Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations (BDA) on November 24, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 November 2009 · Employers' Day of the Confederation of German Employers' Associations (BDA) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Confederation of German Employers' Associations (BDA) Employers' Day in Berlin on November 24, 2009, discussing Germany's economic recovery amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Economic recovery, global financial crisis, German economy, credit conditions for SMEs, international economic coordination, G20 reform, financial market regulation, exit strategies from stimulus programs, social market economy, employer-government relations
Duration
~44 min
92nd percentile
Words
5,265
92nd percentile
Sentences
265
94th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 62%61%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

265 sentences in 52 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

first of all, I would like to congratulate you, dear Mr. Hundt, on your re-election and promise a good collaboration from my side, as has been the case in the past. This does not exclude critical discussions; rather, it includes them, which is indeed the foundation for progress. I also greet the party leaders of the other parties who will speak later, as well as everyone present in the hall. Thank you very much for the invitation.

Mr. Hundt has already mentioned it: We are still in an extremely critical time. The year 2009 will go down in history as the year in which the Federal Republic of Germany turned 60 years old, but also as the year that experienced the largest economic downturn ever in the history of our country. I emphasize this repeatedly because it brings to light the dimension of the task we now face. An economic downturn of minus five percent – even if it may be slightly less by the end of the year – means a decline about five times greater than the largest downturn in the 1970s, which was minus 0.9 percent.

The causes are clear. They are due to the international financial and economic crisis. As an export nation, we are particularly affected – this can also be explained rationally. It has been possible to mitigate the effects with the stimulus programs that we implemented in the previous government. But we are not yet out of the valley; we must ensure that we succeed in doing so as quickly as possible.

There are encouraging signals. At the moment, we have a slight economic upturn. However, in my view, the credibility of forecasts has not increased this year. But in case of doubt, people tend to believe the good forecasts a little more than the bad ones. Nevertheless, we must say: We are moving on an extremely unstable and unpredictable ground, also because it is nearly impossible to predict how the international economic situation will develop. Caution is certainly warranted, especially since we do not know whether all the risks of the banks have truly come to light internationally or whether they have been written off. There are also very different reports on this. This means that we must do everything in our power. But there is simply no solid ground on which to look forward to the next year.

Nevertheless, we have managed to avoid the abyss that the international financial markets were facing with state assistance and to stabilize things worldwide. This has strengthened and institutionalized international cooperation. The G20 will, at least in the financial and economic sector, more or less replace the G8 at the level of heads of government. How many years have we talked about the need for this and in what form the group should be expanded? The crisis has suddenly set the course. At our last meeting in Pittsburgh, we agreed that the G20 will remain a permanent institution.

There is a danger that the lessons from the crisis will not be drawn in a comprehensive sense. On the one hand, one must see that we are currently in the implementation phase worldwide regarding the new rules. This means that one cannot say that nothing has happened at all. But the danger that there is no uniform competitive field internationally – "level playing field" as it is called today – is present. This must be closely monitored. Essentially, the question of whether we have learned a lesson from this crisis will also depend on whether we succeed in finding coherent, coordinated exit strategies from the programs currently in place worldwide.

Essentially, there are competing situations: On the one hand – Mr. Hundt has spoken about this, and I will pick it up again shortly – there is a credit crunch or very difficult credit conditions, particularly affecting small and medium-sized enterprises, and on the other hand, there are large amounts of money that, just by looking at interest rate differences and currency fluctuations, are again the basis for speculations, raising the question of whether there is actually too much money in the markets.

Finding the balance here – that is, on the one hand, bringing the money that is needed into the real economy, and on the other hand, creating the necessary conditions for it – will be one of the very, very difficult tasks. If there continue to be very low interest rates and if the practices currently being implemented in America continue, the next bubble will be triggered.

In this respect, there is already a battle order, of which I repeatedly say that I am at least very grateful for the support from the real economy with regard to the financial market sector. It operates according to completely different principles. Without this support, the struggle and the confrontation for politics are not easy to win. We need reason here, fueled by the desire of broad sections of the real economy that long-term planning must be possible, that innovative products need development times, that the standards of the social market economy must apply, and that we must simply cut the excesses through rules, knowing that the economy can never function entirely without risks.

That is why I have advocated from the very beginning in the G20 process for us to adopt a charter for sustainable economics, where we agree on general principles of economic activity, similar to the international level regarding human rights. This is yet another thick board that needs to be drilled. But in Pittsburgh, at least, a mandate was given to the G20 to continue working on the principles of such a charter. I consider this to be the right path.

One can say that the principles of the social market economy are already gaining some international recognition. The Federal Republic of Germany has long been regarded as a country that cannot react quickly. However, the reflection on whether this way of doing business, in combination with other factors – climate conferences, a shift in energy policy, sustainability, environmental technologies – might indeed be the more future-proof approach has grown.

One more brief remark on the international area: The greatest danger I see is still protectionism. We in the European Union have, with the competition commission that is not always loved by us, a pretty sharp sword to counteract protectionism. I must say self-critically: If this European competition institution and the principle of the common market had not existed, there would have already been the most dramatic attempts at isolation within Europe. However, they exist today in a hidden manner in trade with other continents, especially in the non-tariff area. This is not always immediately recognizable to the World Trade Organization.

Here, I can only ask you again to name names, even if it is very unpleasant. For us, it is very difficult to name things in discussions with the American and Chinese governments when no one is willing to say who it concerns. The answer is always: If we say this now, we might never get another order. – This, of course, does not bring us closer to the issues. Especially when one looks at the areas in which Germany holds market leadership – for example, in environmental technology, mechanical engineering, and other areas – one must be careful that protectionist tendencies do not use the stimulus programs to buy time for their own development, for example in the United States, only to one day rise like a phoenix from the ashes and then, of course, be a much more serious competitor than before the crisis.

Let us turn to the national circumstances, to the issue of credit supply. We will appoint a credit mediator. We believe that we need a structure in which this process is passed down. This means that there must also be contact persons in the states, as it cannot be carried out solely from the federal level.

We see the problems. However, we must be careful not to undermine the introduction of Basel II in the long term. It is indeed an unfortunate coincidence of history that Basel II came into full effect on January 1, 2009. When one looks at the assessments that need to be created and paid for regarding small and medium-sized enterprises in order to even enter the question of credit assessment, it can be heartbreaking at times, as this consumes the liquidity that is actually needed elsewhere.

On the other hand, Basel II was introduced with care. Therefore, I am very glad that we managed in Pittsburgh to extract from the Americans that they will implement Basel II in 2011 or 2012 – I am not entirely sure about the timing. The time gap in between is still considerable. It is already one of the absurdities that the topic was negotiated internationally for years, but ultimately Basel II is not being introduced simultaneously in the industrialized nations.

I believe that we have taken the right step with the Germany Fund. However, we know that the processing sometimes takes a long time or that the application from the house banks regarding the Germany Fund is very hesitant, as we expect the house banks to be willing to create the continuation forecast for the company. If this is not the case, the Germany Fund cannot act. Therefore, we are now moving towards granting the house banks global loans from the KfW using the funds from the Germany Fund. The first negotiations are underway. However, it is important in this context that the federal government does not cover the risks 100 percent. The negotiations regarding the liability issue are ongoing but are very complicated. You will understand that we, on the part of the federal government, cannot take on the risks 100 percent.

I personally view such ideas skeptically that suggest: Now we will develop the KfW into a house bank. In my view, the KfW is overwhelmed by this. It would take forever to have the corresponding capacities available. I believe we need to find a way between KfW and house banks through these global loans and must advance things with a reasonable risk-sharing.

We have managed to create a model for increasing credit insurance. This has taken a long time but has now passed the crucial hurdle. I believe this is an important point.

Through a series of laws and measures, we have managed to achieve stabilization – with the Financial Market Stabilization Act, corporate assistance, and investment programs. I believe all of this is fundamentally correct. I would also like to inform you this morning that the last funds from General Motors for Opel have been repaid. This means that the German taxpayer has not lost a cent to date regarding all operations related to Opel. I jokingly said this morning: If you were to ask in Germany whether the taxpayer has spent money on Opel, I suspect a high percentage would think: Yes. I must inform you: No, that has not been the case to date.

I do not want to be pedantic. I just want to say: It was, of course, absolutely right to take care of Opel in Europe at a time when General Motors was not at all able to do so and to build a bridge. I would have liked the bridge to have ended differently. That is no secret. But if we had not done anything, the whole situation would have ended completely differently. I expect at least a comprehensive thank-you letter from General Motors in a few years. I do not want to go into further detail, even though there is much to say about it.

Industrial production is still, despite all the programs, 25 percent below the level of 2008 in many areas. You all know what it means if we, as our current economic forecasts suggest, will return to the level of 2008 in the years 2012/13. That is a period of up to five years. To maintain employment in Germany, one normally needs a growth rate of 1.5 percent per year. However, we are talking about a period of five years after which we will be glad to be back where we were in 2008. This shows the entire dimension for employment. We can almost be glad at this point that demographic development somewhat mitigates the situation. But it is a huge challenge to maintain a high level of employment, ensure a high degree of social security, and push forward budget consolidation again.

I would like to remind you of this once again: The Grand Coalition was in a situation where we could have achieved a balanced federal budget in 2011. The Federal Republic of Germany was able to report balanced budgets to Brussels in the two years prior to the crisis. We are therefore a country that has truly fulfilled the conditions of the Stability and Growth Pact in an outstanding manner. As a result, we entered the crisis stronger than many other European countries.

We will slightly exceed the three percent mark of the Stability and Growth Pact this year, and significantly next year; that must be stated clearly. But we have the firm intention to return to the path of the conditions of the Stability Pact starting in 2013 or 2014 – I cannot say exactly yet; it depends very much on economic developments. I believe we should set ambitious goals, but at the same time, we should not commit too firmly to forecasts. If there are unexpected events in the global economy, we must be flexible. Therefore, we must condition the various paths very strongly.

I believe that we must first do everything we can for the year 2010 and also for the year 2011 to promote growth and extend the crisis instruments. That is why, in my view, it was important and right to initiate the Growth Acceleration Act now. It is undisputed that we need to do something about corporate tax reform. Its pro-cyclical effects have become very pronounced during the crisis.

The municipalities are complaining about tax losses. Then perhaps we must also jointly say to them: If companies are insolvent, then the tax losses are, so to speak, perpetuated. This means it is better to do something now than to pay for inaction with corporate insolvencies. Secondly, with regard to inheritance tax, the conditions – particularly concerning the wage sum – will change in the coming years due to the effects of the crisis. I believe that creating relief here is particularly a psychological signal. The third point is the improvements in family benefits, regarding which the discussion, of course, revolves mainly around tax reduction measures. I do not want to delve into that here. I just want to say that the measures for the economy are certainly not bad.

I also want to point out that we are now seeing the first crisis effects in the form of declining domestic demand. We have been able to maintain it consistently over many months of the crisis. Now, for the first time, there is a decrease of 0.9 percent. With rising unemployment, the danger that domestic demand will no longer have a stabilizing effect is, of course, very, very great. That is why this first legislative process of the new coalition is, in my view, the right one.

We are the only country, as far as I know – to return to budget consolidation – that has succeeded in anchoring a debt brake in the Basic Law through a major, cross-party effort in the midst of the crisis. This debt brake has been written into the Basic Law in such detail that it does not please constitutional aesthetes, but it also leaves almost no escape routes for those who want to find a gap in the constitutional text. Thus, the path we must take and the requirements are very clear when we will have to start shaping the budget development according to the debt brake by 2011 until 2016. By early 2016, we must be at a new debt level of less than 0.35 percent of gross domestic product. This means that it will amount to around seven billion or eight billion euros for the federal government. You can imagine what that means after the stimulus packages.

Therefore, my entire aim is to preserve as much employment as possible and to create as many new jobs as possible. Because whenever we have 100,000 more employees, we have, so to speak, two billion euros more in the coffers. Only through employment – as we have already seen in the last legislative period – can we tackle these immense challenges of the state. And then we still have to save.

Mr. Hundt spoke so beautifully about reducing subsidies. A little can still be done in this regard. But when it comes to the energy-intensive industry, whose energy price subsidies are to be removed, then I come to you, Mr. Hundt. Then we both set off and consider how we deal with the aluminum industry, the copper industry, and so on. It is not that trivial. We can gladly lean over the subsidy lists together, but the rescue does not come from there.

We will then – this will certainly also be one of the major political battle themes of next year – once again make tax reliefs and at the same time try to make the structure of the German income tax system a bit more comprehensible and, so to speak, simpler, lower, and fairer. I believe we all agree that especially regarding what is happening with small and medium incomes, namely this so-called "middle-class bulge," which has incredible effects with small wage increases or overtime, something must be done, and the cold progression must be reduced.

The second structural element that is very important to me is that we treat children in the tax system like adults. Therefore, we should apply the same basic tax allowance. This is always associated with increases in child benefits. Now there are many disputes over the increase in child benefits. I want to say just one thing about that: As long as the gap between the payments for a child in Hartz IV and the child benefit paid is as large as it is today, there will be an inherent barrier for families with multiple children to take up work. The smaller we make this barrier, the more favorable it is for entering work and for the possibility of earning money again with one's own income. I also hope that the Constitutional Court, which is currently dealing with the Hartz IV rates, does not throw a wrench in the works here.

It will be a long way to go to achieve all of this. But one must set some goals. And the goal for me is to make the middle-class bulge fairer, to treat children and adults equally in the tax system, and to gradually reduce the differences in the question of Hartz IV rates for children and child benefits.

The second major question, when we talk about more net from gross, is of course the question of contributions to the social security systems. This must not be forgotten. I am aware that not everyone in Germany pays taxes. I am also aware that with each increase in the allowances, the number of taxpayers decreases and that social security contributions are paid from the first euro. This means that a simple "left pocket, right pocket," on the one hand lowering taxes and compensating for that on the other hand by increasing wage-related costs, would be completely wrong. Our claim is to remain at 40 percent or less for the parity-financed social security contributions in this legislative period. That will be challenging, but in my view, it is the right thing to do.

That is why we have also said: In the health system, we cannot permanently link rising costs to labor costs. I know that this provokes a lot of criticism. But I also say: A permanent coupling of health costs to labor costs will make the shift to a two-class medicine even more likely. There is, of course, the pressure of labor costs. Everyone feels it and says: Of course, it must be dampened further. This dampening is then diffusely passed on to the service providers but cannot cover the rising costs in the health system.

At this point, demographics come into play, which will heavily influence us in the near future. I want to say it again: By 2020, compared to 2007, we will have 3.5 million fewer young people under 25 in Germany. This is a decline in this age group of 15 percent. The total population will only shrink by two percent in the same period. This shows you the dimension we are facing. If we burden young people, who will then start families, with the responsibility of being in the workforce and also carrying the solidarity for the elderly, while simultaneously increasing labor costs, we will find ourselves in a difficult situation.

Now, abandoning parity in the health system in terms of decoupling does not automatically mean a loss of solidarity. One could, for example, imagine – we have not decided on this, but I mention it only as a thought model – that the difference between the employer's contribution and the actual contribution for the employee is gradually compensated through the tax system. That would certainly be a fair thing. In this respect, it does not mean that the mentioned decoupling must automatically lead to a loss of solidarity. It must only not lead to increasing pressure on labor costs.

I would like to refrain from presenting to you the second point, namely making health insurance more competitive. I have already participated in many panel discussions with Mr. Hundt. I will just say: Even our new coalition partner now sees that the health fund is not a bad starting point for certain changes. I do not want to say more about that. We will talk again next year when we may have more clarity.

Thirdly, it is about long-term care insurance and the question of demographic stability in the form of a capital stock. This is also an extremely difficult task that we have set for ourselves. There will be heated debates about this as well. But there should be no doubt that we need such a capital stock. The question of how it is financed and how it is distributed socially fairly is okay. But similar to the Riester pension, where we have essentially introduced a capital component into pensions, we must also achieve demographic stability in long-term care. Otherwise, costs will develop to such an extent that the ever-shrinking group of those able to work will no longer be able to bear them.

You can see from the changes in the population structure that there are significant needs not only to respond in the social security systems but also to prepare young people for the future. Therefore, the topic of education is, of course, a central issue that will accompany us over the next years and decades. Germany no longer has the standing in its education system in international comparison that I wish for and that we wish for.

That is why we agreed with the states last year that we want to spend seven percent of gross domestic product on education in Germany by 2015. From 2010, our goal is already to spend three percent of gross domestic product on research. The state finance ministers are currently calculating in a very peculiar way that the seven percent target would actually have already been reached if one included the pension burdens for retired teachers. That was not meant with the seven percent target, to be clear. Rising education costs due to increasing life expectancy – that cannot be the statement. It is rather about funds that must really flow into education.

There is a difficult division of competencies between the federal government and the states. Nevertheless, we succeeded last year at the education summit in agreeing on a few things: halving the dropout rate, career counseling by the Federal Employment Agency in schools, and much more. We will now have to discuss with the states the financing conditions regarding how we can achieve the mentioned goal by 2015. I placed great importance in the coalition negotiations that the federal government does not set programs for this without consulting the states on how we will use the planned twelve billion euros – that is, the three billion euros that we will invest additionally in education each year in this legislative period. I did this because we need to find a way in education policy to do what is most necessary first.

When looking at the number of children and schoolchildren with competence levels zero and one, it becomes clear that what is likely required at this point is to make the groups smaller, to make the classes smaller, and to improve support. I also want to talk about early childhood education here, as we will be expanding it to a legal entitlement. The biggest problem – I can predict this – will be ensuring that when the daycare spots are available, we also really have enough educators. In the coming years, there will certainly be incredible competition for attractive skilled worker professions for young people – one should not be under any illusions about that. Therefore, the question of whether service to children and people in the care sector is still attractive for well-educated young people is also a question that will continue to concern us with regard to public budgets.

In education policy, we need a few things that should have long been a matter of common sense. This includes, for example, that the relocation of a family with school-age children does not turn into a family drama. I believe the ministers of education and the state premiers have understood this by now. We cannot constantly talk about globalization and at the same time organize a catastrophe when moving from Saarland to Rhineland-Palatinate. However, when I think about the number of letters I will receive because of this statement, I must say: I have taken this example without precise knowledge. Mr. Beck will surely write to me shortly about everything he has already done and that it is only the Greens and "Jamaica" that are causing everything to be reversed.

We also see in connection with the higher education sector what tasks still lie ahead of us. The transition to Bachelor/Master is correct from an international perspective, even though it certainly needs to be discussed whether every detail has been well considered. But one cause of student dissatisfaction is, of course, that the very strict time requirements in the current study programs ultimately make it necessary to have sufficient rooms for the necessary seminars and exams. I can only say: It was right, after the Federalism Reform I, to decide to adopt the Higher Education Pact, that the federal government supports the expansion of study places, and that we have enshrined these measures – both the research pacts and the Higher Education Pact, the Excellence Initiative, and the financial support for research institutions – for many years, so that there is predictability in the German research landscape.

The coalition agreement also provides for some openings regarding the willingness to conduct research in controversial areas such as green biotechnology. I just want to say: If Germany's largest company, the largest chemical company in the world, BASF, invests one billion euros in research for a starch potato – which has nothing to do with food – and then cannot be sure whether any practical benefit will ever arise from this billion euros invested in research, then Germany will not remain the research location it is now. That is completely clear. At this point, we must be careful.

Back to the crisis instruments. In one of the next steps, we will extend the short-time work regulation. I believe that is right, that is good. The views on the question of how long we should extend the regulation differ somewhat. I can well imagine that we will do this for one year and with a maximum duration of 18 months. This shows that we are making progress, and it also demonstrates a high degree of predictability. Regarding the latest proposals from Mr. Kannegiesser, I will say – to not spoil the mood: We will examine everything, but we must be careful not to fall into permanent subsidies from which we can never emerge. I simply ask you to keep this in mind. I stand one hundred percent behind the instrument of short-time work, but it is one that we have created with a crisis awareness. We will not repeat the mistakes of the early 1990s.

We will convert the loans to the Federal Employment Agency and also to the healthcare system for the crisis period into federal grants. I believe this is an important message. Otherwise, there would have been ongoing pressure on the social security systems and wage supplementary costs that no one could have withstood. One of the mistakes of the early 1990s – I believe this can be said after 20 years – was that essentially the contributors were made to pay for everything because no other decision could be made.

In this respect, I say: There is still much to be done. As far as the minimum wage area is concerned, we will first continue on the legal basis as we had planned in the previous government. We now have an interesting case with waste management, where we are being pressured by the economy to declare general applicability. Perhaps you can put in a good word for it with the Minister of Economics; we have never had such a situation before. Otherwise, we will also take a look at things after a few years. However, I believe we must do everything to ensure that wage determination occurs through collective agreements. That is why I have always been against uniform and blanket statutory minimum wages. But I also tell you: It is not a permanent state that entire sectors have no collective agreements at all. That too does not correspond to my idea of a social market economy. If our opinions differ on this, we must critically address it together.

In conclusion, I would like to say: The forces of the social market economy in Germany, to which the BDA undoubtedly belongs – just like the trade unions, works councils, employers, entrepreneurs, managers, the economy as a whole, and politics – have cooperated well during the crisis. This was not written in our books. No one knew at the beginning of the crisis whether we would succeed in exercising responsibility together without large, newly created structures. Exactly that is what millions of people did last year. I hope we can continue to succeed in this. That is why I have invited employers, the economy, trade unions, and credit institutions to another round next Wednesday, so that we can discuss together how we can shape the path into the exit scenarios.

Germany has gained a lot of recognition through this way of dealing with the crisis. At first, people were not thrilled that we thought first and then acted. However, that has since changed. I also believe that thinking and acting should not be too far apart. But acting without having thought it through has never proven successful. In this sense: To good cooperation.