Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations on December 11, 2007, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

11 December 2007 · Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Confederation of German Employers' Associations' Employers' Day on December 11, 2007, in Berlin, highlighting labor market successes and ongoing reforms.
Main themes
Employment growth, labor market reforms, unemployment reduction, social security structural reform, retirement age increase, older workers employment, unemployment benefits extension, entrepreneurship and investment, wage restraint, workforce participation, economic reform narrative
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,323
88th percentile
Sentences
228
92nd percentile
Readability
52
68th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.94
5th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 59%59%
  • Social 18%18%
  • Institutional 15%15%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

228 sentences in 55 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to take this opportunity to warmly congratulate you, Mr. Hundt, on your re-election yesterday. I look forward to further good cooperation – not always infinitely harmonious, but always constructive. In this sense, I am looking forward to it. We will have our first conversation next week.

This year, I am coming to you for an Employers' Day, where we can jointly note with pleasure that for the first time there are over 40 million employees, over 40 million people who are employed in Germany. What used to happen, namely that on average over 1,000 social insurance-contributing jobs were lost every day, is no longer the case; instead, the opposite is happening: Currently, a net of 1,200 new social insurance-contributing jobs are being created every day. There are fewer unemployed people, namely 1.2 million fewer than two years ago.

I believe that one should not break into hymns of praise. But we can record successes together – you have done so as well. These successes, of course, have many fathers and perhaps also mothers. First and foremost, they are the entrepreneurs in Germany, who have shown courage, innovation, and made investments in many areas. They are the diligent employees in Germany, who over many years have contributed to companies being able to assert themselves in the market through wage restraint and sacrifices. I thank you for stating that politics – both that of the previous government and our government – has its share in this. Ultimately, it is the hallmark of our community that no one can claim success alone, but that it works best when everyone contributes.

Changes and reforms – and this is also our political message – are worthwhile. They can make a difference. If today over a million more people have a job, then that is a huge success for the people, for the families. If fewer people are afraid of losing their jobs, the same applies.

In this respect, it is also very critical from my perspective to see when it is claimed that the reforms are merely impositions. No, changes are necessary steps to lead people back to a better future. I believe that must be our message, because only in this way can we continue on our path. Because 3.5 million unemployed people are, of course, far too many unemployed. Therefore, we must not rest and relax now, but we must continue to pay attention to the framework conditions in a changing world and draw the right conclusions from them.

As the federal government, we have always subordinated ourselves to the goal of creating jobs with the triad of restructuring, investing, and reforming, that we want to give priority to work. We have taken some important steps in this direction.

You just said that the structural reforms of the social security systems have not been addressed. If raising the retirement age to 67 is not a structural reform regarding pensions, then I do not know what else a structural reform regarding pensions should be. You must see that, fortunately, there is currently an employment rate of over 55 percent among those over 55 in Germany. That is a success. Because it once stood at 40 percent.

However, nearly 50 percent of people over 55 still have the impression that they have no chance in the labor market. When they hear that the retirement age will be raised in a few years, it means for them nothing other than having to deal with a longer period that is complicated for them. Therefore, we must do everything we can to bring older people back into work.

I know that intensive discussions are being held about what the extension of unemployment benefits I means for older people. I ask you to consider the matter very soberly. In the past, older unemployed people had entitlement periods of up to 32 months. What have we done now? Under the previous legal situation, a 55-year-old could already receive unemployment benefits for 18 months. That remains the same after our reform, as it was after the Hartz reforms.

There are two changes: People over 50 can now receive unemployment benefits I for not just 12 months, but for 15 months; those over 58 can receive it for not just 18 months, but for up to 24 months. This is linked to an obligation for the Federal Employment Agency to offer a training opportunity – I give more preference to this than to qualification. I suggest that we meet again in due course and see whether this has had a negative impact on the employment opportunities for older people.

Older people have been shown to have a longer placement duration, while younger people have a shorter one. If this is combined with qualification – there have been many 58-year-olds who have not been considered at all by the Federal Employment Agency – then I can only say that we have every chance to make something reasonable out of it. This is anything but a final departure from any reform path. I stand for that.

Regarding unemployment insurance. The contribution rate is decreasing to 3.3 percent, and not only because the labor market situation is so good, but also because Mr. Weise has implemented structural reforms in the Federal Employment Agency. Therefore, I believe that we should also find a good word for that.

In terms of long-term care insurance, you are right: We certainly should have turned to capital coverage. That would have been a necessary structural matter. We could not agree on that because it would have had implications for private long-term care insurance as well. You would not have been too pleased with that – nor would I, by the way. That is why we could not do it.

That we do something for people with dementia, ladies and gentlemen, is a pressing obligation. We decided to finance this through contribution increases because we had room for contribution reductions in unemployment insurance. Now I tell you one thing: These contribution increases will be fully borne by the pensioners, who gain nothing from the reductions in unemployment insurance contributions. But overall, we are reducing the additional wage costs. This allows us to take a step that still offers the possibility of further reducing unemployment and creating new jobs. We are below 40 percent. We can guarantee you that the contribution burden on the employer side will remain significantly below 20 percent in 2008. That is a huge success, of which we – I hope together with you – are a little proud.

We have passed a health reform, of which you may not want to hear much. However, if you read the newspapers these days, you can follow some very interesting developments. Health insurance companies are directly entering into contracts with doctors. There is movement in the system. Next year, we will have to introduce the fund and will see how it works. My opinion here is relatively clear. But we have also made a structural reform here, which you have not particularly praised, but which in my view leads in the right direction.

Of course, we still have some steps to take regarding the activation of unemployed people. We have decided to rethink what actually happens with recipients of unemployment benefits II and how we can create incentives for them to get back to work.

Here, we as a coalition can present a comprehensive concept, on the one hand with child allowances and employment bonuses. However, it must be made clear that it is about not letting people fall into the receipt of unemployment benefits II, but keeping them in the regular labor market without them falling under the means test. On the other hand, we should redesign the additional earning opportunities from 0 to 800 euros, because with the current additional earning opportunities, we have a tendency for individuals to earn 100 or 130 euros and then say: I cannot earn more because from then on deductions from unemployment benefits II occur. That is, of course, a completely wrong way of thinking.

Our goal must be to encourage people to earn as much as possible. We could achieve this if we already account for a certain share from the first euro, so that people have an incentive to earn more. This could be another contribution to getting out of the black market, overcoming the tendency to take smaller mini-jobs, and truly improving access to the entire labor market.

Now today – and this is understandable in light of the current discussion – your speech also devoted a wide space to the entire topic of minimum wage. I would like to elaborate a bit more on this topic. We have been experiencing for several years that globalization has completely changed the field of activity for you as entrepreneurs. The competitive situation naturally also affects the employees. This has created many opportunities for Germany, but also a great deal of uncertainty.

What does this mean for our model of the Social Market Economy, which is not only an economic model but has also expanded into a successful social model in Germany?

For decades, it has been the case for employees that when their company is doing well, they are doing well too. Uncertainty now arises from the fact that this experience has objectively begun to waver. Employees must learn to cope with completely new competitive constellations. A company can be doing well, but it can also be doing well in other parts of the world. Companies have had to and must learn – and they are doing so to an incredible extent – to engage beyond the borders of Germany.

What are the pillars of the Social Market Economy? The pillars of the Social Market Economy are, of course, politics, but equally the economy and the trade unions. I am happy to admit: We as politicians may have sometimes only hesitantly addressed the concerns you have in international competition. But I also say: We must find our way back to a community in our country, where not only politicians are held responsible for the uncertainty and companies only think internationally. That must be brought together.

Therefore, I would like to speak about two topics. The first is the discussion about executive salaries, the second is the debate about minimum wages. I will then add something about investment wages.

It must be made very clear: It is not about legal upper limits for executive salaries. But there is an attitude in Germany that says: If one cannot make a law about a certain problem, then it is best to do nothing at all and end the debate again. I tell you: I consider this attitude to be wrong. The gap between doing nothing, not talking about it, and passing a law is quite large.

Therefore, my request – Mr. Hundt has done this to some extent today: Take this debate seriously. Do not simply dismiss it as a debate of envy and do not sweep it under the rug again, but take it seriously. My second request is: See the opportunities we have when we talk together about what justice means in our country. No one is against earning successfully when business is successful. But there is a great feeling of discomfort when significant risks are conjured up without public discussion and then – unlike employees – one comes away without personal risk.

Such a feeling must not be ignored. Because it has not existed in this range before. That has changed. Therefore, I believe that we must balance it out if we want to maintain our location with the advantages, especially stability, that the Social Market Economy has brought. Because we have a co-determined economy, what I say applies equally to trade unions and companies. The acknowledged responsibility must be taken seriously.

Therefore, I can imagine many things, such as the further development of the Cromme Commission. But let us proceed without prejudice and sensitively. The more openly the economy accepts the topic – I thank you for some contributions – the better it is overall for our social climate.

Moreover, the wishes for limits against a free fall of incomes go hand in hand with the wishes for fair remuneration of entrepreneurs and managers. This must also be seen, as it makes up the entire range of discussion.

The discussion is very much heading in the direction – and this distinguishes Germany from other European countries that have a large number of minimum wages and have not collapsed under those minimum wages – that it is said that a statutory minimum wage leads to underemployment. This is, broadly speaking, not correct. However, the minimum wage must not be too high. I am against a uniform statutory minimum wage, to make that very clear. But I also tell you: I am against it because there is a collective bargaining autonomy in Germany that is not only constitutionally protected but also genuinely desired, and because within the framework of this collective bargaining autonomy, the working and economic conditions are to be clarified between the bargaining partners.

Now we must ask ourselves: To what extent does this happen in Germany? Where is the minimum at which collective bargaining autonomy must take effect so that we can speak of collective bargaining autonomy as a defining pillar of our social market economy? If the figures from the IAB are correct, I must state that collective bargaining autonomy in Germany is under pressure. In 1996, in West Germany, there was a collective bargaining coverage of 69 percent of employees; last year, it was only 57 percent. In East Germany, there was a collective bargaining coverage of 56 percent in 1996; by 2006, it had dropped to 41 percent.

Now you must see – and this applies particularly in the service sector – that this development naturally raises questions, that it does not pass by the employees completely unscathed, and that it also leads to a discussion. Whether we want it or not, whether we consider it politically right or wrong is completely irrelevant. Therefore, I say: The further discussion will depend significantly on the extent to which the bargaining partners are also able to recognize collective bargaining autonomy in Germany as a predominantly lived reality.

I am also aware that alongside the sectoral collective agreements, there are also references to collective agreements and that there are company agreements. That is all correct. However, if there is no longer a sectoral collective agreement for an industry, then there is also no longer one to lean on. I will take a very close look at the collective bargaining landscape again. I am very concerned about the service sectors.

Therefore, I believe that in this entire discussion, there is also an opportunity for you – that is why we have taken so much time – for you as bargaining partners to agree on where the significant gaps actually exist and where it might be good to conclude sectoral collective agreements or regional collective agreements again. I am not in favor of uniform solutions at all. But it is politically not entirely simple, looking at the entire federal territory, where in whole areas and entire industries nothing exists in terms of collective agreements, simply to say: We will not talk about anything else.

Now let us come to the special case of the postal minimum wage. – I have not yet spotted Mr. Zumwinkel here today. – I will say this: As a politician, one would have wished that the relevant representatives of the employers would have simply sat down at a table. They did not do so. I do not want to comment on that further. I will only say: These are our perspectives regarding what collective bargaining autonomy could have still enabled. That did not happen. Whether the unions believe they have done themselves a favor by this, I will leave open. The fact is that now, after several negotiations, due to the special situation of the postal service, more than 50 percent of employees are covered by the collective agreement.

I would like to point out one point that distinguishes the postal sector significantly from other sectors. That is the fact that there is a postal law that deals with the privatization of the postal service. This is similar to what we have done regarding the railways. It was passed at the end of 1997. This postal law would never have been realized in Germany if, at the end of the Bundesrat consultations, a social clause had not been added, because it was seen that in the postal sector, wages, which account for about 70 percent of costs, would be the relevant competitive factor. Therefore, it was emphasized at that time that the working conditions in postal services must be comparable.

Now one can have a long legal debate about whether deviations of ten, twenty, or thirty percent are comparable; it is certainly not more than that. This means that postal competitors are also not completely free in their wage payments if they want to comply with the postal law. I want to mention this again in light of everything we are currently experiencing in this context, as it is indeed relevant for my political decision-making and also for the decision-making of others.

We are entering a decisive phase. I do not want to destroy jobs; no one wants that. But I believe that collective bargaining autonomy must really prove itself in the coming months. It is a right, it is an opportunity, but it must also be utilized if it is to have a future.

Ladies and gentlemen, there is a third part that I consider to be extraordinarily important for the future of the social market economy and which indirectly also has something to do with wage policy. That is the question: How can we better involve employees in the growing productive assets? I believe that we have an opportunity here to break the feeling of too little justice to some extent. The relatively uncontroversial "FAZ" publishes a survey today, according to which only 15 percent currently believe that things are fair in Germany. Do not think that politics can simply pass by something like this without comment. We must change this together.

Therefore, I believe that the investment wage concept, if we manage it sensibly – the coalition partners are willing to manage it sensibly – could be a contribution to making the respective entrepreneurial success of one's own company more visible again. I believe it is important that we rely on voluntariness, that we keep the additional costs limited, and that we make the connection to the own company – about which the most intense discussions are now being held – still recognizable. I consider this to be extremely important. Under this premise, negotiations are now taking place. I believe that we can still achieve a structural progress here that can strengthen the awareness of the capital gain, the asset gain of one's own company.

Mr. Hundt has already spoken about the topic of education and companies. I would like to express my heartfelt thanks at this point. The investments made in education are important, indispensable investments. We have made progress in the area of vocational training. For the first time, more than 600,000 new training contracts have been concluded. I believe the training pact has proven itself. We – at least I – will not relent in asking the unions to open up to this.

We still have the problem that some have not been able to secure a training place in recent years. We will now have to think very hard about how we can also give them a chance. In a few years – you can already feel it today – the issue of a shortage of young talent or skilled workers will gain more and more importance. The stronger and better the economic situation is, the faster this will happen.

I believe that we – municipalities, states, and the federal government – have taken a very important step with the "National Integration Plan." For the first time, we are focusing on the fact that the integration of young people with a migration background is one of the decisive tasks regarding the coverage of the skilled worker demand in the coming years. When you see today that in many German cities about 50 percent of enrollments involve children with a migration background, it is completely out of the question that we do not invest much more effort here and give these young people a chance for training.

We have addressed the interface – we are also in conversation with the states – between school and vocational training. The Federal Employment Agency is doing excellent work here. We all agree: It cannot be that every year 80,000 students leave German schools and are not capable of training, that they have no school diploma and are not accepted by companies. Germany cannot afford that. However, I believe that the responsible parties are indeed taking many steps to improve the situation.

We have launched a "National Qualification Initiative." The excellence thinking in our country has been strengthened by the excellence initiative of the universities. We want to spend three percent of our gross domestic product on research and development. The federal government is contributing to this and thus significantly improving the opportunities for research and development.

I also believe that the research minister, with the help of the Science Union, that is, through the collaboration of scientific institutions with companies, especially with medium-sized enterprises, has found new instruments to ensure that the money reaches those in the companies who develop innovative marketable products. This means that basic research is one thing, but the expansion of this basic research towards marketable products is still one of the major weaknesses in Germany. Therefore, it is right that we focus on this.

We have said that we must first qualify in the domestic area. However, we have also taken initial steps to provide foreign students with better job opportunities in Germany and to facilitate access to Germany for EU citizens from the new member states in selected occupational fields. We will monitor this closely, and we do not rule out that we will go further in the coming years. But national qualification has priority for us – you will understand this – with 3.5 million unemployed.

I believe that for companies in Germany and for employers, it was a good message that we have made important steps regarding the compatibility of work and family, especially in the care of children under three years old. This has two effects: On the one hand, we will have a much better infrastructure regarding the employment of women. One of the reasons why women find it very difficult to learn technical or engineering professions is, of course, the fact that these professions are very innovation-oriented. After a few years of child-rearing leave, it is therefore difficult to return to such professions. This means that improving the infrastructure for childcare will perhaps also lead to more women turning to technical professions again. We must advocate this together.

I would like to explicitly thank the BDA for participating in the "Alliance for the Family." This is a very good initiative. Many medium-sized companies, but also large companies, make a significant contribution to harmonizing work and family. The compatibility of working life with family life is one of the major tasks in Germany, which has a lot to do with mentalities and whose perception suits us very well.

We have decided on two reforms – one is complete, the other is in progress – that are of great importance to you: the corporate tax reform and the inheritance tax reform.

The corporate tax reform relieves companies in Germany. As is often the case, there are rarely only winners in such reforms. Because, as is also often the case, those who feel aggrieved are somewhat louder than those who feel favored. This may sometimes distort the discussion situation. Nevertheless, I am convinced: The investment location Germany will become more attractive. Family businesses will also be better positioned by the corporate tax reform.

We are now addressing the issue of inheritance tax, which is a very difficult topic because the Federal Constitutional Court has given us a significant task regarding the valuation of properties. We discussed the topic today in the cabinet and decided on innovations. It has become clear that there will certainly still be discussions in the parliamentary process. But one thing is already completely clear today: Business succession will be significantly facilitated for family businesses.

In all that you may complain about in detail, I believe this is a very important message that we have also given out of conviction. Because – I say this again, Mr. Hundt – we are sure and know in globalization more than ever: If politics, entrepreneurs, and employees do not jointly take responsibility for this country, and if the framework conditions are such that companies continually consider doing as much as possible abroad and as little as possible domestically, then we will not be able to lead this country successfully into the future.

For this reason, politics cannot always be designed for one group. But we also know that entrepreneurs are the ones who create jobs in Germany, that they are the ones who take the risk and the strength to turn ideas into marketable products.

Therefore, last but not least, a heartfelt thank you for what you do for this country. We will continue to have sometimes controversial debates. But we should have debates that unite us in the goal: Germany must be a humane, successful location, a location that does not forget the tradition of the social market economy, but rather presents it as an excellent model for others in globalization.