Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 21st Trade Union Congress of IG Metall on November 8, 2007, in Leipzig:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

10 November 2007 · 21st Trade Union Congress of IG Metall · Leipzig, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 21st IG Metall Trade Union Congress in Leipzig on November 8, 2007, emphasizing government support for strong trade unions and economic recovery.
Main themes
Trade union cooperation, social justice and fair distribution, German reunification legacy, employment and economic recovery, role of IG Metall, Federal Government partnership with unions, unemployment reduction, solidarity among Germans, future of work
Duration
~53 min
95th percentile
Words
6,352
95th percentile
Sentences
300
95th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.97
44th percentile
Vocabulary
1.86
2nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 43%41%
  • Institutional 23%22%
  • Social 22%21%
  • Ceremonial 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 5%

300 sentences in 69 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Huber,

dear Mr. Conference President,

dear board members and delegates,

esteemed guests of the 21st Trade Union Congress of IG Metall,

I am very pleased to have accepted your invitation after some initial hesitation. I believe it is indeed a good tradition to invite the respective Federal Chancellors. I would also like to convey the warm greetings of the entire Federal Government to you on the occasion of your 21st Trade Union Congress.

First of all, I would like to congratulate you on the venue of the conference, not because I studied physics here when the country was still divided, but because tomorrow is also November 9, and 18 years ago the Wall fell. The fact that this was possible has a lot to do with the workers of the former GDR, who, together with others, ensured through courageous demonstrations on Monday evenings that they have a little more freedom today and that we can live together in one country.

Leipzig has always remained a city of new beginnings in German unity. If you look around this city, at the new main train station, at the state-of-the-art plants of Porsche and BMW – they are a bit closer to IG Metall than to the railway unions, which are also making headlines these days – or here at the new trade fair, you see a city that has changed significantly in these years of German unity. That this has been possible in a great spirit of solidarity among Germans from all parts of the country – through the efforts of those who had already contributed in the former GDR and often had to change their entire lives later, and through the solidarity of those in the old federal states who said: "Yes, we belong together," is one of the most beautiful pieces of German history. We can all be proud of that.

I have heard, Mr. Huber, that your work at IG Metall began here in Leipzig after the fall of the Wall. I would like to sincerely congratulate you on your election as Chairman of IG Metall. I would like to congratulate all those who were also elected, such as the Deputy Chairman, Mr. Wetzel, and the entire board. I would like to offer you a fair and honest collaboration for the good of our country.

The reason I have come here today is also one that is very important to us as the Federal Government and to me personally: The Federal Government says yes to strong trade unions. I want to make this explicitly clear at the beginning of my remarks. This does not mean that we agree on all issues – that has already been indicated; I will come to that shortly. But politics needs capable and negotiable partners; otherwise, something will break in our country. Therefore, I wish you strong action capability as well as strong negotiation capability when it comes to finding good solutions for all of us.

You have chosen the motto "The Future Needs Justice" for your trade union congress. I believe that no one can imagine the future of our country if justice has no place in it. Much in the historical discussion revolves around this question of justice. Bertolt Brecht also said in his famous "Ballad on the Question 'What Does Man Live By?'" – at that time it was a different era – "First, it must be possible for poor people to cut themselves a piece from the large loaf of bread." – End of quote.

When we talk about participation today, when we discuss how we envision our society, it always comes back to the same question: How do we achieve a fair distribution of the metaphorical "large loaf of bread"? On one side is the question of distributing the existing loaf, and on the other side is the question of how we can continually create new loaves so that we have more to distribute. This concerns you, and it concerns us. Fortunately, when I speak to you today, we are in a phase of recovery that has given people opportunities in recent years.

The number of unemployed has fallen to below 3.5 million in October. However, I want to make it clear: It is a reason for satisfaction that there are fewer than a few years ago. But that is by no means a reason to settle for it. 3.5 million unemployed is still 3.5 million too many. Our goal must be to provide every person with a job. We must work for that. We must never give up on this – neither you nor we. The number of employed persons has exceeded 40 million for the first time. This is underpinned by relatively good growth rates for Germany, namely 2.6 percent this year and somewhat less next year.

I believe that since we can see that we have over 600,000 new social insurance-contributing jobs, since we can see that more people are employed, we can already say to some extent: The recovery is reaching many people who were in a much more difficult situation some time ago. Even for those who no longer have to fear for their jobs, we can say that a little more quality of life has been created. We want and must ensure that this process continues.

Many have contributed to the fact that we have these successes today, which, while still not sufficient, are present. Workers have contributed because they have pursued a very restrained wage policy for many years. Employers have contributed as well. Painful restructuring has been agreed upon by both workers and employers. But politics has also played a role in these successes, as I believe: The policy of the previous Federal Government with the "Agenda 2010" and the policy of this Federal Government, which has taken on the theme of "Renovating, Reforming, and Investing."

We need to talk about this now. Because I believe that this path has brought us more prosperity. It has moved us forward. But we must not rest on our laurels; rather, we must continue this path. Therefore, I want to make it clear here that there will only be a policy in the future that continues the path taken two years ago in labor market policy, in financial restructuring, or in securing social security systems and does not deviate from it.

When we started as a Federal Government two years ago, when we discussed the budget for 2007, we feared that the pension system could show a gap of almost two billion euros. Today, due to the 600,000 additional social insurance-contributing jobs, this is no longer the case. In the pension system, certain reserves can even be built up again. This means that social security – whether it is our health system, our long-term care insurance, or our pension system – depends on how the labor market situation in our country develops.

When we talk about this – Mr. Huber just hinted at it in relation to the speech of the Federal President – we know that an incredible amount has changed in the last ten to fifteen years. We call this globalization. Many of the works councils who are delegates here know what is being talked about when it comes to parts of companies that have their jobs somewhere in Asia or elsewhere, which ultimately also secure jobs in Germany – whether in the automotive industry, in mechanical engineering, in power plant construction, or elsewhere. They know the international framework conditions in which we are embedded today.

That is why I want to start with the observation that a part of politics, much more than before – I completely agree with Vice Chancellor Franz Müntefering on this – consists of fighting for the framework conditions for work in Germany that allow us to compete at all. If child labor is allowed internationally, if the ruin of the environment is allowed internationally, if we do not have reasonable fair and free trade, if intellectual property is not protected but is regarded elsewhere as a trivial offense when it is stolen, then we have no chance in Germany – no matter how long and how hard we work – to assert ourselves with what we can do. Therefore, a new dimension of politics has emerged here, in which we can also work very well together. This is the creation of fair and just international framework conditions for the enforcement of a social market economy. – You may still disagree with me later. In that respect, it is not so bad if you agree with me on this point.

The question of world trade, the question of international labor standards, the question of how modern financial instruments are handled, the transparency of hedge funds, the question of how sovereign wealth funds from other countries are used, the question of how transparency in the financial markets as a whole will continue – these are all questions that concern the Federal Government.

During our G8 presidency, we specifically sought solutions and said: It must be possible to have a "Code of Conduct," that is, rules of conduct, for example, for the transparency of hedge funds. At the beginning of the year, the finance minister and I were somewhat ridiculed: Here come the Germans again with all their demands, with their regulatory zeal. Today, towards the end of the year, after many have experienced, even in Great Britain, how banks are suddenly exposed to unpredictable risks, the discussion has completely turned.

If everyone has to deal transparently with their stock, then there is no reason for there to be international financial market instruments with such low transparency that one can no longer assess the risk, and in the end, ordinary people who bring their money to the bank are put at risk. We do not want that. We will work against it. Germany is on a good path.

We have also said – this is quickly labeled as protectionism, but it is not – that we need to look at how corporate participations are acquired today and who is behind them, and whether it is necessary, especially for strategic security interests for our country, to incorporate certain control mechanisms. This is exactly the work we are currently engaged in. We will change our Foreign Trade Act. Control mechanisms are not a German invention; they are quite normal in America. The British have them. The French have them. I believe that the Germans should have something like that too.

This means that we must continually consider: How can we guarantee fair conditions for ourselves? How can we work with our international partners to advocate for minimum standards to achieve a just market economy? Without this, it will not work.

That is the external aspect. Now we know: This struggle is difficult. For this, we need the European Union and a unified stance. One must always keep this in mind. We are now about 500 million people in the European Union. You know that there are 1.3 billion people in China and 1.1 billion in India. If we want to bundle our interests, we Europeans must have strong arguments and a great commonality. At the beginning of the 20th century, it was still the case that one in four people in the world was a European. By the end of the 21st century, it will be the case that only one in 13 people will be a European.

This means that if we in Europe find something good – I am not even talking about Germany alone – we must convince twelve or thirteen others that our idea is great in order to make it the international standard. This shows the magnitude of the task. But I believe that through our model of the social market economy in Germany, we are also attractive and can convince people. That is why it is so important that we continually work on this great consensus that we have in our country, despite all differences.

One of the central themes has been almost symbolic for many other questions in recent weeks. This is the issue of unemployment benefit I. It is actually one of the interesting facets of history that my party, the CDU, already decided at its Leipzig party congress in 2003 here in these exhibition halls that the distribution of how unemployment benefit I should be structured was not as we would have wished. We wanted a somewhat shorter duration of benefits for younger people and a longer duration for older people. We believe that the placement duration for an older person in new work today actually takes longer and therefore, for reasons of equal opportunity, age should play a stronger role at this point.

You demand that a change in the law should not be revenue-neutral. We say it should be revenue-neutral. You demand that unemployment benefit I be extended to 24 months. I say quite honestly: There is a dissent on this, because I believe that especially for younger people at the moment, the chance of getting a job is so great that perhaps with a longer duration of benefits, a bit of the ambition to look for a new job could diminish. – I am just saying how I think about it.

When you conduct surveys – I have looked into all of this carefully – people are in favor of a longer duration of unemployment benefit I. To this, 80 percent of people say yes. However, if you then ask the question, "There are so many resources available in the Federal Employment Agency; do you want the contributions to be lowered so that 27 million employees have more money in their pockets, or do you want unemployment benefit I to be extended?", then the answer looks quite different. Many then say: Oh, if we have this choice, then we might also want more leeway for ourselves. – That is the tension we are operating in.

What I want to say – I believe we should actually agree on this – is: It is very important that we do not only do what is popular, but that we do what is ultimately good for Germany and thus also for the employees. To this, I still say: Social is what creates jobs. If we discuss the nature of work together, then that is okay. But regarding the fact that it is right to create more work and more jobs, we should not create artificial oppositions here in this hall.

Basically, it all revolves around good framework conditions for more employment. If we manage to lower the unemployment insurance contributions and the additional wage costs overall – that is why the federal government has set itself the goal of reducing the additional wage costs to below 40 percent – then we know that the chances of more jobs will grow. This means that lower contributions benefit not only those who have jobs but also those who currently do not have jobs, because their chances of getting back to work increase. That is why the Union says: We want a cost-neutral change in unemployment benefit I in favor of older people. We will discuss next Monday how we can do this and whether we can find solutions without incurring additional costs for the Federal Employment Agency.

I want to say again, when we look at the employment figures, especially for older people: Last year, the number of employees subject to social insurance over 55 years of age, which is still far too low, increased by seven percent. Overall, the increase in employment was 1.6 percent. This means that the upswing has particularly benefited those who are older in recent years. It must be so. We really cannot imagine in an aging society that people are sent home earlier and earlier. In my deep conviction, that is not a humane society. Forfeiting the experience of older people has already proven to be a great disadvantage in some companies. I am also hearing more and more representatives from the employers' side saying: It was not right to send so many older people home and thus lose so much experience.

When we talk about the question of what work we want, we naturally come to the topic of minimum wage. We agree on this as well. After all, I am here at IG Metall, a strong collective bargaining partner; when I ask the employers' side, that is certainly what is said. Of course, we always find ourselves in a tension between collective bargaining autonomy, which, by the way, does not exist in any of the European member states in this strength and form, and the social state mandate, meaning the obligation of the state to ensure that people can lead a dignified life.

In my opinion – and here our views diverge – it is not right to have blanket statutory minimum wages; at least not in the situation in which Germany finds itself with its strongly developed collective bargaining autonomy. This does not mean that politics must do nothing. We are currently in discussion about what we will do on the day the postal monopoly falls, and whether we should not also create some security for the postal sector through the Posted Workers Act, so that things do not move towards a situation where dumping wages are the only means of competition, where the entire competition is fought at the expense of employees. I say very clearly here: If there is a collective agreement that covers more than 50 percent of the employees, then we will declare such a collective agreement regarding the minimum wage to be generally binding. We are currently discussing whether the concluded collective agreement that is on the table covers 50 percent of the employees. We will clarify that. But we will manage to formulate the Posted Workers Act in such a way that it becomes clear: No wage dumping should be practiced here.

I am in favor of us also looking – we have set this for March of next year – at which areas we should still include in the Posted Workers Act. We have done this for cleaning companies, it applies to the construction industry, and we will consider in March next year where there is still a need for action. Because it is of course not only about internal competition, but also about other providers from other countries, from neighboring countries, where perhaps less is paid, thus creating unfair conditions.

Then we have found something

Second

that is less of a problem in the area of IG Metall but more in the area of services: There are entire employment sectors in which almost no valid collective agreements exist anymore. In these, not even 50 percent of the employees are covered by any collective agreement. We have said: Here, it must be considered that the state steps in subsidiarily when collective bargaining autonomy can no longer manage it alone. That is why we have taken an old law into consideration – it shows that those who founded the Federal Republic of Germany thought quite far ahead – namely the so-called Minimum Working Conditions Act. In 1952, it was already said: If there should ever be a case where any industry does not come to a collective agreement at all, then a way must be found for the state to help out, and the potential collective bargaining partners, that is, the employees' and employers' side, must jointly consider what minimum wage could be an answer.

I consider this approach to be more differentiated and more appropriate for our situation. Moreover, I also consider it to be a procedure that strengthens the trade unions. If the state simply sets a minimum wage, then it can also be the case that collective bargaining negotiations proceed quite differently. Then one says: The minimum standard is guaranteed. Why are you still getting upset? Do we have to do something now? This may not apply to IG Metall, but there are other unions that have to fight harder. That is why I advocate that we do not weaken something that has always been a hallmark of this republic, namely a strong, constitutionally protected collective bargaining autonomy, by rushing into a seemingly simple solution.

Now there is a topic that you are dealing with and that also plays a major role in your industry. That is the topic of temporary work. We have introduced so-called agency work. I believe, by the way, that it has proven itself. I do not advise us to abolish it; really not. We will argue about what should be done. You have different ideas than we do. That this instrument has helped many people to find work is completely undisputed. More than three-quarters of all new social insurance-covered employment relationships last year were created in the area of temporary work. This year, that share will only be 25 percent.

What does this show us? I am convinced that in early phases of economic upturn, when the economy is picking up and employers still have no certainty that this is a longer-lasting process, they first go into temporary work as a precaution, and then, when they believe they need the employees consistently, any reasonable employer wants a workforce that is truly committed to the company. That is why it is very interesting that last year three-quarters and this year a quarter of all new social insurance-covered employment relationships were created in the area of temporary work. I believe that things will continue to develop this way with a good economic trend.

But you also know how often more work had to be done in the form of overtime. You also know that you cannot force an employer to hire someone. The increase in social insurance-covered employment relationships is currently mainly taking place in small and medium-sized enterprises, which are very concerned about becoming involved in work processes that they do not want. I can list you series of companies that hesitate for a long time before making new hires. That is why it is – at least from my perspective – right that we have the possibility of temporary work.

Now we come to the next point: "Equal pay," as it is so nicely called in modern German. The principle of equal pay is agreed upon in the reform of the Temporary Employment Act. But now we come back to the point that this principle can only be deviated from by collective agreement. We know the various collective agreements in the area of temporary work. We also know that there are very interesting contracts from IG Metall, for example at Audi and Airbus, which take a different approach in this regard. I believe that before we throw the baby out with the bathwater, we should first consider together how collective bargaining autonomy can perhaps also be strengthened here. I would always prefer this over setting a false minimum wage or something in temporary work with a stroke of a pen that will cost people their jobs again. Because the conditions in the automotive industry and the textile industry as well as in the service sectors are very, very different today. I do not want to disappoint people who have found work again because they cannot continue their jobs.

Another point that I believe is still too little considered is the question of employee participation in the capital returns of the company. You will also experience in the coming years that capital returns – at least in well-managed companies – will grow faster than wages; even in what you consider to be very successful collective bargaining negotiations. This concerns me because Germany is a country where the number of people who share in the increase of capital wealth is very low in international comparison. Of course, we must be careful that these remain voluntary matters, that employees do not get into an unacceptable risk through corporate governance. But I believe it is worth the sweat of the noble – and that is why the parties of the Grand Coalition have now also come together to try to show a way here on how we can better involve employees in their own company.

Just politics, that is just politics for today, is also just politics for those who will work, shape, and decide after us. That is why the question of budget consolidation is a crucial question for the federal government. We have said that in 2011 we want to have a balanced federal budget for the first time in decades. Many of you may say: This is really not the next thing I will deal with. But look: Today, we have to give away more than 15 cents of every euro we have as federal revenue just for interest payments on accumulated debts.

We know – and nothing will change about this – that in our country the number of young people will be lower and, fortunately, the number of older people, because they live longer, will increase. This smaller number of young people will one day have to bear the burden of social security. What concerns me is the fear that the best of these young people – because we have such a beautiful unified Europe, because science can also be conducted elsewhere in the world, because engineers are sought everywhere – will say: If the burdens, the solidarity burdens for me become too great, then I will simply go to another country.

I want the intergenerational justice in this country to be preserved. That is why it is so important that we strive today so that the young people of tomorrow continue to affirm this intergenerational justice. Balanced budgets help with this, lower debts help with this.

We received a tax estimate yesterday that turned out worse than many had expected. We are short 600 million euros for the total we have now approved in the supplementary budget. We will have another billion to distribute next year. But when I look at the wishes across the departments, I know they cost far more than a billion. You all know the international risks, from the oil price to many other things. I believe we should continue the course of budget consolidation because we also need strength for investments tomorrow.

I also found it right that you, Mr. Huber, said that IG Metall demands a further development of the welfare state because changing framework conditions will also bring new challenges. To that extent, we still agree. When I now come to the topic of retirement at 67, which for me also has something to do with intergenerational justice, I probably will not find agreement anymore. I understand – I want to say this explicitly here – that many employees today are asking: What does a retirement age of 67 mean when we have an employment rate of 50 percent among those over 55? Therefore, I say: Older employees – for which Mr. Müntefering has also launched a variety of programs and activities – must have better employment opportunities. We have made progress in this regard. We were once at an employment rate of under 40 percent for those over 55. Today, thank God, we are back over 50 percent. But we need to get to 80 to 90 percent. That is beyond question.

You cannot close your eyes to the data we know about the years 2025 or 2030; we cannot close our eyes to them. They simply tell us: If the pension level is not to fall below 46 percent, if the contribution is not to rise above 20 percent, then we must extend the working life – month by month starting in 2012.

I know that you are thinking about partial pensions, about various transitional solutions, but I tell you: For me, it is important that we do not deceive ourselves a little bit. The contribution equivalence for a pension level of 46 percent is really not very much. But it already requires a company pension, it requires participation in additional private pension insurance, Riester pensions, and similar things, to even maintain one's own standard of living. We must work with the data we have. And that is why I say to you: Deciding on retirement at 67 was not easy for us, but it was the right decision because it sets the right course for future generations.

As politicians, we have the task of facing the facts. You view the issue from your perspective – I understand that – but we must do it from our perspective. I also tell you: When many used to say "The pension is secure," it sometimes cost politics a bit of credibility because some things could already be seen 15 years ago. I myself have sometimes raised my finger in the wrong place. It has not helped us at all; the situation has not become easier because of it.

What will the jobs of the future look like? Simple tasks will always be at risk of having relatively low pay. Therefore, Germany will only be able to maintain its prosperity if we are also the best in many areas. The IG Metall delegates at this congress know this very well because they work in the leading industries of the Federal Republic of Germany: in the automotive industry – the flagship – in German mechanical engineering, in sectors that drive exports – all areas where truly the best products in the world are manufactured. But the employees in these areas also know what that means in terms of innovative strength, creativity, and engineering performance.

When I come to Baden-Württemberg or Bavaria today, where unemployment figures are currently relatively low, there is no longer a call for more money, but rather a call for more skilled workers. You here probably come from large companies. Young people are most likely to go there; the situation is best there. But ask the smaller medium-sized companies how it is to find suitable skilled workers. It is described as a problem.

Now I must honestly tell you: I do not share the call for an immediate opening of the borders and an immediate influx of skilled workers from abroad. That can be the second step. But the first is: We must qualify the people in our country who have not had the opportunity in recent years. And we must spare no effort in doing so. That is why we have launched a "National Qualification Offensive."

When we look at what is happening, you know at least as well as I do: We have placed the issue of integration at the top of the agenda. 40 percent of those who are enrolled in many larger German cities are now children with a migration background. If we do not succeed in giving these children the same opportunities as those whose parents have long lived in Germany, we will not be able to permanently solve the shortage of skilled workers in our country.

The results of migrant children regarding school qualifications are sobering. Now I am not only talking about children of Turkish descent. I was recently told by the Italian ambassador: The proportion of young people of Italian descent who are currently studying at a German university – after all, in the third generation – is one percent, and the proportion of those of Turkish descent is probably even less or similarly low. Low percentages are also evident in vocational training and many other areas. Therefore, it is absolutely right to say: Anyone who comes to school must master the German language. We would rather be strict with children aged four, five, or six so that we do not have young people aged 18, 19, or 20 who are not capable of learning a modern vocational profession.

We have said: We must expand early childhood education. We have a legal entitlement to a kindergarten place, as well as all-day care offerings – all of this is being advanced by this federal government because it also increases the opportunities for those who do not receive much at home from their parents to be able to utilize their abilities and possibilities.

We want every young person to receive an apprenticeship. What is important is that when they leave school, the company also believes that they can succeed. I mean, this is also one of the scandals of the Federal Republic of Germany, that many young people go to school for ten years and then, for example, the Chamber of Industry and Commerce has to determine that they are not capable of completing vocational training. Subsequently, the Employment Agency has to order courses with contribution funds in which what was not learned in ten years of school is taught.

I am very grateful to the Federal Agency for Employment for now discussing this with the state prime ministers. We also pay close attention – our Minister of Education was for many years the Minister of Culture in Baden-Württemberg – to ensure that the educational standards between the federal states are truly aligned. If there is ever a central Abitur examination in Germany, so that all young people know what they can and cannot do, I do not consider that the end of the matter, because it also gives young people more self-confidence. The PISA study has opened our eyes.

Regarding apprenticeship places: I believe that the dual education system is indeed in a very critical phase. Especially larger companies – I say this openly to the employers – have often not trained enough in recent years. The carriers of training are also significantly medium-sized companies.

However, it is good that this year, for the first time since 2001, we have concluded more than 600,000 training contracts. But a real dual education is almost irreplaceable in terms of its quality. This dual education system, which Germany is admired for all over the world – from Ethiopia to India, from Latin America to South Africa – would be shortsighted to abandon it hastily in globalization, only to lament in five years that there are no young people to ensure the future of the companies. I am preaching in the wrong church here, but I will say it again – you can also push it forward a bit through your co-determination – but I also say it at the employers' day. Karl-Josef Laumann is here. We often talk about this with him.

At the moment, young people are getting an apprenticeship place with the good economy – at least more easily than their friends did two, three, and four years ago. However, there are many who are in so-called waiting loops or training loops, and who still appear in the statistics until the age of 25, but are no longer recognizable at all after 25. We will put all our strength into ensuring that in follow-up placements, even for those who should have been placed one or two years ago, we make sure that as few as possible are lost along the way. This is certainly a topic that concerns us very much.

Now – for that, IG Metall is of course not the right place – whether one likes it or not: In Germany, too few young people are learning technical professions, too few young people are studying technical fields. This leads to a shortage of engineers. I cannot change it. I am a physicist; I have made my contribution, but then I went into politics.

We will not be able to develop our automotive industry, our chemical industry, our software industry if we do not have the necessary skilled workers for it. Therefore, we must promote technical sciences and spark enthusiasm for the natural sciences. That we now have two Nobel Prize winners in Physics and Chemistry among us is a great thing and gives us a bit of self-confidence again.

We looked at two engineering disciplines – electrical engineering and mechanical engineering – and asked: How many unemployed electrical engineers and mechanical engineers are there in Germany? There are some. But there is a demand that is clearly above the number of those who are basically still eligible. Therefore, we have cautiously said for these two areas: We also want to give engineers from the new member states of the European Union the chance to apply with us. Whether there are any interested parties at all is uncertain, but we want to give them the opportunity.

I have tried to present to you various aspects of the policy of the federal government. We are guided by the certainty: Without growth, we will also have less to distribute. This means that without growth, we will not achieve justice. We know that justice also means the participation of all. We want to contribute to this, even if the measures you envision and those we envision sometimes diverge.

Justice and the participation of all is certainly more than the sum of all individual interests in our country. Please do not forget: Politics is also always responsible for those who are not organized in this country. We are glad that many are organized – over two million in IG Metall – but there are also many groups in the population that are not organized, and we must also think of their interests. Therefore, we are not, so to speak, the extended arm of any group in politics, but we must try to see the overall interest.

Just politics does not forget the future, but just politics does what it can foresee for the future today. I believe that a Grand Coalition has a special responsibility here. A Grand Coalition is certainly not a form of government that will always exist. But this Grand Coalition has, as you said, also had 70 percent of employees as voters. Therefore, you can assume that we are working, out of self-interest, not to forget the employees.

In this sense, thank you very much for allowing me to be here. I wish your congress all the best and us good cooperation, Mr. Huber.