Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the opening of the 14th Internet Governance Forum on November 26, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

30 November 2019 · 14th Internet Governance Forum · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed delegates at the 14th UN Internet Governance Forum on November 26, 2019, held for the first time in Berlin, Germany.
Main themes
Internet governance, freedom and fundamental rights, multilateralism, digital future, fall of the Berlin Wall, values in the digital world, global connectivity, civil society and technology, open internet, human rights online
Duration
~24 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,820
73rd percentile
Sentences
168
84th percentile
Readability
48
58th percentile
Grade
10.7
28th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.07
21st percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 44%43%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Geopolitical 13%13%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Social 12%11%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

168 sentences in 40 paragraphs

Dear Secretary-General Guterres, dear António,

dear ministers,

Excellencies,

delegates from around the world,

dear guests,

ladies and gentlemen,

welcome to Berlin. It is a pleasure for me and the entire federal government that you have come here and brought your ideas for the future of the Internet. I thank you very much for that.

It is as the Secretary-General of the United Nations just said: He was an electrical engineer and I was a physicist before we went astray; that is true. But perhaps it is a good thing for the technological developments of our time that there are a few politicians who also understand something about technology – even if in my case only rudimentarily; with António, it is certainly different – in order to understand the world well together.

The United Nations Internet Governance Forum (IGF) is taking place for the 14th time, but for the first time in Germany. Especially as the host of this forum, but also beyond this week, we want to contribute to revitalizing and shaping the global exchange on values and rules in the Internet.

It is becoming increasingly important that we conduct the discussion on how we want to shape and use the Internet of the future together. Together means: politics and civil society, business and science. Together also means: with all countries. This is the principle of multilateralism. This is what the United Nations is built upon. And this must also be the foundation for shaping new technological developments.

That is exactly what makes the IGF so valuable. Here, actors of Internet governance from around the world come together to exchange experiences and ideas. Essentially, the analog and digital worlds merge here. "One World. One Net. One Vision." – This year's motto captures the essence of what it is about: namely, to promote a common understanding of what the future of the Internet should look like. What values, principles, and rules do we want to transfer from our analog world into the digital world? What processes work for that?

The value that underlies the triumph of the Internet in a special way is freedom. We know: freedom is never a given; we must continually earn and defend freedom. We must repeatedly clarify together where and how freedom must be protected, what freedom specifically entails, and where the limits are – that is, what is allowed and what is not when fundamental rights of others, for example, children, must be upheld or when fundamental rights of others are violated. Then the limits of freedom are reached.

We Germans have thought and talked a lot this month – as we also saw in the opening film – about what freedom means for our country. Thirty years ago, in November 1989, the Berlin Wall fell. The strong will for freedom of the people in the GDR and our neighbors in Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, and the three Baltic states could no longer be suppressed by state repression.

What the division of Germany and Europe meant for the people can be particularly well understood here in Berlin. A former border crossing between what was then East and West Berlin is just a few hundred meters from here. At the entrance to this venue, there are even still some pieces of the wall – ton-heavy. But freedom weighed and still weighs much heavier.

I can tell you that I conducted my scientific work just a few hundred meters from here, in the eastern part of Berlin. I have never seen Sonnenallee from this side, but not far from here was my workplace.

The wall and the Iron Curtain were torn down 30 years ago. The people's striving for freedom and self-determination had triumphed. Our country and our European continent could finally grow together again. Freedom of travel, freedom of the press and expression, freedom of profession, and free development of personality – all these and other fundamental rights could once again gain validity in Europe.

Freedom and hope for common progress – that was also the vision of the inventors of the Internet 50 years ago and of the World Wide Web 30 years ago. Some of the inventors are also here today. The Internet was technically developed in such a way that it can transcend territorial boundaries, that it can be used in all corners of the world, and that it can connect all people. There are now four billion Internet users. António Guterres pointed out how much faster this process has developed than the penetration speed of the printing press. By 2030, in just over ten years, it is expected to be seven billion people.

We all benefit from this global connectivity, this global interconnectedness. People from various countries and cultures encounter each other across supposed analog barriers – barriers determined by politics, religion, or social status. The truth is: The Internet has long since permeated our everyday lives – at least for those who use the Internet – in all areas. Fewer and fewer people can imagine conducting their communication, work, and shopping exclusively in analog ways. Just as naturally as we use the Internet around the clock, we understand the Internet as a global network, where spatial distances hardly play a role anymore. Data and information flows connect cities, countries, and continents.

Interestingly, in technical terms, spatial distances, which must be bridged by a global network of undersea cables, still play a role. A large part of the data connections between North and South America flows through the landing point in Fortaleza, Brazil. The data traffic between Europe and Asia runs through undersea cables in the Suez Canal. In Singapore, a whole cluster of cables arrives that connects the Asia-Pacific region. Another example is the Internet exchange points, where Internet providers connect with the global network and thus enable access to the Internet. Three of the largest Internet exchange points are located in Europe: in Frankfurt, Amsterdam, and London. They will connect us even after the United Kingdom has left the European Union.

This shared Internet infrastructure has become a cornerstone of the global economy. It is of central importance for sustainable development and innovation worldwide. Billions of people can express their views and ideas on the Internet. They can exchange, share information and experiences. Democratic discourses and political opinion formation take place – for better or for worse, as some – as the Secretary-General also mentioned – only remain in their own echo chambers and no longer exchange with those who think differently. This is one of the challenges that the Internet presents to us.

But there are other reasons why some in the world see an Internet of freedom and openness, as well as the many decentralized structures of the Internet, as a thorn in their side. Non-democratic states and their governments interfere with the freedoms that the Internet creates. They try to enforce their own or national interests and to isolate their networks from the global Internet. Some private companies are also investing in their own, isolated infrastructures. This creates the danger that global companies build parallel worlds – with their own rules and standards, which they then want to impose on others through international bodies.

This is a very difficult issue. I understand this forum as one that wants to address exactly that. Because we need to clarify, so to speak, what we mean by wanting to retain our digital sovereignty on the one hand and not wanting to isolate ourselves but to act multilaterally on the other. Of course, digital sovereignty is of great importance. But it may be that we understand different things in the world, even if we use the same term. In my understanding, digital sovereignty does not mean protectionism or dictating by state authorities what information can be disseminated – that is censorship – but rather describes the ability, both as an individual, as a single person, and as a society, to shape digital transformation in a self-determined manner.

This means that in the digital world, too, technical innovations must serve humanity – and not the other way around. We, as those who have succeeded in Germany through the system of social market economy, know that technical innovations, that companies cannot simply develop freely, but that they always need guiding frameworks. That was the case during the industrial revolution, and it must also be the case in the age of the Internet.

This means we need sovereignty over what happens. Therefore, it is also an expression of sovereignty to advocate for a common, free, open, and secure global Internet if we are convinced that isolation is not an expression of sovereignty, but that we must base our actions on a common understanding of values.

Because what would be the consequences if we opted for isolation? The consequences of an increasingly fragmented Internet are, in my view, never good. They can be manifold, but they are never good. The global infrastructure could become unstable and vulnerable to attacks. There would be more surveillance. State filtering and censorship of information would increase. Perhaps even the Internet and mobile networks would be shut down to prevent communication among the population.

This means: the attack on Internet connectivity, which is the cornerstone of a free, open Internet, has become a dangerous instrument of politics. Many know from their own experience what that is like. Such attacks can deprive people of their fundamental rights to information and communication. This undermines the fundamental idea of the Internet, the idea of its inventors. Therefore, it must be a concern for all of us to protect the core of the Internet as a global public good. And that can only be achieved if we rethink the governance structures of this global network that connects us all.

But how can we counter the efforts of individual states to separate themselves from the free Internet or to shape the network alone? I believe we can do this by understanding that just as the strength of networks is measured by the number of users, it also takes many to maintain a cross-border, decentralized Internet – in other words: by understanding that we must act multilaterally. Only in this way can we succeed in developing a common understanding of what the value of a free Internet is across borders. That is why I very much welcome the Secretary-General's announcement to appoint an envoy for these discussions, who has his personal trust.

During Germany's G20 presidency in 2017, we established a so-called digital strand in the G20 group. We know that the G20 states do not represent the whole world. But it would already be a significant achievement if consensus could be reached on this important issue within this circle. That is why I am glad that we have achieved important commitments from the G20 member states – including on global connectivity to the Internet and on international standards. Why did we succeed in this? It was primarily because we also involved civil society and business. States alone cannot achieve this. That is why it is so important to me that civil society and business are always represented in the G20 process, especially – as António Guterres pointed out – women, who are at risk of being left behind in the new value creation that the Internet enables.

The Internet cannot and must not be shaped solely by states and governments. Because the fundamental questions surrounding the Internet ultimately concern each and every one of us. That is why we need a comprehensive dialogue and the multi-stakeholder approach, as it is so beautifully called – that is exactly the approach of the IGF. That is why I am very grateful to you for coming together here to present your perspective. Of course, this is a new approach. The classic multilateral structures in the world only know the cooperation of governments. But I believe that alone is no longer sufficient today. Therefore, we must continually advocate for this broad approach.

If we want to use the Internet globally, we must also think globally. The Internet concerns everyone – including those who do not yet have access. Therefore, we must strengthen Internet access and equal participation in digitalization. In the coming days, you will also be discussing this issue of inclusion intensively. I was very pleased that we learned at a recent retreat of our federal government that there is a desire to create a comprehensive digital market in Africa, that there is a commissioner for digitalization, and that within the African Union, there is not only a desire to conduct free trade in the classical sense but also to focus on digital expansion, including a common access to the Internet.

Dear António Guterres, you have worked with international experts from politics, business, science, and civil society to produce a report on digital cooperation. Thanks to your proposals for new ways to shape the Internet globally, an important debate is now gaining momentum. When we talk about Internet governance, we must first agree on values. We need to agree on how to protect human rights, democracy, and the rule of law in the digital age, how to strengthen equal participation and security online, as well as trust in the Internet.

Of course, we must take new paths. Because normally, we are used to putting everything we agree upon in international treaties into national laws. But this time, more is needed. We need the participation of the economy, we need the participation of citizens – and this cannot be secured solely through laws. The challenge is great. Digital transformation poses fundamental questions for our societies. Not everything that is possible online and technically feasible is also ethically desirable. We already know this from the world before digitalization. Especially with regard to artificial intelligence, we will discuss these questions intensively.

So we must not only talk about what we want, but we must also talk about what we do not want. If I may take the liberty: the question of what we do not want with new technological possibilities is discussed less willingly in some areas of the community than the question of what is possible. However, this is not about restrictions on the Internet, but again about the question that technology must serve humanity.

All of this only works in great unity. Governments, international organizations and formats, as well as civil society, must be equally included in the considerations. To be honest, and if I only look at my own country, we have not yet reached a consensus among all sides. We have noticed this in the discussion related to copyright in the European Union; also in connection with the General Data Protection Regulation. There are many issues that are still being discussed very controversially.

Therefore, we must be ready to organize new participation opportunities where every voice is heard and counts equally. This means we need real cooperation. This means: we also need the ability to engage in discourse. Therefore, retreating into bubbles of the Internet, where the same opinion prevails, is certainly not the solution to solving the problems.

The Internet Governance Forum here in Berlin is therefore taking new paths. I consider it an important signal that, at the initiative of our Minister Peter Altmaier, parliamentarians from around the world have come here to Berlin. This is also a great gain in democratic terms.

Furthermore, for us as the German federal government, digital transformation is never to be thought of as national, but always also European. Because Europe can make an important contribution to the common global vision for the future of the Internet with its ideas.

Overall, however, the reorganization of Internet governance is certainly a global effort. It requires the collaboration of states and interest groups. Germany is ready to help shape the realignment of global Internet policy under the auspices of the United Nations. We are convinced that the United Nations and the IGF play a key role in enabling a global consensus for an open, free, and decentralized Internet.

Therefore, I wish you much success for this Internet Governance Forum in Berlin. Let yourself be inspired a little by this place, where a new era began 30 years ago with the fall of the Wall. We in the former GDR did not think that this wall would fall during our lifetime. But it happened – with the courage of many people and through favorable overall circumstances. Therefore, one never knows whether the courage of one individual or many individuals might suddenly make paths that seem hardly passable today possible. So discuss freely in workshops, panels, and sessions.

I wish you a week of interesting encounters with people you might otherwise only know from the Internet. It does not have to be only digital; going for a beer or a glass of wine in one of the beautiful Berlin restaurants is also a good idea. Enjoy Berlin. Thank you very much. All the best.