Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Magazine Days of the Association of German Magazine Publishers (VDZ) on November 17, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 November 2009 · Magazine Days of the Association of German Magazine Publishers (VDZ) · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the VDZ Magazine Days conference in Berlin on November 17, 2009, reflecting on press freedom, digital transformation, and the 20th anniversary of the Berlin Wall's fall.
Main themes
Freedom of expression, digital media transformation, press freedom and democracy, fall of the Berlin Wall anniversary, publishing industry challenges, information freedom under dictatorship, business models for media, political and media relations, technological change in publishing
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,816
84th percentile
Sentences
223
91st percentile
Readability
52
70th percentile
Grade
10.1
21st percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 43%42%
  • Economic 24%23%
  • Institutional 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

223 sentences in 43 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

I am pleased to be with you once again. It has almost become a tradition. This is also due to the fact that you are an industry that always has an ear to the pulse of the times, which is intertwined with societal and technological changes in a way that is unparalleled, especially since you are situated in a core area of our society. Freedom of expression and information are the foundations of a free democracy.

Professor Burda has tirelessly been bringing to our attention, with increasing success, that we are in a revolutionary phase comparable to the invention of the printing press, that the life of our generation is changing, but that the life of future generations will change in a much more comprehensive way. It is changing not only in the area we are discussing today but in the entire shaping of our lives.

You have rightly chosen the motto "New Times, New Ways." It is true that anyone who has anything else to do besides dealing with technological developments must be careful not to lose their footing but to keep up, and not just theoretically, but also in practical application.

Therefore, I want to simply begin by saying: We need a free press – regardless of how the technical possibilities are given. Freedom is something that, in this month of November 2009, is once again brought to our attention by the fact that until a few years ago, unfreedom in our regions was something quite normal.

You spent "Publishers' Night" yesterday with Mikhail Gorbachev, who contributed to making November 9 a happy day. I remember that on the 10th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall, which was celebrated in no way as opulently as the 20th, there was a discussion at Springer with Mikhail Gorbachev, Helmut Kohl, and George Bush Sr. At that time, Mikhail Gorbachev was asked what he had done that night. I will never forget it. He said: "Ja prosnulza." Translated, it means: "I slept through it." No one woke him up. He had created an environment that knew that this process would not lead him to deploy tanks.

The fall of the Berlin Wall has many mothers and fathers. Certainly, much also originated from those who lived in the dictatorial systems in Poland, Czechoslovakia, and other countries. Freedom of expression was also a driving force. We should not forget that.

In the former GDR, the duplication of information was one of the hottest issues. You can probably hardly imagine it. For example, if we needed a copy at the Academy of Sciences, one could not use a copier oneself but had to go to a specific place in the institute. There, for 800 people, there was a "copy lady" who was tasked with operating a machine. One had to stand in line and could have certain scientific publications copied. That was basically one of the most secret and best-monitored corners. Those who had good relations with the lady and could, for example, copy a few more pages were in a good position. Today, one can hardly imagine that. But back then, any kind of copying was difficult. That is why, in my life, the blue paper on the typewriter played a significant role. If one had a copy of certain things, it was already close to treason.

Freedom of expression was the pivot around which the difference between dictatorship and freedom revolved. Therefore, the technological developments that emerged in the 1980s were, in my firm conviction, one of the driving forces behind why information could no longer be kept so secret. Today, we see that some countries are doing many, many acrobatics to create blockades on the internet at "Twitter" and similar platforms.

Freedom is constitutive. Freedom of expression is part of it. You stand for that. That is why it is so important that the relationship between politics and the media is based on the firm foundation that freedom of expression is an essential component of our democracy. This means: As media producers, you are committed to the truth. Media can only function and truly thrive in enlightened societies. This means your interest is a well-educated population capable of dealing with the plurality of opinions. Therefore, the intensive dialogue between us is, of course, of utmost importance. I know that the media is in good hands with you, that you approach your tasks with a high professional ethos – individual cases should never be generalized. But this principle is – as is evident in your association – firmly anchored.

Professor Burda has rightly pointed out: With pure idealism and a commitment to freedom alone, one cannot sustainably produce profitable media. You are economically committed to success. You have to assert yourselves in a tough competition. Therefore, the business models that provide a sufficient financial basis and then also offer the best possible quality are of crucial importance.

Thus, the change in the technical area between classic newspapers and magazines and the digital media world is, on the one hand, an opportunity for a wonderful complement, but on the other hand, also a significant challenge for you. As with all technological developments, it is certainly the case that if one blocks off and does not face the challenges, it is not possible to remain economically successful. But facing the challenges is a new prerequisite for maintaining quality in the increasingly competitive environment and not letting it fall by the wayside.

It is the case, and we will all have to live with it, that short-term, sensational information may occupy us longer, and it takes a long time to bring such things back to a normal level. You must also deal with that. This means there exists a tension between a briefly researched, sensational piece of information and a long and thoroughly researched, proper contribution. Everyone must learn to deal with that; politics, by the way, as well. Therefore, the question "How can we provide you with political frameworks in which quality has a chance?" is one of the questions we are in constant dialogue about.

The living environment of the people with whom you are in contact through your products has, of course, also changed. The loss of certainties that have been passed down for generations burdens many people. Globalization leads us to confront a multitude of cultural realities that are difficult to overview. I am quite sure that the next generations will grow into this very differently and will also be able to handle it more easily. But we still need to practice how the global community grows together.

We all have, beyond rationality, a good feeling for Germany. We are beginning to develop this feeling for Europe. But for the entire world, it is still very difficult. There are certainly many large blank spots on the world map for many people. Little can be said about the culture, tradition, history, and living environment of people in other parts of the world.

We are confronted with completely new risks. The close exchange of people across the globe leads to threats that make our system more fragile. This can also be seen in the example of the new flu. Questions arise here as well. Should I get vaccinated? Should I not get vaccinated? How do I deal with it? Is it the so-called pharmaceutical lobby that is forcing vaccines on us again? Is it perhaps more sensible to get vaccinated? I tend towards the latter, to make that clear once again.

All of this concerns people. Daily emerging information must be brought to people – preferably as quality information. There is a sea of information. People must learn to cope with the flood of information. We are grateful when those who produce media help us a little with that.

The much-quoted journalistic advice from Joseph Pulitzer "Write briefly – and they will read it. Write clearly – and they will understand it. Write vividly – and they will remember it." probably applies to all forms of new media, as long as reading is still in demand and not everything is conveyed through images. I suspect that reading and the individual letter will continue to retain their significance.

I believe the foundation is that we do have a joy in understanding something. The question is how far understanding the new through reading is still feasible. Therefore, I belong to those who say: Those who are well-versed in traditional media will be able to handle new media better and will be able to absorb them, capable of turning reading into new thinking and gaining new insights. Those who can do that are equipped with the basic skills to navigate better in the new internet world. However, this is an opinion that is not shared everywhere. Some young people today try it in the opposite way.

We need the classic distribution structures. So that you do not think it is no longer valid if it is not mentioned, I want to make it clear once again: The press Grosso is indispensable for our media order. Your association, the Federal Association of German Newspaper Publishers and the Federal Association of Press Grosso issued a so-called "Joint Declaration" in 2004 for the preservation of the Grosso distribution system. In light of recent discussions, I say: This agreement should remain a significant basis for cooperation between publishers and wholesalers. I consider this urgently necessary and required in the interest of press diversity and thus also in the interest of information and freedom of expression.

The state is constitutionally obliged to create suitable framework conditions for the media that meet the criteria of diversity and freedom. We, as the federal government, fulfill this task in various ways. The range extends from ensuring non-discriminatory technical access to transmission networks and information to shaping the international legal framework for the media. We currently have a lot to do in international processes. This will increase. Here, Europe will also increasingly emerge as an important player, although it does not yet function as well as we envision. When I look at Google regarding the digitization of books, European unity still leaves much to be desired.

In the coalition agreement, we reaffirmed our commitment to freedom of expression and media diversity. We want to review press cartel law and media concentration law. Everyone knows what is being talked about and what a minefield that is, if I may say so loosely. Therefore, I also say right away: The consensus of the industry is incredibly important for political decisions. This means the more you agree, the faster we can act. This should not be an excuse for us to never act because you never agree, but it is, so to speak, an encouragement for you to try to do the humanly possible. At some point, it will be to our detriment if we can no longer keep up with the times. Particularly the tension between German competition law and European competition law puts us in situations that can lead to truly unwanted decisions.

The new coalition has already received fundamental approval from your side on another legal issue, namely regarding the ancillary copyright for press publishers. I am aware of some concerns that exist among authors and, of course, especially in the internet community. However, an overwhelming mentality of free access is counterproductive to the economic success of press products. This does not serve press diversity. This means we must engage with this new protection right. It must, of course, be balanced to meet the interests of all parties involved – the authors, the publishers, the commercial users, and the end users. I know that this is much easier said than done. Here, too, I ask for active cooperation so that we can arrive at a reasonable legal basis in this highly charged context.

An appropriate protection of journalistic sources is also one of the perennial questions we must address. Journalists often receive information only if the informant can trust that their tips will remain confidential with the journalist. Therefore, we want to strengthen the protection against seizure for journalists. Furthermore, journalists should no longer be criminally liable for aiding and abetting the violation of a service secret when they publish material that has been confidentially provided to them.

There is also an intense discussion about whether journalists should enjoy the same protection under the right to refuse testimony as, for example, clergy, defense attorneys, or members of parliament. We will continue to pursue this question; I know that it is very sensitive. The interest of the public, the interest of victims of crimes, effective criminal justice – all of this must not be lost sight of. But here too, we are aware of the sensitivity and the circumstances surrounding journalists.

I believe that the protective rights – however we shape them – will never be a panacea for a diverse media landscape, even if they are important accompanying measures. It is also important for the diversity of the media landscape that newspapers and magazines remain affordable – especially in light of the many free offerings in online media.

This brings us to the nice topic of taxation and the question of reduced VAT rates. First, I want to say: We are not increasing anything. This means that what is, remains. The question can only be: Can the reduced VAT rate be extended to other areas? This concerns online press services. We will examine this. I cannot give you a definitive answer today.

One question will be: How can we differentiate between the areas for which either the reduced or the regular VAT rate should apply? The more you help us to identify the possibilities for differentiation, the easier it could be to approach an answer to this question – although we must be careful that the concept of basic needs is not expanded so much that, in the end, almost everything we have in our society is considered a basic need. We will have to deal with this.

Press products are therefore considered by us to be part of the basic needs of society. This determination is a contribution to ensuring that press products remain affordable, but of course, it is not the only one. Professor Burda has pointed out very clearly that advertising revenue is, so to speak, the conditio sine qua non for quality editorial offices. He has also kindly pointed out that those who live off this should perhaps be a bit more grateful in this regard.

When we talk about advertising, I also want to say: I will pursue the issue of energy labeling, which should always be printed, in the Environmental Council. Such decisions are often majority decisions in the EU these days; we no longer have the unique features we once had. I will certainly look into it.

Overall, I believe we agree: Consumer, health, and youth protection must be guaranteed. However, we also know that further restrictions on advertising are a massive attack on the diversity and quality of the media. We are also fundamentally opposed to making more and more regulations in this regard, based on fundamental considerations regarding the understanding of society and the maturity of citizens. At the moment, in connection with the change of government, we have a very interesting discussion about what we can actually expect from the "average citizen" – this is not meant negatively, but I mean it in the sense of the classical citizen – and how many state regulations are needed.

If every tax cut is disqualified by the argument: "Actually, the state should have said what the money is to be spent on, instead of giving the citizen the freedom to decide how to use it," then we reach a point where it becomes difficult. It is true: Not all people pay taxes. Therefore, we must also think about how the lives of those who do not pay taxes can be reasonably structured. We must do this especially because everyone pays social contributions from the first euro. This is a construction that is already very different compared to how other countries handle it. But disqualifying every increase in child benefits and tax allowances because one cannot trust the citizen to do something reasonable with the additional money is a reversal of the understanding of the mature citizen that I cannot support.

The same applies to the question of advertising. Our aim here must be to empower people through good education to deal with advertising, rather than restricting people's freedom of action through prohibitions to the point where they are completely limited in their decision-making. That cannot be right. This means we reject further restrictions. However, I also connect this with an appeal, namely the appeal that online advertising must be fair and transparent. In online advertising, we naturally have many more interactive elements. The individual citizen often does not know what data they are disclosing when they receive something seemingly for free. Here, a significant educational effort will certainly be necessary. Your contribution to this educational effort could be to transparently inform people about which personal information is made available with which step of using certain advertising offers, which can then be used elsewhere.

We must be careful not to swing between extremes in this tension – I would say, from what the Pirate Party represents to the regularly recurring alleged scandals in which data has been collected somewhere. Rather, we must try to find a path where the self-determination of the individual can be lived by showing them what information they disclose about themselves and when. Companies should therefore design online advertising fairly and transparently. This is especially true considering that young people and children today often have more technical skills than their parents to engage in these worlds. The importance of online advertising for financing and thus the existence of free internet offerings must still be emphasized. It would be completely wrong to say: We reject online advertising. However, regarding the design in the interest of maturity and transparency, there is still much to be done.

Media literacy – this emerges from everything I have said here – is becoming increasingly important. I would therefore like to thank you for continually launching a variety of projects with us and also independently to strengthen media literacy.

Political and social issues are undoubtedly topics that also find their place in newspapers and magazines – despite the enormous growth of electronic media and communication offerings. Much also aims – especially for your association – at a somewhat longer-lasting durability of information. In the constant succession of hourly changing online information, it is sometimes quite nice – at least at my age – to have things that last a week and that one can look back on for seven days. A longer period is almost excluded today. But now and then, there are still monthly magazines. We must therefore ensure that we continue the various communication and media offerings.

We appreciate everything you do in the area of youth to introduce young people to the media. We will continue to work with you in this area. In the media and communications report of the federal government in 2008, we were able to state: Those who do not read newspapers and magazines engage less critically with the internet than the traditionally literate user – I have already mentioned this at the beginning. Therefore, I would say: Print media and internet media should continue on the path of reconciliation. If you list our discussions and speeches over the past years on this topic, you can see that we are making progress. Some topics seem to have somehow resolved themselves. I do not know if peace has broken out between magazines and television providers, but there is not so much talk about it anymore. These were once very hot topics. Perhaps only other topics have temporarily moved to the forefront. I suspect that not everything is perfectly fine yet. However, there have certainly been forward-looking discussions. This will continue to be the case.

In our comprehensive political work, we are of course trying to improve the economic framework conditions. I have not further addressed the economic crisis in my speech. I believe you have also decided to somewhat ignore it in your approach. But we cannot completely ignore it. If the economic framework conditions do not improve worldwide, it will be a very difficult path for all of us. Therefore, the federal government is focusing on growth beyond media policy.

I, like the entire federal government, am indeed subjected to very critical scrutiny regarding the path we are taking. I just want to say: Do not forget, there has not been an economic downturn like the one we are currently experiencing in the 60 years of the Federal Republic. If it is now minus 4.5 percent and not, as predicted, minus 5 percent in economic growth, then we are already happy. But so far, in the 1970s, a minus of 0.9 percent was the heaviest and most severe. This year, the minus is at least five times higher. The question of how quickly we can get out of this will decide much. It will certainly also accelerate the transition to new media in your field. It is in our common interest – especially with regard to the advertising market and much that allows people to improve their standard of living – that we move forward quickly here. This includes for Germany openness to technology, friendliness towards technology, willingness to innovate, education, and future investments. These are also the things we give the highest priority to.

I must point out once again – I have already mentioned it in my government statement: In 2020, we will have 3.5 million fewer people under 25 than we had in 2007. This is a shrinkage of this age group of under 25 by 15 percent in 13 years. In the same period of these 13 years, the total population will shrink by only two percent. So you can see what is happening in our society. A large part, a growing part of those under 25 will also be young people with a migration background. This is also part of the change.

If we do not approach demographic change with much curiosity, with much willingness to innovate – especially in the older age groups – then our country will definitely fall behind. I do not want that, because that would also be bad news for you and for all those who are economic providers.

In this respect, we have a lot to do in the next four years and beyond to keep our country where it is. The strength is there, the ability is there. You contribute to this. Do it with interesting magazines and interesting online offerings.

Thank you for allowing me to be with you once again.