Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Congress of Süddeutsche Zeitung "Leadership Meeting Economy 2009" on November 20, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

20 November 2009 · Leadership Meeting Economy 2009 (Süddeutsche Zeitung Congress) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Süddeutsche Zeitung Leadership Meeting Economy 2009 congress in Berlin on November 20, 2009, discussing the economic crisis and European affairs.
Main themes
International economic crisis, European Union leadership and consensus, Germany's economic downturn, growth strategy, banking sector weaknesses, short-time work and labor market, G20 and global governance, Lisbon Treaty, export regions and industrial base, exit strategies from recession
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,338
88th percentile
Sentences
213
90th percentile
Readability
52
67th percentile
Grade
10.9
31st percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%56%
  • Institutional 16%15%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

213 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be here today. I do not know if I can comprehensively answer all the questions you have raised, but I wish you good, intense discussions in the further course of the Süddeutsche Zeitung Congress! I believe it is important to have such intergenerational forums with young people. With my presence, I at least want to emphasize that this is a very commendable and, in fact, already established concern.

Regarding the personnel decisions from yesterday, you cannot expect someone, about whom so much has already been written regarding what he certainly cannot do, to say anything negative about those you do not yet know. In this respect: Just give people a chance. Europe has 27 member states. You can always choose between controversies – and perhaps a more recognizable profile from the outside – or the attempt to keep this Europe together. There have been phases when Europe did not march together. Those were not the best phases for Europe. In this respect, we made a decision that certainly gave a very high priority to consensus. We were not obliged to do so. According to the Lisbon Treaty, decisions can also be made by majority. But the first decision – at least that was the overwhelming wish – should be one that can be supported by all.

I believe we agree that Europe is without any reasonable alternative, even regarding what you have to discuss here. 80 million Germans is not a small number. While we are the largest economy in the European Union, you only need to attend a G20 meeting to realize that there are individual representatives for over 1.1 or 1.3 billion people in the world. The European Union will have to learn that if it wants to have a say in the long term with its 500 million inhabitants, it must do so together and with one voice. Therefore, the attempt to name personalities who are also guarantors for this was certainly an effort worth making.

The congress is taking place at a time when the international economic crisis has not been overcome. I suspect that the economic crisis will occupy us for quite some time. Germany has experienced an economic downturn or will experience one this year, unlike anything seen in the 60 years of the history of the Federal Republic of Germany. Sometimes I have the impression that this has not yet fully registered with everyone. During the oil crisis, we had an economic development of minus 0.9 percent. This year, according to everything we know, it will be at least minus 4.5 percent. Even if it were only minus 4.3 percent, that would still be dramatic.

This crisis is associated with something we do not usually see in crises that arise internally, namely the fact that the strongest regions of Germany are affected because they are largely export regions. If you look at the short-time work atlas, you will find that the crisis regions are primarily in Baden-Württemberg, Bavaria – of course also elsewhere – and that there are the largest clusters of short-time work due to the crisis.

We find that we have prevented the world from an economic collapse through coordinated and reasonable economic measures. We have certainly drawn the right lessons from the events of past decades – especially from those of the Great Depression of the 20th century. However, there is still much debate about how, for example, the exit scenarios must be designed. We must continue to analyze together what the lessons of this crisis are. The capacities of our companies are by no means fully utilized again. The effects on the labor market will not be absent.

When you look at the banking location Germany, you will find that its weaknesses have also become apparent. We do not have an overdeveloped banking landscape compared to our industrial base; I say this very cautiously.

It is divided into three pillars; I do not want to elaborate on this now, I will only mention one element: The state banks have proven to be extremely fragile, but they have been involved in every major industrial financing in the consortia over the last ten years. If their effectiveness is noticeably absent for a longer period and at the same time international banks do not return sufficiently to Germany, then there are certainly still many problems ahead of us.

As the new federal government, we have set ourselves the goal of pursuing a growth strategy with four core elements.

While one can talk for a long time about sustainable growth, our goal is first and foremost to get out of the valley as quickly and efficiently as possible so that we can reconnect to the level of 2007/2008. We know: In normal economic development years, we need growth of one to 1.5 percent to keep the number of employees in Germany constant, as the efficiency of economic activity continues to develop. If we reach the level of 2008 again in 2013 – according to economic forecasts – then you can imagine what that means for employment policy. While demographics help us a bit in this regard, it is overall an extraordinarily serious situation in which we find ourselves. We know: When the acute phase of the crisis eases somewhat, it will become increasingly difficult to make clear in what crisis situation we still find ourselves.

For the growth strategy, the element of credit supply is of crucial importance. You will also discuss the banking sector later. A functioning credit supply is like water to the mills of the economy. There are also significant concerns here. We have stabilized the financial markets with the SoFFin. In the European currency area, and even more so in the American one, very large amounts of money – at least regarding short-term loans – are still being channeled into the economic cycle. What arises from this and whether new dangers lurk within it can be better identified by experts. In this regard, we need to think about exit strategies, especially coordinated exit strategies, because we need a level playing field between the American and European markets. If we do not achieve this, it is again possible to earn a lot of money due to existing differences, so that in the end, there is no business activity left for the real economy because they can engage all day between government bonds and differences in the world economy and make money, while those for whom the banks should still be there fall by the wayside again. Therefore, I encourage, if I may, the representatives of the real economy to speak frankly with the banks. Because when the real economy withers, the banks are also not as eager to do business anymore, as they ultimately need an industrial base. This cannot all be done by politics; a clear word from the real economy would therefore be very welcome to me. I am looking at Mr. Leibinger, who is also famous for clear statements.

The credit conditions have deteriorated significantly for many companies. This is partly due to the fact that Basel II has now come into full effect at the beginning of this year. This means that the controls and assessments of a company's creditworthiness have become stricter in the midst of the crisis. Some medium-sized companies already have to do a lot of preliminary work or pay so many fees to the bank so that they can perform this preliminary work for the assessment, which, while not fundamentally bad, does not make the work any easier now, in the midst of the crisis. While I am aware of the tension faced by banks, that they should learn from their failures and that we cannot encourage them to grant even looser loans, we must somehow deal with this tension.

The federal government will appoint a credit mediator. We must then continue this regionally because it cannot be done from a central location. For this, we need the willingness of all to ensure that the growth forces in the country do not completely wither away. This leads to the question of what the budget policy of the individual countries looks like in the long term. I will say something about this in the third or fourth point of my growth strategy, but first, I will address the question of what else we can do for growth.

The federal government has decided to set growth impulses also in the tax area. This is being discussed very controversially. I am sometimes a bit surprised at the extent of this discussion, because when one says that all taxpayers are a clientele in Germany, that is quite a significant clientele. Recently, in this context, I said in discussions with the German Trade Union Confederation: This clientele also includes many members of the individual trade unions and very good skilled workers. When you look at the fairness of the German tax system, you find that in the area where most taxpayers are located, the progression rises so unfairly that the goal of making the German tax system fairer must not be abandoned – and that is what the coalition has set out to do.

We are dealing with an interesting situation. We have gained a majority and are doing what we said before the election; we are implementing it. Usually, after elections, the situation is that something else is done. While at the beginning of the last legislative period, the SPD criticized me because the CDU wanted to raise the value-added tax, the Grand Coalition then raised it even more than the CDU wanted. But if one creates a majority with open eyes, looks at the FDP programs, and then says: "It is outrageous that they are now doing what they told us!", then we must be careful. I suspect that people do not hear everything we say, but they do listen somewhere. And the idea that one has a bit more net from their gross is quite popular in Germany.

In this respect, we are now taking first steps and next year further ones that we consider right and necessary. In this context, the change in the area of corporate tax reform, which mitigates the crisis-enhancing elements, is essential. That we want to go a bit further in this regard, we said before the election. I believe it is right to change the wage sum regulation in inheritance tax because it cannot be assumed that the wage sums will remain or increase in the coming years. I see no sense in viewing family businesses, which want to manage the generational transition, with particular mistrust. We can be glad about anyone who takes this step and finds their way into the entrepreneurship of the next generation. I believe we all agree that the medium-sized businesses, which are strongly characterized by family businesses, are one of Germany's great strengths, as they have also consistently produced a high level of innovation.

We will once again increase family benefits. In this regard, it will be necessary to raise the tax allowances, although many say that this will only affect the rich again. However, I want to point out that this is combined with an increase in child benefits. We have the idea of a structural reform of the German tax system so that children and adults are treated equally in the tax system in the medium term. This has something to do with the idea of fairness. I do not think it is wrong for a child to receive the same tax allowance as an adult, which leads to families being treated more fairly in tax law.

The tax allowance has little to do with child benefits but is always mentioned together with child benefits. Since there is a difference between not taking something away from someone and giving something to someone, child benefits will be increased by 20 euros. Now it is said that this would not be necessary at all and that the money should rather go into education. I would like to draw your attention to the following fact: The Hartz IV rate for younger children is 224, while child benefits are at 164 euros. If we continue to let this gap grow, it will lead to the incentive to take up work becoming proportionally lower with the number of children; one must then earn more and more for it to be worthwhile to come out of the transfer payment. This means there is an inherent interest in bringing child benefits as close as possible to the Hartz IV rate so that the number of children does not determine whether it is worthwhile to work again or not. In this respect, this is a regulatory issue that, in my opinion, is not sufficiently taken into account.

At the beginning of 2011, we will take another fiscal step that essentially serves to straighten out the middle-class bulge. The coalition partner has emphasized that this will be achieved through the gradual introduction of a tiered tax system. The coalition agreement leaves the number and type of tiers open, as this needs to be examined to ensure that we do not create injustices with the finite volumes we have available for relief. This must be developed with the principle of fairness in mind.

The third theme of growth forces concerns education and research as a whole. On the part of the federal government, we will achieve the three percent target for research spending in 2010. This means we will invest three percent of gross domestic product in research. The distribution is based on the following: one third federal, one third states, one third the economy. We will also introduce tax incentives for research services, as many of the programs we offer do not benefit small and medium-sized enterprises well. There is tax support for research in many European countries. One can discuss whether there are abuse effects. The fact is that our neighboring countries promote research services, which is why many German companies choose to conduct research abroad in Europe.

In the coalition agreement, we have established that over the next four years, we will contribute to ensuring that by 2015, seven percent of gross domestic product is spent on education. This has been fundamentally agreed upon with the states. The specifics still need to be worked out. While there are many suggestions regarding what we could do in the education sector at the federal level, this must be discussed intensively with the states, as the goal must be to invest where the educational emergency is greatest. When one looks at the fact that today there are children with educational competency levels of 0 and 1, meaning very low competencies, it becomes clear that money is certainly best invested in these areas.

If we want to connect the idea of sustainability with the idea of growth, we must, of course, look at the population development of the Federal Republic of Germany. The Federal Statistical Office has examined the population development for the Federal Republic of Germany up to the year 2060, that is, for the next 50 years. How many children are born in Germany will significantly determine our future. Today, the birth rate is about 1.38. The decision about whether we will fall to a birth rate of 1.2 or rise to 1.6 will make a difference of around five million people in Germany by 2060. One must therefore know what one is talking about. The number of under-25s in Germany will decrease by 3.5 million between 2007 and 2020. This is a decline of about 15 percent in this age group over 13 years, while the total population changes by only two percent. When one considers that the proportion of young people with a migration background in this group of under-25s is continuously increasing, it becomes clear where we need to focus our education policy. Therefore, it is urgently necessary for us to reach an agreement with the states on how we want to approach this educational task.

Last year, we succeeded in pushing through some obvious measures in tough negotiations, for example, that the Federal Employment Agency has access to schools to conduct career counseling, that the number of school dropouts should be halved by 2012, and that language tests will be introduced before children enter school to find out whether they can even understand the teacher. This is not only aimed at migrant children but also at children who come from a traditional German family. We have huge tasks ahead of us, and we cannot afford to have young people leaving school in droves after ten years, only for the economy to find that they unfortunately have not reached the level required to learn a modern vocational profession. All of this are essential issues.

Fortunately, we have agreed on a higher education pact with the states. When one looks at what is currently happening at universities, it becomes clear that the introduction of bachelor’s and master’s programs highlights the gaps in the German education system very clearly. Of course, the training programs have become more "school-like" due to the bachelor’s system. This is particularly evident in many humanities fields. Furthermore, it becomes apparent that the number of seminar places is insufficient and that it is hardly possible to complete the seminars within the existing and designated time frame. Urgent action must be taken in this regard. Therefore, the higher education pacts that we have concluded with the states over many years are of utmost importance.

Research institutions have gained a high degree of planning security through research pacts and the excellence initiative. We know how important research is for future-proof products. This is, of course, also true with regard to climate protection and new environmental technologies. Therefore, I want to say at this point: Germany will do everything to ensure that Copenhagen is a success. I believe that environmental technologies are a huge growth area. This has become widely recognized. The only question is whether countries that started later, such as the United States, will not try to buy time with very ambitious measures to reach a technological level that some competitors are already at today. These are very interesting competitive questions that lead to conflicts of interest between national interests and global necessities.

An important point will also be what happens with the emerging countries. Even if all of Europe and the United States have no CO2 emissions by 2050, this will not be enough to achieve the two-degree target for global warming. We also need commitments from emerging countries in this regard; otherwise, this goal cannot be achieved. I know that it is often said in business circles that climate change has always existed. – That is true. The world has experienced much greater climate fluctuations. The only question is, what does it cost us? There has never been a world so densely populated. There has never been such a fragile technology and civilization along the coastlines. Therefore, the costs – as the Stern Report has made very clear – are beyond the two-degree target. They would be so high for adapting to climate change that one should seriously consider investing smaller amounts in advance to keep adaptation costs as low as possible.

The fourth point is directly related to the laws of growth that we want to implement in terms of economic stimulus through the use of funds and concerns budget consolidation. The medium-term development of budgets will show whether we are drawing the right lessons from this crisis. Before the economic crisis, we were on a path where Germany would have had a balanced federal budget in 2011. At the state level, we had a balanced overall budget for two years, but the international economic crisis has put an end to that for the time being.

It is important that we combat structural deficits. Therefore, Germany has set very strict guidelines for the times after 2015 during the crisis – I believe Germany is the only country in the world that has done something like this; I do not know of any other – with very strict measures. From 2016, the federal government is constitutionally obligated to allow new borrowing of only a maximum of 0.35 percent of gross domestic product; the states from 2020 zero. Of course, we have to allow for exceptions, so that if another international economic crisis or a natural disaster occurs, we can respond. But the definitions are very clear. This is also not left vague in the constitution. We are tasked, starting in 2011 – one must see how the economy develops – under normal conditions to reduce the structural debt, which according to our current calculations will amount to about 60 billion euros, to 0.35 percent of gross domestic product by 2016 in equal steps.

We live with this task; we are aware of it. Federal Minister of Finance Wolfgang Schäuble will initiate the corresponding measures. We must do this because the requirements of the debt brake are very compatible with the demands of the Stability and Growth Pact. The European Stability and Growth Pact must not be called into question. I say this explicitly because otherwise, the acceptance and also the strength of the euro will be severely affected. We already have enough problems. Therefore, Germany will continue to be a country that will fight very hard for compliance with this Stability and Growth Pact.

As for the international lessons from this crisis, we are currently in a phase where much has been initiated for better regulation. With the exit from the acute form of the crisis, we are also in a phase where some in the financial sector are already – to put it mildly – taking quite a big risk. We politicians find ourselves in a not entirely trivial situation. On the one hand, we are not financial market experts. This means that one can easily tell us with every regulation: Now you are doing the wrong thing; we will immediately prove to you how we can circumvent all of this, and so on. On the other hand, we have learned that it brings absolutely no blessing to always listen to the banks, because otherwise the crisis should not have happened. All our statements made in the years prior were dismissed with a tired smile and the saying: 'Don’t talk about things you know nothing about!' In this respect, it is a very serious situation.

I can only say the following today: If we find ourselves in such a crisis again in the foreseeable future, there will come a point when states can no longer help because they will no longer be able to obtain legitimate majorities for it. The people have forgiven us once again for perhaps not knowing. But according to all the crisis forecasts, which are always calculated with wonderful statistical models, it should only happen once every 200 years, what we have already experienced twice within ten years with the Asian crisis and the last international crisis. Therefore, I can only urgently ask to remain on a constructive path. Establishing a fund from a mix of tax and bank funds to be prepared for the next catastrophe is not enough – I say this very clearly.

This naturally also touches on the question of the extent to which industrialized nations are willing to give authority and determination to international, multilateral organizations. The willingness in this regard varies. We Europeans are used to Brussels having a lot to say. I have also been annoyed by the competition commission. But if we had not had European competition law during this crisis, there would already be protectionism within Europe that one could not have imagined. Therefore, one is quite glad that there is a neutral institution that repeatedly calls us to order.

The question will arise as to whether China, the United States, or India are willing, for example, to give the IMF more power and possibly simultaneously waive their own veto rights. At this point, we still have a very thick plank to drill. I am deeply convinced that global markets also need a global regulatory framework. We have had stellar moments, for example, with the establishment of the World Trade Organization and the creation of a sanctions mechanism, a dispute resolution mechanism. That has worked. But such bold steps will also need to be taken in other respects – I am convinced of that.

Since, without wanting to offend the Süddeutsche Zeitung, large parts of opinion formation and also evaluations by rating agencies take place in the Anglo-Saxon world, every half-critical word directed at the Fed or American financial markets is always accompanied by the corresponding tremolo for days. The statement about how little politicians know can always be easily made. Therefore, I say to those who are here in the room and are largely shaped by the principles of the social market economy: For the stability of our societies – let us be reasonable! Even then, one still does not have to forgo profit. We will diligently continue to work on implementing the rules.

There is much to be done. It is an incredibly exciting time. I have repeatedly said that in this crisis the cards are being reshuffled. How Germany emerges from this crisis is not yet decided. If you look at what is being invested in electromobility in China, for example, and how proud we are of our half a billion, and how we are all researching in 25 configurations across different departments in various countries, while the Chinese approach all of this with a fairly centralized structure, then the question of the competitiveness of our diversified systems becomes very clear. I believe that, in the end, learning, flexible systems are more competitive. But we cannot rest on our laurels because of this; rather, we must make an effort. Then we also have good chances.

I wish you a pleasant congress and thank you for the invitation!