In front of the readers of La Voix du Nord in Arras.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

19 November 2025 · Meeting with readers of La Voix du Nord · Arras

Context
Macron addressed readers of La Voix du Nord in Arras in November 2025, speaking at a school complex symbolic of the 2023 terrorist attack, to debate disinformation and democratic resilience.
Main themes
Disinformation and information warfare, democracy and free press, hybrid war, social media and platform accountability, artificial intelligence, regional press and civic engagement, terrorism and national resilience, geopolitical change, the human brain as ultimate weapon, rearmament and security
Duration
~184 min
99th percentile
Words
22,097
99th percentile
Sentences
1,296
99th percentile
Readability
60
88th percentile
Grade
9.1
12th percentile
Syntax
2.82
24th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
8th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 35%32%
  • Institutional 22%20%
  • Technological 16%14%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 10%9%
  • Economic 3%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 9%

1,296 sentences in 226 paragraphs

Mr. President, Mr. Minister, we are very fortunate to welcome you here, but I would first like to thank our readers for their patience, because it is not always easy, but also because — and there is a recent study that highlighted this — regional press readers in particular are often active citizens. That is how we recognize them. I believe that is also why we are organizing this kind of mobilization today.

So, thank you for participating in this meeting, which I think is relatively unique, rare. It is an initiative that has been shared and taken by the Élysée, to have the opportunity to meet you on societal issues that are extremely important, which are the very foundations of democracy, the solidity of information, the quality of our exchanges, and of course, the way we create collective meaning within our societies.

So, the world is changing. It is changing very, very quickly. We see new geopolitical relationships emerging. Important power dynamics are manifesting at different levels, unfortunately also on the military stage. So this obviously requires us to rearm, and that is important. Not everyone is always ready for that; we may have forgotten a bit. But conflict zones today are not always on the military field. Things have evolved significantly. We are facing a hybrid war, and I think that is partly why we are here today to debate, where each of us is concerned about what is happening. It is not just happening in Ukraine; it is happening in our societies, and it is important to understand the stakes.

For as long as I can remember, I would say, the most powerful weapon is not, contrary to what most people think, the atomic weapon or the atomic bomb. The ultimate weapon is the human brain. It is this human bomb that the group Téléphone spoke about a few years ago. This weapon is shaped, nourished, and directed through vast ecosystems of communication and more particularly of information. So, alongside the content that is editorially responsible, produced by professional journalists in companies that are legally responsible for what they publish, which is what we represent within the Rossel group and within La Voix du Nord, a true industry of disinformation has developed alongside this information industry. And that is new.

This disinformation industry is powerful, it is tentacular, it has no responsibility, it is unregulated, and it currently has financial means that are disproportionate compared to what the information media, which some call traditional, have at their disposal. This is an absolutely fascinating subject, vital for our democracies. It is on this debate that we want to bring you, to engage you. And so, I think this is a unique opportunity.

I obviously thank President Macron for providing this opportunity, since it is our role, as press organs, to connect our readers, who are, as I explain, passionate people, who read, who inform themselves, who want to remain active citizens, with the head of state, in order to understand and be able to debate these societal issues that are fundamental for our democracies. Thank you for your presence, Mr. President. Thank you for your presence also in a rather symbolic place in Arras. Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. Thank you, Mr. Marchant, for your words, your welcome, and your organization. Thank you to all the teams at La Voix du Nord for hosting us and organizing this debate. I will not be long because I mainly want to be able to answer your questions.

I want to first say that it is very moving for me to be by your side and to be not just in Arras, but in this place that has marked the life of the nation in recent years, and almost two years to the day, since we are now in November, but no one has forgotten that day in October 2023, and we were with part of the team, obviously, the wife of Dominique and part of the educational team, but I want to say from here how much all of this has marked the life of the nation, this terrorist attack here in this school complex.

And to meet you again to debate precisely the strength of our democracy in Arras in this school complex is, for me, a whole symbol. What the teachers do, the family, is a commitment that is truly the commitment of the Republic and of the school, which is to say that we must yield nothing to barbarism and obscurantism.

At its core, if I think that the debate we have started to have and that we will continue together today is important, it is because I believe it truly touches on the life of the nation. We have settled, over the last 10 years, into a system where, fundamentally, more and more, we learn, we exchange, we inform ourselves, we sometimes build knowledge and our public opinion through platforms, social networks, and now artificial intelligence agents, because all of this is a continuum of innovation, which has models, economic interests, and economic models that we did not quite understand at the beginning. And I think there have been many misunderstandings. But we have somewhat delegated the lives of our children, our adolescents, our democracy to these systems.

Now, there is a lot of good in these systems, which is why we use them. We can easily access information from the other side of the world, knowledge. We can share alerts and thereby manage to protect ourselves, to be a more alert society. Moreover, the Internet, like social networks, was initially conceived by people who primarily wanted to spread knowledge and experiences. But when we end up somewhat locking ourselves into these bubbles, and we will come back to this, I think, in the debate, something goes awry.

I think we need to collectively realize that for our children and adolescents, the situation is becoming problematic. For all of us adults, something is changing in our democratic life, that is to say, the very way we are forging our opinions, the way we are constructing our opinions, in our relationship to what is a truth, a fact or not, is changing. We are becoming increasingly vulnerable, through these social networks, but also the role that artificial intelligence now plays, we are becoming increasingly vulnerable to informational attacks. What you just said very well, indeed, the human brain, the functioning of our democracies can be manipulated by interferences that use this information. On all these subjects, I think we need a heightened awareness, because all of this has experienced a very strong acceleration. And fundamentally, it was around the year 2015 that we had an opening, a democratization of the major social networks. So, we have 10 years of hindsight.

I ran my first presidential campaign in 2017. For the younger ones, that must seem like a long time ago. But in reality, we were starting to campaign on social networks. It was quite unprecedented. Today, it seems totally banal to you. So there was, in 2015, the spread: it has been 10 years that we have all our young people, our teenagers. And we have regulated very little; they have been completely exposed to TikTok, Instagram, Snapchat, X, etc. Something happened, we can measure it. Then, there is a very important second phase which was COVID, where, being sent back to confinement, to solitude, the time of exposure to screens increased significantly. Then, in recent years, there has been an acceleration of informational interferences. In 2022, the Russian aggression war in Ukraine, the acceleration of international tensions, all of this has further transformed things. We must see that in 10 years, there has really been a revolution in these uses and in what has happened in our democracies. I believe that today is really the time, both for awareness and for action. That is why I find these debates very important. I do not want to be longer. I want to express my gratitude for organizing this debate, for being welcomed here, in front of this climbing wall, which is behind your screen, since I am discovering it as you are, and to thank you all, readers, for having, I know, sometimes made some journeys, to be present today and to be able to debate.

Host

Hello everyone. Mr. President of the Republic. Hello, Mr. Minister. Hello to all our readers who have come in large numbers today. We are going to host this exceptional “face to readers,” which is dedicated to democracy, tested by social networks and algorithms.

To begin, I will first present the outline of these two hours that we will spend together. We will start with the first half hour dedicated to disinformation, conspiracy theories, and algorithmic bubbles. A second theme will be devoted to interferences, sovereignty, and dependencies on platforms. In reality, who governs our digital space? We will then continue with children, adolescents, and mental health. How can we protect the youngest without cutting them off from the world? And we will extend this theme with a fourth part on education, critical thinking, and artificial intelligence. How can we equip the citizens of tomorrow?

Mr. President, we therefore propose that you answer our readers' questions in a direct and spontaneous exchange, as we like to do in the “Face to Readers” of La Voix du Nord. One question, one answer.

[Video excerpt]

Hostess

Thank you to the colleagues for this short video. As we can see, the Internet is the Wild West. Our informational space is distorted by platforms and algorithms that play on fears, that stoke hatred, particularly via social networks.

Mr. President, you mentioned during the Paris Forum for Peace, about fifteen days ago, a phenomenon of democratic degeneration. According to you, the people who inform us through these networks are not free and independent media, and the platforms are not made to share information, but to sell personalized advertising, with the consequences we know. We are therefore facing algorithms that prioritize emotion; we observe the rise of conspiracy theories, and in the end, internet users, our readers, we find it difficult to distinguish the true from the false.

Just yesterday, a few days after the commemorations of the November 13 attacks, our colleagues from Le Monde pointed out that a rumor about an act of torture committed at the Bataclan had been exhumed by the far right and wrongly confirmed by Elon Musk's artificial intelligence, Grok, which invented false testimonies from victims of November 13. That is the general context.

Host

35% is the percentage of French people who believe in at least one conspiracy theory. In this context, print newspapers remain the most credible. This is good news for La Voix du Nord. 66% of French people trust us, while only 35% trust online media. One last figure to frame this debate: 51% is the percentage of French people who have been exposed to misinformation in the last three months.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. Hello everyone. Thank you to you and La Voix du Nord for this meeting and for this debate. So, due to my profession, I meet many people from all social categories, all ages. Since after COVID, I notice that more and more, I have people who share conspiracy theories with me, at least their credulity regarding that, saying: “No, but COVID didn't exist, we are being manipulated.” When I inquire about where they get this information, of course, it is on the Internet, on the platforms. Similarly, when I conduct a survey of who reads the press, who watches labeled media, we are currently at 20%.

Hence my concern regarding this disinformation which, for me, threatens our democracy and this freedom of expression. Can we leave it unchecked from all sides? So, the question is: how to fight against this disinformation, especially among older audiences who have not been sensitized, I would say, to a critical analysis of this information? So, for me, this is a real concern, and I really see a rise in credulity regarding this information that is spread on the Net and read by these people who indeed believe what they see.

Emmanuel MACRON

No, you are absolutely right. What you are citing is what we are experiencing pretty much everywhere. We will come back to the younger ones. You are right to mention our elders. Because when we look at the accounts that are often the most problematic, contrary to popular belief, it is often people over 60 who massively relay false information that they sincerely believe and that they found on these networks.

So, there is not a single miracle solution to address the issues you raise. We need to tackle both the content, we need to support, train, and teach everyone how to navigate the digital space. That is our challenge. So, there is both regulation, responsibility, and then there is education, training in critical thinking.

The first element is to ask: how do we deal with false information? Our problem is that when we talk about social networks, there is no editorial responsibility. If La Voix du Nord publishes false information, I can file a complaint. I will take legal action against them and I will say, I will request a retraction, and see if I can sue them, it will cost them money. That is why they try to do everything every day to avoid publishing false information and there is an ethics, a deontology to do so. But all of this, we built it. These are our press laws from the late 19th century. On the Internet, you do not have that. If I am X, if I am TikTok or another platform, I have no responsibility.

We started moderation in 2018, we engaged with this platform, we had done something, sorry for the anglicism, called Tech for Good, to say you must moderate. They had somewhat committed. So, I can tell you, those who started to engage after the election of President Trump, they completely stopped. Because they are now in a logic they call free speech. But it is not freedom, it is the Wild West. It is the law of the strongest. So today, we are fighting to try to do moderation. You have editorial teams, because it happens on their site, that do it. But today, there is no moderation.

So the first thing, we want to have these contents removed. So there, we took a European directive, which is the directive that regulates services. We started. All of this is very slow, it is too slow. We took it in 2022 at the initiative of France, but we want to be able to force them to moderate and remove these false contents. First point.

The second point is that, and you mentioned it a bit earlier in your introduction, we need to know where we are. That is to say, when I buy a newspaper, I pay to get information. This newspaper will earn money, perhaps, from legal notices or advertising, but the core is the subscriptions or the issue that you will pay for. So, this information has value. I know how it lives. When I go on Twitter, when I go on X now, when I go on TikTok or others, I do not pay. So, you have to ask yourself why they give me all this content. They are not philanthropists. They do it because they collect information about me to sell it to advertisers because, in fact, they will make their money from advertising. This is not a criticism. That is how they have constituted themselves.

So, where we are all collectively, we have put ourselves in a somewhat paradoxical situation, is that we are increasingly informed by social networks whose economic model is not at all to inform us, but to sell personalized advertising. As they are clever and well-organized, they want to sell as much as possible. To sell as much as possible, they need to create dependency, that is to say, I need you to go more and more on my networks, I need to have more and more information about you. So, I will not seek to inform you because that is not what will make you come. I will rather create excitement, because that is what will make you stay. It is true, the algorithms are designed that way. I will make sure to push you the content that creates the most excitement so that you stay on my network. What means that what we will push to you is rather content that will create negative emotions because those are the ones that create the most excitement. So, in reality, a system where the economic model of networks is to create excitement to sell personalized advertising cannot work. Otherwise, we think we will be informed. There is no chance. So, the second thing is that we need to clarify the debate at the European level by saying: "we must have networks that inform and we must have networks that sell personalized advertising." It must be clear, but it cannot be the same element.

The third thing, we will come back to it, I do not want to be longer, is the algorithms. It is that, in reality, since it is to sell personalized advertising, the contents that will be pushed to me, there is someone who pushes them. It is not an invisible hand. It is not you who will seek them, they are pushed to you. You have put in a keyword. We have seen, there is your history in the network, so we know what you are more likely to search for. By the way, strangely, you find things. Sometimes, you will have an ad that corresponds to something you asked for the definition of two days earlier, on which you informed yourself. You have all experienced this experience like me. This is the demonstration of what I just said.

There is an algorithm behind it. This algorithm is completely opaque. When I buy La Voix du Nord, I know the editorial line. It is signed, it is clear. And then, there are lots of things, it is not an editorial line, it is facts. Here, there is a hidden editor. It is the algorithm. And this algorithm is biased because it will create this excitement. Sometimes, by the way, it will create political biases because I have understood that, for example, the owner of X had political opinions and even intervened in the political scene. At other times, it can interfere. The owner of TikTok is in China, he has interests, they are not the same as mine. And so, the third element, we need to have transparency of the algorithm.

So regarding what you have described, we need to regulate to remove false information, we need to truly separate information and personalized advertising, and we need to have transparency, that does not mean banning them, but transparency so that we know where the algorithm leads us and that you know, when you use it. Alongside that, we need to continue training, we will come back to it later, I understood for the younger ones. But for the older ones, we need to train precisely on all of this. So that must be what we are doing, it is a debate we must share to understand that there are biases.

Speaker

A little anecdote, I have noticed that algorithms are stupid and mean, they are produced by humans. So, in fact, humans can somewhat constrain them. So I like or follow pages that are contrary to my own opinions. That way, it allows me to have in my feed a whole bunch of documentation that is completely contrary to my idea, but at least I am not followed. There you go, that is the little anecdote.

I allow myself to ask the question that comes to me. I will make a parallel first between real life and digital life in the so-called digital life. In real life, our surroundings, more or less close, we have opinions, sometimes, that diverge. However, we do not insult each other. Generally, we do not hit each other either. Whereas in digital life, especially on social networks, there is like a screen, it is the case to say, that immediately leads to clashes, immediately, we threaten to death the person we have in front of us. In fact, there is no space, how to say, of constraint that allows us to restrain ourselves and to say, I will not go there, I will not do that in real life. Why is there this in digital life? I do not know. So there may be a clue, it is what we have in our pocket. When we walk around in real life, we have our identity card. So when we do things that are against the law, you said it, we can be prosecuted. In digital life, that is not the case.

So, would the solution not be to move towards a digital identity to be able to prosecute people without going to the extreme case of a super securitization of this space of freedom which is important? Personally, I am rather pleased that the European Parliament rejected the Chat Control Directive. It is a debate. But you, what do you think of this balance? How to achieve this balance between the necessary anonymization of the digital space and being accountable for the acts we can do and the words we can say on networks?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. First of all, it is a good strategy to be contrary, but it shows how the public space is biased when we are in the digital realm. It is biased in a simple way because beyond what I described earlier about access to information, it locks us into cognitive bubbles. That is to say, it will tend to make us follow people who think like us and that we will be followed by people who think like us. As there is this mechanism of excitement, and we have all experienced it, we no longer hear those who go to extremes. These bubbles will diverge. It is a phenomenon of both confinement and radicalization that we are witnessing if we let the structure develop spontaneously. It is as if, in this room, we started to hit each other because we were all hooded. We will mainly follow the one who hurls the most insults or who becomes the most violent. Very quickly, it is no longer called a debate. So, it is the very possibility of having a collective deliberation that collapses.

Personally, I am not against lifting anonymity, because we are a democratic society and I think it is a good discipline. It is a real debate when we talk about digital services because there are countries where individual freedom is less protected. Obviously, in authoritarian regimes, but even in Europe, you have journalists, academics, sometimes people who express themselves freely, who are troubled because of their ideas. Some tell me, in Hungary, if you are an academic and there is no anonymity, you may get into trouble, so it is not very good. I understand that. Now, we cannot have anonymity and a total absence of moderation. This relates to the question of responsibility. There is a question of individual responsibility. It has been very well said by your colleagues earlier.

It is activated, it just takes a lot of time. If you are going to post anti-Semitic, homophobic content or inciting hatred, I can prosecute you. But it will follow the course of justice. It will be very long and there will be a lifting of your anonymity at the request of justice from the platform. It will take months and it will not regulate you at all. We have something called the PHAROS platform, which means that if you publish homophobic or anti-Semitic content, I will go to the platform and say it needs to be removed. It will do it, but given the number of contents we have, it is very hard. We can see that the only way to avoid this is either to lift anonymity, but with the drawbacks I mentioned, or to create a system of responsibility for platforms. We have the beginning of that in this famous European directive we have implemented, that is to say, to ask platforms to do the same work that a newsroom does. You come to my platform, I have a responsibility. If you start to have hate speech, speech that threatens others or public order, at that moment, I silence you. Today, they do not do it because it costs them money, because it annoys them, and because it results in fewer pages of ads, since there is less excitement.

Even those who had entered a logic of moderation have rather stopped. And they have managed to completely reverse the values through a form of extreme perversity, since they say, they are the defenders of free speech. No one thinks for a second that free speech is the ability to insult, to humiliate. So we just need to remind everyone that there is no freedom without responsibility. That is what we are experiencing. We cannot speak freely around this room if we do not all have the responsibility to listen to each other, not to insult each other, not to hit each other. We are accepting that when we are on social networks, it would be otherwise. It cannot work. There you go, lifting anonymity, but with limits, responsibility of platforms and, on the other hand, very great vigilance. That goes with the transparency of the algorithm, on the fact that when you are on these networks, you are in bubbles. You, you have a good strategy of circumventing which is to seek bubbles where you are not welcome.

Hello, Mr. President, Mr. Minister. Indeed, first a reaction, and then a question that has evolved. A testimony in the context of my duties. For the past three years, I have regularly received advice from children, democratically elected by their peers, and we regularly discuss democracy. Above all, I really enjoy doing a little roundtable to get to know the children who are here and their motivation for being elected. I have noticed that many of them are directly concerned by the issue of school bullying and especially cyberbullying, either directly or through their relatives. This was really something I wanted to talk to you about because today, they feel a bit helpless. They do not know how to take charge of the issue at their level. Obviously, the teaching staff is also there to guide them, as are the representatives. It’s really about how we can help them find solutions for themselves and for their loved ones as well. Then, I wanted to talk about lifting anonymity and especially moderation on social networks. You have made the observation, and on this, I think we all agree. But now, what solutions and especially what sanctions can we apply against all the platforms, the social networks?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. I think that, to be very concrete in relation to the previous answer, it is the responsibility of the platforms and the possibility of having very high criminal fines if they do not carry out moderation. It’s only like that. There are so many operations per second that we cannot follow with a national platform, each one saying that they need to be removed. It must be said that it is your responsibility. If there are people who are victims, there will be criminal action and you will pay dearly. We have started to lay the foundations. Now, it needs to be implemented much faster. It must become a reality. That will be the fight we are waging at the European level. But it is the responsibility of the platforms with very heavy fines. Regarding bullying and online harassment, as you mentioned, it is one of the battles that the Minister of National Education is fighting. We know that there is a continuum. That is to say, often, children who are cyberbullied are the classmates who continue through one network or another. Sometimes, some who are very exposed on social networks can be harassed even by third parties they do not necessarily know and who they will encounter on the networks.

The basis of all this is, again, to be able to penalize and pursue and thus have a responsibility of the platforms. We set up, several years ago, the protection laboratory. This is part of the things on which we have requested mandatory moderation, and they are slow to implement it. So, they are not doing it voluntarily. Four years ago, the platforms were following us; they said, “we will do it voluntarily.” It was at the Paris Peace Forum in 2021. The reality is, they did not do it. That is why I am in favor of fully implementing the directive on services and activating their responsibilities when there is harassment that they allow to happen against one young person or another. After that, I want to reiterate here to all the younger ones, children, adolescents, young adults, there is a number, 3018, which is supported by the Ministry of Education with e-Enfance, which is the association that provides national support and deals with both bullying and cyberbullying. When you are a victim of this, report it, you need to talk about it, you must not let it happen. Talking about it is very important. 3018, your parents, your teachers, and then, disconnect everything.

Speaker

In the context of my professional duties, I meet people from diverse and varied backgrounds, we have the opportunity to discuss various things, and I realize that misinformation has no social origin; it really affects everyone. But with a slight caveat regarding our elders, who may not have had digital training. It’s normal, since when they were young, there was no internet, even less social networks, and even less AI. I have a rather funny example. Last week, with Alain, who was one of my regular clients at the restaurant, 70 years old, and who comes to tell me, “Boris, President Macron is going to declare war on Russia.” Well, I was a bit surprised at first, so I dug a little deeper. It turns out that he was actually in an obscure Facebook group and had clicked on an improbable link that said you were going to go to war with Russia. I personally hope not, in any case. We dug into it together, and I managed to show him, step by step, that indeed, it was false information.

So I did my duty as a citizen, I was quite proud of myself, but I think about the others, all the other Alains, who do not necessarily have that ability to dig a little deeper. It turns out that there is also something important in a little over a year, I won’t hide anything from you, there is a major electoral deadline that will see these elders, these seniors who vote massively, which is very good that these people vote, but who will be a bit more sensitive to misinformation, especially misinformation coming from countries outside our own. My question is quite simple, Mr. President. Is something being considered or is it feasible for our elders, to give them the keys so that, in a little over a year, when they vote, they have all the keys to understand misinformation and electoral issues, because we are talking about several million people.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, thank you very much. This ties into what we were saying, and it is absolutely true, because there is a generation, even generations, that have been educated and accustomed to believing that when it is written, it is true. Because they have been trained to inform themselves through reading the press and in relation to seriousness. And so that is the first thing regarding what is written on social networks. Added to this is the revolution of AI, because I see roughly the false information you are referring to. It was quite well done, since there was even a report showing the Chief of Staff of the Army opposing the President of the Republic, refusing to go to Russia. This surprised, I tell you, the said general, but there was also a bit of AI in their affair. So that needs to enter the debate.

What we are doing has a pedagogical virtue; it is extremely important. So we need to show, explain, and, in a way, collectively educate society. It is a work of vigilance, and in fact, society needs to rebuild its muscle on this subject, because a democratic life is constantly that. And so, that is the work we are doing. It is an eminently democratic, republican task, which is to reform citizens of all ages to say: “this risk exists, here is what is happening.” The second thing is to remove these false information. That is what I was saying. It is a question of responsibility. The third thing we are pushing, we started several years ago, is directly linked to the press, and it ties into what I was saying about “we must distinguish between networks and sites that make money with personalized ads and networks, information sites.” We will do everything to ensure that a label is established. It is not the State's role to say, because we need to be careful, it is not the Government or the State that can say, “this is information, this is not.” We also do not want to fall into that, because that is not democracy. It quickly becomes, otherwise, an autocracy. It is not me who says every morning, “the information from La Voix du Nord is good or not good.” We would be going back 10 steps. However, I think it is important that there is a labeling done by professionals that can say this corresponds to the ethics of people who handle information. Information is actually a dangerous matter. And so, there are ethical rules.

Reporters Without Borders has set up, with several other partners, such an initiative precisely on democracy and information, which has proposed this type of label. The general states of information have consolidated this. So there is a project that is moving forward. The regional daily press, by the way, has been very engaged in this project, the regional daily press, pardon, and the regional weekly press, to say that we must have a labeling process done by professionals, saying: “these are serious people; these are not people who inform.” And I think that is also very useful. We need to raise awareness. And then, we have today actors, sites that are being set up, indicators that are evaluating each person's vulnerability to credulity. So these are things that are a bit more advanced, but in fact, today, we can say on social networks, depending on your behavior, whether you are more of a high-risk audience or not.

Speaker

But there is still an urgency with the elections.

Emmanuel MACRON

The urgency is why we are setting in motion everything we are doing here and why I am doing this tour of France and others; it is first of all collective awareness, reaction, and then changes in European and national law so that we have these mechanisms. But it cannot be top-down all at once. If tomorrow I were to tell you that I am making a series of laws, based on what we are saying, there would be no trust. Everyone needs to be aware of the problem so that we all say we need to react.

We already set up something in 2021 called Viginum. And now, I am transitioning a bit, if I understood correctly, to the second theme. All of this is the structure of misinformation in our country. But as you very well said, there are powers that can use it. And that is what worries you for the upcoming elections. We have set up Viginum, which is a national administrative body that, at the time of elections, comes under the authority of the Constitutional Council and which, precisely, detects these informational interferences. And so when you have a foreign power that comes and tries to disrupt you, it says “halt there,” it sets up an alert. We were inspired in this regard by the example of Taiwan. It may seem strange, but Taiwan, a democracy, but next to a giant that is not one and does not wish it well, and so they were used to having many informational attacks from China. They set up alert systems, initially a bit like Viginum, and then they spread, which means that today, there is a reactivity on social networks. Citizens in Taiwan know very quickly when it is false information. A bit like us, we have the Amber Alert, you see. There is a disinformation alert that becomes hyper-reactive. That is what we need to achieve.

So Viginum is a very good start. We will now try to ramp it up, but we will create mechanisms that detect and denounce informational interferences. And this, alongside what I am saying, is one of the other key points. So responsibility, again, removal of false information, education and awareness of people who have been less trained by public debate, through a work also offering them mediations. We will try to set up public analyses to alert everyone by saying: “be careful, you are sensitive to these manipulations.” And then, we will ramp up with our platform to combat informational interferences. I believe that is the upcoming theme, so I will return to it.

Moderator

We will therefore talk about foreign interference. You have made a perfect link, Mr. President, foreign interference, sovereignty, and dependence on the platforms that govern our digital space. Just two examples. June 2024, a fake campaign site appears online under the identity of the presidential coalition. It promises a Macron bonus, you know well, of 100 euros in exchange for a vote. Well, you can imagine, if it were that simple to win an election, it would be known. At the same time, an action orchestrated by pro-Chinese accounts accuses Raphaël Glucksmann, head of the PS Place Publique list for the European elections, of being a Trojan horse for the CIA in Europe. These information warfare operations have a common point: they aim to undermine the democratic process in France. You mentioned Viginum, which is responsible for combating these operations, raised the alert in early November. The municipal elections, well before the presidential election, will be targeted and are already the subject of destabilization attempts. Is France equipped to counter the plans launched from abroad? Will the state's responses not risk being perceived as attempts to delegitimize any critical discourse against it? These new threats also raise the question of digital sovereignty.

Mr. President, you have just returned from Berlin where the Digital Ministers were gathered. You will obviously tell us what came out of it. In any case, we saw that if the European Union took the bull by the horns, the findings were alarming. I will simply recall a few of them: 70% of French data is hosted in American clouds that are subject to the Cloud Acts, which allow Washington to access it even when it is stored on European soil. Our computing capacity for artificial intelligence is 16 gigawatts, if I am not mistaken. It is 48 gigawatts in the United States and 38 in China. We talked in Berlin about loosening the regulatory straitjacket to develop digital technology. But what is the trade-off? Can we also imagine that we might lose a little bit of regulation and thus unleash a machine that we know can sometimes be uncontrollable?

Moderator

Three figures on issues of interference, sovereignty, and dependence on platforms. First, 77 manipulation operations between 2023 and 2025 have been orchestrated directly by Russian military intelligence. Another figure to keep in mind is the 3 million French people who were exposed in 2023 to false Facebook pages.

And finally, one last figure is 300 billion euros, of which 109 billion is for France. That is the amount that was announced last February to develop European digital infrastructures.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. I regularly serve as an assessor in a polling station in my municipality. I can't help but think that more and more people, it's a bit of a continuation of Boris's question, are coming to vote based on false information. There is an American agency that has identified more than 140 websites that replicate the visual codes of local newspapers, which obviously mix real information and false information. These sites are still online. They are updated quite regularly, so they can be seen quite easily. This American agency has proven that they are funded by Russian military intelligence. I believe it is the CopyCop agency that creates these sites.

My question is twofold. What is the size of the threat regarding our upcoming municipal elections and our next presidential elections? Do we have an idea of the size of this threat? And my second question is the fact that, as you mentioned a bit earlier, the first information we have on a subject is often the one that stays in our minds most strongly; it is the primacy of information. In fact, I feel that no matter what we do, isn't it always too late when we shut down these sites because the information has already been transmitted and we can no longer do anything other than what has already been done? Thank you, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. This is the direct link. And you are absolutely right. I have three remarks. The first, fundamentally, we have an issue regarding our democratic life. We just talked earlier about the distortion of the public space. But this has a consequence on democratic life and elections. Why? A democracy in a rule of law state like ours is obviously about balances between powers, so that there are powers and counter-powers. It is a process of free and independent elections to have legitimate people that you choose or replace and to whom you will give the mandate to make laws in your name. But all of this rests on a foundation that is public opinion. It is the demos, the people. We have probably neglected the forging of public opinion. We have a weak point in our democracy today, which is that opinions are being formed in a way that has become uncontrollable and with many possible falsifications. So that is the first point regarding the democratic process and how our upcoming elections may be at risk; it is how we manage to quickly address false information.

You are right, we have experienced this in recent years; everyone has contributed, or at least tried to provide imperfect responses. Fact-checking is not sufficiently effective. Why? Because it always comes too late. In fact, we can no longer keep up. And I say this with a lot of gratitude and real respect for the work of the teams who do this, and who, by the way, as has been said, sometimes with exhaustion, it is a bit exhausting to see all this, and we all see it when we look at these pages; it goes so fast that letting the rumor spread, you can say it is false, but something always remains. So we can see that we need to address the problem at its root. This is everything we have just discussed in the first part. Responsibility of the platforms, forcing them to remove false information. And I apologize because I have seen some in the public debate starting to say: "false information, oh dear, it is dangerous, we would no longer be in a democracy." I apologize, we know what false information is. If there are political leaders today wanting to defend their friends in free speech, who say that false information is something we do not know, let them go explain that those who are spreading information today to legitimize the attacks of October 7, 2023, it is not false information. I will not name the people who attacked this issue a few days ago, but still...

So yes, we know what false and true information is. After that, we must distinguish it from an opinion that we share or do not share. It is not the same thing. The first point is that. And therefore, we must no longer be only in reaction; we must structure this space so that false information is immediately cut off or that there is an immediate alert that allows us to identify it.

The second element is that this weakness is exploited by foreign powers. You recalled this in your figures or in the examples cited. Why? Because it is very easy, when we have a space that works, as we have said for a while, if you want to destabilize French democracy, regarding support for Ukrainian resistance or an election, it has become very easy, because it is enough to inject content that undermines trust, undermines a candidate or another, and then encourages it to spread. Today, what makes them spread? It is often through the multiplication of accounts and especially fake accounts.

So, if you look at how the Russians and others are rushing into our informational space, first, they push and accompany our own foolishness. The first point I just mentioned, what we have been saying for a while, is our own degeneration. It is us; we have not been able to resolve the issue. So they push where it hurts. But basically, they do it like, I would say, anyone else. But they are better organized than that. And so, they create armies of fake accounts, these troll farms, these bots. So, these fake accounts, they push them, and thus, you have volumes that, in turn, impress everyone and that, by the way, come back in a loop on other networks, on media outlets that say: "This is very important. This is information that has been relayed a million, two million times." Can you imagine? But by whom?

So, on this subject, there is one point we must see, which is that we must have the guarantee that behind each account, there is a real person. Today, we do not have that. Because today, when you say that there are two million people who liked or there are so many millions of people who relayed, you cannot say whether they are real accounts or fake accounts. When we have mechanisms of interference, there is a massive use of fake accounts that are bought, maintained, to push this content. So, another thing we want to do, that we must do, is to have the guarantee from all these platforms that behind an expression and an account, there is a real person. If there is no real person, it must be deleted. If you allow a fake account to express itself or relay information, it is your responsibility. You must be punished. Who wants to live in a digital space where, in fact, we debate, it is as if we had a series of hidden transmitters in this room that shout louder than you and me? That is exactly what they do. They buy loudspeakers. They are not real people, but they buy 200 loudspeakers in the room, and they start to make them work at full volume, and in the end, you hear only the loudspeakers. That is exactly what happens when we have an attack and informational interference.

So, on this, transparency, prohibition of fake accounts, and responsibility of platforms when we have these fake accounts. And then, alongside that, of course, we need to scale up our VIGINUM, which must alert and raise awareness outside of elections and during elections. I insist on these two points. This vigilance regarding informational interference must not wait for elections. My last remark, for all of us to think about this, is that we are talking about networks because we have seen it operate in certain countries. It is a question; we can also come back to it regarding Moldova or Romania, which have had this experience; they are good recent laboratories.

But in the upcoming municipal elections, in the upcoming presidential elections, I will tell you what is going to happen. More and more of our compatriots will go to their AI, to their AI agent, and they will ask, "Who should I vote for?" That is what is going to happen. And there, we are going to enter, I will tell you, into another world. Because I do not know what ChatGPT will recommend to vote. What I do know is that the people who own ChatGPT, the interests behind it, I am not sure that they are democratically neutral interests or fully aligned with the interests of France.

After that, there are tons of AIs, and depending on what you will have and the guarantees. I have no guarantees. We do not know how they work; we do not know the rules. But there are people who are currently, we have more and more of our compatriots, who are building an intimate relationship with their AI, who ask sometimes intimate questions, more and more, who ask for intimate advice. The morning of going to vote, before you find yourself as an assessor at the polling station, they will say, "Who should I vote for this morning?" That is almost more worrying than on the networks, because the figures on the networks show that our compatriots, despite everything we say, they have less trust in their social network than in their morning newspaper; that is still a chance we have. But they have enormous trust in their AI.

Because their AI is seen as something that brings them knowledge. And moreover, you have AIs that are very well made in the generative models that we have and that we share, because they are anthropomorphic, meaning they mimic a bit the dialogue of a friend, they use the familiar form, they know your habits after 4 or 5 questions, and thus they create intimacy. And there, we are entering, I can tell you, into another world. And so, we will have to ensure transparency on this subject and be very careful about what is happening with these models.

Moderator

Mr. President, you mentioned the Moldovan and Romanian examples. Just in a few words, since you cite them, has France drawn lessons from the experiences of Moldova and Romania?

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes. First, we helped Moldova. It is a good example because we sent VIGINUM teams to Moldova. Moldova had presidential elections and then legislative elections, and the legislative elections were very important. There were daily attacks from the Russians. You know, Moldova is the country that is on the border with Ukraine, and there is a part, a region that is in the hands of the Russians. So it is really a target for them.

In Romania, you may remember that there was a presidential election that was annulled after the first round. Can you imagine, in Romania, in the European Union, after the first round, annulment of this election by the Supreme Court because there were manipulations of information? So that is what happened. Two examples in Europe in recent months.

So not only did we help them, we conducted a feedback session. In both cases, it was the Russians, with local support. And in both cases, it was very well organized. I will give you a small example; for instance, I think what was done best was the candidate who was canceled in Romania, to quickly summarize what happened. A year before, they identified vulnerable audiences. Specifically, they conducted an analysis regarding what we were discussing. They looked at the themes on which these most vulnerable audiences were most susceptible to false information. First, they identified that these were mostly older audiences. And these were people who were visiting religious, war, and alternative medicine sites, and thus, these were people who had lost trust, follow my gaze, in the vaccine and so on, who thought there were other things. They produced fake sites, thousands of pages of content on these themes, fake accounts, tons of social media that kept people engaged on these topics. So, they built a loyal customer base around themes completely outside of politics, but by creating hashtags, references, and loops between these different themes.

Then, when the candidate arrived, they had him create TikTok content with references, hashtags, that linked back to this content and these sites. In a way, they created a loop that completely ignited, and it worked super well, so they created a mechanism of virality. In reality, just like a virus can spread when we have annihilated all the antibodies, this candidate who came out of nowhere, who made his videos with well-made content, was shared across all these sites. So, you had people who were not in politics, who said, I’m not interested, but they had been on their alternative medicine site or their religion site for two years. And then, they saw this candidate come out of nowhere, and we pushed these TikTok videos, we pushed this information. The thing took off in a few months of campaigning. This candidate that no one knew was followed on TikTok more than Taylor Swift. So, we did see that there was a problem, something was happening. It was clearly not just what they were saying that caused such virality.

But they very well analyzed the mechanisms, first of informational vulnerability, based on themes and audiences they targeted. They maintained it by keeping them loyal to sites or accounts. And then, they viralized content by relaying it through these audiences. And then, once you have someone who is followed by several million, who becomes a societal phenomenon, there is a part of the rest of the opinion that you carry along, because they are impressed, so they follow. This guy, it’s extraordinary. In fact, even we, at the beginning, talked about it. It’s incredible, there’s a guy who came out of nowhere. Now he’s expressing himself. There are millions of people following him, a hope is rising. And boom, you create the second engine.

It was very cleverly prepared. So all this to say that the weaknesses of our information infrastructure are very well seen by our enemies, they are very well utilized and methodically used. That’s why we should not see it as weak signals. But for example, I have already had the opportunity to talk about it, when we had this controversy about bedbugs, there were bedbug issues, it was initially not false information, but it was somewhat inflated. It was viralized by the Russians, who wanted to show that we had a problem across the country with bedbugs, to crush the subject in Ukraine at that moment and ridicule French democracy. We established, there was a very well-made note from VIGINUM that showed they had managed to turn this issue, which was entirely legitimate, that needed to be addressed, which goes with inadequate and degraded housing, etc., into a societal debate topic that was a form of decay, if I may say, of France and the way it stood. But they did it with hundreds of thousands of fake accounts. These are the barbs they put in place and prepare, and at some point, they will kick in during the elections. So, since we know roughly how it will happen, we need to put in the antibodies. That’s a bit of everything we’ve been saying for a while.

Speaker

Yes, that’s right. Nice to meet you, Mr. President, Mr. Minister. I am a student at ESPOL, a European school of political science, and I am also a member of the Première Voix committee, which is a committee set up by La Voix du Nord, which is a youth committee to decipher the upcoming municipal elections in 2026, particularly in the Lille region. My question about European regulation is as follows, sorry: Do you think that European regulation, particularly the Digital Services Act, can be effective in combating the spread of masculinist currents that often act as a gateway for young men into more extremist far-right currents, in particular?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Thank you and thank you for this commitment. And you are right that it is a strategy, somewhat like what I mentioned earlier with the case in Romania. We can see that the far-right forces, indeed there is this bias through what we call masculinism, virilism, and they enter through there to spread their ideas. This is something we are obviously also monitoring very carefully, and we are ensuring that the mechanisms of interference do not also use this route, even if we must always distinguish between electoral strategies that political formations in a democracy can have. There, we can denounce them, we can fight them democratically, it’s a debate, foreign interference. It’s not the same thing, and I want to make that distinction.

What you mentioned, which is the Digital Services Act, is one of the European regulations that exist. We must see that Europe is the only continent that has begun to regulate everything we have been discussing. We first created a regulation that protects your data, what we call the GDPR, and which specifically protects the security of your individual data. We want to improve its effectiveness, which was rightly mentioned earlier, because data must be protected, kept in Europe to be active. But it is this regulation that sometimes makes you check cases, perhaps sometimes too quickly, but in any case, there are rules that allow protection against the use of data by third parties when you submit them to the digital space. We will continue to develop that, but we have this foundation. We clarify on points, but it is important.

Then, when France had the presidency of the European Union, we pushed two directives: the directive on digital services, known as the DSA, and the directive on the digital market, known as the DMA. Its purpose is to regulate things. The DSA gives us the basis to create a mechanism of responsibility for platforms to be able to hold them accountable when they do not remove problematic content or allow abuses to occur. So, we have the structure.

Today, our problem is that it is much too slow; in any case, the use of this directive is too slow. There are several actions that have started to be taken; it has been two years of investigation. So you can see that it is not at the right pace. And since we have not yet created jurisprudence, it is not effective. So one of the challenges we face, which we are pushing with the Commission and others, is that initial actions be taken with heavy fines on very concrete cases so that the responsibility of these platforms, the removal of problematic content, particularly during electoral times, can be activated and become a reality. This is the basis on which we will rely to do what we have been discussing: the responsibility of platforms and the fight against false information.

And then, the directive on digital markets, the Commission just activated an action the day before yesterday based on this to ensure that the large platforms, because there are a few players, do not use their position of strength to crush others and prevent them from existing. They do. And so, the first prosecutions will be put in place. So, we have the foundation.

Now, in fact, our challenge is to implement it much faster. And so, on certain topics, we will come back to it later, for the younger ones, we will do it at the national level. There, we are accelerating and we are in the process of creating a coalition with other European countries to be able to use this directive to combat excesses and false content.

Then, to be very precise about the case you mentioned, it is much grayer, so to speak; that is to say, obvious false information falls within the scope of the DSA and its responsibility. Interferences, we can manage to block them. But the electoral strategies of certain parties, including the extremes, to seek out audiences and bring them in through other themes, is not exactly the same thing, to be very precise about your point. I think the real fight should be done with arguments in the public space. I think we need to explain the importance, precisely, of the issue of gender equality, of respect in an open democratic society like ours. And that’s where we must always… there is the aspect of regulation, but there are topics where we must say, the right response is not necessarily regulation, it is the political fight, that is to say, intellectual, of ideas, of values that we must carry.

Speaker

So, you talked about the DSA, the DMA, which are attempts at regulation on a European scale. And I am afraid of their effectiveness. In fact, we can see that current attempts at regulation can encounter barriers related to technical difficulties, so arguments that could be invoked by these digital giants to diminish the effect of these regulations. You mentioned that there were sanctions, fines that could be imposed on these digital giants. But ultimately, the power granted to these platforms to engage in foreign interference might not push them to accept the fines and simply invoke problems of black boxes, algorithms, and that they would not be able to effectively implement the regulatory attempts we have at the European level.

In short, it raises the question of whether the total control of these digital giants over their own technology would not create a sort of enclave in which the law would struggle to apply. That poses a problem for me because I can see that we are fighting with human language, legal language, and they are fighting with the language of machines. And we have no control over this machine language. Thank you, Mr. President.

Emmanuel MACRON

You are absolutely right. But then, it’s the battle we must fight, and it is a battle. The DSA and the DMA are just the beginning. And we have fought hard. I can tell you that France has been at the forefront, but it is threatened every day. First, because there are other states in Europe that think we should not regulate. Then, because you have an ideological battle from the United States. There is not a single speech today in Washington that is made without the influence of these large companies, which are supporters of the current administration, saying: we need to get rid of this. It annoys us.

There is today a geopolitical battle against these regulations. But why is it essential? Because what we have been saying for a while is that our young people spend an average of four and a half hours, and we will come to that just after, four and a half hours a day on these networks, that more and more of our compatriots are getting their information from these networks, building their opinion, perhaps their voting decision, that more and more leaders are expressing themselves on these networks. We do it too, where we are. And we have delegated 100% to non-European actors. Because they are the ones who innovated the fastest and took the place, but they are all American or Chinese. Can we say: they do not respect any of our rules? No. So, we need to make rules, ensure they are effective, and build our own digital sovereignty; it goes through there. And it is still possible, but only if we hold strong.

One on data. That’s why France is fighting to have a sovereign cloud. We have our own sovereign solutions with a specification. There can be American actors, but they must respect our rules. That means that the data of Europeans remains held in Europe and that American extraterritorial laws do not apply to this data. And that is a fight we continue to wage, and we are trying to convince our partners. There is no unanimity today in Europe, but we are making progress, and that’s what we are doing.

The second thing is this system of accountability. We have the foundation. That’s why the coming months are crucial. It’s the implementation of this directive on digital services. And if we succeed and we have the first penalties, and we have the foundation to do it, it’s a wonderful thing. On the transparency of algorithms, on the removal of false information, on the removal of fake accounts. And it’s a political battle that we must wage here, with the Commission, in the European Parliament. But we can win it. No one wants to live in a society where all of this is falsified by private interests. And something has happened, especially since, under the French presidency at the beginning of 2022, we brought this forward. It’s that these platforms, which were seen as major players, have taken on an additional role and have especially now engaged in the political debate. The acquisition by someone who explicitly campaigned for Donald Trump and who now owns X is a complete change. And so, you can see that we have created a lot of rules for our democratic life, responsibilities for the press, audience time, balance, etc. And they say, free speech, you talk free speech, total wild west and I push the content I like. They have their agenda. So, we need to regulate that.

And so, beyond that, we also need to regulate the players, that’s the DMA. And how will that happen? Through capabilities like we have with competition policy, to impose strong stops and penalties. And we have shown in recent years that we know how to do it. Because we had set up just before a policy, for example, against tied selling and market biases that, for example, Google and other major players could have, which disrupted the functioning of markets. They forced you into sales, you had advantages. We imposed billions of euros in penalties. So, we know how to do it, we Europeans.

And so I will not give up this fight, I do not think at all that it is lost. In parallel to that, we need to continue to create European players to have sovereignty and alternatives. That’s why you sometimes see me fighting when we talk about artificial intelligence and generative artificial intelligence models or what we call “

large language models

,” the competitors of ChatGPT. Le Chat is created by a French company called Mistral AI. That’s why I fight for Le Chat to succeed. Because it’s all well and good to say I want to regulate OpenAI and ChatGPT. We will be able to regulate it. It’s urgent.

But if there are no other options, we will be in trouble. So we also need to create trustworthy European alternatives with people who inherently follow our rules. But this fight is totally possible. Simply, it eliminates less the case. That is to say, if we do not lead it today with a lot of strength, and the great difficulty we have is that we have many political formations in Europe that, sincerely, were for free speech and live in a somewhat outdated world, which was for unregulated speech. You have extremes that see their advantage because they are structurally favored by these networks that go to the extremes. And then, you have foreign powers. And there, the first economy in the world, we do not know the interest. And so, they give us blows. And there, it’s a real choice, for me, existential for Europeans.

If Europe wants to be sovereign, independent, free, it must be respected in the digital space. And so, it must succeed in having its values, in having the principles of organization, of public debate, of democratic life that are ours, respected in the digital space. But it is possible to do it. It’s just a question of political will.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. A quarter to midnight, you say, and I see the time ticking away for us as well. You are a Master's student at the École supérieure de journalisme. A small question about regulation, perhaps an almost utopian project, but describe it to us.

Speaker

First of all, hello, Mr. President, hello, Mr. Minister, and hello to everyone. Before I begin, I just wanted to thank you for your presence, thank La Voix du Nord for this conference, as it is a wonderful opportunity, and thank all the people present today.

My question concerns more the international level. I wanted to know how an international body, for example, like the World Trade Organization, could help create a common framework for all these issues related to interference, sovereignty, and digital dependence? And in continuation, today, what are the obstacles to the establishment of such an organization and how could we overcome them? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. So, the great difficulty is that we do not have the same approach at the international level. So, we have forums that exist. On digital governance, so that exists, we have forms of discussions that are hosted by the UN. There has been a lot of work done by the United Nations on digital issues and on these subjects, on artificial intelligence and networks, but we do not formally have a treaty that delegates to an organization the regulation of everything we are discussing.

Moreover, for part of it, it should not be regulated by states or others, for reasons I mentioned earlier, because there is no consensus either. And so today, what is the international order on the issues we have been discussing? The United States, in fact, have de facto decided on the Wild West. Is it sustainable? I do not believe so. But I am neither elected in the United States nor an American citizen. I have a lot of respect for this democracy and good luck to them.

But they have decided that, in fact, it is what we call the “

Seven Magnificents

,” the 7 very large companies that, by the way, create all the wealth of recent years in their stock index, who have taken all the power and who have people accumulating wealth. In fact, they told them: go ahead, do the job. And they decided to be a bit friendly with them, if I were to simplify things. Is it sustainable for a democracy? No. And the parallel to that, you have a good symptom that it is not a very good sign for democratic and informational life, is that the United States has killed thousands of newspapers, particularly daily press, in recent years, because they are installed in a system where there is no longer any value for independent, free, ethical information. So that’s an American model that is, at its core, ultra-liberal, but which today, in my eyes, adorns itself with values that correspond to our democracy, namely freedom of speech, and we do not regulate.

On the other side, at the opposite end, the second largest economy in the world, China, has decided to control everything, and it is in the hands of the government. They have closed many of their platforms. And then, when they have, for example, their TikTok, since it is a Chinese company, it has nothing to do with our TikTok, it is limited in hours of exposure per day, and it is educational content for children. So they have fully integrated that it is a cognitive war in which we have been launched. And their strategy is to say: “what makes young people crazy, I will send them, and what makes my young people smarter, I will keep for myself.” I simplify, but that’s exactly what they do. And we are the fools in the middle of the service saying: “go ahead, young people, eat this. They don’t eat it at home, but they export it to us.” Crazy! That’s China. Then, you have other authoritarian powers in the middle that say: “We, no Internet at home, the Russians and others.” So, they are very clever in intervening.

And then, in the middle, you have the major emerging economies and liberal democracies, and we are struggling with our principles, our traditions, and it’s the debate we supported earlier, that is to say through public debate, undoubtedly imperfect, sometimes too slow, etc., but we are going to build, we are in the process of building, in fact, mechanisms to start putting in regulation. So, I think we cannot today, in the short term, create an international organization that regulates, but I think that, one, we can elevate it in Western democracies and perhaps build a coalition of actors. Probably the Europeans, I think that Latin Americans, Southeast Asia and the Pacific, and part of the African continent can follow us on this agenda. That, I think, should be our priority. But first, we need to push forward in Europe to implement it.

The second thing is that I think there are actors who can help us, and I think that journalists and academics have a very important role because they are professions that have a relationship to the nature of information that is not linked to political power. And that’s very important not to lose sight of this point. I have mentioned it several times in our exchange. But at the moment when we must fight against disinformation, at the moment when we must fight and regain critical thinking, the role of the state is to provide a sincere and impartial framework. But it must never be to say: “this is true or false.” Because there, the great risk is to become authoritarian regimes again. On the other hand, the role of journalists everywhere in the world is to work around labeling initiatives, as I mentioned earlier. And that’s what Reporters Without Borders has started to build, I think it’s very, very fruitful, to say around the world: we have a label and we say this is done by journalists, this is not done by journalists, which still gives you some guidance. And the second thing is academics. And I think we need to go more and more in that direction, when we talk about science, when we talk about other things, so that there is also validation by people who have academic authority. They may agree or disagree, but even in their disagreement, academics know how to say this is scientifically established information or this is not. And so that too is something we must continue to consolidate. That’s roughly the geography of the power dynamics.

Speaker

We move on to, indeed, a third part dedicated to youth who are highly exposed to screens. So, in April 2024, Mr. President of the Republic, you tasked a commission with evaluating the impact of children and adolescents' exposure to screens. We spoke with Servane Mouton on the phone a few days ago, a neurologist and co-chair of this group of experts. And Servane Mouton told us that more than a year after this report, there is still much to be done. However, there was a very clear consensus on the negative effects of screens. She whispered to us that political instability does not help in following up on issues when ministers come and go. Fortunately, measures have been taken. We think particularly of the ban on screens in collective settings for children under 3 years old, since July 3rd.

But we wonder if we shouldn’t go a little further? Yesterday, the Macronist deputies submitted a bill to ban social media for those under 15. I think some will grumble in the room. This text also proposes to establish a digital curfew for 15-18 year-olds between 10 PM and 8 AM, as well as a ban on smartphones in high schools. I think the same, it will cause some discomfort. In the midst of all this, there is the health of our teens who are affected by violent content, pornographic content, cyberbullying, sometimes by indoctrination propaganda.

In the face of this, we find parents who are wondering how to protect their children, who are a bit lost. So, we wonder how the state can help them. For example, your former minister, Clara Chappaz, fought against TikTok at the time of skinny tok

. That should resonate particularly with young people. This hashtag that was launched and invited young girls to extreme advice for losing weight. Minister Clara Chappaz succeeded, after a fierce battle, she says, in getting this hashtag removed, but evidently, it was very, very laborious. So, we wonder how the state can also help in these battles. A few figures, Julien.

Moderator

4 hours and 11 minutes, that’s the daily time. You mentioned it earlier, Mr. President, the average daily time spent in front of screens by children and adolescents aged 6 to 17. 9 out of 10 French people are in favor of banning screens in collective settings for early childhood or in nursery schools. It has started, but the fight is far from won. 84% of French people would be willing to give up buying a mobile phone with or without Internet access for a child before the age of 11. And here too, we can already imagine the domestic battles.

To begin this section dedicated to youth, we wanted to give the floor to a young person for a testimony, as he has been a victim of cyberbullying. Congratulations to him for agreeing to share this with us.

Speaker

Mr. President, in April 2020, during the lockdown, in a segment filmed by a local media outlet, I simply explained how my confinement was going, checking in on isolated individuals, signing up on the civic reserve platform, I’ll skip the rest, and immediately the report started circulating on social media.

These social media platforms did not take long to harass me, perhaps due to my different style, my invisible difference, particularly under pseudonyms, a period I experienced very painfully, as you can imagine. Difficult days, difficult nights, even dark thoughts. Questions I asked myself and that those affected by this scourge also ask. Why? Why such cyberbullying? Cyberbullying is a form of harassment. Those who cyberbully are behind a screen. Words have a huge impact.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you for testifying and for having the courage to say it. I believe that the emotion is felt by everyone. Harassment is a behavior of a cruel pack. It can be young people or older individuals; you don’t necessarily have to be young to harass, who will turn against someone to make them suffer, to humiliate them. And everything we have been saying for a while now clearly shows the great risk of social media. It’s as if we are hidden. Since it is derealized, it tends to push towards extremes, it incites escalation, it gives even more voice to those who are more foolish. And ultimately, it brings us back significantly to behaviors that are the most gregarious. It’s the worst of crowds. And so, yes, in the digital realm, you have pack behaviors. So I am, like everyone else, I think, here, very moved by what you just said and what you have experienced, and thank you for testifying on behalf of many.

That is why harassment is something we must fight against vigorously. We are doing it in schools, as I reminded earlier, the minister is carrying it, and it is something we launched with Jean-Michel Blanquer, which we have never let go. Fighting against harassment in schools, with references, I know there are several here who are engaged in their middle or high schools with their teachers as ambassadors and as sentinels. And it continues online, and that is why it is one of the issues we want to activate both mandatory moderation, immediate removal of content, and, of course, the responsibility of platforms. We changed the law, as you know, on cyberbullying, particularly for our students, as we established systems for distancing, so to speak, from the harasser, not only from their school and high school, I speak under the control of our minister, but also for the closure of the accounts of those who harass. And if they resume, it can be closed for months, or even be permanent for repeat offenders, because that was one of the major problems we had.

Now, those who harass online are prosecuted, they are punished, they can see their account closed. So we have created obligations like that. But here too, it moves so quickly, given the functioning of networks, that we must not let up. And I think it also involves raising awareness. And so, I simply want, through you, to say to all those who are victims, children, adolescents, or adults who are not alone, that they must immediately report it, tell their loved ones, protect themselves, and protecting oneself can also mean disconnecting, not reading, but immediately filing a complaint and protecting oneself with others. Thank you for your testimony.

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. So I am fortunate to have two teenage children, and so I am right in the middle of it, so to speak. I notice, and what I regret, is indeed, as you said, the delay in awareness of all this. Because my daughter got her first mobile phone at 12 and a half. And only because I held out, so to speak. Because otherwise, she already had friends who had one in CM1. CM1 is very, very young. And so, the ban in itself is wonderful, I saw that at the beginning of the week. I thought, great, it’s fantastic. Except that unfortunately, the ban will be circumvented, as parents will give their mobile phones, and it will also be the open door to access social media, because when they are little, for example, we have peace, we give it to them, and then they are in their corner and they are quiet. We do what we want during that time.

So the question would also be to educate parents about the dangers of social media. I think that even from kindergarten, when there are teacher-parent meetings… Well, from teachers, to immediately include this in the discussions, to say, social media is not for a child. It’s for later, because an addiction will be created. After that, we don’t sleep very well. And there, indeed, I agree with you on the need for a nighttime cutoff. It is essential. I am fortunate that for mine, they cut off by themselves. They know. I don’t have to fight over that, fortunately. But I have friends who can’t take it anymore either, because it’s very difficult to take it out of their hands. So how can we make parents aware of this preservation of the mental health of their little ones? Because that is mainly the problem. As soon as a little one has it in their hands, it’s over, that’s it.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Madam. You describe well the solitude of parents. But it’s normal, because there has been a crazy technological acceleration. We haven’t done nothing. We are currently accelerating because there is also a scientific consensus that has been established. And Madam, rightly, you said what you thought. Having received the report, it was not unanimous a year ago among those who wrote the report. So we are bringing all this together.

What have we done in recent years? We first started with mobile phones. It wasn’t easy. So we fought to remove mobile phones from schools, to say that there must be rules. We have put laws in place for parental control, so that, precisely, for our children and young teenagers, there cannot be all social media on the mobile phone, and that we set up other phones that we sell, that there is parental control. These are the laws of recent years, made by successive ministers and parliamentarians. We have experimented, we have started the removal of mobile phones in middle schools, generalized this school year. I believe everyone can say it works super well, the feedback is good, I think, on our minister’s control. So that really needs to be consolidated because it works very well. And I ask all parents to be with us. I think there is rather an adherence, but there was a habit linked to anxiety. He has his mobile phone or she has her mobile phone, so that reassures me. But when the bell rings until it rings for the end of classes, no mobile phone.

It does everyone good, and it’s the only way to be able to learn at school. We want to complement it, and the minister is working on high school, and then we want to complement it, indeed, with a digital break, which is a good thing. But that, I want to say, when you talk to me about circumvention, the digital break like the end of social media, yes, parents who want to tinker can circumvent it. But you know what? You can also give beer to your infant. So, simply, when the state sets a rule, it helps everyone because it establishes a prohibition. Until now, we had not set any rules. So there was a form of… The norm was not known, so to speak, what is good or not good, so families were a bit left to their own devices.

Now, what can we say? 1) the mobile phone is not good when you are young. When you are a teenager, at least, it is not when you are in class, and it cannot be in the evening. And before 15 years old, it is not good to have a mobile phone that has social media. 2) screens, because the Commission first rendered its conclusion on that. There, it’s the same, it’s not a law that will prohibit, but what we say, the recommendation everywhere, now we generalize it, before 3 years old, it is not good to put a screen. Before 3 years old. So, that is what we will disseminate through all those who support young children and their families. No screen before 3 years old.

Host

And when will it be no screen before 6 years old?

Emmanuel MACRON

To prohibit. Then, it’s a very limited use before 6 years old. I say the scientific consensus, meaning that it is not a political and arbitrary decision. It has been nourished by scientific work, then the most limited until 6 years old. We are also looking — but France was rather in an intermediate model, to closely examine the use of screens in pedagogical practice — but models that had gone to all screens, for example like the Scandinavians, are now going back, in forced march, because they see the perversions of this model. It’s not very good. And we ourselves are being very careful, with the pronotes and others, about the schedules, to respect a digital break, with parents and children, all those who have it or know it, that is to say, the update at 11:00 PM, that was not a good idea. So we are also going back on that, and in fact, we are all regulating ourselves. So that is what we are doing.

After, beyond the digital break in the evening, I believe that what we need to aim for, not I believe, what we want to do, is to prohibit social media for those under 15 years old. And so there, there is a scientific consensus that we have built progressively, a year ago. There was the Screen Commission. But on that basis, what have I started to do? 1) I told them, you must disseminate, build. 2) we started a European campaign, because France cannot be completely alone in Europe doing this. I will not go into the technicalities because otherwise, it can be easily circumvented by using VPNs or others. And so, what are we doing? We have started to create a coalition. Several states have joined us, from South to North. So now, we are starting to be a small group of ten states.

What I wish, but I also want to build consensus, for me, that is where these debates are important, is to be able, at the beginning of next year, to arrive at a text that indeed carries. That is why it is very good, there, I asked the deputy who is also launching the parliamentary debate, but a text that allows us to say, for those under 15 years old, no more social media. We have already done everything we have done on mobile phones. Continue in high school, and then a digital break in the evening and protection mechanisms. After that, we still have a few subjects to think about that are not neutral. We say social media. Messaging loops are not social media. So today, in the text as it is written, what we have advanced, we can do it. Why? It is something that the DSA allows me, to return to Lila’s question earlier. Because the Digital Services Directive allows me to request age verification from platforms. And so last July, that’s also why it took us time compared to the Commission. We did all this legal work, we got the response from the Commission, but it took me a year, which told us, you can request, as we did for pornographic sites, to verify the age on social media. It also said, moreover, it is the responsibility of states to define a digital majority. Based on what we obtained last July at the European level, I go into the technicalities so you understand why it takes time.

I received this response in the summer. Now, I am building my coalition with other partners to say, we will be able to pass laws at the national level to tell platforms: you must verify the age of those entering your platform. If they are under 15 years old, you cannot give them access. So now, we have the basis. That is what we want to be able to do in January. But there is, I said to WhatsApp, a blind spot, which is that these messaging services – which are not social media – are not in this text. WhatsApp, they have now put AI. You have an AI agent on your WhatsApp. It hasn’t escaped anyone. For a 13-year-old, if you let them have WhatsApp, it’s not better than a social media, because they have an agent with whom they converse and who can enter into logics that are not good either. So we also need to succeed in capturing that.

There you have a bit of the line. I am aware of everything you are experiencing. In fact, there is an American academic, Mr. Hart, who wrote a book called “Lost Generation.”

The generations that experienced social networks when we were all discovering them in real time are the ones who taught us; they learned with us, and it is true that, as a result, it has been much harder for families. I believe that my responsibility, our responsibility, is now, given what we know, to set the rules, to no longer leave families alone, to establish rules, to impose prohibitions, and then, if they want to circumvent them, fine, but it will still change a lot of things.

When we look at the situation, I will stop here, you have touched on it a bit, but I say this so that everyone becomes aware, including the youngest – because I am aware, it is not necessarily fun to say: you will no longer have access to social networks – it is that in the generation that entered with social networks in 2015, we saw an epidemic of eating disorders, especially among young girls, due to exposure to networks and body and beauty norms that push you towards that, an epidemic of attention disorders. Why? Because when you scroll, you are used to being excited by a video that lasts a few seconds, and immediately, you have to look for another one. And young people tell you that they can no longer stay focused.

So there is a loss of reading in this entire generation. And even young people who tell you, in their own words, where I have seen many in debates, who say, I can no longer watch a movie, it’s too long. So you have a society, in essence, where we have destroyed the ability to be attentive, and therefore to learn, and therefore to support others and to live in society, and therefore to be able to engage in deliberation, a debate. All of this, we need to correct through these regulatory mechanisms to protect our youth.

In fact, we now know that before the age of 15, it is not good to be exposed to all of this. And afterwards, we need to support those over 15, and we will come back to that, I think, in the last theme, but we need to learn how to navigate these networks, we need to have reflexes, we need to be accustomed to it, because it is not innocent.

Moderator

On the logic of attention, Mr. President, you see that they are still all attentive. This is very good news. A theme you wanted to address, you are the director general of the Association Au Mieux in Lille. You help families in social difficulty. Through that lens, you meet many young people and you wanted to talk to us about the recruitment of young people.

Speaker

Thank you. Hello everyone. Hello, Mr. President. Yes, to complete in a few seconds my work, we intervene in families in social difficulty in the Lille metropolitan area. These families no longer have any reference points. So, we try to recreate a link, of course, social, but especially a parental link. And we try to recreate parental authority, or at least help to regain parental authority among these young people. And indeed, the question we can ask, that we are asking... I heard Céline Berton, last week, on France Info, who is the director general of the DGSI, talking about the recruitment of young people into the Islamist movement on social networks, and that more and more young people were attracted or conditioned by these advertisements, well, I will call them that, by these advertisements, and she mentioned young people who were very young. It started at 10 years old, 12 years old, 15 years old, you mentioned it just now.

How do we do it, how can we do it at the level of the French state to protect these young people, especially in my case where they no longer have many family reference points, where you talked about stopping social networks until 15 years old after a certain hour, there are no more networks. What do the young people in child welfare do? The young people who are still in the street at 10 PM because the parents are no longer there, how do we do it? How can we help these young people not to be recruited and to commit the irreparable?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, sir, and thank you for this commitment. First, two things. To be very precise, what I described about the prohibition for those under 15, how are we going to do it? We will implement an obligation for all platforms to verify your age, for all users of these platforms. So, this can be done very simply through a selfie, through code mechanisms, etc. This means that a person under 15 will not be able to access the said platform. It is not a question of parental authorization. It is a prohibition with verification mechanisms.

It is technically feasible, as we have tested it for several years on pornographic sites; it poses many constraints for them, we will face a lot of resistance, but we know that it works, that it is feasible and that it is reliable. So it is a strict prohibition for those under 15 that we want to implement so that a young person, even when they are in child welfare or even when they are indeed in a foster family, in a family that has broken apart, that is suffering, well, it also applies to them. The second thing about recruitment, what the director general of internal security described, what you recalled, are things that we have now clearly established.

And so, beyond the prohibition for those under 15, we want to put an end to that by having transparency of the algorithm and the mechanism of responsibility, and telling them, these contents, not with us. And since we prohibit these contents, and we even passed a law in 2021 to combat them, allowing us to close establishments that promote them. We ask you to remove them; otherwise, you are in violation of our text. These are the two levers.

On top of that, what you describe is very accurate, and many did not want to see it and wanted to be, in a way, in caricature, but I think everyone here remembers the riots we had in the summer of 2023. During these riots, the ignition was among young people who, for an overwhelming majority, came from single-parent families or from child welfare and who were all exposed to social networks. The organization of the riots was mostly done through social networks. And so, that is also why it became a mechanism of derealization. When you have a 13-year-old who starts to go burn everything, break everything, and even the library or the school and others, and when, afterwards, we took their words, punishing them, you realize that you had young people who lived in another world, because these social networks derealize things. They make you live in a reality next door, and above all, they desensitize you.

By the way, the teachers I was with earlier told me that what struck them the most in their experience in middle school was sometimes the insensitivity of certain young people they were confronted with. And it is always the experience of the networks that does that. Because when you spend 4 hours a day seeing violent content, hearing horrors, you are less shocked, you are desensitized. There are no longer any common norms when you live in that. So there you go, we will fight with these two levers.

Speaker

Are you very worried, Mr. President?

Emmanuel MACRON

My job is not to be worried. I see many people in public debate, many public decision-makers who think we should all be whistleblowers. I am aware, determined, and I want to act. But I want, with strength, to convince everyone that we can no longer delay. In reality, that’s it. And we have built a lot of time. I have spent a lot of time meeting scientists, commissioning committees, reports, reviewing them, looking at other European countries. I have done all this work over the past few years, beyond what we had already done on mobile phones and others. In the face of resistance, that is when I realized, a few months ago, that we needed to launch citizen work, because I found that there was a disconnection between the willingness of some to move for various reasons, and the disarray of many young people, the disarray of many associations, people in popular education, many teachers, and the solitude of families, which Madame expressed. We no longer know what to do. And whatever the socio-professional background, but with a very great injustice, it is that the families that are broken or young people alone, it is terrible.

Speaker

What was your trigger?

Emmanuel MACRON

It is a series of meetings like this, and above all, the conviction, based on the report that Mr. Bronner gave me on lights in the digital age, which is about critical thinking, a theme we will address now, and the screen commission. To say, something is happening. There was a very good book written by Mr. Haidt, which was also a revelation for many people, and the testimonies. Today, it is impossible to go to a school or a middle school without being told about this. When I made, a year and a half ago, visits, which I regularly do in vocational high schools, I came to talk about the training map. I had young people who only talked to me about their fatigue from being in front of screens, and who, by the way, now verbalize it, because there is a maturity among high school students who were the generation that went through all of middle school with that. There are young people who tell you: “I was in 9th grade, I spent 6 hours and 30 minutes a day on social networks.” I have known them. And who told me: “I asked my teacher to close my TikTok, because I couldn’t handle it.” Collectively, insidiously, we have allowed a system of addiction, dependency to settle among our young people. And I say this, it is nobody's fault and our responsibility as a whole. In any case, we do not have the right not to face this situation. Simply, everything we are doing cannot just be laws and decrees. If there is no adherence from young people, families, teachers, associations that are the partners of elected officials, it will not work. So there needs to be a bit of a collective awakening.

Speaker

Mr. President, Mr. Minister. I am a high school student, a volunteer at the Backados association, which aims to help young people live longer and healthier. I see every day how social networks influence our emotions and sometimes spread false information, especially on sensitive topics like mental health. My question is: how can the state protect young people and democracy from these algorithms without restricting our freedom of expression?

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. That is what we said earlier. Thank you for the commitment, for saying it. First, freedom of expression exists outside of social networks. And it turns out that there have been, for decades, many generations that have acquired, defended, and practiced freedom of expression, and there were no social networks. So, we should not let the idea settle that if we do not have access to social networks, there is no longer freedom of expression. Social networks, as we have been saying for a while, do have a danger. First, the fact that there are no rules. Pierre, he is older than you, it seems to me. I think he was not exposed to social networks when he was 11 or 12 years old. So, what he said earlier is already a maturity of someone who does not want to be insulted all day or to be locked in with people, so he approaches social networks being armed. I too, all those from our generations, we were armed.

You, in 7th grade, you are not armed to enter social networks, because you enter a space where anything can be said. You are exposed to people who say anything and everything, who will spread doubts about what you are taught, which are not legitimate at all, made by anyone who does not have academic or scientific authority, and who will create a nature of debate to which you will become accustomed, which is often that of invective, insult, and linguistic violence. Our conviction is that before a certain age, and now it is established, that is to say, an age at which we are roughly stabilized from an intellectual, emotional, sensitive, psychological point of view, it is better not to be exposed to social networks. By the way, there is a debate among scientists, always between 15 and 16 years old. We have set 15 years; 16 years is the age of sexual majority in our country. 15 years is reasonable, proportionate. There is rather a consensus with other European countries to say 15 years. To protect you, my first point is to tell you: before 15 years old, the right place for freedom of expression is not social networks; it is first to acquire knowledge, through family, then through school.

I think we should not let go of all this. We are all happy to convey a message, to exchange freely. But the key to the key, if we want to be republicans and enlightened citizens, is that there is first a transmission. That is to say, at the beginning, we know less than our elders. We must not lose sight of that either. The role of the school is to transmit knowledge, certainties that are scientifically established, and to acquire this knowledge. At the same time, the school transmits to us a critical spirit, that is to say, it teaches us to learn and to know how to associate this knowledge, to learn doubt and the method of doubt, which is not distrust. And that is where you are too young to doubt everything. Methodological doubt is to say that at a certain point, things I have learned, which are certain, can be called into question because the state of science will change. But there is a method to do this. It is different from distrust, which is to doubt everything because anyone says anything about everything on social networks. So, you must first consolidate knowledge, certainties, transmission, learning, the learning of critical thinking, and kindness towards others.

That is also what the school does. Being comfortable in your own skin and being nice to others, because that is how a society works, that is to say, respecting the rules, respecting your teachers and your parents, and respecting others when we play sports, when we are in class, knowing how to listen to each other and exchange. This needs to be consolidated. It is not innate. If you are not given the time to consolidate it, you put yourself at risk and you will be very unhappy. So, knowledge, critical spirit, respect, kindness, it is the role of parents, of the school to do this, and of all those who participate in the educational mission. I always think of associations and popular education, which are important partners. We must say that before the age of 15, you are not ready to be exposed to social networks. But you can start in class debates, in family debates, in debates among yourselves. You have freedom of expression. From the age of 15, there is sufficient maturity, a preparation to be able to enter these networks.

The idea is also to prepare you for these networks so that they have systems of responsibility and that you, because you will have been taught all this, become responsible actors on these networks. And that we have succeeded in making republicans who reach that age, maturity, so that when they go on social networks, they do not start insulting everyone or spreading nonsense, but are co-depositors, with us, of the ability to deliberate. Everything we have been doing for a while now seems to me to be exercises like what our elected officials do in town halls; it is a useful exercise for democracy, it is called deliberation. We ask questions, we confront ideas, perhaps agreements or disagreements. We can form an opinion in respect. What we have been experiencing for a while now is the exact opposite of what social networks are. We see our faces, we listen to each other, we structure our remarks, and we try to respond in a reasoned manner. For all these reasons, I think this is how we should do things in the right order, to first teach you, to allow you to become adults from an emotional, affective, intellectual point of view, to transmit values and knowledge to you, and then to prepare you, both protected and ready, to enter social networks.

Moderator

I propose that we quickly move on to the fourth and final part concerning education. Just to remind you that there is a dizzying question: how can the school still transmit fundamental knowledge and train the critical spirit of our children when opaque algorithms capture their attention much more effectively at times than their teachers, no matter how talented they are? France has, however, taken ambitious measures. Starting this school year, all students in the eighth and tenth grades must undergo mandatory training in artificial intelligence. But how can we integrate this artificial intelligence into education in an ethical and thoughtful manner? Finally, there may be a glimmer of hope to offer. You will tell us, Mr. President, in a few words, how to support ethical social media initiatives, but also to support the press in general, quality press that offers qualified information. And perhaps, some figures.

Speaker

86% of students from 16 countries regularly use artificial intelligence for their studies. 55% of children in France report having encountered false images, and 94% of French people make mistakes at least once when presented with 5 photos, 5 deepfakes.

Speaker

Hello Mr. President, hello Mr. Minister. My question is: Do you think that the national education system should train citizens from a young age in a critical and responsible use of artificial intelligence, just like reading or mathematics, in order to prepare them for the jobs of tomorrow?

Speaker

Hello, Mr. President. I speak to you as an aspiring journalist concerned about the media world and its impacts on our society and our citizens. Today, the majority of media in France are owned by millionaires, 9 in this case. Earlier, you said that the owners of social networks were not necessarily very philanthropic. Unfortunately, I believe they are not either. In the face of this, we may have a precious weapon in France, which is our public audiovisual service. However, you also spoke a lot about RSF, Reporters Without Borders. France has dropped in the rankings because RSF considers that the public service is weakened, particularly since the abolition of the television license fee, which has somewhat broken the direct link between citizens and this service. So how can we do it? How can we fight against concentration? Vincent Bolloré owns both schools, media, and publishing houses, while our public service is increasingly weakened.

Emmanuel MACRON

On the first question, first of all, our national education system, and Mr. Minister is here to carry it with great strength, has established and consolidated teaching both of the values of the Republic and of the development of critical thinking. There has been a restructuring of these programs, as you probably know. This is part of the baggage we have acquired. The second thing is that we are in the process of consolidating, starting in middle school and even more in high school, training in critical thinking in the digital age, preparation for AI within the framework of the curriculum. We see this both in the general education framework and in the options that are taken, reinforcing this capacity to train our young people, our students. I confirm to you that this is something we will do. In parallel, in the projects we have opened, there is the training of teachers. Because we must not underestimate the fact that many teachers today also need to be trained in this. That is also why one of the priority projects is the training of teachers through the program we are currently deploying for this purpose. That is a foundation.

Should it be taught like reading or math? I would distinguish two things: the transmission of knowledge and instilling a critical spirit. These are two different things. I say this because it is important: the primary role of the school is to transmit basic knowledge that allows you to recognize, that is to say, also bases of certainty. It is when you have these bases consolidated that you can then manipulate instruments to doubt, to have a critical spirit, to call them into question. But if you do not do it in the right order: I did not learn Descartes before learning addition. You can understand the Cartesian cogito, and it is very important, at an age where you have that perspective, where you have consolidated knowledge. I think we need to be careful to maintain a core of knowledge and not have a great confusion between all this.

The school must continue to transmit knowledge, and it is necessary to be able to acquire others because you are not finished at the end of school. The goal is to make you free citizens, women and men who will perhaps continue to learn after school, but who will be able to change their lives, relearn things, and at the same time master knowledge, professional environments, but be enlightened citizens. There is this knowledge, and then there is the critical spirit through teaching, method, and teacher training. I would distinguish the two. Just a very small remark to make everyone think a little. There is a decline in reading that we see, which is linked to everything we have been saying for a while. By banning social networks, raising awareness, and with the help of teachers who do a wonderful job, we want to defend reading, to put it back at the center. Reading and theater are at the heart of what we want to do for the school. But I just want to make everyone think.

Artificial intelligence is the best demonstration that reading is the solution. Because a generative artificial intelligence model is nothing more than a super calculation model that has read a lot of books. So tell yourself, if you want to be like ChatGPT or if you want to resemble Le Chat, you just need to read a lot of books. Because in fact, that is just it. They are supercomputers equipped with calculation capabilities that have been fed all possible books. But it is an ode to reading; artificial intelligence, if we look at it from this angle. When it comes to journalism, first of all, we have rules today that protect our press. There are still many press titles. La Voix du Nord is a very good example, and the daily press, by the way, and regional weekly press is also a very good example. Simply, we have a crisis of the economic model in recent years that means that indeed, more and more great fortunes have bought the press. Often, by the way, great fortunes that do not make money through the press, which is a bad sign. And I have a very simple reflex. It is a bit like what I was telling you earlier about social networks. When someone informs me but does not make money selling that information, it means they have earned it in another way. So you always have to understand how they make money because no one does this for free. So social networks, I understood that they made their money by selling personalized ads on my back. So they do not want to inform me. And when people who lose money have a press title, it means it brings them something else. But it is not to inform me; it is to play on opinion, to have influence. That is not good.

So, we have mechanisms, after all, and I want to defend the editorial teams of the newspapers you mentioned, because there is journalistic ethics, there are charters, and therefore there is still an independence of the editorial teams from their shareholders. And that is a strength of the French model. There is also an editorial responsibility that belongs to journalists. And so, I also want to defend the journalists who sometimes belong to press titles that may be owned by these people, because they can very well, if the framework is respected, act independently. And there is a code of ethics. So, we can have a model where newspapers, channels are owned by very wealthy people if the ethics are respected, if they have independence charters. You have editorial teams that know how to preserve them. And that is up to you as readers, as journalists, to defend it, to assert it. There are cultural differences. I will not go further into the differences between titles and between organizations. And that is also what should create the difference in trust. I would disagree with what you said about public broadcasting. I believe that the license fee, which by the way was no longer paid by everyone, would be... It is not only those who paid the license fee who had a relationship of trust with public broadcasting. And if I had not safeguarded the amount of public broadcasting through the commitments made, you could tell me that, but it is safeguarded. And so, we remain a country where public broadcasting... It had honestly become an anomaly of the license fee. By abolishing the housing tax, we were not going to keep the license fee; it cost a fortune to collect. There was a commitment, and it was kept to maintain, precisely, the commitment for quality public broadcasting. And when you look at France and compare it with other Europeans, I think we can say that we have a strong model of public broadcasting that we can be proud of. But be careful, we cannot reduce pluralism to the public service model. And therefore, in pluralism, there is a public service actor who must be able to carry out public interest missions, have a specific set of requirements that the legislator asks of him, because he is funded by the taxpayer, and he is anyway, according to the principle of budgetary universality. It is not because we pay a dedicated tax that it has more value or not. It has state budget, so it has value, so it has responsibility.

But pluralism goes beyond public broadcasting. The key behind your question, it seems to me, is 1) we must continue to be very vigilant about the rules and journalistic independence in all titles, regardless of their capital ownership, but 2) the key to this is that we must consolidate the economic model of the press in France. And that is the entire debate we are having in parallel with the actors of daily press, national press, regional daily press, national daily press, and weekly press. It is about seeing how we can stabilize the economic model again. So, by having, moreover, trusted partnerships with AI actors like Mistral, who can be trusted partners that help and develop solutions, including moderation, but by re-sincering the figures, because we cannot accept to be in a country that will live, that should live, I put it conditionally because we want to stem it, what the United States of America has experienced. But this means that we all, citizens, must also accept to say that it is not possible to inform ourselves freely and democratically completely for free. And so, you have access to information through public broadcasting because you pay for it as a taxpayer, but you must also have access to free information because you pay for it as a consumer of this information as a citizen. And we have somewhat acculturated ourselves in recent years to inform ourselves for nothing, for free. That is not a good reflex, because it means, in fact, that you will let information be done by people who are not paid for it. And the key to continuing to have independent journalists is for us, as citizens, to accept to inform ourselves by paying what is necessary to be informed. It is a modest sum, but it seems to me that it goes with democracy. And alongside that, we must build the framework so that the economic model is sustainable. There are a whole bunch of technical subjects behind it.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President, and thank you for reminding us of the difference between certain press groups and a group like Rossel, an independent press group that owns La Voix du Nord. Last question, unfortunately, as we will have to leave. In a few words, you will have to be very quick, but it seemed important to us that you were both here, because you are the origin of the creation of a very important, very useful application, and you have just won a European award. In a few words, explain your initiative and the little question that will serve as a conclusion. Thank you.

Speaker

Thank you very much. Hello, Mr. President. Hello, Mr. Minister. We indeed co-founded with Éloïse, two and a half years ago, the Pol application, which is really a political application with the principle of asking questions every day to our users. These are questions that are either related to texts being studied in the National Assembly or opinion questions. We write a short neutral context below each question and note the opinions for and against from all political camps. The goal is for users to form an opinion based on a plurality of available opinions. The next day, we propose to link these votes, votes from their own deputy in their constituency, and to be able to have the votes of all the people in their constituency, to the votes of the National Assembly and to the votes of all users at the national level. We recently won a European Google hackathon dedicated to combating misinformation, so we want to continue in this direction and innovate to fight against misinformation and for a permanent democracy. Éloïse, I’ll let you…

Speaker

And indeed, our users have a concern. They fear that, precisely, information and education about information and artificial intelligence will only benefit those who are surrounded by people who, precisely, know how to inform themselves. And so, one question: how to prevent this from creating new inequalities and, in other words, a new fracture, a fracture in French society? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much. Congratulations on your initiative and more than that for what you have already structured. I think it clearly shows how we create critical thinking in the debate, that is to say how we engage citizens and how we manage to make this engagement fully active, but with a critical distance that allows us to confront opinions, in this case, texts, but also current events. The great risk for artificial intelligence, as with any technological disruption, is indeed, among the risks, that of inequalities, social inequalities, but also inequality in terms of use and separation in our society.

That is why what we think is, first, one, we should not enter it too early and too quickly. We must be prepared for that. 2) in the overall package, we must prepare our young people to navigate it. And so, that is what we said about the mission of the national education system. 3) we need to set clear rules for everyone regarding usage and acquisition. And that is the entire framework we will have to put in place in the coming years on artificial intelligence and particularly AI agents, which is something we have addressed little today, but which will be a continent, in addition to social networks, that will need to be regulated. And 4) I think this educational work, both of mediation, if I may say so, and of appropriation, will also need to be done for adults, because what we said about social networks earlier and what you observe among those over 60, which is quite true and is measured when we look at the most problematic accounts regarding the dissemination of false information, is often enigmas. It is exactly the same thing we will have with AI. And credulity, for example, regarding artificial intelligence content, we know that people who are not prepared, not trained, will be much more exposed, but audiences who are much less acculturated to this and who are older will be caught much more quickly. And so, if we want to avoid this new fracture, we will also need to implement a real national program to train, if I may say so, in this critical spirit as much in digital matters, whether it concerns networks or AI, we will need to integrate AI.

In parallel to that, we will also need to tighten the rules and, in particular, regarding signatures or identifications of content created by AI. Since it is underlying in your question, if we want to avoid the fracture, it must also be clear to everyone that a piece of content, a video, an image is produced by artificial intelligence and is not the result of a real situation. And that is one of the real challenges. Today, you have seen, you have indeed well put it earlier in your figures and you have admitted yourself that you are being fooled because there are many images or videos circulating without being tagged or identified as being produced by AI. And we need to achieve this obligation that will allow everyone to identify more easily. But it is a matter of democracy and the functioning of the Republic, and your initiative, I find, shows very well that education as well as regulation, which are two levers we have discussed a lot this evening, never solve everything. There is a need for deliberation, a permanent effort, and, in a way, to maintain the democratic muscle through initiatives like yours. And that will also be essential to avoid the fracture.

Moderator

Thank you, Mr. President. My last mission is to conclude, to thank you obviously for this long exchange, to know if you wish to conclude with a few words or if everything has been said for you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you. Listen, first of all, I have to thank you, both of you, for moderating this debate. To the Minister of National Education for all the work he is doing and all the projects he is leading at the head of this magnificent ministry. And, of course, to Madame the Rector, Mr. the Prefect alongside him for carrying out this action with all those who carry out the action of the State, and then, of course, to thank you, La Voix du Nord, the entire editorial team, the group for the welcome, the debate, and to thank you all. I hope this has shed some light on things for you, but what I wish more than anything is that at the end of these exchanges, you can continue to nurture, precisely, in vivo this critical spirit. And if it has raised many doubts or questions in you, that is wonderful, because I do not claim that we have the answers to everything. But what I am convinced of is that we must act and that social networks, like artificial intelligence, are a tremendous opportunity, let us not be mistaken.

It is a technological change, and even more than that, an organization of knowledge, of uses for our generations, which is an opportunity. And so, we must keep this good side. That's how it happened. I would not want there to be any caricatures. Simply, we must domesticate them. That is to say, we must, at heart, remember what humanism is. It is that technological innovation must always serve humanity, that is to say, the dignity of the women and men who make up our society and the progress of our society. And every time we let a technology take precedence over us, not being controlled, we run the risk of harming ourselves, of getting hurt, or of leaving the evolution of our society in the hands of those who have mastery over this technology. And that is exactly what is happening. And so, I believe we really need a collective awakening to say to ourselves, we must protect our children and our teenagers much better than we have done so far. And here, we do not have the right to wait; screens, mobile phones, social networks, AI agents, with everything I have said so far. And so, we need to act fairly quickly, and we will all need to be in a society of mobilization to do so. Then, we must train much more, prepare our young people and our less young people for this transformation to navigate, to have solidly established knowledge and the perspective to distinguish the true from the false in this new space. And it is feasible. It is simply what we had learned to do in the Republic in a space, I would say, physical-human. There you go, we will continue to make Republicans, but in this digital space where there are, I would say, more false pretenses. But it is possible, with regulation, preparation, education, and journalistic work. We must absolutely consolidate the pillars of our Republic and our democracies. And that means that at the same time we have doubt, critical thinking, we must restore a bit of trust in the functioning of our democracy. Because if we let social networks operate as they do today, it is a mechanism of generalized distrust. And thus, trust in the teachers, who, in school, impart knowledge and respect for teachers, trust in scientific authority and in science, because it is established by women and men who, according to a method, define what knowledge is, and the authority in those who legitimately represent the democratic state, and it is the respect for mayors, elected officials, etc., and for the role of those who inform and journalists.

Restoring this principle of authority is essential in the age of social networks that level everything. Not all words are equal. That is not true. Because there is simply a space that must be structured if we want to live in society. And so, our challenge is also to preserve the organization of a democratic society that must be able to deliberate calmly, be in respect, prepare for free elections, and continue to advance with a relationship to truth, to falsehood, and the forging of a public opinion that is not biased. That will involve the regulation of these social networks, mechanisms of accountability, a change in our national and European laws, but also the consolidation of the pillars of our Republic, as I just said. And so, we must reinvigorate deliberation on the ground, but also restore authority to all those who are the custodians of these levees, but also of this fabric of the Republic.

And then, lastly, we will obviously accelerate all the work, as we have said, in the face of our external enemies and these risks of interference, because your examples have shown this very well, our discussion has illustrated it. But beyond everything we have discussed, we also have a risk that these weaknesses at a moment in our organization leave us at the mercy of one attack or another of misinformation. And today's conflict is not only conducted through bombs; it is a continuity, but it also begins in the minds. And so, we must protect that. I do not want to be longer, but thank you for giving me the opportunity to exchange with you on this point. But I need you to continue to keep these debates alive, to reflect on all this, because it will only work if we are a society that, in a way, carries these debates itself. From where I am, with the Government, we will try to advance texts at the European and national level, but they are only part of the fight. The rest is a fight of principle, of value, of trust in our democracy and our Republic. And ultimately, that is the most beautiful, it is what brings us here, to this educational institution.