Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Digital Summit on October 29, 2019, in Dortmund:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

29 October 2019 · Digital Summit · Dortmund, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the annual Digital Summit on October 29, 2019, in Dortmund, speaking on Germany's digital transformation priorities and data sovereignty.
Main themes
Digitalization, data sovereignty, digital infrastructure, artificial intelligence, social market economy in the digital age, worker rights in the digital economy, GDPR and data protection, European digital policy, digital transformation of industry, ethical guidelines for AI, internet anniversary, regional structural change
Duration
~26 min
77th percentile
Words
3,155
77th percentile
Sentences
150
81st percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
10.9
30th percentile
Syntax
3.06
55th percentile
Vocabulary
1.89
3rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 36%35%
  • Economic 23%22%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

150 sentences in 33 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Berg,

dear Mr. Prime Minister – he is probably no longer here, but he was –, dear colleagues from the cabinet, esteemed Madam Vice President-elect, dear Commissioner Vestager, ladies and gentlemen,

I warmly greet you at this year's Digital Summit, this time in Dortmund, and I would also like to extend warm greetings from Peter Altmaier. I have been in contact with him. He needs to take care of himself a bit, but he is doing well so far. We are optimistic that he will be back on deck completely soon.

We are here in Dortmund, in a region that knows change. The Prime Minister has already spoken to you about this today. Once, there were hundreds of thousands of coal miners here; now there are hundreds of thousands of students. So, this region and this city know what change means. And that is why Dortmund is a good location for our Digital Summit this year.

Mr. Berg just spoke of anniversaries: 70 years of the Federal Republic of Germany, 30 years since the fall of the Berlin Wall. I noted today that we are celebrating 50 years of the internet today – at least according to a certain definition of the internet. So, it is clear that what we are dealing with here is not as new as one might sometimes think, but that in its development, entirely new possibilities keep emerging. This is what this year's Digital Summit has also been concerned with.

It is customary for us to engage in the platforms, as they are called – but these are not the platforms we are discussing today; rather, they are working clusters – with the entire range of different topics. It is good that these platforms work throughout the year and continuously advance matters in various areas – from infrastructure to the digitalization of the economy to the learning systems of the working world and also the ethical questions and consumer protection issues. The President of the Federation of German Industries (BDI) recently said: Well, the work between the summits is good, but the summits are actually just show. – I do not know whether I should take that to heart and say: The work of the BDI is good, but I will not come to the anniversary anymore. In any case, I believe that such summits always provide the opportunity to work towards results and then take stock, invigorate discussions, and exchange ideas, in order to then return to work in the sectors.

For us in Europe, it is very important – as the General Data Protection Regulation stands for – that we develop our own approaches regarding the questions of digitalization. In Germany, we would say: We have the social market economy, which must be preserved with its principles and values and at the same time be transformed into the digital world. That is why the term data sovereignty plays such an important role for us. The handling of data, the self-determination of citizens, and the knowledge of citizens and companies about the questions "Where is my data?", "Who is working with my data?", and "Have I given my consent?" – that should be a fundamental theme. Therefore, we can be confident regarding digitalization and say that all the values we have, and all that we have developed with our civil law codes, our competition law, and much more, partly over decades, must also have its effect and justification in the digital world.

Digital life is not an extralegal life, but our fundamental principles must continue to apply and be transferred into the digital world, for example, when it comes to how we develop ethical guidelines for artificial intelligence in the working world. This is yet another new task. But it cannot be that what we have overcome after industrialization, namely that the worker has no rights, suddenly starts all over again with the new technological stage. Rather, we must transfer the value principles from the old stage – what defines humanity and concerns human dignity.

Nevertheless, we must not fall into the delusion that working and living in the digital world only functions like in the analog world. In the analog world, we have physical objects; and once we hand them over for use, they are, so to speak, consumed in a certain way. In the digital world, we have data that we can apply in many ways and share repeatedly without the data disappearing as such. They are rather reusable, from which entirely new qualities of insights arise in networks. We must utilize these possibilities. Therefore, the question of how to handle data naturally concerns both citizens and companies; it affects the relationships between companies, the relationships between the economic sector and the public sector, and also the relationships of companies with their customers. All of this will change; and we need to talk about it.

In order to be satisfactory in this field, as I would say, we naturally need a reasonable data infrastructure. We have achieved quite a bit in Germany, but not nearly enough. We are still not meeting the demands of a highly developed industrial country regarding both the expansion of fixed networks and mobile networks in all areas. Therefore, tomorrow we will adopt key points for a mobile communications strategy in the cabinet and will try to quickly limit the white spots as much as possible, so that there are really only the smallest white spots left, although it is not so easy to provide a country the size of Germany with a high-quality data infrastructure 100 percent. But that is our goal.

We know that we must work very closely together in this federal system. This presents us – both the federal government and the states and municipalities – with some hurdles. Above all, we need to find ways to accelerate. Mr. Berg just mentioned it: There are individual examples with a permit duration of 900 days for a cell tower. That cannot be the standard; it must go faster. We also want to be ready in the public sector to make our areas available – we also want to request this from the states and municipalities – so that we can then expand the digital infrastructure more quickly in these areas.

Of course, our goal is to roll out 5G coverage as widely as possible. Unlike last year, we now have the auction of frequencies. I am pleased to announce to those present from the business sector that the Federal Network Agency will probably publish in a few days how the frequency range reserved for use by companies, agricultural enterprises, small and large companies can be made available. I can also reveal to you: The costs are medium-sized business-friendly, as I was told today. This means that it will be worthwhile for German companies to quickly gain access to 5G.

The question of data management also arises, of course. Mr. Berg just said: Germany cannot do everything. I think we should think as European as possible in the entire area of digitalization. Europe must fundamentally be able to do everything. I do not believe that Europe should define entire areas where we say: We cannot keep up with that. But we cannot do everything at the moment. What concerns me the most is that the management of data – also of economic data, but also of consumer data – lies in very significant areas, for example, with American companies. I have nothing against fair and free competition, but we are getting into dependencies in our value chains that we may not consider right in the long term. Since it may be that whoever has access to the data as such – for example, in business-to-business relations – but also whoever has access to business-to-consumer data, that is, consumer data, is ultimately the one who sits on the biggest chunk of the value chain, it can happen that we become a mere extended workbench in this way or fall into dependencies that I do not necessarily want to fall into.

That is why I see it as a very significant progress – even if there are still many questions – that the Federal Minister of Economics, together with the Federal Minister of Research, has embarked on the path with the GAIA-X project and said: Let us develop a European sovereign data storage structure. This does not mean that all data converge in one place, but it means that there is interoperability between the various data storage options, between the various clouds. I can only encourage everyone to take an interest in this and to declare their readiness. When I then hear "Yes, yes, we are already so far behind," I say: We are behind, and significant financial resources must be invested to achieve storage and then also processing – storage is just the starting point – so also the management of this data, the development of AI algorithms, and the linking to new value creation opportunities. We must, in my firm conviction – or at least we must have this ambition – be able to do this in Europe.

But I also say quite openly: We as a government have thought a lot about this, but we can only advance this project with the interested parties from the economy. If there are no users, then the state cannot work on the offers in such a way that they are really available. We can also make our data available through open data management; then we show that we have trust in such things. Otherwise, it must be driven forward privately; that is completely clear.

We want to do this together with France and also with other European countries. Regardless of other competition law, we fortunately have other funding options in Europe – also in terms of state aid – when it comes to strategically important projects. We are already using these options, for example, in chip manufacturing and battery cells. One could also imagine this for so-called hyperscalers, as they are nicely called, if we once have a running model.

Let me say one more point in this context: We are self-critical of ourselves as a state, but we also have concerns regarding the economy. Mr. Berg just said it himself: Due to the very high utilization time of our companies – especially small and medium-sized enterprises – the phase in which digitalization and also artificial intelligence made a real leap forward has somewhat passed us by; some did not even have time to deal with these questions. We now need to find an intelligent way to network, for example, the work of Bitkom with the work of the Federation of German Industries, the Federal Association of German Employers' Associations, the German Chamber of Industry and Commerce, and the Central Association of German Crafts. We need to utilize the knowledge of the Fraunhofer Society and talk with small and medium-sized enterprises about what is coming their way and what the value creation models of the future are. We must really ask for openness to this. It may well be that a medium-sized company believes it knows its data; that is nice. However, it does not know what it could build together with its neighbors – of course, anonymized – in new value creation chains. If we let this element of value creation slip from our hands, then there will be a rude awakening for the industrial location Germany.

We have a whole range of sectors in which we are strong. This includes, for example, the automotive industry. I believe that if we want to keep this industry modern, we cannot simply say: Well, we will leave autonomous driving to the Americans or the Chinese. Rather, we must have the ambition to be able to do this ourselves, both in battery cell production and in the field of autonomous driving. We have mechanical engineering, we have the chemical industry – and we cannot exclude entire sectors of traditional industry and say: Unfortunately, we cannot keep up there. It must indeed be our ambition to be part of it as well.

What is the point that we, as the state, need to provide now? We can offer you support. We are currently working very intensively on the question: How can we further improve start-up financing? But here too, the question remains: How can we actually encourage more people who have material resources to invest in this area? We are considering how we can engage in risk-sharing, because it is indeed somewhat riskier for a life insurer to invest in start-ups than in other areas. But where there is risk, there is also opportunity. In this respect, we need to become more agile.

We have the task of familiarizing young people with digitalization. That is why there is the Digital Pact for Schools. That is why we are also working together with the states on how to design teacher training and create digital learning content. We have made significant progress in this area.

We have the task of helping employees. I would like to thank the trade unions that are intensively addressing the issue of digitalization in the workplace. The fact that we developed a National Continuing Education Strategy last year is a significant step forward.

I know that there are still further wishes in the room. We have also established a strategic dialogue with the automotive industry. We will meet again on this on Monday. Of course, this will also involve the question of how we, as a state, can shape and accompany the transformation of, for example, propulsion technologies in such a way that skilled workers are retained and the potential for skilled labor is not lost. This requires very close cooperation from those who are knowledgeable in industrial production and an integration with state instruments.

With the National Continuing Education Strategy, we have also provided for so-called experimental spaces in which we examine certain case constellations and try to understand preventively what challenges for employment lie ahead of us.

We have made significant progress in the healthcare sector – this has already been mentioned here: the electronic patient file by 2021, the e-prescription from 2020, the establishment of telemedicine. Here, the issue of trust and distrust of citizens in digital solutions comes particularly into play.

What we need to show much more strongly in Germany – I believe that Estonia and other countries that are much further along in digital usage by citizens can demonstrate this – is that you have a much better way of tracking who has ever handled your data in the digital world, because the traces do not get blurred, than if you have your medical records lying somewhere in a hospital and you do not even know who has access to them if you are not standing next to them – and you rarely do. This means that there is more security when done correctly. I think we need to keep telling people in Germany this.

We have enormous opportunities in the area of urban management. We have just looked at the topic of Smart Cities. In Germany, of course, there is the challenge that we do not end up with a patchwork of isolated solutions, but that we try to pursue this concept with compatible standards.

This brings me to our main task as a government. We have set ourselves the goal, with the so-called Online Access Act, to digitize 575 state administrative services; 115 of the functions lie with the federal government. We have made progress in this regard, although some implementations are taking longer rather than shorter. The goal is that, from the perspective of data minimization, once a citizen has provided a piece of data to the state, they can always refer back to it and access these 575 functions very quickly and easily. This can only be achieved if we truly have the cooperation of all states and all municipalities. The states, as the responsible parties for the 11,000 municipalities in Germany, must pull together on this. Otherwise, we will not achieve it within the timeframe we have set for ourselves.

Much is mentally conditioned. Germany is a country with a relatively well-functioning administration and a relatively high standard of living. This means that the potential to want to climb to the next technological level is not as pronounced as in countries that are much poorer, have poorly functioning administrations, and perhaps still have a lot of corruption. They say: With digitalization, I get more transparency. There are countries where digitalization is synonymous with transparency – in both good and bad senses. On the one hand, the state has a lot of access. But on the other hand, processes that were previously regulated by handing over an envelope with some money are no longer possible today. Therefore, digitalization is also a driver for more transparency in societies.

However, the desire to have and utilize all possibilities of digitalization is not 100 percent present in the population. I found what Mr. Berg said very interesting and would like to emphasize it: If people and companies are not curious about new possibilities – I do not need to explain this in this room, but you are neither the entire business world nor the entire citizenry of Germany – then we will not penetrate even with the best strategies, or we will even encounter aversions, causing people to refuse. Therefore, I find the idea of Digital Day very good and also think it is great that so many associations, organizations, and churches are involved. This is very important.

We are in the midst of the work; the federal government is, so to speak, an actor and at the same time – I admit this openly – also a learner. We have a Digital Cabinet and we have a Digital Council. The way of working must change not only for politicians but also for civil servants and employees. Permanent, lifelong learning must also be practiced. Therefore, it is better that children learn this already in school and then come into the world somewhat educated. We are not only caught in this transformation, but we are right in the middle of shaping it. This already requires a significant effort, which we want to undertake because there are so many opportunities in it.

That is why I think it is good that we always receive a bit of drive from all those who participate in this Digital Summit. We need that as politicians too. Therefore, next year, the work will not be finished. This means we will need another summit like this. I can reveal here that it will take place in Jena.

So we warmly invite you to that already now. Thank you for being here. Continue to engage in the great chapter of digitalization, which will determine our prosperity for tomorrow.

Thank you very much.