Statement after the meeting of the President with representatives of parliamentary clubs

Poland Andrzej Duda · President of Poland

25 September 2017 · Meeting of the President with representatives of parliamentary clubs

Context
Duda addressed press after meeting parliamentary club representatives on September 25, 2017, to announce his revised proposals for reforming the National Judiciary Council.
Main themes
Judicial reform in Poland, National Judiciary Council, constitutional amendment, parliamentary dialogue, presidential role as guarantor, selection of judges, political consensus, Sejm voting procedures, parliamentary club positions
Duration
~8 min
28th percentile
Words
968
28th percentile
Sentences
35
21st percentile
Readability
43
42nd percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.31
83rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.20
49th percentile

Translated from Polish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 89%89%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

35 sentences in 12 paragraphs

First of all, I would like to sincerely thank the representative of Law and Justice, Professor Ryszard Terlecki, I would like to thank Chairman Ryszard Petru, I would like to sincerely thank the representative of the Kukiz '15 club, Mr. Tyszka, I would also like to thank Chairman Kosiniak-Kamysz for attending the meeting. Thank you for this constructive attitude of dialogue and consulting on matters important for the Polish state.

One of the parliamentary clubs refused to attend. Well ‒ this shows its interest in this extremely important issue for Poland, which is the reform of the Polish judiciary. And if they do not want to discuss this matter with the President, then I kindly ask them not to appeal to the President, for example, to convene the National Security Council, because if they do not want to meet with the President, then such appeals from them make no sense.

However, ladies and gentlemen, those who were present formed a sufficient group ‒ in terms of representation of the Polish parliament ‒ to make a decision on the matter I mentioned and for which I asked. Namely: the representatives of the parliamentary clubs today represented a total of 310 deputies, while 307 are needed to obtain the 2/3 majority necessary to amend the Constitution.

I presented my arguments and my proposal. They were, ladies and gentlemen, as follows: in the Polish Constitution, in Article 126, paragraph 1, which generally describes the competencies of the President, there is a statement that the President of the Republic of Poland is the guarantor of the continuity of state power. That is why I proposed that the safeguard regarding the selection of judges to the National Judiciary Council should be the President. That is, that 3/5 of the deputies would elect judges in the Sejm, those 15 candidates, and if no agreement is reached in the Sejm that would allow for this selection, then the safeguard would be that the President would choose from the candidates put forward.

And that was the basis of my conversation with those who came to the meeting today, I repeat: representing 2/3 or even more than 2/3 of the Polish parliament ‒ therefore, those who did not come were already unnecessary. I presented my idea, I believed it was the best solution, that it would best reflect the spirit of this constitutional provision that the President is the guarantor of the continuity of state power. Because then indeed the President would complete this selection to the National Judiciary Council, thus enabling it to function with the proper composition.

While three parliamentary clubs stated that they were ready to accept such a solution, unfortunately, Chairman Ryszard Petru stated that his parliamentary club would absolutely not accept this solution, because he disagrees that changes are needed in the Polish judiciary. Therefore, he will consistently not accept this proposal, which would adjust the Constitution, enabling the creation of the safeguard I mentioned, through the fact that the President will be the guarantor of continuity in relation to the National Judiciary Council, and thus also in the appointment of judges to the courts – that they do not agree to this.

This means, ladies and gentlemen, that there is no chance for this amendment to be passed. Because I understand that Civic Platform has negated my proposal by not coming to the meeting. However, Mr. Ryszard Petru, whom I thank once again for his presence, said that it ultimately will not be accepted, because the parliamentary club of Nowoczesna has 27 deputies, which means that automatically the 2/3 majority is not there.

Ladies and gentlemen, my proposal will be different, because there is no chance of passing what I originally proposed. This is not about me, as President, having the power to choose to the KRS – no. I simply want it to be a choice that has a non-partisan character. The President of the Republic is elected by the nation, is the guarantor of the continuity of state power – it seemed to me that this was a sensible proposal.

If there is no agreement in parliament, my proposal will be that the voting – in the event that it is not possible to obtain 3/5 of the votes – will take place in such a way that each deputy has one vote, that is, each deputy can vote for only one candidate for judge to the National Judiciary Council. This will ultimately lead to a multiparty selection of members of the National Judiciary Council, and such, ladies and gentlemen, a proposal will ultimately be in my draft amendment to the Act on the National Judiciary Council.

I repeat once again: 3/5 as a principle, the basic procedure. In the event that it is not possible to select judges to the National Judiciary Council in this way within the deadline, a second procedure will be activated ‒ such that each deputy has one vote. And I hope that parliament will calmly consider my proposals. I also appealed today to the Members of Parliament, to the Chairmen, to ensure that the work in parliament proceeds calmly. I stated clearly and unequivocally that the attitude of the opposition also has a huge impact on the atmosphere of work in parliament on the laws.

I care about this work being substantive, that it proceeds calmly, and not in an atmosphere of creating some political war. I want the deputies to calmly consider this. If they have good amendments, I will also be pleased ‒ if such good amendments, primarily pro-social, are introduced to these laws. Of course, parliament has the right to make corrections, and I, as President, obviously take into account that corrections may be made here by parliament.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much then. And see you soon.