Press conference of the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, at the Digital Summit in Tallinn, Estonia.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

29 September 2017 · Digital Summit · Tallinn, Estonia

Context
Macron held a press conference at the EU Digital Summit in Tallinn, Estonia on 29 September 2017, addressing EU reform and the digital agenda.
Main themes
European Union reform and refoundation, digital agenda and Digital Single Market, innovation financing and European DARPA, artificial intelligence and emerging technologies, EU economic and monetary union, immigration and security challenges, ecological and digital transition, EU 2019 elections and institutional mandate, labor market and investment reforms, EU-Africa development
Duration
~18 min
60th percentile
Words
2,146
60th percentile
Sentences
84
54th percentile
Readability
35
25th percentile
Grade
14.7
74th percentile
Syntax
3.25
78th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 60%60%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Technological 12%12%
  • Geopolitical 6%6%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

84 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Ladies and Gentlemen,

This informal Summit in Tallinn first allowed us to hold an informal dinner last night for reflections and exchanges, as we had wished with several member states, and as Donald TUSK and the Estonian Prime Minister had agreed to organize. And I want to thank them particularly for that.

This dinner allowed us to exchange views, particularly following the speeches of the President of the European Commission and the one I delivered earlier this week in France, on the future perspectives and transformation of the European Union. The discussion was very open and led to the conclusion to establish a new process and a new organization to accelerate our work, to gain in ambition, and in fifteen days, Donald TUSK, based on our discussion, will propose this new method, with regular meetings as I suggested earlier in the week, of heads of state and government to accelerate this European refoundation.

I think it was important that we had this exchange which, beyond the European Councils where discussions have become extremely technical and revolve around statements, allowed us to reconnect with the thread of European ambition. There was a real convergence to indicate that it is today that we must carry out this work, because the year 2018 is a year of opportunity on the European agenda.

There are transformations and challenges that are playing out now, security, immigration, the development of Africa, but also ecological and digital transition and our economic and monetary power. In five years, in ten years, it will be too late. And it is in 2018 that we must finalize a common roadmap so that the European elections of 2019 can take place on this basis, since they will have to define the mandate of the upcoming Commission and Parliament. If we are not able to do this now, we are somewhat losing the opportunity of the five years that will follow. This is the justification for this approach that I wished to launch with others, and which allowed us this exchange yesterday.

Today has been dedicated to the digital agenda. As you know, the European Commission has conducted several important works to go further in terms of digital regulation, to establish a Digital Single Market, and several initiatives have been taken at the ministerial level, particularly among Finance ministers, in recent weeks.

On this subject, to summarize our discussions which did not lead to formal conclusions or decisions, but which were able to clarify orientations and provide concrete elements, I believe we all share, first, the conviction that the follow-up of digital is a profound transformation element of our societies and economies, and that we need to succeed in carrying out common actions in depth. And I would like to shed light on this debate around essentially four subjects.

The first, if we want to succeed in the digital battle, is that we must have a policy of reform, transformation, and investments to bring forth champions and ensure the success of our players in the digital realm.

This is primarily the objective of the national policies we are conducting. France, at the moment, is doing this with the reform of the labor market, investment in skills, the transformation of its taxation and the financing of its economy to promote the financing of growth and innovation, which are essential in a digitizing economy.

All economies must carry out these reforms, but if we want to fully succeed in this offensive economic aspect, we have several decisions to make at the European Union level: to finalize the Digital Single Market to have an integrated market. Today, a digital player that is created must deal with 28 regulations, each time incurring costs and complexity. Therefore, we must finalize this Single Market for more simplicity, more efficiency, to bring forth our champions.

We also need, to succeed, to advance in the financing of our players, and for that, the completion of a common financing Union is essential, because we need to better finance growth and innovation.

In this context – I have insisted and there is a convergence of several member states in this regard – the idea of establishing a European "DARPA," that is to say, an agency for financing breakthrough innovation, is particularly important. Because, in this economy of innovation and digital, the one who is ahead, who manages to make a technological breakthrough, generally takes the entire market. And therefore, it is essential that Europe, on artificial intelligence, on autonomous vehicles, on blockchain and all upcoming breakthrough innovations, can position itself by having a real common policy for financing these technological advancements.

On this aspect, the ambition has been reaffirmed, with the will to carry all convergences and thus an agenda that we wish to accelerate on the conclusion of the Digital Single Market, with a regulatory content and ambition. And we have also obtained to accelerate the meeting of Telecommunications ministers who will discuss this agenda. The meeting was scheduled for December; as early as October, under Estonian presidency, a meeting will be held to accelerate this Market. This is the first offensive pillar.

The second pillar that we care a lot about is that of fair competition. If we want to succeed in the digital realm, we need there to be fair competition in the global digital space. Today, the dominant players, particularly Anglo-Saxon ones, do not respect all the rules of the game. We saw this last year with the sanction imposed by the European Commission against GOOGLE regarding price comparison websites. I think it was a salutary decision, which marked both political courage and the indispensable regulation, the beginning of regulation, to allow other players to emerge.

Today, we know that Internet giants do not respect the rules of the game and use their dominant position to prevent other players from emerging in other economic sectors. In this regard, we want ambitious regulation, and this must be part of the Digital Single Market. But in the meantime, or to accompany this ambitious regulation, France, Germany, Spain, and Italy have taken an initiative this week that we communicated to our colleagues, which we, a few of us, carried during these discussions, which is precisely to take a European initiative to create transparency on the behavior of platforms and encourage good conduct.

An initiative that, if endorsed by all member states and institutions, would lead to the establishment of a common site, a common platform that would allow anyone, any economic actor who is a victim of excessive behavior or, if I may say, dominant behavior in a market, to report the difficulties they have encountered, to make these difficulties known. It is, in a way, a practice of transparency, using "Name & Shame" to borrow an Anglo-Saxon phrase, which would usefully allow better regulation for many Internet actors who, today, operate with us, who are not necessarily dominant players, and to defend their position.

When GOOGLE decided to enter the price comparison sector, they caused a 90% drop in market share for all independent European operators in this sector. When one of the GAFA decided to delist certain players in activities they wished to engage in, they sometimes killed these players. We need to have, if I may say, "whistleblowers" on these issues of economic aggression, and that is somewhat the idea of this initiative platform that we are launching, and I emphasized this morning on this subject: we need, at the same time as we build ambitious regulation, to innovate in our common practices. Because digital moves faster than our ability to regulate, because the digital players are numerous and we must also leverage collective intelligence. That was the meaning of this ambition carried by several, and it is the heart of this second pillar: fair competition in the digital realm.

The third pillar of the action we must undertake is that of financing common goods. Digital profoundly disrupts our economies, our societies. But it also implies financing things that no private actor finances. A significant portion of our populations do not have access to digital today, because they do not have access to fiber, because they lack knowledge or capabilities, and this is a real challenge for all societies and all democracies in the European Union. If we only have an ambitious digital agenda without trying to reduce the digital divide everywhere in our countries, we will feed populism and extremes. This is an investment that operators do not make because it is not profitable. It is up to public authorities to do it.

Digital, as I said, profoundly disrupts economic sectors and requires requalifying millions of our fellow citizens in each of our countries. This means training them differently, but also training throughout life, either to change sectors or to change types of activities within a sector.

This investment is a public investment. Economic actors hardly do it. These common goods are essential if we want to succeed in the digital transition, and if we do not want this transition to mean the exclusion of contemporary society for millions of our fellow citizens. To do this, we must organize its fair financing by digital actors. However, today, the digital giants do not contribute to the financing of common goods. It would be absurd to ask the actors of today's or yesterday's economy, who are themselves disrupted, sometimes weakened by digital, to be the only ones to finance this transformation! However, today, that is the situation we find ourselves in. Industrialists, our industrialists, our SMEs, our micro-enterprises pay corporate taxes, VAT, and all the taxation we know, taxation from which, in almost totality, particularly the large digital players escape by optimizing their tax structures in international arrangements.

That is why I support the initiative taken by the European Commission for a tax within the framework of ACCIS. That is why I want us to go further and I support the initiative taken by several Finance ministers for a tax on the value created in our countries. This tax will allow for a fair financing of these common goods by taxing the actors who compete with European players and who, today, do not sufficiently or at all participate in this financing.

This is a tax that also has the advantage of not creating a displacement effect or loss of tax base since it is based on the value created in a country and not on the establishment and stable presence in the country of the said operator. This is relevant in relation to the very logic of digital. This means that when some tell us: "If you tax them, they will leave"; no, we will no longer tax, if we follow the proposal of our Finance ministers, if they no longer operate in our countries. But I do not believe for a second that the Internet giants will stop operating in our countries because we take a percentage, justly, of the value created and operated in the said country. This tax is extremely important because we cannot consider that the development of digital can happen without the fair investment in the common goods I mentioned.

Finally, the fourth pillar of our action is cybersecurity and cyber defense. This digital universe offers enormous opportunities for our fellow citizens, our businesses, our governments. We have also talked a lot about e-government. France has been very committed. I had the opportunity to speak on this subject in New York, and Estonia is an exemplary country in this regard. But we also need to secure our systems. We want to better exchange best practices for securing our fellow citizens. In this regard, Estonia and Denmark are extremely advanced, with a digital identity, security procedures. As the Estonian President said this morning, it is a digital hygiene that we need to generalize.

I wished for us to have an industrial strategy on basic materials that would allow us to better secure information exchanges and our digital infrastructure, and we have made several decisions that must be included in the Commission's agenda until the end of the year regarding cybersecurity and cyber defense to better secure our public and private communication networks, to better secure our software, to also better secure certain particularly sensitive objects, and finally to equip ourselves with a counter-attack capability, because there is no credible security without the ability to respond on these issues.

Obviously, a significant part of these discussions falls under defense secrecy, particularly the defense aspect of cyber defense and cyber attack. But on this matter, cooperation is strengthening, and in my view, it is a key element of our agenda.

These are the four pillars of digital action that we discussed today, and France's position is as I have just indicated to you. This is what I wanted to report in a few moments on the agenda for the evening and the day.