mina. Mina is different from Arafat, different from Muzdalifah, different from Mecca itself; Mecca is a city, and people are scattered and busy with their affairs; in Arafat, they are only there from morning until evening; in the morning, they come tired, and in the evening, they hurry to leave to reach other places; and in Muzdalifah, they are only there for a few hours at night and it is merely a passageway on the way to Mina; but Mina is three consecutive nights; those who want to reach Mecca during those three days - at that time and with the means of that day - and return at night are few, and they stay there; in fact, for three nights, thousands of people are there who have come from all corners of the Islamic world, and one sees that it is a suitable place to propagate; any message we want to convey to the Islamic world, its place is there; with the conditions of that day when there were no radio, television, or mass communication means. When a group mourns for Muhammad ibn Ali from the descendants of the Prophet, everyone will naturally ask why you are mourning? One does not mourn for every dead person unless they have been wronged; who has wronged him? Who killed him? Why were they wronged? And many such questions will follow; this is the same very precise and calculated political movement.

During the life of Imam Baqir, I also noticed another point, and that is that the arguments that were made in the first half of the first century of Hijra regarding the caliphate are repeated by Imam Baqir as well - which I will mention if there is time - such as the argument for Imamate, based on proximity to the Prophet; the same argument that Amir al-Mu'minin made in the early days, that the Arabs prioritized Quraysh, and the Arabs boasted over non-Arabs because of the Prophet, and Quraysh boasted over non-Quraysh because of the Prophet, but we, who are the close ones to the Prophet, are set aside while others come; while if the Prophet is the source of pride for the Arabs over non-Arabs and for Quraysh over non-Quraysh, then here too, he is the source of our pride over others and the basis of our priority over others. This argument is the argument of Amir al-Mu'minin that has been repeated many times in the words of Amir al-Mu'minin in the early days; we see that Imam Baqir also expresses these words during the years between 95 and 114, which is the period of the Imamate of this Imam; the debate for the caliphate; this is very meaningful and indicates the direction of motivations and the clarity of this matter. The era of Imam Baqir also comes to an end.

From the year 114, the Imamate of Imam Sadiq begins until the year 148, which is the most important period in this first stage, the period of the Imamate of Imam Sadiq. Imam Sadiq goes through two stages during this period; one period from the year 114 to the year 132 or to the year 135 - or until the dominance of the Abbasids, or until the caliphate of Mansur - is a period of comfort and expansion; that matter which has become famous that the Imams found an opportunity due to the conflict between the Umayyads and the Abbasids belongs to this period; there was nothing like that during the time of Imam Baqir; during the time of Imam Baqir, it was the period of Umayyad power, and Hisham ibn Abdul Malik was - and Hisham was their man - the man of the Umayyads and the greatest figure of the Umayyads after Abdul Malik; therefore, during the time of Imam Baqir, there was no conflict between anyone that would allow the Imams to take advantage of the opportunity; it belongs to the time of Imam Sadiq, and that too belongs to this period, which is the beginning of the gradual invitation of the Abbasids and the expansion of their invitation and the peak of the Shiite Alawi invitation throughout the Islamic world, which I have explained in a discussion that has been transcribed and published, that when Imam Sadiq assumed the Imamate, in various places in the Islamic world, in Africa, in Khorasan, in Fars, in Transoxiana, there were various conflicts and wars; such a strange situation existed, and Imam Sadiq took advantage of the opportunity to convey Islamic knowledge; the same three points that were present in the life of Imam Sajjad - namely Islamic knowledge, the issue of Imamate, and especially emphasis on the Imamate of the Ahlulbayt - are clearly observed in the early period of the Imamate of Imam Sadiq.

Of course, here the issue of Imamate must be raised to see what they were doing; for example, one example is that in these narrations I have noted: Amr ibn Abi al-Muqdam says, "I saw Abu Abdillah (peace be upon him) on the Day of Arafah at the standing place, and he was calling out with a loud voice." The Imam was standing in Arafah, in the gathering of people and among the people, and he was shouting a sentence; he would turn to one side and say this sentence, then turn to another side and say it, then turn to another side; he would turn to all four sides and shout this matter; now what is it? "O people! Indeed, the Messenger of Allah was the Imam." You see the attention to the meaning of Imamate and awakening the people regarding the truth of Imamate, what is Imamate and whether those who are in power are worthy of Imamate or not; then it was Ali ibn Abi Talib, then Hasan, then Husayn, then Ali ibn Husayn, then Muhammad ibn Ali, then he would call out three times to those in front of him and to his right and to his left and from behind him, twelve times; every side he would shout three times and repeated this sentence twelve times in Arafah; then he says, "I asked what that 'Heh' or 'Hah' means?" They said in the language of, for example, Banu Tamim or Banu such-and-such, it is a metaphor for "who"; meaning after Muhammad ibn Ali, I am the Imam. This is one example.

Another example: A man from Kufa came to Khurasan and called the people to the leadership of Ja'far ibn Muhammad, peace be upon him. A group obeyed and responded; a person had risen from Medina and came to Khurasan, inviting the people to the leadership of Ja'far ibn Muhammad — that is, their governance. You should see, during the time of struggles, when could we say the Islamic Republic or Islamic governance existed? Throughout the years of struggle, the maximum we could say was that those who discussed governance expressed the Islamic limits regarding governance; what kind of people should be in power, and what is Islam's view on governance — this was the maximum we stated. In 1978, or at most in 1977, in private circles, we mentioned the name of the Islamic government, without even specifying its ruler; so see, when Imam Sadiq rises and goes to the farthest points of Islam, inviting people to the governance of Imam Sadiq, what does it mean? It means the approach of the time (42), this is the same year 140, this is the very thing that the natural rise of the Imams necessitated for the establishment of Islamic governance in those times.

Well, he went and invited the people to the leadership of Ja'far ibn Muhammad (peace be upon him); of course, we understand the meaning of leadership well today; previously, leadership was only understood as love, meaning inviting people to the love of Ja'far ibn Muhammad; [while] love has no invitation, and if [they invite to love], then the implications of this [narration] no longer make sense; now pay attention: A group obeyed and responded; and a group denied and rejected; they denied and said no. Well, the love of the Ahl al-Bayt was generally not denied in the Islamic world, [so the issue] is something else; and a group hesitated and refrained; hesitation (43) and abstention (44) are no longer about love; this is about something else; this is governance; one group also refrained; then, from every group, a man came and entered upon Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him); (45) [from each group, one person] came to the presence of the Imam and spoke; then, the Imam said to one of those who hesitated and stood before him, "You who hesitated and refrained, why did you not refrain by that river where you committed that wrongdoing?" At that moment, he suddenly became aware and understood that the Imam was hinting; this shows that the one who went to Khurasan did not go of his own accord, nor was it against the Imam's will, [rather] the Imam was also following the matter. This is from the time of Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him), which is certainly much more fervent than when Mansur comes to power. When Mansur comes to power, the situation becomes difficult, and the life of the Imam at least returns to the time of Imam Baqir, and oppression becomes dominant; it is at that time that the Imam is exiled; the Imam was exiled multiple times to Hira, to Ramila, to various places. Mansur summoned the Imam many times; once he said: "May God kill me if I do not kill you;" (46) once he sent a message to the governor of Medina saying, "Burn the house of Ja'far ibn Muhammad," (47) to set his house on fire, and the Imam came amidst the flames and displayed a strange scene [and said] "I am the son of the depths of the earth" (48) which, well, this more so crushed the opponents. The confrontation between Mansur and Imam Sadiq is very severe, and he threatened the Imam many times.

Of course, those narrations that state the Imam humbled himself and acted small before Mansur are not correct; I have pursued [those] narrations; they have no basis at all; they mostly reach Rabi' al-Hajib; (49)

Rabi' al-Hajib is a definite sinner and a close associate of Mansur. Some naïve people have said that Rabi' was a Shia; where was Rabi' a Shia? We followed the life of Rabi' ibn Yunus, [and found] he is one of those individuals who came from the house of Zadi to the Abbasid court and served them and was the doorkeeper (50) of Mansur and later provided many services; when Mansur died, if it were not for Rabi', the caliphate would have gone out of the hands of Mansur's family and reached his uncles; that is why he forged a will in the name of Mahdi, the son of Mansur, and brought Mahdi to the caliphate; then, Fazl ibn Rabi', the son of this person, is also a part of this. No, the family is one of the loyal and devoted families of the Abbasids and had no affection for the Ahl al-Bayt, and whatever they forged was a lie, in order to portray the Imam in the public opinion of the Islamic environment as someone who had to humble himself before the caliph, so that others would also know their duty.

In any case, the confrontation between Imam Sadiq and Mansur is very intense until it culminates in the martyrdom of Imam Sadiq in the year 148.

Of course, the continuation of the matter and the life of Imam Musa ibn Ja'far is an extraordinarily inspiring life, which in my opinion, the peak of these struggles belongs to the time of Musa ibn Ja'far, and unfortunately, we do not have a proper report on the life of Musa ibn Ja'far; sometimes bits and pieces of things from the life of that Imam are found that astonish a person. For a while, Imam Musa ibn Ja'far was not found, meaning Harun was searching for him and could not find him; he would take people and torture them, asking them to tell where Musa ibn Ja'far is. This is unprecedented. Ibn Shahr Ashub in his book "Manaqib" narrates a story about Musa ibn Ja'far that we do not have about any of the Imams; Musa ibn Ja'far, for a period, "entered some villages of Syria disguised as a fugitive and fell into a cave where there was a monk." (52) Then he spoke with that monk and said some things; these indicate some sparks in the life of Musa ibn Ja'far that at that time the meaning of that eternal imprisonment becomes clear, otherwise, when Harun first came to power and came to Medina, as you have heard, he treated Musa ibn Ja'far very well and respected him.

And the famous story is narrated by Mamun that we went, and the Imam was riding a donkey and came and entered the area where Harun was sitting and wanted to dismount, but Harun swore that he must come to my presence while mounted, and he came mounted; then they respected him, said such and such, and when they were leaving, they told us to hold his stirrup. Of course, it is interesting that in this same narration, Mamun says that my father Harun would give everyone five thousand dinars and ten thousand dinars as a reward, [but] to Musa ibn Ja'far, he gave two hundred dinars, while when he spoke and asked about the Imam's condition, he said, "Yes, I have many children, many troubles, and my living conditions are not good;" now, in my opinion, this conversation of Musa ibn Ja'far with Harun is also very interesting, meaning this conversation is very familiar to us and completely understandable how a person can express to someone like Harun that yes, our situation is not good and our life is not sustainable and so on; it does not mean begging and humiliation; a person who has done this knows how it is; and many of you, I know, during the tyrannical regime and the time of oppression, have done such things out of precaution (53), and in any case, it is completely understandable.

After he says these words, which necessitates Harun to say, "Well, very well, then this fifty thousand dinars belongs to you, I will only give you two hundred dinars;" he says, "Then when I asked my father why you did this, he said that if I give this, it will mobilize the sword-bearing men of Khurasan, and they will throw two hundred thousand men upon me;" this is Harun's understanding, and Harun understood correctly. Now some think that they were slandering the Imam; no, the truth of the matter was this. At the time when Musa ibn Ja'far was struggling with Harun, if there was money in that regime, many people were ready and willing to fight alongside Musa ibn Ja'far, and we have seen examples of this in other places outside the Imams, [such as] Husayn ibn Ali, the martyr of Fakh, who was before Harun, during the time of Musa al-Hadi, and others; [therefore] it was very clear that their actions indicated that if the Imams rose, how much they could gather people around them, and Harun understood this correctly. Therefore, the time of Musa ibn Ja'far is the peak time that later also leads to imprisonment.

Then, when it comes to the eighth Imam (peace be upon him), again the period is one of expansion and the good condition of the Imams, and the Shia are widespread everywhere, and there are many opportunities that culminate in the issue of the succession; of course, during Harun's time, the eighth Imam lived in utmost precaution, meaning concealment, [although] they had efforts, movements, and contacts; one can understand; for example, suppose that Dabbal Khuzai, who speaks about the eighth Imam during the time of the succession in such a way, did not just come out from under a rock; the society that Dabbal Khuzai nurtured, or Ibrahim ibn Abbas the poet nurtured - who is among the eulogists of Ali ibn Musa al-Ridha - or others, must have a culture of affection for the family of the Prophet in that background; and this is not such that we see that yes, in Medina and in Khurasan and in Ray and in various regions, they celebrated the succession of Ali ibn Musa al-Ridha, but previously there was no such precedent. What happened during the succession of Ali ibn Musa al-Ridha, which is a very important event — and I mentioned it in my message last year, of course in passing — indicates that the state of people's affection and the outpouring of love for the Ahl al-Bayt during the time of Imam Ridha was very high; in any case, after that, the conflict between Amin and Mamun and the war and struggle between Khurasan and Baghdad lasted five years, all of this led to Ali ibn Musa al-Ridha being able to do good work that peaked with the issue of succession, but unfortunately, there too, as we said, it was cut off by that incident of martyrdom, and a new era began, which in my opinion marks the beginning of the suffering and sorrow of the Ahl al-Bayt from the time of Imam Jawad onwards, worse than all other times.

Well, this is a general outline. I had, of course, divided my discussion into two parts: one part was a general outline that ends here, and another part is diagrams of the movements of struggle in the lives of the Imams, which of course it is natural that there is no time for that. Of course, I may not be allowed to take more of the time of dear brothers and esteemed friends, but what I thought and noted and had the opportunity to work on for a few hours the day before yesterday and yesterday and find in my old notes, this is it. Of course, the topics under discussion are not limited to these, and if someone wants to work, there are many more topics, but now for the sake of those who may want to work, I present these topics:

One of the issues is the claim to Imamate and the call to Imamate, which is a sign of a struggle movement wherever it appears in the lives of the Imams; at that time, the narrations "The Imams are the light of God" (55) in Al-Kafi and the narration of Imam Ridha in that detailed statement (56) and that letter of Imam Ridha apparently to Fazl ibn Sahl or to another one of those very detailed discussions. [So] one issue is Imamate.

One is the interpretation of the caliphs regarding the claims and actions of the Imams. You see that from the time of Abdul Malik to the time of Mutawakkil, there has always been a certain interpretation of the lives of the Imams; well, this must be followed up, and one cannot be negligent; why did they interpret the lives of the Imams in this way? For example, regarding Musa ibn Ja'far [it was said] "The two caliphs collect the taxes from him?" (57) or for example about Imam Ali ibn Musa: "This is Ali, his son has sat and claimed the matter for himself;" (58) or about other Imams; this claim that the caliphs and their supporters derived from the lives of the Imams is noteworthy and is one of those important points that I have mentioned some narrations here.

The insistence of the caliphs, especially the Abbasid caliphs, to attribute Imamate to themselves — of course, the Umayyad caliphs also had this insistence — and the sensitivity of the Shia, not to allow it. Kuthair, who is one of the great poets of the first class of that early period, meaning in the same rank as Farazdaq and Jarir and Nasib and others, is a Shia, and he is also one of the great poets; when he came to Imam Baqir, the Imam said, "Did you praise Abdul Malik?" I heard you praised Abdul Malik? Kuthair became flustered and said, "O son of the Messenger of God, I did not say to him 'O Imam of Guidance'"; I did not call him "Imam of Guidance" or "Caliph of the Messenger of God"; rather, I said, "O lion, and the lion is a dog, and O sun, and the sun is an inanimate object, and...," and began to justify; the Imam laughed; he pointed to Kumayt, (59) then Kumayt stood up and recited the Hashemite poem:

Who for a heart that is enamored and captivated

Except for a passion and not dreams (60)

Until it reaches here that

The rulers are not like the shepherds of the people

They are equal and the shepherds of the cattle (61)

That is, the Imams were sensitive about Abdul Malik being praised, but the students of the Imams and friends, like Kuthair, their sensitivity was about Imam al-Huda, saying we did not call him "Imam al-Huda."

[Of course] he also wanted to say "Imam al-Huda"; during the Abbasid period, this was more pronounced. Marwan ibn Abi Hafsa, the wicked Umayyad, was a poet of praise and a dependent and mercenary of both the Umayyads and the Abbasids, and it is strange that during the Umayyad period he was a court poet, and when the Abbasids came to power, he became a court poet again, because he was a very great poet and they bought him with money; when he praised the Abbasids, he did not limit himself to speaking of their generosity and qualities, [but] attributed them to the Prophet; one of his poems is this:

How can it be, and that is not going to happen

For the daughters' sons to inherit the uncles' estate (62)

He says how can such a thing happen that the daughters' sons inherit the uncles' estate? Well, the uncle of the Prophet, Abbas, has an inheritance, and why do the daughters' sons, who are the children of Fatimah, want to inherit his estate? See! The dispute is over the caliphate; it is a real cultural war, a political war. In response, immediately a famous Shiite poet, the Ta'i poet — apparently Ja'far ibn 'Affan Ta'i — answers, saying:

Why should it not be, and that is going to happen

For the daughters' sons to inherit the uncles' estate

For the daughter is entitled to half of her father's wealth

And the uncle is left without shares (63)

He responds, saying, well, the daughter takes half of her father's wealth, what does the uncle take from the wealth of the one who has a daughter? So you have no inheritance that you are claiming; see! Among the poets, there is a cultural dispute, a political dispute; this sensitivity is about the claims of the Imams, which is also noteworthy.

The confirmation and support of bloody movements is one of the discussions in the lives of the Imams that reflects this orientation of struggle, [such as] the statements of Imam Sadiq about Mu'alla ibn Khunays when he was killed: "He will not attain his rank except by what he attains from Dawood ibn Ali"; or the statements regarding Zayd and regarding Hussain ibn Ali, the martyr of Fakh. I saw a strange narration in Noor al-Thaqalayn where someone narrates from Ali ibn Uqbah or Aqbah "from his father, he said: I entered with Mu'alla to Abu Abdullah (peace be upon him)"; we entered upon Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him); the Imam began without preamble and said: "Rejoice! You are on one of the two good outcomes. Allah has healed your hearts and removed the rage from your chests and granted you victory over your enemy," and this is the word of Allah: "And He heals the breasts of a believing people" and if you die before they see that, you have died on the religion of Allah which He has approved for His Prophet and for Ali." He does not say what the issue was, but you can see what the issue could have been; Mu'alla ibn Khunays, who was later killed, Mu'alla ibn Khunays who "was the door of Imam Sadiq" - this door itself is a wide door that shows who the doors of the Imams were, and most of them were also killed: Yahya ibn Umm al-Tawil was martyred, Mu'alla ibn Khunays likewise - Mu'alla ibn Khunays and another person entered upon Imam Sadiq; Imam Sadiq, without preamble, says that "Praise be to Allah, He has calmed your rage, He has calmed your anger, He has granted you victory over your enemy, you have entered upon one of the two good outcomes; if this had not happened and you had gone, you would still have gone on the religion of Allah." It is clear that they had made a sharp movement and had come, and the Imam was giving them divine strength; and likewise, there are other narrations regarding the support of bloody movements.

Another discussion in the lives of the Imams is the prisons, exiles, and persecutions, which I believe is a chapter that should be pursued, as it has detailed matters that I do not even have the opportunity to read one of them now.

One is the sharp and incisive language of the Imams against the caliphs; if they were conservative people, they should have taken a soft tone like other scholars and ascetics and such; even that ascetic who was favored by the caliphs. You know there were many ascetics whom the caliphs were fond of; they would advise them and would even bring Harun to tears, but they were careful not to call him a tyrant or a devil, while the Imams did.

Another discussion is the harshness of the caliphs towards the Imams; like the behavior towards Mansur, of which I mentioned several instances, and [the harshness] that Harun had towards Musa ibn Ja'far, and such.

One issue among the topics that should be pursued is the claims that indicate the strategy of the Imamate. Sometimes one sees claims in the lives of the Imams that are not ordinary, indicating a specific strategy, which is the same strategy of the Imamate; for example, I mentioned a few examples in the discussions we were having regarding Imam Baqir. One is the issue of Fadak, where Harun once said to Musa ibn Ja'far to "limit Fadak until I return it to you," specify it so that I can return it to you; the Imam initially refuses, then says: "I will only take it with its limits," if you give me its original limits, I will take it; then he says, "Very well, specify its limits"; then it is very interesting, the Imam specifies the limits for him; the first limit is: "As for the first limit, it is Aden"; one limit of Fadak is Aden; now they are sitting in Medina or Baghdad and talking; one of them is Aden, the farthest point of the Arabian Peninsula; then the face of Al-Rashid changed; [Harun] turned pale; and he said, "What is this?" He said, "And the second limit is Samarkand"; the second limit of Fadak is Samarkand; then his face darkened; and the third limit is Africa; the third limit is Tunisia; then his face turned black; and he said, "What a statement!" He said, "And the fourth is the sword of the sea from what is next to the islands and Armenia"; the margins of the seas and those islands and, for example, Armenia; now whether it is Armenia or wherever; for example, the farthest point of the Mediterranean Sea and those areas; Al-Rashid said, "Then nothing remains for us"; then he turned to a council; "Get up and come sit in my place"; Musa (peace be upon him) said, "I informed you that if I limit it, you will not return it"; then at that point, he resolved to kill him; here, he became determined to kill Musa ibn Ja'far; this claim of Musa ibn Ja'far and such claims in the lives of Musa ibn Ja'far, Imam Sadiq, and the eighth Imam exist, which is also a significant discussion.

Another discussion that is noteworthy is the understanding of the companions of the Imams regarding the movements of the Imams. The companions of the Imams were closer to the Imams than we are; what did they think about the Imams? Did you not encounter in the narrations of the Imams that the companions of the Imams expected an uprising? Did they expect an uprising for no reason? The one who rises comes and says, "O son of the Messenger of Allah! Why do you not rise while five hundred thousand men in Khorasan are waiting for your signal?" and the Imam constantly negotiates with him until he finally reaches a smaller number; why does he say to rise? Or those many individuals who constantly referred to Imam Sadiq, [of course] excluding the spies of Bani Abbas; I do not mean them; those who were spies, from the Imam's response, it becomes clear that they were spies, but those who were not really spies and from the Imam's response, it becomes clear that they were not spies, why did they refer?

This narration is very interesting; Zararah, who is one of the greatest companions of Imam Sadiq, comes to Imam Sadiq and says, "O son of the Messenger of Allah! There is a person from our companions in Kufa who is indebted to one of our enemies, and since he could not pay the debt, he has fled; you say if this issue will be resolved in just a year or two, we should say this person should remain a fugitive until, God willing, the rightful government comes and his issue will resolve itself; but if it takes longer, this poor man cannot remain a fugitive for long, we should gather and pay his debt." The Imam does not give a clear answer that it cannot be done; now, why should Zararah think that something will happen in just a year or two? Does that mean Zararah was naive and not familiar with the issues of the Imams? When Imam Baqir passed away, Zararah said to one of the companions of Imam Sadiq, "You will not see anyone other than Ja'far on the pulpits of the caliphate"; then he said when Imam Sadiq passed away, I asked what happened, how did it happen? He said, "Yes, this was my own inference that I said, meaning the Imam did not say it" so that the Imam's words do not turn out to be false. Why could Zararah make such a mistake? Is this really a mistake? Or is it the understanding of the companions regarding the claims of the Imams and the future of the Islamic world concerning the Imams, which is something noteworthy; we who are not close to them; all of them were waiting. And know that the companions of the Imams, all or most, were waiting for an uprising to occur and for the rightful government to be established soon, which has detailed stories in this regard. The understanding of the companions of the Imams regarding their movements, which is the same expectation of the caliphate, is also a chapter that is worth examining.

Another chapter is whether the reason the Imams were hated by the caliphs was the envy of the caliphs. This is a question. Some people think that the Imams were killed because they were envied by the caliphs; I do not accept this. I accept that the Imams were envied; [regarding] that noble verse "Or do they envy the people for what Allah has given them of His bounty," the Imam says, "We are the envied"; the Imams are envied, but when can envy lead to such consequences? Was it envy over their knowledge? Was it envy over their piety? Well, there were many knowledgeable and pious people; at the same time as the Imams, there were those known for their knowledge, piety, and asceticism, and the caliphs would go to them and cry. Mansur said that

"All of you walk slowly

All of you seek prey

Except for Amr ibn Ubaid."

He excluded Amr ibn Ubaid; of course, I have seen in the life of Amr ibn Ubaid that no, he is also among those exceptions, "seeking prey" and such. There were many like this. Those who had much knowledge, much piety, and a good reputation among the people, like Abu Yusuf the judge, like Abu Hanifa, like Hasan al-Basri, like Sufyan al-Thawri, and such well-known figures of knowledge and piety who were also beloved, had knowledge, had piety, but did not claim the caliphate; the caliph had nothing to do with them; there was no envy towards them; envy belongs to someone who has a claim; [towards] one who has no claim, what envy [is there]? And what is that claim? Therefore, envy is not sufficient. This is also a discussion that is worth considering.

Another of the topics is that among the companions of the Imams who were harsh, there are those like Yahya ibn Umm al-Tawil who had sharp movements and openly spoke ill. Yahya ibn Umm al-Tawil would go to the mosque of Medina, turn to the people, and say: "Indeed, we disown you and what you worship besides Allah; we have disbelieved in you, and enmity and hatred have appeared between us and you"; the words of Ibrahim to the disbelievers were said by Yahya ibn Umm al-Tawil to the Muslims of that time; or he would come to the Kufa canal, address the Shiites, and say things. Mu'alla ibn Khunays, when the people went to the desert for prayer during the days of Eid, would come in tattered clothes and disheveled hair, then he would weep, cry out, and say: "O Allah, this is the place of Your saints"; this position that they have usurped is the place of Your saints; he would cry out and say it openly. This is also worthy of investigation and examination as to why they [did this]. Now we see, unfortunately, that they have bombarded the image of Mu'alla ibn Khunays, this long-time companion of Imam Sadiq and martyr before the friend of Allah, that the Imam cut off relations with Dawood ibn Ali because of him and cursed Dawood ibn Ali, and Dawood ibn Ali was killed because of the murder of Mu'alla, and the Imam said: "Mu'alla will not attain his rank except by what he attains from Dawood ibn Ali"; now they have accused this person of being an unreliable narrator, and I see the hand of the wickedness of Bani Abbas in such matters to remove prominent figures of Shi'ism from the scene; this is also a topic that is worth discussing.

And finally, the issue of Taqiyyah, which at that time makes sense within this framework; Taqiyyah means that Imam Sajjad, Imam Baqir, Imam Sadiq, and the other Imams do the things I mentioned and do not allow this cover and protection to be removed from their actions, and if someone is harsh, they tell him not to be harsh. In that narration, the Imam says: "It is not from the acceptance of our matter to confirm it"; it is not enough for someone who carries our matter and accepts our guardianship to just confirm us; no, rather "from the acceptance of our matter is to conceal it and protect it"; you must keep our matter secret, you should not tell anyone. Then the Imam says, "This is Abu Hanifa, he has companions, and this is Hasan al-Basri, he has companions"; no one has anything to do with their affairs; I am also, well, the son of the Prophet, under the cover of the Quran and Hadith and knowledge, could have companions and no one would have anything to do with me; you all go here and there and say and do not conceal my secrets and create so many problems for us; this is the statement of Imam Sadiq, which is also another discussion, and the discussion of Taqiyyah is also a detailed discussion.

In any case, this issue of struggle and political orientation is one of the very, very important topics in the lives of the Imams, and what I have presented is one-hundredth of what can be said in these areas.

And I hope that Almighty God grants success to the brothers who are interested in this work to pursue this issue. I have done a lot of work in this regard; unfortunately, today I do not have the opportunity to summarize that work and I do not have the time, and I wish that some determined individuals would emerge and continue this work so that the political life of the Imams (peace be upon them) is compiled and reaches the people, and we can have this life as a lesson and model, not just as an eternal memory.

And peace be upon you and the mercy of Allah and His blessings.

74) Surah An-Nisa, part of verse 54; "But rather, they envy the people for what Allah has given them of His bounty..."

75) Al-Kafi, Vol. 1, p. 186

76) Muruj al-Dhahab, Vol. 3, p. 303

77) Surah Al-Mumtahana, part of verse 4; "... We disavow you and what you worship besides Allah. We have rejected you, and enmity and hatred have appeared between us forever, until you believe in Allah alone..."

78) Al-Kashi's Rijal (The Book of the Knowledge of Men), p. 382 (with slight variation)

79) Bihar al-Anwar, Vol. 47, p. 109 (with slight variation)

80) Al-Kafi, Vol. 2, p. 222

81) Al-Kafi, Vol. 2, p. 223