Exchanges between the President of the Republic and the readers of Ouest-France

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

10 December 2025 · Exchanges with the readers of Ouest-France · Saint-Malo, France

Context
Macron participated in a reader Q&A session with Ouest-France regional media group in Saint-Malo, Brittany, on December 10, 2025, focusing on social networks and democracy.
Main themes
Social network regulation, disinformation and fake news, democracy and elections, digital responsibility, freedom of speech, media law, algorithmic manipulation, citizen protection, Digital Services Act, tech company accountability, critical thinking, presidential election 2027
Duration
~206 min
99th percentile
Words
24,667
99th percentile
Sentences
1,391
99th percentile
Readability
62
91st percentile
Grade
9.0
11th percentile
Syntax
2.85
28th percentile
Vocabulary
1.93
5th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 38%37%
  • Institutional 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 15%15%
  • Technological 13%13%
  • Environmental 8%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%5%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Not in focus 3%

1,391 sentences in 233 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Republic, good morning, thank you for proposing this exchange with the readers of regional media, as this is not actually the first date. You are today in Brittany, in Saint-Malo, to meet our readers from the SIPA Ouest France group, led by Fabrice Backhouche, who is present here, so Ouest France of course, Groupe Actu, which is a collection of about a hundred titles across the entire national territory, but also the audience of Novo19, the national generalist channel created by the Ouest France group and incidentally the first national channel created a bit far from Paris under the good Breton air.

Welcome to you. We are going to talk about social networks that were bequeathed to us at the end of the 20th century with a beautiful promise of freedom. We were finally going to be able to say everything at any time to the whole Earth. Nothing was supposed to hold back words or images, no matter what they said and no matter what they showed. We opened our conversational space to every wind. Digital networks constantly broadcast the best, but also the worst of what human nature is capable of inventing, as words, and producing as images. They have liberated the speech of oppressed people, but their activity has also contributed to the destruction of individuals.

At the dawn of the 21st century, did we not ultimately accept the unacceptable, by accepting the fact that these networks were not responsible for what they disseminate, not responsible before the law, unlike the media? I would like to quickly remind you that in France, the media are regulated by law, this has been true since the Third Republic, particularly the law of 1881, among others, that the law has provided for the development of free media, it has also provided for the protection of citizens against potential excesses of the media. Concretely, professional journalists are obviously responsible for what they write, and in each media outlet, a person, the director of publication, is criminally and personally responsible for everything that is written. This is not true for social networks. Things are totally different. We have allowed them to develop very freely, we just forgot the question of protecting citizens. Many citizens pay a heavy price when they are impudently threatened, harassed, insulted, with regularly terrible consequences.

Social networks have taken on a gigantic place in our democracy, when today some of their owners assert, looking us in the eye, that they refuse to apply our law, which would be, according to them, nothing but censorship. We can legitimately worry about the future of our democracy. Fortunately, things are moving forward. Europe has provided a number of texts that should now regulate the activity of social networks, notably the Digital Services Act. It still needs to be applied. The digital space cannot be a lawless zone. Technology, which is advancing at a dizzying speed, can bring us and will bring us tools that can be wonderful for human development. But on one condition, that these large companies respect the law, as each and every one of us is required to do. There you go, Mr. President of the Republic, this is what will feed the many questions from our readers. Thank you.

Host

Thank you. So, two hours of exchange. We have selected or pre-selected about fifteen questions. And of course, if we have time, we will obviously take other questions, because I know that there are quite a few young people who have prepared questions with their teachers. So, perhaps we will have a few minutes to grant them. We will start with the first theme called "Social Networks, Democracy, and Elections." For each of the themes, a journalist from the SIPA Ouest-France group will obviously set the scene.

Hostess

Mr. President, good morning to all. At a time when disinformation and fake news have never undermined the pillars of democracy as much, how can the upcoming electoral deadlines, the municipal elections soon and the presidential election in 2027, allow citizens to exercise their critical thinking and vote without being manipulated by algorithms and other conspiracy theories?

Host

So perhaps a word on what disinformation represents on social networks?

Hostess

Yes, according to a study by Science Feedback from September 2025, which looked at TikTok, Instagram, X, Facebook, YouTube, and LinkedIn, disinformation is no longer just isolated in the corners of the web; it has become a central issue in public debate. In this digital arena, TikTok, we can say, is the worst student. Still according to this study, between March and April 2025, nearly one in five pieces of content on this application contains false or misleading information. 34% of posts spread hate speech or others disseminating false information. It’s 32% on X. Facebook would convey 13% of false information and 8% on YouTube. The study thus demonstrates that on TikTok, primarily consulted by the youngest and most vulnerable, users are 10 times more exposed to misleading content than a LinkedIn user, for example, who addresses a more specific adult audience in a more professional context.

Host

What will be the impact of social networks, particularly on the upcoming elections, the municipal elections that are fast approaching?

Hostess

Yes, we consider that there is more than ever a real risk regarding the municipal elections as mass manipulation tools and external interference also target municipalities. Even though it should be noted that the trust link with the mayor remains quite solid. But for how long? In the face of fake sites, for example, that inject controversial topics, traditional media must be able to guarantee reliable, verified, and balanced information. This implies being transparent, being reactive, and that we collectively choose a quality treatment.

Speaker

Thank you. First of all, thank you, Mr. President, for coming. It is something, I would say, quite motivating for citizens to be able to exchange directly with you, and even exciting, there you go. That’s my point of view. Fighting against the deviations of social networks. I will get straight to the point, since we have little time. I think it starts first by fighting against anonymity. This is really the major problem of social networks in general, anonymity. So, I will take this opportunity, because there are means, I actually make a proposal. Article 11 of the Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizen, which is of course included in the preamble of our current constitution, is quite short but very clear. "The free communication of thoughts and opinions is one of the most precious rights of Man. Every citizen may therefore speak, write, and print freely, except in cases determined by the law to respond to the abuse of this freedom."

So, shouldn’t the law simply determine that henceforth, anonymity constitutes an abuse? And that would fall into the category that would therefore be punishable. This is the first proposal I make to you, and I would of course ask you, this is my question, how can we implement this proposal if it pleases you? And if it does not please you, I would be very happy to hear your arguments, knowing, I add here, of course that I do not hold the truth, I am like everyone else, I seek to get closer to it every day, and it is not easy.

The second thing from a more positive angle. The first question is on the angle of negative sanction, anonymity. The positive side, you pointed out earlier, is participatory citizenship and how to develop it today. I systematically return to the thinkers we had in the 18th century, who are very interesting. I think of "Sapere aude," dare to use your own understanding, Emmanuel Kant, of course. And I think we need to develop discernment. I have 9 points. I will propose them to you in writing, so you will have the opportunity.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you. First, thank you, gentlemen presidents, for the welcome and organization of this debate. Mr. Regional Prefect, Madam Rector, ladies and gentlemen, in your ranks and qualities, we say ladies and gentlemen, and thank you for coming here to have this debate, and I wanted to start by apologizing for the delay, which is not due to a choice, a will, but to the somewhat unpredictable nature of international news; at 3:00 PM, the time we were supposed to start our debate, I was at the town hall of Saint-Malo for a phone call with some colleagues on the question of Ukraine and President Trump. So, we had these 40 minutes of discussion to try to make progress on a subject that concerns us all. So, please forgive me for the delay with which I arrived before you.

I wanted to thank you for organizing this debate, and I find that you have framed it perfectly, if I may say so, without being caricatural, that is to say, social networks bring us a lot in our daily lives, it is a tremendous advance, it allows access to knowledge, to understand things, to alert on situations, to circulate information much better, but it must be noted that, fundamentally, over the past ten years that we have had hindsight, because it has spread into our lives for 10 years, things have happened that should encourage us today to take a little step back and, in essence, regain control of these networks. When we talk about our children and adolescents, because now we will return to it, since it is one of the themes you have chosen, we can see that it has disrupted their lives and has real consequences that we can measure.

Then, when we talk about the functioning of our democracy, because more and more people are getting their information from social networks, I had said, and particularly among the youngest, and so it creates unfair competition, we will probably return to this subject with the press, but as a result, it structures our democracy, because a democracy is about going to elections, but having forged a free opinion, and we are increasingly forging it on social networks. Is it free? Who structures it? How? This is a real democratic question. And so the answer is not univocal; there is not one, if I may say, a unique or simple answer, but it probably goes through prohibitions, through regulations. Because today, there are almost none. The first ones, we put them in place, and they have prevailed for a little over two years, and they were just applied in recent days regarding the directive that was mentioned earlier, which is the Digital Service Act concerning the X network, but it is the first time, so it is just the beginning. So, we sometimes need to prohibit, to regulate, certainly to educate, to instruct, to understand, to restore critical thinking in society, and finally, to continue to innovate to regain control. Innovation is also part of the ways to re-domesticate all this, to put it back in the service of a certain idea of humanity.

So, based on this question, we will return, I think, to other issues of interference, since the first theme, if I understood correctly, is about the upcoming elections. The question of anonymity, which is the first question in this theme, is much broader, so I will answer it, but then I will probably return to more specific things regarding the elections. So anonymity has brought a lot of things to social networks because it has allowed people in societies that are not free to express themselves. In France, you are not attacked today if you express yourself on a social network and decide to do so without anonymity. For sure, whether you are a scholar or a citizen, even within the European Union in Hungary, you would have some difficulties expressing yourself with the same freedom if there were no anonymity. For sure, even more so in more authoritarian countries where there are social networks. So that is to say that anonymity in a system that is still globalized, even at the level of the European Union, has advantages, at least, and is difficult to completely eliminate.

The second thing is that many people would tell you: "anonymity is what has also allowed people to be whistleblowers, to people who do not want to hide their identity, but to share this or that content without being totally exposed, without having social pressure." So there has been, and we can measure it, an interest in anonymity in the free functioning of information, of what has been done on the Internet. On the other hand, it must be noted that anonymity has disinhibited things. Because when you do not see your face, when you do not know your name, it frees up speech a bit and can encourage some to say anything.

So, I don't think that the immediate lifting of anonymity, I’m not saying, like you, I don’t necessarily have the answer, the infallible science, but I have listened to the arguments of both sides because I could initially lean a bit in your direction. I think it’s very complicated. We will not have consensus at the European level to do it, and it’s very complicated to do it only in France, and it can have a lot of perverse effects to completely lift anonymity. But it seems to me that we need to, 1) accelerate the work of the justice system when we want to lift anonymity to prosecute someone. We already have the means and ways, but it’s still too slow. 2) What is the problem for you? It’s the people who abuse anonymity. I was listening to you. And so there, we have some initial tools, but we need to go further. And I think that’s the key in what we are trying to do. That is to say, when someone says something racist, anti-Semitic, or homophobic, we need to be able to immediately demand the removal of that content from the platforms and be able to prosecute that person. In reality, we have the legal bases; we are not using them enough. Because on these types of content, it is unassailable, we have the legal basis, it is already prohibited. 3) We need to activate the responsibility of these platforms. We will often return to this in the debate, but if Ouest France published something that is racist, anti-Semitic, or otherwise in an article or in its letters or in its columns, the editor-in-chief would be attacked immediately because he has the responsibility, and thus he would be brought before the courts. It needs to be the same for the platforms. We have the basis with the DSA, but we need to go much faster and stronger. And so there, we need to take – it’s in the package we are planning for the start of January – circulars that allow us to go in this direction.

Finally, we will return to this in the second theme, so I don’t want to be longer, there is the question of false information and people who spread false information with anonymity. That is much more complicated to regulate; it is not the judge who can say whether it is true or false. It is often the critical debate and the ability to distinguish the true from the false. So, you see, it’s not black or white, but if we want to move forward, simplify things, I think we need to go much faster on lifting anonymity when there is a problem; remove, apply the immediate removal of content when it is clearly hateful or illegal content; and implement the responsibility of the platforms. That seems to me more effective than the immediate lifting of anonymity.

Speaker

My question is simple. First, thank you, Mr. President, for coming to us. Indeed, it seems inconceivable to me to completely eradicate fake news, but we must be able to succeed in diminishing its effectiveness. My question is simple. In your opinion, what is the best way to achieve this that can combine effectiveness and respect for freedom of expression?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First, this has been said in the introduction, and it is apparently what you think. You are right; it is not the State that can do this. And I always insist on this point because there have been some biased debates in recent days that have said a bit of nonsense, including about what I may have said. I think it is not at all the job of the State to distinguish the true from the false. It is precisely the job of a free press through contradiction, verification, and then, for other subjects, it can be the work of scientists, a scientific voice to be restored. And you are right. There have always been what we now call fake news, that is to say, false information, rumors. Historians and sociologists, by the way, have written on these subjects.

The question is how we can quickly put an end to them to prevent them from becoming the most widely believed information, even though they are false, or, in a way, to contaminate judgment. The key is first to restore a central place to those whose job it is, namely journalists and media outlets, because they have professionals who have been trained to do this, they have a code of ethics, a Code of Ethics. I remember that this is the case for Ouest-France. I have held this Code in my hands, and I still remember it. So journalists have a Code of Ethics that applies to themselves. It is verified by peers. And then, they have a responsibility that can be activated by law. And so the first thing is to ask where the information is. And that is a first remark I wanted to make that goes beyond the elections; it is perhaps at this stage of the discussion that we should be clear about what social networks are and, fundamentally, what they are for.

When we talk about elections or information, the great misunderstanding lies there. Social networks are not made to inform us. And do you know why? Because you have never paid a social network to inform you. However, information, if you want it to be prepared by people who will go investigate, who will verify it, who will control it, there must be an economic model behind it. When you buy a newspaper, you know that you are paying for information. And then, alongside the information, editorials, a line that you follow, but you pay. And incidentally, they also make money with advertising, legal notices, or others. But there is an economic model; you pay for information. When you go on social networks, you do not pay. So how do social networks make money? Not by informing you; they make money by selling personalized advertising. It’s not a dirty word; it’s their job; the business model of social networks is that.

So, what fundamentally drives them to have the maximum number of people on these social networks and to create the maximum excitement? They do not want to inform you. In any case, they have no interest in informing you; they have no interest in you seeking arguments. They want there to be maximum movement, maximum excitement, because it is on this basis that they can have the maximum information about you and sell more expensive personalized advertising that they will push to you. This is not at all a criticism I am making; I am describing exactly what it is. TikTok, X, well, all social networks operate on this economic model. This is what has led them to take a lot of advertising from the press sector, which has gone to social networks because, then they say, we are much more effective. Rather than sending the same ad to all readers of Ouest-France, we know that he loves Formula 1, that she prefers cinema, etc., and through the consulted networks, through the pages consulted, they will push this information. And so the social networks we consult, which we have been talking about for a while, their business model is not to inform you and to inform us. Their business model is to create excitement to sell personalized advertising to third parties.

Once we understand that, we realize that what is most important is to create dependency. That is what will motivate the algorithms of the networks. And then, what is much more effective for creating excitement is to push content that is shocking, that will make you react, sometimes that will, in a compulsive way, bring you back. So for some, it will be cat videos; for others, it will be content related to your passion, whatever. But the lowest form of excitement is information, argument, rationality. Emotion creates more excitement. Negative emotion or addictive things create even more. So you understand that we are talking about an exchange infrastructure when we talk about our social networks, whose objective in everything that determines it is not made to channel information or push good information to you. It is made for you to be dependent, to spend the maximum amount of time there, and to be as excited as possible.

Once we have said that, it is structurally a potential propagator of false information. So, I frame this to say, well, let’s not be mistaken; social networks are not inherently places to get informed. And it will never be, except on the day when you have a social network that will ask you to pay for information because that means there are people who will produce that information because it has value, so it has a cost. So, we will not be able to solve this if we do not first say that the place to get informed is the press, it is the public debate, and information does have value, and therefore it can have a cost at a given moment. It has an individual cost, and it has a collective cost.

Once we have said that to try to regulate and limit false information, the first thing is to have transparency and fairness of algorithms. I must be able to know if I have an algorithm because it is the one that will push information to me. Is this algorithm biased? Is it likely to push false information to me? We have the beginnings in our famous DSA at the European level, but we need to go much further on the transparency of algorithms.

The second thing is to have the responsibility of the platforms. It is a European fight. Now, we have started with the DSA; we need to push much further, which is to say: when, in a proven manner, you have been alerted that information could be false, that after a contradictory process that must be determined, which should be done among peers, it is proven that you did nothing, that you allowed it to spread and gain momentum, your responsibility can be called into question, just like a press publisher.

And then the third thing that is very important to prevent the spread of fake news is fake accounts. And that is the link with what Mr. said, probably more important and more of a priority than anonymity, it is to demand the disappearance of fake accounts. Today, when you have an account on social networks, you cannot necessarily say who it is, if they have chosen anonymity, but you cannot even say if it is a physical person or not. This means that you can have, especially in electoral situations, information that is spread where you are told that there are 100, 150,000, sometimes 1 million people who have pushed it, who have liked it. So it starts to take on value because we are in this society that is quantitatively measured through likes or retweets, etc., you cannot say how many are real people. And what happens, very simply? You have people who buy fake accounts, these famous bots, these troll farms, and who buy them to manipulate the informational space, and thus massively spread fake news. Those who are interfering from abroad in our country today use this extensively.

And so, there are things we must do ourselves that are related, if I may say so, to the structure of social networks, the algorithm that is not transparent today, the fact that there is no responsibility and that these networks are not made to inform us. And then there are things where we are far too naive and that are massively used by foreign interference, which are these famous fake accounts. If we address these three issues while always keeping in mind that social networks are not made to inform us, we will be much more effective in combating the spread of false information.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. My question is about digital sovereignty. We know that the social networks used by the French and Europeans are digital services offered by American or Chinese companies. So, I wonder, what can France and Europe do to guarantee our digital sovereignty?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. So, the issue of digital sovereignty is much broader than social networks, but what you say is absolutely correct. That is to say, these large networks are non-European. But we have a chance; it is that all those who, in Europe, consult them and thus make them earn a lot of money, because, as I explained earlier, they make money from the advertising they sell on all of us. That is in our hands. So that is also why we have an interest in regulating. Because if we do not regulate, we delegate all of our emotions, our ability to approach certain realities, sometimes to inform ourselves, even if I try to explain that it is not the right place for it, and for many of our young people too, to sometimes discover a lot of things, we delegate it to these companies that are either American or Chinese. So, digital sovereignty, when we talk about social networks, is about the ability to regulate content and thus to set limits and to say this is our model, our collective preferences that we want to impose.

Our chance, our strength in this context, is precisely the nearly 450 million European citizens who are affected by these regulations. That is also why, even if sometimes it is slow. You have often heard me say that we must first go through Europe, because it is at the European level that we have this striking power. And that is what we did under the French presidency. We imposed two rules on them. This directive on digital services, DSA, and the directive on digital markets, DMA, because some are also trying to devour all the others and abuse their dominant position. This is the great battle today, because you may have seen it in the last few days, but the major digital players, particularly Americans, and sometimes their government, say: "We will demand that the Europeans remove these rules because we no longer want to see them." It is a power struggle that must be assumed, and that is sovereignty, because they are still dependent on our market as well, because they make a lot of money there.

So the strength lies in the fact that Europeans are united and that they say to themselves, after all, it is the brains, the emotions of our children, we will not let them slip away like that, and it is the health of our democracy. So that is our sovereignty. In fact, regulatory sovereignty. And then we need to reconquer technological bricks. This is a bit of the whole battle we are waging on artificial intelligence, because what you say is true, we lost it on social networks. We do not have alternative players. I cannot tell you, leave all the American platforms, we have a great French platform that provides the same service, that would not be true. On the other hand, in artificial intelligence, that is exactly what we are doing, because we can still do that. We say to ourselves, of course, there are ChatGPT, etc., these so-called generative artificial intelligence models, which produce language, and there we have a French player called Mistral AI with Le Chat. So I tell you, go download Le Chat rather than ChatGPT, because it is French. What is a generative artificial intelligence model? It is just a supercomputer that calculates very quickly, which has enormous power, to which we have made read the maximum number of books. ChatGPT has read a lot of Anglo-Saxon books, Le Chat has read a lot of French books. It is better for us if we want to maintain cognitive sovereignty. So we have that, and we will fight to keep and develop our European generative artificial intelligence model.

We want to have European computers, supercomputers, and data centers, that is what we are currently doing in full swing, to have these computing capabilities that are European. And then, we are consolidating, and this is a strategy at the European level with the Germans, to have on our soil all the key technological elements that allow us to talk about digital sovereignty. There are two sectors, when we talk about digital in the broad sense, where we need to reconquer our sovereignty because we have lost it in recent years, it is social networks, that is why we need to regulate, so that our rules prevail when it concerns us. And it is the cloud we are talking about, that is, the place where our data is stored, where, in recent years, we have managed to push the Americans to come back with us so that it is regulated by Europeans, because our data is also one of the true treasures of the 21st century, and we had let everything slip away solely to the American side. So we are in the process of rebuilding European solutions, and France is at the forefront of these two battles.

Moderator

Thank you. We will move on to the second theme related to the environment. Social networks, the environment, the climate challenge, with, of course, the scientific truth that is often called into question on social networks.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. "Climate disinformation has become a threat to our democracies. We must protect science and build our policies on facts." I imagine you recognize these words. Yes, they are yours. You spoke them at COP 30 in Brazil a few weeks ago. During that speech, you pointed out the prophets of disorder, without naming anyone in particular, but one could imagine that Trump, Donald Trump could be one of those prophets of disorder, he who multiplies criticisms against science and who described, a few months ago, climate change as the greatest scam the world has ever known or the greatest scam perpetrated against the world. In France, you know, we are not spared from these elements of language. Many political figures amplified by certain media echo them and target scientists.

So, I will cite climatologists, meteorologists, oceanographers, agronomists. There you go, it is online that they suffer all these attacks you mentioned earlier. And they are victims of pressure, they are victims of threats, of harassment, with the complacency of these social networks. We will mention X, you spoke about it earlier, which has indeed been condemned. X which uses its artificial intelligence Grok to amplify this disinformation, there you go. So, in the face of this relentless false offensive that spares no network, I spoke of X, but of course there are many other networks that are involved. How can we stop this machine, this machine that undermines trust, that blurs the facts and above all that delays action?

Moreover, in this context, your words, your decisions can also be confusing, there you go. You denounce climate disinformation with very strong words, as you did at COP. But the decisions you make at the climate level, at the biodiversity level, at the agricultural level, may seem contrary, even contradictory to the climate emergency and to the conclusions of scientists. So there you go, these scientists have indeed noted this and lamented these decisions. And we even have the High Council for Climate, an institution you created in 2018, which somewhat regrets this climate inaction.

To conclude, the idea is how to restore credibility to these scientists so that there is a real awareness that is taken as they request, and how to stop making them targets, and above all, what response can we provide them in this context. Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Of course. So, because you said a lot of things, perhaps it justifies that I try to follow the thread to tell you how I see things. Whether it is about climate, in fact, as well as health, which are the two major issues in recent years that have been the subject of such an attack, we live in a transformed world that has experienced a form, well, where obscurantism is returning and where conspiracy theories are present. These are the two major subjects. I would say climate and health. In fact, when I say health, it is a bit about vaccines. These are two subjects where you have had in recent years a questioning of science, sometimes behind a real aggressiveness, threats against scientists and people who have strayed from the spirit of the Enlightenment. And so with sometimes a retreat from practices. I say this because we have today French families who, for example, are opting out of vaccination because they have read something on the Internet, and you have people who are retreating on climate adherence because they have read on the Internet this or that information.

We are fighting, and it is the quotes you have repeated, for decisions to be made on a scientific, open, and independent basis. France is uncompromising on this issue, and I have always been very clear, and Europeans are uncompromising on this issue. That is to say, fundamentally, there must be a science that can say in a totally independent, academic manner, with people who have the legitimacy to do so, that is to say who have been trained, who have read books, conducted studies, research, who are recognized by their peers, with, there too, certainties, uncertainties, and challenges. That is the very nature of science. But science must be able to be academically open and able to express itself. That is the basis of everything. And in an open democratic society, that is what must be preserved.

In France, there is academic freedom. Freedom means the President of the Republic does not say, we are not allowed to research on such a thing, or this research is good and this research is not good. And that is the first point you mentioned, and I want to reiterate it here, because we are fighting for that, and we, Europeans, are fighting for that. At this very moment, in the United States of America, you have a government that says: "Research on, for example, diversity, all these forms, is not good, we cut the words. Research on climate is not good and is prohibited." And they have cut all funding. And they have removed those very words. And there has been pressure on universities and research organizations. So that is the summa divisio. And we are fighting for that, we are at the forefront. I held a summit at the Sorbonne a few months ago, where I invited other Europeans saying: we must fight for this free and independent science. And that is what we have always fought for.

Once we have this free and independent science, then public action is built on top of it. That is why you were not precise in your questioning, because you gave the impression that I was ambiguous regarding this defense. No. No! But in reality, we make decisions every day. Does a politician, therefore, have the ability to make all the decisions that scientists demand? In reality, no, because that is governance. It means you are obliged to make decisions and trade-offs between multiple constraints. That is to say, you have scientists who will tell you: "We need to move towards zero, for example, input on plant protection products." And then, alongside that, you have other scientists, rightly, who will tell you: "We need to preserve the food sovereignty of the country." And if you go for zero plant protection products, you will completely disrupt your agriculture and lose it.

So, you make decisions that never fully satisfy everyone, but that are pathways. And so, the scientists are in their role. And what you said is, for me, the perfect illustration of what we do, which is the strength of democracies. I defend free and open science. It informs government decisions. The government makes decisions every day that take this into account, but also other constraints of our life: industrial life, agricultural life, other interests that are sometimes food-related. Because if I were to fully follow these demands sometimes to move towards zero plant protection products, what do we do? We can, as has happened in certain sectors, completely eliminate the sector and import products from abroad because we no longer produce them here, which do not respect these rules. It is more complicated than one might think.

We are obliged to find solutions that are as good as possible. And then, we set up independent bodies that can say: "You have made some progress, but it is not sufficient, you have not been good here, with our criteria." Then you will cross the street, as the other would say, and you look at the other side of the street, the one who did not agree at all, he says: "I am not entirely in agreement with what you did either, because with my criteria, you prevented me from producing 100, I now only produce 70 or 80 because you imposed rules on me." But that is the path we are taking. But I want to make this distinction between the decisions we make that are based on science, but that may not follow science 100% because we must constantly make compromises in organizing the life of the city, and the fact of contesting free science. France, it defends in an unassailable manner open academic freedom and even the possibility of being criticized in its actions by science.

Now, let me tell you that for the past 9 years that I have been President of the Republic, France is no longer in a state of climate inaction. You used that word, which was a term for which France was condemned by a ruling that concerned the period from 2015 to 2018. You will recognize that I was elected in May 2017. And therefore, it did not concern my actions. When I was elected, we were reducing our CO2 emissions by 1% per year. In the first term, we moved to 2%, we doubled that. In the first three years of this second term, we went to over 4.5%. We are back on track as far as we are concerned, and it has been acknowledged, including... There are many things we need to do better, and I am still fighting, and we will be releasing the national low-carbon strategy in a few days. Nevertheless, we cannot be told that we are inaction. Otherwise, nothing makes sense. Because otherwise, executives like ours, who have been fighting for years to improve things, sometimes placing many constraints on our industries to decarbonize their production. Here, you have the Roullier group, in this city, which has spent millions of euros under collective pressure to decarbonize its production. You have farmers. Ask them if they have not been asked to make efforts in recent years. They have led a real revolution to reduce their emissions. So it is not enough yet. But do not say that we have done nothing, otherwise you will discourage everyone. And especially because, factually, that is not true.

Speaker

I read via, of course, my subscription to Ouest-France on COP26, also through other networks, but I do not educate myself through social media. I followed your advice. So, it was held in a context marked by the climate emergency, underscored by the very bleak projections of the United Nations Environment Programme. You were there. How to engage a democratic resurgence capable of accelerating the climate transition and all this under the scrutiny of social media?

Emmanuel MACRON

A vast program. First, social media, as was very well said by Mr. just before, also disseminate a lot of scientific truths. The difficulty we have, as you mentioned in your framing, is that we have about a third of the content, which varies according to the networks, but which disseminates false climate information, and we have a rise, Mr. mentioned the X network earlier, we can see that there is deliberately an algorithm that promotes climate-skeptical content. So, there is a weakening in certain societies, at least, there is an organized approach by some because they also have ideological connections that somewhat undermine this trust.

Now, if we are honest, it is also many governments that do not engage enough. I am not saying that we are perfect; I defended my results just now, but we can always do more, we must always do more. We simply have problems of conflicting uses, difficulties in advancing on certain subjects, but we must relentlessly push forward because I believe I can tell you, at least from where I stand and having received the IPCC scientists last week, you know, the IPCC is the group of experts assembled by the United Nations, they are climate experts from around the world. So, there are more than 600 experts who are the most recognized who meet in the IPCC, and it is they who, in a way, gave us the foundations. The Paris Agreement, which was signed, will be 10 years this Friday, was based on the reports of the IPCC. And so, the best way not to fall into climate inaction and to respond to this urgency is to continue to rely on science.

And what does science tell us? What do the IPCC scientists say? 1) The Paris Agreements have allowed things to move, that is to say, where the trajectory, 10 years ago, was heading towards 4 degrees, we are not there. 2) We had said we must aim for 1.5, unfortunately, we will exceed it. And it is probably in the coming years that we will touch it. So that means there has been an effort, there has been an awareness, a lot of things have been done, but it is not fast enough. 3) They tell us there will be disruptions, and therefore we must concentrate action.

Now, I could have a debate here for several hours, but to try to tell you what is the possible action and where our priority for action lies, it is to accelerate the exit from coal for all those who are leading it. So, we have very important states: China, India, Vietnam, Indonesia. The faster they go... because they continue to increase coal use, in fact – the faster they reach their coal peak and start to decrease, the faster we will have concrete results on emissions. So, priority number one, exit from coal. And therefore, lead them to go towards gas, but at most renewables or nuclear, which are decarbonized energies, as you know, and reduce needs. But 1) it is the exit from coal. 2) Methane, which is really one of the most aggressive emissions. It turns out that there are many methane leaks when extracting hydrocarbons. It is to have reinforced action on this point. And 3) to support key countries, which are often major emerging economies, to help them finance their energy transition.

And then after that, all the richest countries, including ours, should follow their path. And so there, we can see, within Europe, there is hesitation; many are saying, well, it is already hard enough, we will ease off, we will make fewer efforts. We can see that in our debates, we have these conflicts, what was described earlier about public debates is quite true. So we must continue to rely on science to say, we have already done things, but we must continue and not lower the flag, not reduce the effort.

The last point is that we have learned in recent years that the fight for the climate is inseparable from that for biodiversity. And so oceans and forests are twin battles. Why? Because they are carbon sinks. They are carbon sinks that are unfortunately becoming less and less effective for our forests because climate disruption is starting to affect them. So there you go. 1) Defend free science. 1) Fight against misinformation on social media when it promotes climate-skeptical content. 3) Try to explain that we have a concrete action plan, which, although not perfect, allows us to make progress and that the past 10 years have already allowed us to make some initial progress, even if they are not sufficient.

Speaker

Welcome to Saint-Malo. Mr. President, I will go a bit in the direction of the first question. I would like to draw your attention to the preservation of natural environments, which seem too often sacrificed. What will we do when our GDP grows by 3, 4, or 5%, but the ambient air is laden with PFAS, our oceans are richer in microplastics than in marine fauna, while fresh water is no longer drinkable? This is already partly the case and in an irreversible way. Social media are the vector of conspiracy theories, and some across the Atlantic, already mentioned, even claim that climate change is the greatest scam in the world. What do you think? I apologize, this is a bit redundant with the previous question.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. No, but this allows me to perhaps return to this subject, broader than just CO2 emissions, and come back to it. First, as you said, there is an ideology that fights what I have called a reactionary international, which actually fights a bit, well, even resolutely, free and open science, which fights the contribution of this science in terms of health, the vaccine, and everything that has allowed to improve public health over the past decades, and which indeed fights climate. Why? Because it contradicts financial and economic interests, let’s be honest. And because you are a country where there are many interests in hydrocarbon production, and indeed the United States, it is the great change that many have not seen in the last 15 years. The United States, which depended on oil and gas from the Near and Middle East, has become a major producing country with the technique known as fracking. And so they defend their interests. One can defend one’s interests. Simply, one cannot defend one’s interests by lying to people.

And so this is where we have a deep disagreement and where we must fight to preserve the voice of scientists. On biodiversity and plastic issues, since you mentioned them, I want to respond substantively. First, France has a history in this area. We are one of the first countries to have created the Conservatoire du littoral, which does remarkable work, and it is its anniversary this year. The natural parks, which were a French innovation, we protected our space in France long before others. And we were at the forefront; it is the initiative we took with Costa Rica and a few others a few years ago, before the biodiversity COP that took place between Kunming and Montreal, to have 30% of our marine and terrestrial areas protected, which was really a struggle. We managed to impose it in this biodiversity COP, and France is implementing it for itself, protection and super protection. We announced this protection again at the Nice summit. And then, we managed to complete all this in Nice, during the United Nations summit on the oceans, where we finally managed to ratify something we had been waiting for decades, which is a treaty that will regulate the high seas. Because believe it or not, two-thirds of our maritime spaces in the world, two-thirds, were the Wild West, there was no regulation. And so even when we protected ours, it was a bit ridiculous; we were not protecting the open sea. Now we have a legal framework to do so.

Where do we still have a lot of work to do? The issue of PFAS, which is fundamental and which is also a public health issue, you mentioned it, but which is actually broader than everything we say, and the question of plastic, I will come back to it. France, thanks to collective action, really from associations, local authorities, all of us, has been at the forefront of starting to move away from single-use plastics. We were one of the first countries in the world, if not the first, to impose that in fast food, we no longer have disposable plastic, to impose it. What did I not hear at the time? Well, we did it. And we started to move away from single-use plastics. We started to move towards recycling. I believe a lot in working with local authorities and succeeding in improving things. Now, we must fight for a framework, which is the plastic treaty, which failed last summer. And there, we have relaunched it precisely with some discussions. For me, the priority for the coming year is that we set a framework to indeed engage key countries in the fight against plastic as we did, to do it at least at the scale of the Mediterranean if we cannot achieve an international treaty. And so we have, there too, made progress in recent years, not enough yet, we must relaunch the fight. But France has been at the forefront of protection, and that, for decades, of its space. Now, we must continue, plastic, PFAS, particles, to truly ensure that air quality, the quality of our water, and the preservation of biodiversity and our spaces continue to improve.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Among the actors of climate change, we always tend to mention coal-fired power plants, cars, planes, factories, and also the servers that are used to collect and store the billions of pieces of information that circulate every day. As for coal, you mentioned it, cars, etc., we are trying to engage actions to correct the course, and as for servers, I feel like we are heading towards a runaway situation that will be further increased with artificial intelligence. What could be the solution on this issue since more and more we are storing and circulating information? Could we perhaps also, at the European level, by default, impose that all information that circulates be ephemeral for a day, a week, and that it disappears by itself? This would prevent it from being propagated, re-propagated, and recollected some time later.

On all subjects, whether it is emails on WhatsApp, on Facebook. Why not, by default, have ephemeral information that disappears by itself? And if we really want to save something that is very interesting, we take the action to save it. Whereas today, by default, it remains ad vitam æternam, it takes up space, and servers are only becoming more saturated.

Thank you. So perhaps for the clarity of the debates, and for the younger ones, let me try to explain how it works. In fact, we consume energy all the time for heating, for transportation, and indeed, we consume for digital services, because you consume when you perform actions, that is to say, every time you watch a video, send an email, click, or send a message on X, and we also consume for artificial intelligence and these large calculators. I will come back to that.

So all of this is our energy usage. If we want to succeed in the battle against climate change, we must do several things, and that is the strategy we have defined, which is based entirely on science, which is the result of a report from the International Energy Agency and our regulator called RTE, our network agent, based on our needs and others. 1) We must reduce, save energy wherever we can, through demand response, that is to say, installing sensors, having smart apartments or smart homes, and successfully implementing energy demand response. The best energy, the least costly, is the energy we do not use. That’s a bit of your idea. I will come back to that. 2) It is to electrify our practices. That is to say, as soon as we consume energy, the more we move towards electric, the more we reduce the use of energies that are actually much more polluting than our electricity. And 3) It is to improve what we call the energy mix, that is to say, how we produce electricity, based on what? We are fortunate in France, it is nuclear energy, which means that when we use 100 units of electricity, 75 come from nuclear, and the rest from renewable sources, etc., and very marginally from thermal sources. And we will completely close our thermal power plants by 2027. So we have a mix that is very low in carbon in France. And that is a blessing.

So what are we going to continue to do? Try to consume less energy wherever we can by being smart, electrifying our practices, that is everything we are doing, urban transport, we will increasingly move towards public transport, but also towards the electrification of these to move away from fossil fuels, and then continue to reduce thermal energy to have electricity produced with 100% nuclear and renewable sources. That is the right strategy. So that is what we will continue to do. In this context, we have a problem of digital sovereignty that was well pointed out earlier.

In reality, today, our problem is that we do not have enough servers and calculators on our territory, and therefore our computing capacities, we Europeans, have delegated them to the Americans and others. That is not great either. And having your data held at the other end of the United States or elsewhere is not very reassuring, I tell you as I think, because at some point, if they decide to change the rules or if they say: hey, your health data stored on the other side of the world, I will decide to sell it to a service provider or an insurer, I am not sure I could completely block that. So, our digital sovereignty requires us to have more computing and storage capacity at home. So, it is a bad idea to go backward. Now, how should we do it?

We must succeed in having more frugal practices in terms of digital usage. And so, you are right. First, we all, as citizens, need to realize that every time we are on social networks, clicking, sending a message, an email, it has an energy cost. 2) Having good practices, and that is rather for providers and in contracts, to limit the required storage. And some providers are indeed going in the direction you are talking about, and we have innovations that allow for what you are saying and that have started to be implemented. And 3) We need to move towards more frugal models of artificial intelligence. And that is indeed the strength of Mistral that I mentioned earlier compared to others. Mistral is a model, to put it simply, that, to achieve the same result, does a bit less computing than others because it tries to target better. And so, it is less demanding in computing capacity to achieve the same result as one of its American competitors. Because it was, as we started a bit later, we are trying to be smarter.

This frugality of artificial intelligence needs to be valued. And we must value it as citizens because we can achieve climate transition by making technological and digital transitions. We just need to, as everywhere, try to find the right balance. So, I think we should not reduce our storage capacities and our service capacities because we need them for our sovereignty, but we must, through innovation, reduce unnecessary storage, reduce totally unnecessary data storage, you are right, promote ephemeral practices when they are accepted, agreed upon, and when we have the right innovation technique, and have more frugal models. That is what we are working towards.

Moderator

The third theme, then, is a relatively important theme. And in particular, there are many young people who are all ears, who will listen to you as we will talk about social networks and their impact on our youth. So, to set the scene, I will ask Camille Da Silva. She is a journalist, she is the head of Dimanche Ouest-France and she is a member of the Media Education network. Camille, we are listening to you and then we will give the floor to the readers.

Camille DA SILVA

How can we talk about one without mentioning the other? They have almost grown up together. On one side, TikTok, Instagram, X, all these applications that make up our social networks. On the other, there are the young people, a population too vast, too heterogeneous to be contained in a single term. But let us at least agree on the fact that these young people are partly minors, that they are therefore the citizens of tomorrow, which makes them a sensitive audience, as they are still developing. While preparing this text, reflecting on all these young people I can meet in my work who are getting phones in their hands at an increasingly early age, an image came to me, that of a teenager who has been placed in a Formula 1 car even though he has never driven. Because that is what digital technology is today: speed, a highway of possibilities, but also the risk of a crash if we lose control.

So, in saying this, I do not mean to simply point fingers at social networks. I am actually the first to use them, like you, Mr. President. I know they can be wonderful, create connections, succeed where we have long failed. I think, for example, of the #MeToo movement, born from a liberation of speech behind screens, which ultimately succeeded in changing the law in favor of women.

Social networks have this incredible power to transform reality. But like many other powers, it stirs up interests. There was a utopia at the foundation of the Internet, that of a great library of knowledge managed by the people, for the people, far from the rigidity of institutions. But what about in the age of capitalism, with these giants who monetize the available brain time of the most vulnerable, armed with addictive algorithms, with these young people who, without even realizing it, have become products, sometimes even to the detriment of their health, with these platforms where reason is eclipsed by emotion, where violence, radicalism, or misinformation are rampant, as they generate more clicks? Is this what we hope for future citizens? Is this what we want for the society of tomorrow?

In light of these reflections, Mr. President, you recently announced the ban on phones in middle schools. Some go further, like Australia, by banning social networks for those under 16. But is there not another way? What about education on social networks? What public policy to promote verified information and develop critical thinking? Because there are barriers, they are already there, I see at least three: family, school, media.

But all are quite helpless, as they are left alone in the face of tools that surpass them, rules of the game established without them, and funding that is not commensurate with the stakes. Our readers will now be able to ask you their questions about young people and social networks, Mr. President.

I hope, for my part, that we will answer these: Are we finally going to help this teenager who has been placed in a Formula 1 car and who has already started the engine? Are we going to give him the tools and equipment necessary to win this race that seemed lost from the start? Thank you.

Moderator

Mr. President, we will give you the floor in a moment. You will obviously be able to respond to the many comments that have been made. But before that, to open this sequence, I wanted us to hear the testimony of a mother named Emmanuelle Pouédras. So Emmanuelle, where are you? Here we go, we will give you a microphone. It seemed particularly important to us to hear this testimony, as it perfectly highlights the danger of social networks on our youth. Emmanuelle, we are listening to you.

Emmanuelle POUÉDRAS

I will try. First of all, I start by saying: Thank you, Ouest-France, for inviting me. I received the invitation yesterday at 4 PM. I crossed Brittany and I am here. There are many young people, that’s great. I am, indeed, Emmanuelle, I live in Lorient. And Mr. President, you know, my 15-year-old son took his own life. He jumped off a 14-meter bridge the week of the school year, in 2024. The investigation, finally, an investigation, I don’t know, since there was no requisition on his phone. They returned the phone to us saying: sorry, it is locked, we can’t do anything.

But as I am a mother, as I fought to be a family, as perhaps many of you and perhaps others tomorrow, I said: I cannot stay like this. And so, I conducted my investigation, not through his phone, but through other elements. And I discovered the unthinkable.

My son was being cyberbullied by classmates who, during the day, everything went well. And then, in their rooms, they insulted him, called him “big shit,” launched polls to know his sexual orientation. They insulted him by calling him “Gabriel Attal.” And when I discovered all this, it may still show a bit, it caused facial paralysis from the shock. And then, by chance, in the course of an email, from his email box, what do I discover? While we had banned it, we had said because I am aware of the subject, social networks were not okay in our house, we talk about it beforehand. And there, I discover that he has TikTok. And there, I open the TikTok feed. Because obviously, neither TikTok, nor Instagram, nor all the others, during the 6 months I conducted the investigation, responded positively to my request.

Thanks to the media, thank you media, I carry my fight. We filed a complaint. First investigation, there was none. We filed a complaint. Today, I do not have a receipt from the public prosecutor saying: we have received your complaint. It is important to set the context, because I hear, I follow you, I am the minister, of course, I know that things are being prepared, but now, concretely, what do we do? What do we do for these thousands of cyberbullying cases that are stuck in the prosecutor's office, here and there? What do we do for these families who need help? They know the 3018. How is it possible that I am asked, while I am grieving, how is it possible that I have to conduct the investigation? How can we investigate the death of a 15-year-old child without making requisitions on his phone? I ask you, Mr. President, what are you going to do to ensure that all these cases stop and that, finally, they are treated?

The question of age, 15 years, not 15 years, I don’t know. The media ask me the question. At 20, one can be immature and be in danger and be fragile. At 14, one can clearly have the critical capacity to say: this is social media, I am not going to go there or I am not going to believe it. My son thought he was having fun on social networks. The state did nothing. It has been 10 years, I don’t remember exactly, that we have social networks. The state has not protected a whole generation.

I wrote to you to meet you because I have a lot to say, I come from marketing. So, I left marketing for what you explained, the abuses, I could not be a mother and work in marketing. I need to meet you. My 18-year-old son who will vote in 3 months needs to understand that the state hears him. So, what do we do? What immediate measures are you going to impose regarding the prosecutors, regarding the platforms, so that they finally support grieving families? And then, so that you remember us, I am leaving you a photo of Clément with our contact information.

Yes. First of all, thank you for having the courage to give this testimony because you have spoken for unfortunately many families and mothers who have experienced this tragedy. So, thank you to you. We will talk afterwards, and I do not want to discuss a particular investigation or a procedure as you have described here in public and elsewhere. In any case, it seems that there are aberrant elements, and so we will look with you at all the state services that are involved so that indeed, things can be clarified and that you have, of course, answers to all of this.

So you have my commitment on that, and we will see each other right after. Then, we have a justice system, independent of your case, if I may say so, but which is very mobilized on this subject. We have now criminally qualified cyberbullying, finally, the law in recent years, if I may say, unfortunately, because it was a bit of a hidden continent. Ten years ago, harassment existed, but we did not talk about it.

In recent years, we have taken up this subject because it has also come to light. It has also come to light, in part, thanks to social networks. You mentioned, Madam, earlier, the equality between women and men that has been relayed by social networks. It is also true for harassment. This is why, since the beginning of our debate, we must not be simplistic when we talk about social networks. There is the best and the worst. But harassment is a continent that was hidden, which has been revealed. In the face of this, we have mobilized.

First, we have trained the pHARe programs, the teachers; now, in our middle schools, in our high schools, in our schools, we have teachers, we have a teaching community that is much more trained, that is vigilant. We must now improve the dialogue with parents because it is in every detail that we must track things.

We are also training our young people, I speak under the authority of Madam the Rector, but who must indeed be part of this community of vigilance, in order not to leave others in this worst behavior, which is to insult a student. And there is the famous 3018 that you mentioned, which we have now generalized, which allows us to fight against harassment and cyberbullying. Because what we often see, it seems that it is different for your son, but it is that school harassment continues through networks, through WhatsApp groups… That is often the case. And so, apparently, for him, it was constant cyberbullying, but that was not the physical case.

But we have created the instruments to try to do this. Now, what do we need to do behind this? It is to implement the texts that we have also voted on, because on this subject, we have voted on the texts. A child who harasses is the one we exclude from school; it is no longer the child who is harassed who must leave. We have created a responsibility for the child and the parents who harass, and we have also created a responsibility on the platforms, which means that today, under French law, a child who harasses can be banned from social networks and expelled. Now, something has happened that we need to clarify for your son, but all this to say that there are many things that have changed, but it is a vigilance of every moment, and it is individual cases, and each time it is terrible distress. And this fight against harassment and cyberbullying, we will not give up anything.

And so we will see each other afterwards, I promise you, for the fight for your son and your fight for you and your family. Thank you. I would like to respond very directly, in essence, to the question you asked by taking up your metaphor. My child, if he is in a Formula 1 car and turns on the ignition, I do not want him to win the race; I just want him to get out of the car. I will be very straightforward with you; I just want him to get out of the car. I want to first teach him the code, make sure the car works, teach him to drive another car, and then, when he is of age and has understood how it works, he can access it. But I will not allow him to succeed in the race. So, you understand in which direction we are going. Essentially, what has happened in the last 10 years? And I say, all the countries in the world that have social networks have faced the same thing.

We, adults, have been in the same situation; we have all used social networks. You said it, you as a journalist, me as President, you as a candidate, you all do it as citizens. And then, it is a technological innovation; we have seen all this; it is an opportunity. Essentially, we have become a society, we must also say things, where there has been this growing pressure: first, to occupy our children, because it starts there. It starts with screens before social networks. Take a train; a child makes noise, all eyes turn to the parents; there is no need to speak to beg the parents to quickly give him a screen to stop making noise. In fact, we now know that it is bad. The first thing, I take in order, we know today because it has been scientifically established; there was a commission that reported to us a year ago, screens before 3 years old are a disaster. It is a disaster for emotional and cognitive development, so screens should not be introduced. It should be limited as much as possible before the age of 6, even if it is to occupy.

We must relearn to live with our children in society, to let them make noise: it is us who must adapt. That is how it is. And it is up to parents to raise them well. It cannot be the screen as a distraction all the time; it must be limited as much as possible before 6 years old. The screen must be proportionate in its use in teaching methods. I would say that France has been quite cautious: we have never gone to full-screen like the Scandinavians. The Scandinavians, who did it, are now going back. We know that; it is what we will apply, what we have already started to apply, and that the messages to families should be super clear about what we know, because it is scientifically proven. There, it is the same way. I used the same method, that is to say, we took scientists to build a consensus. Until a few months ago, there was no absolute consensus on this. There were, moreover, many disagreements among specialists. All this has consolidated.

Then, there is the phone. You mentioned it. In fact, we have conducted experiments since 2017 in our schools and colleges, and we have, since this school year, generalized the absence of mobile phones in middle schools. That is to say, from the bell to the bell, if I may say, the phone is in the backpack turned off or in a locker. Everyone has the organization they want, but there is no longer any mobile phone in middle school. Our intention, with the Minister of National Education, is to do the same in high school next school year. Why? Because we know that it terribly disrupts attention, creates disorder in class, and de-socializes during recess. There are only negative effects, and it does not allow teachers to do their job well, nor students to interact with each other as they should, and it disrupts many things. On the phone, we will go to the end of this fight. The first feedback is very good, and the countries that have done as we have received very good feedback. I assure you, it is a good thing for you. Even if it brings constraints, it does not mean absence of mobile phones, because I see protests in the looks of the audience interested in this. It means that when you are at school, in middle school, in high school, the phone is turned off and in the backpack. When you go out, you can call your parents, etc.

The third step is the question of social networks, your famous Formula 1. For me, there have been two stages. 2015 is the moment when it spreads very widely. And we let things happen, all of us. There was a terrible acceleration in 2020 during the Covid period, where, not just for our young people, but for all of us, the average screen time increased significantly. This means that today, the average screen time for a young person is 4 hours and 20 minutes per day. Now, you may have some who say, it will be zero for me. There may be some who will tell me, "I spend 2 hours a day." I have encountered in debates, meetings I have had with middle school students, young people who confessed to me that they spent 6 hours a day on a mobile phone.

You are right about school, the media, the family, your triptych. I completely agree. First of all, it is not fair because there are young people who have an organized family that will be there, that will be vigilant, but you have families that are less well-equipped, you have families to whom we have given no advice, and then there are children who live with single mothers, and then there are children who live in broken families. So, if we delegate this to the family, it is not fair because we are sending it back to different models. And then, we have not given the families any rules of the game. We have not said, it is good, it is not good. The school is doing its best: we have put in media education courses and others. But what do you want to fight against 4 hours and 20 minutes of exposure per day? You can say, I will add already overloaded programs, an hour of civic education or media education per week or every two weeks. You have no chance of fighting against an average of 4 hours and 20 minutes of exposure per day. It is far too much.

We can see that, essentially, the first thing that has been found is the accelerator pedal on your Formula 1. It is very, very hard to relearn the code and all that. In fact, we now know how to measure things. That is why many scientists were not in agreement until recently, because there are no perfectly scientifically measured causal elements. We have had sociologists, psychiatrists, cognitive specialists work on this. Now we have super clear correlations that have been made by the Screen Commission, which were made last year by Mr. HAIDT, a scientist you may have read, "Anxious Generation," this book he published about our young people. He has made many correlations, studies that have been done recently again with PISA, by the OECD. The more we increase screen time, the more educational performance drops. It is terrible. The more we increase screen time, the more mental health problems increase. Over the past 10 years, we have seen, as social networks have spread among our young people, an epidemic of malaise, mental health problems, an epidemic of behavioral disorders, particularly among young girls. Why? Because social networks have spread standards that create shame about one's own body, complexes.

We now have a huge problem with relationships and gender equality. You rightly said that social networks have allowed the emergence and dissemination of MeToo. At the same time, social networks among our young people mean that most of our young people access an image of women first through pornographic content on social networks, thus an extremely degrading approach to the other sex. You have, essentially, everything we do not want, to which we have overexposed our children through social networks, and it is clear that all these correlations show that social networks have not allowed for the best. Therefore, for the good emotional, human, and cognitive development of our children, we cannot leave them to social networks.

And we cannot regulate, especially if we do not send a clear message to families. If we do not prepare to, first, give certainties, then have a critical mind. That is why the consensus is being forged; Australia has just done it. What we want to do is at 15 or 16 years old. That is what we need to refine because it is clearly the age at which there is emotional maturity, where the brain reaches a level of maturity. Before that age, to say: we should not be able to access social networks. Because, in fact, we are not ready. Moreover, what we have experienced, my generation, that of many who are in this room too, and I say this for our younger ones, because we are not ready, and because, in fact, we need to send this message to young people: there must be a prohibition because that will allow families to have a guide, a rule, and to adapt, for our young people to understand, because if we do it in a more subtle way, it will never work, because there will always be social pressure. "My friend has it; how can you prevent me in our family?" "I am cut off from the world."

So, how are we going to do this? That's why it took us a little time. First, we fought at the European level, because age verification can only be done at the European level; it is a European competence. Sorry, it's a bit technical. But that's how it is because we decided to regulate our networks at the European level, because we are a common space, and that's how we are strong. We obtained from the Commission last summer that we could impose age verification on our social networks, a great step forward. We knew it worked technically, sorry for the comparison, because we had done it for pornographic sites. We had this problem for years; we had minors going to pornographic sites. We imposed age verification on these sites so that only adults could access them, using proven techniques that work, it functions. They are not happy, but it works. We can use this technique for social networks. Countries must define digital adulthood. So what we want to do in the coming weeks, but this also goes through these debates, because the collective consciousness needs to be strengthened, because it works if everyone understands what is happening, is to say: we will impose age verification on all social networks, and we will define this age at 15 or 16 years. To say, below this age, there can be no access to social networks. This is the only way to protect.

In parallel to that, what do we need to do? Strengthen our schools, teacher training, and schools, first to transmit knowledge. Before critical thinking, the role of the school is to transmit, I would say, certainties and knowledge. If there is no knowledge, there can be no critical thinking, and then we cannot be confronted with everything and anything. So, we need to do it in the right order. Before learning Cartesian cogito, we learned that 2 plus 2 equals 4 before moving on. So, we must start from knowledge. The school must transmit fundamental knowledge and solidify it well. It must teach students to reflect on media and social networks from a certain age, strengthen critical thinking, and prepare our young people so that at the age of 15 - 16, with the support of families, they can go on these networks. In the meantime, we also want to improve them; that's the whole discussion we are having elsewhere, so that they are prepared on these social networks and that we have solidified our rules.

I believe this is the best way to draw the consequences of a scientific consensus and what we have collectively learned in recent years. I consider this battle to be absolutely fundamental. Essentially, we are going to get out of the fast car a bit and learn about other cars that go slower; we will learn the rules of the road, to continue your metaphor, and we will protect our children in this phase because we are now sure that indeed, Formula 1 goes very, very fast and that there are accidents we must be able to avoid. Many will tell me: "Okay, but it won't work; there are people who will escape it." First, if there is real age verification for all social networks, no, there is a rule. Then, if families want their children to escape by giving them access to social networks, I want to say that they will take their responsibilities, but I will make a simple comparison, that of alcohol. We have prohibited alcohol for minors in our country. Decades ago, it was not prohibited. In fact, there were families that gave it to their children. We said, science tells us that it is bad for public health, we prohibit it. There may still be families that give alcohol to 10-year-olds. Finally, you will agree with me that this is not the majority of people, because everyone has understood that it is not good. What we need to do is send a message to all families and all young people: before 15 - 16 years, it is not good. That's how we are going to do it.

Host

Welcome. I will introduce you in a few words. You are a member of the parents' association of a middle school, the Val de Rance middle school in Plouër-sur-Rance. Within this association, you work to delay the age of smartphone ownership and to limit its use by children and middle school students. You are working, in particular, with a website called "Débranchons-les." You have a question that somewhat relates to the President's earlier remarks.

Speaker

Thank you for coming to us. Our group of parent collectives wishes, in relation to what you just said, to reverse the norm that is currently to equip children earlier and earlier without necessarily having controls or learning with it. To reduce social pressure so that parents do not feel compelled, in order not to isolate their children, to give them a smartphone if they have not decided to do so, and thus to protect our children. Mr. President, you have regularly taken a stand recently on the dangers of social networks for youth. Yet, they remain omnipresent since they are constantly in their pockets via their smartphones.

My question is, with a year and a half left in your term, would you be willing to make a commitment today in front of us to have a courageous and useful law voted on by the next presidential election, and even before, to effectively protect our children from the dangers of social networks? We are legitimately questioning, as parents, the timing. We have countries like Australia that have implemented this, effective from today. Regarding the law we were asking if you were ready to make this commitment, what would it be and with what budget? I am thinking in particular of schools that lack the budget to meet these obligations of prohibiting smartphone ownership in schools, there you go. As you said earlier, we have enough scientific hindsight today. Families are living through tragedies. We need to act. It is becoming really urgent, and it was already urgent before.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Madam, and thank you for your commitment as a parent. I will say a word about it. First, we have all learned together in recent years, and we have not done nothing, I try to remind you. We have passed texts against harassment and cyberbullying. We have experimented with and generalized the ban on phones in middle schools; that has been done, and we want to do it now for high schools. We have also passed texts on parental control for the purchase of phones, as you know, which was an initiative of parliamentarians a few years ago. On the prohibition of social networks, it is a debate I have taken up since 2022. We launched this commission that was entrusted to Mr. Bronner, then the Screen Commission. It delivered its work a year and a half ago, with, by the way, disagreements on points where we refined things, but above all where we had to move Europe to be able to do this control, this age verification. Otherwise, we could not pass any text; we did not have a way to verify if you were 15, 16, 17, or 18 years old. We got that last summer. So, we are not behind. I would even say that in Europe, we are among the most advanced with the Danes. We are the ones who are going to do it. Australia, as you just said, is in the process of doing it. France is among the countries that are at the forefront on this issue.

The goal is to submit a government bill at the beginning of next year and to have it voted on as soon as possible. I can very easily commit that it will be voted on before the end of this term because that is what I want to do, and I think it is a matter of educational responsibility and public health. However, a law does not do everything. I wanted to emphasize one point, the importance, beyond teachers, of parents and associations of popular education, of all those who, alongside the educational community, play this role. We also need all of you to be engaged. The law must set a standard, and the state must take its responsibilities to help you. After that, we need the commitment of everyone. Regarding equipment, to be honest, it is not something costly. We have done it for middle schools. Well, it depends on the departments for middle schools and the regions for high schools. These are debates that the government has with one another. Objectively, these are not extremely large amounts, and it is also organizational questions. There are, by the way, in other countries, countries that have started to impose bans. Do we need lockers everywhere? There is also the idea that you turn it off, you put it in the backpack. So it is not necessarily a huge cost. I do not think it is an element that will block us. These are debates that will then be with the departments and regions, but there will be the necessary support. This is really not the main issue.

There are two points that need to be debated. I mention them here for us to think collectively. I do not have the answer, and I have also asked for a consultation. What do we do with messaging services that have AI agents? A real issue, to name just one, META. Today, WhatsApp is a messaging service; it is not a social network. Nevertheless, now there is a conversational AI agent. Many young people are starting to exchange. Is it as dangerous as Formula 1? In any case, it can also go fast. It is a real issue that we need to address. This was raised with me by parents and movements in popular education. That is why I am thinking of this as I see you. But it is a real issue since we must also prohibit it because it is not simply a messaging service. The second thing is also all the online systems that go with video games. Video games are one thing. But you have online communities that sometimes form very, very young. Here too, it is a real question that arises regarding everything we are discussing about attention, the relationship to screens, and the relationship to virtual communities. There you go. I put it out there; it is a debate that is not yet settled. But thank you very much for your commitment and your question. The answer is therefore, without ambiguity, yes, and starting in January.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President of the Republic. Given what you said earlier, why not impose a digital curfew rather than a ban for those under 15 or 16 years old?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, we would be returning to memories we do not want to relive. We agree. Those famous curfews were, by the way, rather great digital openings. First, because the issue we are raising for children and adolescents does not only arise at night. Nevertheless, you are right; one of the problems we have, beyond all those I have mentioned, is that many young people actually have sleep problems because they stay up very late on their phones. There are curfew systems that already exist; there is no need for the law or for me to do it. Well, some have radical practices, like unplugging the Wi-Fi, but by configuring the phone, there are many parents who do it and know how to do parental control. So that already exists.

In reality, what we are saying here is that even if we said, we need to stop at 10 p.m., 9 p.m., or 8 p.m., X hours a day, it is not good before a certain age. It creates exposure to a lot of content that we have a lot of trouble regulating, at least that we do not know how to regulate today. I say this after years of trying curfews because these are practices we have encouraged; we have supported this, we have put, as I said, parental control on phones, we have encouraged counter-curfews. I have held, I think, about ten meetings at my level with the heads of these platforms to help me regulate content for young people and adolescents. The reality is that for a few years, they improved a bit, and then they completely dropped the ball and did not even moderate this content. So, I completely understand your point, but I sincerely say it is not enough. I know it does not please you, but I think that before 15 years, 16 years, it is really not a good thing. It is not just a question of curfew.

My dream is that there be time for sports and time for reading. Because what we are witnessing at the same time in our societies, among the younger generation, but not only among the younger generation, is a very concerning decline in reading. This allows me to make just a small remark to say that it is not just a problem late at night, but that all those who are addicted to social media are reading less and less. As a result, it develops our abilities to concentrate, much less than before, our abilities to access complex reasoning, and thus to confront scientific reasoning that can enlighten us, which are currently declining. Our abilities to concentrate at work and to evolve and to be fully formed citizens are also affected. Therefore, the mental training that comes from being exposed very early to social media, with the scrolling that goes with it, meaning rapid content, leads to a collapse in reading among young people, and even in the films that are watched, because we get used to formats that are very short.

I think we need to slow all this down a bit, for everyone, but especially for the younger generation, to give time back to reading, which is the most wonderful thing, to be free, to know, to feel, to escape from loneliness. Social media sends you back to your solitude, because in fact, you see a lot of things, you are excited, but you are always alone behind your screen. Reading allows you to feel, first to understand landscapes, stories, this sharing with others. It is the escape from solitude, reading, because it opens you up to the imaginary and to someone else who will feel, who will put words to what you feel, which is one of the most beautiful human experiences. So, at the same time, everything we are saying here may seem like a prohibition simply, it is a wonderful liberation of useful time for reading and for doing sports. It is a wonderful reopening to regain a bit of control over your lives, your emotions, and your brains, which, otherwise, are left to others. So, the curfew is not enough.

Host

Let me introduce you in a few words. Mother of three children, the eldest is 10 years old. You say that social media and algorithms raise many questions for you regarding the impact they will have on their ability to express their identity, their intelligence, and their free will. I specify that you are a self-employed entrepreneur in the digital field. So you are at the forefront of witnessing this limitless and rule-free evolution.

Speaker

Thank you very much. This debate is really extremely interesting. I am happy to be part of it. My question concerns social cohesion. It also touches on democracy, on what makes us a distinct people governed by common values. I wonder how we can continue to be a society when social media, algorithms, which are notably American, even Chinese, promote not the values that govern us as the French Republic, but rather sensationalism, polarization, and communitarianism. So, what can France put in place to ensure that we remain united as the French people, especially the youth, around common values?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Madam, for this question. So, it is a bit the underlying theme of everything we have been discussing for a while, and you are absolutely right. First, just as I said earlier that social media are not made to inform us, explaining the economic model. Structurally, social media tend to lean towards extremes and the fracturing of society, for several reasons. First, because, as I said, they are models of excitement. And so, in the order of merit, emotion is superior to argumentation and reason, and negative emotion is superior to positive emotion. This means that, structurally, those you will hear more, who will be the most exposed, are those who will push these negative emotions, even if they are not in the majority. So they pull towards the extremes, they are not a factor of consensus. And fundamentally, the infrastructure of social media is somewhat anti-deliberative. In this room where we look at each other, we take the time to listen and exchange, we have a structure that is deliberative. That is to say, we look at each other. I can see if you agree, disagree, roughly, there are things... We can see it in the face. So we will try to convince, we will listen to each other. But mechanically, unless — sometimes, there are always people who are totally refractory — but you will create, through a debate in a room, it is true in a municipal council room, it is how we created democracy in the Athenian agora, you will create consensus through discussion. Sometimes, you will notice your disagreements, but you will not all immediately shout at each other in invective.

Social media is as if we all entered with hoods and we all shout at each other in invective, and it is the one who says the most horrible things who wins in the end because there are others who follow him more saying, that one is motivated. It is a bit structured like that. So it goes to the extremes, it diffracts. It is not good. So structurally, it is favorable to the extremes and it prevents the deliberation that goes with democracy. The second thing is that it instills distrust through everything we have said so far, because it creates an informational universe where it is very hard to distinguish the true from the false. And AI, artificial intelligence, sorry, adds to this confusion. That is also why we must regulate it, we must know when it is content from artificial intelligence.

And where, in a democratic society, it is very good to have doubt, because doubt nourishes the mind, nourishes critical thinking, allows for reflection, if you enter into a permanent distrust, it becomes a problem, because you no longer trust anything. And there is no longer a foundation. You no longer even trust scientific discourse, you no longer trust any form of authority that allows for living together. It is the debate we had on climate. And by the way, at the same time that people are increasingly informing themselves on the Internet, we have not mentioned it until now, but the big difference between regional daily press and daily press and social media is that people tend to trust their newspapers, but they are rather distrustful of social media, even if they go there a lot. They do not trust. And so social media creates a society of distrust, it removes the common ground.

And then the third thing is that it traps us in cognitive bubbles. What does that mean? It means that you tend to follow people who think a bit like you, and the people who follow you are generally people who think like you, who find that what you say is nice. And so, in fact, it puts us in a permanent bias, which is that we end up over-informing or over-communicating with people who already agree with us. And this is not a real debate like in this room, it is not a debate like in the street, it is not a debate like in a café, it is not a debate like in civic life, because we are in a bubble. And these cognitive bubbles, by the way, also elevate those who are the most radical, who are generally the most followed.

This is what we observe in social media, it is exactly how they function. And so you can see that it rather destroys the common ground. And so, in the process of regaining control over our lives, our democracy, the key for a nation like ours, but it is true for all nations, is how we restore the common ground, which is not unanimity of the common, it is to say: we have differences, we have disagreements, we do not think the same things, but we have good reasons to live together and to be a nation.

The first is to support families in their educational role, and therefore to give them clear rules, as I said, regarding screens, social media, to protect their children and help our families do this work that is theirs. Then, it is to strengthen our school in its role of instruction. The school cannot do everything, it cannot substitute for our families, it instructs. But it is fundamental, and it was the word of Buisson, Ferdinand, that the school transmits knowledge, critical thinking, but it makes Republicans. And so the role of the school in transmitting this common ground is key. And that is also why we are currently reinvesting in the training of teachers and that the role of the school, its character, is a daily struggle to which we must not yield anything. The third is to strengthen, and this, at all ages, critical thinking, in school, but also throughout life, and there, to reinvest it, because it is what allows for the establishment of common ground, paradoxically. And the fourth is to defend the values of our Republic, and therefore to give it vitality. And that is why I also thank you and thank the PQR and today Ouest-France, because these debates allow for the creation of common ground. And so, what are the bodies that structure on the ground? Associations, our elected officials, and especially our mayors, the press, state services, and therefore everything that structures the Republic in its foundations. And so this foundation, we must revitalize it. And so the good solution is also to bring back proximity and deliberation into our lives. And I think that in the coming months, what we must do to support this movement and restore common ground is also that. The municipal elections will also be an opportunity to do this, I would say, in real terms and in vivo. Here are some of the points regarding what is not going well and what we must continue to try to do, what needs to be consolidated.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. I would like to revisit the topic of the ban on social media for those under 15, particularly regarding the method used to verify users' ages. For example, if there is a use of identity cards, this could raise issues of anonymity, certainly between users, but also between the user and the platforms. Do we want companies like Meta to hold our identity cards in their databases?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Very direct question. There are several methods to do this. There can be the identity card with privacy rules. And so that typically falls into the question we discussed earlier. But in the terms of use, they are not authorized to keep them, it is guaranteed, we can verify it. Nevertheless, there is the selfie. We will also use techniques in Pronote, because it is a national platform that allows for age and identity verification, which does not give your identity number that you know well and that your families know and that can be used for this access. So, there are several different techniques that exist, which are stabilized, which have proven themselves. So 1) there will never be only the identity card. And 2) we have passed texts, particularly this famous GDPR, to protect your personal data, your privacy against these digital giants. And that is part of the digital sovereignties mentioned earlier. It is that we have already passed regulations in Europe that are very contested by these platforms to tell them that you do not have the right to use your identity card if that was the means you took to verify your age. It will not be the only means and you are protected.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President. You recently announced your intention to ban mobile phones in high schools. And yet, this is an exercise that has failed at the prison level. So I wanted to know your action plans. For me, and this is just my opinion, but the phone in the backpack, the phone in the lockers or elsewhere, is just smoke and mirrors. They are clever, the teenagers, much more than we are. Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, we have already implemented parental controls on phone purchases, as you know, by setting rules and so on. After that, the signal we send is that it is not a good idea to have a phone in high school and middle school. So already, we are creating a norm. We need to see what happens. It has been since the start of September that we have been doing this in middle schools. And now, to prepare minds, I said that next September, we will do it in high schools. We are sending a clear message to parents who, I hope, will encourage as many parents as possible not to give their children phones at all.

Nevertheless, I also hear the message from some parents who say: for me, it is useful because he or she takes the bus. I want to know when he leaves school, for organization purposes. And that is respectable and must be heard, even if in other generations, we managed to do without it. But the practice is now there, and there can be a good use of the phone. I simply believe that when a rule is set, it should be applied. First of all, you are right, there are some who are clever, but there are still many who accept the rule and authority. And then, you have teachers, school counselors, and school principals who know how to enforce it. And the feedback we have, because of the inspections by our middle school principal since the start of the school year, is good. That is to say, it is generally respected. If someone takes it out, it is enough to sanction them immediately and inform the parents that they will be sanctioned. We confiscate, we sanction, and there you go, there is an escalation.

So I do not share your pessimism at all, and I will not compare our teenagers to prisoners. I am shocked like you, we are all shocked by what happens in prison. Let's be clear, what happens in prison, why? It is because you have people in visiting rooms, families, relatives, or lawyers who pass phones to others or people who send them. That is also why we are tightening the rules significantly, and today, we have created prisons where we conduct full searches, where we have video surveillance. So, we are tightening the rules, we are adapting. And believe me, we will eradicate this issue. But it is rather in that direction that I want to go rather than in comparison. There you go, I close this parenthesis. In any case, I believe in it. I think it is possible. I think it is feasible. And will it achieve zero risk? No. But it will change the norm. And so it changes the perceptions of families. Today, if we do not say that it should be avoided, families are left alone, teachers are left alone. And so today, we leave a teacher facing their class, until now that has been the case, when a student takes out their phone in class. There, we will say, the rule is clear, it is no. And then we will multiply the checks. So, is the world perfect? No. Should we therefore let our guard down? Never in life. You know, knives have been banned from schools for a long time. A few months ago, we launched a systematic operation to check for knives in front of the school, and I think of a wonderful woman who was there during a check and who, unfortunately, was stabbed and died, but we saw that there were thousands of knives being carried. Does that mean we should give in? No. And so, we need to go see the families, tell them that it is unacceptable, hold our children and teenagers accountable, and stand by the teachers. In any case, such a rule helps teachers do their job, it helps principals, it helps the educational community do its job well. We cannot leave them alone. And it sends a clear message to families. So, I think it goes in the right direction, there you go.

Speaker

I simply believe that the teaching staff is suffering.

Emmanuel MACRON

But I agree with you.

Speaker

They are not there to enforce safety rules.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but the teaching staff asks for clear rules. We are saying the same thing. You are right that there are teachers for whom it is very hard. But if at the national level, we do not say that phones are banned in middle schools, I leave the middle school teacher alone in their classroom. If a student takes out their phone, they say it is not prohibited. There, if at the highest level of the State, we say: "it is prohibited in middle schools and tomorrow in high schools," the teacher is no longer alone because they can rely on a national rule that is supported by the minister, by the rectors, by the entire hierarchy.

What needs to be understood is that our teachers are suffering because society is suffering and that there are today troubles and that they are confronted with difficulties that young people and families are experiencing. But they suffer because sometimes, too often, we do not have clear enough messages and an affirmed authority. They suffer when the rule is not clear, when we do not defend them enough, when we say: "to teach secularism, you must not be bothered, when we reaffirm the authority of the teacher, even when it does not please a certain parent who comes to threaten them at the school exit." So, believe me, in the face of this suffering, a clear rule is protective. And so, what we are saying is good for all teachers in France. And the mobilization today of your minister, of the rectors, of our school principals, of the academic directors, of all that we call the educational community, is to support our teachers on the ground so that they can do their job in the best possible conditions, that is to say, teach the content that is provided in the programs, do it freely, do it while being respected by the students and families. Well, such a rule goes in that direction because it is national and applies to everyone.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President, you said a little while ago that one should not get information from social networks, that it was not the place. I think that if we conduct a broad survey, perhaps more on this side where there are young people or on that side, I think that if we ask them the question: where do you get your information, it will be on social networks. So, we have a real challenge as traditional, official media to ensure that young people prefer to get their information from us, the media, rather than on social networks. This challenge is enormous for us, especially since, as the television channel Novo 19, we have a media regulator, ARCOM, which obviously imposes rules on us regarding respect for diversity, inclusion, and verifying our information and sources. And all these constraints, of course, allow us to have verified information. There is a recent survey by UNESCO in 2024 that says that nearly two-thirds of influencers claim not to verify their sources before sharing them with their audience. That is to say, most young people or people here see unverified information every day. How can we ensure that there is a regulator for these social networks and that we, the media, can also do our job properly? As you said, this job requires time, requires money, and there is a real economic model challenge for the media today, whatever they may be, print media, radio, or audiovisual, since many of our contents are also taken as they are by certain people on social networks, without citing our sources, and taking the information that we have verified ourselves.

And I will come to the last point, which is obviously completely related, which is this famous information label. We are eager to hear from you, Mr. President, since everything has been a little distorted, according to you, to know, should there be an information label so that everyone, when they see content on social networks, since we ourselves use social networks, obviously, should we have an information label that will allow everyone to know that there is journalistic work that has been done behind it and that has been verified? Thank you very much.

Speaker

I was going to suggest that you respond to this question about labels, since it has stirred up the political world a bit.

Emmanuel MACRON

The political sphere.

Speaker

The political sphere, especially the Parisian political sphere. We are listening to you, and then we will give the floor to the readers.

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, my neighbor rightly reminded me to be careful, because I used an acronym earlier when responding to you by saying GDPR. He told me: "I do not know what that is." When I said that we were protecting and that we had taken rules, he is right because we should not use acronyms. At the European level, we have taken rules on social networks. We have, since a while ago, and you opened the ball by mentioning it, a directive on digital services called DSA, Digital Services Act, which regulates, allows for the creation, goes in the direction of what we have been wanting for a while, but which does not go far enough in practice and which we would like to tighten, but which begins to create rules of responsibility and transparency of algorithms. Then, we created a directive on digital markets, the one I also mentioned quickly, DMA, to regulate the actors, there, the market, so that there are not actors that are too big or that engage in predation. And then, there is this famous GDPR that dates from a little before, which is a regulation we adopted at the European level to protect data and privacy.

So, we impose on all those who operate in Europe, and therefore, all the major platforms, all the major networks, including encrypted messaging services, to comply with rules for the protection of privacy and data. So, that is why I could tell you that, for example, they cannot use your identity card without your consent, they cannot store it, etc. That is related to this regulation we adopted at the European level. There you go, I close this parenthesis. It was to correct my mistake from earlier.

On what you said, in fact, you opened the question we discussed at the very beginning when we talked about the municipal elections, about what, fundamentally, the status of information is in this vast world of social networks. Essentially, information existed before social networks, it will exist after, it exists during. The question is how we preserve its status, because we always feel like we are facing information when we are on social networks, and everything gets drowned out. I explained earlier why that was not the right vector, because it is not the right economic model. Nevertheless, you can go through social networks to reach a newspaper. I believe one of you mentioned it earlier. I go on a platform, well, on a social network to reach the site of Ouest-France. Nevertheless, you have to be careful because sometimes, as a result, you give publicity to a social network and you do not give it to Ouest-France by doing that. Because in fact, they are gatekeepers, if I may say so.

The key is that there are people who have decided to take their responsibility, to organize themselves to produce information in democracy. So, that is a special status. It is not an account on any social network. It is not necessarily even a site. It is a newspaper, a press title that can then be digital or paper because it is not contingent on the form or have a channel like yours and that comes from different media will organize, journalists who are professionals, so they have a degree, they generally have a code of ethics that goes with their editorial team, and as it has been said, since the laws we established in the 19th century, the laws of 1881 and afterwards, a responsibility as a publisher. That is a bit the guardian of the temple. Because we had newspapers that existed before all these laws, but these newspapers did not have the same relationship to information because there was no responsibility. And often, they were owned by the wealthiest. That is also why throughout the 19th century, we experienced democratically what it was like to have newspapers that did not have exactly the same relationship to information and truth. So, it is a democratic learning process that we have gone through over time. And then, we improved our rules throughout the 20th century, to even increase the rules in terms of pluralism regarding channels and to increase the rules during the electoral period, with periods of silence that are observed, balance, etc. We created a system where you have professionals, where there is an economic model, where there is a system of responsibility where we ensure pluralism. That is the treasure of free and open information in democracy.

The great risk at the moment is confusion. And so, by reaffirming this, I simply tell you: "not everything has the same value." Therefore, when you consult someone's site, even if they have 500,000 followers, it is not necessarily information. And even if it is not a press title, it is someone who will tell you something. So if it is a scientist, they may give you the fruit of their work. If it is a citizen, they may give you their opinion or the information they have gathered themselves. But that does not have the same value as an information site with an editorial team that has developed a system over time. This distinction is fundamental if we do not want to lose ourselves. And we will first have to, on a democratic level to preserve our elections, likely tighten the texts during electoral periods, because everything we have imposed does not exist in the same way on social networks and digital platforms, and we have seen this in our recent elections. We can also refer back to this, because we have not talked about it, but we have also learned a lot from the elections in Romania or Moldova recently, which have been subject to deep interferences and destabilizations.

The difficulty at the moment is that fake information sites are being created every week. This should not be overlooked. You have people creating something that looks like a newspaper on the Internet, but there are not journalists behind it and so on. So, we need to hunt this down; we need to be careful. In the examples from Romania or Moldova, they rigged the elections by taking over a hundred, even thousands of fake information sites. Therefore, you need to refer to people who have the status of a press title with the responsibilities that accompany it. What we need to do is to consolidate the economic model of these titles, educate about the media, and work on the critical thinking of everyone to distinguish between what these press titles are and the rest of the information.

The question of the label comes into play exactly here. Where it has been distorted, what I said, in a way that I believe is very improper and by ill-intentioned people, is that I never spoke of a state label. Never. I never said that. I even said the opposite. It is not the Government, whatever it may be, that decides whether Ouest France is a newspaper or not. Because if we did that, we would no longer be in a democracy; it would be an authoritarian regime, meaning you would have a Government that can decide on press freedom, on what is good and bad press, never in life. The Government must guarantee, and the judiciary as well, the sincere framework of pluralism, the free circulation of ideas, of all opinions, and the proper functioning of information through which we form a free opinion for elections. On the other hand, I recognized and encouraged an initiative that comes from your profession. It is that your profession, faced with the spirit of confusion that I have been describing, said: "we must be able to distinguish between those who truly do the job of a journalist and those who do not." And so, Reporters Without Borders, which is a non-governmental organization organized by journalists, with people whose job is to certify, has created something like... You know, it’s like Bureau Veritas. They have created an independent certification process saying: "they are doing their job as journalists well, meaning they have professionals in their editorial team, they verify information, they say when they have made mistakes, they provide a right of reply." This does not replace the law. It must not be a law, but they have created this process. I do not know, by the way, if you are certified in this process, but I was reacting because your colleagues from the EBRA group, therefore in the Grand Est, said: "we have this label called 'JTI', for Journalism Trust Initiative, so the initiative for trust in journalism." I was just saying that these are commendable initiatives because they are people who say: "in our case, we respect the ethics of the press," but in no case should it be a state label.

So, regarding the relationship to the press and information or misinformation, we have been circling around this for a while; it is not the state that can decide what needs to clarify the rules to distinguish who is a journalist and who is not? It can only come from initiatives that are your own. It can only come from this dialogue among peers and clarity. It must go through media education and a much stronger critical spirit in society so that you know how to distinguish when you look at pages. And that will take time, but it cannot come through prohibition or through a label. So, you allowed me to clarify what was a real falsehood pushed by many. I never spoke of a state label, and I think that would be the worst solution. Nevertheless, I commend the initiatives that are being taken to distinguish what a press title is, with the responsibilities and professionalism that go with it, and any page that gives opinions, views, or sometimes false information on networks.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President, thank you. So my question, as the other would say, is quickly answered. Since the beginning of the debate, it has allowed for much progress on the subject. So, my question is as follows: social networks are powerful tools for communication and democratization of the information they convey. They have also become echo chambers for misinformation, manipulation, and political interference. Artificial intelligence, by amplifying these phenomena, poses a systematic threat to our democracies, our critical minds, and the future of our generations. However, despite existing legislation, circumventions remain too easy, sanctions too rare or insufficient, and platforms too little responsible. What global strategy do you envision to protect our public space, our informational sovereignty, and especially our citizens, particularly the youngest, against these drifts that undermine living together and trust in our institutions? I specify that I used Chat, Mistral AI to refine this question.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for this beautiful illustration. Thank you for putting it that way. Artificial intelligence can help, but it must not replace. Thank you for promoting Chat. We have talked about it a bit since earlier, but to get straight to the point, as one would say in a large team. Less regional.

First thing, hunt down fake accounts. I believe that the first thing to sanitize this space is to ban fake accounts. We must be sure that behind each account, there is a person. If there is not a person, the platform must guarantee it to us. That is something we need to change. Second thing, create platform responsibility. We started with our directive on services; we started there, the first time, the first sanctions on X. We need to go much further so that when we see that there is platform responsibility for disseminating false information, they can be activated, and thus it costs them dearly so that they are obliged to moderate, regulate, and verify. Third thing, transparency of algorithms. Because in reality, when you go on social networks, you scroll, you travel, which is actually the case for many people who get informed on networks, it is not you who is looking for it. If you go to the site or if you open the Ouest-France newspaper, there are people who have sorted the information, who have prioritized it for you. There, someone is going to prioritize on social networks for you, but you do not know them, you do not know their preferences; it is not transparent. Transparency of algorithms. We will then be able to know what the biases are.

I take a very simple, factual, recent example to show you the danger of this matter. French researchers, working for a start-up we had them work with the Ministry of the Interior, Arlequin, Mr. Micheron, did this work; they create totally neutral accounts on TikTok. They noticed that between the third and fifth content scrolled, when you are a teenager and you create an account, there will be a Salafist content. Because it creates excitement, it pushes things. So, there is a bias; we can see it well; there is a bias in this algorithm; it is not transparent. No fake accounts, platform responsibility, algorithm transparency, and finally critical thinking, educating the population through these debates, and thus hammering, hammering, hammering the fact that those who do the information are called journalists, and that we need editorial teams, press titles to do this work, and that it is not something that is open to everyone, without ethics, without rules, and that it is not the same as reading the very page of someone who has many readers. So educating about this is fundamental. I would say that the last point to achieve this and recreate common ground in this space is to regulate the economic model that comes from one to the other because, in fact, billions of advertisements have been taken away from our press titles, which participated in the model to go on these social networks; we need to be able to rebalance this model to ensure economic viability alongside our titles. There you go.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President. First, I wanted to say that I am very honored to be able to ask you my questions. You said it, social networks are not the place to get informed. Unfortunately, many still do, and information circulates on social networks, and everyone can say what they want without verification. So I will ask you a question that touches on freedom of expression, a fundamental freedom. Can we say that on social networks or elsewhere, we can say whatever we want on social networks or elsewhere in the name of freedom of expression, even lies? And the second question, Mr. President, how can we limit fake news without falling into censorship? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, this is the debate we have been having a bit since earlier, but you are going even more specifically. Essentially, we can see the whole debate that is rising, even internationally. You may have seen that in the United States, they are attacking us on all regulations, saying we are for free speech, meaning freedom of expression.

The gentleman rightly cited earlier the preamble of our Constitution and even what comes from the law of 1789. Our democracy, the Republic, was built on freedom of conscience, but also on freedom of expression. But this freedom is not an absolute freedom. And indeed, none of our freedoms is absolute. Freedom exists only within limits that allow for the respect of others' freedom and a possibility of living together. If I have an absolute freedom that consists of doing anything and that this freedom hinders your freedom, very quickly, we enter into conflict. And that is why the law can frame this freedom within limits that are subject to our constitutional principles.

There is no freedom of expression that is absolute. And indeed, throughout history, we have created it. We have created newspapers, and their freedom of expression is framed. That is to say, if they say something that is false, I have a right of reply that I can request. And even if they say something that harms my interests or defames me, I will pursue them before the judge.

First point, this does not exist on the Internet. It is not true to say that there is freedom of expression on the Internet because there is no responsibility. However, nowhere in real life is there a freedom without responsibility that goes with it. It does not exist; it is not possible. And so, the digital must do exactly as in real life. There is a wonderful freedom of expression. Everyone can express themselves freely on networks. There is a responsibility that must go with it, from the person and from the platform. That is what we have been saying since earlier.

The second thing, and we may not have made the distinction enough since earlier because the questions have not allowed us to do so, but you mentioned, I believe, hurtful content and then false information. There are illegal contents and then there is what we call false information. It is not the same thing. Illegal content is things that are really prohibited. I mentioned it briefly earlier, but for example, racist remarks, anti-Semitic remarks, homophobic remarks; there are things that the law prohibits. We must remove those immediately. And we have the legal basis to do so with a platform called Pharos; we have texts.

We also have for the electoral periods, I will come back to that later, VIGINUM. But we can do that. The problem we have is that the platforms do not cooperate enough. And even when there are illegal contents, they leave them. And we have an enormous difficulty in taking action against them. We have created the right laws at the national level, we have created the right operators. But we have platforms that do not cooperate and we cannot sanction them strongly enough. So what we need to change is to sanction them much more severely for illegal content. Regarding false information, it is not the same nature, because in reality, even if it is a lie, we will prove it through debate. There are several types of lies. There are lies that will harm you and we can clearly see that they will try to harm you, and then there are lies about general things. We need to be able to combat those through critical thinking and dialogue. They do not have the same status. That is through critical thinking, through controversy, through the free circulation of ideas, but nevertheless, there needs to be a system of responsibility comparable to that of the press that is put in place for these platforms and social networks. Otherwise, there is no way to regulate, to create the right incentives for them to remove this false information.

Then, during the electoral period, since you mentioned that, for political life, we have created specific texts to prevent foreign interference. And so we created what is called VIGINUM, which is a state agency that monitors to see if there is interference, that is to say, if there are foreign powers that come to interfere to push these false information that will either harm the country or harm a particular candidate. And at that moment, there is an alert, we make it public, so that everyone can react and to be able to remove this content. We do that, it works.

Nevertheless, the problem we have is that the platforms cooperate far too little and we have a base that is a bit fragile because we look at the general terms of use of these platforms. That is what VIGINUM does. And so it says, this is foreign interference. Here, it says, this is not in accordance with your general terms of use. Therefore, you must remove this content which is obviously a lie. There are networks that cooperate, and there are those that do not cooperate at all. And so that is what we need to strengthen today. So that is why we need to change.

First, we need to toughen our texts, to make greater use of existing texts. That is what we will do with the Minister of Justice through what we call penal circulars to ask prosecutors and judges to take more action. Change European law to toughen this up and allow, precisely, to be much more effective in removing illegal content and better regulating the fight, well, better regulating, precisely, these fake news and creating systems of incentives and responsibility to do so. But that is another system and it is necessarily slower. For the electoral period, we need to succeed in being much more demanding with the platforms so that our democratic life is not distorted by these foreign interferences.

One last point, we created something in the law a few years ago that we will also use much better, which is what we call the electoral summary, which also allows us to bring a case before the judge and to remove certain content when we are in an electoral period. We did it once in 2019. We will ensure to use it better, particularly for municipal elections, because you have outgoing mayors or candidates who sometimes face major informational attacks, terrible false information that is disseminated, which can distort the election. At that point, the judge must be able to immediately remove things, because it completely distorts the election, and do it very quickly. It is under the control of the judge.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President, thank you for giving us the floor. Thank you also to Ouest-France for facilitating these exchanges. My question is quite quick. It has already been mentioned by Clémentin, but it will allow you to go a little further perhaps. Do you think that the European Union will ever be strong enough to significantly regulate the power of social networks, which are one of the spearheads of American and Chinese soft power? And if so, when and under what conditions? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. We have started to say it. We have started, and in reality, we are the only ones doing it. The Americans regulate nothing, the Chinese control everything. And by the way, what shows that it is even a subject, if I may say, of cognitive sovereignty, is that our children and adolescents who are so much on TikTok, the Chinese who created TikTok, do not have the same TikTok at home. They have something that is limited in the number of hours per day and that only provides educational content. So you can see that it is a matter of power. In fact, it is a geopolitical battle.

There is the unity of the nation, the protection of our children, the protection of democracy, but behind everything we are saying here, there is a real geopolitical battle. It is that there are people who have understood that a lot of money could be made from this, mainly the Americans, and some leaders in the United States who decided to leave this thing privatized. And there is an alliance with the international reactionary forces that say: we believe in free speech and fundamentally, they allied themselves and said: you let us make a lot of money and we will push what you want, that is to say we will be anti-climate when you want to be anti-climate and we will push your agenda.

And then, on the other side, you have China which makes it an instrument of power. First, it sees that it is dangerous, so it has banned all American actors in its territory. It created its own, it makes a lot of money abroad with our youth, but at home, it has created educational content. We are in the middle. And as often, it is the whole challenge of Europe, we have seen ourselves too much as a market, but we must be a power. And a power means that we must be much more sovereign. That is the fight I have been leading for eight years for Europe. A more sovereign Europe means a Europe that decides for itself.

So, we do not have the actors, but finally, these actors come to us because we are a very large market. It is a source of power. So we have started to regulate. I will tell you, the test is in the coming months. Because after the reaction that X and the American leaders had after the statements of the American vice president a few months ago in Munich, the battle is launched. They will do everything to bend the Europeans.

I will fight with all my strength so that not only we hold, but that we can go further in the direction we have been discussing for a while. It is a real political battle, in the noble sense of the term, that is to say it is a battle for our convictions, and it is a battle to know whether Europeans want to continue to be sovereign from a cognitive and democratic point of view or whether they want to delegate all that by saying: it is too complicated, to others, the Americans or the Chinese.

I think it would be madness to let it happen, madness. And so as quickly as possible, we must strengthen these rules, that is to say, enforce our directives, ensure that there are massive penalties on actors who do not comply, and implement the fight against fake accounts, the responsibility of networks, and the transparency of algorithms effectively. That is the battle of the coming months and we will not give up. But I believe that Europeans are aware. I think that everything we have launched here, and I will lead, in the coming months, my colleagues to do the same in their countries, we all feel it, even those who have been consuming social networks for years, we feel that something is wrong. And by becoming aware of it, we see that there is an urgency to act. And so I think that this collective awakening is also a way out of the state of minority of Europeans that imposes action and strength now.

Speaker

Thank you. I would like to ask you a question, Mr. President of the Republic. You make comparisons between pornographic sites and social networks, but there is something that exists and allows young people to access pornographic sites called VPN. How are you going to legally prohibit or even punish VPNs regarding pornography, but also regarding social networks since your goal is to ban social networks for those under 15 or 16 years old? I am 14 years old, if I use a VPN, I could use social networks. What is your counter-attack against that? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, you are right. First, and thank you because the comparison you made is the right one. I compared them regarding age verification, but I did not compare them by nature, but it is about age verification. You are absolutely right, it exists.

Why do I think that despite everything, it is a good measure and what can we do to counteract? Until today, we have not provided a guide for parents. So parents, we have not told them: this is good, this is not good, this is prohibited, not prohibited. Now, we have given a guide. So parents will be there to control much better. They will say: there is a norm, it is decided at the national level, it has passed into law, so it is not good for my child. Until now, we were not clear on the subject. That is the first thing that changes. So first, I think there are many teenagers, many children, many parents, who will either cooperate, that is to say, will no longer go there, or will enforce it and they will control.

Then, there are the smarter people, this ties back to the discussion we had earlier, who will say: I found the trick to bypass VPN. That is absolutely true. In the same way, if I make the comparison I was making earlier with alcohol, it is prohibited for minors. There are always people who manage to have an adult friend buy alcohol or tobacco for them. Nevertheless, we have significantly reduced consumption since it has been prohibited. So we will, and we have seen it with pornographic sites, we have significantly reduced it because, after all, the majority do not seek VPNs, it is more complicated, you have to be smarter, etc. So 1) I think it will be super effective, even if there are these bypasses that exist, you are right. 2) We will try to hold the providers accountable to help us in this regard, because they can help us by limiting access to these famous VPNs. When providers encourage VPNs or explain that with them, it will be easier to access, some do it, it is not civic. 3) That is why I am leading the European battle, because you are right, if I do it alone, you can go look for a VPN, because neighboring countries do not do the same thing.

If it is European, it is much more complicated. And so the fight we are going to lead is, I committed myself, at the beginning of the year, the law that is coming, I will submit it in France for it to be voted on very quickly. But in parallel, we will create a coalition of European states, particularly, I would like all the neighboring countries, the others, to follow us and do the same, so that the whole European Union enacts this ban on those under 15-16 years old. And then, there is no longer the possibility to bypass in the same way, there you go. But it is a very good question. Now, there was a question next to me.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President of the French Republic. You say that social networks push us to close in on ourselves. Which is not entirely false. However, social networks like TikTok, for example, can encourage us to read or to engage in sports. Well, that is true. So, is there not a way for our social networks to be, so to speak, cleaned up and to highlight the benefits of our networks, so that the good things from the networks are more prominent for young people?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, regarding reading, the example you took, I would say we could use it to say the opposite. The more time you spend on social networks, the less time you spend reading. And that is rather verified. So I would prefer that it not be on social networks, that you follow the advice of your parents, your friends, your teachers to go look for this or that book and read it. That is much better. I am serious about this because reading, as I said earlier, is very important not only for education but for your own development, for your emancipation, I believe, for individual happiness, but also to create well-educated citizens.

What you are saying is a bit of what we have tried to do in recent years, because we have not done nothing in the face of this. I did not suddenly wake up one day saying that we need to impose a ban. We have been trying for years. Since 2018, I have organized a summit twice a year that we called Tech for Good, pardon the anglicism, but we brought these social networks and technology companies together to discuss how we could improve content, better regulate it, to do things for our children.

The reality is that they do not want to do it. I will not lie to you, I will not beat around the bush, it does not interest them. Because that is not how they make money. And so, by putting maximum pressure on them, we managed to get them to do what we call content moderation, that is to say, to look at whether content was suitable for a child or not, to remove it, to help us fight against cyberbullying. When we checked the number of moderators who spoke French across their entire network, depending on the platforms, it was between three and seven. They were laughing at us. So they want to make money. They are private companies. In reality, given what we know, given the fact that, as you said, they did not want to clean up and separate what is good and what is not good on social networks for you, I would be irresponsible to say: keep going, it’s great, and you will clean up. Maybe there are a few flowers in the middle of the dump, but I prefer that you do not set foot in it. I tell you this sincerely. So they did not play the game.

For years, we gave them this chance, they did not play the game. And it is a bit of a limit, it relates to the questions we have been discussing, that if we had our own networks, we could impose, we could have created our own network with educational content. It is an idea of digital sovereignty. We do not have them yet. So I would be delighted if there were innovators who create companies and a social network suitable for young people with educational content. Maybe that will come and we can encourage and open up. At that point, we will find the way. But today, we do not have an actor as strong as these recent ones, French or European, that provides educational content and where I could say: you can go because there are reading recommendations, intelligent advice, pedagogy, and so on. Today, there are some great things, but there are some terrible things. And we can still say that it is not very good for your personal development, for your balance, for learning, for becoming an adult. There you go.

Moderator

Thank you very much, Mr. President. Unfortunately, I would have liked, and we would all have liked, to listen to you for a long time, but the pressure is too strong and so I must cut you off. In any case, thank you very much. We can applaud you. Thank you for coming. And we will indeed follow the law.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. In any case, thank you for the time you have spent and taken. And I just wanted to tell you that behind all this, there will be decisions, laws, texts, European battles, but all of this is only worth it if we manage to mobilize society. That is to say, everything we have been saying for a while now is also about civic and citizen awareness. And so, there you go, everyone has a role to play. Thank you very much.