Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration of the tenth anniversary of the Federal Network Agency on February 28, 2008, in Bonn:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

28 February 2008 · Celebration of the tenth anniversary of the Federal Network Agency · Bonn, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Federal Network Agency's tenth anniversary celebration on February 28, 2008, in Bonn, marking the regulator's role in liberalizing German public services.
Main themes
Federal Network Agency anniversary, regulation of public services, social market economy, competition policy, telecommunications and postal reform, network industries oversight, market liberalization, regulatory framework, German economic policy, innovation and regulation balance
Duration
~31 min
84th percentile
Words
3,770
84th percentile
Sentences
178
86th percentile
Readability
47
55th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
3.00
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 40%40%
  • Institutional 37%37%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Technological 3%3%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

178 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Dear Mayor,

dear Mr. Kurth,

dear colleagues, some of whom are former colleagues,

dear former Minister of Economics – we were not colleagues back then; the Grand Coalition did not exist yet –, dear colleagues from the German Bundestag, dear employees of the Federal Network Agency, dear guests of this festive assembly!

Congratulations, dear Mr. Kurth, on the tenth anniversary of the Federal Network Agency! Mr. Scheuerle is also here – you are the two who have, so to speak, brought the child out of elementary school. I also congratulate the 2,400 employees. Some of you have shown us today that you not only regulate well but can also make wonderful music. For that, I extend my heartfelt thanks!

I convey these congratulations on behalf of the Federal Minister of Economics, who is opening the International Crafts Fair in Munich at about the same time, but is represented here by Parliamentary State Secretary Schauerte and State Secretary Otremba. I may also exceptionally do this on behalf of the states. – Mr. Rhiel is also here. – The states certainly have a significant share in the regulation. While they are not always completely aligned with the federal line, they are overall well on board in a convoy.

I am glad to be here today not only because I fondly remember the old plenary chamber, dear Ms. Dieckmann, but also because someone is celebrating a birthday today who could almost be called a "hidden champion" in our republic. The Federal Network Agency is an institution with a lot of influence, feared and loved, whose decisions are often longed for or awaited with trepidation and are not always shared by all those affected, and are sometimes controversial. The legal path is open to everyone in Germany. This is used quite extensively.

The Federal Network Agency is an authority that has to work in the daily balance of very different interests and can perform, as I see it, incredibly interesting work. Because you, the employees, you, dear Mr. Kurth, and the vice presidents essentially fill in a piece of the regulatory framework of the social market economy every day in a way – Ms. Dieckmann just hinted at it – that the public services, which were previously firmly in state hands, are now being released into the liberal order of the social market economy. However, this cannot be released without barriers and without accompanying circumstances.

In the cases you mentioned regarding postal services, telecommunications, electricity, gas, and railways, the legislator has always decided to first provide a legal framework, so to speak, in order to subsequently allow for some leeway. However, the legal framework grants very different starting positions to the potential competitors.

You must then ensure, with a certain sensitivity, that what is commonly referred to as justice is enforced in these areas. This is a truly ambitious task and certainly cannot be enforced differently than in an iterative process in which not everyone can be completely satisfied at every moment.

If I may say so, I would say: Overall, this has been reasonably successful. The legislator exercises a certain restraint because he knows he cannot really interfere with you. Because that would then mean "interference." But if things should get really tough, we will of course intervene.

You also have an interesting relationship with the Federal Cartel Office in various areas, which would also require deeper exploration. We are also trying to create a certain order through legal frameworks there.

Through your work, public services are thus released into the liberal order. At the same time, you are the engine or the brake of innovations. This, I believe, describes a very extensive task.

When the regulatory authority for telecommunications and postal services was selflessly established by the then Minister of Posts Bötsch while dissolving his own ministry, there were various forecasts about how long this would be necessary. Some said: After ten years, it will be over. I do not have that impression today. Rather, your field of tasks has expanded. The Minister of Posts dissolved his ministry, as I said. That was something that one could almost only know from the times of German reunification, so a rather charitable act for the common good. But most employees were able to take on another important task as a result.

The social market economy is discussed repeatedly. This year, we will have to talk particularly about it, as June marks the 60th anniversary of the currency reform. This currency reform not only served to introduce new money but was the original impulse of the social and economic order of the Federal Republic of Germany. It coincided with the end of what Ludwig Erhard called "rationing."

One of the essential prerequisites for the functioning of the social market economy is, of course, the regulatory framework for competition. When we sometimes argue today about what this should look like, we need not worry. Personally, I am calmer since I read how contested antitrust law was. It was vehemently denied by the BDI; they did not want it at all because they did not want to oppose the selfless formation of monopolies too much. But Ludwig Erhard always said: Antitrust law is a "consumer protection law." That Germany today has such a prosperous middle class is certainly one of the consequences of Erhard enforcing this antitrust law. The question of how antitrust law should be designed still occupies us today. The legislative achievements of the Federal Ministry of Economics in connection with the changes to antitrust law in the areas of energy supply were also not undisputed.

You must therefore repeatedly find the right measure. The law gives the regulatory authority a certain space. You now indeed have five areas, Mr. Kurth. The tasks have thus increased, not decreased, under your wings. In all these areas, the question arises: What is fair competition? It is clear that there are different ideas about this.

I have actually been very relieved by the expansion of the areas of competence. Mr. Clement, I suspect it was during your time that energy came under the influence of the regulatory authority or, since 2005, the Federal Network Agency. As Minister of the Environment, I always had a dispute with the then Minister of Economics Günter Rexrodt – Fritz Bohl will remember this – about whether the mechanism of self-commitment would be sufficient to ensure adequate competition. I was skeptical – I do not want to dwell on that – but I think you will now keep the energy sector in good hands.

When we talk about public services, we are dealing with areas that affect the life and safety of every individual in our country. We are dealing with areas that involve huge fixed costs and incredibly large investment projects, which of course must be equipped with a certain legal certainty. We have experienced many failures in European countries and globally from too rapid paths to freedom that do not meet the demands of public services. Therefore, this task is indeed enormous.

When former state-owned enterprises are released into the liberal economic order, we also have to deal with requirements for these companies that hardly anyone remembers after ten to fifteen years, but which – as we see when we think of telecommunications and postal services – still bring significant labor law restrictions compared to competitors. Here, as always with employees, it is about people. This must always be taken into account.

We repeatedly have heated discussions, including at the turn of the year – to stay on the topic of postal services; I naturally hope for good cooperation – about the question of the minimum wage. Some had even forgotten that one of the last battles in the federal government at the time of postal privatization was about the fact that postal services have very significant wage components. At that time, the majority of the Bundesrat, represented by the Social Democrats, demanded that no incomparable competition should arise from the question of wages. This was, for example, one of the boundary conditions that no one saw today when it came to competitors.

Since I am on the topic of postal services, I want to say that today, of course, the question of European frameworks also has a significant influence. Deutsche Post AG has prepared for the liberalization of postal markets far more than some European competitors. That we will not achieve liberalization of postal markets in Europe three years ago or even this year, but at best in three years, is again an indication of how boldly Germany has taken this path and how hesitantly other countries are dealing with it. We now have completely different conditions in the European landscape, in the European internal market. There are countries that have gone the liberalization path together with us, and other countries that are still far behind and still have many decisions to make.

Mr. Kurth has already spoken about the telecommunications markets, which have transformed through the establishment of an additional free network, an invisible network, alongside the bound network. What has happened there is, in part, breathtaking. In the entire mobile communications sector, we are doing well in Europe today. This is thanks to one of those present, namely Mr. Schwarz-Schilling, who made fundamental decisions long before the liberalization of the entire telephone market that were pioneering for European success, namely regarding the allocation of frequencies. There was no voluntary allocation where everyone could choose a frequency; rather, efforts were made to align the various interested parties to the same frequencies and thus enable international communication. We could see with the Americans what difficulties market development can be associated with when this does not happen at a certain time.

I find it fascinating how regulatory decisions can either drive or hinder innovation. The fact that this decision, for example, was made at the time of German reunification or rather shortly before the fall of the Wall shows that one must always remember that fundamental decisions are often made ten years before the technology visibly breaks through for everyone. Conversely, wrong or unmade decisions can lead to a lack of innovative power for decades. When it comes to energy – I will come back to this shortly – we must therefore be careful not to make decisions in Germany that set us back rather than move us forward.

As for landline phone calls, the prices – just to reiterate – have fallen in the past ten years from an average of 31 cents to one cent for domestic calls and from 73 cents to also about one cent for long-distance calls to the USA. This development did not always proceed entirely voluntarily, Mr. Kurth; I believe you and Mr. Scheuerle had a hand in it. There has also been much debate about whether this is fair. The "last mile" will long remain in our memory in various respects.

Today, we have similar discussions regarding broadband connections: Who invests and where does he invest? For example, the route between Cologne and Düsseldorf is relatively sought after, but in my area, between Stralsund and Rügen, the circle of providers is smaller. We received wonderful fiber optic cables when the money for German reunification was still flowing well. However, laying copper lines to the connections of interested parties in sparsely populated areas today is a difficult matter. Therefore, I believe it is right that the European Commission says: Let us create competitive advantages for those who invest, for example, in rural areas. We need such decisions in the future as well, because that is the essence of public services. If we do not want to give that up and if we want to give rural areas a good opportunity for development, then this must always be kept in mind. We need a as uniform and harmonious development as possible. That is certainly the expectation of the citizens. One must also occasionally point out that 50 percent of the people in Germany still do not live in cities but in rural areas.

Incredible numbers of jobs have been created. Competitors in the telecommunications sector, for example, have created more than 50,000 new jobs. We often tend to value the jobs that are lost more than those that are newly created. Therefore, we should always keep in mind that this industry is a huge employment engine that will continue to develop well.

There is another static way of thinking that does not move us forward, and I would like to remind you of it here. It is often said: A letter that is written must be transported, and the relatives who have been called must continue to be called, so it does not really matter whether this is enabled by the former monopolist or the current competitor. This way of thinking is static and completely ignores that more competition also leads to a broader range of offerings and more imaginative offers, that new markets develop from competition, and that people behave differently in the area of new offerings. Therefore, I always advocate for dynamic thinking and not for thinking that is fixed to the present time.

We are constantly faced with the question: What is the European Commission, the European level, doing in our painstakingly liberalized telecommunications market? There is, of course, an inherent force in the European internal markets to consider: Does everything still need to be regulated nationally, or do we also need to centralize this at the European level? I believe that where very different markets have developed and where there are also different legal conditions, we should avoid unnecessary centralization. Therefore, the federal government does not advocate for the establishment of a European regulatory authority, but rather for the ability to regulate many things sensibly and decentrally. – Mr. Kurth's expression shows me that he is somewhat satisfied with this statement.

We certainly need the group of European regulators and an exchange within this group. But when it comes to the veto rights of the Commission that are to be expanded, we will assert our influence during the revision of the European Telecommunications Directive. However, we must know that decisions in Europe are increasingly made by majority votes. In this respect, we also need allies time and again.

Now I come to the energy internal market as another area. Here too, we are dealing with a multitude of European regulations and a manageable number of providers, some of whom are present today – which we are of course pleased about – as well as with an industry that will be of eminent importance for the economic location of Germany in the future.

Here too, we will have to make fundamental decisions. Because the question arises: Is it sufficient if energy is generated somewhere in Europe, and the economic location of Germany only ensures that the electron somehow reaches German soil, or do we have the ambition to remain an energy generation location with a reasonable energy mix and thus also a certain resilience to crises and changes on a global scale? I strongly advocate that we should be able to generate our energy based on a reasonable energy mix fundamentally for ourselves.

However, since decision-making processes are long-term and lengthy, the overall discussion at the moment is not particularly encouraging. I have to say it like that. I say this not because Mr. Clement is here. I would have said it even if you were not here. There are indeed very strange ideas about how to take climate protection into account. I am somewhat astonished – I am currently experiencing this in my closest home in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern – how coal-fired power plants have suddenly become a symbol in that one can only be climate-friendly if one does not see a coal-fired power plant in one's immediate vicinity.

The German coal-fired power plants are the most modern, the German coal-fired power plants are the most environmentally friendly. Our entire thinking and striving must be directed towards ensuring that as many people from China and India as possible can see German coal-fired power plants so that they can build many of them in their own countries, because then we would have already done a lot for climate protection.

Now, as a federal government, we also have to engage in Brussels on the question: What about generation and the grid? This is a highly exciting question, regardless of whether we are talking about trains on the railway or about electricity transmission through networks. The discussion is free and open, and it is always surprising, as we could hear again in the last hours. However, this will not deter us from continuing to pursue our current line in Brussels. We believe that forced sales of the networks are not a guarantee for competition. There must be transparency. Otherwise, everyone must decide how they see fit.

However, electricity generation without proper networks is of course also a foolish thing, because then the electricity does not get from the producer to the customer. The producer who believes he can achieve good customer loyalty without caring about the networks may experience a rude awakening when the generated electricity no longer reaches the customer. We also see in other countries that the care for the networks is something that will occupy us greatly.

With the massive expansion of renewable energies, completely new tasks are of course arising for the networks. With the German Electricity Feed-in Act, the Renewable Energy Sources Act, the obligation to feed in is also an obligation to build networks. If suddenly all producers have no interest in the network, then the state would have to reconsider what guarantees it can create to ensure that functioning networks still exist. But, Mr. Großmann, I hope you are pleased not only with the generation of electricity but also with functioning networks.

I believe that, on balance, it was indeed correct that the Federal Minister of Economics, in the area of energy, to strengthen competition in the electricity market, did not strengthen the regulatory authority this time, but rather revised the antitrust law. Here too, we will look again: Does this bring something, will this bring something? We must ensure that in the electricity market, alongside the regulatory authority, there are also transparent electricity exchanges and not too many effects from the actions of those who are essentially only playing with virtual quantities. However, this leads us into the financial markets. You do not regulate those yet, so we do not need to deal with that on the tenth anniversary of your authority.

Now I come to the most complicated, because politically currently the most sensitive area. I do not want to ruin anything with my birthday speech here, because we still have tasks to complete with the railway. I just want to say this much: Both at the Post and at the Railway, we are approaching a growing area that will gain importance in the coming years – that is logistics. Here, we as political actors will also have to learn a complete rethink. Customers around the world are no longer interested in whether something is transported by train, by ship, by airplane, or in any other way from A to B. What matters now is: Who can deliver a good from A to B in a short time at an affordable price?

In this competition, in this task, stands our Deutsche Bahn AG. We have also transformed the railway into a public limited company, but we have not yet completed the last steps and must now consider these steps very carefully. We believe that the network should remain 100 percent in state ownership. However, after this still somewhat generally and consensually established finding, the difficulties already begin regarding how we should proceed. I have the impression that creative thinking from the railway and many other stakeholders could open up paths for us to take another step towards more privatization and more competition.

However, I say: All those who think that nothing needs to be done and that one can remain at the status quo would, if that were to happen, experience that the railway would soon return to the federal government and ask what financial resources it could receive from the federal budget to actually fulfill what it is supposed to and must do here in the country. I would like to avoid this state. The general conditions are such that the railway must also face innovation.

At this point, I just want to remind you: The trade unions and the employees of the railway have engaged in the process of opening up to competition. One can say that this is not sufficient and that it is still not perfect, but not only the management but also the employees have approached this process with a really good attitude. We should not disappoint them, because the right moment will not come again so quickly, and some things could perhaps be much more difficult if we do not take advantage of it now. The initiated know what I am talking about. I do not want to go further today because I neither want to let the celebration end in sadness nor want to politically destroy anything.

I believe, dear Mr. Kurth, you have always had ambitious politicians by your side, sometimes also receiving unsolicited advice, you have always had company heads from various sectors – so to speak, the old providers and the new providers – not always in harmonious accord by your side, and you have found attentive parliamentary support for your work. For this, I would like to extend a heartfelt thank you to the members of the Bundestag present. I know of some whose hearts beat for the competitor and of some whose hearts beat for the former state-owned enterprise. But in the mix, an incredible expansion of the discussion has emerged in the German Bundestag. Since we are in the old German Bundestag today, I want to tell you that I believe this support will also do you good in the future.

This means, dear Mr. Kurth, it looks like the network agency will have plenty to do in the next ten years. I wish you and the employees all the best on this path! What you do every day – even if it may sometimes only concern small details in the larger context – is a very exciting activity. From your decisions, from each individual decision, a lot can depend. Therefore: The fewer court proceedings and the more good decisions, the better for all of us.

All the best and thank you very much!