Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the ninth annual conference of the Council for Sustainable Development on November 23, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

24 November 2009 · Ninth annual conference of the Council for Sustainable Development · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Council for Sustainable Development's ninth annual conference in Berlin on November 23, 2009, linking sustainability to global financial crisis recovery and G20 governance.
Main themes
Sustainability, international financial crisis, G20 resolutions and global governance, charter for sustainable economic practices, multilateral cooperation, United Nations reform, delegating national sovereignty, short-term thinking vs. long-term planning, European Union governance, developing countries and growth, course setting for Germany
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,861
91st percentile
Sentences
216
91st percentile
Readability
48
56th percentile
Grade
11.9
44th percentile
Syntax
3.04
53rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
12th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%34%
  • Environmental 28%27%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

216 sentences in 48 paragraphs

Dear Council Members,

Ladies and gentlemen,

We are now almost old acquaintances at this annual gathering. This meeting is always a great pleasure for me because you not only bring the topic of sustainability closer to the federal government but, above all, also carry it into society. Therefore, I would like to sincerely thank you for the good cooperation over the past four years.

I would also like to include in my thanks the international expert commission on sustainability, which we have asked to prepare a report for us, looking at us from the outside. We will carefully examine the proposals. We appreciate and respect what we believe to be a well-balanced analysis of what has been achieved and what still remains on the agenda.

I had the report joyfully in my hands when Mr. Stigson asked the relevant question: What will happen in the future? – That is when I realized that he would be pleased if he were asked again whether he should prepare such a report for us in three years. I would say that praise and criticism balance each other out, so we feel compelled to improve, and we will invite you to prepare another report for us.

The principle of sustainability is not yet anchored in all areas of society. Therefore, thank you for the motto you have chosen for this conference this year: "Sustainability in a Changing World – Setting the Course for Germany."

Mr. Hauff just said: The course setting is perhaps so well possible because we must try to turn the international financial and economic crisis into an opportunity. That is the task ahead of us, which, however, will be anything but easy to accomplish and will require support of all kinds. Because the urge to simply continue as before – especially in the financial markets – is overwhelming. I have repeatedly stated this in various contexts.

We must now implement the G20 resolutions in a determined march through the plain. We must ensure that this is not watered down here and there – sometimes in Europe, sometimes in America. We must ensure that we get coherent rules in a connected world, because global cooperation, including with global institutions, is, in my view, indispensable.

I believe we Europeans have a slight competitive advantage because we are accustomed, through the European Union, to delegating national competencies to a multilateral organization. Others find it more difficult. Especially when one thinks of our partners in the United States of America, it becomes clear that where they are internationally anchored, they are often anchored in such a way that they have a veto right. This does not apply, by exception, to the World Trade Organization; that is quite interesting. From the IMF to the UN, however, the component of the veto right proves to be a rather sharp sword in cases where one does not agree with what a multilateral organization is doing, while we in the European Union, for example – now through the Lisbon Treaty – increasingly have to live with majority decisions, which of course often makes life much more strenuous compared to having a unanimity principle that provides a quasi-blocking option. I believe that in the coming years, it will be especially important to learn to delegate responsibility as nation-states and to subordinate ourselves to international mechanisms.

The causes of the international financial market crisis are undoubtedly the acceptance of incredible risks and short-term thinking. Sustainability is, so to speak, the exact counterpoint to that. Therefore, alongside crisis management, which we must of course continue, I have from the very beginning advocated in the G20 process for the development of a charter for sustainable economic practices, which in my vision – this is still a kind of vision – should one day enter the arsenal or the fundamental values of the United Nations alongside the Human Rights Convention as an economic convention.

One can always ask: How do I try to get something off the ground? I thought the G20 process could perhaps be an interesting start. You can do it bottom-up or top-down. Doing something top-down in the United Nations is not trivial. Klaus Töpfer knows this and understands how difficult it is. Therefore, one must come from both sides and then try to make the project a common understanding of the United Nations through the anchoring of the G20 resolutions in the individual economic regions of the world – because the G20 cannot decide alone. I believe that in the end, global legitimacy can only lie within the United Nations.

That is why I am very pleased that we succeeded in Pittsburgh in at least issuing a mandate for the development of a charter for sustainable economic practices. Enthusiasm is limited in some areas. Many do not know what we want to achieve with it. Developing countries are always very cautious because they think we want to curtail their growth prospects. This is a well-known phenomenon since Rio. But I believe there is still no alternative to the long-term goals we are pursuing.

Since our G8 presidency in 2006, I have invited representatives of the major international organizations – the International Monetary Fund, the World Trade Organization, the ILO, the OECD, and the World Bank – every year. In the fundamental principles of these organizations, one can recognize many main lines of global cooperation. I am pleased that these multilateral organizations are also participating and that it has been successful for them to all now take part in the G20 process. The only thing missing in this entire sequence is actually a UN environmental organization that would bundle various activities and then belong to it.

Now, however, back to the national challenges and to "Sustainability Made in Germany" – this also applies as a synonym for technological excellence, it applies to the model of the social market economy, which is always a model that does not only focus on short-term successes but is founded from the very beginning on sustainability in the social sphere, on intergenerational justice, on balance, and on solidarity. For many years, the social market economy as a societal model was not particularly recognized internationally because it was considered slow, cumbersome, and difficult to implement regarding the entire partnerships between employees and employers; that is all very complicated. In the meantime, it is succeeding in the international discussion; and I believe we Germans can be proud of that.

Indeed, when we talk about growth strategies, we do not need just any growth; that is also undisputed. I only say that we are currently in a difficult situation. We are – I will now always be quoted to the decimal; therefore, I must be careful – in the growth forecasts for this year somewhere between minus five and minus 4.5 percent. We are thus one of the countries most clearly affected by the international financial and economic crisis in terms of the real economy.

However, we also have the best recovery potential if markets elsewhere in the world should develop again, because 40 percent of our gross domestic product depends on exports. This means that on the one hand, we can stimulate domestic demand. On the other hand, we can hope that export opportunities will arise again. We have export opportunities not only in the classic areas such as chemistry or mechanical engineering but also increasingly paired with environmental technologies, which are now developing incredible volumes and of which Germany holds up to 30 percent of the global market shares in many areas. We should make every effort to maintain and expand these shares.

The greatest danger on the way is protectionism. A country like Germany relies on open markets. If I think, for example, that since my election as Chancellor four years ago, I have repeatedly said the same hopeful phrases about the Doha Round without any substantial progress being made so far, it becomes clear that one needs a lot of courage and the ability to drill a thick board to not lose optimism. However, we need a success of the Doha Round. The bilateral trade agreements worldwide are not an alternative. But the economic crisis has already led to protectionism – not always in the area of tariffs; it is now known that the WTO is keeping an eye on that – being attempted in many places at least in the so-called non-tariff areas.

At this point, I can only say: It takes courage, also the courage of the German economy. It is of no use if one tells me that we have difficulties in America and China because entirely new forms of protectionism have been introduced there, and when the American government then asks me who is affected and urges me to name names, I must say: People do not say that because they are afraid that they will not receive any orders at all. It is clear that we cannot break down barriers in this way. One must name things.

In environmental technology, it is the case that the United States has taken a new path, that they know they need time in some areas, and that the joy over the entire German imports to America is limited, and of course, they are trying to counter that with their own developments. Therefore, advocating for open markets is all the more important.

The global market volume for environmental technologies amounted to around 1.4 trillion euros in 2007. That is a great number; one only talks in trillions now. If one puts it in relation: 1.4 trillion euros is less than the total debt we have in Germany; it is probably a third of what has been written off at the banks, or it is about 15 to 20 percent of the gross domestic product of the United States – just to establish: It is indeed a size that one can work with and that will continue to grow.

We know that renewable energies are of interest, and we know that especially modern drive technologies are a market that would suit a country like Germany extremely well. We discussed at our cabinet retreat in Meseberg how we can better bundle the topic of electromobility in Germany and thus also take a leading position, although this will not be easy because the Chinese and also the Japanese are investing a lot, a lot is being done in the United States, and it is not yet decided that the car, which was first built in Germany at the end of the 19th century, will indeed be future-proof in its new form in the 21st century. One must say that many years have been wasted by the German automotive industry – especially regarding storage technologies. They are now trying to make up for lost ground here.

We want to organize the transition to a low-carbon society. We want to create the age of renewable energy. If I look at the commitments we have to undertake if we want to achieve the two-degree target by the year 2050 – and I do want that – then it means that we must reduce at least 85 percent of CO2 emissions. If we consider that we still have 40 years until 2050, it means that the period from 1970 to 2010 – a period that almost everyone in this room, except for the little grandchild who has made himself known here, can overview quite well – corresponds to the period in which technological change must be accomplished. This is of significant importance when one only considers how differently a car will look when it is an electric vehicle and no longer one with a classic injection technology.

With that, I come closer to the central theme of the coming weeks, the climate conference in Copenhagen. You spoke from my heart, Mr. Hauff, when you said it is the most important economic conference of this year. Whether it may be the most important is debatable; however, it is at least on par with the economic conferences we have conducted. At the beginning of the year, I said: This year will show whether global cooperation can really be elevated to a new level. The G20 meetings alone are not yet proof that we are capable of setting the course anew. Therefore, I am also very keen that we do not write off "Copenhagen" before "Copenhagen," as you also said, has even begun, because then we would be doing the work for those who do not want success in Copenhagen.

We will not have a detailed treaty in Copenhagen. But I also say that one can ascertain that something has changed compared to the beginnings of the climate conferences. Klaus Töpfer knows what he is talking about in this context; I still remember the Berlin Mandate, Kyoto, and so on. Back then, we were far from having heads of state and government engage in such detailed discussions about climate change as they do today. There was a large conference in Rio; and from then on, these issues became a matter for experts. One took care of biodiversity, and the other took care of climate protection. But the fact that this is now a matter for heads of state, and that one can hear fluid presentations on mitigation, adaptation, financing forms, and so on from the Chinese president to the American and Brazilian presidents and all European heads of state and government, is still a feast of tabernacles for me as a former environment minister, I must say, because only in this way does the whole thing really become a cross-cutting task and a coordination task.

Nevertheless, the board that needs to be drilled is thick. We experienced with "Kyoto" that the United States of America agreed to the Kyoto Protocol, but in the following years, neither the House of Representatives nor the Senate ever thought about ratifying it. That was not a particularly successful model either. I can still see Senator Lieberman in front of me when I visited him, and he showed me 98 no votes on "Kyoto" and said: Do not think that the two that are still missing were yes votes; the two were simply not there on the day we voted. – We cannot afford to let that happen again. Therefore, the strategy of the government of the United States of America, including the president, is, of course, correct in saying: I promise nothing that I do not also believe I can subsequently get ratified in Congress and the Senate.

Then the Waxman-Markey bill was passed. Now, it is not entirely easy to demand that by 2020 not only 17 percent of CO2 emissions should be reduced, but an additional 20 percent. However, that would be desirable to achieve the two-degree target, which is not trivial technologically. And since majorities are needed for everything, and one can already see from the dispute over health reform in the United States how difficult that is, one must – unfortunately, as I say – be realistic, but also hope for exponential progress.

We need reduction commitments from industrialized countries. We need medium-term targets for that. We also need statements from emerging countries about when they want to reach their peak, because even if the United States of America, Europe, and Japan have zero CO2 emissions by 2050 and the others continue as they do today, we will not achieve the two-degree target. We can no longer do this alone. This shows the extent to which emerging countries are also involved. Of course, we must be pioneers, and of course, we must also do something regarding financing.

My greatest concern – I must say this quite honestly – is not that we do not have medium-term targets – we will also be able to agree on follow-up targets; that may still be possible. The most difficult point, however, will be: Is there a willingness to make binding target commitments in the international monitoring mechanism? Does everyone then say: I do what I can and make a national law? Or can I manage this as an internationally binding obligation? I say very clearly: If we are serious about a post-Kyoto agreement under the umbrella of the UN – as we said in Heiligendamm together with the then American president – it means nothing other than that there must be internationally binding targets. We must work on this political statement in Copenhagen because this cannot later be negotiated in detail by environment ministers, but must be there as a kind of overall state commitment. This is the most difficult point I see for "Copenhagen." The European Union is not a problem in this regard, but we must also work with others.

I am certainly motivated to contribute to success and to embark on the path of a binding international climate protection agreement negotiated as soon as possible, which enables us to achieve the two-degree target. While we cannot outline the entire path from 2010 to 2050 in detail, we need milestones. There must be a clear promise. A failure would be a rather dramatic signal. I have specifically named the criteria for success because we must not allow ourselves to say: If we are all going there, it is a success at any cost. – Because then it will also be said: The environmental organizations always complain anyway. Instead, I understand success as a political framework in which work can be done next year with the aim of an internationally binding agreement that allows for a path to a two-degree target and provides for the necessary provisions regarding reductions and financing.

Germany has set an ambitious target with its commitment to reduce CO2 emissions by 40 percent by the year 2020. For this, we must prepare our energy and economic policy as well as the private sectors accordingly for the future. A controversy usually comes to the forefront when it comes to energy policy: that is the controversy over the use of nuclear energy. It is planned to phase out the use of nuclear energy by 2020. In some cases, this can be extended. We do not shy away from this controversy; my position on this is known. However, it is much more important that we have the firm and unshakeable goal of making renewable energies the energy supply of the future as quickly as possible. There are still many problems ahead of us in this regard.

It is not only important to be able to generate renewable energies, but they must also be generated as economically as possible. For this, I need declining subsidies. One must also succeed in bringing the electrons from the place of generation to the place of use. When I look at what is happening in Germany in terms of line construction, I find that we still have a long way to go. I cannot imagine that there is a great societal acceptance for the entire Bavarian industry to move to the North Sea to get offshore power as quickly as possible. In this regard, I see problems ahead of us, for whose solution I also ask the environmental organizations to participate; otherwise, this question will be the bottleneck for the expansion of renewable energies in Germany. If we need planning acceleration in this regard, then that would be for a good cause. However, there are still some societal contradictions to overcome.

I want to address the budgets. If the international economic crisis had not come, we would have had a balanced federal budget in 2011. Germany had balanced overall state budgets in 2007 and 2008. This has helped us a lot, because we will also exceed the deficit limit of three percent of gross domestic product only slightly this year, and more significantly next year. However, we have the firm intention to return to compliance with the criteria of the European Stability and Growth Pact in the foreseeable future.

Germany is the only country that has written a debt brake into its constitution in the midst of the crisis. Although there were representatives of the German Bundestag who believed that the debt brake enshrined in the constitution was linguistically completely unacceptable, it is so detailed that there is no or almost no escape from this debt brake. However, provisions have been made in the debt brake for the case of a major natural disaster. A country cannot say with its hands tied that it can no longer help anyone. If a financial market crisis comes in the form we experienced last year, so that we have to save banks because otherwise they would drag the entire world economy into the abyss, there would be the possibility that, with the exception of exceptional regulations, only in a very limited scope would one make use of the debt brake.

We must, as a federal government, reach a maximum of 0.35 percent of gross domestic product in new debt by 2016. This is also always about structural debts, not one-time expenditures. If we reach 60 billion euros in structural debt next year, then that results in the path we must take to reduce debt year by year; otherwise, we will violate the constitution of the Federal Republic of Germany. You cannot tighten a corset more than that. Therefore, we are faced with a very ambitious task. The states are obliged to have zero new debt from the year 2020. This goes relatively well with the European Stability and Growth Pact. That is why I wish that other countries in the European Union, but also countries elsewhere in the world, would submit to similarly strict restrictions.

For Germany, this is of particular importance because Germany is one of the countries most affected by demographic change. What lies ahead of us in the coming years has not yet been fully grasped in its dimension. The number of people under 25 will decrease by 3.5 million by 2020. This means a decline of 15 percent in this age group between 2007 and 2020. The number of people living in Germany will only decrease by two percent during the same period. So you see the dramatic challenge we are facing.

If you imagine all of this against the backdrop that we live in a united Europe, where young people can much more easily seek their place of residence in other countries than older ones, you realize that Germany faces the great task of providing young people in Germany with good prospects. Therefore, we must also move away from – I have also said this in my government statement – the notion that when we make social systems demographic-proof, there is an immediate collective outcry: That will be more expensive. – Yes, it will be more expensive in the short term. I cannot change that. Care will become more expensive anyway as we have more and more older people. We are pleased about the increased life expectancy, but we must also accept that we need a capital reserve in the long-term care insurance to cushion this demographic change to some extent.

In the next ten years, in the second decade of the 21st century, it will no longer primarily be about who can make their commercial area available the fastest, but about how many well-trained workers will be available. Therefore, education policy is also part of sustainability policy. To make matters even more complicated for those under 25: The proportion of children with a migration background in this group will increase; this means that there are special tasks here. Therefore, we will further strengthen our efforts for integration.

We have agreed with the states that by 2015, seven percent of gross domestic product will be spent on education. Some finance ministers of the states believe that we are already doing this today because the pension burdens for retired teachers are included in that. That was not the intention. It is therefore about currently available measures.

We also need – even though the states are responsible for education policy, which I support – a coordinated approach because it cannot be that we, as a federal government, end up dealing with numerous school dropouts who are unfortunately not capable of training, and that for these, unemployment insurance contributions or other funds are first drawn upon. Therefore, I am very pleased that we agreed last year at the education summit in Dresden to halve the number of school dropouts, that there can be career counseling in every school to which the Federal Employment Agency has access, that language courses are offered everywhere when children start school to ensure that they can understand the teacher at all, and that we must advance early childhood education with significant support from the federal government and ensure that there are enough educators available and that it does not happen that we have places but unfortunately forgot to train enough. This leads us to the attractiveness of the professions, because with fewer and fewer young people and fewer and fewer school graduates, the question will increasingly be: Which vocational training is actually interesting for me? – We cannot afford to lose any young, well-educated person who contributes to our country.

We will also invest three percent of gross domestic product in research starting in 2010. The federal government has provided its share for this. The innovative strength is also related to the question of how much research capacity can be invested in innovations for sustainability.

These are some of the tasks we face domestically. I know that there is currently a general debate about tax policy, but the challenge we face as a society is much broader. I do not want to sound too dramatic, but the next decade will be crucial in determining whether Germany remains on a sustainable path to prosperity or not.

I spoke with the French President about whether we could align our gross domestic product calculations more closely with sustainable growth factors. This has been attempted many times. At the beginning of the year, I was in Paris at a commission set up by Nicolas Sarkozy, led by Professor Stiglitz, which made proposals on this matter. I suggested that the expert councils of both countries meet together. We probably need a bit more support for sustainability—except for the debt brake; the expert council is already very focused on sustainability there. It then needs to be discussed how Europe can be a driver to incorporate sustainability into the Lisbon Process, into the Lisbon Growth Strategy. I believe we need to stop thinking in old ways at this point.

We also have sustainability tasks that extend beyond our borders, which we must not lose sight of in this crisis, even though all of this is, of course, as complicated as squaring the circle. Achieving the Millennium Development Goals in development policy and development cooperation is of crucial importance. We can produce significant disappointments if we let up here now. Germany has set an excellent path in recent years, which is not being followed in many countries around the world.

Next year, we will have the International Year of Biodiversity. Biodiversity is something that is incredibly underestimated in its importance. Many people wonder why we are becoming increasingly susceptible to various diseases and do not understand that biodiversity and natural diversity are our shield and our protection against being vulnerable to everything and anything. Biodiversity, the protection of the diversity of our planet, is a moral task in the broadest sense—up to climate and desertification and many other issues. However, we must also keep in mind the question of the growing world population and food security. The conference that took place last week in Rome was not particularly successful.

Politics has quite a lot to do—from the credit crunch for small and medium-sized enterprises in our own country to the large international conferences and the precautions regarding the regulations that make large agreements possible—and must bundle quite a lot. But the more we succeed in this, the better. It is good that we have already started thinking in these categories with our Sustainability Council and the national sustainability strategy. Strengthening this way of thinking will become increasingly important in the future.

We encourage the Parliamentary Advisory Council for Sustainable Development in the Bundestag to be tasked with overseeing the sustainability assessment. This will have the side effect of further entrenching this way of thinking in the parliamentary sphere. Today, when we talk about sustainability, we have a certain tendency to write specific target functions into the Basic Law; that is nice, but it alone is not enough. In this respect, we need to be a bit more specific.

In 2010, the next report from the Federal Statistical Office on sustainability indicators will be published. This will again have a lot to do with our standards for growth. In 2012, the next progress report will follow. I hope and believe that you are among those pressing for these processes. I would like to thank you once again for that.

I will try to contribute, and the federal government will try to contribute, to making thinking in terms of sustainability a matter of course for future generations.