Speech by Federal Chancellor Dr. Angela Merkel on the 70th anniversary of the Taxpayers' Association of Germany on September 10, 2019, in Berlin:

Germany Angela Merkel · Former Chancellor of Germany

14 September 2019 · 70th anniversary of the Taxpayers' Association of Germany · Berlin, Germany

Context
Merkel addressed the 70th anniversary celebration of the German Taxpayers' Association (Bund der Steuerzahler) on September 10, 2019, in Berlin.
Main themes
Taxpayer advocacy, fiscal policy and tax burdens, Federation of Taxpayers history, budgetary transparency, state financing and public services, tax fairness, German postwar economic history, federalism, role of civil society in democracy
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,297
64th percentile
Sentences
129
75th percentile
Readability
47
53rd percentile
Grade
11.0
33rd percentile
Syntax
2.88
31st percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
42nd percentile

Translated from German

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%49%
  • Institutional 32%32%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

129 sentences in 27 paragraphs

Dear Mr. President Holznagel,

dear state chairpersons and members of the board,

dear parliamentary leaders and colleagues from the German Bundestag,

dear colleagues from the parliaments,

dear Mr. Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of the Interior of the State of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern, dear Lorenz Caffier, ladies and gentlemen, the Federation of Taxpayers is turning 70 – and it has fittingly scheduled its celebration during the budget week, in which we will also discuss tax revenues and expenditures again tomorrow. Seven decades of acting as an advocate, mouthpiece, and representative of taxpayers – this is something that all those engaged here can truly be proud of and that ultimately millions of taxpayers can appreciate. Therefore, I would like to extend my heartfelt congratulations and best wishes.

As far as is known, there were initial ideas for a taxpayer initiative in Germany as early as the 1920s. This was also the time of the storm of Mosel winemakers on the tax office, treasury, and customs office in Bernkastel-Kues in 1926. The trigger for this act of desperation was bitter economic hardship. The French and Spanish competition was overwhelming. In addition, there was an unusually high wine tax. The Mosel winemakers therefore saw their existence threatened. They demanded tax refunds and better economic conditions. The action ended in a widely noted trial across Germany; and it also led to a political success, namely the abolition of the wine tax. Subsequently, the economic situation of the Mosel winemakers also improved.

Whether the tax office stormers of Bernkastel had any influence on the idea of starting a taxpayer initiative for all of Germany is not documented. In any case, the idea matured for many years. This maturation process culminated in the founding of the Federation of Taxpayers in 1949 – the year in which the Basic Law also came into force. As the first taxpayer initiative in Germany, the Federation of Taxpayers is thus part of the founding inventory of the Federal Republic; and it should remain so. The idea of federalism is also not foreign to the Federation of Taxpayers, as can be easily seen from its state associations. The research of the financial scientist Günter Schmölders in the field of financial and tax policy – specifically regarding the behavior, attitudes, and motivations of taxpayers towards taxation – is considered decisive for the founding.

Few people really enjoy paying taxes. But most are likely aware that without taxes, there can be no state. Tax revenues enable us to finance our community and provide state services – services that serve the public and would not exist without taxes. – You have also pointed out the good sides of paying taxes in your film earlier. – This primarily concerns infrastructures that facilitate living and working, mobility and social welfare, education and culture. We taxpayers know that our legal and social state costs something and therefore must be adequately financed. However, this does not absolve politics from the task of reconciling state financing with the legitimate interests of taxpayers. The tax contribution should be perceived as fair and just.

This is precisely where the Federation of Taxpayers comes in. It has always kept a watchful eye on budgetary and financial policy developments and takes a stance on them. It is, so to speak, the guarantor of a lively exchange between taxpayers and politics. It questions and pushes for simplification and relief. It stands by citizens and businesses with information and advice. It supports model lawsuits. Last but not least, it monitors the actions of politics and administration and calls for a reasonable use of tax funds.

Of course, this dispute can sometimes be quite uncomfortable. Thus, the Federation of Taxpayers was viewed very skeptically by politics and administration, especially in the early years of its existence. Over time, however, the Federation of Taxpayers established itself as a persistent guardian of budgetary and financial policy. Behind this lies the insight and experience that a critical exchange is necessary and often rewarding in order to ultimately find a path that is acceptable and justifiable in the interest of the common good. The large number of congratulators also shows that this is seen across party lines.

One of the first successes of this persistence – it is hard to believe that one had to fight for it – was to make the budget plans of the public sector transparent. For in the early years of the Federal Republic, the inclination to publish budget plans was rather low. Transparency, as we know it today as a democratic imperative, had to be learned by politics and administration.

Moreover, after the Second World War, there were initially very high tax burdens – with a top rate of 95 percent for income tax, a corporate tax rate of 60 percent, and high wealth taxes. Until the currency reform of 1948, there were only minor reliefs. However, science, business, and associations continued to push for more incentives for performance and wealth creation. It was only after the founding of the Federal Republic of Germany that ways were sought to reduce the tax burden. However, since the occupying powers preferred high tax rates at the time, a small trick had to be applied. Instead of dealing with the tax rate, the focus was increasingly placed on the tax assessment base, in order to make the tax burden more bearable by reducing it. It is also known that it was not so easy for Ludwig Erhard to introduce the Social Market Economy at that time. I believe these two things correspond very well with each other.

The first tax reform measures – announced by Konrad Adenauer as early as 1949 – finally took place between 1953 and 1955. The long drilling of thick boards paid off. Not only was the tax assessment base reduced, but the rate was also lowered. There were also structural changes. These should certainly not be the last tax reforms, as we know. Others followed, of course with attentive accompaniment by the Federation of Taxpayers. To name just a few examples: The rate reforms in income tax, which began in 1958 with the introduction of the splitting rate, the corporate tax reforms of 1977, 2000, and 2008, as well as the resolution of the German Bundestag in 2012 to regularly present reports on cold progression in the future.

About 65 years after the first major tax reform and after numerous legislative changes, tax structure and tax rates are still at the center of many discussions today. Since the Association of Tax Advisors has also congratulated you, I do not want to hide that there is sometimes a certain tension: The simpler the tax law, the worse perhaps the cards for tax advisors. But there are perhaps many who long for a simple tax system.

The issue of reducing cold progression is as old as it is current. As early as the 1960s, the Federation of Taxpayers advocated for a tax reform in income tax to counter cold progression. However, corresponding corrections in the past have only occurred sporadically. It was not until 2012 that a Bundestag resolution paved the way for a fixed and reliable procedure. In 2015, the first tax progression report was presented. The tariff correction linked to the report was legally enacted. Thus, corresponding reliefs could come into effect in 2016. Based on the reports presented every two years, the legislator has now compensated for cold progression three times in a row.

More tax justice through regular tariff adjustments – that should be in the interest of the Federation of Taxpayers. The quiet, but nonetheless audible applause has shown it. But I also know that after the reform, there is already another reform on the horizon. Because there is always something we can improve. Therefore, the work will not run out for the Federation of Taxpayers; I can promise you that.

It is true that our tax law is manageable for the regular case. It is also true that it can become quite complicated. Because it is indeed a feat to reconcile a simple tax law with a complex economic system and the endless variety of life. Globalization certainly presents us with completely new challenges, just as does digitization. There will therefore be much material for discussion when the international tax architecture is fundamentally modernized. The OECD is working on this; and we want to see results next year. We know how complicated the discussion about appropriate taxation of the globally active digital economy is, especially. But in the coming years, we will also have to deal with which tax shares we as an export nation can retain and which will remain in the countries where value creation also takes place. This will also be a constant struggle.

In whatever economic sector – to prevent tax avoidance or double taxation, we cannot avoid linking tax law internationally more and better, given global value creation chains. This is not easy in practice. But we must seize the opportunity and put it on a simple, understandable basis so that citizens understand what is happening.

The keyword simplification is, so to speak, the magic word and a regular demand with regard to bureaucratic effort. The Federation of Taxpayers rightly and successfully insists on this. We want to follow the two bureaucracy reduction laws from previous legislative periods with a third, to relieve citizens and businesses once again. The relief should really be noticeable. Therefore, in political action, things must be thought from the taxpayer's perspective. We therefore involve citizens directly in the search for ways to simplify – for example, with the so-called form laboratory for income tax. Here, forms are subjected to a practical test regarding user-friendliness. We did this, for example, in connection with the Family Relief Act; and significant improvements for taxpayers and families have been achieved.

There will soon be, starting in 2021 – which is of course also a subject of controversial discussions – a first major step of relief regarding the solidarity surcharge. However, you want to set the date for the complete abolition of the solidarity surcharge already. Nevertheless, I consider the agreed start of the exit from the solidarity surcharge – we even agree on that – to be an important tax policy step. A first step is important; and that does not mean that we will stop at this step. I say very explicitly: The goal remains to completely abolish the solidarity surcharge. The Federation of Taxpayers will certainly ensure that we do not lose sight of this goal.

In the constant struggle for relief and frugality, you sometimes also bring out quite heavy artillery. That is legitimate as well. Publicly effective examples are the annual spring cleaning campaign, in which you make savings proposals for the new budget, the Black Book, in which you list cases of what you consider gross tax waste at the federal, state, and municipal levels, and the Taxpayer Memorial Day, which is meant to remind us from when taxpayers no longer work for the state and social insurances, but for themselves.

The Federation of Taxpayers also ensures that the public keeps a close eye on the development of national debt. For this, the current debt level is estimated and displayed second by second on the so-called debt clock. This debt clock is a legitimate appeal to politics to engage intensively with national debt – not least with a view to future generations who will inherit the debt burdens. I keep saying in international discussions: Given our demographic situation, this issue is much more pressing and important for us than in other countries with a different demographic development and more young people.

It was, of course, nice that the debt clock received special attention when it became clear that it would run backwards starting in 2018. In fact, the red digits should now be replaced with black ones; but that might not be so good in terms of visibility. That, by the way, the reverse operation is technically possible at all is thanks to the renewal of the clock at the end of 2016. Before that, it would not have been able to display debt reduction at all. But the main thing is, of course, that total government debt is decreasing. And so, the total government debt ratio will fall below 60 percent of gross domestic product this year. This means that Germany will comply with the corresponding upper limit of the Maastricht Treaty for the first time since 2002.

Despite all the criticism, for which we are of course open, this development also shows that we take the responsibility for a solid budget policy as the federal government seriously. I assure you: We remain committed to the goal of a balanced budget – in the federal budget – not for the sake of self-justification, as we are often accused, but because there are solid economic reasons and aspects of fairness that support it.

In a democracy, politics needs vigilant and constructive partners. We appreciate that. That is why I am here this evening and congratulate you wholeheartedly. It is good that politics can and must continue to count on the statements and recommendations of the Taxpayers' Association in the future. The fact that the Taxpayers' Association is one of the largest taxpayer organizations in the world speaks for itself and for its commitment to taxpayers. The large number of guests here today in these Bolle Festsaals indicates that the association truly has a firm place in our society. You spare no effort to save many people unnecessary tax burdens. That honors you and the Taxpayers' Association as a jubilarian.

Therefore, once again, heartfelt congratulations and much success. Be an uncomfortable partner. Remain fair in your reporting. I look forward to further cooperation.

Thank you very much.