Statements during a meeting with a group of students.

Iran Ali Khamenei · Supreme Leader of Iran

28 November 2002 · Meeting with a group of students

Context
Khamenei addressed a group of students during an annual Ramadan iftar meeting in November 2002, reflecting on youth potential and Iran's academic progress.
Main themes
Student movement, Iranian youth potential, university education, scientific progress, optimism about Iran's future, Ramadan gathering, academic Olympiads, Iranian talent, university management challenges, idealism and national development
Duration
~25 min
75th percentile
Words
2,990
75th percentile
Sentences
133
76th percentile
Readability
49
61st percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
26th percentile

Translated from Persian

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 48%46%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Geopolitical 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 12%11%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Economic 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

133 sentences in 16 paragraphs

In the name of God, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

This meeting is a very sweet and desirable one for me. Of course, the nature of this meeting is symbolic; that is to say, for several years now, we have been gathering with a group of male and female students to break our fast on one day of Ramadan each year, which in itself is a symbolic act. I wish to reflect the value of the student body and the very important role that this group can play in the present and future of the country in public opinion through this act. I also want to show that the Islamic system welcomes the growth of the student movement and all the characteristics that belong to this movement. These characteristics are the very things that you mentioned and know: the surge of enthusiasm and talent, youthful motivations, idealistic demands, and a commitment to ideals that may seem unattainable even to non-youth, but the young do not think this way at all and strive for them, and it is this effort that frees nations and countries from stagnation. This is the main goal of the meeting.

The fact that you stand up to speak and share your thoughts is also a special benefit for me, which I value. Of course, some friends have said to raise questions; this means that I should respond. This meeting is not for that purpose, because if I were to hold a question-and-answer session, it would not be completed in this half hour—now that there is only a little more than a quarter of an hour until the call to prayer. A question-and-answer session takes longer than this. I have held question-and-answer sessions in the past and, God willing, I will continue to do so in the future. This meeting is for me to hear from you. I want you to speak, and I want to listen; that is, the very thing that, despite the limited time, has somewhat happened: some of you spoke, and I listened; I also took notes. The points raised by some of the brothers and our respected sister have been recorded, and I will say to follow up on them.

I will only mention two or three points: one point is that I am optimistic about the university environment and the student movement, contrary to the statements of some students who lack this optimism. This optimism is not due to wishful thinking; after all, I have spent my life engaged in these matters. At my age and with my situation, wishful thinking is not very likely. I receive extensive information—both scientific, cultural, and moral and spiritual—about the state of universities, and the overall outcome of all this information is what I have said: I am optimistic.

In the scientific field, the shortcomings you mentioned do exist: the problem of professors, the problem of management, the problem of planning, the problem of budget shortages, and so on. I am aware of these; these are issues that I have been repeatedly discussing and following up on in meetings with university members—whether professors, students, or management—over the past ten years. Of course, a lot of improvements have been made in these areas. However, despite all these problems, the enthusiasm for scientific inquiry and the blossoming of talents in our universities is palpable; we cannot ignore this and only recite verses of despair. Our dear friend also said: "I want to bring good news, others have warned"; but that one word of good news was lost in his warnings! Although that good news is real.

The good news I am referring to is genuine. The scientific movement and the blossoming of talents in our universities are progressing. You can observe that the number of candidates participating in national and international Olympiads in various scientific fields is increasing. I was given a report that, if I am not mistaken, one hundred thousand people applied last year to participate in the mathematics Olympiad; this is a high number. Those who are familiar and knowledgeable have said that out of these one hundred thousand, at least forty thousand are in an ideal academic and educational situation. In the basic sciences, we are always among the top ten countries in the world in international Olympiads. Even in computer science—a field that is entirely imported; that is, we have no prior experience in this field—we have been able to achieve high rankings in international Olympiads. Iranian talent plays a role in this achievement, which was also denied. For several years, I have been constantly shouting: "Iranian talent"; now, after all these years, it has finally become part of the culture! Now everyone believes that Iranians are talented; otherwise, in the past, they denied even this and said: "Iranians cannot do anything; we must give up on Iranians." This was how they influenced minds. Talent is involved, but it is not enough; effort has also been made, both by the doers—the students—and by management, professors, and so on. This trend is a good one; why should we ignore it and only recite verses of despair for ourselves? This is the scientific aspect of the matter.

Our dear friend mentioned that I said in Friday prayers that I expect the scientific community of the country to be a producer of knowledge for the world in fifty years, and this is not impossible. Now, refer to yourselves; if you find that this statement seems impossible to you, know that the imposed culture is still in your mind that tells you: you cannot do it, you have no capacity. This imposed culture must be eradicated; it is entirely possible. We have suffered from corrupt rulers, oppressive governments, and regimes dependent on the West and America. Wherever we wanted to blossom our talents over the past one hundred and fifty to two hundred years—which is the era of the birth and growth of science—they crushed it. If we wanted to produce the same small industries that came from the West—glass, textiles, photographic glass, and so on—they conspired against us, and the global companies that wanted to have consumers in the world did not want such things to exist, and therefore they blocked it. Our past governments were also dependent, corrupt, incompetent, or ineffective. After the revolution, those barriers were broken. Of course, if it were not for the imposed war; if some other issues did not exist, the revolutionary management could have performed much better than this. God willing, by the grace of God and the blessing of the Islamic system and the revolution, these tasks will be accomplished in the future; this is the certain destiny of our country.

In the moral realm, it is the same. Some exaggerate the moral issues and problems in universities. Now, I never want to say a word that would encourage someone who is facing a moral problem to consider that problem trivial or small; however, I want to tell you that our young student generation is, among Western countries afflicted with moral problems, and even among Islamic countries, far superior in terms of morality and spirituality, and in terms of delicate human feelings. In one university—many of you may know it, and some of you are certainly from that university—students make an agreement to fast on the first day of Sha'ban and collect their meal tokens to be used for the poor. The issue is not just helping the poor; the issue is fasting; the issue is attention to God; the issue is the path of divine worship. In our university, these matters are fortunately not rare, neglected, or strange. Even the political and factional differences and the unethical behaviors that are observed here and there cannot eliminate the predominance of spiritual tendencies.

My understanding and expectation from the student body and the Islamic system is that we consider the student to be a fully-fledged Muslim intellectual; they are religious. There are movements in the world—some of which have branches in Iran—that do not consider the student to be either an intellectual or a Muslim. They do not consider him an intellectual because they subject him to party and political biases and imported dogmas. When we say dogmatism, our minds immediately go to religious dogmatism; yes, that is one type of dogmatism, but more dangerous than that is political dogmatism; dogmatism arising from the formation of parties and political organizations that do not allow anyone to think. If we present ten convincing reasons for the legitimacy of a position, they will accept it, but in practice, they will show otherwise! Why? Because the party, that political organization above them—like the mafia godfather—has asked them to do so. Unfortunately, one can see this in some corners of even the university environment. Therefore, that group that is afflicted with such dogmatism is no longer an intellectual; because intellectualism requires a quest for truth, open-mindedness, and reliance on logic and reasoning. The fact that they do not want to be Muslim is because they know that being Muslim is dangerous. Today, most of the troubles that the camp of arrogance, specifically America and Zionism, face—of which there are many—are due to the fact that Muslims have reached a self-awareness in which the great Imam, the Iranian nation, the revolution, and our system have played a significant role. Most of their troubles stem from this; therefore, they want to crush it. For this reason, they are very dissatisfied and unhappy with the student being a Muslim.

I believe that the unity of student organizations—which has been mentioned—is a good thing; however, not in the sense that all organizations should disappear and one organization should emerge; this is not a correct experience. It will not leave anything that the same organization will not face many of the problems of many organizations. The correct way is for the existing student organizations to come closer to each other with understanding, a sense of justice, and the qualities that are characteristic of students; to place the truth in the center and let support and opposition arise from reasoning and logic.

My dear ones! The university is a center of knowledge and awareness. Anything that interferes with knowledge and awareness has no place in the university. The university suffers fundamentally from these interventions and the role of political dogmatists in student environments. The university should be a place for scientific and research work. The university should be a place where deception, fraud, and fallacies either do not exist or exist minimally. Those who thrive in chaos and can only live in a chaotic environment should not be able to play a role in the university. This is the expectation from the university and the young students and professors and university administrators to make it a reality. The way to do this is to carry out work based on that foundation of awareness. For example, suppose a political issue is raised; very well; political disagreements and disputes are natural and not a problem. Not only in political matters, but even in religious matters, differing opinions and viewpoints can help progress and pose no obstacle. I, myself, being a cleric and having spent my life in the clerical world and in seminaries, have seen that in the seminary, raising a topic that contradicts the prevailing opinion is never considered a sin; however, it has a condition. The condition is that both the presentation and the discussion must be scholarly. Suppose a political issue is raised in the university that is a matter of disagreement. What is the obstacle? Thinkers and intellectuals should be invited to come and discuss with each other in a calm environment. They should be asked to look at the issue scientifically. Such a thing is also possible in religious matters. On the one hand, many of the issues that students raise are closely related to Islamic and religious matters. This will compel scholars, scientists, and thinkers from the seminary to come into this arena, and this will lead to the elevation of thought and Islamic thought. We should seek this, and any action contrary to it is not suitable for the university environment and students. Chaos and raising fists over nothing and creating uproar, and, as some friends say—who are very concerned—insulting the sacred, is not appropriate. Of course, I do not worry as much as the brothers who are concerned; because a little of it is due to your youth. You are young and have not seen these things; you get flustered easily. We have spent a lifetime and have seen much of this; we know that these things are nothing.

Anarchistic tendencies are completely opposed to what is appropriate for the university. Opposition to order and to whatever it may be—some are like this—is not suitable for the university. Of course, the primary duty of everyone—whether students or non-students—is to defend the Islamic system. Let me tell you this: I do not say this because I am a member of the system and a responsible person in the system; no, I am still that cleric, let me make that clear. My feelings and spirit have not changed from the feelings and spirit with which I spent years in oppression and fought; I am still the same person; of course, with less enthusiasm and more experience. I say this because today this Islamic system is the only bastion of struggle against oppression and arrogance in the world, and there is no other bastion like this. Today, many governments, despite their nations and intellectuals and their inner feelings and hearts, have kissed the threshold of America and even the threshold of Zionism! Many European parliaments have also kissed the threshold of the Zionists and have become their money slaves; as the saying goes, they have become the servants of their pockets! The center and power that is recognized as a formal political entity in the world—with the platforms that exist for such an entity—and is based on a sixty-million-strong nation and is still considered a bastion of defense for freedom-seeking, justice, and human and international ideals is the Islamic Republic of Iran today. Defending this system is the duty of all; it is not specific to someone who is a member of the system or part of the government or otherwise; everyone must defend it. If someone acts contrary to this, it is not necessary for someone to bring evidence that this person is, for example, affiliated with such and such a spy agency; it is not necessary for them to be officially affiliated; but they say the same words and do the same actions. Even if they do not receive money from them, they are, in fact, their unpaid servants. Today, the CIA of America and the Mossad of Israel have as their primary goal to create an opening within the Islamic system so that they can strike a blow and diminish the strength and authority that this system currently has in the world as a bastion. Now, if someone inside, even with a clenched fist, even from the university, even from behind an official podium, shouts this, that is not art; that is not something to be proud of. What honor is there in siding with the most tyrannical bullies in the world and the most unjust governments and centers of power?! The day we fought against the tyrannical regime, every action of a fighter was honorable; those struggles were honorable. Today, some sectors are fighting against tyrannical, dependent, and corrupt regimes in the world, which is honorable; but opposing a system that stands firm against the centers of power and arrogance is not honorable for anyone. I believe that these movements are imposed on the university; these movements are obstacles and adversaries to knowledge and awareness in universities. Universities reject these, just as the quality of their behavior and their political maneuvering has reached a point where many of our students have even become disillusioned with politics, to the extent that they have lost interest in political work. Of course, some university officials are not without fault.

The points that one of our brothers raised regarding justice as questions were very good points. These questions need to be answered. Of course, I said that this is not the place for it, and I do not necessarily have to respond. You should think about the answers yourselves. In these good meetings and gatherings with professors and prominent thinkers and Islamic figures in society, find the answers to these questions and even help us in these areas and give your opinions; these opinions help us a lot. Of course, the anti-corruption movement to eradicate it and the movement for justice will, by the grace of God, continue. It is a difficult task; however, this difficult task will continue in the Islamic system. The meaning of the system and the spirit of the system is precisely this, and it must continue, and God willing, it will continue; the enemy will also have many. Know this as well. Amir al-Mu'minin, peace be upon him, said—according to what is narrated—"Justice is the widest of things in terms of description and the narrowest in terms of implementation." Justice is such that in slogans and in speech, it is very sweet and appealing, and everyone says it and likes it; but when it comes to the implementation and fairness, it becomes very difficult. Many of those you see sometimes shouting in favor of justice, when it comes to action, they falter and may even regret shouting.

In any case, you should uphold justice in your conversations, decisions, and judgments within your own environments. God Almighty, if He wills, will bestow His grace upon all of you and us.

And peace be upon you and the mercy of God and His blessings.

1) Nahj al-Balagha: Sermon 216 [ ...for truth is the widest of all things in mutual description...]