Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel at the "Petersberg Climate Dialogue III" on July 16, 2012, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

16 July 2012 · Petersberg Climate Dialogue III · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed environment ministers at the Petersberg Climate Dialogue III in Berlin on July 16, 2012, urging momentum toward the upcoming Doha climate conference.
Main themes
Climate change international agreement, Kyoto Protocol successor, two-degree target, shared and differentiated responsibility, equity in climate protection, Doha COP18 conference, binding climate treaty, fossil resource management, momentum from Durban outcomes, ambition and action in climate policy, fear of change vs. cost of inaction
Duration
~24 min
75th percentile
Words
2,938
75th percentile
Sentences
136
77th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.93
38th percentile
Vocabulary
1.99
9th percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 53%53%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Institutional 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

136 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Dear Ministers,

Above all, dear future host from Qatar, Excellency,

You have already conveyed the greetings of the Emir to me; and I would like to reciprocate them here once again in front of everyone. I sincerely thank you for Qatar's willingness to host the next climate conference. It is, so to speak, a sign of the changing world that Qatar has agreed to hold the next climate conference in Doha. I say quite honestly: When I was Minister of the Environment from 1994 to 1998 and we negotiated the Berlin Mandate here in Berlin in the run-up to the Kyoto Agreement, I did not expect that any of the Gulf States would ever host a climate conference. The world is changing; and in this case, it is changing in the direction that the Kyoto and Rio processes have led us, namely towards a shared yet also differentiated responsibility.

I have been told that you have already had an interesting debate today on the question of equity. I believe that the question of equity is one of the most global questions in all aspects – particularly in climate protection. It has to do with justice, it has to do with how we share responsibility together while always granting everyone equal opportunities. We know that we also carry a burden of history with us, as some have interpreted their understanding of equity very selfishly in the past. Therefore, others say: This cannot culminate in us being called to shared responsibility first; rather, our current understanding of equity must somehow take the past into account. But even if we understand equity in such a way that those who have sinned in the past do not emit any climate-damaging gases like CO2 in the future, the unfortunate realization is that we would still not achieve what we all want, namely compliance with the two-degree target. Therefore, there is a shared responsibility.

In this respect, I wish for this meeting here in Berlin to mark a little what every cyclist knows who goes on a mountain tour – our Minister of the Environment rides his bike from time to time; I do not know if he goes on mountain tours as well –: One must use the momentum from the peak one has just left behind to get as well as possible to the next peak. That is what it is about here – we are currently in the process of not losing momentum in order to achieve further results in November in Qatar.

I believe that this interim stage here must urgently give new momentum to Qatar. Because I do not think it is a secret to remember two things from Durban.

One is that something incredibly important was achieved there. After we all had concerns that there would never be a binding climate agreement, we now leave Durban strengthened in the expectation that we have the chance to obtain a binding future climate program, a climate treaty, for all. That is the good news.

The bad news is: The Kyoto Agreement is expiring, and we have not managed to immediately follow it up with a successor agreement. In the meantime, during the period after one has lost something and before one has gained something new, much can happen. From financial and economic crises to many other things, there is much in the world that could prevent us from working vigorously on this future question. Therefore, it will also depend significantly on you here. It will depend on you whether the conference in Doha and the subsequent conferences will actually achieve the necessary successes so that what we have set for 2015 – with implementation in 2020 – will become a reality.

The difficult thing about it is that climate protection always requires changes from us. However, change sometimes also triggers fear: Can I do it, what does it mean, do I know all the consequences? What is often overlooked in this discussion is that if we continue as we have been, we may superficially have no worries, but this inaction – as the Stern Report has shown at the latest – will have terrible consequences. Therefore, in my firm conviction, it is always the better option for all of us in the world to change something rather than to do nothing and thereby impose devastating side effects on ourselves.

That is why I belong to those who say: When it comes to the fundamental discussion – do all climate simulations match? Have researchers – I believe that research is on a good path – already recognized everything in detail? – I do not want to spend my time discussing every error in the predictions a hundred times longer than any action we actually need to take to cope with climate change.

One thing is for sure: There are already seven billion people in the world, and there will be nine billion. Fossil resources are finite. There are many good reasons, besides climate change, which I explicitly believe in, to handle the resources of this Earth differently than we do today. This means that the motto of this year's Petersberg Dialogue – "Matching Ambition with Action" – expresses exactly what we need. We must have a clear ambition to achieve the agreed goals. In the meantime, we must act. We must take action. We must initiate, launch, and implement projects so that we can learn more about mitigation and how we can curb climate changes.

You know here in this room that time is pressing. I say this again because there are also press representatives present. It cannot be said often enough. Because it does not help to play for time. The two-degree upper limit is certainly not too ambitious. It already requires the utmost from the adaptation of our natural ecosystems. We know that with what is currently voluntarily on the table, this two-degree target is not achievable at all. Despite all the failures of Copenhagen, it was still an interesting exercise for everyone to state what they are willing to give and contribute. The addition of all this will certainly not lead to a limitation of the temperature increase to two degrees. It will rather result in double that – one can argue whether three or four degrees. But what that would mean can again be read in the Stern Report.

A binding regulatory framework – I say this quite openly – sounds like music to my ears because we have not had that so far. Until now, there has been the attitude in shared responsibility: It does not have to be binding for everyone. I therefore know how difficult it is to actually enforce binding commitments.

It is the case that we need to clarify open questions regarding the second commitment period of the Kyoto Protocol. The European Union advocates ambitious regulations in this regard. But we know that not everyone who participated in the Kyoto Protocol will follow us. "Kyoto II" will of course be something like a test of character; the industrialized countries should not have any false thoughts about that. If we, on the part of the industrialized countries, do nothing now and say: "Kyoto I has expired, we are not interested in the interim phase, let’s wait and see what happens in 2020," then the developing countries will rightly say: "Those from the industrialized countries who take these negotiations so little seriously cannot expect us to move."

Therefore, we need a consistent rethinking, especially in the understanding of what we mean by "growth." We have great understanding that growth must also be expressed in an increase in gross domestic product. We have seen it that way for years. If I currently follow the discussions in Germany about the question of whether China might grow by only 7.5 percent instead of nine percent and what horror that causes even here in Germany, then I do not want to pretend that we are only talking about qualitative growth. We are of course still talking about quantitative growth as well. But we will only succeed in the task if we view growth as more than just quantitative growth.

You all from the developing countries know that an increase in gross domestic product, combined with pollution of rivers, destruction of the environment, and depletion of available resources for food security, is not really good growth in terms of better quality of life for people. Therefore, a new understanding of growth will also make the transition easier for us. However, I want to say self-critically: The discussions about the financial and economic crisis or the discussions we have about what actually underlies the difficulties in the Eurozone are almost exclusively conducted in quantitative terms.

When one says: "We in Europe have incurred too much debt in the past, we have lost too much competitiveness, we need to learn to handle our capabilities differently, we need to reform" – and if such reforms inevitably also mean a slight shrinkage of growth figures during the adjustment phase in order to subsequently be able to grow on a more sustainable path, then there is a broad discussion in the world that says: "That cannot be." Everyone must grow quantitatively. To that, I respond: It is important to shape things sustainably.

When I was in Indonesia last week, I learned that Indonesia is a country that suffered greatly under the Asian financial crisis, has overcome the adjustment process since 2004, has then grown strongly again, and has managed to reduce its debt in relation to gross domestic product from 80 percent in 2004 to 24 percent in 2012. There are many countries in this world – from Brazil to Mexico to Indonesia and others – that can understand the adjustment difficulties we have in the Eurozone in order to create sustainable growth.

When we think about sustainability, it is fundamentally always about the same topic: How do we think about future generations? If we take a new concept of growth in all areas of policy, we will find it easier to convince people of the necessity of climate protection because they will change their overall thinking.

I am well aware that – when I am in Qatar, when I am in the United Arab Emirates, when I am in Saudi Arabia – all these countries, which still rely heavily on fossil resources today, now know that they cannot base their future solely on the exploitation of these resources and that they cannot simply use what they have in revenues for consumption, but must invest it innovatively so that sustainable development paths for future generations emerge.

That is why it is very important that we take seriously what was discussed under the slogan "Green Economy" both at the G20 summit in Los Cabos and at the Rio+20 conference, and that we succeed in decoupling our economic development data from resource consumption. Germany has repeatedly shown this. In 2010, we had 24 percent less CO2 emissions than in 1990. During the same time, however, our economy grew significantly. The German reunification, which brought special effects, also fell in this period, which is why the decoupling may have been less pronounced elsewhere. But this decoupling can be achieved.

We in Germany are also contributing to the Green Economy by restructuring our energy supply completely. However, we are currently also experiencing that maintaining the target triangle – supply security, affordability, and environmental friendliness – is not an easy path. Whoever always says that it must be done easily, I tell them: It is true that our Minister of the Environment thinks this through very well and says that we must think about all three parts simultaneously – that corresponds to the idea of sustainability – and accordingly shape our energy transition. The social component, the affordability of electricity, as well as the environmentally friendly component and the fact that one wants to have a secure energy supply throughout the year belong together.

If we in Germany – I am convinced that we can do this – manage the transition from fossil energy supply and energy supply through nuclear energy first through a phase-out of nuclear energy and then through a reduction of contributions from fossil fuels in the coming decades towards renewable energies, we will contribute to ensuring that other countries can learn from and benefit from these experiences. This is part of what I envision with the statement: We have advanced our industrialization at the expense of the environment, now we also have a piece of responsibility to shape the learning process towards a renewable sustainable energy supply. We know that this also has its price. But we pay this price because we are convinced that it is the right way.

We also know how difficult it is to improve energy efficiency. I say this self-critically: Germany has not always played a brilliant role in this regard, for example in the negotiations on the Energy Efficiency Directive in the European Union. You must not think that everything goes smoothly for us. The views of an Economic Minister and the views of an Environmental Minister are just as controversial as in many of your countries. The Chancellor must then ensure that reasonable agreements are reached.

In our highly developed countries, there is of course also a significant reluctance among the population towards new infrastructure projects. Many people say: We all have electricity, we all have a power line; what do we need new ones for? – However, when we now demand that we need thousands of kilometers of new power lines to transport wind energy from the north to the south, where the large industrial facilities are located, this also leads to significant disputes among the population. Therefore, we must face this dispute transparently and in discussion with the public.

I know that many countries are now gaining experience with lower emissions. I want to mention a few countries. Mexico has passed the "General Law on Climate Change." It provides for a 50 percent reduction in emissions compared to the year 2000. South Africa has presented a national vision for a CO2-friendly economy. South Korea has initiated an emissions trading system. Japan aims to develop a strategy for the energy sector this summer. China is working on establishing emissions trading pilot projects in some cities and provinces. The expansion of renewable energies is to be promoted. Brazil and India have interesting climate protection projects. In Indonesia, I, of course, spoke about the issue of tropical forests. There are also ambitious goals for reducing CO2 emissions there. The United Kingdom aims to achieve a reduction in emissions of at least 80 percent by 2050. France has also announced new accents in climate protection policy.

So there is a lot happening in the world. It is now about us binding it all together. The European Union has a pilot function with its CO2 certificate system when we talk about the exchange of experiences in certificate trading. We want to bring all revenues from the auctioning of emission certificates into an energy and climate fund in Germany. However, the certificate prices are currently not as high as we had hoped. We had actually already planned the revenues for international and national projects. But we will continue to work on that. In this respect, we were also able to pledge a financial contribution to the Green Climate Fund as one of the first countries.

I probably really do not need to convince you here in this room of a low-carbon economy – that is your daily business – but I would like to encourage you once again to systematically move forward on the path we have taken – Cancún, South Africa, and a few years ago Indonesia was also one of the hosts. This will not be easy until 2015; you do not need to be a prophet for that. Whenever you want to get 180 countries to agree on something, it is quite difficult. But the more each individual contributes and the more each region of the world takes the initiative in its own way, acts, and comes up with contributions, the greater the common understanding will be to actually achieve and successfully conclude this great task of an international agreement.

When I became Minister for the Environment in 1994, environmental politicians were the pioneers of what is now a completely self-evident cooperation on a global scale. In light of the international financial crisis, environmental policy today must fight to be a pioneer again. But I tell you that dealing with our natural resources – with our Earth, with our air, with our water – is certainly worth showing particular responsibility. Because what is the purpose of economic activity in the world? What is the need for economic activity? – It must be for the benefit of humanity. We have seen with the example of the financial markets: They have become detached from the well-being of people, have taken off, somewhere quite far from the Earth, and have caused great harm to many people. It is largely in your hands to ensure that such a thing does not happen again with natural resources.

That is why I am happy to be here today. That is why I wish you all the best for your discussions. That is why Germany will do everything to make the presidency of Qatar a success. Since I have had the pleasure of being in Doha myself, I can say: Besides all the work, it is also a highly exciting conference location. I wish for good results in Doha and a good preparation here in Berlin.