Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the CDU/CSU Congress "Courage for the Future: Germany as an Innovation Location" on March 29, 2017, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

1 April 2017 · CDU/CSU Congress "Courage for the Future: Germany as an Innovation Location" · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the CDU/CSU parliamentary congress on innovation in Berlin on March 29, 2017, covering Brexit and Germany's role as an innovation hub.
Main themes
Brexit and Article 50, EU cohesion and negotiations, Germany as an innovation location, future EU-UK relations, rights of EU citizens in the UK, Rome Declaration and EU unity, globalization and digitalization, Germany's innovation policy, courage for the future
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,189
87th percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
50
63rd percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
7th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 28%26%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Social 23%22%
  • Technological 13%12%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

216 sentences in 62 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Vice President of the German Bundestag, dear Mr. Singhammer, dear Deputy Parliamentary Group Leader, dear Michael Fuchs, dear Michael Kretschmer, dear colleague from the Cabinet, Ms. Wanka, dear colleagues, but above all you, ladies and gentlemen, who are our guests today at this important congress of the CDU/CSU parliamentary group, before I speak on the specific topic, I would like to say a few words about Great Britain and the European Union in light of recent events.

The British government has now officially communicated its intention to leave the European Union. We, Germany, as well as the other partners of Great Britain in the European Union, certainly did not wish for this day, as we are losing a strong and important member state.

However, we naturally respect the democratic decision of the British voters. With the request under Article 50 of the EU treaties, we now have more clarity about how the British side envisions the further path and what goals Great Britain wants to pursue in the negotiations.

Now it is up to us, the 27 other member states and the European institutions, to define our own interests and goals on this basis. Therefore, in the coming weeks, we will discuss our negotiation guidelines. On April 29, at a special meeting of the European Council, we want to adopt these guidelines.

The federal government has prepared well for this process and will, of course, position itself on all emerging questions. I would like to mention just a few points, as they seem particularly important to me:

First:

For many people in Europe, the intended exit of Great Britain from the EU is associated with very concrete concerns about their own personal future. This is especially true for the many German and European citizens living in Great Britain. Therefore, the federal government will work intensively to ensure that the consequences for the daily lives of those affected are kept to a minimum.

Second:

We know that there are close interconnections between Great Britain and the European Union, of course also with Germany, that have developed over 44 years of membership. In the negotiations, it must first be clarified how we will now orderly disentangle these interconnections. This will also involve dealing with the many rights and obligations that have been associated with membership so far. Only once these questions are clarified can we subsequently, but hopefully soon, talk about our future relationship.

Third:

I hope that Great Britain and the European Union will remain close partners, because for me, the United Kingdom is and remains a part of Europe, with which we share much, not least our common values. Based on these values and with the help of fair rules, we strive for a balanced relationship of rights and obligations.

Fourth:

The European Union is a historically unique success story. It will remain so even after Great Britain's exit. We will ensure that. In the coming two years, the European Union will not only conduct negotiations with Great Britain. It will also continue to work on many other important tasks that we as Europeans face together. This involves joint European responses to globalization and digitalization, to international terrorism and developments in our neighborhood, to flight and migration, but also to climate change.

A few days ago, the heads of state and government of the 27 remaining member states and the representatives of the European institutions signed the Rome Declaration. In it, we reaffirm our commitment to a mutually beneficial European cooperation. The 60th anniversary of the signing of the Treaties of Rome has thus become a symbol of great unity.

Now it is important to maintain this cohesion of the EU-27, especially in the negotiations with Great Britain. We, as the European Union, will conduct the upcoming talks fairly and constructively. I hope that the British government will also approach the negotiations in this spirit. The British Prime Minister assured me of this in a phone call yesterday.

Today is also a day of new beginnings. Therefore, I now come to the title of this congress, which is called "Courage for the Future." It deals with Germany as an innovation location. I find that a very fitting title for the challenges of our time, but also for the discussions we are having.

I would like to remind you once again of the "Ruck" speech by Federal President Roman Herzog. With it, he vividly described what is meant by "Courage for the Future" 20 years ago. He called us to conscience, and I would like to quote him: "The ability to innovate determines our fate." I want to repeat that: "The ability to innovate determines our fate." Very simple, but it must be done.

Today we can say that we have taken this admonition to heart in recent years. As Michael Kretschmer has already mentioned: Germany is now one of the most innovative countries in the world. We have achieved what all member states of the European Union have aimed for, namely to spend three percent of GDP on research and development. We have achieved this by investing and have now reached over 17 billion euros in the federal budget of the Federal Minister for Education and Research.

We have not just accumulated this money, but we have also invested it sensibly in new structures and created reliability, which is something that is particularly needed in the field of research and innovation.

The High-Tech Strategy is certainly the centerpiece of our innovation policy. It is about pooling forces to specifically cultivate those fields that are of particular importance for our prosperity. At the beginning of this legislative period, we revised and focused the entire High-Tech Strategy once again. In relation to this High-Tech Strategy, a status report is made each time, stating where we stand, in order to then see how we can reach the forefront of development. We have identified the following areas, which you have certainly already discussed today: digital economy and society, sustainable economy and energy, innovative working world, healthy living, intelligent mobility, and civil security.

As you can see, research and innovation are spreading into the entire social reality. It is easy to name areas of responsibility, but we must, of course, also carry out the corresponding work.

Our Pact for Research and Innovation, which deals with non-university research institutions, ensures reliability and planning security. We have really brought reliability into this: The budget has increased as agreed, by three percent per year in this legislative period – and we have taken on the shares of the states in the increase.

We have always done all this with the thought: How can we increase university research? Because we have seen that a divergence between university and non-university research is ultimately not good, especially not for the education of many young people.

In order to better manage the duality of federal and state responsibilities and to improve cooperation between the education and research sectors, we have finally amended Article 91b of the Basic Law in this legislative period. We have also presented a comprehensive package to promote top-level research at universities and further developed the Excellence Initiative.

The joint higher education pact brings 760,000 additional study places and ensures demand-oriented study offerings, from which, of course, students benefit. We are also making provisions for the demographically more challenging years, in which we will have fewer young people. With our Tenure-Track program, we have also set a new emphasis to better advance academic careers after graduation.

In this respect, one can say that much in this status report is very encouraging. I could talk about this for quite a while, but the motto is "Courage for the Future" and not "Praise for the Present." However, simply stating what we have already achieved gives us a good platform to then look at: Where do we want and need to go?

We know that lifelong learning, further education, and professional qualification are very important, and therefore we have initiated many measures, especially in the area of STEM qualifications – mathematics, computer science, natural sciences, and technology – which we must continue. We have done a lot to make women more open to scientific subjects. In this respect, some progress has indeed been made.

Also under the heading of what has been achieved: We, the federal government, have taken over BAföG. There was much discussion about the fact that we are always the ones whom students approach and say: "We do not have enough." However, it has developed quite well so far. We have already managed to push through the first increase in BAföG.

Now we must note that Sweden spends about 3.5 percent of GDP on research and development and that the figures in Israel and South Korea are also higher than ours, but otherwise, we are doing quite well.

Above all, we must recognize that we live in a time of revolutionary, sometimes called disruptive, but in any case, tremendous changes driven by the development of what we call digitalization. These are developments that are not only in the realm of technical feasibility but also deal with the networking of everything that exists: the people among themselves, the things among themselves.

These developments will profoundly change our society. Some have said that this can be compared to the emergence of the printing press. I am no longer quite sure whether that image is sufficient or whether the change will not be qualitatively much deeper.

When living in such a period of qualitative change, it is always very difficult to understand what is actually happening. It is best to reflect back and consider how it was when industrialization, that is, the transition from an agrarian society to an industrial society, took place.

Mobility is often compared to the transition from the carriage to the automobile. If you take these comparisons, you must be careful to remain optimistic, at least with regard to the automobile manufacturers. Because hardly any of the carriage builders survived. And it does not seem that the introduction of the automobile on the roads in Europe and Germany was particularly promoted by those who owned horses and built carriages.

The real challenge for us in politics, who cannot understand this change any better, and perhaps even worse, but for whose development we must set the framework, now lies in figuring out: Who are our contacts when we want to talk about this change? We have known our traditional contacts for 40, 50, 60 years. But woe to them if they behave like the carriage builders at the end of the 19th century or the beginning of the 20th century. How do we know if they are better than the carriage builders and horse owners of the past century? They will of course claim that they are, that they know everything, and so on.

We do well to embark on a journey together and to cast our gaze into the new world, for the changes will take place. The danger for Germany lies in the fact that we are very good in the world of industrialization. Those who are not so good may be quicker to say: "Well, there lies our new opportunity." But if they are at the forefront of the current or recently past development and are to recognize that something completely different is now happening, then the danger lies in their complacency, in thinking they can continue to get by for a few more months and years, saying: "It still works, it still works," and one day realizing that something else is already happening around them.

Sometimes I worry a bit that we, because we are somewhat resistant to the new, also become a bit ignorant of what is happening elsewhere. That would be quite fatal.

For example, if one looks at the health card and all those who already have much digitalization in healthcare, saying: "Who knows if that is secure, we are quite safe with our things," one day one wakes up, and it is suddenly not just little Estonia that can do it better, but then it is also Denmark, and perhaps one day it will also be BRICS countries.

If you travel around the world today and ask who struggles with electronic signatures as much as the Federal Republic of Germany does, you won't find many countries. A few haven't even started, others can do it, but to spend years on it and then put it on hold for three years to consider whether we can really do it is rare.

We must – and this will be a central part of our work and also our program for the next legislative period – as a state first implement digitalization as a change in our interaction between institutions and citizens. We have made a groundbreaking step in connection with the federal-state financial negotiations. We have inspired the states to agree that we need a common access for every citizen to their state. This must then, of course, also be extended to the municipalities. This means that the citizen does not have to worry about whether it is a municipal, state, or federal responsibility; rather, the citizen registers and gains access to all conceivable services. Implementing this will be the task of the next four years. For this, we must also find the right balance between security and digital possibilities. But we should orient ourselves towards those who are truly the most efficient in the world. I predict to you: This will still be a significant amount of work.

However, if we do this and if it becomes a matter of course, then perhaps we will also be able to speak with even more insight with others; in industry, in science, in research, and with start-ups, to truly embark on these new paths. We have set a proper focus on this in this legislative period with the Digital Agenda.

We have developed a common platform within which Industry 4.0 can be developed from large companies down to medium-sized enterprises. We are doing quite well, also together with the United States of America, when it comes to addressing the standards in this area. The fact that Industry 4.0 has a lot to do with the Internet of Things and the digitalization of production processes has not only been recognized by large companies, but it has also gradually become clear in the medium-sized sector that the entire manufacturing chain and much more is changing, such as that developments are first digitally simulated before they are then replicated in reality. There are many, many good examples of this.

Where I always have a bit of concern, and some may have heard this from me before, is the question: Is it also clear that not only the production chain is changing, but that above all the relationship between the producer and their customer is changing dramatically? The real point is that the customer will formulate their wishes completely individually through the possibilities of digitalization in the future, and the producer must respond to that. Whoever has the customer-producer relationship in hand, whoever leads the pen, will be the one who retains the maximum value creation, thus holding the profit in their hands and controlling the processes. Therefore, at the moment, in my firm conviction, there is a race going on between those who produce – and we are strong in that – and those who have a better grip on customer relationships, the so-called consumer-oriented internet access. The focus is more in Asia and the United States of America than it is already here with us.

However, through the merging of both areas, production and customer relationships, as well as through the digitalization of production, we have another interface where we can dock and where we can fully contribute our capabilities. We must utilize this interface, and we must use it in such a way that we not only change our production process but also our customer-producer process.

Start-ups must be brought together with our traditional economy in a clever way. We need to get this right. For this, we need the start-ups, the many that provide us with applications and show us what can be done with the large amounts of data available today from the many different customers. We should not wait for the traditional industrial producer to find their start-up; rather, perhaps we should also set incentives from the government side for this.

We need to look at whether we can set a focus when we do tax research funding, so that they can couple together, meaning that one is rewarded for collaborating with start-ups. Because this finding process, who needs whom, must not be too one-sided and also not too slow. Rather, both sides must mutually inspire each other. For example, we see in Israel how wonderfully this works.

Now, I am talking about many things that depend on the prerequisite that one can actually utilize IT capabilities and the possibilities of digitalization. This means one must somehow have reception, and one must somehow have a broadband connection. We aim for every household to have internet available at a speed of 50 megabits per second. With that, one can calmly watch their videos and do this and that. But with that, one does not have the Internet of Things, nor autonomous driving, nor telemedicine, nor real-time transmission of other data. This means that 5G or real-time transmission is necessary. Expanding fiber optics and rolling out the 5G standard – that is what we must do.

This quickly leads us to the point that we must not only do this in Germany, but we must do it in Europe in order to benefit from the advantages of the common market in the form of a digital internal market.

We must also introduce the corresponding regulatory framework. The General Data Protection Regulation is now in place. Following the ECJ ruling, we are currently discussing the Telemedia Act regarding how to gain access to free Wi-Fi. I would say: This is not Industry 4.0, but a new edition 2.0 between legal politicians and interior politicians on one side and internet politicians on the other side, about how we should proceed best.

This raises the question each time: How open do we want to be, and how risk-averse must we be? I could imagine that if we do it cleverly in the European Union, we could find a sui generis regulation, so that not everything can be collected and stacked arbitrarily, at least that the citizen is informed.

All of this brings us to the point of education. The Federal Minister of Education has just presented many good ideas regarding schools. We are sometimes astonished that our good ideas do not find much resonance with the states. But I think we must see that teachers also need to be educated, as they are growing into this development just as we as politicians are. We need the infrastructure. We need educational content. The federal government can be helpful in this. We will approach this with interest in the next legislative period.

We will experience dramatic changes in mobility. When autonomous driving was discussed two or three years ago, there was always a quiet laugh at CDU meetings. Today, the laughter has diminished. People no longer dare to say it outright, but most think they will not experience it. Here in this hall, it is different. But when the average age of the members of a party is over 60 years, one has to grapple with the phenomenon. This is perhaps particularly significant for the older generation. Perhaps there are opportunities that we do not yet see today.

The entire mobility chain will change. I do not want to present all of this here. Our car manufacturers invested almost 22 billion euros in research and development in this country in 2015. A lot is happening, because the automotive industry, which is truly a pillar of our economic prosperity, is fundamentally facing three – as they say – disruptive developments: The drive technologies will likely be new, the question of autonomous driving, meaning the digitalization in the car, will come, and also the question of whether I actually still need to own a car or whether I can behave differently regarding ownership. This will first show in urban areas. It will come later in rural areas, that is clear. But in urban areas, we are already seeing it.

All three developments are interconnected, because the more one can drive autonomously, the less important the drive technologies become. Then the value of acceleration from 0 to 100 is not as significant anymore. Although the electric motor enthusiasts would probably argue that it works well there too. In any case, things are changing rapidly. We must respond to this, from vocational training to work organization to understanding what parking infrastructure we need or what offerings we need for public transport.

This brings us to what I heard from my Japanese colleague at CeBIT, that Japan is thinking about Society 5.0. This leads us to the questions: What does this mean for our social relationships? How does it affect working hours? What is it like with availability when working in start-ups? But what about the desire to own property? What about classic collective agreements when all bus drivers now switch to smaller units and we organize much more individually tailored transport? What does this mean for the self-esteem of bus drivers? What can we promise them in terms of stability?

I see many opportunities. We must not always discuss it as if all jobs are disappearing now. I have visited many companies where digitalization has been advanced significantly. They may have somewhat different jobs. But I have not yet found anyone who claimed that the number of jobs had halved. There is also a lot of dramatization being developed.

But much will change, which is why further education is important. I emphasize, given the current situation: Further education should be for those who have work, and not wait until they are unemployed to then debate how long they can be trained and how long they need unemployment benefits.

Lastly, to return to the social aspect: We will be able to do many things that we could not do before. Especially in the health sector, there will be dramatic changes that could have implications deep into the insurance systems and also for extending life expectancy. New ethical questions will arise. We should try to provide answers to these relatively early – and all of this with a consciousness of courage, not so much with the courage of the desperate, but with a well-founded, calm approach to developments that we should embrace openly and that should encourage us to think anew wherever necessary, but also to incorporate all the experience we have and not to overlook any generation.

This also means that we must engage with a completely new group of companies. They are sometimes not organized or organized differently than we know. At least they do not immediately strive for membership in the Federation of German Industries (BDI) and the German Chamber of Industry and Commerce (DIHK). One must deal with new association structures. This is not a criticism. I am just stating that this is observed. They do not even all strive for membership in Bitkom, from which we thought we had found our new harbor. This means we need to establish new contacts and also consider new funding opportunities.

We have struggled for years with the question of better loss offsetting for growing start-ups and better initial financing through venture capital. Europe is still far behind the United States in this regard. So we still have a lot to do that is necessary. But the development of our election program provides us with a very good basis for this, for example.

I hope that as many people as possible will participate intensively in this discussion. Such a discussion does not happen often. We usually only have it during crisis developments. For example, when we had the banking crisis, we constantly had to seek expertise from banks because we ourselves did not know exactly how everything was developing with derivatives and this and that.

Now we are still in a position to prepare some things evolutionarily, to gather expertise, to consider how we can create the legal framework, how we can prevent the formation of monopolies, and also give medium-sized companies a chance in this market. It is important that we do not only have very small companies that are subsequently bought up by the very large ones. Rather, a strength of the German economy has always been our antitrust law, which has also given the medium-sized sector room to breathe. All of this needs to be carefully considered.

In this regard, dear Michael Fuchs, there are, besides important matters such as better consideration of low-value economic goods – I say this explicitly – many other questions to consider in order to shape the future. In this sense, I thank you for your presence and wish us all the best.