Cristina Kirchner at the UN Security Council

Argentina Cristina Fernández de Kirchner · President of Argentina

24 September 2014 · UN Security Council summit meeting on terrorism and foreign terrorist fighters · United Nations Security Council chamber, United States

Context
Fernández de Kirchner addressed the UN Security Council on September 24, 2014, speaking on terrorism, the 1994 AMIA bombing, and Argentina's memorandum with Iran.
Main themes
Terrorism and AMIA bombing, ISIS and global jihadism, Iran-Argentina judicial cooperation memorandum, vulture funds and political interference, Cold War blowback and the Taliban, Arab Spring and radicalization, UN Security Council resolution on terrorism, dialogue between nations, Argentine judicial sovereignty, Hezbollah and state actors
Duration
~16 min
54th percentile
Words
1,873
54th percentile
Sentences
39
24th percentile
Readability
29
15th percentile
Grade
20.8
98th percentile
Syntax
3.79
99th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 79%79%
  • Institutional 8%8%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

39 sentences in 21 paragraphs

Well, the truth is that I greet each and every one of the heads of state and government who make up this Security Council: I come with some certainties and some questions, as well, to participate in this meeting of the Council, undoubtedly to approve the resolution we have agreed upon; undoubtedly also to decisively and definitively condemn terrorism.

My country, the Argentine Republic, along with the United States of America, were the countries in the Americas that were the targets of savage terrorist attacks: in 1992, the Israeli Embassy was bombed in Buenos Aires; in 1994, the AMIA headquarters. From there, I also have many questions because with all that is happening, this phenomenon that has now appeared, ISIS, something unknown last year, it is as if since 1994, when this happened in Argentina, at that time in my country and in the world it was said that Hezbollah was responsible for the bombing of AMIA; today Hezbollah is a party in the country of Lebanon; then, in 2006, the Justice of my country, due to the creation of a Special Prosecutor's Unit, promoted by President Kirchner to thoroughly investigate the attack that had occurred – I reiterate – in 1994. It has been 20 years this year since the attack, without the culprits having been judged yet, and from this investigation, the prosecutor decided, the judge of the case, to charge Iranian citizens: 8 citizens living in Tehran.

From there, President Kirchner, first, and I, later, from 2007 to 2012, requested at each of the Assemblies held here at the United Nations, the cooperation of the Islamic Republic of Iran to be able to interrogate these accused. Moreover, we offered alternatives – like the Lockerbie case – we offered alternatives of a third country where they could be tried.

Finally, in 2012, the Iranian Foreign Minister proposed a bilateral meeting, and from there a Memorandum of Understanding for Judicial Cooperation between both countries was formulated in 2013, with the sole purpose of allowing the Iranian citizens to testify before the judge, because in my country there is no conviction in absentia in the Argentine judicial system, they must be interrogated, they must be judged, and this is part of the validity of the Constitution and fundamental rights.

From the signing of that agreement, both within my country and organizations from the community, which had always accompanied us in the demand for cooperation against the Islamic Republic of Iran, accused us of agreeing with the Iranians, and we really had a doubt about whether when we were asked to demand cooperation from the State of Iran it was done with the real intention of achieving that cooperation or of creating a casus belli.

And also in this country, fundamentally, the so-called vulture funds made a formidable lobby before the American Congress, this can be recorded on the websites of the vulture funds, of the Task Force, where they put photos of me with Ahmadinejad, where it seemed to be, and if it was so called the Islamic Terrorist State until last year, it was condemnable to make a memorandum of understanding for judicial cooperation.

With real surprise, but not with displeasure, with surprise, but not with displeasure because nothing that is dialogue can be bad, we learned that over the weekend the head of the State Department of this country met with his Iranian counterpart, in a well-known hotel in this city, in order to address the problem of ISIS.

You know that they are Sunnis and those who govern Iran are Shiites to see what degree of cooperation or progress could be made in the nuclear program, and so, I observe a much friendlier and more amicable discourse even from those who, last year, accused us along with them or of having spoken with them of being terrorists. I do not think dialogue is bad and welcome it; I believe that dialogue is always good between nations.

But the questions I ask myself are that since that attack in 1994; passing through the Al Qaeda attack on the Twin Towers, devised and carried out by Osama bin Laden, who also did not appear like a mushroom after the rain. Osama bin Laden was trained, along with the Taliban, to face Russia, during the Cold War, in Afghanistan, that strange country, from which only Alexander the Great came out alive, as I say. But really the question is now also the famous Arab Spring emerged, in which everyone was apparently freedom fighters, and where from the Arab Spring new democracies were supposed to arise, and it turns out that many of the Freedom Fighters of the Arab Spring turned out to be many fundamentalists, who today received military training at that time and are now fighting in ISIS and recruiting young people.

I clarify, as a note of color, that I have also been threatened by ISIS, in my country an investigation is underway in Justice regarding a threat that ISIS has made against me. I really do not believe much that ISIS is concerned with the President of the Argentine Republic, I sincerely believe so. And the reasons they have said they have threatened me and that they will attack my life are my friendship with Pope Francis and the fact that I recognize and advocate for the existence of two states: the State of Palestine and the State of Israel so that they can coexist peacefully.

I have noted down here some questions that arise for me, because also in the interregnum of all this, Saddam Hussein appeared with chemical weapons in Iraq, with which a battle was fought, and finally Saddam Hussein was ended and then Iraq became increasingly complicated, and it is as if the world is becoming increasingly complicated and that the scenario we had last year, where it seemed that the most important thing was Iran and its nuclear threat, has now ceased to be this and has passed to ISIS, new terrorists, who we do not know who buys their oil, we do not know who sells them weapons, we do not know who has trained them, because they obviously manage economic resources, manage armament resources, manage resources for dissemination that are frankly cinematic, which leads me to raise questions about what is happening and fundamentally how we can effectively combat terrorism because evidently the military response, which obviously must defend against aggression, without a doubt, no one questions it, it is clear that the way in which terrorism has been fought is not adequate because it is becoming more complicated, there are more groups, they are more violent, they have more power.

Logic indicates that if I have been observing a certain methodology to combat a problem and that problem, instead of disappearing or diminishing, increases and worsens, at least, I have to review the methodology and the methods I am carrying out because something is not going well. I do not say that I have the revealed truth about what to do, I do not say that I have absolute certainty about how to do it, what I do know is that there is an old saying in my country that says that the only thing that cannot be done with cannibals is to eat them. And I think that the most important thing is that we understand that the logic of terrorism is to achieve a reaction that is exactly symmetrical in violence and attack to justify a permanent blood credit, because for each one, there are two, and if they killed two, there are three, and if they killed three, there are four, it is the permanent blood credit.

And also, in a framework in the Middle East, where the State of Palestine continues to be unrecognized, where we have seen the disproportionate use of force against the civilian population in Palestine and where we have not seen any of the leaders who were firing rockets on the other side fall. On the contrary, we have seen innocent children, women, and elderly people die. This continues to feed these groups more and more.

That is why I say that, beyond this Resolution, which we share, which we approved to help, to accompany, but, honestly, it would be very false, very cynical if I came to tell you here that we are getting it right in the method. It seems to me that the situation in the Middle East tends absolutely to complicate.

Moreover, as a member of the G-20, last year, in St. Petersburg, not so far away, it was in November, if I remember correctly, not even a year ago, the possibility was considered that the great enemy was the government of Syria and that those who fought it were the Freedom Fighters. Well, it has been discovered that many of the Freedom Fighters are now part of ISIS. So, who were the ones feeding the opponents and giving them weapons and resources as Freedom Fighters, freedom fighters?

So, I think it is necessary to rethink a lot of things, especially those who have a lot of information, much more information than I have, of course, as President of the Argentine Republic, you can imagine that my country does not produce weapons, does not sell weapons, on the contrary, we have to buy oil because we lack energy, even though we have a large deposit that will make us great suppliers in the future… and I do not know whether to be happy when I say this because every country that has gas and oil has great problems. But the truth is that we are a country that does not produce weapons, we are a country that buys energy, we are a country that does not have all the information that the great powers have.

But many times, I believe that, in addition to having information, we must understand what happens in each society, in each people and try to see what are the most appropriate instruments to seriously combat terrorism. Because it would not be strange at all that next year, in 2015, ISIS has disappeared and any other small group with some strange name has appeared, with even more virulent and violent attitudes, well, and, finally, we do nothing but deepen.

Also to conclude, Mr. President, do not worry, I will finish, I believe that also a fundamental issue in this struggle is respect for human rights.

And why do we talk about this? We talk about it from a country that suffered an unprecedented genocidal dictatorship and that also acted with unprecedented Justice, there was no need to create a Nuremberg Tribunal or to resort to judging dictators at the Hague Tribunal, it was Argentina itself, our own judicial system, that prosecuted and convicted those who had been responsible, including also for the death of French citizens, like the French nuns, and Swedish citizens who also disappeared.

With which, we believe that we have some precedents to be able to speak of the need for this struggle to be carried out within a framework of legality and respect for human rights that guarantee us precisely, not to continue feeding the monster.

Thank you very much, Mr. President.