Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the international WBGU symposium "Towards Low-Carbon Prosperity: National Strategies and International Partnerships" on May 9, 2012 in ...

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

12 May 2012 · International WBGU symposium 'Towards Low-Carbon Prosperity: National Strategies and International Partnerships'

Context
Merkel addressed the WBGU international symposium on low-carbon prosperity in Berlin on May 9, 2012, marking 20 years since the Rio Earth Summit.
Main themes
Climate change mitigation, low-carbon prosperity, renewable energy transition, greenhouse gas emissions reduction, resource efficiency, global climate agreements, common but differentiated responsibility, Germany's energy policy, Kyoto Protocol successor, emissions trading, fossil fuel scarcity, industrialized vs. developing country responsibilities
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,747
72nd percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
2.96
43rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 48%48%
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Not in focus 0%

136 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Dear Professor Schellnhuber,

dear Lord Stern,

dear Mr. Molina,

dear State Secretary Schütte,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

above all, you, ladies and gentlemen, the guests of this event, the theme of your event – and 20 years after the meeting in Rio – is: "Towards Low-Carbon Prosperity." Unfortunately, this topic is still relevant. One could even say: It is more relevant than ever. Everything related to resource consumption and climate change, regarding the solution of these problems, has moved somewhat in the last 20 years. But the movement is too slow when compared to the changes we are facing. Global CO2 emissions have risen again. Therefore, we must continually advocate that we do not lose sight of the goal of limiting the temperature increase to two degrees.

Lord Stern has made it clear to all of us that inaction will be very costly. This means that we must keep reminding ourselves: If we do nothing, the situation will not become more comfortable. It may seem that way at the moment, but in the long run, the opposite is true. The question of how we can reasonably address the issue of finite resources and the question of climate change has now become an absolutely global question. In the last 20 years, it has become clear that it is no longer just a question for industrialized countries. Even if industrialized countries acted alone and did everything right, we would still have a climate problem, a warming problem. Today, therefore, more countries share this responsibility. Nevertheless, it remains true what was agreed upon in the Climate Framework Convention: We have a common but differentiated responsibility. Particularly regarding the development of technologies, including the testing phase of technologies and the pioneering role, industrialized countries have an outstanding role, as far as they are able to.

I always mention climate change and resource efficiency or the finiteness of resources in connection because I have no desire to constantly engage with doubters about whether climate change will really be that severe and will occur to such an extent. The mere fact that we are heading towards nine billion people in the world shows us that even those who do not believe in climate change must rethink. To avoid any doubt: I belong to those who believe that something is happening with the climate. But so that we do not waste time on the question of whether it is happening, I simply say: Those who do not want to believe it, who continually sow doubts, who emphasize uncertainties, should just remember that we are heading towards nine billion people in the world, and they should look at the speed of fossil resource consumption. Then they will come to the same conclusion that those who make themselves independent of generating energy in the conventional way are in a good position. Therefore, a different energy supply, namely through renewable energies, and a more efficient use of energy and resources are the two key factors.

When looking at the price development of raw materials, which is of course subject to fluctuations, the general trend is clear: Scarcity usually leads to rising prices, creating competition for deposits. Even if the so-called shale gas seems to provide some relief for the energy supply of some, it will not have a lasting effect that allows us to forget everything we have otherwise said about energy efficiency and renewable energies. The Scientific Advisory Board on Global Environmental Changes has repeatedly addressed these issues since its establishment 20 years ago. I would like to sincerely thank all those who have been doing this for two decades for their commitment.

I think we all agree: We need a follow-up agreement to the Kyoto Protocol, a new climate protection agreement. There is always hope and, I would put it this way, also despair. But every time one thinks that it cannot progress at all, it does move forward a bit. One gets the impression that it is always progressing too slowly, but at least it is progressing. It was certainly important that it was agreed in Durban to continue, to strive for a climate agreement.

It is also important that we do not lose sight of the targets: We must reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Germany wants to be a pioneer in this regard and aims to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 40 percent by 2020 compared to 1990 and by 80 percent by 2050. We are also advocating for an ambitious policy at the European level. We currently have some leeway. We can see this in the certificate prices, which do not give the impression that scarcity is already overwhelming. Therefore, this will also need to be discussed further. The financing of all the necessary measures we have set for ourselves is also closely linked to the revenues from emissions trading.

Between 1990 and 2010, we reduced our annual greenhouse gas emissions in the EU by over 15 percent. Germany has played a significant role in this success. We should not always emphasize this, but to avoid any illusions, it must be acknowledged that Germany has a very large share in this. However, we will probably not be able to have such a large share in the future, as we will not experience German reunification again. In this respect, we are now entering normal waters.

Nevertheless, we have managed to be among the most energy-efficient and environmentally friendly economies through a multitude of regulations, especially regarding industrial production. In the entire area of private consumption, the heating market, and similar areas, we are not doing nearly as well. There are still huge opportunities there.

We have set ourselves the goal of increasing the share of renewable energies in total energy consumption to 60 percent by 2050. For electricity consumption, this should be 80 percent. This means: We must now find the right framework conditions. In light of what happened in Fukushima last year, the federal government has once again changed its energy policy. This has contributed to a societal consensus regarding the phase-out of certain energy forms, such as nuclear energy. However, it has not yet led to a societal consensus regarding the changes and the necessary infrastructure measures. We will still have a lot of work to do here, as it is becoming clear that the transition to the age of renewable energies represents a significant qualitative shift in energy supply and also in the economy.

The incentive regulations for the expansion of renewable energies must be reconciled with the phasing out of, but still necessary, use of conventional, baseload-capable, and mostly fossil energy sources – this will be the real task of the coming years. How to keep the one, which has always been profitable, namely fossil energy generation, economically viable without giving up the incentives for the other, renewable energies, will require a significant shift in thinking. Here, the term capacity markets must be mentioned. One must only be careful not to end up producing only subsidized energy but also to consider economic viability.

One thing has always been clear to us in connection with sustainability: environmental friendliness, social compatibility, and economic viability – this triangle. This will now need to be viewed from a completely different perspective. The priority feed-in for renewable energies, as it exists in Germany, does not automatically align with the operation of a newly built coal-fired power plant and its baseload hours.

To achieve this, two things are necessary:

The first is the expansion of the grid, as the networks will be required to function differently than before. There is also a lot happening technologically in this area.

The second aspect is finding storage options. In general, the great innovative challenge of our time is to develop storage for electricity. Therefore, a lot of research is being conducted in this area.

Research is the key to the success of the energy transition. The federal government has found an approach with the high-tech strategy of the Federal Minister of Research to speak very honestly about it: Where are we at the forefront of research worldwide, and where do we need to take action? The topic of energy research is of outstanding importance. However, we also know that other countries are very ambitious in this regard. This means: If we want to remain innovative, we must also put all our strength into it.

But it is not only about individual storage or individual network sections and the necessary technologies for them, but it is also about societal cooperation. Examples include the CO2-free city, smart grids, and a completely different consumer behavior. The consumer must think along about when things are attractive to them and when they are not. This means: It is already a change in overall societal behavior, for which a lot of argumentation must also be done. We can actually consider ourselves fortunate that we have timely discovered the blessings of information technology, the internet, and all the possibilities of data processing. Otherwise, we would not be able to achieve the logistical connection of everything needed to ensure a completely different form of economy. This shows that people continually come up with ideas that they can use well to accompany their changes.

The German population is not always as willing to change as we might wish. However, it must be seen that we only have a chance to maintain our prosperity in the coming decades if we remain innovative. As we age on average and even with extended life expectancy, the life horizon of the elderly tends to be shorter, there is a great danger that our society will rest too much on the point it is at. This means: We must do everything to encourage lifelong learning so that people think beyond their own life horizon and maintain the innovative power as the basis of our progress. We see rising economies that are doing this quite well today.

There are many small building blocks, such as model projects for CO2-free cities, for smart grids, and for a high energy efficiency house. A few months ago, I opened the Efficiency House Plus with Federal Minister of Construction Peter Ramsauer, into which a family of four has moved to test practical living and report back to us. In many areas, capabilities are therefore growing. These must be linked in the coming years.

Of course, international agreements and international cooperation are extremely helpful. There have also been a number of advances in this regard, not only that a timeline was developed in Durban, but also that we have entirely new constellations in the world regarding how cooperation occurs.

Basically, a country like China knows for two reasons that it can no longer play the role in energy supply and climate protection that it played 20 years ago: First, because its own energy demand is so high, because its own resource consumption is so high, as it has never been before; and second, because it is no longer so easy to find the partners among developing countries that one would like to have in the world.

We remember the G77 plus China: That was always a very solid entity when we negotiated the Kyoto Protocol. It is not so simple today; rather, the G77 are more aligned with Europe, and China must ensure that it retains its former partners. This means: One can also see shifts in power, which then leads to the formation of new alliances. The success in Durban would not have been possible if developing countries and European countries had not worked very closely together.

I want to explicitly state: I see Germany and Europe in a pioneering role also from an ethical perspective. I see this role partly because it concerns our standard of living. But it is also our moral obligation to go through the testing phases, to learn how to deal with the complexity of new energy supply, with resource efficiency and efficient technologies, and also to pay subsidies, because we too have, in other places, when others did not yet have the opportunities for prosperity that we had, exploited resources for years and decades. In this respect, it is also about a certain balance. I believe we should accept this task and also turn it to our advantage.

This means that we must also utilize the Energy and Climate Fund for the projects that have been agreed upon and for the developing countries. Therefore, it is very important that we can actually deploy the resources we have promised, as many countries hope that they will then be able to take the necessary measures. The topic of the Green Economy Roadmap is a central issue that we should also fill with content and timelines at the United Nations. This will play a significant role with regard to Rio.

A persistent issue that is still unresolved and, unfortunately, will not be resolved in Rio either: Given the high importance of sustainability and environmental protection, the United Nations, in my opinion, needs to have an institution that deals with these topics. A central theme must, of course, be climate protection, but also issues like biodiversity and many others are required here. I do not hesitate to say, as I have often mentioned, that this organization will most likely be based in Africa. That is also good. With UNEP, there is already a foundational element in place. However, it does not speak well for the speed of the international community that we have not made progress in this area despite the 20th anniversary of Rio.

I say to you, who come from the various disciplines of science: Stay persistent and, I want to say this somewhat casually, sometimes wake us politicians up. If you have good arguments, we will listen to them and we cannot evade them. We are experiencing this at all corners and ends. Advocate for the societal community of those who say: we need to fundamentally change to grow larger.

There has been a significant change in thinking over the last 20 years, from the business sector, but also from many citizens, but all progress is of no help if the reaction ultimately comes too late. That is why I repeatedly recommend looking at what happens when nothing happens. And that will be bitter. Because even if things change as they might have changed, had we – I return to the doubters – no industry: The mere fact that we are now more than seven billion and will soon be more than eight billion people, the majority of whom live in very different parts of the world than was the case centuries ago, will lead to consequences that can trigger many civilizational conflicts, which will cost us dearly.

Therefore, I must tell you: With the Sustainability Council, but also with the WBGU, the federal government has committed to institutions that keep an eye on us and force us to think differently. We still have many homework assignments to complete, as we know, from demographic sustainability to financial sustainability to questions of resource sustainability and environmental sustainability.

I also simply ask the environmental community for a bit of support when it comes to financial sustainability. We are currently having a discussion that sometimes seems quite strange to me. It is said that we are now only saving. I must point out that we are actually only talking about whether we spend ten percent more per year than we have, or only five percent, or perhaps only three percent. In almost none of the cases is it mentioned that we are paying anything back, and in almost none of the cases is it mentioned that we are only consuming what we earn in a year. There are some Scandinavian countries that are role models in this regard, but otherwise, what is referred to as austerity means a deficit between six and three percent. I cannot find that we are making significant progress with that. Sustainability is something that must become a matter of course in all areas of life. Therefore, solid growth and solid prosperity cannot be based on debt, on increased resource consumption, and on other waste.

Since I know that you all already know this, I will just say: Let us be brave together to achieve this collectively, each in their own role. Finding majorities for this is not always easy and not at every moment, but I believe we have the responsibility to do so. I wish you successful discussions.