Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the German Coal Day on November 6, 2007, in Essen:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

6 November 2007 · German Coal Day · Essen, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Coal Day in Essen on November 6, 2007, marking landmark decisions on phasing out subsidized hard coal mining by 2018.
Main themes
Phase-out of subsidized hard coal mining, Hard Coal Financing Act, Evonik Industries AG formation, social compatibility of energy transition, RAG AG restructuring, planning security for Ruhr region, federal and state cooperation, legacy burdens of mining, German industrial heritage, union negotiations with IGBCE
Duration
~29 min
81st percentile
Words
3,492
81st percentile
Sentences
174
86th percentile
Readability
49
60th percentile
Grade
11.2
34th percentile
Syntax
3.03
51st percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
17th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Environmental 22%22%
  • Institutional 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

174 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President of the Coal Association, dear Mr. Müller,

dear Mr. Prime Minister, dear Peter Müller,

dear Mr. Schmoldt,

dear Mr. Mayor,

dear Minister, dear Christa Thoben,

ladies and gentlemen,

I am very pleased to be here today to spend this special coal day with you to some extent. I believe it is indeed true: rarely have such far-reaching coal policy decisions been made as in the year 2007. Mr. Müller just reminded us of the genesis – the coal day two years ago when Ronald Pofalla was here – and of what has happened in the meantime. I believe it can be said that the connection between the black and the white areas has rarely been so central to our considerations. This means that today’s Evonik Industries AG is already visible. We will get used to the name just as we have the RAG deep within us.

In February of this year, we agreed on an option for phasing out the subsidized promotion of hard coal by the end of 2018 – linked to a review clause. I do not want to engage in probability statements today, but I believe it is very important that we have thoroughly examined the option of phasing out subsidized hard coal mining by 2018 in all its facets and thus established an option for a socially acceptable exit from German hard coal mining. Indeed, the important thing about this is that we have gained predictability. I would also like to emphasize once again what Mr. Müller said: the considerations of the year 2012 will be exclusively of an energy policy nature. Thus, the necessary security regarding social compatibility is also given in the 2018 variant.

When I say that "we" have decided this, I mean the federal government, the states of North Rhine-Westphalia and Saarland, RAG AG, and the IGBCE union. We have established that the white area of RAG will have access to the capital market. This opens up a growth potential that, as I hope and believe, will also unfold its benefits. After we made this determination – initially in outline – we, of course, negotiated intensively and made decisions. I do not want to hide the fact that there were some mornings when I woke up with the entire variety of tasks weighing relatively heavily on my mind, as there was much to consider and many different interests to reconcile. I believe that, on balance, many have fulfilled their responsibilities, and we have found a good solution.

We have agreed that there will be a foundation. The states and the foundation have concluded a legacy agreement. Clarity had to be created regarding the eternal burdens of mining and their financing. A model for financing the hard coal aid until 2018 has been agreed upon, as well as an understanding regarding the old and eternal burdens after 2018. The federal financing contributions are laid out in the so-called Hard Coal Financing Act, which has been passed by the cabinet and will soon be discussed in the Bundestag and the Bundesrat. The signs that there will be a positive discussion are, I believe, unmistakable.

The decisions now have two effects:

First, there is planning security, predictability in the socially acceptable phase-out process.

Second, Evonik Industries AG has all the opportunities to truly unleash its economic power.

I believe these are the right and important decisions for the company and for the people in the region.

However, I do not overlook the fact that the term "decision-making" says very little about what is actually happening here. During the time I have lived in reunified Germany, I have experienced and felt much about what coal mining means for the people in the Ruhr area, what tradition and history are attached to it. Making decisions in the way it has been done now is, of course, far more than a material or legal procedure; it also truly means a piece of change for a region that has been of outstanding importance for the industrialization of Germany and that should continue to be of great importance for the Federal Republic of Germany – I want to state this explicitly; I will return to it later. This is the wish of the federal government.

Therefore, because this was and is also an emotionally difficult task, I would like to thank everyone who has participated in these negotiations today. I would like to extend a special thank you to Mr. Schmoldt, who, as he has just expressed, has taken on this responsibility as a representative of the employees, who have both a right to a socially acceptable perspective and have shaped life in what is called the coal pot. From my perspective, a heartfelt thank you for not closing yourself off to a constructive process despite everything that separates us in terms of assessments – you made that clear just now. It is not common these days to take on so much responsibility. I hope that so much praise from the political side does not harm you. I will be at IG Metall on Thursday. Let’s see how that goes.

Of course, great expectations are now tied to the further development, especially also to Evonik Industries AG. In the coming months, the RAG Foundation and the company will decide on the design of the IPO. There will be a completely new collaboration between the foundation and the company. I believe that the way we have arrived at the decisions and the personnel configurations that have now been made provide a good basis for what lies ahead for the company to have a good chance of being wonderfully and sensibly regulated.

What are the assets that many envy you? – Mr. Müller just pointed out that there are indeed interested parties. – It is a power plant division that can claim to be a leading force in the German electricity market. It is a broadly positioned and highly innovative chemical company. It is a solid real estate portfolio, and it is, last but not least, a management that is willing – a heartfelt thank you for that – to truly bring these areas together into a whole and to fully exploit the synergies of the group. If we had not been politically certain that this will and willingness exist, then the decision for a total company would certainly have been more difficult. But we were able to make it for good reasons.

Therefore, I also believe that, given these assets I have mentioned, the conditions are good to utilize the capital market and its opportunities and to assert oneself in the global market with innovative products and services. I would like to take this opportunity to wish the new company every conceivable success.

At this point, since the Hard Coal Financing Act and the question of eternal burdens have been mentioned, in which both the states and the federal government have taken on a good deal of responsibility, I would like to remind you that this solution also reflects that the entirety of the German taxpayers is willing to fulfill their responsibility regarding the history and responsibility for German hard coal mining. This is also important when one remembers how sometimes one-sided speeches have been made.

Now, of course, with this step, with this decision-making and with what is changing here, the question of what future the Ruhr area has is also opened up. I believe that the Ruhr area remains of central importance in terms of energy policy and energy generation for the Federal Republic of Germany. I would also like to remind you that work in both mining and the energy sector is characterized by the highest precision, but is also not without risk. The tragic accident in recent days at one of the major construction sites has reminded us of this once again. Therefore, I would also like to say at this point: We hope that no people will be harmed in all major projects that are being carried out here in the region and beyond. I would like to take a moment to remember the relatives and friends of those who have lost their lives.

The structural change in the Ruhr area is certainly not easy to manage. If we only look at the mining sector – in 1957, mining in the Ruhr area employed 470,000 people; today there are only about 30,000 left – then we know: the Ruhr area is already familiar with structural change. But I believe that the Ruhr area has always positively embraced this structural change and has placed its advantages at the center.

One of the advantages is certainly the central location in the heart of Europe. This makes the region a preferred location for transport and transport infrastructure, for services, and for logistics. Here is a business community that consistently takes on the challenges of change. Therefore, I would also like to say the following: I believe that the Ruhr Initiative Circle, which I visited last month, is taking on the task of structural change with extraordinary commitment, showing perspectives, and consistently demonstrating future orientation. For that, a heartfelt thank you.

The companies in the Initiative Circle have committed, for example, to double their spending on research and development from today’s 1.5 billion euros to three billion euros by 2015. This is exactly the way we need to respond to the challenges we face globally. It also aligns very well with the federal government’s direction when entrepreneurs say: We see the key to prosperity, to the success of the people in Germany fundamentally in research, development, and innovation.

We have jointly set ourselves the goal of spending three percent of gross domestic product on research and development in Germany by the year 2010. – The aforementioned determination of the Ruhr Initiative Circle is of utmost importance in this regard. – It is something like a joint venture of state efforts on one side and economic efforts on the other side to achieve these three percent. The federal government will invest an additional 6.9 billion euros in research and innovation alone in this legislative period. The more economic growth increases, the larger the sum must naturally become. That is immediately clear. But we also know: money alone is not enough. We need a comprehensive strategy. This comprehensive strategy can only be realized in the cooperation of state institutions – federal and state – and economic enterprises. I think our Minister of Research has hit the right point with the Science Union by bringing economic and scientific institutions to the same table.

When we think about the perspective – I spoke of an emotional topic regarding the decision-making – I find it fitting that in 2010 not only Essen but the entire region can hold the title of "European Capital of Culture." Everything that means economy and material success is always accompanied by cultural framing and a sense of life.

I can only welcome it when the entire region grows together, feels its common responsibility, and becomes a metropolitan region. I have just returned from India, where I looked at the metropolises. The Ruhr area is certainly not the largest metropolis in the world. Therefore, one should try to understand each other well in the region, from the transport system to other questions. This helps and brings us competitive advantages in global competition.

We know that energy policy will be of crucial importance not only for this region but for the Federal Republic as a whole. Thus, it is not unexpected that energy policy is being discussed today on this coal day. The federal government attaches great importance to a predictable energy policy. However, the differences of opinion regarding a form of energy policy have already been addressed.

Mr. Müller, it would have been nice if you could have made the decisions regarding the future of nuclear energy a bit better elsewhere. We need to reconsider together where there are still opportunities. We have set tracks that will at least pose difficulties in achieving ambitious climate protection goals. We are all in agreement on that here. I must unfortunately say: I simply fear that this also applies to the use of economic opportunities in terms of the export of energy generation facilities. When you look at the world – regardless of whether one has a positive or negative view of nuclear energy in Germany – one must say: The world will be relatively little guided by our opinion, if I understand that correctly. Therefore, it is important that we think a bit more about these future opportunities.

I believe it was very good, Mr. Großmann, that you set an impulse in the currently relatively heated discussion about electricity price increases and reiterated that solutions can ultimately only be achieved through dialogue. In our large energy dialogue, we have certainly achieved one thing, namely that we were able to calculate scenarios for the various CO2 reduction possibilities. We have also recognized that it would be easier for us to achieve the ambitious goals without the phase-out of nuclear energy. I think that the BDI, with its cost-benefit analysis, has also made an important contribution to providing us with better insights. But now, regarding energy producers, we primarily need to find a thread of conversation in which we exchange arguments rationally, in which we do not put each other on the pillory, but in which we also explain to each other what the actual situation is. If politics cannot understand certain things, it will of course speak out, just as companies do.

I want to say at this point: We certainly want competition. This applies to all sectors. We also need it in the area of electricity generation. That is why we want to ensure, with an amendment to antitrust law – which is currently being discussed – that antitrust authorities can act more quickly and effectively against the abuse of dominant market positions in the electricity and gas market. I want to make it very clear: I do not want to participate in suspicions, but as Chancellor, I will also demand transparency. The willingness to engage in dialogue has certainly encouraged me. Thank you very much for that.

I believe that the willingness to engage in dialogue is also very important in the current situation. Because while we have decided on a number of things that enable more competition, such as incentive regulation, we have also clearly opposed supporting the EU Commission's considerations, which essentially only aim at the forced sale of networks and a property division. We do not consider that to be the royal road to competition. However, it is all the more important in this phase that we also exchange views reasonably and transparently. We believe that access to the grid must be ensured for all market participants through effective regulation. The Federal Network Agency has, in my opinion, clearly demonstrated this. Therefore, we will also advocate this direction at the European level.

We must also continually inform customers about their options for switching electricity suppliers, which is one of the options that every informed customer has. Many private customers are not aware of this or do not know the details. We can also awaken a lot of savings potential. Therefore, climate and energy policy – I believe this is not a particularly adventurous or exciting forecast – will in the future be more closely intertwined rather than less.

Now the question of to what extent Germany should take the lead in climate protection is a broad field. Mr. Müller has expressed quiet doubts about CO2 reductions of 40 percent. We must see that Germany already has to make a huge contribution with a reduction of 20 percent by the year 2012. I know that these goals are ambitious and difficult to achieve without nuclear energy. On the other hand, the question of what we do or do not do is not entirely within our own discretion. I believe that the decision of the European Union was wise, whereby Europe commits to a 20 percent reduction and, if other international players join in, to a 30 percent reduction. We know that Europe – Germany alone certainly cannot – cannot solve the issue of climate protection on its own.

Europe currently accounts for 15 percent of global CO2 emissions. That will decrease. I advise us to take a calm path in Germany now. For this, we have developed energy scenarios. I see with great concern – I must say this very clearly – how many municipalities are now, so to speak, deciding against any form of coal use for emotional reasons. The energy mix is our future. Efficient energy use – wherever possible also through combined heat and power – is our future. But to put one energy source on trial and believe that this would serve climate protection quite well is, I believe, not the right way. Therefore, I appeal to everyone here. I could also express it a bit loosely: Not turning off the standby mode but being against the coal power plant in the city council does not help. We must see energy efficiency and climate protection as a complete system and a collective task.

We will advocate for a strong industrial location in Germany in the matter of climate protection. For this reason, I am also deeply convinced that, for example, CO2 trading systems and certification are fundamentally the right instruments, but that it will ultimately not be sufficient to limit these exclusively to the domestic industrial sector. I believe that when we talk about global emissions reductions – only those count – we must all work hard to ensure that we also establish international trading systems beyond Europe. Otherwise, there will be huge distortions of competition in the industrial sector. I am very actively promoting such systems on my travels to other regions. There are also many supporters. A global problem can ultimately only be tackled with global agreements under the auspices of the UN and with global instruments. This will be the most cost-effective, efficient, and ultimately also the fairest way.

But – I want to say this at this point – this is not entirely within our discretion. Man-made climate change is happening. The other is also happening, but we cannot prevent that. However, if we allow global warming of more than two degrees Celsius, we will incur significant economic damages with substantial costs. The Stern Report speaks of five to even 20 percent of global gross domestic product. One can still assume that the consequences in one's own country may not be as severe as elsewhere. But the number of war zones, conflicts, and refugee movements will increase. And we will not be unaffected by that. Therefore, I believe that a long-term energy policy is of utmost importance here.

When we think of the energy source coal, we will also have to deal with zero-CO2 coal power plants, that is, sequestration. I want to say at this point that CO2 separation can be an important element of a climate-friendly energy supply – but certainly not on a large scale before the year 2020. But it is, of course, important to create the framework conditions for that. I hope that these framework conditions will be created in Germany with determination. Whenever it comes to the storage of certain substances in Germany, the discussion is generally not very easy. Therefore, I hope that planning and other requirements will be found for this good purpose – and with a cheerful spirit, not with a large rejection movement. I sense what I am talking about. Those who share the opinion that the world cannot do without coal for the foreseeable future and that coal will only have a really good future if we also consider separation must also advocate for forward-looking planning law in this situation.

This coal day will be a special point in the history of German hard coal mining. I firmly believe that, regardless of all commitments to the review clause. This coal day also broadens the view that coal has something to do with energy policy, that energy policy has something to do with a modern industrial location, and that the Ruhr area is such a modern industrial location and should remain so. It also shows how closely the various areas are interconnected. I would like to thank all the actors in hard coal mining for seeing this overall responsibility and for taking the people along the way.

On behalf of the federal government, I would like to say that we, together with the state governments, including Saarland, will do everything we can to ensure that the regions that made a decisive contribution to the establishment of this Federal Republic of Germany also have a good perspective in the future and that the people in these regions can live in prosperity. In this sense, I wish you all a heartfelt Glück auf!