Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the mid-term review of the current term of office of the National Regulatory Control Council on October 22, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

22 October 2019 · Mid-term review of the current term of office of the National Regulatory Control Council · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the National Regulatory Control Council's mid-term review in Berlin on October 22, 2019, reflecting on Germany's efforts to reduce bureaucracy since 2006.
Main themes
Bureaucratic reduction, regulation and overregulation, National Regulatory Control Council, balance between security and freedom, digitization, business burden relief, EU and federal law complexity, climate and consumer protection legislation, common sense in lawmaking, protectionism through regulation
Duration
~25 min
76th percentile
Words
3,028
76th percentile
Sentences
167
84th percentile
Readability
50
64th percentile
Grade
10.5
26th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 62%62%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Technological 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

167 sentences in 31 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Ludewig,

dear members of the National Regulatory Control Council,

dear State Minister, dear Hendrik Hoppenstedt,

dear colleagues from the German Bundestag,

ladies and gentlemen who have come here today – I see representatives from the business community and would like to mention Mr. Wollseifer as a representative for all –, the question of how much state we need, how many regulations we need to reasonably, prosperously, and safely regulate our coexistence, has been a concern for governments since the founding of the Federal Republic of Germany – that is now 70 years. Because without regulations, there can be no state. Legal certainty is important. But when exactly does regulation become unnecessary overregulation? Where is the line in the tension between security and freedom? Where does the effort justify the additional security? Or how much freedom must I relinquish, even if it involves an increased risk? Such questions concern us all. Very often, when something happens, the answer is: the relevant regulation was not sufficient. So there is a tendency to ensure more and more, supposedly for safety, only to find that life takes new twists and entirely new scenarios arise. After 70 years of the Federal Republic, one can also become overly regulated and thereby restrict freedoms. There is also legitimate opposition to this.

The Regulatory Control Council deals with these questions on a daily basis. These are, of course, questions that repeatedly concern us in public. Whether in climate protection, consumer protection, or labor rights – when we draft laws, it is important to ensure not only that we meet the goals we pursue with these laws but also to keep the effort as low as possible and not to lose common sense. Digital labs, for example, come into play here, because the distance between the user or the affected party of the law and the maker of the law is often so great that it is very difficult to empathize with the other perspective.

Now, there is not only federal law. There is EU law, municipal law, state law, there are professional associations, self-governing bodies, which, by the way, are sometimes also the subject of complaints when it comes to effort and data collection. Many companies and citizens feel burdened by all of this. Why is it so difficult to reduce bureaucracy? There is hardly a regulation that does not have at least one beneficiary. We must see that regulations are sometimes also small forms of protectionism. The so-called non-tariff barriers exist not only in international trade. As Minister of the Environment, I have gained many experiences, such as how the concrete industry benefits from thicker manhole covers or how the steel industry benefits from more rungs in the drain after someone has fallen in at some point. You can hardly imagine what can happen.

Citizens expect, on the one hand, that the state fulfills its obligations and also controls and regulates. But the sense and purpose of some regulations are often not clear to everyone. Forms are often somewhat stubborn compared to what a person associates with common sense. All of this has its price – its price in time and in costs.

That is why we have been systematically addressing this issue since 2006. We have significantly reduced information obligations for businesses – that is, the number of applications, proofs, statistics, and the like – and have not rebuilt them. We have found ways to simplify procedures, for example, in BAföG and in nursing documentation. Above all, we have become accustomed to presenting new bureaucratic burdens as well as reliefs in all government drafts, so that we can also take stock. This has created more transparency. To ensure that this is done objectively, we established the Regulatory Control Council in 2006. We have understood that it has become a permanent task and that the scope of your work has also broadened.

I think it can be said that the constant effort is worthwhile. The annual recurring burdens for citizens decreased by a total of around 700,000 hours and 24.5 million euros in 2018. Here, we can say that digitization is also bearing fruit – for example, the online platform for parental allowance. For businesses, we achieved a reduction in annual burdens of 405 million euros in 2018.

Now, if one follows Mr. Ludewig's statements in a well-known German newspaper and our calculations, one sometimes gets the impression that we need to better align our statistics. Because there are various calculation methods involved. But overall, I think it can be said that there were only a few discrepancies in quantifying the reduction of bureaucracy costs. This was during the legislative period from 2013 to 2017. I want to highlight the minimum wage. Everyone tells me that the calculations are correct; and yet they are not entirely understandable from a common-sense perspective. If the fact that three billion euros more in wages are paid is associated with additional costs for compliance, then that is, of course, correct from the companies' perspective. But in the perception of citizens and also in the perception of companies, it is something different than if, so to speak, three billion euros had to be accounted for because new forms had to be filled out. In this respect, the methodology here may need to be reconsidered. But perhaps we will not see such a legislative initiative as the minimum wage again.

If you look at the period from 2011, the balance does not look so great. If you look at the period from 2015, it gets better. Between 2011 and 2014, there were basically two occurrences – one of which is the minimum wage – that set us back. Otherwise, everything is flowing well.

"One in, one out" – that was the major innovation we introduced in 2015. I still remember how we discussed the methodology back then. It has already shown its effects. Because all departments are now required to constantly review regulations to see if they are still current and necessary and what interrelationships exist. Therefore, it is also possible to let something expire from time to time. Since the introduction of this bureaucracy brake, there have been reliefs amounting to a total of 4.2 billion euros. This is countered by burdens of around 1.3 billion euros. Thus, we have even achieved "One in, three out," if one wants to express it in English.

Nevertheless, the blemish remains that "One in, one out" is not applied everywhere. The effort that arises for businesses due to the transition to new regulations – such as new software, training costs, retrofitting of technical systems, for example, exhaust filters, and so on – is not included. Therefore, I say that the demand of the Regulatory Control Council to also include this transition effort is justified and understandable. I think we will continue to discuss in the federal government that this should indeed happen for the sake of transparency. After all, in the first two years of the current legislative period, the transition effort amounted to only 900 million euros. That is a lot of money, but still less than one-fifth of the value of the previous legislative period. One can therefore also strive to ensure that the transition effort does not become so costly.

It is, of course, subject to criticism that the implementation of EU law is not included in "One in, one out." I would like to point out that we would significantly exceed "One in, one out" if we also took into account the effort of implementing EU directives. However, in some departments, there was concern that they were more affected by EU rules than others and therefore had fewer opportunities to intervene. While one can exchange views between ministries regarding regulations, one is dependent on the goodwill of others. In this respect, the departments are, of course, careful to fulfill their obligations themselves.

Therefore, the message from Ursula von der Leyen, the future President of the Commission, is really good. She says that she wants to apply the "One in, one out" principle in the EU as well. That would be a huge step forward and would be very beneficial for us. The Juncker Commission has already done something that was not customary in EU practice until then. It has set aside 80 directives and thus somewhat put aside the philosophy that with each new directive, the integration of Europe would improve. It is not the number of regulations in Europe that determines Europe's capabilities and skills, but rather whether it can be a lived practice in a reasonable way. Therefore, it is really very, very important that the new Commission President continues this and says: We apply the "One in, one out" principle.

Now, as Mr. Ludewig has already indicated, it is indeed always about how we can make laws and regulations understandable. It is therefore obvious to involve those who are affected. That is why a very important point was the life situation survey conducted by the Federal Statistical Office. In 2017, nearly 10,000 individual interviews were conducted to gather experiences with laws and regulations. It is not just a small sample taken once, but it is already a very comprehensive process. Then one can see very clearly what citizens and businesses are dissatisfied with. In ten topic workshops at the Chancellery, we sought new solutions with those affected as well as with experts – for example, on the topics of value-added tax, trade tax, volunteer work, and unemployment benefits. The result of these discussions was quite a number of practical proposals that were summarized in a work program in 2018, which we are now implementing.

The most comprehensive innovations – these are not yet included in your latest statistics because the law is still in progress – have now been initiated in a third Bureaucracy Relief Act by cabinet resolution. With this law alone, we want to relieve the economy by another approximately 1.1 billion euros per year; and thus more than with the two preceding laws combined. – I would like to sincerely thank Hendrik Hoppenstedt at this point. He has repeatedly pointed out the issues and said: "Don't come to me again with 200-million-euro laws; it really has to be something that is also visible." Among other things, we will introduce an electronic procedure for sick leave. The submission of the yellow slip to the employer will thus be eliminated. We will also relieve taxpayers in archiving tax data – and of course do several other things.

The ministries are currently preparing further measures. This includes, for example, making the application for family benefits easier or simplifying the complicated system of import VAT. This would be very important for many reasons – including competitiveness, as I learned during my visit to the Port of Hamburg. However, it must be said that we as the federal government cannot act autonomously in this regard, but are always tied to the state tax administrations. These are noble institutions, but before all federal states agree on the same procedure and the transition of the software, it can take a while.

Among the topics that the Chancellery coordinates within the federal government, in addition to reducing bureaucracy, is also digitization. Here, I want to make it clear that what Mr. Ludewig said is really essential: We need to take the perspective of users much more into account. Not only through the way we draft laws can we incorporate the perspective of users. Through digitization, we also have the opportunity to improve the accessibility of the administration, so that everyone can handle the services with the administration when they have time; and not just during the administration's opening hours. This is, of course, a huge step forward for citizens.

By 2022, we will offer 575 administrative services from the federal and state levels digitally under the already mentioned Online Access Act (OZG) – parental allowance, child benefit, housing benefit; how many tables and chairs can one set up on the sidewalk in front of the café? The latter is not a federal task, but is indeed very important at the municipal level; and this should be clarified with as few clicks as possible.

Let me address something that has been weighing on my mind; namely the question: What "sense of urgency" do the administrations and the citizens of Germany actually feel when it comes to transitioning to a digital way of shaping our lives? Let me put it this way: This "sense of urgency" is not particularly pronounced in comparison to other European countries. Last year, we invited Denmark as a model country to a conference in connection with the discussion about the Online Access Act. I must tell you: My conversation with the then Danish Prime Minister was simply sobering. In Denmark, there is no longer any postal correspondence; there are no mailboxes. For a while, they still sent out the PIN once a year, but that was the only letter that reached anyone. It is hard to imagine that here in our country. However, this is already a reality in our immediate neighborhood; and I am not even talking about Estonia yet.

In my conversation with the Estonian President, who is vigorously pushing for digitalization, I learned about the General Data Protection Regulation that compliance with this regulation, which is such a drama for us, is not a drama at all in Estonia. Why is that? Because everything there is digitized. Every association has everything registered in a certain way. All commercial registers, all personal registers, all vehicle registers – all are digitized according to the same methodology. Therefore, when it comes to the information that must be provided under the General Data Protection Regulation, it is no longer the case that any association has to painstakingly fill out any forms; instead, one can simply access the necessary information; and with one click, the matter is settled.

She also said she knows exactly why it is like that in Germany. In Denmark, they are intensively looking at Germany and examining what is different about us compared to them. They are then looking for models on how they can connect with us and present us with services; this is also a business model for them. Therefore, they need to understand what we do that seems a bit strange and outdated from their perspective so that they know how to advise us. Finland is now also taking a joint path with Estonia. And they are also creating European allies. Portugal would be another country to mention. We are thus surrounded by countries that have a lot of "drive" in this matter. Therefore, we too must really move forward.

That is why we recently agreed in the Digital Cabinet to accelerate the modernization of the German register landscape. This is not only about the Central Foreigners Register but also about others. We also want to focus more on the needs of the citizens, which we can also do through the digital labs.

We also need practical tests. We have been working on this since 2015 under the heading "effective governance." For example, in collaboration with citizens, the comprehensibility of forms and the protection of small investors in the Investment Act have been improved through clearer information. We must also always be ready to readjust existing regulations when we recognize that enforcement brings too many difficulties.

This brings us to the point of "ex ante" and "ex post." In the coming years, we will evaluate the impact of over 300 laws. If you predict an administrative burden for us ex ante, we must have the ambition to prove to you that the burden is much smaller ex post. That would already be a real incentive to say: We must move forward.

I just wondered while listening: When the Norm Control Council began its work, we had already evaluated all existing laws for their administrative burden, right? It was only about information and reporting obligations back then, wasn't it? If I remember correctly, the Federal Statistical Office dealt with that at the time; and that could now also play a role in the methodology. However, State Minister Hoppenstedt whispered to me that they are currently developing a methodology. I would also put this methodology on as neutral a footing as possible. The originator of a law should not be too involved in its evaluation, I would simply say. They should not, if only because they would be assessed as biased, which would undermine the credibility of the data. However, I believe I have said something here that is not yet "common ground" in the State Secretary Committee. But perhaps it can become that now that I have said it.

With that, I have also arrived at the section of "thanks." When you look at where we started in 2006 – namely only with reporting obligations – and where we have come to now – namely with the examination of administrative burdens; and thus much closer to the people – it shows the distance we have covered. Only if we start where people really feel affected will the impression arise that something has been simplified. In addition to what we are doing, I also place a lot of hope in digitalization. I also acknowledge that you have been a bit restless lately because the times we have given you to assess the impact of a law have been very short. This was somewhat due to the urgency under which we are currently working. I believe that will normalize again.

So: Thank you for your patience with us, thank you for your willingness to continually embark on new paths, and for the time you dedicate to this work in the Norm Control Council. This has overall led to a much more transparent legislative process. In a time when feelings and facts are always in a certain competition with each other, I would say: At least on the factual basis, we have quite a bit to show. However, this must also be reflected in the emotional realm. And that is why we must continue to work hard.

Thank you very much and all the best.