In front of the readers of La Provence in Marseille.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

16 December 2025 · Meeting with readers of La Provence · Solidarity Warehouse of the CMA-CGM Foundation, Marseille, France

Context
Macron addressed readers of La Provence at the CMA-CGM Foundation's Solidarity Warehouse in Marseille on December 16, 2025, discussing democracy, media, and disinformation.
Main themes
Democracy and media, social networks and disinformation, media education, foreign interference, regional press and trust, artificial intelligence in journalism, fake news and fact-checking, local information, social solidarity and food aid, CMA Media and La Provence
Duration
~175 min
99th percentile
Words
20,952
99th percentile
Sentences
1,246
99th percentile
Readability
61
89th percentile
Grade
8.9
10th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 36%34%
  • Institutional 24%23%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Technological 11%11%
  • Economic 9%8%
  • Geopolitical 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

1,246 sentences in 199 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good morning. I am delighted to see you here, at the heart of the Solidarity Warehouse of the CMA-CGM Foundation. Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. President of the Republic, I am pleased to see you for this exceptional morning, this exceptional meeting. We will talk about democracy, social networks, media education, and foreign interference. You will see, many questions will be asked of you over the next two hours, which are obviously crucial, which can be followed on our website www.laprovence.com and will also be featured in our editions tomorrow morning. I will now give the floor to Jean-Christophe Tortora, General Director of CMA Media.

Jean-Christophe TORTORA

Mr. President of the Republic, ladies and gentlemen, dear readers of La Provence, first of all, welcome to the Solidarity Warehouse. Ultimately, this is a place that embodies the spirit of Marseille, the Marseille in Grand that is so dear to you, Mr. President of the Republic. But it is also a Marseille with a big heart, a big heart carried by associations and volunteers who, every day, help and connect here, in this territory, providing no less than 10 million meals in 2025, which is double that of last year. I would like to take a few seconds to applaud these associations. So let us applaud these associations that have a big heart. Let us applaud the Restos du Cœur, the French Red Cross, the Secours Catholique, and the grocery association with the SOS group. Of course, I would also like to thank the public authorities, the State that has been involved in this project, and of course thank the CMA-CGM Foundation, chaired by Ms. Tanya Saadé.

So, you will understand, Mr. President, why we chose this place that embodies social innovation in this territory, a place that connects us and a place that will allow us to debate this morning with you on very important subjects: the question of information, the question of social networks. Of course, we will talk about democracy. So you, and I am addressing the readers of La Provence, you have changed a lot. It is difficult to keep up with you every day. Because we try to follow you, both in your new habits and in your new ways of consuming information. For the young group that we are, we are not even 3 years old, the CMA Media group, it is indeed very important for us to listen to you. So, our president Véronique Saadé gives us two missions every day.

The first mission is, of course, to innovate. We have no choice in the media industry but to listen to you, to respond to your needs, to evolve our formats, precisely to be both in local information and in international information. It is a challenge and a daily challenge for us. The second mission is to explain, to demonstrate pedagogy every day, to accompany you between quality information and also fake news.

So, to meet these two challenges, Mr. President of the Republic, it is no coincidence that you chose the daily and regional press to lead this tour of France. Because the regional daily press is at the forefront today of this fight that you are leading. Why? Because first of all, the regional daily press, La Provence, we are the champions of trust. When we survey the French people, it is true that the regional daily press is ahead in terms of trust, and I salute my other colleagues, ahead of television, ahead of national press, ahead of radio. Why? Because the regional daily press is at the heart of the daily lives of the French, is at the heart of the territories, is at the heart of living areas, and this trust is crucial for the fight you are leading, Mr. President.

Of course, I would like to take this opportunity to salute all the work of the teams at La Provence, its General Director Jean-Louis Pelé, its Editorial Director Olivier Biscaye, who, every day, leads this program here, in this territory of Marseille and La Provence. And then, I will make a revelation to you, Mr. President, they are secretly preparing a new formula for La Provence for January 10, which will feature even more proximity and local content. Because you, the readers of La Provence, that is what you are asking us for, to do even more local. Why? Because, deep down, we do not always know what is happening sometimes in other countries, as we have seen in the United States, when there are information deserts, the consequences that this can have for democracy.

Perhaps a word on artificial intelligence, you will talk about it in a moment. Artificial intelligence, for us, is a Pharmakon. It is both a poison and a remedy. A poison because today, it amplifies disinformation with great power, and at the same time, it can also be the remedy because it can help our readers and our journalists to sort, to verify information and to do fact-checking. That is why, at CMA Media, we invest a lot in AI, as you know, through French flagships, whether it is Mistral, or of course, Kyutai, because we invest in technology and in French excellence for the service of readers and for the service of our journalists.

So, you see, information is a daily battle. I would even say, Mr. President, it is a combat sport, information. You who enjoy leading matches, when we know your passion, like all of us, for Olympique de Marseille, we know that a match has two halves. The first half is what you are doing today, with the regional dailies, with the French people, in your dialogue that you initiated a few weeks ago, from Toulouse, a city that is also dear to me, it is what you will continue with the idea of proposals, you will say it later, for the beginning of 2026. Well, here, we propose a second half to you. This second half, after having done this national tour, is to do here a world tour of newspapers around the world. But I will reassure your collaborators, you will not need to travel around the world, because here, on June 1, 2, and 3, we will host the World Congress of Newspapers, 30 years after what was held in 1995, with the presence of President Jacques Chirac. And I really want to thank Rodolphe Saadé who supported us in this candidacy, because it was the means for us, for Europe, for France to host this World Congress, to bring these subjects, Mr. President, to nearly 700 newspapers that will be here, in Marseille, for 3 days, because we know well that all the discussions that will take place this morning are important and you will take measures and decisions for France. But we also need to bring these subjects to the world. And here, Mr. President, on June 1, I hope you will be here for the second half that must take place here in Marseille. I salute the General Director of WAN-IFRA, the World Association of Newspapers, Vincent Peyrègne, who is among us.

There you go, Mr. President, dear readers, you see, in Marseille, we do not lack resources, we have the desire. Thank you all for dedicating your morning to such an important subject. Thank you, Mr. President of the Republic, for leading this fight. We are here, in this fight for information, for the territories, and in service of democracy. Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, thank you for the welcome at your solidarity warehouses and the CMA-CGM Foundation and the La Provence group. Thank you very much to all of you for being here and for taking the time for this exchange. You have framed the debate very well. Ultimately, what interests me is that we can exchange freely and transparently about how we are experiencing this time in our democracy. We can see that for the past 10 years, because we now have a 10-year perspective on these social networks, they have entered our lives. As you mentioned by using a well-known term from ancient philosophy, speaking of what is both the medicine, the remedy, and the poison, the Pharmakon, there are very good things brought by our social networks as well as by artificial intelligence, which allow us to communicate, to know what is happening at the other end of the world, to alert, to exchange knowledge, etc.

And there are also things on which we need to regain control. And for the younger ones, our children, our teenagers, but also for the functioning of our democracies, the proper functioning of information, of a free press, the proper functioning of our democracies in electoral times, we can see that we need to move some elements and fully realize what has actually happened in recent years. Something has transformed and it also makes us more fragile, it has created problems in society, and so it is up to us today to seize it. I believe that for democracies like ours, it is extremely important, because ultimately, we are plunged into a globalization where on one side, if I may say so, there is a Chinese model that is all control by the State, and on the other side, there is a model that gives everything to the private sector, including democratic choices. It is a bit of the American model. We, as citizens, want to choose for ourselves. That is what democracy is. So, we need to try to understand what is at stake. I do not want to be longer. I now especially want to answer your questions about our social networks. But above all, you give me a wonderful opportunity to be in Marseille again. So, thank you for that.

Moderator

Mr. President, you have here readers from our three departments of the diffusion zone, Bouches-du-Rhône, Vaucluse, and Alpes-de-Haute-Provence. We will discuss 4 themes: dependence on social networks, cyberbullying, disinformation and foreign interference, media education, new technologies and AI, which we just talked about, and then social networks in the face of violence and organized crime phenomena. A recent news story from Marseille leads us to address this subject with you and with all our readers.

We will open this meeting with a first theme, the theme of dependence on social networks and cyberbullying.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. I am a senior student at the Provence school, a Jesuit institution. You will address the issue of disinformation later. However, today, we are also confronted with a real abundance of information, particularly related to social networks. This constant exposure to information seems to be a real vector of stress and anxiety for young people, especially regarding uncertainty about their professional future. In your opinion, what concrete responses could help us achieve more discernment, but also find a better balance?

Speaker

Mr. President, hello. I am a senior at Joliot-Curie High School in Aubagne. Having uninstalled the TikTok social network myself to avoid addiction, my question is: when can we talk about addiction and what can we do to curb it?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. To start with the second question, there is a lot of debate, by the way, among specialists. I had requested a report that was given to me about a year and a half ago, in the spring of 2024, and some say: there are addictions that can be qualified, others say it is debatable, we cannot yet talk about addiction, there are debates among specialists. Nevertheless, what we see at work, and this relates to the question you are asking, fundamentally, both of you, is that we are spending more and more time in front of screens and that young people, particularly on social networks, are spending more and more time. So even if we must be very cautious because it has clinical characteristics, we see that a dependency is forming. I meet more and more young people like you who either ask family adults for help or end up removing it themselves because they cannot regulate themselves.

But I would just like to take a step back to ask why we are here and what the situation is and what is happening. And fundamentally, when we talk about social networks, what are they? Because there are many underlying ambiguities in the debate. The first ambiguity is that you start by saying there is an overabundance of information. I have an overabundance of content, but is it strictly speaking information? That is already the first distinction that needs to be made. That is to say, we have access, through our social networks, to a lot of things. But within these many things, I cannot necessarily say whether it is true, whether it is false, whether they are pieces of information or whether they are emotions, whether they are transformed content or not. The status is ambiguous. And this is where I agree with the notion of dependence that you have felt. We need to know what we are talking about. What exactly are our social networks? They are platforms in which we are connected, choosing to be under our identity or under anonymity, because we have these two options, we may come back to that, and which expose us to content.

I always try to understand and follow the thread. Why are there people who have an interest in exposing us to this content? The question we must always ask is how they make their living. Because they do not do it to please us; social networks are not a solidarity warehouse; there must be a business model; they make their money. When you buy La Provence, you pay to receive information. So precisely, information, because there is work behind it, I pay for it. Social networks, I do not pay for it. So how do they make money? They make money by selling advertising with me. So social networks put us online, expose us to content, but their business model, and it is not at all an offense to say this, it is not a reproach, their business model is not to share information; it is to be able to sell to advertisers the most individualized advertising possible to the right people. This is why, over the last 10 years, newspapers that had a lot of advertising have lost it because it has gone very massively to social networks because it is more individualized. And so you have an abundance indeed of signals, of emotions. But as they are structured, what do these social networks seek to do? To create excitement in you. This is where it is linked to addiction. Social networks are designed to push content that they will measure themselves creates a reaction in you, meaning it will increase your exposure time, it will encourage you to watch more and more videos, to spend more and more time, and to have additional excitement. That is the engine. Because the more excitement you have, the more you will stay, the more I will identify what you react to, the more I can sell this advertising in a more tailored way. That is what we are talking about.

So, my point is that we need to clarify something. Social networks are not made to inform us. You can access information platforms, your press titles, but their model is to sell individualized advertising about you. Perhaps that needs to be clarified.

The second thing is that, mechanically, yes, they create dependence. I will be very cautious because it is up to clinicians to do so, to talk about addiction, but they create dependence because negative emotion is more significant than positive emotion, which is more significant than argument, because it is what will create more excitement in you and more time. Today, among the youngest, we are at 4 hours and 20 minutes a day. So, it does have something to do with dependence.

We can see that we need to slow all this down; we need to clarify the status; we need to say what it is for, why it is made, because we have somewhat lost the thread of all this, and we need to manage to slow this thing down because spending too much time on it means giving up reading time for the youngest, time to build their lives. Indeed, that is also why, we will probably come back to it, for the youngest, I hope we can move towards mechanisms of prohibition. But it is clear today that there is increasing dependence, that it creates more and more disorders. And here too, without a causal mechanism being created, we have correlations that are now established that show that the more time we spend on social networks, the more anxiety we have, the more mental health problems we have, the more we decline in educational performance, the more we have problems with eating disorders, particularly among young girls, etc. So, it is not separable from the difficulties we have in terms of mental health among the youngest.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Child psychiatrist, director of the ASMA association, responsible for preventing adolescent suicide in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur region. Mockery and sarcasm have always permeated schoolyards. Social networks have transformed this seemingly innocuous practice into cyberbullying, a catalyst for drama for the most vulnerable. If networks are spaces for exchange and creation, they are also spaces of violence. The most vulnerable of these children, sometimes raised in a fragile, precarious environment, sometimes without parents, I think of children in foster care, need reliable, constant, and reassuring protection. The strengthening of psychosocial skills for the weakest must be encouraged. The stronger ones, the GAFAs, must be called upon. When will we impose a code of ethics on these multiple contents, Mr. President? When can we hope to see the recommendations of the screen commission that you established last year applied? Parents, more than children, urgently need it.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First, thank you and thank you for what is being done by your association and your commitment. We had the opportunity, when I gathered several professionals on these subjects a few months ago, to meet. What is being done is admirable.

You said it perfectly, bullying, whether it is school bullying or cyberbullying, is a continuum. That is to say, we have seen this continuum emerge in recent years, we have collectively reacted, and I really want to thank all the educational communities, the teachers, but all those who support them, our children and adolescents as students, and now the families we need to engage and all the associations that help. It is a continuum because, at its core, it is the most gregarious and cruel thing in human behavior. We see someone who is a bit in a position of weakness or we isolate someone because it is group logic, and we make them suffer. So, bullying leads to the worst, obviously, to school dropout, to great suffering, and sometimes even to suicide.

So, in recent years, we have equipped ourselves, so to speak, that is to say, we have stood up, then we have trained the teachers, the Phare program, we have alerted, we have set up platforms for bullying and cyberbullying. We have trained the students. Now, we are training families, which is very important. We are distancing children who bully. Before, we would rather tell families: "think about what your child is leaving the establishment." And then, we also equipped ourselves on cyberbullying by saying: "if you bully, we can deprive you of social networks and distance you." So, society has reacted, but it is a daily battle because there are still weak signals that we do not see, things happening that are unacceptable. And I say it again here, we must not give up this fight.

Now, behind that, cyberbullying continues in other forms. You said it, there are actually two ways to deal with the platforms, either they cooperate, or we realize that they are not interested. I will be very direct with you. My answer is simple, and I speak from experience; they are not interested. Since 2018, I have gathered the platforms at least twice a year, sometimes taking the global leaders. We have created, we have initiated European and international initiatives. After the terrible attack in Christchurch, we made this Christchurch call which allowed us at least to obtain some things on terrorist content. We tried to do it for children. We set up this laboratory to protect children. We had started to have commitments for moderation, saying: "yes, yes, we will help you on cyberbullying or on content that is identified as destabilizing for your young people." They have put in almost zero staff, they hardly ever spontaneously remove content, and if there is no appeal on appeal, they do not do it, and we have a lot of trouble holding them accountable.

That is why I tell you, responsibly, for me, the answer is that for those under 15 or 16 years old, we must ban social networks. It is the only way to protect them. The only way. Because today, the people who produce the content on these networks are not interested in the emotional and mental health of our children and adolescents. They have simply decided that it was a material for them. It is a material to sell something, to monetize it. So, we cannot delegate the mental and emotional health of our children and adolescents to people who have simply decided to make it a means of generating revenue. That is why I have come to the conclusion that we could not moderate; we had to cut.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. I would also like to point out in this morning's newspaper, forgive me for the promotional sequence, a very good feature on social networks that follows up on what you are indicating.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President, professor of Sales, Economics, and Law in a vocational high school. Well, you have just about answered, but I still want to ask my question. Social networks can be positive vectors, and I was wondering, wouldn’t it be possible to require them, without banning, but precisely to include more positive content, that is to say, for example, 10% of sports activities, 10% of general culture, 10% of solidarity actions so that it is indeed really interesting, healthy, and diversified content.

Speaker

Mr. President. President of the Chamber of Trades and Crafts of the Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur region. First of all, I wanted to thank you for the wonderful video message that we were able to see during our General Assembly on December 2 and 3 at CMA France. My question will be quite simple. We are a network; you also know craftsmanship at the national level. Even more true here, craftsmanship is the first business in the Provence-Alpes-Côte d'Azur region. We also train young people, more than 6,000 apprentices, 10,000 learners, and we face these social networks daily. We have a proposal. My question is the following: would you be willing to collaborate with us to develop a module precisely on these social networks so that our young people are attentive, of course, and pay attention to the use of these social networks? Thank you.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Founder of the Joy Up application. Joy Up is an application based on positive psychology. I like to make things joyful and positive; there are meditations, self-hypnosis, and podcasts, particularly on non-violent communication. So my question is the following: are there plans, beyond the restrictive measures that you seem to want to implement, for positive measures for students, teachers, parents, adults as well as young people, to introduce them to non-violent communication, to how to relate to others, to kindness, all these subjects that we do not learn in school and not necessarily in the family either? Thank you very much.

Thank you very much. So, on the first question, in truth, we do not control what social networks do. They are not state-owned. I would say the only place where what you seem to want to do exists is China. China, which created TikTok and exports it to us with a lot of content, does not broadcast TikTok in its own country; it severely limits the number of exposures per day and provides educational content. But we do not have a state social network. So I cannot give you such a guarantee. The problem is that we are entering a jungle, and in this jungle, as I said earlier, it is the laws of the market that operate, for better or for worse, and thus it is the exposure to a multitude of content that will create excitement. The example has been made by independent researchers on TikTok. The fourth video that is scrolled is an exposure to Salafist content because it creates excitement, as we have seen, and immediately it leads us down side paths. So, I do not think that this is the right method. I say this after having sought many ways, as I mentioned, to engage them, and after having listened a lot to science.

On the other hand, what we can say is that when a young person spends an average of 4 hours and 20 minutes a day on a screen, they have problems with loneliness, desocialization, often with sleep, because this 4 hours and 20 minutes leads them very late into the night. These are young people who have a lot of trouble focusing their attention, which you find a little later. These are young people who are increasingly struggling to read; we see a drop in the reading rate, among young people as well as among older people. These are young people who are doing less and less sports because they stay on their screens. And so the right response is not to look for content on networks that encourages reading and sports; it is to ensure that in the lives of our teenagers and our children, there is time for reading, time for sports, time for life together. And that is the whole job at school, with families, with extracurricular activities, to get everyone back to reading, and to tell young people as well as older people that reading is a wonderful lever for emancipation, something that allows one to understand the world, to understand oneself, and also to learn to build reasoning, to get our young people back into sports rather than seeking it through networks.

That is our approach. So in the meantime, we are training, and this is a bit the link between your three questions, and the idea is not to have only prohibitions. At the same time, it is to protect our young people, now that we know a little more in hindsight, the impacts that it has. Because we must say that we have, fundamentally, 10 years of hindsight. Social networks arrived on a very large scale in 2015. There was a small revolution around 2020 with Covid, where screen time increased for everyone. We have seen the impact. And now, we are all starting to measure it. So, we need to protect, but at the same time, we need to prepare.

What we are doing in schools is improving teacher training, introducing courses on kindness that did not exist, taking a bit of an example from Scandinavian models, which are more advanced than us on this point, and it is about preparing, and thus preparing by transmitting knowledge to our children, then critical thinking, and at the same time, good behaviors, and at the same time promoting positive content like yours, which then allows, when young people who, after all, at 16 years old remain young, arrive on the networks, to be accompanied in this regard. That is why what CMA France proposes, and thank you, President, goes entirely in the right direction, because the idea is to protect for a time, to prepare in school with families, but then to be able to support our young people when they arrive on these networks, with content that is entirely positive and that creates synergies with their professional activity. I am convinced, particularly for professions like those you train for, and we measure it, you measure it, the apprenticeship masters tell me very often, when we have young people who have spent hours and hours a day for years on networks, they have a lot of trouble keeping their attention behind a workbench, in a bakery, or... because it just disrupts the organism. It puts you in a situation where you are constantly used to being overstimulated. We even have young people who say they can no longer watch a movie sitting for an hour and a half. And that is the reality. They are used to having content that lasts a few seconds that rolls out. So the initiatives you are carrying are very good, and we will support them.

Moderator

If you allow me, stay with me for a few moments to answer a question that was not quite planned here. But the French are in favor of a ban on social networks for those under 15. In our dossier this morning, Australia has decided to do so and announced it this week. Are we heading towards that? Are we really going to clearly ban social networks for those under 15 in France?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, I think we are ready for that now. You talk about surveys. The Screen Commission has made a recommendation. There were still discussions among experts, but it has consolidated to say: it is really not good before 15-16 years old. And in reality, we can see that the consensus, you take Australia, it is 16 years old, in many countries, because I speak under the control of many more experts than I am: before 16 years old, in fact, emotional life is not fully structured, the brain is not mature, there are still many things that need to be fixed, and we destabilize them by overexposing them to social networks.

The second thing we needed, because this is in the spring of 2024 that we have this, we did all this work of scientific consensus, last summer, so less than 6 months ago, we had the response from Europe. Because in fact, it is very nice to prohibit, but you will tell me: how are you going to do it? So, we can only do it if we can control the age. So we obtained from Europe, because it is a European competence, these social networks, Europe told us: "Yes, you have the right to do age control, age verification for social networks," exactly as we obtained for pornographic sites. This fight that we waged a few years ago to say that we can no longer have young people who, at 12 years old, can access a free pornographic site. We have implemented these controls where we verify with either a selfie, or an identity card, or an identifier to ensure that we have adults. Europe told us: "You can do it for social networks." And it is a national competence to define digital majority.

So here, the idea is to arrive at the beginning of next year with a bill that will define a digital majority at 16 years old and that will say: you will verify your age, and below this age, you will not be able to access social networks because we consider that they are not good for you; you are in digital minority.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President. President of a small amateur club in Marseille, partner of your beloved club, Olympique de Marseille, forever the first. I had to slip that one in. I am faced with a new phenomenon, like all my fellow amateur club presidents, called the "Mbappé project," namely parents who are furious and absolutely want their "little one" to become a footballer. Unfortunately, talent is not enough. For that, they do not hesitate to showcase them on social networks, on all platforms. I completely agree with what you say because they do not take into account the danger of showcasing their own children. And when unfortunately failure occurs, since very few succeed, we, the clubs, end up with them completely destroyed. We forget that they are children. I see children aged 7-8 years; it is horrible. And when we tell them, they do not listen to us. I listened very carefully to what you said earlier; what can the State do to remedy this knowing that it also leads to serious excesses? I had an educator who was stabbed by an unhappy parent. In my club, it happened just when you came to the Benza neighborhood. By the way, I introduced you to him, and we exchanged with each other. Thank you, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. What you describe is much broader, but it goes along with it. We are in a society... First of all, there have always been parents who dream of the best for their children. Now, it simply goes into overdrive because everyone can see them and everyone puts them on social networks. That is the problem. It is that we should not put everything on the shoulders of social networks. It is an accelerator of things that have always existed before.

But in fact, all this brings us back to the importance of reality and our living structures. That is to say, we are rediscovering the importance of family, school, associations, that is to say, what makes it so that we are not just alone with millions or billions of people. And that is a bit the perverse effect of networks. It is wonderful, it is galvanizing. Wait, even when you are a presidential candidate or when you want to pass messages, you are President, it’s wonderful, you put out a message, a few minutes later, you can say: millions of people have seen me. They have seen you, they have read you. Did they understand you? You are not always sure? Because everyone can go off in all directions, I can tell you. But because there are no these intermediate structures. So it also goes to the heads of many. So I think that the importance at this moment is to cool the engine a bit, if I may say so, and to take the time to train our young people, our teenagers, and that is why we need to protect them, educate them, that is the role of families, instruct them, that is the role of schools, and accompany them, that is the role of football clubs, sports associations, associations in a broad sense, because that is how we manage to help them rise.

So the key for me is, 1) to send a clear message today: before a certain age, it is not good. That is for the young people. At the same time, we send a message to families. Until now, we were not clear with families. We did not know if social networks were good or not, whether to go there or not. We need to be clear about things. Now, we are sending a clear message. And 3) to hold families accountable to say, let your children grow and take the time to grow. Ultimately, it is in dialogue with teachers, educators, that you will understand if you are dealing with Mbappé and Mozart or not. And by the way, I also say this for many families; it is not necessarily how your child will be the happiest. But they need to go through the whole journey. Mbappé is a good example; he is also a young man who has a crazy talent for football but who was very supported by his family, by his first clubs, who kept a cool head and who also continued his studies for a long time. Thank you for having this word for many young people; sometimes parents or the entourage would want to take them out. There you go. We need to take the time to grow and to become an adult.

What you describe is even broader, but it is, fundamentally, we are relearning how to make society. I know it is hard, but it is thanks to clubs like yours and associations. Our role is that. So the role of the State is, fundamentally, to provide a norm based on science, to say now, we send a clear message to families, to be supportive of families, teachers, associations, and to accompany you in this essential work of education, instruction, and support.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. I propose that we open the second theme of this meeting, disinformation and foreign interference.

Speaker

Mr. President, hello. I am a student at school 42, a computer school. On the side, I started my own business where I help companies save time. I have a question for you. At a time when disinformation and foreign interference fully exploit our social networks, how can the State protect democratic debate without infringing on freedom of expression and help citizens distinguish more clearly between a fact and an opinion?

Having personally left social networks for a year, to protect myself from disinformation, addiction, and algorithmic influence, I wonder if the State is considering strengthening the visibility of reliable and verified information sources to help citizens, especially young people, better navigate the flow of information.

Emmanuel MACRON

They are of age, but afterwards, I will try to frame things because I think there will be others. Because, in fact, it is a continuum; we can see it well, even in the public debate we have had in recent weeks, there has been a lot of confusion. You are absolutely right, the great risk is to say, I was astonished to read that you said I had become a great totalitarian who was going to prohibit everything. No, but that is a bit of the debate we have been having for some time now.

What is happening? First of all, it is perfectly normal that on social networks there are information, facts, opinions; these are different things. But there is a great confusion in the status. I think we need to agree on the fact that information and the functioning of a democracy presuppose, as a foundation, having a free circulation of information that is forged freely and independently. It is a profession, it is work. I do not produce information. I will produce positions; I will be able to refer to science. Some will tell me that I am doing communication; I will give opinions.

But I believe that information is the profession of people who are journalists. And that is the first important point that needs to be reframed, because, after all, it is something we learned with democracy. We are going back a bit to the 19th century at the moment. We spent the entire 19th century building our press system. It was the laws of the 1880s that created the press. Why? Because throughout the 19th century, we had newspapers that were created. But these newspapers often informed, they gave opinions, they could be manipulated; it was the law of the strongest or the richest. But there was not much in terms of ethics. The laws of the Third Republic in our country, which by the way are the ones that allowed the creation of your titles in La Provence and that structured our regional and national daily press, are laws that guaranteed the independence of journalists, but that also created a system of responsibility. This means that if La Provence says something that is false, I can request a right of reply, but I can also seek its responsibility. There will be an editor-in-chief, someone who has the responsibility of a press publisher, who will, before the courts, be able to be challenged by me if I believe that he has said something that harms me, he has stated a falsehood or he has wronged me. This is very important because there is no freedom to inform without responsibility that goes with it and without journalistic ethics that goes with it. I repeat, it is not the business of the State. It is not the State that builds this information, but it is this framework of free and independent press.

Today, that is not social networks. If tomorrow, any platform says something that is completely false about you, causing you harm and so on, it does not really have any responsibility. You cannot take it to court. And it does not produce information. And as I said earlier, that is not its point. So that is the first distinguishing element that needs to be made. It is fundamental. And so if you want to inform yourself, you can go on social networks, but go look for the sites of information titles, that is to say, well-known newspapers, because that is how you will have the certainty of having information. Otherwise, you will have opinions, and I cannot tell you whether they are true or false.

Then, in the face of this complexity, as you mentioned earlier, this overabundance, journalists, independently and freely, have said that we need to better distinguish our titles from others, and they wanted to create labels. And I repeat, and I have already said it several times, these are not State labels; they must especially not be State labels. It is an initiative that was taken by Reporters Without Borders, with certifiers, but a bit like, by the way, there are Veritas offices or others, they said: we are creating an initiative among journalists to say here, we really have very serious ethical rules. This is, for example, what we have called the JTI, which is the Journalism Trust Initiative, so the initiative for trust in journalism. And it is journalists who evaluate each other to say here, these are really titles.

Why? Because you have a lot of fake newspapers being created. You have a lot of people who put out false information online or who write a rag that has nothing to do with newspapers, who have not registered, who do not have the status and who make believe that they are newspapers. But that, if I may say so, is something that is managed by journalists; it is not at all the State that should do it.

Then, you have the question of false information, what we call fake news. It is a very particular status. You will read something; it is not a newspaper that writes it, it is not a press title, about you, about something you know is false. That is very difficult to regulate, the true from the false. It is through debate, controversy, and the evidence provided that you will be able to untangle it. But it is very difficult, even for the judge, to identify what is false. It is by definition a much grayer area, and it exists in life. It can be the rumor that is spread, the false information. It takes on a much larger scale in social networks. But there, I will not lie to you; there is no miracle remedy for that. There will always be true and false news, just as there are in life. Simply, they take on a larger proportion. What needs to be established is simply when this news takes on a volume, when it is identified and when it causes harm to someone. At that moment, we need to be able to identify a responsibility of the platforms. That is what we have put in place at the European level with the Digital Services Directive. We told them, from a certain level, you do have a form of responsibility for what you publish. And if it is obviously false, and if it obviously causes harm to someone, I can seek your responsibility. That is the very beginning. Europe is the only place where we have done this, and we must continue. And what we want to do on this is to strengthen things, to go much further.

The third element is during election times, because you mentioned interference. We may come back to foreign interference, but during election periods, you are a candidate for the mayor of Marseille; if I say something false about you, it will cause you harm. I must be able to stop it. We have put in place what we call an electoral injunction. Simply, we do not use it enough. And so there, we are going to do what we call a criminal circular. And that is an emergency brake. I say something that is totally false. You know it, but legally, I cannot immediately have it removed. Electoral injunction, it will disturb the election. I must be able to have it removed. Otherwise, it harms you and it will distort the election. Because social networks, through this functioning, clearly distort our elections. And so there, it is the electoral injunction.

The last point is manifestly illegal content. Racist, anti-Semitic content, or content that incites hatred, we must be able to remove it. Today, we have an organization; we have what is called Pharos, which is a platform we have set up, which seeks precisely these reasons. We have created state mechanisms. So, this is not false information; it is information that will endanger your life or that, as the law has prohibited for years, has a content that is very clearly racist or anti-Semitic, etc. At that moment, we must remove it; we must hold the platform responsible. Does it work? In theory, yes. But the President that I am must, in all honesty, tell you, in practice, it is average. Because we do it manually; it is not satisfactory. The only way to make it satisfactory is to go to the end of a full and complete responsibility of these platforms. Because today, it is this Pharos platform that will look each time with limited means; it will try to have them removed. Generally, it works. Now, I have a bad sample because it is often what I am interested in. We may come back to it for interference. But it needs to be systematic.

In fact, what needs to be said is that such a social network, you did not do it; if you did not do it, we will impose a fine of so many millions of euros. It is only like that that it can work. So, what we want to push at the European level now is much more immediate and substantial fines on these social networks that do not cooperate and that do not remove all of this. There you go. Sorry, that was a bit long, but because we need to clearly differentiate the statuses between the information or what we read on networks.

Moderator

Fines without, of course, as some French people are calling for, shutting down sites, platforms, and media.

Emmanuel MACRON

But I think there needs to be escalations. So, we are talking about platforms. This Digital Services Directive, known as the DSA, for Digital Services Act, is something France pushed for during its presidency of the European Union in 2022. It was finalized in early 2023. You can imagine that we took the first action against platform X two weeks ago. So, it is not moving super fast, after all. We did it; the amounts are very limited. We have put on 3 or 4 actions that were pursued; it will amount to 120 million euros. It is not yet deterrent. So, we need to have an escalation that is much more deterrent and that afterwards, we can revoke your approval.

I will give you a very simple comparison. It is exactly for me like insurers. When you have an insurer, we cannot control all the operations of an insurer. It is like for a social network; there are too many operations. So, what do we do? We have put obligations in place. We say: "We will regularly check if you are doing it, either if people say it has not been done well, or through stress tests. If we find out, however, that you have not done it, be careful; the fine will be astronomical." We have done it. And then, after one or two fines, or if it is very serious, we revoke your approval. We do it for money. Why do we not do it for our brains? Why do we not do it for a democratic functioning? Why do we not do it for the minds of our youth, the lives of our youth? It is exactly the same thing.

So, we need to create a system where we say: we will not be able to check you every morning, but here are the rules; if you do not respect them, that is to say, you must, on these racist and anti-Semitic contents, remove them within X time, you must, if we have reported to you more than a certain number of times concerning problematic content, you must have moderation and get back to us. And so, there is a specification; if you do not do it, you will be held responsible with very high fines. That is now the second step of the European fight. This is European; it is not French. The minor prohibition is French; we will do it at the beginning of next year. This is the European fight we are launching next year.

Participant

Mr. President, good morning. We welcome and engage with many of our clients during this period, which leads me to ask you the following question. How can France manage disinformation and foreign interference that have a direct influence on our economy by contributing to an anxious climate despite this festive period?

Emmanuel MACRON

You are right, and that is why we are here. And I will tell you, today, it is not working very well. So, I am not for us to stop being a democracy, I assure you, because many say: "We need to go for it; we need to be much tougher, etc." No, because, in fact, we cannot cut everything off at once. We must not cut everything off at once.

The question is, how do we get there? So, we have already made progress since earlier by saying that we need to create systems of accountability. We need to engage in collective education, to remind people that if you want to be informed, you need to read newspapers. If you want to be informed, you have to accept paying for that information. And I find that the somewhat unhealthy situation we have entered into over the last 10 years is that we have gotten used, as a democracy, to saying: "information has no cost anymore." So, implicitly, we are saying: "it has no value anymore." This is not possible. You see, this means we are getting used to something that is: it’s not really information that we are willing to not pay for. That’s not it. If we want people to do the work of informing, we must accept to have a viable economic model behind it and therefore to pay. It’s modest. Or we can say, it’s a real debate that we will also launch in the coming months, if you don’t want to pay per issue, we say it’s a common good, then this common good must be financed as citizens. A real debate. There are indeed agreements and disagreements. You have many journalists who will tell you "never in a million years." I don’t want that. That’s bureaucratization. But today, it’s the worst of systems. We are essentially saying: "information is worth nothing, so I won’t pay for it and we no longer make the distinction."

So nevertheless, beyond what I have already said earlier about responsibility and the clarification between what is a news title and what is not, there are things that are not going well today, which we must clarify, on which the open democracies that we are are far too weak and which create foreign interference.

The first is the existence of fake accounts. Today, you can have people activating fake accounts, troll farms, etc., who will push content to weaken you. Today, the paradox is that these large platforms, generally American, sometimes Chinese, during election periods or times when it is difficult, have among their best clients, the Russians, who buy fake accounts by the hundreds of thousands or millions to massively push content and succeed in spreading false information or amplifying information that was emerging. This applies in both cases. Today, when you open a message, look at it and it says it has been viewed 12 million times, retweeted or liked, you cannot tell if there are real people behind it or if they are fake accounts.

So, everyone benefits, if I may say so, from these platforms, because they make money from these purchases. We must prohibit that. In any case, we must require the platforms that behind each account, there is indeed a real person and not potentially a fake account or a troll, because that distorts everything. First point.

The second point that is fundamental, in my eyes, is the transparency of algorithms. Today, content is pushed. When it’s Provence, you have an editor-in-chief who pushes his content, who decides what goes on the front page, what goes on page 2, page 3. You can agree or disagree. There is accountability. Generally, it’s collective, it’s an editorial choice. When you go on a social network, who pushes the content you will see? It’s not you who are freely searching for it. They are not pushed by people who have discussed and who say to you "here is my line." They are pushed by an algorithm whose purposes are generally economic, meaning it has identified what creates excitement in you. By the way, you have all experienced this. You asked a question about a certain device, and strangely, an hour later, two hours later, or the next day, you are pushed content about that type of device or an advertisement, life is well made. Well, it pushes you the content, it’s its algorithm. But this algorithm can also be used politically. And it turns out that some owners of social networks today have political battles. Second element, we must have transparency of algorithms and be able to control them. Let’s eliminate fake accounts, demand transparency of algorithms to control them.

The last point, we want to be able to obtain much faster removal of accounts that are manifestly interference, manifest. To tell you that we are very far from being there, I will give you a very recent real experience. On Sunday, I received a Facebook message from abroad, from one of my African colleagues, to be honest, and he says to me, "Dear President, what is happening with you? I am very worried." He sends me a Facebook message; agricultural crisis, etc., we see a journalist who is next to the Élysée, etc., who says there has been a coup d'état in France, a colonel has taken power. So, we find that amusing. 12 million views. I, as President of the Republic, as some would say, ask my team, this thing is not possible, especially in this period, ask the platform to remove it immediately. The Pharos platform calls Facebook. It says, this thing needs to be removed. Look, it obviously creates chaos. It’s exactly what you are saying, it’s worrying. And your client who comes to see you that day thinks there is a coup d'état at the Élysée with a colonel who has taken power, etc., can be worried. Facebook's response: "It does not violate our terms of use." Refusal to remove. I tend to think that I have more leverage than anyone else, in any case, it might be easier for me to tell them that it’s serious if I call, but it doesn’t work.

So, you see that we are not equipped as we should be. So, I am for a free, open debate, but these people are mocking us. They disregard the serenity of public debates, they disregard the sovereignty of democracies, and therefore, they put us in danger. That’s why we need to succeed when we have, and it must not at all be the prince's doing, with a procedure voted by the legislator, but at the French and European level, when we have manifestly false content that endangers public safety through false information that destabilizes, we must be able to have it removed. Thank you very much.

Speaker

Mr. President, hello. I am the president of Kiro, a French company from French Tech 2030, whose mission is to ensure quality information for patients, but also relevant for healthcare professionals, all thanks to the artificial intelligence we are building in France. We are currently leaders on this subject in Europe with 3 million users. And yet, due to regulations and the precautionary principle, our projects are completely blocked in France even though they benefit from state funding and we are working with public institutions. The consequence is simple. In three months, our technology has advanced faster in the United Arab Emirates than in a year and a half in France. This means that if Kiro does not want to lose the battle against foreign competition, particularly from our Chinese or American competitors, we will probably have to train our algorithms abroad with biases from other countries. We will have to train engineers and doctors there. This also means that we risk importing our technology later at a higher cost, with a risk of bias that will be inherent to the worldview of these countries, even though we are a French company. It’s paradoxical, but today, the precautionary principle risks killing the principle of innovation. I remain an optimist. We are fighting for the French system, but we need to lift certain barriers and act for French innovation and access to reliable information.

My question is simple, Mr. President, in this context of disinformation, is the main danger not ultimately that of a discreet, somewhat more insidious interference? Those that condemn us, due to a lack of rapid innovation in France and excessive regulation, to develop technologies outside of France, with an immediate risk of integrating the worldview of other countries, biases that could impact the quality of information, the health of patients, and, more generally, the public interest of our country.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. So, I am ready to look perhaps more specifically at what is blocking, whether it is clinical trials or the use of AI for certain cohorts, because it’s a subject that is somewhat disconnected from the rest, and I think, by the way, that we should not oppose them. You know the fight I have been leading for 9 years for innovation in the country, to move forward and lift the barriers. We have lifted them because we are the country in Europe that creates the most startups and which, in continental Europe, is clearly leading in AI. After that, on AI and health, you are absolutely right. In reality, it’s not just AI, by the way. We have an issue with clinical trials, the speed of our procedures which today paralyze us and make the case you describe unfortunately not isolated. We have many startups that are being created, sometimes even in our public structures, which, due to the slowness of our clinical trials or our procedures, will do their first cohort and register outside of Europe, because it’s, at its core, a European issue, and we lose, therefore, the opportunity. I will not oppose the two. We need to protect our youth, we need to protect our democracy, and at the same time, we need to be very innovative because we do not want interference, but we want to reduce our dependencies. That’s the whole European fight we are leading. Tomorrow, I will have the opportunity to speak on this subject at the European Council. We need a Europe that innovates and innovates faster and stronger.

So, should we necessarily oppose the precautionary principle? In any case, if the precautionary principle does not have a principle of innovation as strong in front of it, it inhibits everything. And the reality is what you are saying, and we see it in reality in all sectors. It’s a bit what makes everyone very nervous. It’s the incoherence of a public action that asks producers in our country to comply with more and more standards for a multitude of good reasons, but which, at the same time, is open to all winds and allows the re-importation of products made abroad that do not respect the same standards at all. So, we are recreating dependencies. That’s crazy. So, we need to resynchronize the obligations we impose on our producers and those we impose on people who import into our country. Many of the debates we have are about this. So, for us, the mother of all battles at the French and European level is to simplify the rules, it’s one of the major agendas we have and that we are pushing, by the way, in Franco-German cooperation, to be able to indeed innovate much faster.

On your particular case, I am entirely ready to look at it and see how we can help you, particularly on the health issue, but more broadly, everything we are saying to combat interference goes hand in hand with a renewed policy of digital and technological sovereignty. What does that mean? Allowing innovation, development, creation, or repatriation of technology blocks in our country. That’s what we are doing, and that’s what we are doing in Marseille, by the way, with data centers, with computing models, etc., because it’s one of the points on which we have been very dependent, and it’s what we must do throughout the value chain. So, I promise you that we will look very closely at your case to be able to catch up with our Emirati friends and, above all, keep you at home.

Moderator

We will open the third point which is also very important, media education. We will talk about new technologies and artificial intelligence.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. As the principal of a REP+ college in the 14th arrondissement of Marseille, I measure every day the commitment of the teams of the National Education against cyberbullying, artificial intelligence, and the use of social networks. We are therefore acting within a framework set by the Institution that involves prevention, sanctions when necessary, and educational support for students and families. This commitment has recently been put to the test. The death of a 14-year-old boy from the neighborhood has profoundly affected our students. Social networks widely disseminated and commented on this tragedy, even going so far as to stage the agony of this young person through repeated images. The emotional impact was immediate. In responsibility, we opened a listening cell in support with the academic mobile security teams and engaged in educational work on images, their transformation, and their circulation.

However, 15 days later, we were faced with another situation. Students used, via social media, the Fisha account, to name just one, to digitally alter photographs of students and adults from the institution. We applied the sanctions provided for, but above all reinforced educational support in close collaboration with families and our partners. These situations, Mr. President, show how quickly digital uses evolve, very quickly, particularly with artificial intelligence, and how they make students more vulnerable.

My question is therefore the following: How does the State intend to concretely strengthen the resources of the National Education system in terms of training, operational tools, and clear regulatory frameworks to enable institutions, particularly in REP+, to face these new forms of cyberbullying and better protect students? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, thank you for your commitment and what you have just described. First of all, you have perfectly illustrated, I believe, why we must arrive at a ban. I would say, the first thing is that we must provide a standard, protect you, and also allow for distancing from these instruments when they cannot be regulated and produce the worst.

I would like to make an adjacent remark. There is nothing to do with freedom of expression when it comes to allowing content that shocks and shows the worst. I say this because it is always in the debate we have, and you can see it well, we are told: we are talking about free speech. It has nothing to do with free speech to show indecency. That is not true. We practice freedom of expression every day, we know it well in our country, it is not indecent, freedom of expression, because with it goes, precisely, a public decency that consists of not shocking others, of not insulting them. I close this parenthesis.

What we want to do for the school, is first to protect it. Your role is not to do everything and take on all the ills of society. However, today, you are somewhat confronted with this because we have allowed too many things to happen around. I want to reiterate how we will pace things a little over time. The first element, I did not mention earlier, but for me, it is perhaps the foundation. Now, we know that screens before the age of 3 are harmful. Therefore, the standard is no screens before the age of 3. Finally, it is not a great law that will solve this issue, but it is to implement it in all state services that manage children under 3 years old, but it is that we all have awareness of this, in the pressure we exert daily, in public transport or elsewhere, towards families who have young children to support. Then, between 3 and 6 years old, not too much screen time, as little as possible. And then, in the educational life, we must limit screen time. It is not about going to zero screens, but we can see that all those who went to full screen are now going back.

Alongside that, we have mobile phones. Many of the young people you are talking about are young people who have mobile phones, who have them in class, etc. We have conducted experiments in recent years. The feedback has been good. In fact, to protect and support teachers, the educational community, the lesson I have learned from these past years is that we need to provide a national standard behind which you can, in a way, not take refuge, but that you can oppose to families and students. Otherwise, all the pressure comes back to you, and that is where we have problems. The national standard now is to say, of course, at school and in middle school, since last September, no more mobile phones, from bell to bell, in the locker, in the backpack, no more mobile phones from bell to bell, everywhere in France, zero exceptions. Next September, in all high schools, vocational high schools. From bell to bell, from start to finish, in the institution, there are no mobile phones. This is something that will greatly protect teachers, the educational community. This, plus the ban on social media for those under 15, is a real change because you will no longer be confronted with these types of situations.

In parallel, in teacher training, we are putting in place modules, precisely, for education, media, and social networks. With the rectorates, the Minister of National Education, who is very committed to this issue, will implement training modules. But in fact, we must do both. We cannot ask you to do everything today while you are exposed to everything. That is why we need to cool down, if I may say so, protect our children and adolescents, recreate a national standard that was too ambiguous, even non-existent until now, hold families accountable who must play their role — Education is for families. Instruction is for you. — and engage with extracurricular activities. What we will have to do in the coming months, that is also why I am having all these debates, with associations, with the educational community, is to send the message to families and hold them accountable, because it is not you who can manage everything. There you go.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President. I have just graduated from HEC. I am a member of the South Winners, the supporters' group of OM in the South stand of the Stade Vélodrome. And I am the founder of the Protis Club, which is an association that recruits young people from all social backgrounds in Marseille, from the North and South neighborhoods, to enable them to unite their strength beyond fractures, to reveal their potential, and to achieve personal and professional fulfillment.

My question will focus on the success of young people, because social networks can create both the worst and the best. But a young person who masters them can highlight their ideas and projects to, precisely, rally support, strengthen their impact, and even be a source of inspiration for others. My question is whether your commitment to this important issue, and also your commitment to Marseille, can be an opportunity to rethink the model of education and higher education to integrate this aspect and teach young people to make social networks a springboard for their influence and the projects they can undertake?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, but you have said that perfectly. Today, by the way, there is a lot of innovation in our social networks. They are also relays, but because we have been talking for a while, it is normal, it is a bit the debate, about the difficulties we can see and what needs to be regulated. But I said from the beginning, it can also be the best alongside the worst. These are networks that allow talents to connect with each other, that allow young people, sometimes less young, very inspiring, to find relays, to share their projects, to give them much more impact. All of this, of course, we want to develop. Today, we first have training that has been structured in recent years. In the various plans we have implemented, we have encouraged our engineering schools, our universities to develop these projects and develop these training programs, which focus on artificial intelligence and related professions, which, of course, on the more marketing side, because fundamentally, we can see that there are two levers: there is the very technical lever and there is the very marketing lever on social networks. We need to develop both skills. Those who succeed very well often have both categories of skills.

Of course, at the same time, we want to protect our young people and adolescents, we want to prepare them while protecting them. We then want them to have the most positive and critically constructive relationship, in the good sense of the term, with these social networks. We want them to be able to use them for positive projects, whether they are entrepreneurial or sports-related. This is largely the case today. I would say they are polluted by a negativity that still exists in these messages, which we need to be able to push back. I think that our common goal is to succeed, fundamentally, in restoring civility in these social networks, that is to say, allowing young people or less young people to promote their projects, to make their projects, ambitions, and talents known, to inspire others, and to put negative speech back in its rightful place. There can be criticism, there can be doubt expressed, yes. That it be permanent negativity, that it be distrust, even uninhibited violence, no. And that does not happen naturally, for the reasons I mentioned earlier, because networks will push you to extremes if we let them do so on their own. So it only works if there is a group discipline.

This group discipline is called building society and building a nation. That is what we have today. If we let ourselves go in a herd-like manner today, we will quickly start shouting at each other and hitting each other. We have a group discipline, we look at each other face to face, we see our faces. We have decided to have a discussion for two hours, we have decided together to have the same moderator, we have set rules for ourselves and we said: we may agree, we may disagree, but we will try to move forward together. Why can’t we do that on social networks? Of course, we can do it. Simply, those who decide to reattach to this rule must be collectively more numerous and somehow regain the majority. So, I am very supportive of what you just said. It is up to us to remobilize.

Moderator

Excuse me, Mr. President, on certain networks, X, for example, it is impossible to do what we could imagine here this morning: to discuss calmly without being completely in agreement and to fully share what is said. You announced that you might leave X. Is it not ultimately a global movement that needs to be launched on these platforms? Or should we stay to observe what is happening there and regulate?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I cannot say, and it is not for me to set a standard for others, but I would like to make a distinction. First, it allows young people, less young people, to make known or to know. So, there are interests, there is a positive aspect. It allows people to raise alerts, to share. So I would not put everything in the same basket. What we have been doing for a while is very different. Just as I made a distinction between all the content we have on a social network and information, being on a social network, sending messages, reading them, scrolling through content, is not the same as leading a debate or having a deliberation. That is also very important to measure; social networks do not make democracy. Because it is one with the multitude, but there is not something discursive, on the one hand, and respectful, on the other. These are two very important points.

Deliberation, which is constitutive of democracy, is in the public square, it is what a town hall also does. It is what we do in important moments of democracy, in our televised debates, in our debates also in public squares. We are men and women: we may not agree, we are face to face, we set rules of speech, we will try to move forward on questions, answers, we will oppose opinions in a respectful manner. That is not what a social network does, and it is not made for that, as I said earlier. So we should not delegate democratic deliberation to social networks; that would be a mistake. However, we can see that we probably need to reinvent these deliberative frameworks. I say this with great humility, from the great debate to citizen conventions, what we are doing. That is what I am trying to do. We need these places of deliberation. Otherwise, there is nothing between solitude and exploding anger.

The second thing is that the paradox of social networks is that they increase solitude. We probably have not measured this, because people then go less to common places. It is not a coincidence that it takes an average of 4 hours and 20 minutes per day; we go less to cafes, we go less to associations, we read less, we go less to sports clubs. All that brings back the common, brings back liberation. When we go to do sports in a club, we meet people from other social backgrounds who do not think like us. That is where we confront ideas. We have deliberation in the locker room. We have deliberation in the moment of conviviality after the match. It is a democratic deliberation. We agree, we disagree. We have it at the café, we have it in the public square, we have it in the association supporting this or that cause in which we are engaged. All these living spaces that are the fabric of life in society, that take us out of solitude, they allow us to build the common. They are vital for a democracy. Social networks, they send us back to solitude.

I may have millions of friends, but I know very few of them. But in fact, what structure do they have? They are rather people who follow me or whom I follow. That is to say, there is a huge bias; they are generally people who think like me. So, I have very few deliberations, very few controversies. I have selected people who think like me. The people who come to see me are people who already think like me. We don't have much deliberation. So, you constantly have a confirmation bias. That is to say, you will, on social networks, tend to be overexposed to content that thinks like you, since these are people who follow you. This is something we do not measure enough. And so, if you are a bit skeptical, for example about the vaccine, it is people who are a bit skeptical like you who will start to follow you, and then they will share all the content from people who are a bit skeptical like them. Very quickly, we will find ourselves with 3,000 vaccine skeptics. Quite quickly, we become conspiracy theorists. This is exactly what is happening. The bottom line is that in many categories of society, there is a decline, for example, in vaccination rates, because there are people who sincerely believe that it is dangerous. When they went to the café, they talked at the school exit or in their association, they were confronted with other people who told them: "There, you are talking nonsense, I assure you. Have you looked into it? Do you know anything? Have you studied virology, have you seen a doctor?" There was a contradiction.

We know that social networks trap you in solitude, and between solitude and the multitude of networks, there is no mix. There are these cognitive bubbles. There is the algorithm and the bubble. It traps you in a bias. I deeply believe that we need to recreate places for deliberation, but also to consider that we must discipline our relationship with reality, which cannot only go through these networks.

Moderator

You are implicitly suggesting to leave X, aren't you?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, because I believe in freedom. I believe that everything we are doing here, I will tell you, is the strength of democracies. It is to be free, transparent, and to have a critical mind. An authoritarian or totalitarian regime prohibits these networks. Russia, an authoritarian regime, prohibits these networks. It uses them to drive us crazy. We must be able to prohibit certain things when it is very serious, but we must define the rules in accordance with our Constitution. I say to the young people, it is very serious. I say when it is completely false or it is illicit content, it is very serious. For the rest, what is the bet of the Republic? It is education, critical thinking. So, I believe that collectively, we must have the intelligence together to first take a step back and say: maybe these social networks are good for this and that, but I will give them less time in my life. I will dedicate more time to reading, I will dedicate more time to associations, I will dedicate more time to the common good differently, and then maybe people will decide to step out. But I prefer it to be the free choice of our fellow citizens rather than an injunction coming from above. The work of enlightening, as we are doing, to awaken critical thinking, is, I believe, the work of the Republic.

Participant

Hello, Mr. President. I am the leader of "Mailinblack," a cybersecurity company, a leader in France for SMEs based in Marseille. Our mission is to develop artificial intelligences to protect 2.5 million Europeans today against billions of attacks per year coming from email, the web, stolen passwords, user behaviors, and their education. So, before French Tech, I had the benefit of having two perspectives today. Before French Tech, I was with GAFAM. At the time of Microsoft, I was able to see from the inside the seriousness of American industrial policy regarding digital technology. We have been talking about it for a while now from different dimensions. What I have observed is a determination that has nothing to do with free trade, liberalism, and is totally characterized by a desire to build a global leader. I am not only talking about support in research and development, public procurement, the extraterritorial laws you mentioned earlier, but also about judicial patriotism that has exposed competing French actors.

My question is therefore simple: today, in this framework, in this global arena: why are we not playing on equal terms with the United States? The State has already done a lot, and I want to emphasize that, and I thank you for it. Great cybersecurity challenge, France 2030, France relaunch 2030, etc., a lot has been done, and we must be very grateful. However, my observation is that I sense a very strong determination from the United States. I could say the same about China today regarding the establishment of a global leader in cybersecurity.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, but I will tell you. The worst for me about the European fight, we did not build ourselves like that at the beginning; it is the transformation we are undergoing. Europe is a brilliant invention of the last seven decades. We did it first to stop making war, and it worked. It had never lasted this long before. Then, we did it to create a common market, and that worked. We created prosperity. We never thought of ourselves as a power. We put the consumer at the center, and we are an open power. But I will tell you: it no longer works. This is the fight I have been leading for a few years, and I would say even more since 2020, because we have taken massive blows from the Americans and the Chinese. The Americans have implemented the Inflation Reduction Act; they said: "We will help the companies that come to us; we don't care if the Europeans succeed or not." It was not the current president; it was his predecessor. Now, they have imposed terrible tariffs on us because they say: "We are a power." The Chinese overproduce, they close their domestic markets, and they say: "We are coming to you." The bottom line is that they have exploded their trade surpluses with us. We are in the middle; we are the only ones to be an open power. Rather than being an open market, we are not a power.

If we want to have the determination you describe, which I totally share, for me, the key to the economic and industrial battle we must wage for Europe in the coming years, but it starts now, is simplification. This ties into what Mr. was saying. The rules are too complex and, above all, they are too different. Simplification is everything that hinders innovation; it must be lightened, and above all, we must finally create a single market. When you create your cybersecurity company, you have a market of 68 million inhabitants, France. Then, you fight with 27 regulations. The single market is to give you a domestic market of 450 million inhabitants, like in the United States. That is not the case today. So, the integration of the single market is key.

2) It is innovation. The Americans invest much more public and private money in innovation. So, having a much stronger European budget in terms of innovation and a finally integrated European capital market that allows for financing innovation, which is not at all the case with us. That is the heart of the reform for the next six months. And 3) it may seem like a big word, but protection. Today, there is no protection in Europe for these actors, as you very well pointed out. That is why this is a completely current battle. We, France, are fighting to have a European preference or European content. For example, in the automotive sector and in various sectors. Many in Europe are still against it because they prefer to buy from Chinese subcontractors; it is cheaper. But that is a short-term view. If we do not have a European preference, a European content, like the Americans have in the NAFTA market. In North America, there is not a single one of these major sectors that has not defined a regional content. After that, you can sometimes enter when you are non-NAFTA or non-ALENA, that is to say Canada, Mexico, the United States.

But if the content has been respected with us, that is not at all the case. So, we started to do this in the defense industry, and we succeeded in imposing rules. Now, we want to do it in the automotive sector, and we want to do it in all sectors. In the digital and AI sectors, we are fighting for a European preference. If there is no European solution that exists, fine, to buy non-European. If it exists in European, public buyers as well as private buyers must favor European solutions and have protected European content. Otherwise, we will never be a power. That is the key to the battle, but you are absolutely right. Simply, it is a bit of a geopolitical awakening that we are undergoing. This must be done with urgency because, in fact, the economic situation is currently under maximum pressure.

Participant

Hello, Mr. President. We talk a lot about sovereignty in artificial intelligence. But true sovereignty is not just about mastering technology; it is about its appropriation by the greatest number. However, as you know, today, a large part of the population does not know about AI, and this digital divide will mechanically fuel the social divide. Schools will not be able to train everyone, or not quickly enough. So, I have an idea that I submit to you. I propose the creation of an urban campus open to all, supported by local actors, with very short training programs, not to create engineers—there are schools for that—but to raise awareness, to desensitize, to explain, and to show the greatest number, to the entire population, and especially to the most disadvantaged population, that AI is not magic and that it is not reserved for an elite.

My question is simple. What do you think of this vision? And is the State ready to support and accompany this type of territorial project to make Marseille the capital, at least Mediterranean, of inclusive AI, of a performing and popular AI?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, you are absolutely right. Everything is important. We need computing power, infrastructure, we need actors. Then, for artificial intelligence, we need sectors in which it will spread. But the question of what we call the adoption of artificial intelligence is key. It is key from an economic and social point of view. A few weeks ago, we held the first "Adopt AI" summit at the Grand Palais on this matter. It is key because we can have the best AI champions. The first point from an economic perspective is that our companies, and by the way, this goes from our artisans to our large groups, adopt it, meaning they reap the benefits in terms of productivity, improving their performance. This is fundamental for having an economy that produces faster and stronger. The first distinction between countries, which is key for Europeans, will be made on this basis. There are countries that can have champions. If you do not have a market, the champions will leave. So, adoption in terms of AI is fundamental, but it is also fundamental for us to improve our productivity, our competitiveness, and to create more wealth.

This requires training artisans, business owners, and employees of SMEs and micro-enterprises, and here, our consular networks play a very important role, the services of the State, our Entrepreneurship Carrefours, as we have developed in Marseille, are absolutely fundamental. On the other hand, you have the social divide. You are absolutely right. AI is like social networks and access to digital technology. The elderly and the most disadvantaged are often further away from these practices. We need to be able to, as we have done in recent years with mediators, with actions, reach out and encourage all initiatives that allow for training. Schools are a lever, but we should not place all the burden on schools. Schools should raise awareness. They must first transmit fundamental knowledge, a critical mind, self-confidence, and, indeed, kindness. For the rest, it is up to the rest of society to act. So, yes, in our AI strategy, there is a whole section on adoption with a social part that encourages initiatives like yours, so let's go for it!

In Marseille, a lot has been done in recent years. I mentioned our Entrepreneurship Crossroads. I want to thank all the actors who are here, who have done a lot. We have reached out to many young people, often from the most disadvantaged neighborhoods. We have guided them towards training, towards entrepreneurship, and very often towards digital professions. It turns out that we are reaching digital jobs and digital skills, bringing many young people who, sometimes, did not have academic skills. This is also an element of catching up, of acceleration. So, in this regard, all the initiatives, and School 42, which you are part of, I believe is a wonderful example of this, because it is a test, it is non-academic, so to speak, it’s the pool, if I remember correctly. We select based on specific skills, and then anyone can participate. All these initiatives are very good. So, in both the economic and social aspects, the adoption and dissemination of AI is a battle that is just as important and must be fought in parallel with that of super innovation.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. We will open the fourth and final part of this meeting. It seemed obvious and relevant to us, a month after the execution of Mehdi Kessaci. While Marseille is facing, more than ever, the drifts of drug trafficking, you have exchanged a lot and intervened a lot on the subject. Our fourth part is called "The impact of social networks in the face of violence and organized crime phenomena." You are highly anticipated, Mr. President, on this subject here in Marseille, with our questions.

Speaker

Hello, I am an activist, I live in the northern neighborhoods of Marseille, in the 14th arrondissement. We have already met during your visit. We exchanged, unfortunately, always on these themes. Today, I will ask you my question regarding networks and the link between networks and drug trafficking. Today, it is evident that social networks play as central a role as traditional dealing points for traffickers. Recruitment via apps, the means seem insufficient, yet we need resources to fight against the DZ Mafia and other networks, both on the networks and in the neighborhoods. In the 13th and 14th arrondissements, only 22 to 23 police officers would be deployed on the ground for a population of 140,000 inhabitants. How can we expect the police to be effective on the networks and on the ground under such conditions without putting themselves in danger?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Thank you, Madam. As you said, we all have a thought for the Kessaci family, his mother, his brothers and sisters, after the tragedy that occurred. I want to tell you here that having this thought is also a thought of struggle that I have. And I know the commitment I made to his family. If you allow me, I would like to provide a somewhat comprehensive response on the fight against narcotics. First of all, it did not start yesterday. When we met, we had already begun the fight, and I am trying to keep the commitments I made. A few years ago, we launched a general mobilization against narcotics because we saw that traffickers were organizing themselves and that it was taking on another dimension. We created what we called OFAST, which was a national body that allowed us to put together resources that had previously been completely separate: police, gendarmerie, to track networks across the national territory. In the 13th and 14th arrondissements that you mentioned, I was there in 2021 at the police station, and I made a commitment. Earlier, as soon as I leave you, I will be at the same police station because we have invested, we have created, we have reinvested.

I want to tell you that, above all, we have restored resources. The prefect can give you the figures, but it is not at all that. In recent years, in accordance with the commitments I made, we have added 500 police officers net in Marseille. Which, taking into account departures, means 300 police officers net more. 500 more, 200 departures. There are more than 300 police officers on the Marseille plate. With a permanent harassment action, we have mobilized, mobilized, mobilized. We have also said each time, point of deal by point of deal, we have reduced them by half, the physical dealing points. The follow-up rate has tripled. So, it is very hard to hear when we have experienced what we have experienced there. You mentioned a recent tragedy as well, Madam Principal, earlier. But we will not give up, and I want to salute the mobilization of the prefects, of all the security teams, of the magistrates who are here. We have now moved to a second stage. We have made the narcotics law and we said: we are setting up a national command staff, a national prosecutor's office that will be established on January 5. We are restoring resources, and we are putting resources back into Marseille because, in fact, the more we create, the more we pursue.

The more we pursue, the more we have coming into the courts. So, we are restoring courtrooms, we are restoring magistrates. We have already created several dozen in recent years. So we will not give up anything, we must bombard. Now, we must also adapt to practice. Let’s be clear. You are absolutely right, social networks have become, in essence, places of trafficking. So, what do we want to do? 1) We will go after them, we will hold them accountable, we will engage in dialogue. Today, we have very limited means. We will go after them, we will tell them: you are recruiting young people, you are endangering the lives of others. One time out of two, we manage to make the withdrawal, one time out of two, they tell us: it’s in our terms of sale. So, we will change the European standard to be able to pursue them, hold them accountable, and attack them, which is currently very difficult for us. First point.

The second point that is absolutely fundamental is the heads of networks. This is what we are currently shaking up. You referred to a few well-known networks. We are currently shaking everything up. The Minister of Justice has made several diplomatic visits, the national director of the judicial police, I will do so in the coming days, to seek cooperation in the countries where the heads of networks are, to seize their assets, to arrest the heads of networks, to return them to us. This is the key to all of this. We have hardened our position by doing what? These neighborhoods fighting against organized crime, by placing them precisely in super-secured neighborhoods where we ensure that there are no more phones, no more contact, and where there is an unprecedented level of security management in French prisons. This is what the Minister of Justice announced a few months ago. So, the system, we tighten, we tighten, we tighten. But we must be clear, as we tighten, they will continue to react. As we tighten, they will continue to intimidate. This is what they did with Mehdi.

They wanted to instill fear. The road will be long, but we must not give up anything. We have results. It is because we are bombarding. And let me just make one last point, because there is often an absent in these discussions. I say this here for all those who are here and for the readers. None of this would happen if there were not people who, kindly, buy cocaine, hash, etc. I am fed up with having young people we mourn, and in neighborhoods having other people who consider it festive to buy drugs and who are generally not from the same social backgrounds. A few years ago, we said there must be criminal prosecution. As we could not carry out a criminal prosecution, it took a long time, because we had to bring them to the station, etc. We implemented, it is an innovation of recent years, a fixed penalty for offenses. Immediately, we could impose the fine. This allowed us to start moving things forward.

Now, we will drastically change two things. 1) The recovery procedures. We will appoint Republic commissioners to help public finances and justice recover them, because we have recovery rates that are not satisfactory. 2) We will raise the fine to 500 euros. 500 euros, because we need to hit the wallets of those we catch with drugs in the city, because it is not festive to get high. It is not the same as things that are legal. There is what is legal and illegal in a democracy. It is just that everyone who consumes drugs should be well aware that they are fueling the drug trafficking that is destroying our cities and neighborhoods. If we do not make this clear to people, we are targeting the wrong audience.

Speaker

I would like to respond to the second question. The judicial and repressive aspect is very important, but we see public service budgets drastically decreasing; social centers, local missions, which are an important or even essential part of the fight against trafficking, are losing a lot. In the city of Marseille, we are lucky with the city adding one and a half million more per year, but we have the Metropolis and the region that are reducing or even eliminating their support.

Mr. President, we do not need to remind you of the importance of public service in popular neighborhoods, so why not, as part of Marseille en Grand, include the funding of social centers and all other public services that are suffering in the neighborhoods and the associations that work to implement the policy you want for our neighborhoods? I know that Marseille is dear to you. You came to see us in neighborhoods where Presidents did not come, where no one went, but public services are suffering. I am a board member of a social center that sees its subsidies decrease year after year while we are supposed to be representative of France and all its strength.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, you are right that alongside the repressive aspect, there is the preventive and educational side. It is very important. That is also why I asked for massive prevention campaigns to be set up to explain to young people and less young people the ravages of drugs and to raise awareness, as we have been able to do on road safety, on the issue of drugs and narcotics. Then, I will allow myself to tell you that in Marseille, I will make many jealous, but Marseille en Grand is a plan that has no equivalent. There is no other city that we have supported in the same way. In Marseille, we have deployed two-thirds of the amounts we committed to. That is to say, there is more than 3 billion euros, in addition to all the normal funding that has been put into Marseille. More than 3 billion euros. And on competencies that are not at all the competencies of the State normally. That is to say, schools, we have already engaged more than 87. There is no other city in France where the State finances schools than in Marseille. Not one other.

After that, I am not here to prosecute your local authorities, but the State cannot replace municipal, departmental, or regional associations. It is up to your local authorities to do that. I can tell you one thing. We have put an unprecedented amount on education in Marseille for prevention and education, both pedagogical and building-related. But also and above all, since you are talking to me about prevention, when we launched Marseille en Grand, there was a dire need for health services in the northern neighborhoods. On health in Marseille, not just in the northern neighborhoods, but everywhere, we are putting, State, more than 800 million euros. We are transforming a military hospital, which we will reopen Laveran, which will be open to all. La Timone, it’s a revolution, and all the local authorities are there, your department and your region too, alongside the city. The Women’s House, opened. And we have opened 7 dispensaries, particularly in the northern neighborhoods and in the city center, 7 dispensaries. There is no other city where we have done this. So this policy, the State is indeed behind it, including on the prevention side.

Moderator

Thank you. A quick question, Mr. President, perhaps on the collaboration between platforms and justice. We mentioned earlier some platforms that are the supports for many drug traffics, can justice go much further and compel this collaboration? Because we know that, as we said, young people are recruited on social networks, the prostitution of young people is also on social networks, linked to drug trafficking. How can justice go a little further, even further than what you just indicated?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, this is a very complicated subject because it is not just about social networks, and that is also why I do not want to make caricatures. It is a subject that involves social networks and encrypted messaging. Today, what is true is that traffickers use certain social networks, particularly those that have more instant messaging with self-destructing messages, to sell to their clients. Right now, we do not have mechanisms that are effective enough, and that is what we are working on. We can have their cooperation to lift identities and go after people judicially, but the judicial process, as you know, is very slow. It takes months, sometimes years, because everything is congested. We do not have immediacy today, and what we are trying to change is to be able to activate much faster and especially to be able to cut off. For that, we need to toughen the rules; it is an ongoing battle.

On the side, there is recruitment. Recruitment is much more insidious. It is very hard because they sometimes use codes to say: it is totally forbidden or not, because these are messages that are much less clear, much more gray, but above all, if we chase them off certain social networks, they will go to encrypted messaging. And encrypted messaging is a completely different matter. So, what we are doing now is building first protocols for cooperation, but also, there is a whole dialogue between our intelligence services and the legal experts, because obviously, we must protect public freedoms and individual liberties. You do not want to be in a society of 100% control. But in order to observe these behaviors, to see the messaging that does not cooperate, and to identify those who are being recruited, but especially the recruiters. So that is a point on which we have improved. It is a point on which, thanks to our investigative services, and I want to pay tribute to the work of the judicial police, all our police services, the intelligence services that operate on national and international soil, and our magistrates. We have made a lot of progress, but we have a problem with the speed of action and immediacy. For that, we need to change the rules and we need to move much faster to the source.

Moderator

Thank you very much. There are still two questions to finish. You mentioned earlier the PNACO, the national prosecutor's office that will be established. Many here are calling for a Marseille branch. Could you announce it to us today?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, but I will tell you, you know, the priority is efficiency, and so it is a national prosecutor's office. It is next to the national headquarters for the fight against organized crime that has been set up; it works if they are close. There is a very strong Marseille branch; there is a tradition of a very strong judicial police in Marseille. What you need to understand is that, in fact, efficiency, to use a football metaphor, "the ball must circulate, the ball must move." There needs to be harassment on the local front, meaning that we need to break down the very local deals as soon as they establish themselves. There needs to be police presence; that is why we have reinstated police and magistrate personnel; there needs to be local follow-up. But it is essential that the case is immediately connected to national and international levels if it makes sense. It happens that Marseille, which suffers so much, is a port city, because it is an open city to the world, it is the epicenter of international networks, which have their heads of networks in several Mediterranean countries.

Some of their heads of networks are in our prisons and in our neighborhoods fighting against organized crime. After that, they have victims in our neighborhoods; they go looking for them. And sometimes, they even recruit them in cities outside. So the key is speed, interconnection among all. We have a single team. And do not worry, whether it is in Marseille, whether it is in Paris, whether it is deployed elsewhere in the posts we have abroad in the various capitals of the concerned countries, we act together to quickly dismantle these networks. We have a battle here, and it must be said, there is a war that has been declared against these networks that today kill innocent young people to intimidate, want to instill fear, simply because they want to replace public order. They want the law of the strongest. They want the law of the narcos. There is no chance that they will win.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President, I am a street mediator for the APIS association. My job consists of going directly to the field, day and night, in sensitive neighborhoods, at the foot of buildings, at drug trafficking points, to create links, dialogue with young people, residents, in order to dissuade some from turning to delinquency, and for the residents, to resolve everyday issues. We met on September 1, 2021, at the Bassens housing project. I had recommended two things to you, Mr. President: the follow-up of the Marseille en Grand plan and education. It is on education that I want to return. Why? In January 2024, I am with a group of teenagers in the Parc Corot housing project; I decide to take them to visit the Motorcycle Museum. Upon leaving the Motorcycle Museum, we come across the body of a young woman who has been burned.

What was the reaction of these young people? To instantly pull out their smartphones, film, and share on social media. To share on social media the charred body of a young woman. Just last night, I was with the father of Abderrahim, who would like to meet you. He was asking me: are there other videos of my son circulating on social media? My question is very simple: Mr. President, today, I am on the ground; I have created a project called "Mediation Nomade," which is poorly supported. What resources are allocated for prevention? I affirm to you that we have very few resources for delinquency prevention today in Marseille, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, and thank you to your associations once again. You said, and it is through associations like yours that I have seen every time I have been to Marseille and which have been at the heart of the building of Marseille en Grand, that we can reconquer. It will not happen overnight. I know there is sometimes fatigue, as you said earlier; it is hard, it is long, but we must absolutely not give up in this fight. This fight begins in families. That is everything we continue to support with the first thousand days. If we neglect the first three years of a child's life, it is absolutely terrible. So, the fight, the support for families, parenting, is key.

Then, there is school. That is also why we want to protect our schools from mobile phones, from social networks. These are the measures we are taking and which are key. Because the young people you described, if we had trained them not to have a phone all the time, not to be on social media all the time, they would not have that reflex. So, the school that we must strengthen, the training of our teachers, the support, the resources we give them. The third is the support with the city, the Metropolis, the department, the region, all the actors of the entire associative fabric to ensure that, from sports to education to prevention, as Madame mentioned, with social centers, we recognize that a young person's life does not stop at the school gates. That is why I believe a lot in our local committees of the foundation, our local CNRs that we set up in recent years. I regret that they have not been sufficiently mobilized. They worked very well in Marseille.

What we have done with Marseille en Grand regarding schools, you may remember, I said in September 2021: we are going for it; I want 50 schools. We have far exceeded 50. That is on the educational plan. We have more than 80 schools that are being rebuilt, renovated. But above all, we have launched educational projects. These educational projects are wonderful, meaning we have teachers with school principals, parents, and associations who work together, who sit around the table to build common educational actions and do prevention. It is a matter of weaving, if I may say, every day. So, we will not give up on the education aspect of Marseille en Grand; it is one of the 7 key components. It can be followed transparently. All these components, we have put a website online that is now public. You can go there. It is on the Élysée website. We have Marseille en Grand. You can follow it; all the actions are there. By the way, you can write to correct, give your opinion. But what is very important is to not give up. So, on education, we will continue to allocate resources because, as you said, prevention is key. So, supporting associations like yours and, in connection with the city, being able to give you the means to engage these young people, to occupy these young people, to have time and teach them the right behaviors.

I emphasize the website; it is very important because we have compiled data that is all public. You can see, on the different components, education, health, security. So, there are 7 pillars. It is on the site l'Élysée.fr. You have an item Marseille en Grand, and you can do this follow-up. And if there are comments, questions, things, we will improve.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Thank you for allowing us this time for exchange, for having permitted it in this city that you love, and thank you for loving it, which represents a bit of what France has best and also what it has worst, unfortunately. I am a chartered accountant, specialized in supporting innovative companies, and so it is also an opportunity for me, very quickly, to thank you for everything you have done for this innovation ecosystem, which was not the same before you. Thank you. I am the initiator of the collective "Marseille au pluriel," which is supported by citizens, business leaders, journalists, including Philippe Pujol, whom you know, but also the university and the Chamber of Commerce, whose president I salute. We work to recreate links, that should resonate with you, between the people of Marseille, using the tools of interculturalism. We do this by doing things together, with simple and effective methods, by creating bridges between the associative world and businesses, which is a powerful and, in my opinion, underestimated lever to rebuild cohesion and society as you said. Our approach is pragmatic; it is based on reciprocity and the affirmation of a common, clear, recognized, and accepted framework in which differences can express all their richness. Our obsession, really, every day, is cohesion.

We believe that another path is still possible to avoid having to choose between the plague and cholera in 2027, by rallying the silent majority around a common vision of our society to be written, far from political divides. For us, this third way is interculturalism. I come to my question. Social networks have become a strategic tool for organized crime, especially among young people, as we have seen throughout this exchange. The problem is not only security-related; it is also cultural, identity-related, and symbolic. Where the State often responds only with repression, and it has no choice, social networks offer young people a narrative, recognition, and a sense of belonging. They are therefore cultural amplifiers. This is precisely where interculturalism has its place.

Here is my question: in the face of the growing impact of social networks in the recruitment and normalization of organized crime among young people, why not explore the path of interculturalism as a matrix for our public policies to build, especially on social networks, but not only, strong counter-narratives, common reference points, and a republican sense of belonging, rather than leaving the symbolic ground to those who thrive on division? I will not finish by saying that we are forever the first, even if I am absolutely convinced of it, but what I would like is to allow us, universities, us, Chambers of Commerce, to meet with you to show you what we can concretely do here, because it works. If we are given the means, we believe that, perhaps, we could take this experimentation a little further in the country and rebuild society. Thank you.

Thank you for these initiatives and what you are advocating. Fundamentally, of course, we must encourage exactly what you are saying. I do not know if there is a single counter-narrative, but in what you have said, there is one thing that is very true: if we have young people who are led towards the worst projects. What we said about the drug trade was true at one point and may still be true of projects, for example, Islamist terrorist ones, that may have existed on these same networks. It is that they give, in a way, the feeling that there is a possible future and perspectives, for some financial, for others meaningful. So, you are right, there is a narrative behind it. In any case, there is the feeling that there is a possible future. That is the catastrophe. In our fight, we must first show that it is primarily a narrative of death that these networks propose.

And they exploit cannon fodder. They exploit young people whom they lead into situations of extreme danger to be sacrificed, to be killed here or there. It is a project of death. There is a terrible cynicism. But behind it, and more broadly, it is a bit in the background of the debate we have been having, what you describe. We have a crisis of the common in our democracies, which has deep roots; I do not want to end with overly philosophical remarks, but we have societies that have secularized, meaning that religion has gradually receded, which provided a framework; families have disintegrated. In any case, there is a crisis of the family model, we can see that clearly. We have more and more families that we call "single-parent." We also have many young people who have fragmented family structures. We have an individualism that has increased, which creates a much stronger vision of society, an isolation. Social networks, they do not bear all the responsibility, but they have come as an accelerator of these transformations in our societies. They have accelerated an individualization, and I would say a loneliness that goes with it, which I described earlier. It is a reality. This loneliness gives a great vertigo because I feel constantly alone in something that is unexplained, misunderstood by others, and at the same time, faced with a multitude without filter, which can be the message from the end of the world, the volume of these messages, their repetition, the clash.

And I am exposed, that was the first question, your word struck me, to an "overabundance." And what does that create? It creates permanent uncertainty. We are in a society where the reference points we had have been somewhat shaken, where there is more and more loneliness and where there is an overabundance of messages. All of this creates a form of loss of common rules and reference points. Sociologists used to call this "anomie." It is an old concept from DURKHEIM. We could say a bit of disorder, but that is what we are experiencing. As a result, it creates mechanisms of great anxieties that we still see on climate issues among our young people or less young people, which we see on technological issues related to these, or that we see, as soon as society heats up, has a frenzy. We are in societies that have changed because of all this. So, in the face of this, we must absolutely recreate what has been the heart of the republican struggle, which has made us individuals, free and rational as we are, different. That is to say, recreate, preserve the individualities that we are, but by reinstating critical thinking and rationality. That is why the heart of the battle is to protect and educate the youngest, to restore critical thinking to take a step back, and that can be taught at all ages, and thus relearn, redistinguish the notions, regulate.

Then, we must succeed in restoring the common, it is essential. So, to give back, as I said, to the family, to the school, to associations, to the community, to businesses, to what brings us together in a collective project, meaning and time. Many of these networks have stolen a lot of time from us. And giving time back to this common good also means realizing that we are not just individuals living between their solitude and what they make of it with their family or the choices that are theirs, and a job. There is something in the middle of that which is a life in society that, sometimes, in the workplace or in a civic common space, means that we build something together. That is exactly it, making a republic. It is very important, every day, to restart these projects, even if it may seem exhausting, and especially to give them importance and recognition. By being here and telling you this, I say it with great importance. It is not the million people who will see something that they will forget the next second. It is perhaps the dozens of lives that you will change with a project because you will have taken people by the hand for months, years, and you will have meaning in your own life.

In this regard, the framework of the Republic can be one of understanding and crossing cultures. It takes place in a framework that is that of universalism. The Republic is based on the fact that we are citizens, and that we come with convictions, religions, origins, that we will learn to know each other, but that we belong to a narrative that is greater than us and that we still want to write. Being a nation is that. It is never fixed. It is to say that we still have great battles to fight because what holds us together are the great battles we have fought together. It is the great history that has made us, and it is exactly what you have described.

Moderator

Thank you very much, Mr. President. It seemed to me that there was a bit of a conclusion in your remarks. If you would like to say a word to conclude, perhaps, and to talk to us about what comes next. I wanted to thank you for your presence this morning. On behalf of the teams at La Provence, the event teams that organized this meeting, thank you for the exchanges we have just had with all of our teams and these 280 readers who are here from our territories and who also needed to carry this message.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Thank you to La Provence for this exchange. As for the assessment, I will continue in Marseille to go to the field, to see the achievements and what remains to be done for Marseille en Grand. I will continue to report and then continue the collective work for Marseille en Grand. You can count on me. What I wanted to tell you is that beyond this debate, decisions will be made. At the beginning of next year, I will announce very concrete decisions for the youngest. We have already talked about it in substance. We will implement these decisions in France to protect our children and adolescents, at school and outside of school. Then, we will launch the European battle, a new step, to better protect our democracies against interference, but also to better protect against drug trafficking, against the misuse of networks. The third battle will be a national one that will take place on the press. There have been the États généraux de l'information. There is clearly an economic model that is in crisis and that has prompted work, and therefore there will be work to determine how we can ensure that the economic model of free information is preserved.

Then, there is a fourth battle, which is yours. It is a civic battle every day. What we have been talking about since the beginning is the battle of the Republic, I told you just now. When the Republic was formed, it said: I am looking for black hussars, the teachers, to go and seek the children in all the countryside and ensure that they spell, speak, and write the same language, know the same authors and know the same poems. Some will love them, others will not. But they will belong to the same story to be able to do things together. That is exactly the battle we are rediscovering. These same fighters from the beginning of the Third Republic said I do not want a public space, a democracy of false appearances where information can be monopolized by a few, manipulated. I want people who can organize the controversy freely, give you facts, opinions, and you will exchange them. These are the great laws of the press.

That is exactly what we must rediscover. The battle of the Republic has been to preserve, from all foreign interventions, from all risks, from all laws of the strongest, the law of all, which is ours. That is exactly what we must recreate. The only thing that weakens our democracies is not daring to have difficult debates, it is not putting things in place. The only thing, and this is true in all areas, is inefficiency and slowness. And believe me, I have often made mistakes. But my worst mistakes have been the "what's the point." It is when I was told, let’s not go too fast, do not do this or that. When we have identified that there is a problem, we must charge ahead. The only thing that creates distrust and makes many people say: "ah, ultimately, an authoritarian regime would be better than democracy," is because the same people who tell us we are totalitarian as soon as we want to regulate something for the young are the ones who tell you that there should be a good authoritarian regime when the law no longer suits them. No!

Democracy is demanding for everyone. It requires deliberation, transparency, but it must regain a sense of efficiency. So yes, we must find a democracy that, when it seizes a problem, makes the right decisions and acts. You have understood, from our children to the functioning of democracy, we still have plenty of things to do, but we will get there.

Moderator

Thank you very much, Mr. President, and thank you all.