Government statement by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel, on the European Council on October 17 and 18, 2019, in Brussels before the German Bundestag on October 17, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

17 October 2019 · European Council, Government statement before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on October 17, 2019, ahead of the Brussels European Council meeting to outline Germany's positions on Brexit and other pressing European issues.
Main themes
Brexit negotiations, Good Friday Agreement and Irish border, EU internal market principles, Western Balkans EU accession, Turkey military offensive in northern Syria, EU-UK future relations, European Council summit agenda, stability at Europe's borders, Germany-UK partnership, Kurdish YPG and northern Syria
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,648
70th percentile
Sentences
137
77th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
12.0
44th percentile
Syntax
2.99
47th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 56%54%
  • Economic 13%12%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Environmental 5%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

137 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Dear colleagues,

Ladies and gentlemen,

For two and a half years now, we have been negotiating intensively about the United Kingdom's exit from the European Union. There has been movement in recent days, significant movement. The British side has shown a willingness to negotiate and has backed this up with very concrete proposals. We are therefore on a better path than before, but – I must say this very clearly this morning – we are not yet at our goal. We must and will therefore continue to do everything we can to bring the negotiations to a successful conclusion. I would like to extend my heartfelt thanks to Michel Barnier, the chief negotiator, and his team, who are truly working day and night.

It remains true that if we want to find a good solution, it is akin to squaring the circle. In recent years, months, and weeks, we have thought several times that we were on the verge of a solution. Then things fell apart again. Therefore, I cannot say here today how the European Council will end tomorrow. But I can tell you that it remains clear that we will not allow hatred and violence to flare up again on the island of Ireland due to a hard border. We will advocate that the Good Friday Agreement is not put at risk by anything or anyone.

The principles of the internal market must also not be called into question – this cannot be emphasized often enough – because we have not yet reached an agreement on all issues related to customs. We need practical, realistic solutions for how the new customs controls in Northern Ireland are to be implemented concretely. Negotiations on this are ongoing.

So we can conclude: An agreement on an orderly exit of the United Kingdom from the EU is still possible. We will negotiate until the last second. If necessary, we can also meet again at a special council; but let us first see what develops. Even though we are well prepared for a disorderly exit, an orderly Brexit is, of course, in the interest of all, I believe, also in the interest of Great Britain.

The United Kingdom is and remains an important partner on many issues, whether economic or security-related. We share a long history and common values. Therefore, we want to maintain close and trusting relations with Great Britain after its exit, both economically and in foreign and security policy.

For this reason, the Federal Government will continue to do everything in its power to shape the future relations between the United Kingdom and the European Union, as well as between the United Kingdom and Germany, so that we have a good common future.

The intense engagement with the question of Great Britain's exit from the European Union in these days must not obscure the fact that there are other pressing issues in Europe and the world that need to be resolved. These are fundamentally related to security and stability at Europe's borders. This particularly concerns a question that was debated very intensively in this house a few weeks ago: the commencement of accession talks between the European Union and North Macedonia and Albania.

Germany, in particular, is connected to the Western Balkans not only geopolitically but also economically and socially through the many people from this region who live with us. It is in our common European interest to bind the countries of the Western Balkans to Europe in the long term, not only but also to integrate them into the European Union. For this to succeed, we must stand by our promises to offer these countries a European perspective. Keeping promises is the best prerequisite for being able to convincingly demand reforms and the rule of law from our neighbors in the Western Balkans – and thus also the best prerequisite for prosperity, stability, and security within Europe.

I therefore welcomed and thank the Bundestag for its decision on September 26, which has done justice to this responsibility in the Western Balkans. Thanks to this early and carefully considered stance, we have built a bridge to many partners in Europe who still have concerns. Therefore, I believe that our position can serve as a model and an inspiration for others. We are also in favor of making the accession process overall more transparent and better. But I am convinced that it is worth offering Albania and North Macedonia a European perspective. We will have this debate today in the European Council to perhaps convince those who are not yet convinced. However, I must tell you: The chances of reaching a consensus vote are not good.

Above all, we will, of course, talk about Turkey today and tomorrow. Our relations with Turkey are multifaceted. It is our European neighbor and NATO partner. The situation there, right at the border of Europe, affects us all directly. I have repeatedly urged Turkey – including in personal conversations with the Turkish President – in recent days to immediately end its military offensive in northern Syria against the Kurdish YPG militia. I repeat this here at this point. Despite all understandable security interests: Turkey's military operation in Syria only brings new human suffering to a country that is already so battered. It claims many victims and drives tens of thousands of people, including thousands of children, into flight. It is a humanitarian drama with significant geopolitical consequences. Therefore, under the current conditions, the Federal Government will not supply weapons to Turkey. I am pleased that this is also the position of our European partners.

When I speak of geopolitical consequences, we must remember that Russia's role in the region, along with Iran, has been massively strengthened after the withdrawal of American soldiers. The consequences of this development are not yet foreseeable today. Just looking at the terrorist organization ISIS, Turkey's military operation leads to great new uncertainty – and this after a years-long struggle against ISIS, often supported by the international community. It leads to insecurity in the region, but also in Europe, when the detained members of ISIS are no longer guarded. Thus, Turkey's military operation in Syria further shakes this already crisis-ridden region. The successes in the fight against ISIS, which were largely made possible by Kurdish forces in Syria, can thus be undone. We are convinced that Turkey's security interests at the Syrian-Turkish border can only be truly achieved through diplomatic means, not military ones.

We will also discuss another issue related to Turkey. These are Turkey's ongoing gas drilling activities in the waters of our European partner Cyprus. We cannot accept that Turkey knowingly disregards the territorial integrity of an EU member state. We will express this at the EU Council as well.

Notwithstanding the new developments, we must also see that 3.6 million Syrians have found refuge in Turkey, and there are still many refugees from other countries. In this way, Turkey is making an extraordinarily important humanitarian contribution, which, by the way, also partly shames us in Europe when I think of some discussions.

I am aware of all the criticism that has been directed at the EU-Turkey Agreement since 2015 and especially since the spring of 2016. However, I will continue to advocate that this agreement remains in place. It saves lives, very concretely in the Aegean, and it prevents smugglers and traffickers from regaining the upper hand and taking money from people who actually have none. I will continue to advocate for this agreement so that the people who have found refuge in Turkey can lead a dignified life close to their homeland, thanks to the financial resources provided by the European Union and additionally by Germany. This has, for example, contributed to almost all Syrian children in Turkey being able to go to school. The people who have been so tormented by war and flight are the weakest in this conflict. Therefore, we must not shy away from our responsibility even now, under the impression of Turkey's advance in Syria, but must continue to meet it. Ending the EU-Turkey Agreement would not make things any better, but would worsen the situation, and that at the expense of the weakest. This stance has been underscored by Federal Interior Minister Horst Seehofer and European Commissioner for Home Affairs Dimitris Avramopoulos with their joint visit to Greece and Turkey.

The situation at Europe's external borders shows that Europe's role in the world must increasingly change. More and more tasks are coming our way. For this, Europe needs a modernized and needs-adapted multiannual financial framework. Therefore, it is good that the current Finnish presidency of the Council is advancing the debate and presenting a basis for discussion to the European Council. Unfortunately, I must say that there will be no agreement on this European Council yet. But there will be discussions in which I will advocate for a forward-looking budget that secures Europe's capacity to act in three respects.

First:

For us, modernizing the multiannual financial framework is crucial. Our goals must be supported by corresponding provisions in the budget. This applies to climate protection, migration, a research-intensive and innovative Europe, and stronger cooperation in foreign and security policy. The reliability of established policy areas is, of course, not called into question. For example, it must be taken into account that many regions in the new federal states still have structural disadvantages. Overall, it is about finding the right balance for a budget that can also meet Europe's new challenges.

Second:

The starting point for negotiations cannot be wishes, but must be realistic foundations. As net contributors, we are leading the negotiations on the volume based on a budget approach of one percent of the economic output of the 27 EU member states. Just that already means a significant increase in contributions, especially for Germany.

Third:

Germany will be disproportionately burdened by this increase and also due to the impending exit of the United Kingdom from the EU in the multiannual financial framework. Therefore, we must also talk about a fair distribution of the financial burden and a rebate for Germany.

Moreover, the European Commission's proposed linkage of the rule of law with EU finances is of the highest priority for us; because membership in the European Union and the associated freedoms and achievements must also come with corresponding responsibility in the use of EU funds. Those who disregard the principles and rules of law in the expenditure of European funds should not expect to continue to benefit financially from Europe without restrictions in the future. In this way, we strengthen good governance throughout Europe and protect the interests of millions of taxpayers.

A swift adoption of the multiannual financial framework is a prerequisite for the European Union's capacity to act. It is thus also a prerequisite for the new European Commission, which will soon begin its work – unfortunately somewhat late – to actually implement its priorities.

We are currently between the departure of the old Commission and the arrival of the new Commission. I would like to thank the outgoing Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker and the still-serving President of the European Union, Donald Tusk, for their tireless and passionate commitment to Europe. Both have achieved great and lasting things for Europe and its citizens. With the strategic agenda adopted in June, both have played a decisive role in outlining the program for the next five years.

The new institutional cycle with a new Commission is now an opportunity for us to agree on the further path, on goals and priorities, to advance Europe. We will already discuss this at today's European Council with the new Commission President, Ursula von der Leyen. In her political guidelines, she has outlined the priorities of her future work. I very much welcome that the elected Commission President has made it clear from the outset that she sees the new Commission as a geopolitical Commission.

Even today, Brussels sets standards worldwide, for example when the competition authority makes decisions against powerful corporations like Google or Facebook. We want to set such standards in other areas as well, such as climate protection or digitalization, in challenges where we can only make a mark together as Europe, which will then be seen and carry weight worldwide. Europe must set its own accents and become digitally sovereign. We need unique features that reflect our way of life, even in digitalization. In a successful digitalization made in Europe, the human being must and will be at the center. This was already the guiding principle of the General Data Protection Regulation, and it will also be the guiding principle when it comes to ethical standards for artificial intelligence and the handling of data in the 5G network area.

This applies equally to the area of climate protection. For this challenge facing humanity, the new Commission has announced, among other things, a European Climate Law and a so-called European Green Deal, with which Europe aims to become the first climate-neutral continent by 2050. In doing so, Europe shows that it is committed to the Paris Climate Agreement and the agreed 1.5-degree target as well as to climate neutrality. However, we are not yet in agreement with all member states in Europe on the implementation of these goals. We must, of course, take into account the specifics of each individual member state; for it makes a difference whether a country like Poland derives 80 percent of its energy from coal or whether a country like Sweden already derives over 50 percent of its energy consumption from renewable sources today. For this reason, Europe must support the states in their transition to climate neutrality by 2050 in order to continue to be a leader in climate policy in the world in the medium term.

A European Commission that explicitly understands itself as geopolitical will focus on strengthening Europe's role in the world. To do this, we must stand more united for our convictions and interests. In light of a rapidly changing global situation, Europe can no longer afford to fall apart on important foreign policy issues.

Germany has always advocated for exactly this strong Europe outwardly. For this reason, we will, for example, invite all heads of state and government of the European Union to an EU-China summit in Leipzig as part of the German EU Council Presidency next year. We are making the relationship of the European Union with China a focus of our EU Council Presidency in the second half of 2020; because today we do not have a unified China policy of the European Union, and that is not good for the European Union.

It is crucial that Europe speaks with one voice. Otherwise, we cannot achieve concrete results for our future cooperation, for example when it comes to climate protection or investments. For this, Germany wants to make a contribution during its Council Presidency in the second half of 2020. The times are turbulent and the expectations of Germany are high. I am aware of that. Nevertheless, we look forward to working with our partners in Europe as well as with the newly elected European Parliament and the new Commission.

Mr. President, dear colleagues, we must never forget, in all challenges, what we fundamentally have in Europe: this unique community of peace and values. And a look at the borders of Europe shows us what we have in Europe.

These days, we are remembering the fall of the Berlin Wall 30 years ago. We remember the courage of the countless citizens of the GDR who took to the streets in 1989 for freedom, democracy, and justice. And this courage reminds us of how worthwhile it is to stand up for convictions, values, and goals in the future, especially for a united Europe. This courage reminds us that positive change is possible. It is our duty to advocate for this, especially in Europe.