Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW) on December 16, 2008, in Mannheim:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 December 2008 · Speech at the Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW) · Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW), Mannheim, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Centre for European Economic Research (ZEW) in Mannheim on December 16, 2008, discussing Germany's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Global financial crisis response, economic stimulus measures, Germany's economic resilience, coordinated international action, structural reforms, employment and labor market, export-oriented economy, demographic change, European economic coordination, growth forecasts and uncertainty, fiscal policy
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,585
89th percentile
Sentences
200
89th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.09
59th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 74%74%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

200 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Dear Professor Franz,

dear Minister Frankenberg,

dear Chairman of the Supervisory Board,

dear guests, who are present in large numbers,

I am very pleased to be here in Mannheim today – we have been talking about this for a long time, Professor Franz –; it is also a thank you for the work of the ZEW and for your work on the Council of Economic Experts.

Of course, Mannheim is also a place of high scientific competence, as is all of Baden-Württemberg. That is clear. However, I was recently startled when I was at the CDU party conference. When I named all the elite universities there and attributed them to Baden-Württemberg, there was a loud outcry: Everything is in Baden. I then had to tell the people from Baden that they do not want to give anything to the Swabians. I could not have imagined such a thing beforehand.

But I do not want to delve further into the depths of Baden-Württemberg's state history; rather, I want to say once again: Thank you for allowing me to be here at a time that should be very exciting for the economic sciences. Certainly, generations of dissertations and other works will be written about what we are currently experiencing but have not yet fully lived through. On the other hand, this also means that we are living in a very serious and also very difficult time.

One is inclined to say, with Mark Twain: "Predictions are difficult, especially when they concern the future." Rarely has this statement been as true as it is at the moment. We are experiencing a constant change in growth forecasts for the next year and also for the medium-term future. I believe this is in the nature of the matter because the mathematical foundations on which one describes it probably start from relatively stable cycles, and one simply has no empirical and theoretical experience with rather shock-like conditions.

In this respect, I believe we should follow Professor Zimmermann, who says that we should not unsettle people every day with forecasts whose error margins cannot even be properly described. We simply have to look as an export-oriented nation at how the situation presents itself for us. We can say: Germany is better prepared for a crisis than it was a few years ago. We have carried out a number of structural reforms. Companies have positioned themselves very well. Workers have, for years, supported a moderate wage policy. The employment rate is high. With just over 40 million employees, the number of people in employment is the highest we have ever had in Germany. The number of employees subject to social security contributions is high. In the next decade, we will enter a phase in which we know that demographic change will become increasingly noticeable, which will make our skilled labor force incredibly important for the future of Germany. We should not lose sight of this in the current situation.

There are a multitude of recommendations regarding what politics can do and should do. These recommendations are always given under the premise – I completely agree with Professor Franz on this – that political action cannot completely compensate for cyclical effects. One can counteract, one can try to counteract sensibly, one should try to counteract at the right time. But in a global crisis, which we have, we learn that action should also be coordinated as globally as possible.

This was for us in the federal government and also for me personally a reason to say: Let us begin with a first package of measures after the acute international financial market crisis and the relatively coordinated response that we – especially in the European context – have found, but then, especially with regard to the upcoming presidential transition in the United States at the beginning of next year, think again about coordinated responses.

Furthermore, the course of the crisis in the individual European member states presents itself very differently depending on their industrial base and orientation, so that despite all coordinated action, the measures can and must differ from country to country within a certain range. Germany, for example, does not have a real estate crisis in the sense that we see it to some extent in the United Kingdom; nor do we have a "construction bubble" like the one we have seen in Spain. These are points on which we do not have to react to the same extent as others. With the American programs that are currently effective, one must see that they are ultimately a reaction to debt and do not even set positive economic impulses, but are supposed to compensate for, for example, credit card debts and real estate debts.

We are clear that it is right to implement measures that are forward-looking and have a quick effect. That is why our first package of measures was designed to try to set impulses as specifically as possible for each sector while also providing relief in the area of additional wage costs and through increases in child benefits and allowances, so that the corresponding volumes are available for consumption.

We can discuss for a long time, for example, about a declining depreciation and about relief in vehicle tax, which are indeed specifically oriented to sectors, or about a craftsman bonus. In the first package of measures, an attempt was made to provide what the respective sectors deemed most sensible as a stimulus – partly also calculating that economic policy, as we know from Ludwig Erhard, always has a 50 percent share of psychology.

We know that this alone may not be enough. That is why the federal government will also act again in January. I want to say about this package of measures that it is one that can certainly hold its own in Europe and on a European scale. It is not the case that other countries have done significantly more. Some have done something different. Spain has acted more strongly but has also recorded completely different sales declines. Other countries have reacted similarly, comparably, or in some cases not at all, so that the European program that we adopted at the European Council on Friday is, so to speak, a canopy, a roof under which the individual member states still have to fulfill their tasks.

At this point, I want to say that we should first think about things that can be done without spending money. For example, we discussed at the European Council that it is not enough for us to all put money into infrastructure projects, but that the time frames in which we can actually use the money are so long that it does not provide the necessary impulse for economic policy.

As member states, which is not always easy, we have been able to convince the Commission that, first, the so-called de minimis rules should be raised. Today, states or the federal government can provide grants of up to 200,000 euros. If the grants exceed this amount, it is subject to state aid and must first be accepted by the Commission. We have now said: Let us raise this limit from 200,000 euros to 500,000 euros for two years, so that quicker action is possible, especially at the municipal and state level. This was a request from the prime ministers. I am glad that we have succeeded in this together.

Secondly, we have achieved that the tendering processes in Europe will be accelerated. We know that contracts must be tendered for amounts starting at five million euros. From that point on, there is a tendering period of 87 days. This will now, also for a limited time, be shortened to 30 days. We would have liked – and I will keep pushing for this – for the tendering threshold, that is, the amount above which a tender must be issued, for example for schools and municipal buildings, to be raised from five million euros to ten million euros. We have not yet succeeded in this, but I am optimistic.

So it is not always a question of the billions we put into our hands, but especially in Europe and Germany, the question also arises whether one can actually do something with the billion that one potentially has. I believe that placing value on this is at least as important as the amount of our budgetary allocations.

In what still needs to be done, we must consider the situation we find ourselves in. It is clear that in the infrastructure sector, everything that can be done quickly should be done. I have told the Federal Minister of Transport, who already has a higher planning budget for road, rail, and waterway construction for next year than was originally planned, that we should look at all projects that are planned and ready for tender and then try to provide the necessary funds for them. I have asked the prime ministers, with whom we will meet next Thursday, to show us what they consider to be ready for tender, which only needs to be tendered – hopefully with a shortened tendering period. Then we could get started in early spring and really tackle things.

I think that in this respect, several billion will come together, but I also tell you that I am somewhat astonished by the hundreds of billions in America that are supposedly ready to be spent immediately. I need to take a look at that. Whether they have no planning law at all or whether one can build a bridge in mid-air, I do not know. But I suspect that the money will not flow there within two, three, or four months either.

In addition, we are considering – this will please Mr. Frankenberg – whether we can also accelerate the research projects at universities that are supported by the federal government and bring some of them forward. Furthermore, we want to forge a pact with the states and municipalities to be able to set smaller contracts, for example for the renovation of schools, in motion more quickly, in order to really achieve something for the future viability of our country. This must always be our benchmark, from the street to the research institution to the municipal facility.

However, it is not so easy to forge a pact between the federal government, states, and municipalities, because we have just established in the federalism reform that the federal government has almost nothing to do with the municipalities. This means that we also have to find a constitutionally permissible way here. But I believe that, especially to show people that something is happening in such a time that has to do with the future of our country, this is very important.

The entire area of building renovation for the purpose of thermal insulation and more economical energy consumption as a contribution to climate protection is also very good and important. In this respect, I think we will also make progress. We would basically need to create something here that might be possible under the pressure situation we are in: We would need to change the tenancy law so that there are better incentives for landlords to renovate their housing stock. This means nothing other than that the reductions in ancillary costs must also be taken into account when allocating them to the cold rent. Anyone who has ever dealt with the concerns of landlords and tenants and their representatives knows that this is naturally a difficult undertaking in Germany. However, it would unleash incredible incentives across the entire private housing stock to really do something for the future.

The area of broadband connections in rural areas is very close to my heart. The Federal Republic is already very well equipped with broadband connections in urban centers. But the incentives for rural areas are lacking to really provide everyone with a fast internet connection. In five or ten years, there are fears of tremendous structural disadvantages in rural areas; some of these already exist today. For reasonable marketing, you need a broadband internet connection these days. If all those who live relatively isolated in sparsely populated areas do not have this, it will bring structural disadvantages. This means for us that we need to find investors who are willing to make investments that may seem unprofitable at first glance, and that these – I also included a half-sentence in the conclusions at the European Council, which I am very proud of – must receive better usage conditions for a certain initial period before full competition takes effect. This is not needed in urban areas. It is clear that competition can work immediately there. But if one or two investment-strong providers in Germany – primarily Telekom and Vodafone – are willing to equip the entire country with these connections, then they must also be given preferential access for a few years so that their investment is worthwhile.

Since regional politicians are present, I would like to mention in this context the beautiful term of the digital dividend. Due to the changes in the television sector, frequencies are available from our perspective, but those who own them do not want to give them up. Only the states are capable of taking these television frequencies from the public broadcasting institutions and allocating them to telecommunications. Because in sparsely populated areas, one cannot dig up everything for a ground connection and lay cables; rather, one must also do a lot over the air and through frequencies.

If we were to take all of this together – this also has a lot to do with creating the appropriate regulatory framework – then incentives for private investments could arise, for which no state funds and support pots would need to be utilized. The Commission wanted to make 500 million euros or even one billion euros available for broadband connections. I said: That is not our biggest problem. Our biggest problem is rather that we need a regulation that makes investing worthwhile.

Therefore, my plea is to not forget market-based incentives even in times of crisis and not to believe that those who do a lot with state funds on credit have done the right thing. However, that does not mean that one should not also use state funds – see infrastructure.

Now, of course, we have the big problem ahead of us that our export-oriented economy depends on not only the willingness to consume in Germany but also on orders coming from abroad. Therefore, we now have to ask ourselves: What bridges can we build over the year 2009 – for the time being, I have this year in mind; then we must look further at how the general economic situation develops – to give employees a perspective in the companies?

The federal government has extended the duration of short-time work benefits to 18 months in the first package of measures. That was, let’s say, a political act intended to symbolically convey the message to companies: We have an interest in ensuring that employees, wherever possible, remain in the company. However, we know that almost no one can be on short-time work for 18 months, that no entrepreneur can pay social security contributions for that long. Therefore, we must consider together at this point – as, for example, in the discussion with representatives of business, trade unions, and economic institutes on Sunday: How can we build this bridge so that it can also be accepted by the companies?

On the one hand, one can provide guarantees for a certain part of the social security contributions – through the state development banks or through the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau. On the other hand, one can consider whether the government itself should take over part of the social security contributions.

Mr. Leibinger from the company Trumpf gave us a tip that I gladly picked up. He said: Do something in terms of qualification. It is very important that we do not just let employees go on short-time work during this time, but that we do everything to make them fitter for the future. We have also made considerations in this area together with the Federal Employment Agency.

I believe that together we can create a lot of tailored solutions. Therefore, I was pleased, even though I know that this is certainly not the answer to the question of employment, that some DAX companies have said: We will not issue any layoffs for operational reasons in 2009. I know that not every medium-sized company can simply promise that. But it is a symbol; those who can, try it. It is also a message to the suppliers, for example from Siemens, when Siemens can say: We will not lay off our skilled workers for operational reasons. Such companies have a vested interest in ensuring that the supply chain does not crumble and is not destroyed, only to be painstakingly rebuilt.

In conclusion, I want to mention two things that we should not overlook, especially when we compare ourselves with the United States of America.

First, the President of the European Central Bank pointed out something to us. All European member states say: We let the automatic stabilizers work. However, that means something completely different in Europe than in the United States of America. Because for us, it means that we do not cut pension payments, unemployment benefits, or health insurance payments. We have a pension system that is not largely based on capital. The President of the European Central Bank, Jean-Claude Trichet, told us: This would create a stimulus of over two percent for gross domestic product compared to if we were to adjust all social security systems to the extent that tax revenues decline. One must not forget this when discussing consumption stimuli that are being provided.

The second thing I want to mention is: After we have followed with concern the inflationary effects of rising raw material and food prices in the summer, a completely different situation has now arisen within six months – falling energy prices, falling raw material prices, thus naturally counter-inflationary tendencies and, of course, important signals for general consumption. Even if prices may not remain as low as they are now, this is a situation that consumers can handle much better than the situation that existed last summer.

Personally, I am not a fan of consumption vouchers. I want to make that very clear. I believe they are not particularly suited for the German situation. When looking at the American population, they have completely different repercussions, also with regard to social security payments and in terms of credit card debts and due payments for home purchases. In this respect, we do live in a different environment.

But with all the measures mentioned and everything that is being discussed, there is a great deal of uncertainty regarding the question: What is the nature of this crisis? One can say: This crisis was triggered by a crisis in the international financial markets. It is certainly undisputed that behind this international financial market crisis, so to speak, in the waning economic cycle, a structural change in certain sectors was already visible. There are many people who say: The automobile production in the world was certainly not too low. The crisis thus already had structural elements. However, it also has this eruptive character of the international financial market crisis. Now the exciting question is: How did this come about and what is behind it?

I believe that it could also have come about because, ultimately, countries – primarily the industrialized countries and especially the United States of America – have lived beyond their means. This means that, so to speak, they have stimulated the standard of living and growth with a shift to the future. The question now is: Is this crisis one of the financial markets, and is everything back to normal when the financial markets are back to normal? Or does the fact that we have lived somewhat beyond our means not also have a structural effect that makes banks and financial institutions cautious and leads them to ask: Where do we ultimately end up? This is also one of the reasons why I am relatively cautious about the question of how much debt one should actually use to combat a crisis that is also related to high debt in the past and living beyond one’s means.

Now, one cannot return to the path of order one hundred percent at the moment of crisis. But one must keep in mind that, as after September 11, 2001, in the United States of America, where efforts were made to keep growth going, one does not neglect to return to the path of virtue, but that one has this line in mind today, as we return to a reasonable path after the crisis, to prevent further such crises that we could then experience in the coming years with astonishment and increasing intensity. This must be avoided.

Therefore, it is right and important that we discussed at the G20 meeting which risky instruments of the financial markets need to be better regulated and made more transparent. But this alone will not be enough if there is not also a commitment behind it – I have called it the commitment of the Swabian housewife – that one cannot spend more than one earns. I believe that the world as a whole must come to this path if it wants to avoid these huge imbalances. Moreover, this applies not only to the money spent but also to the raw materials consumed, to the natural resources utilized. Essentially, we have the same effects from climate protection to the handling of raw materials to the management of finances, so we must learn how globalization can be designed sustainably, durably, and sensibly.

For this very reason, work on the transparency and regulation of financial markets must continue. For this very reason, I believe that we need certain basic lines for the world economy, similar to what we already have in the European internal market. Therefore, I have spoken of a World Economic Council, analogous to the UN Security Council. This does not mean that it is a form of government, but it means that one agrees on certain global standards that must be adhered to by all countries within certain ranges. Otherwise, there will always be attempts for the risk-taking of one to lead to the full realization of opportunities, ultimately resulting in the distribution of risks across the entire world. The world will not tolerate that too often. For this very reason, I think that alongside national efforts and a coherent European response, Europe’s voice is also needed to present a unified front globally and to demand the corresponding measures.

A final word on the situation of the financial markets. With our Financial Market Stabilization Act, we have shown how quickly we can act when necessary. That was a real feat for all constitutional bodies. It has also shown what stability and positive will exist in our political institutions. We have ensured that the landscape of banks and financial institutions does not fall into a meltdown, but we have not yet restored the functionality of the financial institutions. Our meeting on Sunday, which also included actors from the financial markets, made it very clear once again: The mere implementation of the Financial Market Stabilization Act will not be able to restore full functionality because global trust is severely disturbed, because, as we now see in the case of Mr. Madoff, risks lurk and linger that are difficult to foresee, and therefore this trust will only be restored when all actors in the capital markets regain trust.

We have now essentially addressed the banks, the savings banks, and the cooperative banks. But there are also hedge funds, there is private equity. We have wide capital markets through which many financings have occurred; not everything has gone through banks in recent years. This means that these parts are currently non-functional. They cannot be restructured or guaranteed by the state; that would overwhelm everything. Only when the capital markets develop again in a direction that establishes trust will lending also get back on track. The concern I have, also based on the analysis we have been given, is that potential growth effects in the real economy may also be absent in areas that are not particularly affected by the crisis but cannot be served with loans, and that thus another tightening of the economic crisis may occur because the financial markets do not fulfill their function as they should. The credit volumes are constant; they are partly constant because credit lines from regular customers are always extended. But if someone comes and says: I have a new idea, I have a long-term project that takes longer than three years, then it is almost impossible today to get a loan for this without state guarantees. That is the difficulty that cannot be blamed on a single bank because the liquidity available in the markets for long-term projects is simply very scarce.

This brings us to a point that we must once again consider from a governmental perspective. Germany and many states still have an excellent credit rating. We are rated "AAA." If anyone is to be given something, it should be us first. We just need to be careful not to guarantee too much and withdraw so much liquidity from the markets that those who are rated only slightly lower can no longer access liquidity, thereby solidifying state action to the extent that nothing functions without it. Finding a reasonable way to act as a state, while not replacing the markets, will be one of the most important tasks in the coming months.

From a cyclical perspective, it does not matter whether Deutsche Telekom is able to lay broadband networks – I initially spoke about regulation; now I am talking about borrowing – or whether the state does this with its resources. If Deutsche Telekom is structurally capable of doing so, we must ensure that long-term projects can indeed receive financing.

With that, I have actually described the scenario of the political tasks: as a state, to pay attention, to protect, but not to replace, in order not to destroy the economic dynamism that will eventually sprout again like a seedling. In this sense, we think and consult, and we believe that if it is sufficient in America to implement a large program when the new president takes office, then it will also be right in Germany to launch a second program around the same time, which is well thought out in its facets and for which we will also advocate in Europe. In this sense, the federal government is working.

I am pleased that I saw on Sunday that there is a great willingness from the economy, the trade unions, the financial market participants, and also from those who accompany us with their scientific advice, to see this task as one in which we must jointly take responsibility. Politics can – as we have shown – intervene at specific points in a crisis. But politics certainly cannot lead a system of social market economy through a crisis alone. Therefore, I am grateful to everyone who contributes constructively. The situation is such that there is no universal recipe, but it is our task to show people a good way forward. We are ready for that. Thank you very much for allowing me to present this to you here.