Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the lecture event of the Berlin Chamber of Commerce and Industry on February 11, 2009, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

11 February 2009 · Lecture event of the Berlin Chamber of Commerce and Industry · Berlin Chamber of Commerce and Industry, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the Berlin Chamber of Commerce and Industry on February 11, 2009, discussing Germany's economic crisis response and the significance of the country's 60th anniversary.
Main themes
Global financial and economic crisis, social market economy, German economic history and Ludwig Erhard, 60th anniversary of the Federal Republic of Germany, fall of the Berlin Wall and reunification, German Mittelstand and antitrust law, politics and economics relationship, elections in 2009
Duration
~52 min
94th percentile
Words
6,217
94th percentile
Sentences
327
96th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
3rd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 67%64%
  • Social 17%16%
  • Institutional 10%9%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

327 sentences in 67 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, who have come here today from far into the back corridors of this house,

I would like to thank you for the invitation from the Chamber of Commerce. I am pleased to be here again and to speak to you at the beginning of a year that is, in many respects, a special year and will be.

I just laughed when Mr. Schweitzer compared politics and economics in their relationship with heart and mind. I wasn't quite sure whether we in politics get the heart or the mind, or whether it is a mix of both. In any case, both are needed; probably both in both areas. Because I cannot imagine running a business without passion, without heart and soul, and I cannot imagine politics without a piece of passion, fighting for something, and the joy of achieving something. In this respect, we must get along well in both areas in a good mix.

The year 2009 is special in three respects.

First

, it is a special year because we have quite a few elections. This is not the subject of today's discussion, as you will notice.

Second

, this year is a symbolic year: The Federal Republic of Germany is turning 60 years old. This is, of course, of great significance for a city like Berlin. It will not be easy to properly commemorate and celebrate this anniversary in a city that was divided for many years. When we talk about the Federal Republic, we must never forget that, of course, in the new states, that is, in the former GDR, reconstruction work was done after the war, that people had to rebuild anew from the rubble. It will be very important that we find a language here that, on the one hand, clearly defines the character of the unjust state that the GDR was, and on the other hand, does not exclude the achievements of the people over the past 60 years as achievements for Germany.

It also fits very well that on November 9, 1989, the wall fell; that means we are also celebrating the 20th anniversary of the fall of the wall. This, in turn, means nothing other than – and I am personally always surprised by this – that we in East and West have now lived together for almost a third of the time that the Federal Republic of Germany has existed. And somehow we do manage to get along reasonably well. You can still see in many places in Berlin what we have not achieved, but I believe that, on the whole, much has succeeded. At the latest, when you travel abroad, you are told what we have accomplished. It is sometimes quite good when others remind us of that.

The Federal Republic of Germany has become successful in its 60 years precisely for the reason that Mr. Schweitzer just mentioned, namely because it has committed itself to the social market economy. That was a fundamental decision. Ludwig Erhard was not encouraged by the Allies at that time; rather, he managed to assert himself with a bit of trickery and good tactics. His words will always remain in our memory. When General Clay told him that all his employees found Erhard's approach to economics to be incorrect and absurd, Ludwig Erhard calmly replied: My people have written that down too. He then nevertheless abolished the compulsory economic management, relied precisely on this individual freedom, as it was called, and said: If we have shortages, then we must trust in the diversity of people; we must trust that it is inherent to people to develop and unfold; we must create a framework for that, but we must not allocate from the center. This led to what we today commonly refer to as the economic miracle. This has made this republic strong. This has enabled us to achieve the reconstruction of the East in the way we have done and are still doing today. And this has led to the fact that we have a free market order.

In this free market order, however, Ludwig Erhard also always set limits. Ludwig Erhard enforced antitrust law against the resistance of the Federation of German Industries because he was aware that the middle class has no chance if the stronger are allowed to become even stronger, to become market-dominant, and if it is not ensured that freedom is not just an individual size that belongs to one or a few, but that the free development is possible for all. The history of antitrust law is the history that has made the German middle class the backbone of our economy. This applies to the companies gathered at the Chamber of Commerce and applies in particular to the craft businesses.

Now we find ourselves – this is the third reason why the year 2009 is so exciting and special – in an international crisis of the financial markets, in an international crisis of the economy. The social market economy must now prove itself under circumstances that are quite unique. Therefore, I want to talk the most about this third part, as it presents us with challenges that we have not known for decades.

In these days, I have spoken again with European business leaders, who, in response to my question about whether we are really in an extraordinary situation, reaffirmed what we all actually know but sometimes suppress, while we wonder whether we might be wrong in our assessment. They all clearly stated: It is a crisis like those living now have not experienced before. This first manifested itself – I believe one can say – in a crash of the banks. I will not forget these days from a political perspective. And many others will not either. Suddenly, there was no one left in the world who could help, except for the states. One must say, the banks were quick to come to us and said: Only you can help. We had not experienced anything like that for a long time. We also had hardly any time to be stunned; rather, we had to act quickly.

And we did that, and unfortunately, we had to get used to sums that are rarely discussed in the political arena. 400 billion euros in guarantees, 80 billion euros in capital injection for the banks – that is the framework in which we operate. If you look back to America these days, you see that one now has to approach the trillion mark to still be able to describe it all.

We acted quickly. I want to say this again here because it often gets forgotten: We did not act for the bankers or for the banks, but we acted for the companies in this country and for the savers. This is a rescue package. When the middle class often asks, "What are you doing for us now?" I can only say: The first thing we did for you is that we ensured that the cycle of the economy did not completely collapse.

The sad or burdensome thing is that while the crisis of the banks has slowly subsided and we have certainly saved it from collapse – from the core meltdown, as it was always nicely put – the full functionality of the banks is not yet guaranteed. Now one can talk for a long time about the question of when a credit crunch begins and when it just becomes a bit more difficult to obtain a loan. But of course, it is the case that at least the conditions under which one receives a loan – at least when one wants to obtain a loan for a longer period for a larger investment – have deteriorated rapidly. This today leads in many places to the fact that investments that might have been profitable at lower interest rates are now being questioned.

Now we are in a situation where we must continue to work – worldwide, by the way; this can only be done worldwide and coherently – to gradually restore the banks to full functionality. In this context, the discussion about the bad bank has reached us at the beginning of the year, which is being conducted very excitedly. I will tell you honestly and sincerely: There will not be a large bad bank in Germany where all banks can unload their remnants, so to speak, their waste – I do not want to speak ill of that in the presence of Mr. Schweitzer. So it will not be the case that one can anonymously deliver all risks to the state. Because – everyone must know this – that would lead to the Scandinavian way, so that we as a state would also have to say: Then please give us the good part of your bank as well. It cannot be demanded of us – what does "of us" mean; we are only the representatives of the taxpayer – that we take on all the risks and then the good parts can recover and flourish again.

On the other hand, you rightly expect that the banks will become fully functional again. This means we must give the banks the opportunity to separate their bad risks or assets, and we must – we have committed to this – then again help the banks through the taxpayer – of course with fees that will also have to be repaid later – to secure, manage, and wind down the whole thing so that they can continue to work with the good part in a private manner.

This means that we are guided by the idea: As little state as possible, but as much state action as necessary to get the important banking system running again. This is, by the way, also the approach of all other European countries. Just look at what is being done in Great Britain and elsewhere. We are, so to speak, on a common line. We must be because the banking world is intertwined in a way that we could not have imagined before this financial crisis.

However, we also have a special case that is being discussed a lot these days: That is Hypo Real Estate. Hypo Real Estate is in a situation that has already demanded many guarantees from us. We have provided a total of 400 billion euros in guarantees. Hypo Real Estate has already claimed at least 50 billion euros from that, if not a bit more. This means that a single bank is repeatedly demanding guarantees and eventually also capital from us. This is, of course, a difficult situation because the balance sheets of such banks are in the hundreds of billions of euros. In a business model where you finance projects for 30 years with bonds that only run for a few months, you constantly need short-term refinancing. If these cannot be serviced, it must be compensated so that the long-term projects can continue to be financed. That is the problem. The further the short-term nature of one side and the long-term nature of the other side diverge, the more dramatic the state activity is desired.

Now comes the important point: We have committed ourselves internationally – after the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers, I believe that was a correct commitment – that we will not let any bank fail that poses a systemic risk. Hypo Real Estate, for example, poses a systemic risk. This means we must now see how we deal with it. Our benchmark must, of course, be to think of the taxpayer and ask: How do we find the most bearable solution for the taxpayer?

Therefore, the question is currently being discussed: What can be done? I do not want to present our answer to this question in all its details here; it is still being developed. I just want to tell you: I am not in favor of nationalization. I never wanted to do that. I was glad to be done with the system in which everything was state-owned; you can believe me. I have been sufficiently resistant to such systems through 35 years of habits that I could never get used to it again; you can assume that too. However, we must see how we can arrange it so that neither a bankruptcy occurs nor the taxpayer is unduly burdened. The shareholder is, at the moment, with all due respect, not our most important focus. We must first see how we can manage the whole thing.

I want to say a word about the discussion regarding Dresdner Bank and Commerzbank, which has also attracted a lot of attention. The merger decision was made before the financial market crisis, before they came to the state and asked for help. We then carried out a recapitalization of 18 billion euros at a capital value of the bank that is currently far below that. We must, of course, fear that such a beautiful object, finely adorned by state recapitalization, is an interesting target for hasty takeovers. We cannot expect the German taxpayer to put 18 billion euros into it, only to then watch it possibly be taken over by someone else. That is why we took a stake of 25.1 percent, to say: At least in this case we have a right of objection – we do not want to engage in business – and can say: A takeover cannot work unless the federal government agrees and this is recognized.

That is the matter regarding the banks. This discussion will continue for quite some time. We need a restructuring of the state banks. This is also obvious. The state banks are currently very caught up in their own problems. Berlin is familiar with such issues.

There is also a tendency that is not good at the moment: The more individual nation-states help their banks, the more these banks restrict themselves to their home market. This means that banks that have taken on a lot of financing in Germany are currently not available for financing models in Germany. What is behind this? Behind this is the need for us to learn that the products of the financial markets must be more strictly monitored and made more transparent.

At the G20 summit in Washington, we set out to achieve the following with the action plan, which will be debated again on April 2 in London: No place in the world, no product of the financial markets, and no actor in the financial markets should exist without regulation. If there is such a thing, very, very high risk premiums must be applied. This means I must back the riskiness of my product with more equity. The real problem was that there was no longer any balance between the level of risk and the availability of one's own risk mitigation options. We will work on that.

I am concerned that in some places the cause of this crisis is already being forgotten, because we are all busy combating the economic crisis. But we must do everything to ensure that something like what we have just experienced never happens again.

However, there is something else behind this. This also needs to be discussed. It is that there are too great imbalances in the world, that many Western countries have become accustomed to living beyond their means, that this was particularly the case in the United States, and that this – so to speak, tolerated by the state – further promoted the idea of taking ever greater risks with the banks. There was no control. On the contrary, there was even a certain encouragement, because it was said: As long as there is growth, we will move forward. And the imbalances have thus grown ever larger.

This brings us to the more difficult part that we must address. There comes a point where we must say: If we all depend on each other, we need a few common principles of economic activity in a globalized world. That is why I speak of a charter for sustainable economics. I have received a lot of support from international organizations – World Bank, World Trade Organization, OECD, International Labour Organization, and IMF – because these international organizations view these imbalances with great suspicion. We must also talk about this in the future.

Now we are in the present. The fact that not only the feeling but also the fact is there that the world has lived beyond its means naturally leads to dealing with a large uncertainty factor in the real economy and not knowing exactly how demand will develop in the coming years. This, in turn, leads to a reluctance in lending. This, in turn, leads to a decline in production. Consequently, the banks again face the necessity of cleaning up their own balance sheets, because the declining stock values in the economy also lead to the banks finding themselves in a worse position.

We have said: Like everyone else, we in the Federal Republic of Germany, with a clearly negative economic growth, have the task of doing something to shorten and flatten this economic trough from a state perspective. We cannot undo this crisis. It will have an impact. But we can dampen it in terms of its effects.

Now the question arises again with heart and mind, individual freedom, the state, and the question of what should be done, what should not be done, and what the standards are. I say: We have an interest – I assume this crisis will be over in a certain time X – that after the crisis we are not in a situation where our greatest treasure, namely qualified skilled workers and masters, have disappeared from the companies, wandering around somewhere, and thus losing something very valuable that has been supported and nurtured by us in Germany for years and decades, from training to master BAföG.

Of course, we cannot set aside market principles. But we can build a bridge. What does this bridge look like? This is the second package of measures. We have put together overall measures packages with a volume of 80 billion euros for two years. This amounts to a stimulus of 1.5 percent of gross domestic product per year. In our case, the automatic stabilizers come into play; these make a significant difference in Germany. There will be a pretty good pension increase this year. We are making no cuts in the healthcare system. On the contrary. We had quite good wage increases last year. This means that in Germany, unlike in America, where for example the pension system depends on the capital market, the effects for consumption this year are positive. This significantly increases the stimulus package. When comparing American and German figures, one must always take these two things into account.

As an export nation, we are expected to do something because we must have an interest in others getting back on their feet. It is therefore about preserving jobs and building a bridge. That is why we have chosen various elements in this package of measures.

First – and this is certainly a difficult task – we have said: If well-functioning companies can only obtain loans under conditions that turn a well-functioning company into a poorly functioning one, we must consider whether to work with state guarantees. It is sometimes presented as if we were granting guarantees for the first time in our lives. The classic federal budget also has a fairly high guarantee framework. Many export transactions are state guaranteed. This is a common procedure.

We have said: We will only do this if the house bank principle applies. This means that if the house bank, which can do this, gives a positive continuation forecast for the company and is also willing to take on a small part of the risk, then a guarantee will also be provided through the Kreditanstalt für Wiederaufbau. If I look at what is currently happening in America regarding the Fed, it is all going through the central bank there. Just imagine if the Bundesbank were to provide guarantees on all bonds that all large companies issue if they requested it. We are not going that far at all. But we must also ask ourselves: If this is the case in America, if there are similar mechanisms in the UK, can we afford to do nothing but what we would do in non-crisis times with a clean regulatory zeal and watch as other companies, which may be worse off, survive?

That is why it is so important that we discuss in the European Union what fair competitive conditions are. It cannot be that one provides guarantees for companies at an interest rate of three percent, another at six percent, and the third at nine percent. Even then, there are distortions in competition. That is why the European internal market is very valuable. That is why I believe that Europe is proving itself in this respect, just as the fact that we have the euro has proven to be an incredibly stabilizing factor against the fluctuations we would have if we had 16 different currencies, despite all the difficulties we have. So much for the topic of credit frameworks.

The Federal Employment Agency is also represented here. – We have secondly said: Extension of short-time work to 18 months and the offer to companies that we will cover 100 percent of the additional wage costs from the companies if they offer qualification, and half of the additional wage costs if it is all without qualification.

My heartfelt request is: Before you lay off people, consider whether you can build this bridge of short-time work. I know that we cannot mandate this. We do not want to. This is an offer. But it is an offer that you should see as us wanting to help you to act in the long term. Because in a few years, the scarcest resource in Germany will be qualified labor. If we do not act sensibly here, there will not primarily be relocations of businesses from Germany because of corporate tax reform or minimum wages or anything else, but there will be relocations of businesses because you cannot find people here who can actually do the work.

Since Germany is a country that must continually develop and produce good, qualified, and new products, we will always depend on qualified labor to a much greater extent than, for example, in emerging countries or elsewhere. Therefore, my request is: At least consider our offer.

Third point: We have said that if we are in a crisis, if private construction activity is visibly collapsing, and little is being invested, it would be right for the state to increase construction activities. Here we had the assurance: If the federal government does it alone, that is nice – we can do it for roads, highways, and similar projects – but if we want to do it quickly, it is best to pass it on to the municipalities. Thus, we have crafted a joint program between the states and the federal government, where most of the funds go directly to the municipalities.

Again, we have followed the philosophy and the standard: If we do this, we want to preserve jobs – here in the construction industry – but we also want to make our country more future-proof so that we emerge from the crisis stronger than we entered it. Therefore, we have decided to spend two-thirds of the funds disbursed, about 14 billion euros over two years, on education; that is, for kindergartens, schools, and universities. I undertook an educational trip. In the end, it was such that children asked my secretary if I could come to their school, because wherever I went, something nice was always done beforehand. They wanted me to come to them. I am not responsible for education. I know that. That lies within the competence of the states. But I say: If we undertake such an initiative, it is perfectly fine for many parents to say: Okay, our children are now going to a better school; it looks a bit better.

It is a typically German discussion that has been said: Now they are painting the school, but there is still no teacher. – Okay, the teacher still needs to be found. But it is already nice to have taken step one, so the school is painted. And then perhaps even a teacher will be found who prefers to work there rather than in an old, dilapidated building. Ladies and gentlemen, that is the philosophy. I hope that the municipalities will accept this well. The anticipation is currently great. I hope that this can also be implemented.

Another point: We have said that we want to invest in research, in a research program for small and medium-sized enterprises. Research should particularly take place in the automotive industry, where we want to ensure that new drive technologies are developed more intensively. Again, the philosophy applies: We want to emerge from the crisis stronger than we entered it.

We have introduced the scrapping bonus in the automotive sector, which is certainly not clearly assignable to regulatory policy, the so-called environmental bonus, because it is a key area of our economy. It is well received. It is an example of our stance: We do not care whether a Renault, a Peugeot, an Opel, a Golf, or a Polo is purchased. We are in favor of everyone in Europe benefiting because we also benefit from Europe. Therefore, we are of course watching with eagle eyes what happens in other European countries when the automotive industry is supported. That must also be said.

So that is the framework. In addition, there is a relief package for citizens. We had reliefs from January 1 due to the increase in child benefits. We will implement a pension increase on July 1. Then there will automatically follow an increase in Hartz IV benefits, then a tax relief – the first stage of a tax structure reform – plus a reduction in health contributions, so that even with the 0.9 percent for employees, we will again be below 40 percent in wage supplementary costs. I believe that is also a reasonable step.

I believe that with the toolbox available to the state for managing the crisis, we have all the options to do what is necessary. However, we must also say: There cannot be constantly new packages. We are reaching the limits of our capacity. We will have a deficit of nearly three percent of gross domestic product this year, and even higher next year. Therefore, we have also agreed on clear repayment rules with regard to the profits of the Bundesbank.

If everything goes well this week, we will receive a fundamental constitutional amendment in the form of the so-called debt brake alongside our expenditures. This means that the federal and state governments want to commit themselves to significantly limiting debt accumulation and restricting it to extraordinary events. This is a monumental task; I will come back to that shortly. But it is an important turning point that, by the way, could only be successful – the federal and state governments have negotiated now; the final stone will be laid on Thursday – because we see the exorbitant debts that we now have to incur, and we want to make provisions for the future despite the crisis.

This – I say this with all humility – is something I currently miss in other countries. Elsewhere, dramatically more debts are being incurred than in our country. The crisis did not arise from not incurring debts, but rather the crisis arose partly because too many debts were incurred. We must now be careful not to outline the next crisis while combating the current one. That is the most important task I see.

If we now look into the next decade and ask ourselves what the major tasks are that Germany faces, then managing globalization is one of them. It is about the questions: What structures do we need, what kind of cooperation do we need? I have briefly outlined this for the financial markets.

The second is the demographic change for Germany. In the middle of the next decade, we will see massive changes in the age structure of our population. For many, this is still not tangible today. In the new federal states, you can already see it because there was a huge change due to the collapse of the birth rate in the early 1990s.

And thirdly, with the increasing world population, we have the resulting task – we will have to live with the fact that the natural resources, the raw materials for the development of the world economy are becoming scarcer – to handle these resources more efficiently.

These will also be the three areas in which politics must set the course for the next legislative period. We say, of course: We must keep the performance drivers in our country in a united Europe and a globalized world. When Ludwig Erhard introduced the social market economy in Germany, there was no threat: I will simply go to another country. Today, in a European internal market, that is of course very easy. This means that whenever we make a politically wrong decision, there is a risk that one will go to the neighboring country and say: I have it better there.

Therefore, we believe that we – this is currently being discussed differently in the parties – fundamentally need a tax reform. I say that the injustice of our tax system lies in the permanent cold progression and in the so-called middle-class belly, that is, in the non-linearity of the tax rate. This must be gradually dismantled. We will develop various models for this. I am speaking here today as Chancellor, not as party chair. But we will also develop one. That is how it is, you can believe me. I will come back to the difficulties shortly.

Furthermore, we must of course keep the wage supplementary costs around 40 percent – this is not an easy task when you have an aging society and health and care costs rise every year – and we must reduce bureaucracy wherever we can – with the help of the standard cost model, an international approach that measures bureaucracy costs in the area of statistical obligations. The Normenkontrollrat has worked very well in this legislative period. We have saved costs amounting to six billion euros. You may say that you do not notice it because the remaining bureaucracy costs are dramatically higher. But we can tell you exactly where changes have been made.

In light of the demographic change, we have a huge task ahead of us: the integration of children and young people with a migration background. In Berlin, people know what is being talked about. In all German areas that play a significant role in industrial development – the entire Rhine-Main region, Stuttgart, Munich, Nuremberg, Erlangen, Fürth – already today, 25 percent of citizens under 25 years of age have a migration background. This number will increase. In many German cities, the enrollment rate is now such that the number of those with a migration background is greater than the number of those coming from a long-established German family.

If we do not succeed in integrating these young people so that their educational level is comparable to those with a German background, then we will have an insurmountable problem. That is why I brought the Commissioner for Integration into the Chancellery and said: This is a cross-cutting task. That is why we have created the National Integration Plan with the states and municipalities. There is much to be done.

I also know that you contribute a lot by training young people. Of course, you also say: I can only train them if they have a school diploma that is sufficient for specialized professions. But if we do not address this issue – it is not only about ensuring that every person in our country has the same opportunities, but it is also about our economic strength – then we will have a huge problem in the middle of the next decade. Therefore, I ask for your active support here.

This again coincides with education and family policy – it was right that we started to expand childcare options for children under three years old in this legislative period. In Germany, we always have the discussion about whether one must send their child to daycare at the age of one. One does not have to. We want freedom of choice. We want nothing more than for parents, whom we trust to make decisions about how they want to live, to actually have the choice. However, they often do not have it today. If they cannot afford a nanny and undertake other financial efforts, that freedom of choice is not there. Therefore, it must be provided.

For integration, this is particularly important. Because educators rightly tell us: By the age of three, children can usually speak properly. But by the age of three, the German child does not yet have a pronounced charitable and solidarity inclination. Therefore, in kindergarten, it tends to approach the other child who can also speak and ignores the children who cannot speak properly yet. This means it is better to start language education earlier because language is the key to educational opportunities later in life.

That is why we have also said: We must work better together between the federal and state governments in the field of education. The states did not like it when we came together in Dresden for the qualification and education summit. But we agreed on good things. We agreed that by the year 2015, three percent of gross domestic product must be invested in research and development and seven percent in education. This is a huge effort, but it is the international standard. We have said: We want to halve the number of school dropouts, and we want to allow vocational offers and vocational advertising, especially in secondary schools, but also in all other schools.

It is easy to say that the state is responsible for education. Only when the child comes out of school, suddenly the federal government is responsible again. It is then responsible for Hartz IV payments, it is responsible for vocational training. Then, as a first step, one can use unemployment insurance funds to catch up on the school diploma. Therefore, the interfaces must be better managed. If we do not learn this in this country, we will fall behind internationally.

In this example – I could also mention the example of infrastructure and many others – you see: The state also has the necessity to increase its expenditures once again. We have the necessity to provide incentives to the performance drivers and to relieve citizens, for example, through a tax reform. But we also want to introduce a debt brake now. Since I studied physics, I know that everything must somehow fit together. Therefore, the key to what we must achieve is growth. We must be ready in this country to achieve the highest possible growth rates. We have seen it in the last three years: When economic growth is reasonable, the problems with the social security systems become much smaller. Then contributions can be reduced. If we have as much employment again as at the end of last year, when we had the highest number of employed people in the history of the Federal Republic, then we can afford many things that we cannot afford with zero growth.

Therefore, we must not, of course, conduct certain experiments. I believe that it is not right that we, as one of the very few countries, shut down nuclear power plants while all others are talking about building new ones. I do not want to build new ones, but I do not want to be the first to shut down the safest ones in the world.

I believe that we must deal with green biotechnology. We cannot keep dismissing entire fields of research and saying: We do not want anything to do with them. Those who are picky, who are fussy, who do not want this or that, jeopardize growth and will deprive themselves of the opportunities that make us attractive as a country.

Therefore, it is important to balance growth, relief, and necessary state expenditures without constantly living beyond our means. This will be our philosophy for the next decade. The specific political answers will be given differently by the parties. But overall, it is no longer certain in the globalized world – we cannot even write this as a legal claim into the law – that we belong to the leading countries in this world. We must earn this year by year.

We have a great youth. There is a lot of courage and good will among the entrepreneurs in this country. Therefore, I believe that all doors are open to us. We can do this. The world is watching us. It expects us to be innovative, creative, and precise. It is in our hands. Therefore, we should act as closely as possible, with heart and mind, together in business and politics.