Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Energy Forum of the IHK Nord on February 17, 2009, in Neubrandenburg:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 February 2009 · Energy Forum of the IHK Nord · Neubrandenburg, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the IHK Nord Energy Forum in Neubrandenburg on February 17, 2009, discussing energy, trade, and Germany's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Energy policy, economic crisis response, financial market stabilization, export economy, German banking system, international trade, regional economic development, new federal states, IHK Nord cooperation, job creation, European internal market
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,227
87th percentile
Sentences
221
91st percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
10.8
30th percentile
Syntax
2.95
40th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 57%56%
  • Environmental 12%11%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

221 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Prime Minister, dear Mr. Sellering,

dear Mr. Mayor, dear Paul Krüger,

dear Mr. Ruprecht,

esteemed chamber presidents,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

Madam President of the State Parliament,

dear colleagues from the State Parliament,

esteemed guests,

I am, of course, very pleased to be back in Neubrandenburg today. I have been coming here regularly since my school days, as what is now part of Brandenburg, Templin, used to belong to the Neubrandenburg district. Therefore, this city has been familiar to me for a long time. I am also glad that the chambers of commerce from the North are meeting today not in Hamburg or Bremen, but have made the journey to Neubrandenburg. The city of four gates is a beautiful travel destination.

Neubrandenburg, with its four gates, is a city that has always stood for lively exchange with other cities and regions. The beauty of this place is also a testament to its long tradition and to the fact that the citizens of this city, who have built impressive places of worship, have not had to suffer from great poverty. Thus, Neubrandenburg is a place of openness to the world and cooperation, and is therefore exemplary of the fundamental idea of the IHK Nord, in which you have united and developed the North into a concentrated economic force. As someone who has his constituency in the North, I find it right and good that now and then a clear signal is also sent to the center and the south of the country: Here is strength, here is the future, and here is also the will to contribute to Germany's prosperity.

As an export nation, we know that we need the openness of world markets. There is currently an intense discussion within the European Union about this. We can be glad to have the European internal market and thus also institutions that ensure fair competition within Europe. In this context, the institution of the World Trade Organization must also be mentioned. However, its results often take a long time to materialize. This means we must also advocate for an open trade internationally.

We are currently in a special situation – as you have already mentioned. When we were invited here, we did not yet know to what extent the international crisis of the financial markets would also show its effects in Germany, now also in the form of an economic crisis. As an export nation, we feel these effects in a particularly strong way. This has also been made clear by the economic data from the first days of this year. However, I believe that we in the Federal Republic of Germany have enough experience to say: We can manage this, we will manage this. If we tackle this together, we have good potential and a solid foundation. Above all, we want to use the crisis to emerge from it stronger than we entered. In this respect, the topics you are addressing today are indeed future topics.

We can say – this has been felt and seen particularly in the new federal states – that significant progress has been made in the last three years. This has been reflected in an employment situation that, while still not what we desire in the new federal states, has improved. It has also shown: When the economy grows, when we have a strong economy, more jobs come to us again. This is then also an opportunity for the people. We must take this as a starting point in this crisis and then try to build as many bridges as possible into a new era in which there is again economic growth.

The starting point of the current situation was the banking crisis. I want to say at this point: We did the right thing with the Financial Market Stabilization Act; the collapse of the banking system has been prevented, but the crisis of the banks is not yet over. Therefore, we must, especially in the work of the federal government, actually deal daily with the question: How do we return to a state in which the cycle of financial systems works in a way that is truly helpful for you as entrepreneurs?

This crisis shows that it is good to have a three-pillar model in which savings banks and cooperative banks make an important contribution. But we also know that for investments in a longer-term area and also for interregional investments, the savings bank system and the system of cooperative banks alone are not sufficient. This means we also need banks that operate on a regional level. Therefore, the federal government must repeatedly discuss the question: How can we achieve further progress here?

In a discussion, we are dealing – I will only touch on this briefly – with the question: What do we do with banks like Hypo Real Estate, which on the one hand are systemically relevant, but on the other hand have the potential to demand new guarantees or even liquidity from us every day or every week? We have promised internationally: Something like what happened with Lehman Brothers must never happen again. We must therefore protect banks from insolvency, but we must also handle taxpayers' money sensibly and frugally. This means we must find ways to achieve the goal without unduly burdening the taxpayer.

This requires, measured against the classical paths of a market economy, quite unorthodox thinking. We do this not to undermine the market economy – that is sheer nonsense; I want to make this very clear again – but we do this to get the market economy functioning again. I keep saying: I actually had the chance to experience state-owned enterprises for 35 years. I was glad to have largely escaped that with German reunification. Therefore, I will gladly release any bank that is again functionally independent into market freedom. But to handle taxpayers' money frugally, we must now, for example, ensure that we obtain a state control majority in the case of Hypo Real Estate if necessary – of course in the least intrusive way possible – and then manage the realization in state custody in such a way that it does not become a bottomless pit.

The second point being discussed is the so-called bad banks, into which the bad assets of the banks are to be outsourced. I advocate that we do not relieve the banks of their responsibility. They must make this division themselves. It makes no sense to hand over an anonymized collection of bad risks to the state. The state can neither manage these things well on its own, nor can it be willing to take on the bad and leave the good with the banks, only to then see that the shareholders return to the profit margin while it is left sitting on the remnants. That would not be in the interest of the taxpayer.

I believe that with these directions we can make progress. Nevertheless, the work in the banking sector is not yet done. It must be done, because if the financial cycles do not get back on track, all the packages of measures we implement to stimulate economic growth or to dampen the recession will have no chance of working.

Now, on the part of the federal government, together with the federal states – the Prime Minister was also in the German Bundestag and spoke there – we put together a package of measures last week, with which amounts in the order of 1.5 percent of gross domestic product for the years 2009 and 2010 will be deployed to counter the economic downturn. In putting together this package of measures, we focused on the future and said: We want to preserve as many jobs as possible in this crisis. This is, of course, only a bridge. The state cannot completely undo an economic crisis of international dimensions. But what is within its power, it can use to counteract. We have fulfilled this responsibility.

In this respect, we are in a very good position on a European scale. Because apart from the fact that we are deploying twice 1.5 percent of gross domestic product, particularly for investments, it should also be added that the so-called automatic stabilizers in Germany have a very helpful effect. The automatic stabilizers are the benefits that come through the social security systems to the people and thus affect consumption. Due to the relatively good wage development last year, we will have a decent pension increase as well as an increase in Hartz IV rates. This means that money will flow back into circulation through the social security systems and support the citizens. This has virtually the same effect as if we were to implement tax cuts for them. Thus, Germany ranks well in the statistics of the European Union in terms of counter-cyclical measures. We are also making our contribution to Europe; this must be said from time to time.

We have now structured our package of measures in such a way that it targets companies and jobs. Therefore, there is a guarantee umbrella to provide guarantees to viable companies that have a positive outlook but are facing difficulties due to certain developments in the credit markets. That this is the subject of many discussions goes without saying. I want to emphasize once again at this point: We have long-standing experience in export business with export guarantees. It is not as if a guarantee framework at the KfW Development Bank is being invented for the first time now. We also have instruments for guarantees at the state development banks. Anyone who, like me, is familiar with shipbuilding and similar industries has already dealt with guarantees even before the financial crisis.

However, we must, of course, ensure that no distortions of competition arise now. This means we will not abandon the house bank principle, as we still consider the house bank to be the bank that can best make a forecast about the company's development. In general, we will also expect that a small part of the risk must be borne by the house bank, but given the difficult credit situation, a larger part can be guaranteed by the KfW.

By the way – this is important for the IHK – we launched a small and medium-sized enterprises program last year. We are also discussing necessary small improvements in this regard, as this program is not so easy for companies to access. However, it must always be made clear that we want to protect every job, not just in large companies. All our regulations are designed so that every company can take advantage of the protection options – from short-time work to the guarantee framework. It is not the case that only the large ones are helped and the small ones are left behind.

Next, I would like to address the instrument of short-time work. The regulations we have established in this regard – half of the additional wage costs being covered or 100 percent of the additional wage costs being covered if companies continue to qualify their employees – are regarded in Europe as very innovative. The guideline here was and is: We want to emerge from this crisis stronger than we entered it. I believe that a good collaboration with the Federal Employment Agency will be possible here. I urge all companies that can afford it to take advantage of these offers. It is about a bridging function and about the assumption that we will have a better economic development again in the foreseeable future.

If we look around – not just in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, but throughout Germany – we see that demographic change will be one of the most important issues from the middle of the next decade. We are already feeling this massively today. Skilled workers, qualified citizens – the human capital, as it is beautifully called in economic language – are the treasure of our country. We must not lose them in this crisis, but must give them a professional connection, just as we should give young people a chance to secure training positions this year as well. In a few years, they will be in short supply throughout Germany.

In addition to the topics of guarantee frameworks and short-time work, there is also the topic of infrastructure measures. I sense great anticipation everywhere and also hope for a smile on the face of the mayor. Certainly, the state has already distributed the funds almost completely.

We have said that we want to invest two-thirds of the funds from the federal and state governments in education, that is, in improving educational conditions – starting from kindergartens to schools to universities and colleges. I believe this is a proper investment in the future. Otherwise, ongoing projects should not be stopped, but should continue smoothly and take on additional tasks. This is what we have fought hard for.

But I must also tell you – there is much mockery of our federal community and much criticism: When the need arises – as was demonstrated both in the autumn with the Financial Market Stabilization Act and now in the discussions about this investment package – the federal government and the states have repeatedly found the strength to negotiate very quickly and results-oriented for the good of our country. What has been achieved in terms of legislative procedures and administrative agreements in the shortest time is impressive. This shows that there is a great deal of commonality when working for this country.

The municipalities are also significant beneficiaries of this program out of conviction, because we believe that municipal self-administration has the strength to quickly initiate visible projects and thereby show the people that the state is not inactive, but is investing in our future.

In our economic stimulus program, there is a relief package that concerns the reduction of wage-related costs. With this, we will again be below 40 percent, including the employee contribution. This has been a long-standing demand of the economy. This helps you, along with the corporate tax reform, to some extent, considering that wage-related costs were already significantly higher.

We are also approaching a socio-political goal with the tax financing in the healthcare system, namely that the healthcare costs of children are borne by the taxpayer and not by the employee who pays contributions. I believe this is also appropriate because children are truly the future of us all.

We have also made a certain contribution in the tax area because we know that due to cold progression, what is earned more is becoming less and less visible in the wallets of individual employees. In this respect, it is a very balanced program.

The most controversial measure from an economic policy perspective is the one that is the most visible and works best. This is the so-called environmental premium, commonly referred to as the scrapping premium. People understood this very quickly. By the way, we have shown with this example that we are an open-minded country. There are some tendencies in other European countries to only allow small cars for new purchases. We have said: We do not care what type of car people choose when they buy a new car. We benefit from the European market. If someone in Europe benefits from what is purchased here, then that is simply the right response to the general openness of the markets.

In addition, there are research components, especially for medium-sized companies. I ask the chambers of commerce and industry to take a close look at what research opportunities we enable, because in times of crisis and liquidity shortages, there is a trend to save on things that are not essential. However, we want medium-sized companies to continue investing in research.

We have – and I believe we would not have achieved this without this crisis; the Minister-President of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern was not enthusiastic about it at all times – made provisions for the future in the form of an agreement on a debt brake in the Basic Law. This is, as I would say, an extremely ambitious undertaking. Today, it is sometimes talked about very casually that no new debts will be taken on until 2020.

I believe it is a correct setting of the course. But it is one that will still occupy all of us, both at the federal and state levels. We have no alternative. Today, at the federal level, we pay 15 percent, or 15 cents in interest on borrowed debts for every euro we collect from taxpayers. We must get out of further indebtedness, otherwise, we will not be able to keep up in a dynamically developing world in developing new creative and innovative products, even though we will have an increasing need for innovations due to the aging population and fewer young people. However, the path to curbing new debt will not be easy and will require many efforts from all of us.

Shaping the future – that is also your topic today in particular – in the form of energy policy. Energy policy is for a country like Germany what the treatment of the blood circulation is for an organism. We need a country with a strong energy policy that focuses on diversification as much as possible. I do not want to talk further about the political differences regarding the operating times of nuclear power plants. My opinion on this is known. Let us see how this develops further. But it is also true: One cannot create an energy policy solely with the topic of nuclear energy.

You have rightly pointed out that a number of power plants will go offline in the coming years – both coal and nuclear power plants – and that there is a high need for innovation. We are experiencing that the acceptance of new constructions in the energy sector is declining. Everywhere in the Federal Republic of Germany, including Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, the construction of a coal power plant is no longer as trivial as it once was. I think it is fair to say politically: We cannot exit from all energy sources that seem unacceptable to us in any way.

Renewable energies will have a large share. There is no question about that. Especially in a country like Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, this will increase. We are, of course, also working on storage options. This means that one can achieve better bridging when the base load is not feasible. The most exciting innovation question is certainly the storage of electrons. How can this be improved both in terms of electromobility and in terms of fluctuations in energy generation? Whoever has the big new idea will make an important contribution not only to the future of our country but to many countries.

But we cannot build on the principle of hope. Things take longer. We have already seen with fusion that everything does not develop as quickly as we believe it should. Therefore, it is good if we have scenarios for how energy consumption develops. The federal government has done this. It is important that this is also done for the federal states.

We will have significant fluctuations due to the increase in renewable energies regarding electricity production. For example, we know today that between a quarter and a third of electricity comes from nuclear power plants. In Bavaria, 60 percent of electricity demand is covered by nuclear power plants. This means that in the event of their shutdown, a large amount of electricity would have to be transported from the northern and central regions to Bavaria if one does not want to buy electricity from nuclear power plants in Temelin and elsewhere. This means that our entire transmission structure must be redesigned. Mecklenburg-Vorpommern will also be an exporter of wind energy. The construction of lines today is almost as complicated as the construction of coal power plants; either the beautiful expensive underground cable – then people still do not want to pay a higher electricity price – or the high-voltage line, which can only be legally realized with many lawsuits.

We must actively promote among our population that securing the prosperity of our country is not possible without a consistent energy policy. This also includes the construction of new power plants and not just the construction of gas power plants. This also includes the construction of power lines and pipelines. The so-called CCS process, that is, the separation and storage of CO2 from coal power plants, will of course also entail very extensive approval procedures, both regarding the discharge of these CO2 gases. – One must sharpen the basic chemical knowledge that CO2 and CO are something different and that CO2 is not as dangerous as carbon monoxide. That this is the first level of acceptance is now also known in the Ruhr area. I mean that the first CCS project is to be realized there, and it is not that the Ruhr area has a lower level of education while we here in Mecklenburg-Vorpommern all know this. – On the other hand, the storage of CO2 will entail the most expensive approval procedures in mining law. So, in the next ten to fifteen years, it will not be the case that we will rely significantly on CCS technology, but at best there will be pilot projects.

Germany has chosen a very exciting path with renewable energies. We have created incentive systems that pose significant problems for some conventional plants. Due to the obligation to feed in, the utilization of conventional power plants is, of course, sometimes very below average. Optimal wind conditions regularly lead to lower utilization rates of coal power plants, which in turn brings increased costs for the electricity price. This must also be known. Nevertheless, I consider our investments in renewable energies to be absolutely correct, forward-looking, and now also an excellent export factor. If the Americans start in this field, we should do everything we can to demand and develop it as an export market for ourselves.

The best thing is still to save energy. There are still significant potentials. For example, heat is generated in connection with the Greifswald coal power plant. Wherever this can be done in urban areas, we must also try to use heat efficiently. The entire topic of building renovation and building insulation is a huge issue. Not for nothing is the entire heat market classified as a "sleeping giant" in energy policy. With efficiency improvements, one can achieve incredibly much here. You are absolutely right that it is indeed the case that in sophisticated technological processes, the efficiencies are now at the edge of what can be achieved at all. This means that the marginal costs are getting higher and higher, while in the area of old buildings or in the transport sector, we can still advance and make things more efficient with very simple means and methods.

We have set ourselves ambitious targets for improving energy efficiency. We are very, very grateful to the crafts and medium-sized companies if they make their further contributions in this area. This is already being done to a large extent.

One more word about gas supply: We need the Baltic Sea pipeline. This is our common view in the federal government. Here, too, the approval procedures are not as trivial as we had hoped. If we pass by a country like Sweden, we must simply see that Sweden has no fossil needs for its electricity generation – half comes from renewable energies, the other half from reconstructed nuclear power plants – so the dependence on natural gas in Sweden is almost zero. We have very different conditions in Europe. Nevertheless, we want this pipeline. It is also not directed against our neighbor Poland, but we have offered that, conversely, gas flows can come from us to Poland. We are in a European internal market. The companies in Germany that are interested in this Baltic Sea pipeline are always ready to supply our Polish neighbors with gas. I believe that we are making progress step by step in persistent dialogue.

I find it right and good that you, as the Chamber of Commerce and Industry of the North, clearly state where the course for the future must be set. I wish you much success in your subsequent and much more specific discussion. Let us work together to promote among the population that Germany must not become a nation that imports electricity and is dependent on others. Let us advocate that Germany, as an industrial location, should produce its own electricity and also export it when there is a surplus. The export of electricity to neighboring countries is also part of the export economy. We have the know-how. We have long-standing experience. We have the most efficient technologies to offer almost everywhere. Since mechanical engineering is an important pillar of our entire export structure, it also suits us well to have new efficient coal power plants in our own country and not just want to sell them to other countries. Those who do not value their best assets are usually not regarded as good export partners for long.

So, I wish you all the best, a strong voice for the North in the concert of the chambers of commerce and industry overall, and continued strength and optimism for the time ahead. I believe we can all achieve this together.