Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the Budget Act 2020 before the German Bundestag on November 27, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

27 November 2019 · Budget Act 2020 debate before the German Bundestag · German Bundestag, Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the German Bundestag on November 27, 2019, during the Budget Act 2020 debate, using NATO's 70th anniversary to review alliance history and Germany's defense commitments.
Main themes
NATO's 70th anniversary, collective defense, alliance history and enlargement, NATO-Russia relations, Afghanistan deployment, Arab Spring and Libya intervention, Syrian civil war, Crimea annexation and Ukraine, German defense spending, transatlantic partnership, security challenges, Western Balkans stability
Duration
~45 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,388
93rd percentile
Sentences
308
95th percentile
Readability
57
81st percentile
Grade
9.6
16th percentile
Syntax
2.78
20th percentile
Vocabulary
2.01
11th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 37%36%
  • Institutional 15%14%
  • Economic 14%14%
  • Social 11%11%
  • Technological 10%9%
  • Environmental 8%7%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Not in focus 5%

308 sentences in 70 paragraphs

Mr. President!

Dear colleagues!

NATO will celebrate its 70th anniversary this year. On this occasion, the heads of state and government will meet in London next week, on December 3rd and 4th. I believe this is a good opportunity to take a moment to reflect.

I think we can all agree that during the first 40 years of its existence, NATO was a bulwark for freedom and peace during the Cold War and ensured that there was no war in Europe. In this context, we are particularly indebted to our American friends.

But it has already been 30 years since the end of the Cold War. After 1990, NATO was given an interesting allocation of tasks and experienced an interesting time. Perhaps we should take a brief look back at these 70 years:

At the end of the 1990s, the question of enlargement came to the agenda. In connection with the first round of enlargement involving three countries, the NATO-Russia Founding Act was also concluded at that time. I do not know who still remembers this: It was a rather controversial discussion about whether NATO should be expanded. It was then significantly expanded again in 1999, 2004, 2009, and 2017. In 1997, in the run-up to this enlargement, the NATO-Russia Founding Act was concluded, which was signed in Paris, limiting troop deployments in the new member states, that is, in the eastern states, prohibiting the stationing of nuclear weapons there, and accepting the recognition of the then-existing borders and territorial sovereignty. Essentially, this was associated with the hope of having a more fruitful coexistence with Russia than was actually the case.

At the end of the 1990s, NATO intervened in the Yugoslav conflict. In my view, this contributed to the fact that peaceful negotiations could take place and the Ahtisaari Plan was approved at that time. NATO has established itself as a stabilizing force in the Western Balkans to this day.

At the beginning of the first decade of the 21st century, on September 11, 2001, the first major terrorist attack occurred, the attack on the World Trade Center. The term "asymmetric warfare" was on everyone's lips. At that time, for the first and only time, Article 5 was invoked by the United States within NATO, the mutual defense obligation. The assistance was also granted by NATO member states. We did this out of conviction.

Since that time, there has been the deployment in Afghanistan, in which Germany is still involved today. I know what difficult confrontations that was back then. Therefore, I would like to express a big thank you to our soldiers who have been serving there since that time – Peter Struck always said that our security is defended at the Hindu Kush – and who continue to do so to this day.

There was no NATO mission during the second Iraq war, when Europe was divided and we could not reach a common position.

The second decade of the 21st century is essentially characterized by two developments: first, the Arab Spring and the reactions to it. We remember: in 2011 – when we were a non-permanent member of the Security Council – there was the NATO operation for airspace monitoring in Libya. Germany abstained at that time. The mandate was overextended. It was one of the last mandates in the Security Council that existed. Since then, Russia has rarely participated again, and the Security Council has become quite incapacitated. We saw at that time that this mandate was overextended, that Gaddafi was essentially chased away, and that instability broke out in Libya. Even today, no political solution is in sight.

We then witnessed the civil war in Syria. NATO did nothing there. This civil war has slowly but surely become a proxy war. We must now state that it is the most brutal and worst humanitarian situation we have had since the genocide in Rwanda: 500,000 dead, twelve million displaced, half of whom are internally displaced, the others are refugees outside Syria. Here, too, a political solution is waiting for realization.

At the same time, in 2014, we had the annexation of Crimea by Russia and the invasion of Eastern Ukraine. At that time, NATO committed itself to refocusing on collective defense, as the attacks came right up to its borders. The NATO summit in Wales was a turning point in this regard. At that time, we committed to developing our defense spending towards two percent, which we have been doing since then. The budget for next year indicates a NATO quota of 1.42 percent. In Wales, we were at 1.18 percent. We will continue to do this gradually: 1.5 percent by 2024. The Minister of Defense has now set up a plan on how we will reach the two percent by improving our alliance capabilities and increasing our capabilities by the early 2030s. You can count on that.

When you look at all of this, I believe it is time for analysis: What has succeeded, and what has not succeeded so well? And what does this mean for NATO and the future?

First of all, I want to say: The alliance defense for the Eastern European countries has succeeded. We are a leading nation in Lithuania. We participate in air surveillance, if I may say so for the German contribution. We see every day what hybrid threats are also coming from Russia, to which the soldiers there are exposed. We also have the advantage of the alliance, which realizes Article 5 and has helped the United States in Afghanistan. And we can say that we have stabilized the Western Balkans, which is of utmost importance for our own security.

But we must also note: Political solutions are lacking in Libya, as well as in Syria. Turkey has become estranged as a member state within NATO. There are a multitude of terrorist threats at Europe's doorstep. The United States no longer automatically takes responsibility when there is a fire in our vicinity. And a completely different multipolar order has emerged, in which China plays a prominent role and also demands much more of the United States' attention.

Therefore, it is important what this means for us and for our stance towards NATO. I say first: Stronger than during the Cold War, the preservation of NATO is today in our own interest – at least as strong as during the Cold War.

Because – as the Foreign Minister said yesterday – Europe cannot currently defend itself alone. We are dependent on this transatlantic alliance, and therefore it is also right that we work for this alliance and take on more responsibility.

We need to clarify what NATO wants to be responsible for. Is it only responsible for collective defense, or is it also responsible for security in our surroundings? I believe it was right to establish a European arm of defense policy that works with NATO: PESCO, the structured cooperation within Europe with the aim of being able to conduct joint operations independently of NATO, but never to work against NATO or instead of NATO, but to establish a further European pillar within the alliance in case of doubt.

It is also about joint armament projects. We need to advance these armament projects significantly together with France. I would like to thank the Federal Minister of Defense at this point for pushing forward on this. I ask the German Bundestag to help here, both with the joint aircraft project and with the joint tank project.

So we must engage in the future in various formats: in NATO, sometimes only from the European side, but as much as possible always with UN support. The difficulty is that it is not so easy to establish new UN missions; because the United States has become very reserved, especially in an area that is of great interest to us: the Sahel region. At the moment, it is not possible to obtain robust UN mandates for the missions. This must continue to be worked on.

For us, it is important – this is of particular significance – that we always see a common approach that does not focus solely on the military, which says: The military is involved, but the essence is the political solutions, the essence is the development cooperation, the economic strength that we give to regions. That is why we call this the connected approach, with which we began to work in Afghanistan. It is good that France is fully re-engaged in NATO for the first time since 2009. This happened under President Sarkozy. This had not been the case for a long time before. This allows NATO to work more politically today. And political solutions are part of it; military solutions alone will never be enough.

Of course, the question also arises of how we deal with the difficult partner Turkey. Do we want to keep it in NATO or not? Are we working towards that? This does not mean, of course, that one should not express opinions to each other, that one should not address differences. But I say: Turkey should remain a NATO member. We must advocate for this; because it is of geostrategic importance for the alliance that Turkey is involved.

Now it is very easy to be critical of the United States, which may no longer want to take on the responsibilities it once did in many areas. But this first reflects back on us, on Europe. The first task for NATO to function is that the European Union is united; because most member states of the European Union are also NATO members.

For Germany and its foreign policy, this means in a very special way that we must advocate for this unity, initially with a view to stabilizing the Western Balkans. I am in favor of reconsidering whether we should discuss new accession procedures in the European Union; I say quite honestly: We could have done that perhaps a year ago. Above all, I believe that we must tell the countries of the Western Balkans: You have a reliable European perspective. – Therefore, I say with regard to North Macedonia and Albania that we must start the promised accession negotiations – I do not say: conclude – otherwise we will lose these countries, and that is to our detriment.

Furthermore, it is right that Europe – Great Britain, France, and Germany – plays an intensive and active role in the Iran agreement, the JCPOA, to prevent nuclear armament of Iran. In this context, I want to explicitly praise the activities of France, but it is clear: All three states are pulling together here and trying to use this agreement as a lever to prevent further escalations. We also appeal to Iran to see that this agreement has value in itself for Iran.

We will take a more active role in two political processes and contribute our part. The Foreign Minister is doing this in connection with Syria. We have worked hard to ensure that a constitutional convention could finally be formed at the United Nations. This cannot happen without talks with Russia, and it cannot happen without talks with Turkey. Therefore, there have also been meetings between President Erdogan, President Macron, and myself, and between Putin and Erdogan. It is important that we support the UN envoy Pedersen in this regard.

And secondly, we are conducting – because we have a high reputation with African countries due to the fact that we abstained in the Security Council at that time – high-level talks in Berlin between the Foreign Office and the Chancellery with the UN mediator Salamé and the key actors to prevent – and this is difficult enough – a proxy war in Libya on the scale we have seen in Syria, and to prevent – that is why a solution for Libya is so necessary – the entire Sahel region south of Libya from descending into terrorist instability. This is one of the biggest problems we are currently facing; and that it has something to do with our security is something everyone can easily imagine.

Therefore, it is right and important that Germany and France decided at the G7 meeting in Biarritz to launch an initiative for security in the Sahel region, alongside support for the G5 Sahel force. We will continue to work on this – at least I want to – to obtain a robust UN mandate.

This brings us to another point. In the future, we will not be able to conduct all operations ourselves. Doing more can also mean helping others with training, enabling, and equipping them. We are already doing this in Mali, but it needs to happen on a broader scale. We must confront an issue that we cannot avoid in the long term: when we train and equip others in different regions of the world, the question also arises of who supplies the equipment. You could recently see at the African Union meeting with the Russian President in Sochi that this was accompanied by a large display of military items. The African countries could choose what they need, partly at discounted prices.

I ask us: Is it in our interest if it is clear that Africa is only equipped by Russia, China, and Saudi Arabia? I believe that cannot be right. If we are enabling others for security and peace in Africa, then we cannot completely refuse to provide equipment. That is why I am a bit uneasy when we continue to restrict our measures. We are not credible if we train people who have to engage in terrorist struggles and then tell them: Well, you have to figure out where you get your equipment from.

Yes, we also need to clarify our European stance on China. This is a major topic of discussion. The many years old, but youthful in spirit, Christian Schwarz-Schilling said wise words at the CDU party conference. He said: Those who believe they can find a course in dealing with China alone at the national level, and do not attempt to develop a common European stance, will be crushed and will fail.

If I may say this openly: One of the greatest dangers – I will call it that; at least concerns – is that each member state in Europe pursues its own China policy and that in the end we send completely different signals. That would not be devastating for China, but it would be devastating for us in Europe.

It is undisputed that we need high security standards for the expansion of 5G. But after we define them for ourselves, we must also discuss them with our other European partners. Just as we have a drug approval agency in Europe, we probably also need an approval agency, a certification agency that deals with the certification of 5G components and works with national institutions such as the Federal Office for Information Security. Because if in a digital European internal market everyone does their own thing and acts differently, then we will not get far. This means: changing telecommunications law, changing IT security law, and of course discussing in Parliament how we set the highest security standards. But we also need to look to Europe and first find common solutions with France, from which we can then develop overall European solutions.

Of course, we must criticize when we hear the reports from the Uighurs. I completely agree with the Federal Foreign Minister that the UN Human Rights Commissioner must have access there. I believe that the European Union said the right thing about this yesterday. I think it was a good sign that the elections in Hong Kong were conducted so peacefully and that people still expressed their opinions. This is "one country, two systems." And those are two systems. And China is a different social system, a completely different one. There is a systemic competition. But I do not know if the answer to systemic competition – something we also know from the Cold War – can be isolation; rather, the answer to systemic competition must be that we confidently assume that we can set our standards without proclaiming total isolation. That is certainly my approach.

All of this will only be possible for Europe if it is economically strong. The economic strength of Europe is closely linked to the economic strength of Germany.

This brings us to what is essentially being debated here this week. In the last 20 months, as a federal government, we have initiated many things. We have laid this out in the mid-term report.

I believe we have done really important things, especially in a time of economic downturn caused by global developments, by cyclical developments, to counteract this with robust domestic consumption. I do not want to repeat all of this here: child benefits, child tax allowances, legal entitlement to all-day care, reduction of the solidarity surcharge, improvements in health insurance and long-term care insurance, minimum wage increase, pension increase, mother's pension. We have now agreed on the key points of the basic pension – something very important – and will implement it legally. We have decided on a minimum training allowance. We have ensured – and I find this a very important thing – that for training in professions where people, especially women, work with people, no school fees need to be paid anymore, but there is a training allowance.

It is actually an anachronism that this has not been achieved in 70 years of the Federal Republic; this could have been done even before German reunification. And we have provided an answer to one of the essential questions of the German economy: with a skilled labor immigration law. We will discuss the functionality of this skilled labor immigration law in December at a summit in the Chancellery, so that we can provide a proper answer to one of the major challenges of the German economy. We have massively improved internal security. We have managed and organized migration. We have done a lot for integration.

We are relatively robust. The budget is at a record level. Next year, we will fall below the Maastricht criterion of a debt ratio of 60 percent. I want to say at this point that I am surprised that there is always such a dismissive attitude towards a balanced budget in this house.

I must really say: If one believes that in times of such low interest rates – Olaf Scholz presented this yesterday – one should also incur debt, what does one want to do in times when interest rates return to normal and rise?

How much debt does one want to incur then? That cannot seriously be the case. We have a budget with a peak in investments. We have never had such high investments in the budget. We have added many investments through the climate package. One cannot only find investments good when they cause debt. A proper budget means: investments in a balanced budget. Everything else is absurd.

However, we have – and here we may have slightly different opinions in the coalition – at least in the medium term the task of adapting the conditions for the German economy to the international framework. This means, on the one hand – we may still manage something here – that we have similar tax conditions for partnerships and corporations. But starting in 2020, we will be the country with the highest corporate taxes in Europe.

France will gradually reduce its corporate taxes – which are still above ours on average today – to 25 percent, the Americans have massively reduced them in this regard, Portugal is close to us in this respect, and the Netherlands will also undertake a corporate tax reform. This means that in the medium term, we need to take a look at this, even though we also have other issues that are at least of equal importance for the German economy.

Therefore, I would like to focus today on two things that I believe will determine whether the German economy and thus jobs and prosperity can be maintained here, so on two things that are of crucial importance.

On the one hand, it is about the question: How do we respond to climate change? What answers do we find to this? And how do we achieve the transformation of our economy? The federal government has presented an ambitious package for this. There is discussion about whether the entry prices are too high or too low, there is discussion about whether the commuter allowance is overcompensated or not, but fundamentally there is no doubt in large parts of this house that the framework of measures is correctly chosen. We will now also discuss this in the Bundesrat. I can only advise us all to find reasonable solutions for this; because time is pressing. From the beginning of the 2020s, we will have clear budgets for CO2 emissions that we must adhere to. If we exceed them, we will have to pay massive penalties or we will have to pay money for certificates. This means we are obliged to meet our targets year after year and not at some point. Therefore, we must quickly begin the transformation. I believe we have set the right things in motion. That is why I hope that we will find the corresponding solutions in the Bundesrat by the end of the year. We as a coalition are certainly ready for that.

We have taken another massive step: we have decided, based on the results of a commission, when we will phase out coal-fired power generation at the latest, when we will no longer have coal as an energy source. This creates predictability.

There are the corresponding laws for this. Most people in this house are probably aware of the following: Germany accounts for one percent of the world's population and causes two percent of CO2 emissions, and it has the best technologies. Who, if not us, should show that it is possible to counter climate change? That is the task.

Of course, we will encounter difficulties along the way. How could it be otherwise? We will phase out nuclear energy, we are phasing out coal-fired power generation, and we must establish gas as a bridging technology. That is why I find it rather difficult that the European Investment Bank has now decided not to finance gas technologies as a bridging technology at all. I believe that is not right.

However, we will of course continue to face difficulties in shaping the expansion of renewable energy. It will be about the cohesion of our country. It will not be enough if people in the city explain to people in the countryside how the expansion of wind energy can work. We see that we have divisions. We saw this yesterday at the farmers' demonstration.

At the moment, there is a danger – this danger does not only exist in Germany; it is not a specifically German problem at all, but there is the danger everywhere – that the living environments of people who live in the city and those who live in the countryside are different, that these people have completely different problems.

If we as politicians do not help those in the city who cannot find affordable housing, and do not help those in the countryside who want to know what they will gain from the expansion of wind energy besides having a 220-meter wind turbine next to them, then we will not succeed. But we can succeed if we promote the cohesion of this country.

That is why I will meet with representatives of the farmers' associations next Monday. I will of course tell them that they must find answers to the challenges of the new era. We have not adhered to the fertilizer regulation for years; I cannot now say: Oh, folks, there are still three years to go. That will not work. But what we can tell the people who get up in the morning and go to bed late at night, who work in the summer when we are all sitting with a cool beer, is that we respect their work, that our statement: "We want to eat regional products" is not just hot air, but is meant seriously, that we want local food and a strong agriculture. That is what we can and must tell our farmers.

Similarly, we must talk about the expansion of wind energy. We have now lifted the solar ceiling. We have increased offshore expansion. But we will also need onshore wind energy expansion.

Now there is a discussion about this as if there were worlds between us. You know that in most federal states there is a distance rule of 1,000 meters. Perhaps we would not even need a federal regulation if all the states, for example Brandenburg, had been smart enough before they formed a coalition with the Greens and not only negotiated the 1,000 meters during the coalition negotiations.

Now we are only talking about a single area, and that is the fringe areas, where one can ask whether they start at seven houses or at 30 houses. That is the difference between the view of the Federal Environment Minister and the Federal Minister of Economics. After we managed to agree on the basic pension, I predict to you: We will also find an agreement there. The 1,000 meters are the norm in most federal states in Germany.

We have another major topic. That is the transformation in the automotive industry. This transformation – we heard it yesterday: job cuts at Audi – in the automotive industry is necessary; because mobility will change. Even Kaiser Wilhelm thought that the horse would come back when he saw the first car. He was wrong. You will also be wrong.

There will be a completely new mobility with autonomous driving, alternative drives, and different ownership structures than we know today. It will take years, but it will be good if politics helps.

We as the federal government are conducting a structured dialogue with the automotive industry. We will expand the charging infrastructure. We will support the introduction of new drive technologies through purchase premiums. We do not rely on just one technology, but we take it seriously when the automotive industry tells us for the passenger car sector – not for the truck sector, not for the rail sector – that for the foreseeable future, electric mobility is currently the technology of choice. We will get people to buy cars with alternative drives when the corresponding charging infrastructure is in place. That is why it is right for the federal government, states, and municipalities to work together here and create trust for the people.

The second major task is how we will achieve the transformation in the course of digitalization. For this, the federal government held a retreat where we made important decisions.

First of all, it is of course about expanding the infrastructure. We have developed a mobile communications strategy that outlines how we will roll out mobile communications comprehensively. Because we know that white spots are unacceptable for people, especially in rural areas. We have a clear strategy for the expansion of 5G.

The conditions for the auction of frequencies are very strict. I also thank the colleagues from the Bundestag who have held us as a government very accountable in this regard. We will, of course, also advance the expansion of fiber optics.

But much, much more important is that we understand that the new raw material is data. The federal government has now established key points for a data strategy based on the Data Ethics Commission, which we will adopt in the spring. I have the impression that we are already aware of the importance, the large companies too, but that in the German medium-sized businesses, the significance of what has emerged from the nature of data as a new raw material is still not sufficiently recognized. That is why I support what Peter Altmaier has proposed, namely that as politics – which is somewhat strange – we work together to develop a platform where data can be processed, not only in Germany but preferably together with France and across Europe. It must be understood that it is not just about knowing my data.

Germany was one of the first countries to advance Industry 4.0. The digitalization of one's own production is the first step. The second step is the networking of all people and, above all, also objects in the world. This offers completely new possibilities for gaining insights. This must happen in the health sector. This must happen in environmental protection. But it must also happen for new business models. The sooner we accept this, the better. But that first means that I have everything digitized and know what I have. We are in favor of – I am currently looking at Nadine Schön – doing this as much as possible in the open data area as open source, so that it is transparent. But in order to create new products from this, we still need a cultural change in Germany. One must understand that this is urgent.

I have the impression that we are far too slow in this regard. We as representatives should be the ambassadors who say: Do not sleep through this time, otherwise value creation models will pass us by and we will become the extended workbench. – That is my very great concern. But I believe that as a federal government, we are now on the right track.

We must be leaders in AI, in artificial intelligence, in the algorithms that work with this data. Fortunately, we have six corresponding research centers. They are being supported. The federal and state governments must work well together. I strongly support the additional strategy from Bavaria, which fits perfectly with the federal strategy. I know that a lot is also happening in other federal states. That is good.

Whether we remain a leading industrial location in ten or twenty years will depend far more on this and on climate change than on other things. The decisions for this are being made today. Economy, social market economy, our social model – carrying this into the new era is understood as the task of the federal government. But we see that the many changes, the dramatic changes in the world are also leading to great frictions in our society. As good as the internet is and as good as the digital possibilities are, they also pose many dangers; that has been the case with every new technology. That is why it is good that the large international Internet Governance Forum of the UN is currently taking place in Berlin, which deals with such questions.

We must state: Although we are doing very well economically, although there are wage increases for many people, although we have more employees, socially insured and employed overall, than we have ever had, there are frictions in our society that should make us uneasy. The murder of Walter Lübcke, the events in Halle, they all shake us. One wonders: What is going on in our society? And that after 70 years of the Basic Law. The dignity of man is inviolable. This means freedom of expression. Freedom of expression in our country is guaranteed. To all those who constantly claim that they are no longer allowed to express their opinion, I must say: Whoever expresses their opinion, even pronouncedly, must live with the fact that there is opposition. There is no freedom of expression at no cost. Not everyone always agrees. But freedom of expression has its limits. They begin where incitement occurs, where hatred is spread. They begin where the dignity of other people is violated. We will and must stand against this in this house. We will also manage this. Because otherwise, this society will no longer be what it once was.

So I say to you: You have hopefully noticed, we have a lot to do. We have started a lot, but much still needs to be done. That is why I believe we should continue to work throughout the legislative period. That is my personal opinion.

I am in. It would be nice if you are too. Thank you very much.