Joint statement by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, and Paolo Gentiloni, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 September 2017 · 34th Franco-Italian summit · Confluences Museum, Lyon, France

Context
Macron and Gentiloni jointly addressed the 34th Franco-Italian Summit in Lyon on September 27, 2017, presenting a shared bilateral roadmap.
Main themes
Franco-Italian bilateral cooperation, European integration, cultural exchange and Erasmus, climate change and global warming, military cooperation and defense industry, STX shipyard agreement, Lyon-Turin infrastructure project, Sahel security cooperation, European university initiative, shared industrial strategy
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,297
64th percentile
Sentences
67
44th percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
16.7
88th percentile
Syntax
3.35
86th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
40th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 37%34%
  • Economic 27%25%
  • Ceremonial 17%16%
  • Institutional 11%10%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Environmental 2%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

67 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Dear Paolo,

I am first of all delighted that we can all meet in this beautiful city of Lyon for the 34th Franco-Italian summit at such an important time for Europe. We were able to see part of the city together earlier, and we will, along with our ministers, shortly be able to cross another part and share a friendly dinner in this capital of French gastronomy, and we could almost make the people of Lyon believe that, for the moment of a day, it has become the capital.

In any case, we saw earlier, through this quick journey of our shared cinematic history and this beautiful Confluences Museum, all the symbolism and harmonics of this term which is a bit of our common history on both sides of the border and, more broadly, in Europe because it is indeed about confluences between France and Italy, because it is indeed about confluences through our common constructions for the European Union.

This evening, we will have the opportunity to delve into the details of the shared roadmap between France and Italy with all the ministers present here that will guide the coming months of our joint work. We were able, at first, to exchange on important bilateral issues – and we will return to them – on which we wish to advance together, with a bilateral roadmap and concrete projects for the coming months.

I will mention a few, but I invite you to take note of the complete document that has been distributed. In terms of culture, Italy already has a Culture Pass from which I drew inspiration during the presidential campaign, and I therefore wish that, notwithstanding the useful exchanges of good practices that we can have, we can work concretely on this idea of a cultural Erasmus, of a cross-exchange of artists. There are already great institutions on both sides of the border that welcome many artists, but we can and must go further in this area.

I also wish that we can work together, develop a joint agenda, and give substance to this idea of a European university so that we can also advance concretely, already bilaterally, on what we want for Europe. Our document – and tonight's discussion will show it – is also a shared strategy in terms of climate and the fight against global warming. We have joint commitments at the international level in Europe, pardon me, but we can also do much more at the bilateral level through industrial exchanges, exchanges of good practices, strengthened interconnections, and the development of joint initiatives that are detailed in the roadmap.

It is also an already intense military cooperation that will be further developed with the launch of a study on the rapprochement of our industries with the aim of creating a global champion in the naval field. This extremely important idea, which we care about a lot, will help structure this strategic agenda. And beyond that, the enhanced cooperation that we also wish to have in the Sahel by deciding on common military deployments that will give substance to the cooperation we already have on the ground.

I want to particularly return to two files that are illustrative for me of the method that, together with the Italian Prime Minister, we wish to pursue. A method in which good projects are projects that make Italy and France winners. When one has to carry out a political action and to preside or govern, one is always confronted in our mutual opinions with commentators who want to know who wins when we discuss, who prevails. Sometimes even those who said it was scandalous for the other to win say the next day: "It is I who has now prevailed."

So I will tell you, there are two projects on which we win together because if we do not win together, we both lose: it is the STX project and the Lyon-Turin project. On the STX project, the last few weeks have been used by our ministers, and I thank them for finding an intelligent solution. Last spring, I wanted us to give ourselves a little more time because the agreement that had been reached did not guarantee, particularly for the Saint-Nazaire shipyards, the absence of any technological transfer and the risks of transfer of charges that could have jeopardized the sustainability of this site. On the other side, there was a legitimate desire from Fincantieri to be the industrial operator of this shared site.

The agreement we found, after France exercised its right of preemption for a time – and this has always been clear in this regard – is to be able to have the capital holding that we wish and thus a 50/50, but through a sustainable loan of shares, so that Fincantieri is indeed the industrial operator who consolidates, decides, and directs the destinies of a true European group with the possibility of guaranteeing the Saint-Nazaire shipyards: that there is no transfer of charges, that there is no technological transfer, and that in case of a problem, this percentage that is loaned is returned.

None of us will have to lead the day-to-day destiny of this company, but we are thus creating the conditions for a clear direction on the economic and industrial level and clear guarantees on the ground for the industrial footprint in France as well as in Italy. That is why we can both say today that it is a win-win agreement. To those who say: "It's terrible! In fact, there will be an industrial operator who is not French," I want to remind them that until a few months ago, by a very large majority, the shareholder and the operator was Korean. Let me explain, when we defend Europe every day, why it is better to have a Korean operator and shareholder than an Italian operator, and those who say: "Wonderful! I won! Italy has the majority" should look at the reality of the shareholders' agreement: we are at 50/50 with real guarantees, this is not the agreement of spring, but we have built the terms of an agreement that allows the operator Fincantieri to direct the destinies of this company. I therefore believe that we have built something intelligent, but we wish to go further together through this partnership in the naval sector.

Regarding the Lyon-Turin project, we are both fully committed to ensuring that the cross-border section of this line, which is part of the trans-European transport networks and whose realization relies on international agreements, is successfully completed. Commitments have been made, community funding has been decided, we must be clear about the base tunnel, and I want to reaffirm our commitment to each other here. We can both regret that others made breakthroughs before us. Therefore, in the strategy that Italy and France will have to conduct, it will be necessary to develop this axis economically.

Its strategic dimension for France, Italy, and Europe as a key component of the Mediterranean corridor of European networks is an essential criterion in the reflection we want to conduct, and also by the first quarter of 2018, in full association with the European Commission, our two governments wish to clarify the future terms, beyond the base tunnel, and that is why we have decided to set up a working group between our two ministries of Transport, in connection with the European coordinator, with the aim of jointly making precise common proposals by the end of the year. You have also seen the industrial agreements that have just been signed in front of us.

We then discussed common international issues, particularly Libya. We have taken several initiatives together in recent months on the Libyan issue, and we both supported last week the roadmap presented by the Special Representative of the United Nations Secretary-General, Ghassan Salamé, on the sidelines of the General Assembly.

This roadmap, I believe I can say, faithfully reflects everything that Italy and France are committed to regarding the resolution of the Libyan crisis, and therefore we will do everything together to ensure that this roadmap is respected and that concrete results can be achieved in order to politically stabilize Libya and to build the framework for the upcoming elections.

In the coming weeks and months, we will act in concert mainly in three directions, beyond this roadmap. The first, in accordance with the summit of August 28 in Paris, is to prevent migration and human trafficking in the Sahel-Saharan band and along the Eastern route through our joint action, that of our partners, the European Union, and the African transit countries to prevent them, work with the UNHCR, work with the security forces mainly from Niger and Chad, and prevent additional migratory influx.

The second, by having a joint action, in connection with all the actors on the ground, to combat the establishment of any terrorist group in Libya. The risk, we know, is that groups coming from the Iraqi-Syrian area may use the period to establish themselves. We will therefore both be very vigilant through our military, police presence, and our cooperation to eradicate this point.

The third, by fully cooperating to stabilize the migratory pressure in Libya. And on this subject, it is essential that, particularly with the UNHCR, all stakeholders in Libya improve the current conditions of refugee camps, that international rules are respected, and that the pressure that has been exerted and that has previously been exerted on Italy is contained as it has been since the summer.

On these three files, we will work closely together. More broadly, this theme leads me to mention the European agenda that we have also discussed extensively. We wish together, on current issues, to take common positions, particularly for this Europe that protects. The Europe that protects is the Europe of defense. I have mentioned the bilateral issues on which we wish to advance more quickly, but whether it is the European Fund or the policy we have more broadly with a few of structured permanent cooperation, we will defend a common view. In terms of controlling strategic investments, we will jointly support the initiatives led by the President of the European Commission.

For the reform of the posted workers directive, we are jointly carrying all the same amendments, and we will thus be able to give full comfort to the presidency of the Council to obtain during this presidency an agreement that I wish to be as rapid and ambitious as possible. This is also, this agenda of a Europe that protects, the one that will allow us to act together on migration and beyond the issue of Libya, I wish that we can work together towards an acceleration and greater coherence of the European agenda in terms of border control, asylum, return to borders, and integration policy.

There are currently seven texts on the table being discussed that are subject to technical blockages because these discussions are scattered. It is essential that, on this subject, we can restore political meaning and have a coordinated approach that corresponds to what we want to do, to have an ambitious development policy towards the countries of origin because it is the only sustainable response, to have a demanding policy towards transit countries – which we launched on August 28 – to have a policy of protecting our borders in common, and this is the solidarity we owe to the countries of arrival, particularly Italy, to have a policy of harmonizing our asylum rules and a thorough reform of Dublin, to have a very coordinated policy of returns for those who do not hold titles, and finally to have a common policy of integrating refugees where they are welcomed.

It is on these pillars that we will work together in the coming months because it is essential to move in this ambitious direction. Beyond this agenda of a Europe that protects, which is our short-term agenda, we have revisited all the proposals I made yesterday at the Sorbonne for a European initiative that has been the subject, I must say, and I said it yesterday, of many friendly political exchanges with the President of the Italian Council, and on this subject, we both have the will to carry this ambition in a concrete manner and, starting tomorrow evening in Tallinn, to be able to launch these initiatives of the group of friends of the refoundation and to be able to move forward, to also give our ministers the opportunity to work together, to our teams to carry this European agenda of initiatives and to have very strong bilateral coordination within the framework of this European agenda because – I believe I can say – it is the history of our countries and Europe can only be revitalized if we have this degree of ambition together.

And whether it concerns transnational lists, whether it concerns the refoundation project on all aspects of sovereignty, unity, and democracy, I hope that we can actively work together in the coming weeks and months.

So, dear Paolo, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, this is what I wanted to remind you of after the exchanges of the day and before the concluding dinner this evening and to reiterate here that this cooperation, which has a long history, is essential to advance Europe. Today, we are two ambitious countries for the European adventure, with a shared desire to refound it. Next year, Italy will host the next summit, but I am already thinking about 2019, when we will celebrate the 500th anniversary of the death of Leonardo da Vinci, which is one of the traces of this shared history, and we will then meet in the Loire Valley to celebrate our friendship and shared culture. Thank you.