Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 42nd Congress of German Local Newspapers on May 10, 2016, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 May 2016 · 42nd Congress of German Local Newspapers · British Embassy, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 42nd Congress of German Local Newspapers on May 10, 2016, in Berlin, speaking on the importance of a free and diverse press.
Main themes
Role of local newspapers, media literacy, press freedom, globalization and its challenges, refugee crisis, digital media and online incitement, information overload, diversity of media landscape, freedom of the press, identity and regional roots
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,244
62nd percentile
Sentences
154
82nd percentile
Readability
44
46th percentile
Grade
10.7
29th percentile
Syntax
2.73
16th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
38th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 32%28%
  • Social 30%26%
  • Ceremonial 16%14%
  • Institutional 14%12%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

154 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Dunkmann,

dear Mr. Ambassador,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

ladies and gentlemen,

thank you very much for the invitation and the warm welcome. I am pleased to be a guest here at the British Embassy. I believe you have made a good choice with your venue.

The German writer Theodor Fontane, who spent several years of his life in London, wrote a poem titled "Zeitung" (Newspaper), in which he states among other things: "And nothing can outrage me more deeply than to hear people rant against newspaper writers." In the following lines, Fontane has the angry critics take aim at the supposed clichés, only to conclude himself: "But if you take away our clichés for just three weeks, pure nonsense will be spoken." I believe there is much truth in these words. We do not always like everything that is written in the newspapers. Nevertheless, newspapers undoubtedly broaden our horizons. They help us form a nuanced, balanced opinion.

That is why we can consider ourselves fortunate to have a diverse newspaper landscape in Germany. There are around 350 daily newspapers in Germany—many of them with various local editions. A total of about 16 million daily newspaper copies are sold, of which approximately twelve million are accounted for by local and regional papers.

The classic local newspaper is a basic medium that keeps its readers informed—usually about national and international current events, but above all about local happenings. Who does not feel addressed by that? For who does not like to know what is happening in their immediate environment and what might directly and personally affect them? With its regional roots, the local newspaper is part of the daily lives of millions of people. In this way, it also strengthens identity. This is probably one of the reasons for the high support that local newspapers enjoy, especially in an age of increasing globalization.

The significance of globalization and the importance of other cultures are also increasing significantly for individuals and our society here at home. This applies, on the one hand, with regard to the opportunities. Just think, for example, that we in Germany owe a large part of our prosperity to vibrant foreign trade. Or consider the possibilities of traveling—wherever—and learning—wherever. On the other hand, as a global community, we also share more risks than we did a few decades ago. Developments elsewhere in the world increasingly affect us as well. This means that more and more countries and regions are facing the same challenges—in the economy, in climate protection, and in security and stability. The cruel war in Syria, for example, seemed very far away to us here five years ago. But with its consequences in the form of the refugee crisis, this war has come very close to us, literally to our doorsteps.

Global challenges require global responses. Finding these is often very difficult and time-consuming. Just think about how complicated it sometimes is for us to agree on a solution path within our own country. When you consider that we have nearly 200 countries in the world, you can imagine how complicated it becomes when these countries need to come to an agreement.

The world seems to be becoming increasingly complex and confusing. With such changes and the associated uncertainties in our living environment, the need for orientation and comprehensibility grows. While access to information is easier today than ever, the variety of information is also greater than ever. Therefore, the danger of isolating oneself against such an information flood or wanting to limit oneself to very few information channels should not be underestimated.

This means we need to develop media literacy. We must learn to distinguish the important from the less important. What is needed are understandable and practical explanations, clear background analyses, and guidance. I firmly believe that there is a great opportunity for newspapers in this. Therefore, there is no question that we need a diverse, free, independent, and opinionated press.

However, the added value of a diverse media landscape is already called into question when journalists, newspapers, or publishers are criticized carelessly and indiscriminately. How quickly criticism can become unfounded was evident at some demonstrations recently, where reporters, photographers, and film crews were insulted, threatened, and attacked. This is shameful for a country that sees itself as enlightened. That this has occurred is also one of the reasons why we have been downgraded in the press freedom rankings.

We are experiencing particularly aggressive incitement on the internet. In the anonymity of this medium, the threshold for crossing lines seems to drop very easily. Journalists and editorial teams can attest to this. Online forums of newspapers are repeatedly used for attacks that exceed the bounds of good taste. The moderation effort is becoming unmanageable for some forum operators. Some daily newspapers—especially local newspaper houses—have responded by restricting the comment function on their websites or completely shutting down their online forums. This is understandable, but it is also unfortunate, because we need a culture of communication on the internet as well—one that respects human dignity, as stated in our Basic Law. I can only appeal to all involved to use online forums responsibly, tolerantly, and with respect for others.

A week ago, on May 3, it was the International Day of Press Freedom. If you look around the world, you see that in many countries, journalists lack the opportunity to work freely and independently. In several states, press freedom is restricted. In some, it is not granted at all. In some places, journalistic research is only possible under state surveillance. Interview partners and informants are intimidated. It goes so far that persecution, imprisonment, or even death threaten. Those who stand up for free reporting in the face of such dangers have my utmost respect.

Press freedom is an essential prerequisite, but it is certainly not sufficient on its own for truly good journalism, which thrives on thorough and independent research, investigative questions, precise and engaging texts, factually sound comments, and clear positions. This means that quality starts with qualification. Training to become a print journalist is still something like the highest school of the media industry. Many local newspapers are also involved in this. They challenge the intellect of their young talent. They foster enthusiasm and curiosity. They teach how to look critically at events, uncover grievances, and present the results of research in an understandable way.

Good journalists are and remain the most valuable asset of newspapers. This should be undisputed. The contentious issue is whether the work of journalists proves to be financially rewarding for them. Authors, including freelancers, depend on fair compensation for their work if they want to make a living from it.

This is precisely the subject of the planned reform of copyright law. The federal government has now adopted a draft law to ensure a fair share for creators in the value creation from their works. But the discussions are—this you can easily imagine—not trivial. On the one hand, it is about strengthening the position of creatives. On the other hand, we need a reliable basis for publishers as well. They must be able to operate economically. We believe our reform proposal takes this into account. Since you did not address it critically, it may not be so bad from your perspective.

Undoubtedly, however, it is a tough competition in which publishers must assert themselves. Of course, suitable business models are crucial, providing a sufficient financial basis. We have had many discussions, for example, about distribution and sales. I know this is a difficult chapter. Whether and to what extent, for example, online offers can charge fees must be carefully examined. However, the advertising business remains an important source of income for publishers.

Given the significance of the media economy in our democracy, the federal government does not want to leave publishers alone with all their operational challenges. Therefore, we facilitated mergers of press companies in the last legislative period. Mergers can create a better economic basis. We have always kept an eye on the small publishers as well. It is now also planned to facilitate business cooperation among publishers below the editorial level.

I know that the joy over the minimum wage in the newspaper business is limited. Therefore, I ask you not to overlook that we have decided on one of the few exceptions with the transitional regulation for newspaper deliverers. The minimum wage in full applies to this professional group only from 2017. Given the many subscription customers, this exception particularly benefits the publishers of local and regional newspapers. But time is passing. I have understood that a challenge awaits you then. Nevertheless, I hope that you will make good use of the transitional period.

We have made significant progress regarding the tax framework for the media industry. For audiobooks, the reduced VAT rate already applies. We want to achieve the same for e-books and e-papers. This concerns European VAT law, which must be amended accordingly. This means that the EU Commission must make a proposal that all member states must agree to.

About a year ago, the responsible ministers of France, Poland, Italy, and Germany issued a joint declaration on the equal treatment of printed and electronic works. It states succinctly—I quote—: "A book is a book, regardless of its form." The same applies: A paper is a paper. But because we speak more German, I have now focused on the book. The same can be said for newspapers. It is encouraging that Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker has also expressed support for an extended application of the reduced VAT rate. A proposal for the modernization and simplification of the VAT system is expected this year.

In terms of electronic media and new digital offerings, data protection also plays an important role. With the General Data Protection Regulation, we finally have a uniform legal framework across the EU. This links protection standards with reasonable conditions for data-based business models. It is well known that the management of large amounts of data, big data mining, is becoming an important source of new business models and value creation. Of course, compromises were also necessary with the General Data Protection Regulation. This is inherent in the nature of things. It is important to reconcile entrepreneurial freedom with the protection of data, which is equally in the interest of companies and consumers. We now face the task of adapting national law to the requirements of the European General Data Protection Regulation. In doing so, we will keep the press privilege firmly in mind. We will not waver on this. It is a requirement of free reporting.

The fact that we are unifying data protection in Europe also brings us closer to a digital internal market. The federal government also supports this initiative of the EU Commission. Because uniform regulations help us avoid distortions of competition and ultimately better utilize the opportunities of digitalization through greater legal clarity.

With the digital transformation, newspaper publishers have been tasked from the outset with developing contemporary business models. Local print media have long found their complement in apps and internet offerings. This— as you know better than anyone else—particularly appeals to younger reader groups. Overall, about 45 percent of the population over 14 years old visits the websites of newspaper publishers. About 65 percent read the printed newspaper. There is thus a convergence. This means that the calculations of many publishers are working out, who are betting on a coexistence and synergy of printed and electronic offerings.

The experience is that traditional media are indeed pressured by new media, but they are by no means being displaced. Rather, competition leads to a differentiation of existing offerings and ultimately to a coexistence of various media that can be profitable. Thus, the internet enables traditional newspapers to reach a new audience. Conversely, digital offerings benefit from the quality of newspaper editorial work.

Even if I repeat myself: In the changing media world, good journalism remains an important success factor and, as such, an indispensable constant. This success factor is characterized not only by intellectual and craft qualities but also by a clear professional ethos. This includes seriousness, incorruptibility, thoroughness in research, as well as a clear separation of editorial content and advertising. I often tell local politicians that it is not so easy to be a local politician because one can be directly confronted with one's actions, for example, at the baker's or in the pub. The same certainly applies to many local editors who are well-known in their towns and who constantly have to justify themselves. This means that maintaining incorruptibility and independence while encountering one's readers daily is sometimes certainly as difficult as it is for mayors. But ultimately, it is about credibility.

I am therefore pleased that the topic of your "Media Policy Hour" will be the "high good of credibility." I can only welcome that. Because we must indeed ask ourselves where some of the distrust towards established democratic institutions comes from and how we can reduce it. We face this challenge in politics just as you do in the media.

Therefore, I wish you good, stimulating discussions and a successful course for your congress. Take advantage of the opportunities of such a beautiful message without hindering the message from working. I wish, in the necessary independence from politics and local media, all the best. I believe these good wishes are not an interference in your independent work. All the best for the future.