Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Eighth Annual Congress of the Council for Sustainable Development on November 17, 2008, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 November 2008 · Eighth Annual Congress of the Council for Sustainable Development · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Eighth Annual Congress of the Council for Sustainable Development on November 17, 2008, in Berlin, discussing Germany's progress on its National Sustainability Strategy.
Main themes
Sustainable development, national sustainability strategy, greenhouse gas emissions and climate protection, renewable energy, short-term vs. long-term thinking, global responsibility, land consumption, gender pay gap, Kyoto Protocol commitments, education for globalization, cross-generational responsibility, shared governance
Duration
~37 min
88th percentile
Words
4,431
88th percentile
Sentences
231
92nd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
2.97
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Environmental 24%23%
  • Institutional 22%21%
  • Social 16%16%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

231 sentences in 57 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Hauff,

esteemed members of the Council,

dear colleague, Thomas de Maizière,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be with you again this year. "Taking Responsibility for the Future" – this title of the event already shows what is important to you. I believe it also gets to the heart of what the sustainability debate is about: detaching ourselves from short-term, self-centered discussions and turning towards a cross-generational consideration of our actions, and indeed our actions in the broadest sense.

That is easier said than done.

First,

we cannot always assess all the consequences of our actions; that is part of the truth. But the much more difficult question is whether we are not, after all, closer to home than to the larger picture – I can also say "the jacket" if that fits better – and whether we repeatedly resort to the seemingly more convenient, often more easily enforceable solution. Are we taking responsibility for the future or are we consuming the future? This is not only a question of conscience, but ultimately a concrete economic, social, and environmental policy fundamental question that, of course, manifests itself in our daily actions.

However, we notice – at least I do – that, in light of many current problems, we are increasingly struggling with short-term thinking, that the inadequate effects of short-term or regionally focused actions are becoming visible more quickly. We feel that the challenges we face are increasingly of a global nature.

I do not know if you feel the same way, but I have the impression that over the last 20 years the necessity to think globally has been increasingly reinforced by many practical examples. It is often also to be noted – I sometimes include myself in this – that the ability to think globally is by no means as developed as the necessity. Therefore, I am convinced – I have repeatedly mentioned this in connection with the call for an educational republic: In order to understand globalization, a new kind of education is urgently needed. This means historical knowledge, cultural knowledge, as well as cultural empathy, knowledge about regions and the conditions there.

But I do not want to distract right at the beginning; I want to make it clear: Of course, we can only credibly advocate for sustainability on a global scale if we also do our homework at home. Because we take this seriously, we adopted the progress report on the National Sustainability Strategy in the Federal Cabinet on October 29. This is a comprehensive report that describes what we have achieved, where we currently stand, and what we still need to accomplish.

I also want to be quite open: The analysis shows a mixed picture. There are successes, for example in climate protection. From 1990 to 2007, greenhouse gas emissions fell by 20.4 percent. This means we are only 0.6 percent away from achieving the Kyoto target by 2012. When I look at our European neighbors, I can say that Germany belongs to the leading group of countries that are meeting their Kyoto commitments. I also want to say at this point that I am still considering some European target marks, because we will have a very hard time advocating for a post-Kyoto agreement at the conference in Copenhagen next year if Europe itself has not met its goals.

In the same period – from 1990 to 2007 – the share of renewable energies in primary energy consumption has quintupled. But there are, of course, many other areas where significant action is still needed. Therefore, I want to mention one area where we cannot be satisfied at all when we look at the development. This is the goal of the sustainability strategy regarding the new consumption of land. Here we have set ourselves the goal of reducing to 30 hectares per day by 2020. Currently, we are at 113 hectares. If you look at the development curve, there must be a qualitative change here in order to achieve this goal at all.

Another goal of the sustainability strategy is, for example, to reduce the income gap between women and men. Women still earn significantly less than men for comparable work on average. I also find this very unsatisfactory.

So I have given you here two examples where we, like in many others, still have to work very ambitiously. However, we also repeatedly notice with these questions: Responsibility for sustainability is by no means only borne by the federal government, the federal level, but it is a task for the entire state. States, municipalities, businesses, civil society – all share the responsibility. Everyone is responsible for how the question is answered: What decisions are being made for the future? How can future generations live in the 21st century? Will it be a century of conflicts over the distribution of resources? Will it be a century of social conflicts between the young and the old? Will it be a century of environmental destruction, or will we, over the course of this century, manage to transition to an era where sustainability and intergenerational justice prevail? We are faced with these questions; they are not yet definitively decided.

Future perspectives are always very difficult to assess. Next year, the Federal Republic will be 60 years old. If you had asked in 1949, when it was founded and the country lay in ruins, about the prospects of our development, certainly not everyone could have imagined what the Federal Republic of Germany looks like today. Therefore, I actually want to encourage us that, if we have clear goals, visions, we can also achieve what we consider impossible today. I believe that this courage for visions, the courage for guidelines, and also the courage for the consistency to uphold these guidelines must guide us. The past shows us that it is possible. I believe we should also carry this optimism outward.

I say this now at a time when we must talk more about crises. The international financial market crisis is a classic example of unsustainable action. It is an example that immediate profit maximization is exactly the opposite of sustainable action. We can see from the effects on the economy in industrialized countries – we have enough to deal with that – but also in emerging countries and especially in the poorest countries in the world, for example in Africa, what setbacks this can lead to. We have been talking for years with African countries about good governance, benchmarking, and many other things. When you now see the fundamental difficulties these countries are facing, you also see that self-centered actions in the financial markets have ultimately caused a great catastrophe or global crisis.

Mr. Hauff has thrown the idea into the scene to think about the topic "Financial Market Crisis and Sustainability" in the Sustainability Council. If you do not say now that you need completely different personnel and many new people and only financial market experts, then we can gladly discuss this. It must be manageable with finite capacities. But the perspective on international financial flows from the sustainability perspective could indeed be a very exciting one. I therefore recommend a conversation with Chancellor's Office Minister Thomas de Maizière on this question, and you will, as with all other questions, find a good solution.

We set out this weekend in Washington as the G20 – that is, 20 governments from developed and emerging countries – to think about an architecture, a financial market constitution for the future. I believe that this was a remarkable gathering. This group was, by the way, almost identical to the group we met in Japan on the occasion of the meeting of the major economies – "major economies" or "major emitters." This means that you will always find a group in the world that symbolizes about 80, 85, or 90 percent of pollutant emissions or capital flows. There is thus a group of countries that are particularly responsible for what happens in the world and that should discuss these matters together.

What pleased me over the weekend was that the responsibility of all – regardless of the perspective from which they viewed these matters – was visible and palpable. It was not a blame game over guilt questions, although much can be said about that, but rather the focus was on the future and the feeling of being interdependent and only being able to walk the path of reason together. Therefore, we took a first step towards more transparency, more predictability, and towards a world where there cannot be individual blind spots where neither the markets, nor the products, nor the participants are controlled. I believe this is the starting point for things to improve at all, because financial markets can also expand over quite small regional areas. We have now noticed this in not very large countries that have far more banks than they have, so to speak, area. This then also leads to imbalances.

However, I also say: One can see from this example that it is not so easy to talk about some of the underlying problems of this whole activity, which have been present since the negotiation of Bretton Woods throughout history. The question is: How many financial imbalances can the world actually tolerate – how many assets on one side and how many debts on the other side – and how long can this tension build up?

It shows that the growth and stability pact of the European Union, which sets limits on our borrowing, is, in my view, a quite reasonable thing if one does not want to run into disasters in the long term. I say this because there is, of course, again the discussion in the European Union: How much debt can we incur in a crisis? I do believe that in difficult economic times one can certainly accept a certain new debt if one commits to compensating for it in good times of growth – this is the discussion about introducing a stricter debt brake in the context of the federalism reform II. But it is important that one emerges from an economic cycle with a zero; everything else is not sustainable. Therefore, even now in the crisis, care must be taken to handle money carefully and not to let go of everything we had firmly resolved two years ago.

I believe it has also been shown that the model of the social market economy, which is also rooted in Europe and which we implement in Germany, is a very successful model. What caused the crisis was a lack of regulation of the financial markets, while the social market economy has always been an order of the market. I recall how Ludwig Erhard fought to enforce antitrust law against the Federal Association of German Industry, which of course had no interest in ensuring that the multitude of competitors could actually survive. The fact that Germany today has a middle class, that Germany today has family businesses, that Germany today has a diverse corporate structure is, by the way, one of our great strengths in innovation; also in environmental technologies. Therefore, it was right that at that time this order of the market was introduced with competition regulations and that the market could not simply unfold unregulated.

Now it is about enforcing this in the international dimension as well. This is, of course, a tough nut to crack. For example, we have succeeded at the World Trade Organization, after much effort, also in practical shaping, to establish an international body that has arbitration possibilities and can also impose sanctions. This process is quite original. We must continue to pursue this path in the international arena.

One of the many discussions related to the financial summit over the weekend concerned the question posed by many countries: Is it possible to develop any international institution so that national thinking takes a back seat to thinking for the community? Especially in connection with the International Monetary Fund, it was said that whenever a difficult decision needs to be made, the national component becomes particularly strong, and not even the Europeans manage to present a united front there.

I then referred to the World Trade Organization. We must, of course, succeed – we know this from the European Union as well – in ensuring that representatives of a nation-state in a certain function not only represent their national interests but are also willing to think globally. Only this step will lead to recognized rules and, if necessary, to the introduction of sanctions when these rules are violated. It may be one of the most exciting tasks how globalization will ultimately be shaped.

It has sometimes been mentioned at this conference that the advice given by the International Monetary Fund during financial crises in Africa, Asia, or Latin America is not actually being followed one-to-one by the industrialized countries. They are currently accumulating significant debt and are not doing what the IMF has always demanded in the past when providing assistance, namely to practice sound budget management. Actions and words are already being put to the test. And this will intensify. That is also the right thing to do.

Mr. Hauff has rightly said that we must not stop discussing other topics because of an economic crisis and a financial market crisis. A sustainability strategy always means thinking and acting multidimensionally. This is something that not only politics struggles with. Reporting and many other things always refer to only one topic or at most two. But having ten topics in mind at once and mastering them simultaneously in a multidimensional interplay of forces is something we must achieve in our thinking and also in our actions. Complex thinking is the foundation for sustainable action; otherwise, it will not work.

Therefore, it is already important to bring together the issues of economic development, jobs, and social security with the questions of ecological future design. I would not say that it has become easier to conduct climate negotiations at the December Council in Brussels. But it would be completely wrong to deviate from our climate goals just because we are currently facing economic difficulties. That would be against the idea of sustainability.

This means we must establish that we are providing assistance now, but also doing so in a way that does not call into question the goals we defined yesterday and the day before, but rather supports these goals as measures of assistance. This is also being discussed, for example, in the question: Where do I help in the automotive industry? What economic stimulus measures do I implement? It may be sensible, for example, to connect things with building renovation. It may be sensible to do something for CO2 reduction, also in the automotive sector or by having the European Investment Bank provide loans for the development of modern transport carriers. It may be sensible to address the relationship between rail and road by increasing the expansion in the rail sector.

So we have many options for action. It is now very important in this crisis that we utilize them based on our sustainability strategy. We have a lot to do in the area of energy efficiency and resource efficiency. And our national and also our European actions must correspond to this.

In the progress report that you now have, we have further developed our strategy.

Two things were very important to us:

First, participation, and second, transparency.

I want to clarify this with three points:

First: No previous sustainability report has been supported by more societal groups or institutions. In addition to the Sustainability Council, the Parliamentary Advisory Board of the Bundestag, the federal states, and the municipal umbrella organizations have contributed their own inputs. I believe that this provides us with valuable starting points for our further actions. Therefore, I would also like to express my heartfelt thanks. Because only in this joint action can we really make progress.

Second: In no previous strategic report has the public been able to engage more. The decision-making of the report in the federal cabinet was preceded by extensive participation from interested citizens, associations, and institutions over an entire year. We received a multitude of suggestions, which were then incorporated into the final version.

Third: No previous progress report has been more meaningful, as the Federal Statistical Office has objectively and professionally analyzed the development of the indicators at our request. We have incorporated the results of the analysis into the report. I believe that only if we manage to work with comparable indicators over a longer period of time will we make progress in understanding what we have achieved and what we have not achieved.

It is one of the most popular exercises when asked how something was three or five years ago to respond: Back then, we measured differently, counted differently, or defined it differently. Then one is quite sure that it is never comparable and that one can afford a nice result without knowing whether it has really improved. Therefore, my request is also to stay somewhat with the indicators and not to develop them again after just one year, so that in the next report we can say: Now we have new indicators again and must therefore see everything differently.

In addition to many briefly addressed topics, the report sets four focal points, which I would like to elaborate on here, as they show how multifaceted sustainability as an overarching political concept is.

The first focal point is climate and energy. I have already pointed out: Here we have moved a lot. The integrated energy and climate program is one keyword. We have also initiated a number of initiatives within the framework of the German G8 and EU Council presidency. This concerns the EU climate and energy saving package, which is to be adopted in December, as well as, of course, next year the negotiations on a Kyoto follow-up agreement.

These negotiations are key negotiations, I would say. They will not be achievable without the cooperation of heads of state and government. This is not a criticism of the environment ministers. But it was a very important experience this year in Japan to sit down with the so-called major emitters and for the first time in this circle, at the level of heads of state and government, to discuss the necessity of the climate issue. It is already astonishing that an incredible movement has developed in recent years. Statistics are being circulated, showing who has achieved what, and there is debate about renewable energies and the respective paths to them, so I consider this an optimistic sign.

Nevertheless, I do not harbor any illusions. We will soon have the conference in Poznań. Then we must ensure that around the time of the G8 summit in Italy in the summer of 2009, the foundations for a post-Kyoto agreement are laid by the end of the year. There is a new American administration. There are many hopes resting on the elected president. I would like to join these hopes, but I still do not believe that the negotiations will be a walk in the park. We will have to tackle some tough issues. Therefore, it will also be so important that Europe enters these negotiations with a convincing strategy and also well-prepared homework.

I know that our Danish friends are intensively preparing for this Kyoto follow-up conference in Copenhagen. I would like to add that the German government will support Denmark in organizing this conference to the best of its ability. Because it is very important that we organize climate protection worldwide beyond the year 2012.

One of the central questions will be how to balance the commitments of industrialized countries with those of developing countries. Because we must also see that Europe today – with a declining tendency – still accounts for 15 percent of global CO2 emissions and that if we want to achieve a halving by the middle of this century, we will, of course, also need a contribution from developing countries. There is no doubt about that. We can go to zero in Europe, and America can significantly reduce; however, that will not change the global overall target. Therefore, there is such a great task ahead of us, and that is why I have also advocated that the World Bank now ensures, with investment programs, that new investments in an economically difficult situation are directed precisely towards renewable energies and higher energy efficiency and not in the wrong direction.

The second topic is the raw materials economy. Here we notice and have noticed that price fluctuations can have immediate effects. This means that a sustainable raw materials economy is of utmost interest and necessity. During our G8 presidency and also afterwards, we had many discussions, especially with African countries, because it is also about enforcing sustainable extraction of raw materials. Furthermore, it is about concluding fair contracts with developing countries. Because this is their wealth; we must not deprive them of it, but we must also orient ourselves towards long-term sustainability. This is also a topic that we must repeatedly discuss with some developing countries. Therefore, it is my goal that we develop general standards for dealing with raw materials that developing countries can rely on.

A third focal point for us in Europe and especially for us in Germany is demographic change. We must succeed in utilizing the opportunities of this change to strengthen civil society, promote more solidarity between generations, foster a culture of togetherness, and encourage more participation in shaping one’s own living environment.

At this point, I would like to additionally highlight the topic of integration in connection with demographic change, which is of central importance for sustainable development in Germany. In all industrial sectors in Germany, the proportion of young people with a migration background among those under 25 is already 40 to 50 percent today. This trend will continue. This means that managing demographic change in Germany can only succeed if we achieve a completely different attitude and entirely different results regarding integration. We have tried to take some important steps through the connection of the integration commissioner’s office to the chancellery and through the National Integration Plan. But this will also be a very long-term process. I can only advise all of us to continue this process intensively for the benefit of us all.

The fourth focal point is global food security. It is the subject of a central Millennium goal of the international community, namely to halve the global proportion of hungry and extremely poor people by 2015. We all know how the development of food prices and raw materials, now also due to capital outflows from developing countries, has unexpectedly called this goal into question. Therefore, it will require all efforts to achieve our goal by the year 2015. I also know what this means for the German budget. We have made significant progress in recent years. Nevertheless, the commitments are very ambitious. We must make every effort with all we have to ensure that we do not lose sight of this goal.

In addition to working on these various topics, we are also establishing the strategy itself on a new foundation with the report we have presented to you. We define sustainability as a guiding principle for the policies of the federal government. This means we ask how the effectiveness of the sustainability strategy can be improved in the daily work of the government. Because sustainability must not only come into play with individual flagship topics, but it must shape our daily work almost as a matter of course.

Effectiveness and bindingness are your concerns, the concerns of the Sustainability Council. Therefore, you have repeatedly called for sustainability management. We are trying with our approach to come a good deal closer to this demand. One of the important measures in this context is the inclusion of sustainability as a fixed part of legislative impact assessments. We introduced this at the beginning of the legislative period in connection with the additional consideration of the costs of bureaucracy. At first, this is always difficult. In the end, it becomes completely natural. In the future, we will examine every law and every regulation during its development to see what impact the proposal has on sustainable development.

A corresponding amendment to the joint rules of procedure of the Federal Government is being prepared. I hope that the dispute over the sustainability impact assessment does not take longer in the end than the legislative proposal itself. But somehow we will make progress. Because usually someone has an interest in a law.

So it is about capturing things early on. I believe that we have taken an important qualitative step together. Overall, we can state that we have made progress with the present report. But I want to be very clear: progress does not yet mean that the goal has been reached. Therefore, the question is: How do we proceed?

In 2010, there will be the next indicator report from the Federal Statistical Office, and in 2012, the next progress report in the comprehensive sense will follow. We want to fulfill one of the announcements today. The Federal Government and the Sustainability Council are launching a joint competition titled "Generational Dialogue in Practice – Citizens Initiate Sustainability." This means we want to focus on projects that lead to better cohesion among generations in demographic change. We hope that this competition will also strengthen civic engagement in its diversity and encourage many people in our country to participate.

Mr. Hauff mentioned that the topic of sustainability should be included in the context of Expo Shanghai 2010. We take up this suggestion and consider it a good one. Now we should talk about how we can actually realize this. I believe that it suits Germany well to present itself in Shanghai, and that new opportunities could arise for us regarding export markets in terms of sustainability.

I would like to conclude with a word of thanks. Mr. Hauff and the members of the Council for Sustainable Development invest a lot of time, energy, and effort into their work for the sake of sustainability and hopefully also find much joy and passion in it. They know how to keep us engaged with a wise mix of praise and criticism. One always needs a little encouragement. On this path, we might succeed in making it so that people say: Sustainability "made in Germany" is something good.

To further good cooperation and thank you very much.