Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the Leaders' Dialogue "The Economics of Climate Change" on September 25, 2007, in New York:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

25 September 2007 · Leaders' Dialogue "The Economics of Climate Change" · New York, United States

Context
Merkel addressed the Leaders' Dialogue on the Economics of Climate Change at the UN General Assembly in New York on September 25, 2007.
Main themes
Climate change economics, post-Kyoto framework, IPCC scientific evidence, CO2 emissions reduction targets, European Union climate commitments, sustainable development, biodiversity, Millennium Development Goals, human-caused climate change, adaptation strategies
Duration
~19 min
62nd percentile
Words
2,236
62nd percentile
Sentences
115
69th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
10.8
29th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 63%63%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 11%11%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

115 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Kilz,

Mr. Holbrooke,

Mr. Berger,

Mr. Walther,

Excellencies,

ladies and gentlemen!

I would like to thank you for the opportunity to speak here at the Leaders’ Dialogue at the invitation of the "Süddeutsche Zeitung," to discuss or reflect on the topic of climate change with you.

Climate change is indeed a top issue. The fact that it has been chosen by the UN Secretary-General as the main topic for this UN General Assembly shows that this issue has made its way from the realm of experts into the work of generalists, that is, the politically responsible in the broadest sense.

I would like to perhaps recall history. Essentially, the Rio Agreement, the commitment to sustainable development, was one of the major breakthroughs that led to the ecological component—namely, that our resources are limited and that we must manage them wisely—being more strongly integrated into people's thinking alongside the social and economic components. Following Kyoto, there were various framework agreements, of which the Climate Framework Convention is the one that demands our attention the most.

I would like to remind you that next year a Conference of the Parties—analogous to the Climate Conference—on the topic of biodiversity will take place in Germany. The issue of biodiversity is just as pressing as that of climate change. It is just more difficult to grasp because we cannot quantify it as easily.

Overall, a comprehensive UN process of so-called sustainable development has emerged, in which we, among the states of the world, have committed to saying: environmental development, economic development, and social development can go hand in hand; environmental protection and social standards are therefore not opposites.

The Climate Framework Convention has been implemented into the so-called protocols. From this, quantifiable targets were established for the first time in Kyoto. In my estimation, we have only seen something like this a second time with the Millennium Development Goals, in which we formulated the intention to allocate 0.7 percent of gross national product for development aid by 2015.

Kyoto was adopted but ultimately not ratified by all—among others, not by the United States of America. At one point, there was even a very critical question of whether it would be possible to find the necessary majority of states. This was achieved through Russia's accession.

Mr. Kilz is already asking today whether Kyoto will fail and whether we will achieve the Kyoto targets. The question is justified, as the targets set by the industrialized countries at that time are very difficult to achieve. There are a number of states that have not ratified at all, and there are some states—like Canada—that have declared that they will not be able to meet them because it is no longer feasible.

The European Union is on a path where it is not yet guaranteed that we will truly succeed. As the European Union, we have to achieve a reduction rate of eight percent. Germany must account for three-quarters of that—this has to do with German reunification. Germany will almost meet its contribution. However, although Germany will account for about three-quarters of that eight percent, we are currently only at a two percent reduction within the European Union, because the very high economic growth in some countries—Spain, Greece, and others—is unfortunately not decoupled from CO2 emissions but is associated with very high CO2 emissions. Therefore, we Europeans should not sit on our high horse.

In any case, Kyoto was a very important step. I maintain that it was a milestone. We have gained new insights this year. Time is pressing to ask: What comes after Kyoto—since the Kyoto Framework Agreement expires in 2012?

Now we have the much-mentioned IPCC. This is a body of scientists who are continually refining their findings to answer the question of the extent to which climate change is caused by humans. That is the real, exciting question.

I want to say right away: Climate change has always existed. I grew up in a region of Germany shaped by the Ice Age—there were times when there was only ice. But if you look at what is currently happening in Greenland, you see that the scientific evidence that the current climate change is caused by humans is very, very high: What used to take 10,000 years, namely a temperature change of two to four degrees, is now happening in 50 years. According to what happened 10,000 years ago, the temperature was constant for about 5,000 years, then it rose or fell by two to five percent over the next 5,000 years.

Today, we must adapt—this is why there is so much talk about adaptation—within 50 years, and this is with a world population that will soon be around eight to nine billion people. This means we will soon have such a level of population that the consequential damages, if we do nothing, will be very, very large. The scientific evidence is therefore, in my view, overwhelming.

Now there are doubters who still say: Who knows for sure? There is something like prophylaxis; one can say: If the indicators are so overwhelming, perhaps we should do something. To those who now ask whether it is even worth doing something, I would simply respond: Given the finiteness of oil and gas in the world, it is worth it for the developed industrial countries, for the sake of independence, to strive for the most economical consumption of carbon-based energy sources. Even if all scientists were wrong, one would still not have done anything wrong. I think that is a good reason to take action.

I have often discussed this with American officials: When I consider the extent to which the United States is dependent on the most unstable regions of the world, simply because they have such a high consumption of energy sources, I think that is also a reason to really make an effort in this regard.

Now there are reports—which are of course very important for you in business—that state: If we do nothing and then have to adapt to everything that happens, it will cost us about five percent of the world's gross domestic product in expenditures. These expenditures will not be evenly distributed among everyone, but overall they will arise from the damages caused—they could even be higher. If we act, then we can—also because we still have some time; by the middle of the century we should achieve visible successes—manage with the use of one percent of our world gross domestic product and change our style. So we are not talking about "additional costs" compared to "doing nothing." Rather, we must weigh what "doing nothing" costs and what "doing something" costs.

Therefore, the whole question of climate change is not at our own disposal, but it follows objective realities. Scientists tell us: You can maintain a limit of two degrees of increase with a relatively manageable effort; however, if the increase in average global temperature is higher, it will cost you much more. Therefore, it is not reasonable to allow a greater increase.

If we want to maintain this limit of a two-degree increase, we must achieve a halving of global CO2 emissions by the year 2050. There is now a noble dispute about whether the base year to which this refers is 1990 or today. This makes a significant difference, but I do not want to delve into that here.

Now we have approached this question at the G8 meeting. The United States has spoken of "seriously consider," meaning that they would seriously consider whether such a halving target should be pursued. I think we now also have an agreement that we want to do everything under the umbrella of the UN. We have an agreement that we need a medium-term target—by the middle of this century.

Halving CO2 emissions means nothing other than that we must reduce CO2 emissions from today's four tons per capita of the world population to two tons. However, I have not yet factored in that the world population will continue to rise. Four tons per capita—China is currently at 3.5 tons, India is far below that, the United States of America weighs in at 20 tons per capita, Germany at eleven tons, the European Union averages nine tons. There you see the dimension we are facing.

Therefore, there is a common but differentiated responsibility of industrialized countries and developing countries. The task will be to find a way in the post-Kyoto period where not only the industrialized countries are set on quantifiable reduction targets, but where the so-called emerging countries must also take their share. Even if the industrialized countries were to emit zero CO2 in the future—for example, Europe currently accounts for 15 percent of global CO2 emissions, which will tend to decrease—we have not solved the problem. This means that the emerging countries must take responsibility.

The question now is: On what basis do the emerging countries take responsibility? I believe—although it may be difficult—that there is no other way than to grant every person in the world the same right to development. This means that in the long term, we will only get the emerging countries on board if we say: Every person in the world is allowed to emit equally.

The topic of climate is therefore so fascinating, as I see it, because it stands pars pro toto for the foundations of our future common way of living in the world. What do we allow whom? How did we actually envision this? Are the Chinese and the Indians also allowed to drive a car and have a refrigerator? What are they allowed? If the dignity of man is indivisible and equal, then it means I cannot tell others: You may not do what we are allowed to do.

On the other hand, this question is also not burdened by historical conflicts, wars, and so on. If the developing countries say: You have done everything wrong in the industrialized countries for a hundred years; then we say: Okay, but it affects you just the same. It is therefore not worth looking back to the past; rather, we must look forward. The commonalities of the rules of the game that we have to work out can be wonderfully learned and developed on this topic, as I see it. This is a long-term task.

Now the question is: How do we approach this? The United States today still says—basically, so do the Japanese and the Canadians; the positions on this are still somewhat soft: We are developing new technologies, we agree to that; we set a long-term goal and then we will see if we can achieve it. I would say, according to the rules of probability, it is relatively unlikely that if everyone says they will make an effort, exactly what the scientists tell us should happen will come to pass, namely that we do not increase the temperature by more than two degrees. It could work—there are wonderful technological successes, and we have always experienced that much is possible—but it is unlikely.

I therefore say we need two things, which could even be alternative or both must be applied:

We need regional reduction targets and we need instruments for achieving the goals as economically efficiently as possible.

It is of no use to take the most expensive route; rather, we must try to make it economically efficient. It can probably be done most economically efficiently by developing a CO2 certification system, as we already have in Europe today. Then, certificates would also have to be purchased in the less developed countries, which would force these countries to implement technologies. This way, we would likely advance technological change at the lowest cost.

If everyone could agree on that, we would no longer need regional targets. However, we would then need a global trading system. Until we have developed that, we should agree on regional targets, because otherwise, I believe, it will not work. We are still in the toughest negotiations with the United States and other countries on this last point.

Two

things have been achieved:

Making climate change a topic at the UN and—almost achieved—setting a medium-term target.

The

third

goal is, of course, not so easy to achieve; it still needs to be accomplished.

Now we have the choice of whether to tackle this. I am optimistic because it is no longer just a problem for the ministers of specific departments. Nevertheless, I know that it will change our way of life significantly. However, we have experienced – for example, at the recent automobile exhibition in Germany: If we develop a joy for technology and tell ourselves that we still have some time – but we must do everything to truly implement the technologies – then we can achieve an incredible amount through new forms of energy generation and, above all, through energy savings as well as through new technologies in the transportation sector.

For the industrialized countries, if they take on this challenge, it can mean an incredible safeguard of jobs for the future and an incredible export opportunity towards the developing countries. When one considers that we all have significant demographic problems and that our consumption sector is no longer growing dramatically on its own, then it has many, many advantages to say: We will apply our technological edge, which we have in many areas, to this issue.

In this sense, I will continue to work.