Conclusive proposals from the President of the Republic.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

2 March 2023 · Conclusive proposals from the President of the Republic

Context
Macron addressed the One Forest Summit in Libreville, Gabon in March 2023, presenting concluding proposals on forest protection and climate action.
Main themes
Tropical forest protection, deforestation, climate action, biodiversity conservation, fair agreement between international community and forest nations, indigenous peoples' rights, forest economy and jobs, carbon sequestration, Congo Basin, bioeconomy, COP commitments, trust and multilateral cooperation
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,213
87th percentile
Sentences
197
89th percentile
Readability
56
79th percentile
Grade
10.6
27th percentile
Syntax
2.95
41st percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 43%41%
  • Economic 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Institutional 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Social 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

197 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Mr. President,

Once again, ladies and gentlemen,

I would like to first thank you, thank you for leading our work in this way. Bravo to you. You can applaud. Thank you, Asha. And I really wanted to thank all of our panelists and all our experts, actors, etc., who have both shared their experience, their ambition, and who have also challenged us, I will come back to that.

I believe there is now a very established consensus. The figures have been given. Scientists have intervened on the necessity to act, and the consensus is there on what our tropical and primary forests represent as a whole. On the stakes it represents today and the risk we run by not protecting them tomorrow. And if I take the latest figures from 2021, just there, every year, four million hectares are lost within the primary tropical forests that store the most carbon and biodiversity on a global scale.

That is 2.5 gigatons of CO2 emissions more, equivalent to one year of fossil emissions from an emerging country the size of India. So we also see the opportunity cost. Therefore, if we want to avoid climate catastrophe, and several of our researchers have reiterated this very well, we see the urgency to act to protect our forests, to put an end to deforestation.

Urgent also, because we have seen the link between plant and animal life, to no longer decimate the great apes or elephants that hold these forest ecosystems with them. This was also very well explained to me this morning.

So to act quickly, we have already made commitments. That is the good news. So we do not need to make grand commitments today because there have already been Glasgow. We committed to halt and reverse deforestation by 2030. And there was Montreal, COP 15. We committed to protect 30% of nature by 2030. So I want to say that there is no need for a commitment from Libreville, that is the good news. There is a need for an action plan from Libreville.

I heard the calls from Tamarah and Hindou earlier. Ladies, thank you very much. I believe we all understood that we need the cash on the table and concrete actions right now, with enthusiasm and impatience. Dear Lionel, that is the “at the same time” of Libreville.

So first, I would like to try to recap the philosophy that brings us all together. Behind the fight for the protection of forests, more broadly of nature, there is this question of trust. This was very well said earlier. And fundamentally, what is needed is a fair agreement between the international community, which legitimately cares about the protection of major carbon sinks, and the forest countries, along with them, the local populations, the indigenous populations who have been there for centuries, even millennia, and who know how to do it and who also want to succeed in their economic development. And that is the basis of this fair agreement.

I think we need to listen to each other at the forefront. And it seems to me that there are three fundamentals behind these fair agreements that we can reach. First, the international community is not entitled to demand, in a way, the sealing off of tropical forests. Whether it is the Congo, the Congo Basin, the Amazon, or the Asian forests, they cannot become entirely large national parks that are off-limits to humans.

And so, very clearly, we must also look at ourselves. In the European Union, - the figures were very well recalled earlier - the forest produces three to four million jobs. So these large forests can produce, with harmonious, reasoned, and controlled management, several million jobs. And they can also, and this is all the work that needs to be done, allow for a transition from the informal economy to a higher value-added economy. Because we must respect indigenous peoples and the knowledge of your grandmother or your aunt Hindou, but we must also allow them to often move out of what they have lived in, and before them their own mothers and grandmothers, which is an inadequately compensated informal economy, to move towards models that you describe for Veja and that others do, which is to fairly compensate their services and the adjacent services and thus have stable and recognized jobs.

And so, a protected forest that maintains or even increases its carbon sequestration rate is not just a forest closed to humans; it is a forest sustainably exploited and justly compensated. That is the first term.

The second, I just mentioned. Protecting the forest is not contrary to the economic interests of forest countries. It is, in fact, the opposite. They are the most interested parties, and we have very well described, by the way, the revenues derived from the forests of the Congo Basin estimated today at 450 million dollars, which could drastically increase by exploiting the extraordinary opportunities for local bioeconomy transformation with measures like the ones you have begun to take, Mr. President, right here.

And then, the third point, certain vital reserves of carbon and biodiversity, such as mangroves, peatlands, and certain highly protected areas with particular species, as the minister reminded me this morning, deserve a higher level of protection because their degradation would have irreparable consequences for climate regulation or for ecosystem reasons, it must be done. And so, it is legitimate that these countries keep intact and ask for compensation for the ecosystem services rendered by this super protection.

And so we must also accept to have responses that are somewhat differentiated according to the scientific analysis that is made. If we have good monitoring of these different ecosystems, there are some that we will protect entirely. There are some that we can sustainably and durably exploit, and we must succeed in generating sustainable and well-compensated jobs and revenues in these countries. That is the philosophy of these fair agreements, it seems to me, that brings us together and that stems from both the expertise accumulated in recent years and the discussions of today.

So, to achieve this, if we set a course, it seems to me that it is to place natural capital at the heart of our economies. And the central question is how we can indeed place the natural capital that we have all mentioned at the heart of different models, in other words, how we move from an economy that tends to, fundamentally, poorly evaluate carbon because that is what we are collectively doing, I will come back to that, which does not evaluate or undervalues biodiversity and therefore leads to its degradation, to an economy that restores all its value to the natural treasure and guarantees the stability of the planet. And that is, in essence, the great transformational project we have to undertake.

So, the first step is that of political commitment. That one, I have already mentioned. COP15 Montreal with the 30% and what we took in Glasgow. There is a very important alliance, and I want to remind everyone here of its importance. It is the Coalition for High Ambition for Nature and People, which allows each country to engage behind these objectives. And so we need all the represented countries to join this alliance.

Next, we need to concretize this political commitment — that is fundamentally what has been said: we have great international mechanisms, we have many things that exist, but the difficulty, as has been very well said, is that action is hyper-local, the mechanisms are totally global, international, and multilateral, and so there is a missing step. It is that of concrete commitments, political contracts with the countries, with clear objectives set by the forest states in full sovereignty, involving their local populations, the indigenous populations who have this knowledge, this expertise, this legitimacy based on science, and with measurable and justifiable steps behind. And in exchange for these commitments, we will need to generate much more funding.

So, there is good news, which is that this is exactly what we have done in the last eighteen months on the climate side, seeing exactly the same problems with what we have called “JETP,” which are these partnerships we have set up for the energy transition and that we have deployed with countries like South Africa and several others. We set a goal, it is led by the country, there are concrete steps, and as a result, we mobilize much more.

That is what we will do for biodiversity. And it is the heart of the initiative we launched with Gabon at COP 27 in Sharm el-Sheikh, with a goal of building these Positive Conservation Partnerships, known as PCP. So, these contracts will inevitably have to be based on science. That was the first pillar, and I thank the scientific community that has been gathered here for several days in Libreville in this regard. And so, there will be the details of the roadmap that has been worked on.

But already, we have the One Forest Vision, which is the document you have put on the table and which, I believe, should be the basis of these contracts for the countries of the Congo Basin, with very clear objectives. They were mentioned earlier, mapped down to the tree, the most vital reserves of carbon and biodiversity. And for that, we need cutting-edge satellite technologies and others. We will also put European funding. France will also contribute with several companies present here. But we need, as has been very well said, scientists and teams on the ground working, by the way, with the populations to be able to make these measurements, which are sometimes weekly or more, and to do so over the long term. And then measure the net balance of sequestration of the three forest basins and their evolution over time. That is the first step, science. So we will put the money on this One Forest Vision. We have a reference document, and it will be specified in the coming days and weeks with the roadmap.

Next, these contracts will also have to be based on local knowledge and practices. This has been very well said, and so it must be anchored in the method. I am pleased in this regard with the launch that was made within the framework of the summit of a coalition under the patronage of Gabon, Uganda, and UNESCO, to inscribe traditional knowledge within the list of the heritage of humanity by 2024. This commitment, as the Director-General reminded us, is key to preserving, to sanctuarizing, this know-how and the fact that our methods will be based on this know-how.

These contracts will obviously need to have an economic dimension graduated according to the degree of protection we want to have and the radicality of the protection we want to implement on a scientific basis. As I said, protecting nature starts with changing production methods. Sometimes completely, at least partially, reducing pressure on ecosystems. And so, I really want to thank all the entrepreneurs and business leaders from the North and the South who gathered around the One Forest Business Forum with very clear recommendations that need to be applied in these contracts: better exploit resources, better compensate populations through a model centered on local transformation.

Several announcements have been made in this regard within the framework of this business forum. With, in essence, a simple challenge. We, as Europeans, have decided to contribute. Frans TIMMERMANS was with us and has carried much of this subject. We also did it in a Franco-French manner. We banned imported deforestation products. So we first did it in France by saying, “wherever there are productions that are the result, fundamentally, of models that are very brutal towards forests, we say no, we will no longer import them.” Then Europe took the same approach.

Many countries, and I can understand them, have come to us saying: “you are being incredibly brutal with us. You are preventing us from developing.” Therefore, the counterpart to this measure, which was necessary to protect our forests, is that we must double our efforts to help the countries we are telling to stop the bad model of deforestation. We will no longer take certain agricultural products. I do not want to stigmatize anyone, nor any practice that relied on uncontrolled deforestation. In return, when we have a strategy, thus a contract that preserves the forest or has a reasoned approach to its exploitation, we must double our efforts to help them structure supply chains on the ground and create added value and jobs. That is the heart of the strategy. And it happens that there is now a small economic and industrial revolution taking place in agroforestry, in the valorization of all forestry practices and all downstream supply chains, and fundamentally, in bio-sourced materials. So, today we need to double our efforts within the framework of these contracts to build value chains around bio-sourced products and low-carbon impact — this was very well articulated in the examples earlier — a structured forestry economy, behind construction and the development of cities that will rely on such an approach, and also succeed in producing for the industry bio-sourced materials and components with companies that will help transform them, etc., etc. So, it is this added value that we want to develop in these contracts.

Finally, there is the remuneration that goes with these contracts. The contract cannot go in only one direction. If countries commit, the community has the responsibility to put in more money. Therefore, more sustainable economic models must also be more rewarding for populations and for countries. Thus, developing forest countries that provide a service to humanity by keeping their forests intact or by reforesting, very legitimately, they tell us — and they are right — “we want to be compensated for this.” And this is also the whole meaning of the PCP initiative that we are carrying and that we are establishing at this Libreville summit. What we wish to put in place is really a mechanism for remuneration for ecosystem services rendered, inspired by what has been done by companies for several years or by financiers for some years.

And if we look at things, it has been very well said by the last panel, we have a model that is failing today for two reasons. First, it is failing because the carbon market, which was initially designed to finance emission reductions under the Paris Agreement, has drifted in recent years. It has drifted into a voluntary market. And as soon as it allows the trading of avoided deforestation without any real clear regulation, lacking real standards that are sufficiently stringent, if I may say so, it has devalued the price of carbon and it has devalued it far too much, we know that well. This means that today we have phenomena of greenwashing. The great risk, if we stop there, is that a distrust will settle regarding carbon credits. There have been several scientific and journalistic works recently that have shown this very well. So, this is a failure. We need to correct it very quickly. You described it very well, but otherwise we are at risk.

And then our system is also failing because, paradoxically, in this system, countries that have intact stocks and wish to preserve them do not have real economic incentives to do so. Which is a bit absurd because we have a market that does not recognize the value of the stocks at its true worth. So, we sometimes put a lot of money into repairing the mistakes that were made or to go in the opposite direction, but we do not put any money at all to help conserve the treasures we already have. Which is a bit absurd. So, this is something we must correct. Ultimately, the challenge we face in this remuneration system, which is still a work in progress — we do not have the answer today, we must be humble — but the challenge is that we must complement carbon finance with more comprehensive mechanisms that integrate the notion of stock, that marry carbon and biodiversity, and that are more robust and regulated on the biodiversity and carbon finance side. That is the key. It needs to be more robust, a bit tougher, and more regulated.

And that is also why this will be an endeavor that somehow marries the two COPs. Because my deep conviction is that we can no longer separate the carbon and climate issue from the biodiversity issue. They are completely intertwined, and we saw that clearly in today’s discussions. So how to do it? As I said, we do not have all the answers today. But the PCP initiative on this remuneration part is a first experimentation. And based on the political commitments of the countries, the goal is to enable the creation of “biodiversity certificates” that can thus attest to the exemplary policies of countries that protect their vital stocks of carbon and biodiversity and be exchanged either with sovereign states or with the private sector as a contribution to nature protection. So, through these contracts, we will have fairly qualitative mechanisms. It is simpler than universal and unique criteria. It does not replace them. But we will have these certificate mechanisms that will allow exchanges and monetary commitments, and that is what will allow us to put more money in and compensate them.

Ultimately, you have understood, what we propose in Libreville is more political commitment from countries and in exchange, more funding. So to quickly deliver initial results — because I heard, “cash on the table” — we have made some decisions here. First, we will make an additional 100 million euros available to countries that wish to accelerate their strategy for protecting vital carbon and biodiversity reserves within the framework of Positive Conservation Partnerships. So, within the framework of these Positive Conservation Partnerships, we will put at least these 100 million. They come in addition to everything that has been done. But here, it is very quick, very rapid, it is traceable since it is the Walton Foundation for 20 million euros, Conservation International for 30 million euros, and France will put in 50 million euros. All others are welcome. But the commitment we have is to move very quickly, to adhere to the objective commitments of the countries.

We want to quickly unlock this funding to develop the scientific analysis we need, because it is the basis, as I said, and to support what is already mature within the framework of these partnerships. Part of this funding will also strengthen the initiative for the forests of Central Africa, for which France will double its annual contribution. And I hope that through this initiative, we can make a special effort to support African countries that are therefore committed to protecting their forest stocks and that have called on the international community in Libreville to help them more.

Next, we will operationalize the recommendations made by the Global Environment Facility on biodiversity certificates. And here, I want to thank Carlos MANUEL and the GEF again for the report that was prepared after COP27. So, this was what we had requested in Sharm el-Sheikh together; we need a report, to advance on the methodology, it has been delivered. We see that we are making good progress. Now, there is still work to be done, as you said very well earlier. France and the United Kingdom will lead a coalition on the subject with the support of the Global Environment Facility and all partners who wish to work with us. And the idea is that by the end of the year, we can finalize a unique methodology and that beyond our PCPs, we really have a methodology on this, precisely on this universal approach to biodiversity certificates that allows us to move forward.

But at the same time, we must be realistic. We need to accelerate disbursements. Yesterday, I was still with the President. The first question his minister asked us was: “we have received very little money compared to what you asked us for.” So it is true that I always have this question, and I know that many ministers or others, every time I see them, tell us: “do not make new commitments, we need the money.” So we are doing it together, we will do it, and we will be there to disburse our bilateral share. But we need to accelerate the release of credits and the very concrete disbursement to be credible on all these projects.

In conclusion, the next steps because we are here to move forward — and I said, since this is not a summit of declarations or ambitions, we are making commitments, a method, the one I just tried to summarize — but therefore, we need to set appointments. So all these commitments lay the groundwork for these fair agreements, what I was trying to describe, which puts natural capital at the center and allows us to set a course for action. The next step, we will have on June 23 in Paris, a summit on the New South-North Financial Pact. This should be an opportunity to take stock of our commitments, particularly the financial part. Dear Lionel, on what has been said, and thank you for the 2 billion fund, it is exactly at the heart of the philosophy we have been working on for two years with the IMF and others, which is to de-risk economies, particularly African economies, to allow liquidity and private financing to flow into these issues.

We have, fundamentally — it was very well said earlier — on the fight against inequalities and climate, exactly the same problem. Many people tell us: “it’s great, we are ready to put money in,” but they do not want to because there are country risks that remain and because, in a way, we cannot have guarantee mechanisms. So, there is a huge gap between public money in the form of grants and private financing that can come, which are all the countries, all the areas of countries that are pretty much all yours, which are too rich to rely solely on grants and where there are still too many country risks to have enough private capital. And there we need to mobilize. For me, this is at the heart of what we need to do on June 23. Public, private, international organizations, and it is at the heart of the reform of the World Bank that must be accelerated and on which we are working with the United States of America and a few others; the re-engagement of the IMF, and the managing director is doing a tremendous job on this subject, and private partners, we must succeed in putting in place mechanisms to bridge this market gap that, otherwise, will not allow us to have maximum credits on biodiversity and climate issues. That is June 23.

Next, we will have COP28 in Dubai, where the Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea will come with me directly — we will go together, my friend — to build a strategy because we are doing it together throughout the Indo-Pacific region and obviously more specifically Oceania, Melanesia, and others. He is doing a tremendous job. So we will go to COP28, and there we will need to draw the first results of this strategy, and I think we need to set ourselves the goal at the time of COP to be able to sign the first country contracts for this positive conservation and take stock of biodiversity credits following the report that was delivered today. Here are the two steps we have, just for this year. This means that we can meet in early March, say see you in June, and see you in December.

Then, I think we need to do so in a very, I would say, pragmatic manner, but organize a One Forest Summit every year perhaps rotating among the countries of the region, and then turning to other regions, we need to go to the Amazon, to Asia. And to take stock each time of the method, the signed contracts, the results obtained, what works, what does not work, to also continue to be called out on the money that does not arrive or the impatience that is expressed legitimately. So with that, we need appointment clauses so that we can report on the commitments we are making today.

There you go, I have already been too long, I will not be any longer. But you have understood, there is a scientific vision in Libreville, it is the work you have done. But there is above all a coalition of actors and an accelerated action plan to be able to support, invest alongside the countries and forest states that have already done a tremendous job. I do not say help because they do not need our help, they have already done a lot. And I do not say help because they are the ones who are helping us in the battle for biodiversity and against climate change. I therefore say: Invest as partners to succeed. Thank you all.