Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the celebration "60 Years of Human Rights" by Amnesty International and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation on December 10, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 December 2008 · 60 Years of Human Rights celebration by Amnesty International and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed a joint celebration by Amnesty International and the Friedrich Ebert Foundation marking 60 years of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights on December 10, 2008, in Berlin.
Main themes
Universal Declaration of Human Rights 60th anniversary, human dignity and human rights protection, German reunification and Cold War memory, values-based foreign policy, freedom of expression, human rights universality, economic interests vs. human rights, Amnesty International, Basic Law of Germany, courage in human rights advocacy
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,733
72nd percentile
Sentences
130
75th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.07
57th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 33%33%
  • Social 27%27%
  • Institutional 26%26%
  • Ceremonial 9%9%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

130 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Ms. Fuchs,

dear Ms. Lochbihler,

Mr. Federal Minister, Mr. Vice Chancellor, dear Mr. Steinmeier,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to accept the invitation to this joint conference of the Friedrich Ebert Foundation and Amnesty International, and this is not my first time at the Friedrich Ebert Foundation. Perhaps we can agree on this, Mr. Steinmeier: Whenever you visit the KAS, I will come to the Friedrich Ebert Foundation.

The protection of human rights holds a central place in the policy of the Federal Government – this has already been said several times today. In this context, it is essential to continually remind ourselves that the protection of human dignity and human rights is anything but self-evident.

We should keep in mind that we are celebrating "60 years of human rights" in a city where the wall that divided the city fell just 19 years ago. The question of how we interacted in the former West Germany and the former GDR gives us a small insight into what courage in the fight for human rights means – on one side for those of us who lived in the former GDR. There was no freedom of expression as we understand it today, no freedom of speech, no freedom to travel. One had to struggle over where to say what, how to express oneself. The ability to read between the lines was more developed there than in countries where freedom of expression truly exists.

On the other hand, one can also think about the courage of those who lived in the free, old Federal Republic when it came to bringing a book across the border to the East that someone there wished for. The heart palpitations, the contemplation of how to hide it, the fear of whether the border guard, who was sometimes even worse, would check everywhere – we should not forget all of this in order to grasp how much one must also personally invest to truly advocate for human rights. That is why the wall and barbed wire are for me a clear expression of how valuable, but also how vulnerable, human rights are.

We are in a fortunate situation today, even though we must remain vigilant in our country. We no longer need to bang our heads against the wall that stood against human rights, but can today also direct our gaze to other countries, and we do so.

Today, December 10, reminds us that 60 years ago the United Nations General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights – a step that has unfolded in its international dimension over decades and will continue to do so. Since then, there have been new standards, global standards, indivisible standards. But we also know how much still needs to be done. The news and our knowledge remind us of this every day. Yet since December 10, 1948, there has been a valid and now globally accepted basis for appeal.

The then Secretary-General of the United Nations, Kofi Annan, stated ten years ago regarding the Universal Declaration of Human Rights: "A legacy of human hope at the end of a century of human loss." With this, he wonderfully described what characterized the 20th century. And he also set the task for us in the 21st century.

Under the immediate impression of the horrors of tyranny, National Socialism, and two world wars, the international community found the strength to adopt this human rights declaration in 1948. We can say that our Basic Law is also strongly influenced by this human rights declaration. Article 1, paragraph 1 of our Basic Law states: "The dignity of man is inviolable. To respect and protect it is the duty of all state authority." This means for us that we must not remain silent when it comes to human rights. But I also say very clearly – I believe everyone here in the room knows this: It is not so easy to make this decision accurately every day.

Human dignity is not negotiable. It applies equally to everyone, in all states, cultures, and religions. There is no distinction between important and less important human rights. Therefore, one must not, for example, equate human rights with traditions. For honor killings, for forced marriages, traditions can and must not be an excuse. In concrete discussions, however, the argument is often not entirely simple, as the line between respect for cultures and traditions and human rights is often misused.

Or take the classic case we are often confronted with. Expanding trade relations, securing energy supply, managing the financial crisis – there are a multitude of economic interests and security interests of which we know we can only pursue successfully in cooperation with other states. It is also legitimate and important to pursue them. But I believe it is also right to say in this context that German foreign policy has always been, is, and should remain a values-based foreign policy, namely one that is bound to human rights.

However, there are always tensions in individual cases. Everyone here in the hall knows, for example, that there was a dispute between me and the Federal Foreign Minister regarding the reception of the Dalai Lama. But such disputes will always occur. I believe we should also strive to engage in these discussions. The good thing is that as a Federal Government, we will never allow values and interests to enter into an unacceptable competition with each other, but that we are shaped by the common effort to continually find the right balance. But I also say: We cannot expect that in this search for balance we will be praised and lauded by all non-governmental organizations at every moment. It is rather good that we are sometimes reminded not to seek a simple compromise path too quickly.

I say that it is right that all Federal Chancellors of the Federal Republic of Germany have made the respect for human dignity a common value foundation. I believe that this common foundation also facilitates cooperation with our colleagues in the other member states of the European Union. It creates strength. It creates trust. But it also challenges us, when we sometimes take quite different paths, to stay united within the European Union and to continually find a common solution.

We advocate against torture and the death penalty. Both are neither ethically nor legally justifiable. I believe it was very important that during the 62nd General Assembly of the United Nations, a resolution against the death penalty was passed for the first time. This gives more emphasis to the views and convictions that the protection of human rights is not merely a national task. The issue of the death penalty must also be discussed with all countries and cannot simply be legitimized with regard to traditions or old legal provisions.

I therefore also believe that we must endure the tensions when it comes to what the United Nations Security Council impressively highlighted in the 1990s and which the World Summit in 2005 referred to as the "responsibility to protect."

This is a very complicated topic. On the one hand, the national sovereignty of a state is a high good. Therefore, the quoted sentence from the World Summit must not be understood as a blank check or invitation to intervene from the outside in every case, at any time, and everywhere; that can only ever be the last resort, the ultima ratio. This should, wherever possible, be made legally binding under international law. But we must not exclude this means either; and this also shapes the policy of the Federal Government.

On the other hand, national sovereignty must not serve as an excuse for governments to commit or allow serious human rights violations without hindrance. This was also the message of the World Summit of 2005. We must always keep in mind: The international community must remain vigilant. It relies on the support of regional communities. Therefore, part of our policy is also to support and strengthen these regional communities.

Often, each of us will feel how impatient one can be, for example, when we think of Zimbabwe, when we repeatedly talk with the African Union, when we hear much in small circles and bilaterally that unites us in our assessment, and when we then repeatedly wait for negotiation successes and ask ourselves whether it is right that we wait so long and whether we are doing enough. I believe these dilemmas, these conflicts, these questions will accompany us in the coming years because they are part of the political process.

But it is also part of it to continually strengthen the forces on the ground – that is why I, like the Federal Foreign Minister, rely on such regional organizations. Otherwise, our policy is often understood too quickly as a policy of misunderstanding towards the respective regional peculiarities. To be honest: We should not accept traditions as an excuse for human rights violations, but we should also be willing to learn more about cultures and living conditions in other parts of the world than we know today, in order to gain a piece of respect from that.

But I believe we agree that we must do everything we can to enable a life without the terror of President Mugabe, especially in Zimbabwe – whether through direct action or by encouraging Africans. We must not forget the suffering, the misery, and the plight of countless raped women in the Congo. We must raise our voices against this terrible injustice. We must work closely with our European partners and worldwide to point out such issues early on. But it is not easy to watch as 17,000 UN soldiers are unable to prevent such human rights violations. Therefore, I would also like to thank the Federal Foreign Minister for his significant efforts to ensure that at least a process is now underway in which negotiations are possible. We will do everything we can to be helpful in this regard.

It is, of course, important to seek direct dialogue – publicly and also privately, both in bilateral encounters and with human rights organizations. There is, for example, the rule of law dialogue with China, which has already been mentioned and which I consider extremely important.

However, we must not be deceived by the character of unjust regimes. Inhumane regimes themselves do not place much value on diplomatic approaches. They often test us in our determination. Therefore, we should always try to push the boundaries in this regard. I would also like to thank the Federal Government's Commissioner for Human Rights Policy and Humanitarian Aid, Günter Nooke – Ms. Lochbihler just told me that he is at another event – who tirelessly advocates with his team at the Foreign Office and finds a clear voice.

For a credible and strong commitment to human rights, we have the Human Rights Council within the framework of the United Nations. I say very clearly: It does not always meet its requirements. It tests our patience in many places. Nevertheless, I consider it an important institution. We must learn to work together internationally within it. But one needs – measured against the concrete fates on the ground – a high degree of inner strength in connection with the current text work on the comma and every single formulation to continually give the negotiation processes a chance.

Especially in connection with the Human Rights Council, we have often asked ourselves: Should we withdraw, stop participating? The firm conviction is: Those who withdraw must also re-enter. Because if we are no longer involved, it becomes even easier for others. But I do not want to give the impression that this all happens without any emotion. Nevertheless, it is right that the Federal Republic and the Federal Government repeatedly affirm their commitment to these international institutions, because there is no alternative to them.

In this context, I would also like to mention the International Criminal Court. It is, so to speak, a delayed institutionalization of what is laid down in the Declaration of Human Rights. It is a global institution. Particularly in connection with the financial crisis, we have discussed a great deal internationally about the possibilities, opportunities, and necessity of global institutions. There is widespread distrust, especially among developing and emerging countries, that supposedly global institutions could repeatedly be used to provide a particularly strong forum for economically powerful countries. Therefore, it will be up to us at this point to advocate for these global institutions and to serve them not from a national perspective, but from the perspective of the values for which they were created. This is just as important for the International Criminal Court as it is for other institutions.

It must be made clear that nation-states are also relinquishing a piece of competence and subjecting themselves to the assessment of global institutions. We Europeans do not have the greatest difficulties with this, because we have made this experience for our own benefit after the Second World War. We know that by relinquishing national competences, the European Union grants us economic prosperity, social prosperity, and also political strength. But we should share this experience with others, for example, within the framework of the African Union and other regional alliances.

Of course, we must advocate that heads of government and government members worldwide cannot evade criminal responsibility. This is, in concrete terms, not such a simple matter. For example, one negotiates on one side with Sudan, with the head of government, and on the other side, an indictment is at stake. We are committed to this negotiation process and do not know whether it might not become even more stalled, although it is already proceeding very slowly, and at the same time, we have said yes to the International Criminal Court and cannot then say no at that concrete moment. That is how we have handled it. But I want to say that with such matters, which seem clear, many aspects go through one’s mind.

Thus, there is also an obligation to global action through the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. At the beginning of the 21st century, there is no longer any isolation of the individual regions of the world. We have the technical means for much to come to light, to be dragged into the light. One can no longer simply isolate oneself from the Internet and other means of communication. We have the chance that those who suffer from human rights violations – and that is many – can make their voices heard internationally time and again.

We also know from many examples in the former GDR how important it was for people when they were imprisoned in Bautzen or elsewhere that there were people in free countries who knew about it, who spoke about it, and who never let it be forgotten. When we consider how many fates of a much more difficult nature exist in the world today, it becomes clear that in the free world, everyone is actually needed to advocate for one or two such fates.

We know that we are now entering a time that is also economically more difficult for us. The danger that we will first think of ourselves and say that other matters can perhaps wait a moment is always present. Therefore, I would like to conclude with a heartfelt thank you to Amnesty International, on behalf of so many organizations, and, on behalf of the foundations in our country, also to the Friedrich Ebert Foundation and Anke Fuchs. I want to thank you for always advocating for human rights, whether a topic is at the top of the agenda or threatens to be forgotten, for repeatedly pointing out the wounds, raising awareness, and thereby providing great security to people and families even in the most difficult situations, and on the other hand, for continually reminding and urging political leaders – whether here or elsewhere in the world – to do the right thing.

"60 years of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights" is an occasion to be even bolder, even more determined in case of doubt, but also an occasion to say: The Federal Republic of Germany has a political foundation that allows non-governmental organizations to advocate for human rights, and it has a federal government that makes the effort to take human rights seriously in daily actions.