Joint press conference of the President of the Republic and the German Chancellor during the state visit.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

28 May 2024 · Joint press conference of the President of the Republic and the German Chancellor during the state visit · Meseberg, Meseberg, Germany

Context
Macron addressed a joint press conference with Chancellor Scholz at Meseberg on May 28, 2024, concluding a Franco-German state visit and ministerial council.
Main themes
Franco-German cooperation, support for Ukraine, European defense and security, missile defense and deep strikes, European defense industrial base, future combat systems, G7 financial assistance for Ukraine, European economic growth, investment and innovation, green technologies and artificial intelligence, savings and investment union
Duration
~46 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,535
93rd percentile
Sentences
247
93rd percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
11.7
42nd percentile
Syntax
3.01
49th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
22nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

247 sentences in 77 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, good morning to all.

I am very happy to be here with you in Meseberg for the final stage of this state visit that began on Sunday. And I want to sincerely thank Chancellor Scholz and Federal President Steinmeier for their warm welcome, and from Berlin to Dresden, Münster, and now Meseberg, this joint immersion in the challenges we face, with very varied stages and many advances.

I am also very pleased to be here with you to concretely tackle many of the challenges we face together. And that is what we will do in our Franco-German Ministerial Council, the 24th of its kind, and in this Franco-German Council for Defense and Security.

Of course, the first issue - as the Chancellor just reminded us - is that of Ukraine, the security of our Europe, our peace. On this matter, the position of Germany and France has been united from the beginning, hand in hand, and our support for Ukraine will last as long and as intensely as necessary.

We have intensified this support together in recent months and we have also built new bilateral and multilateral channels to implement the lines of effort we defined during the conference on February 26 in Paris. I also want to thank Germany for the immediate action on air defense, which has been coordinated by you and is fully in line with this approach. We are also in the process of completing and increasing our support, and I will have the opportunity in the coming days - we discussed this with the Chancellor - to return to additional capabilities and the continuation of our aid to Ukraine.

Beyond that, as the Chancellor said, we are converging to provide additional financial assistance as we have since the beginning. We have done this as Europeans by building agreements to have new facilities, new European financing to support Ukraine since the beginning of this year, and our wish is that we can continue the same effort at the G7 level. Our ministers have started the work and we will work together so that by the time of the G7, which will take place in mid-June, we can have a joint initiative involving all G7 countries to strengthen funding for Ukraine, to provide more clarity and depth to it using different techniques that are currently on the table. We can return to this if questions arise.

Beyond Ukraine, the question of strengthening our security, our common defense in Europe, and as Europeans is obviously close to our hearts, and this is what we will discuss shortly through robust, credible, and common responses. I am particularly thinking of missile defense, for which we want to strengthen our autonomy, and deep strikes - the Chancellor just mentioned this - on which we are ready to launch long-term cooperation together.

These are all subjects on which, fundamentally, we see that we need to build a common framework for defense and security, define common concepts, share our needs, define common capabilities, and strengthen European defense in the long term, notably through increased support for the European defense industrial and technological base. This is what we have pushed for together, which was confirmed by the Commission a few months ago in the proposals made. The challenge now is to think about innovative and credible financing options that the European Council plans to revisit on June 27 and 28, with the idea that we can prioritize more towards European industries and projects.

Our Council in this regard will also allow us to take stock of our bilateral cooperation in armaments. I am thinking of the future combat air systems and the main ground combat system, the future combat aircraft and future tank projects on which our ministers signed a new agreement last month in Paris that specifies the distribution of industrial responsibilities. All of this contributes to building a common framework of peace and security in Europe, with the European Union, with NATO, with the European Political Community. And in this regard, Franco-German cooperation is crucial.

Beyond this topic, we will also be able to revisit economic, financial, and European growth issues. Fundamentally, we are both convinced that our Europe needs to innovate, to have even more growth, and to be at the heart of innovation, whether in green technologies or artificial intelligence.

For this, we need an investment shock within our Europe - and we will return to this, it will be at the beginning of our discussions in the Franco-German Ministerial Council - moving towards this union of savings and investment. For several years, we have been talking about this - and I want to emphasize that there is, and this is for me one of the significant achievements and results of this Ministerial Council that we have translated into a common text in the press, in a shortened form today, and a longer text that will come out of this Council. The convergence between the two of us is unprecedented in this regard, and I have no doubt that it will now lead to a strong accelerated movement throughout Europe. It was necessary, and we have achieved it.

It is indeed thanks to this that we can build, fundamentally, a true European capital markets union, that is to say, a Europe of savings and common financing. We have a lot of savings in our Europe today. This savings is not allocated to the right places and in the right sectors, and it still too often leaves - about 300 billion euros per year - European soil to invest in American capital. We have therefore decided together to call for the creation of a European savings product - massive financial savings, I mentioned, 35 trillion euros - and this savings product will be directed towards our long-term priorities, green transition, artificial intelligence, innovation, defense, which for us is an element of coherence, efficiency, and utilization of this savings.

Next, we want the Commission to move quickly on the issue of securitization, to make operational proposals to the Council in the coming months, also without taboos, with the appropriate prudential responses so that financial actors take more risks in these areas.

Finally, we will mandate our finance ministers during this Franco-German Ministerial Council, pardon, to implement our common ambition regarding the supervision of financial services, as well as the harmonization of our bankruptcy law, business law, and taxation, and greater convergence in tax matters. We also need to have a robust reflection on the transposition of banking and insurance prudential rules that today exclude too much risk. This project is major, it may seem technical, but it is decisive for the financing of our economies and for mobilizing the private money that exists towards our priorities. And for me, this is truly in action, the Franco-German couple, which shows concrete results through this decision.

The second topic of this Ministerial Council will be our joint contribution to the strategic agenda of the European Union for the next five years, and a text that we will therefore sign and transmit together. I will not go into detail here, the Chancellor has already emphasized several actions. But fundamentally, when we look at the economic challenges facing the European Union, pandemics, increasing competition, the U.S. Inflation Reduction Act and its consequences on the reallocation of factors, obviously, the war, the major transitions I mentioned in terms of climate and digital, we are therefore faced with an imperative to support production on our soil, innovate even more, mobilize more investments, take more risks so that Europe is not left behind by other major powers.

But fundamentally, this new paradigm of growth and competitiveness that we carry together is to produce more and greener, to simplify the rules - as the Chancellor just said - massively, to accelerate European industrial policy to become a leader by 2030 in key industries and technologies such as artificial intelligence, quantum, space, 5G and 6G, biotechnology, net-zero technologies, and chemistry or mobility. It is to win the battle of innovation and research by taking more risks, to define a trade policy capable of defending our more balanced interests, and to stimulate more public and private investments, as we have just said. This is, in my eyes, one of the important results of this Council.

And this common strategy that we defend is, in my eyes, a structuring framework for the European Commission and our actions for the next five years, because as I reminded again yesterday and this morning, there is urgency in this regard and the risk is great for Europe, if we do not make the important rapid decisions we have just mentioned, to be left behind by other powers and to lose our ability to build our prosperity.

Finally, I want to say a word about the situation in the Middle East. The situation, indeed, in Rafah is horrific, and I do not want to revisit what I already said yesterday; Israeli operations must cease in Rafah. There is currently no safe zone for Palestinian civilians. The International Court of Justice has called on Israel to end this offensive that puts civilian populations at risk, already displaced several times to avoid the fighting.

Our position has been clear from day one: we firmly condemned the terrorist attack by Hamas on October 7, and Hamas is responsible for this situation. We recognized Israel's right to defend itself, but while respecting, like any democracy, international law and humanitarian law. We have constantly prioritized the release of our hostages, and I want to thank the mediating powers that help us in this regard, and we reiterate our support for all initiatives in this direction. But as early as October, we called for a ceasefire because we see that the response to Hamas's terrorism cannot be a continuing ground operation.

That is why we support Algeria's request for an emergency meeting, and we are building with Algeria and all our partners in the Security Council a common resolution aimed at addressing this humanitarian emergency on the ground but also providing responses in terms of ceasefire and giving a clear UN mandate on Gaza.

The broader exit, and this is the last important point of response we have provided from day one, can only be political. And this is what I recalled in the exchange I had with our Arab partners last Friday: we are ready to actively work on a peace solution. It is achievable, with political will. It goes through a path, that of the day after for Gaza, more broadly for a Palestinian state, which requires many reforms, evolutions, a regional balance, and guaranteed security elements for Israel. It is this comprehensive political response that is now a necessity.

Chancellor, I also want to thank you for the quality of our exchanges just now and the richness of this Franco-German Ministerial Council, thank you for all the joint work and reiterate here that, beyond our common friendship built in the face of crises, I believe I can say that the decisions we have made both in response to the war in Ukraine launched by Russian aggression, but also in the face of all the challenges of our times, we have constantly made common decisions, I believe, that have allowed Europe to move forward. And what we are doing regarding this Council, on the occasion of this Ministerial Council, both on the financing of support for Ukraine and on defense issues, as well as on the Capital Markets Union or the competitiveness and growth of Europe, is part of this Franco-German ambition.

Our friendship is in action, it is made of a history, it is made of personal ties that unite us, but also of strong decisions made at the right moment. And I believe that this is the right moment to make the decisions we are acting on today.

Thank you, Chancellor, dear Olaf. Vielen Dank.

Journalist

Good evening. Guten Abend. Just to follow up on what you just said about Gaza and Israel and Rafah. This resolution you are proposing, is it a resolution, is it a way to revive the French resolution project in the Security Council, is that correct, in connection, in cooperation with Algeria? To what extent are you sure that all Europeans will vote for this resolution, particularly Germany? Well, that was the follow-up question to what you just said.

And then otherwise, on Ukraine, I wanted to know if, Mr. President of the Republic, you have in mind to send French instructors, indeed, on the ground in Ukraine? Where do we stand? The Ukrainians have said they are ready, have almost said that the instructors have even arrived on site. What is the purpose of sending French instructors to Ukraine?

Do you think, Mr. Scholz…

What do you think of the perspective of sending French instructors to Ukraine?

You were very skeptical a few months ago about sending Western troops to Ukraine. Is it a good idea to send French instructors?

And then, in this context, why talk so much about negotiations and peace? During the trip, you spoke several times about negotiation, I believe, Mr. Macron, while the situation is bogged down on the ground, the fighting is stagnating, the Russians have the advantage. Why revive the idea of possible negotiations? Thank you.

Emmanuel Macron

On your first question, the objective that is ours, and this will be the work of our diplomats in the coming hours and days, is to provide a comprehensive response to the situation, not simply the project that may have already been put forward, but to complete it, to enrich it also in light of the degradation of the situation and what has happened in recent days, which is absolutely dramatic. And I say this because it is our duty in every respect.

So, we will complete this work, continue it, and it will indeed be the work of the coming days to convince all our partners. And I have complete confidence in our ability to find precisely decisions and also a way to express them in common, particularly with our European partners, but to convince beyond that, which could block an essential resolution for the situation in Gaza.

If you are referring to what was issued yesterday on certain communication channels by our Ukrainian partners, I believe they themselves have corrected those statements. So, I am not in the habit of commenting on rumors or decisions that may arise.

We have a precise framework of action: it is to support Ukraine; to do everything necessary and for as long as necessary. I have already expressed myself on several occasions and I will have the opportunity, when President Zelensky comes to France on the occasion of D-Day next week, to receive him, and at that moment, to express myself very precisely to announce what we are going to do. But I will not comment on what has been uncoordinated and unfortunate communications.

Then, I have spoken of peace several times because I believe it is our objective. And it happens that this morning in Munster we were talking about peace. I do not believe I spoke of negotiations. It happens that Ukraine has taken the initiative with Switzerland to organize a conference that it has called a peace conference. So I do not think it is a dirty word, including for the Ukrainians, but that is how they want to end.

I simply recalled very simple things during this trip. Peace is not the capitulation of Ukraine. That is a very important point because today, there are false pacifists in Europe, in all our countries, people who say: "we, we are for stopping everything immediately." Moreover, if we follow today the voice of a part of the Russian authorities, the President goes around the world saying: "I am for peace. They have still given up the territories I invaded by force." That is not peace. That is not our vision of peace. I have said and recalled, peace can only be durable and therefore in respect of international law.

Then, I think no one believes that peace will return solely through arms. And so we have a simple principle, which is that we are for negotiations. But the day they are decided by both parties, particularly by the Ukrainians, and that they take place under desirable and good conditions for them, that they are not imposed on them; it is the opposite of capitulation. It is not the day, it is not the hour, you have said it very well. On the other hand, we must constantly talk about peace to remind that we are building through our aid to Ukraine, the conditions for peace. We are helping a country that is invaded by a revisionist imperialist power, to defend itself in order to one day open peace negotiations. Referring to the discussions this morning, I fervently hope that it is not in 30 years.

Journalist

[Translated from German]

Mr. President, Germany has initiated a Sky Shield missile defense system, and a large number of countries are already participating. When will France decide to participate in this project?

And for Ukraine, the Ukrainian President would like, alongside Western instructors, permission to attack Russian positions with Western weapons. Would France be ready to grant this authorization, for example, for SCALP cruise missiles?

And Mr. Chancellor, regarding the ESSI, the missile shield, we think it is important for you that other countries such as France or Italy participate, and how do you envision the financing, can you imagine European financing as proposed by Poland and Greece?

And regarding the instructors in Ukraine and attacks on Russian territory with Western weapons, we need to ask whether this would be direct participation in the war, if it would mean such participation, is this something you have ruled out? Would it therefore be participation? Would it be a red line?

Emmanuel Macron

Thank you very much for your questions. First, on the question of defense and a shield and a ground-air defense initiative that has been taken by Germany, we are in a very different strategic and capability situation between Germany and France. And this is because France is a nuclear power with air and naval capabilities, which gives it a deterrent capacity and places us in very different positions regarding the risks we are exposed to. And so, it is legitimate for each country in Europe to look at the risks it is exposed to and seek to protect itself as best as possible, depending on both its history and its preferences. And so, it is based on these differences that we approach things.

So, I think the German initiative has the merit of raising this question in a very pertinent way for all countries that do not have deterrence. And in a framework that has changed and that I recalled myself - it seems ancient given the pace of current events - but in 2019, when the United States unilaterally decided to withdraw from the INF Treaty - placing us in a situation, we Europeans - we were exposed to certain weapons held by the Russians without a framework. So, it is based on these differences that we do not necessarily have the same initiatives.

The key, what we will together address during this Franco-German defense and security council - and I think it is in this regard that, for me, the moment we are living is very structuring - is that finally, we are starting to ask the most fundamental questions. Who are our enemies today? Who are our adversaries? What are their capabilities and the risks they pose to us? Who are their potential allies? What are the risks we have tomorrow? And based on that as Europeans, regardless of the alliances we have — and NATO — independently of those and in complement - because that is exactly how the so-called Sky Shield initiative is conceived - well, to build strategic responses and then European capabilities. And from ground-air defense to the question of deep strikes, to how to integrate into a European strategy the fact that several British and French powers have their own deterrent capacity, all of this needs to be integrated into a common security and defense framework. That is what we are building and what we will now structure.

As for your second question, which has indeed been raised by some of our partners and allies who have explicitly expressed their intention to allow, France has always maintained the same framework of action in Ukraine: we support Ukraine to resist and defend its territory, and we do not want escalation. It is the same framework in which we want to intervene.

What has changed is that Russia has somewhat adapted its practices. Several of you, including a good evening newspaper in France, have released this map which is very accurate, but which shows you that Ukrainian soil, you see, is being attacked from bases that are in Russia. So how do we explain to the Ukrainians that they need to protect these cities and essentially everything we see around Kharkiv? If we tell them "you do not have the right to reach the point from which the missiles are fired," in fact, we are telling them "we are supplying you with weapons, but you cannot defend yourselves."

So we remain exactly within the same framework: we believe that we must allow them to neutralize the military sites from which the missiles are fired and essentially, the military sites from which Ukraine is being attacked, but we must not allow them to hit other targets in Russia, obviously civilian capabilities or other military targets. When it is from identified targets in Russia that Ukraine is being attacked, well, I think we should be able to allow them to do so if we truly want to achieve our objective. And I believe I can say that factually, we are not escalating by doing this, since it is Russia that is organizing itself in this way.

Journalist

Good evening Mr. Chancellor, Mr. President. You mentioned earlier, yourself, these Israeli strikes that killed 45 people, according to Palestinian authorities. And today, they mention 21 people killed in another strike, which has created a lot of outrage. We saw it notably this afternoon in France, where there was an incident in the National Assembly. I do not know, Mr. President, if you wish to comment on this.

But beyond that, on the substance, we heard earlier in your statements the words of our two countries condemning these strikes. But beyond words, do you understand? And what do you say to the critics who denounce, according to them, an impunity of Israel, even a passivity on the part of our countries? Is it conceivable for you to consider sanctions, for example, financial ones, or on arms deliveries to Israel? And do you also consider sending a signal, as partners like Spain or Ireland and Norway have done, to recognize the State of Palestine in the short term? Thank you.

Emmanuel Macron

I do not want to reiterate what I mentioned in my initial remarks. On the situation, I want to be very clear: there are no double standards for us. And so the respect for international law applies everywhere and the consideration we have for lives is the same for every life. That is why there is no, in our eyes, impunity either and that we support international justice, its work wherever it needs to be done and where it will be done.

As I speak to you, we believe that the most useful action is indeed to obtain a ceasefire and an international framework that allows both to ensure the security of Israel, respect for humanitarian law, and the protection of populations in Gaza, which is not the case today. And we cannot accept a situation where it is presented as irreconcilable, where somehow, one would have to choose between the security of Israel and the protection of civilian populations in Gaza. That is impossible.

And so we will focus our energy on continuing the humanitarian actions we have been carrying out since day one: military boats to treat more than 1,000 Palestinians and children; delivery of medicines, food; dropping these also in Gaza. We will strengthen and complement this with diplomatic action and this resolution to try very concretely to stop things and obtain the ceasefire that we have been calling for since October.

As for the recognition of the Palestinian state, I have already said, we have always defended it, including a few years ago, when no one was talking about it, we were there to defend it, I remind you. Sometimes even in the region. We have always defended the two-state solution as being the political solution and particularly the one that allowed for addressing the legitimate rights of Palestinians aspiring to a state. There is no taboo for France and I am totally ready to recognize a Palestinian state.

But I have always said from the beginning, and I explained this again last Friday to all the foreign ministers of the region who came, with whom we worked on the Arab initiative, I believe that this recognition must come at a useful moment, that is to say at a moment when it fits into a process where the states of the region and Israel are committed and which allows, also based on a reform of the Palestinian Authority, to produce a useful result. I will not make an emotional recognition, if I may say so. I think that in the face of what we are experiencing, this emotion that we feel because, like you, I am shaken by the images we see, shocked by what we see today in Rafah. Well, the response must be political through resolution, through action and an immediate ceasefire.

Journalist

[Translated from German]

Mr. President, Mr. Chancellor. I wanted to address a topic where there are many differing opinions between France and Germany regarding the financing of other projects. You spoke of an investment shock for Europe. You proposed yesterday to double the European Union budget. I wanted to know if this is really a realistic prospect?

This is also a question directed at Mr. Chancellor. We have seen in recent years that the 27 states of the European Union wanted to limit the European Union budget instead. What has changed for you to be able to realize this vision?

Mr. Chancellor, you spoke of the inspiring speeches of Mr. President yesterday in Dresden and of a geopolitical Europe. If this is the geopolitical Europe we want, would it be time for Germany to have common financing paths? Something to which Germany has sometimes opposed until now - the fund for reconstruction after Covid, to name just one example. Would this be a path you would like to take for the investment shock you mentioned? Is this the path that should be taken in the European Union?

And to conclude this press conference, you spoke of harmony. In the last month, we have often heard about dissonance or a lack of harmony between the two of you, is this the end of that lack of harmony between you two?

Emmanuel MACRON

First of all, I have good news for you, it has actually happened that we have doubled the European budget. What I mean by that is that we need, let me explain, we need to have a much larger common financing today. But if you look at the last eight years, we had under the Juncker Commission a Juncker plan that was in addition to the European budget and that was a massive plan that allowed for the financing of projects. These are loans, but it provided a common financing capacity. And at the time of Covid, based on a Franco-German agreement, the Chancellor remembers, he was then Minister of Finance, we first decided to raise money together and we enabled this European recovery plan. And the European recovery plan, I do not believe I am betraying you by saying that you qualified this moment as Hamiltonian. Indeed, it was a real change in the conception of financing our Europe and the reality is that the magnitude of this plan was the same as the budget.

So, I am not saying that we need to double the budget as it is currently designed with state contributions - because we all have our budgets to build and that would be absolutely impossible. But my message in Dresden, at the Sorbonne, is simply to be clear-eyed. Look at the investment wall that is in front of us. Defense and security, cleantech - because the Americans are putting a lot of money with the IRA, more than we are - and artificial intelligence. If we just take these three things, it is at the scale of Europe, several tens, even hundreds of billions per year for a few years. And in reality, we cannot just let the states each do their own thing because we will break the single market if we do that and we cannot smooth it over time because the allocation of factors is happening now, the real massive investment choices to be in the race or not are being made now. So, we need to have this shock.

On the public side, I think we can build and that will be all our work, not technically doubling the budget, using the same lines as today, but having a common financing capacity using the techniques that have been ours, either during Covid, or by being innovative, using existing mechanisms. I do not want to preempt instruments, but we need common financing to move faster on these transitions and our defense initiatives. That must then be complemented by national choices, but which are limited in time.

And then, the other leg is private financing. And that is also why what we are carrying today in this Council of Ministers is very structuring. Creating the Union of Capital Markets gives us the guarantee of several tens, even hundreds of billions per year that will be better directed towards our priorities and the risk-taking on the private side of these priorities. And I just mentioned the same: artificial intelligence, industry, green technology, defense, and security. That is a necessity.

So, we have work ahead of us, but I think it is realistic too because I rely on the experience of recent years and what we have been able to do.

Then, it is as old as the Franco-German couple to say that it is in crisis. It has always existed. Look at the last 70 years. So, either we make great advances, and then six months later, we say it is a crisis. One proposes, the other does not respond immediately, whether it is Sky Shield, whether it is the budget. We say: "ah, a crisis." Well no, it is a path.

And so, it is a maieutics, Europe, and starting with the Franco-German couple. It is a permanent translation from one to the other, it is a journey we take together to achieve a result. The result is never totally German, nor totally French, it is Franco-German. And then, it becomes European. And at this rate, we will always be in crisis, I assure you, and Europe will always be in crisis, because we will never be the same. And that is a chance. And I believe that is the lesson for me of Franco-German friendship and in this regard, it is in this that it is the matrix of the European adventure. We always come to an agreement and we move forward. And by the way, if we are here, it is because we have advanced, survived crises, and built the future. But without ever being the same.

And that is what makes Europeans, I believe, a unique continent, at least for these seven decades, a little more, and that makes us also a continent, in my eyes, stronger than others because we have already come to an agreement with someone else - which is not the case for solitary great powers. And it is for this reason, because we have these capabilities, that we can always also have a head start. I do not see it as a handicap.

So yes, there are moments when we do not start from the same position, from the same point of view, and that is perfectly legitimate. There are many subjects on which we do not have the same histories, we do not have the same situation today. Our duty is to overcome it to build a common solution, which is good for one and the other and the Franco-German general interest, then European. I believe that is what we have been able to do and what we are doing. It is for this reason that Franco-German friendship is so important and that I am extremely happy about these three days of state visit and the exchanges we have today and beyond that, that we have every day, with my friend Chancellor Olaf SCHOLZ.