Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the 11th German Mechanical Engineering Summit on October 15, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

15 October 2019 · 11th German Mechanical Engineering Summit · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 11th German Mechanical Engineering Summit (VDMA) in Berlin on October 15, 2019, speaking on industrial policy, digitalization, and global trade challenges.
Main themes
German mechanical engineering industry, Industry 4.0 and digitalization, medium-sized enterprises (Mittelstand), bureaucracy reduction, EU internal market and posting directive, multilateralism and free trade, international trade conflicts, German-French cooperation, World Trade Organization, economic outlook and cyclical slowdown, innovation and industrial transformation
Duration
~31 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,713
83rd percentile
Sentences
166
84th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
12.3
49th percentile
Syntax
3.23
75th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%36%
  • Environmental 25%25%
  • Technological 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 7%7%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Not in focus 1%

166 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Dear Mr. Welcker,

ladies and gentlemen,

dear members of the Association of German Machinery and Plant Engineering (VDMA), it is a pleasure to be with you. The last time I attended a VDMA machinery summit was in 2008. That is clearly quite a while ago. Nevertheless, we have annual contact through the Hannover Messe, which is organized in rotating leadership together with the Federation of German Industries (BDI) and the Central Association of the Electrical Engineering and Electronics Industry (ZVEI).

I believe the Hannover Messe remains an impressive showcase of our industrial capabilities. Industry 4.0 has become a buzzword. It is clear that innovation is a central theme for you. This is also reflected in your motto "Producing the Future." You are, so to speak, the ones driving the transformation for the manufacturing sector in times of digitalization. You are pioneers and a showcase.

I believe we have developed a very good cooperation in recent years. In 2013, the Platform Industry 4.0 was established at the Hannover Messe. It has since become something of an international trademark. It was expanded in 2015. We can say that we have a multitude of cooperations here – with China, Japan, the USA – and have thus initiated many things.

Your industry is strongly characterized by medium-sized enterprises. We must always keep in mind that 99 percent of all companies are medium-sized, that 80 percent of all trainees receive their training in medium-sized companies, and that the medium-sized sector accounts for 60 percent of jobs and 54 percent of the economic output of our country. Therefore, it is also good and right that the Federal Minister of Economics has not only presented an industrial strategy but also a medium-sized enterprise strategy, which I am sure is being intensely debated among you. And that it bears the title "Appreciation, Strengthening, Relief" fits, I believe, well with what you rightly expect from us.

I want to take up something that you just mentioned, Mr. Welcker, namely the issue of bureaucracy. We recently initiated a third Bureaucracy Relief Act with reliefs of one billion euros regarding reporting obligations that you have. However, on the other hand, new things keep being added. The so-called A1 certificate, which you mentioned, was the subject of my discussions with the French President a few days ago. We will take up the issue again tomorrow at the German-French Ministerial Council, because something has happened here that – I will be very cautious – is close to a certain form of protectionism in an otherwise free internal market. We have a posting directive; and in this case, it is not the EU's fault that the posting directive requires what has now happened, but it has arisen under pressure from certain member states that these certificates must be submitted in advance. And since you, as you rightly say, need to be flexible in your contract executions, this is an enormous effort. These certificates could just as well be filled out afterwards and then settled. In this respect, it is a problem of implementation. And I will not relent in trying to reduce this bureaucratic monster, because at the moment, dealing with some member states of the European Union, it is truly outrageous and costs you time and energy without any discernible sense.

Your association's meeting this year takes place at a time when the economic development, especially in your industry, is concerning. It is also somewhat of a leading indicator for certain things that are in the making. We certainly have certain typical cyclical phenomena after a long growth phase, but on the other hand, the whole situation is further driven by international trade conflicts.

I thank you for the support of the VDMA in advocating for a multilateral world. We see significant difficulties and cracks in a worldview that has become self-evident, at least for us, namely that there are win-win situations when countries in the world work together in a partnership, fair, and barrier-free manner. These patterns are being called into question, including all multilateral institutions. For me, this indicates a paradigm shift in an order that emerged after the Second World War – incidentally born from the experiences of endless suffering that Germany brought to the world.

Despite all criticism of the imperfect functioning of multilateral organizations, it is very concerning that it can be quickly possible to dismantle such institutions, to render them incapable of functioning, as is now threatened with the World Trade Organization, because the arbitration courts can no longer meet, without knowing what to put in their place. I am deeply convinced: If everyone only thinks of themselves, this world will become weaker, it will become poorer. I will continue to resist this. But it requires all of our efforts, because what seems self-evident is no longer taken for granted.

Thus, we can only hope that certain trade disputes, which also directly impact your order intake, will be resolved. With an export rate of 80 percent, the majority of jobs in your industry depend on foreign trade. The US-China trade dispute casts its shadow over your economic situation. There are also disputes between the European Union and the United States. We have the uncertainty of Britain's exit from the European Union and thus from the European internal market. What now seems clear is that Britain also wants to exit the customs union. This complicates the talks with Britain, because we will then have an internal market border that will also have its effects on the island of Ireland – between the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland – but due to the historical Good Friday Agreement, border controls on the island of Ireland are not supposed to take place; so the agreement between Britain and Ireland states. This is somewhat like squaring the circle, what is currently being attempted to negotiate. It is very, very complicated.

We will work until the last minute to ensure that a regulated exit of Britain takes place. But one thing is already clear – we are also prepared for the other case –: Britain will develop into another competitor at Europe's doorstep. And this will require the European Union to be even more competitive and to take on geopolitical responsibility.

In this economic situation we find ourselves in, we have the task of trying to strengthen the foundations of growth and prosperity. For us, this also includes a solid fiscal policy. We currently have a peak in investment. We have not had so many investment funds in our federal budget for a long time. And we believe that a balanced budget, given our demographic situation, is also an important setting for the future. Therefore, we commit ourselves to a balanced budget.

However, this does not mean that we do not invest, that we do not make provisions for the future. Here, I want to particularly point out that since 2017, for the first time, we have reached the three percent target for spending on research and development – three percent of gross domestic product for research and development. We have now initiated a tax incentive for research and have also set the right course with the High-Tech Strategy 2025 and the implementation strategy for digitalization to support your efforts and to accompany the digital transformation and technological change well. We have established an agency for leap innovations in Leipzig to be able to respond more quickly – similar to the United States with its DARPA institution. We have a strategy for the implementation of artificial intelligence. Thus, in the last one and a half years, we have set a multitude of courses towards the future and are working closely together in many areas.

At this point, however, I want to say: Your companies are fully engaged in digital transformation and are also highly dependent on changes in other industries, for example, the automotive industry. But in one area, I think we need to work even more intensively together. The digitalization of production processes taking place in your companies has significant impacts on employees. Therefore, regarding lifelong learning, we have developed our qualification strategy together with the economy.

What greatly concerns me, however, is the issue of data autonomy, the data sovereignty of European companies. This is also a topic that we are discussing intensively with the French President and also in the European Council. Data management is currently taking place to a large extent in collaboration with American companies. I believe we need our own cloud management in Europe, our own hyperscale, as it is called, a platform where we can not only store data but also process it, so that new products can emerge from data through artificial intelligence. I ask you to discuss this intensively in your industry, because we – each individual company – can fall into dependencies that we may not foresee today in their full consequences. Therefore, we are ready, also within the framework of a European cooperation for new technologies, as we are doing in chip manufacturing, to develop solutions together that enable and allow European companies data sovereignty. We need to work even more closely together on this.

I also believe that the new Commission President and the new Commission, which hopefully can soon start its work, have set the right course and have focused on digitalization, geopolitical challenges for Europe, and climate change.

Mr. Welcker, you have also addressed the fact that climate change, like digitalization, has profound effects on your industry, but also on our entire way of life, and that we are in a deep transformation process. Therefore, let me say a few things about what you said regarding the climate package of the federal government.

It is the case that the industry, together with the energy sector, is already subject to a pricing system for CO2. This means that the question of avoidance costs of CO2 in cement plants is already fully represented through the European emissions trading system. The certificate price there is currently around 25 or 26 euros per ton, perhaps with a slight upward trend; and this is already having a steering effect. We hear few complaints at the moment. I would say: The moment the prices in the European emissions trading rise towards 40 euros per ton, we would then be in a situation where we would have to discuss whether the costs are too high for those who are in international competition. But that is not the case at the moment. So, the entire industry and the entire energy sector are subject to emissions trading. And we can already see, for example, with lignite power plants that due to rising costs, the export rate of lignite-based electricity to Poland has decreased. This means it has a direct climate effect in the building and energy sector.

What we are now doing with the climate package of the federal government mainly concerns the areas of transport and buildings, waste management, and small businesses, essentially the crafts. Here we are starting with a CO2 pricing, although one must honestly say that we are not starting from scratch, as we have historically grown prices on fossil energy sources. For heating oil, the prices are relatively low, for gasoline and diesel – if you only consider the current taxes – they are over 150 euros per ton. However, these are not perceived as such, but what is becoming more expensive is what is felt. This means that ten euros per ton are now being added. You say: That is too little. – That may be, but it is the start of a permanently increasing pricing system, which at the beginning is still accompanied by minimum and maximum prices, but will take place with freely floating prices by the end of the decade.

The avoidance costs in the building and transport sectors are much higher than those we have in the industrial sector. Therefore, one could say: Now I will immediately combine the two systems. – We did not do that in the European Union because we believe that, firstly, the industry is significantly in international competition and, secondly, we also need pressure in the transport and building sectors to bring about changes, because mobility will change dramatically and the insulation of houses and the better energy efficiency of houses is also a topic that needs to be addressed. If we combined the two points, prices in your energy and industrial sector would rise slightly, let’s say from 26 to perhaps 31 euros per ton, and we would have zero steering effect in the transport and building sectors for a long time. Only at the very end, when we want to achieve CO2 neutrality by the middle of the century, would pressure arise in these areas. We believe that this is not good; rather, we need the development of alternative drive technologies right now and must expand renewable energies; and this, by the way, also in parallel. The electric car is still not particularly CO2-friendly as long as the electricity does not come from renewable energies. By 2030, however, we will have two-thirds of our electricity generation from renewable energies; that is our plan. Around 2030, we can merge the two certificate systems because we believe that by then we will have advanced the transformation process in the building and energy sectors.

Now to the sector-specific rigidity that we have agreed upon, which you see as so rigid: Yes – but. Yes, because we have experienced the following: The transport sector has not achieved a single ton of CO2 emission savings since 1990. More efficient cars have been developed – although one might question whether this development continues in light of the SUV trend – but traffic volume has continued to increase. And thus, CO2 emissions in the transport sector have remained constant. They need to come down.

In the building sector, we have made slight progress, but we still have a very, very poor stock of old buildings. Therefore, we have set sectoral targets. However, with the introduction of the pricing system, these sectoral targets have become somewhat obsolete. This means that the stronger the price signals work, the less significance the sectoral targets will have. However, to see how various measures work, we have agreed: If the overall target for emission reduction is not achieved, we can exchange between the sectors. This means that if one sector performs better because the avoidance costs are lower here, the other sector can be relieved as a result. Such a decision will be made by the Climate Cabinet. And with the increasing rise in price, the sectoral target will lose significance. Nevertheless, we must be accountable: What have we achieved in which area? It will not be sufficient if we only replace all oil heating systems on one side, but on the other side, for example, in the transport sector, have achieved nothing at all. This means that while the sectoral targets are enshrined, they are also not binding at the European level; and they will lose significance with the increasing strength of the price signal. We do not have the option, according to European conditions – and that is good for Germany – to exchange between the emissions trading of the industrial sector and the reduction targets to be achieved there and in the building and transport sectors, but the pressure now lies primarily with our climate protection programs in the building and transport sectors plus agriculture plus waste management.

Now, one can say a lot of critical things, but what we have achieved is the following: We will have a budget for CO2 emissions in the transport and building sectors available for each year from 2020 to 2030. If we exceed this budget, that is, if we do not meet our CO2 reduction targets, we will have to buy additional certificates on the European market and spend expensive money for them. There is therefore great pressure to achieve the specified European targets nationally. Therefore, I believe our program is somewhat smarter than you have portrayed it. But it is true – and we have discussed this repeatedly with the ministries – that it makes sense to take a look at the avoidance costs and say: Now let’s pick the low-hanging fruits first and not do the most expensive things first. We see this point very clearly.

Climate change is a huge challenge; and it will also lead to completely new technologies emerging in the industrial sector. In this respect, by the end of the year, we will also develop a hydrogen strategy alongside the further expansion of electric mobility. Hydrogen may become one of the most interesting energy carriers – also with regard to the storage of renewable energies. Industrial value creation processes will change completely. If we only think about the fact that one day we will need climate-neutral steel production, then really interesting innovations are on the horizon.

And I want to express my gratitude to all of you who are developing great systems that work more energy-efficiently and are particularly innovative with regard to climate protection.

We have an investment program for energy efficiency and process heat. Furthermore – and I agree with you, we need as much renewable energy as possible as quickly as possible – we have raised the funding cap for solar systems. We have also raised the cap for the expansion of offshore wind energy and will thus be able to expand renewable energies more quickly.

We are being criticized for having newly set the distance rules for wind power. But I want to say the following: If we have no new construction of wind facilities due to a lack of acceptance in large parts of Germany – especially where the wind blows very well and wind energy is very efficient – and the approval processes already take five years in some cases, then the state must also act.

I recently discussed with students at the Natural History Museum in Berlin. They asked: With whom in the world can we form a partnership for climate protection? – I said: Take the young people from my constituency. – In my constituency by the Baltic Sea, wind power plants are being built. And if you have your house in a village where repowering is taking place, that is, the wind power plant is being replaced and a 80-meter plant becomes a 220-meter high plant, then the acceptance of renewable energies in your own backyard is a bit worse than in Berlin, where I take the electricity from the socket and say it should come from renewable energies. If we do not have acceptance, the expansion of renewable energies will be very difficult. Therefore, we are now also considering how municipalities with wind power sites can be better involved in the revenues from wind energy so that they see that besides noise and a few blinking lights on top of the wind turbines, there are also some benefits for them.

I want to thank you for positively accepting this challenge of climate change. I want to thank you for undergoing a major transformation process with regard to digitalization. I promise you that we will accompany you on this path, especially in dealing with data. I assure you that we will try not to create too many bureaucratic things either in Europe or in Germany. However, we must – and the federal government is also working on this – ensure that we integrate digitalization into our lives much more quickly.

I recently had a discussion round with the Estonian president. When one talks about the General Data Protection Regulation in Germany, there is general complaining and the general remark that it is a bureaucratic monster. The Estonian president pointed out to me the following: If all our data were digitized – for example, all the registers we have, commercial registers and others – if all non-governmental organizations and all associations had already digitized their data, then the implementation of the General Data Protection Regulation would require a fraction of the effort that we still produce with our analog and manual procedures in Germany. This means that a regulation that causes no discussion in Estonia, but is regarded as groundbreaking for the data sovereignty of citizens and businesses, becomes a bureaucratic monster in Germany during implementation because we are so far behind in the digitalization of public income and expenditure.

Therefore, a central project of the federal government, with which I would like to conclude, is that we will create an Online Access Act, which means that we want to open access to all government services to every citizen by 2022. These are over 500 functions that will be made accessible to citizens in relation to the state, over 100 of which are at the federal level. And if we then enable this access with a uniform identification of citizens, we will have made significant progress. Then we will also have a common platform from which the economy can better digitize its customer relationships than is currently the case.

This requires an active government, but it also requires the desire and drive of a population to further open up to digitalization. And when I read this morning that Germans have concerns about mobile payment systems, then I believe we are somewhat in a situation where we are victims of our still somewhat well-functioning administration because people do not feel the pressure to change. They feel it in your companies already, but in daily life, this pressure is not so great. Therefore, alongside all technical steps in digitalization, we also need an awareness of how important digitalization is and how it will change our entire lives.

I say thank you. I promise you that we will strive to create the best possible export conditions for your industry with regard to trade frictions. Because the strong dependence on exports means, of course, that you feel global tensions much faster than some other industries. Therefore, it was particularly important for me to be with you this year.

I know the situation is more serious than it has been for many years. We are trying to solve the problems together with you, and I hope we can at least succeed partially. Thank you very much.