Ministerial statement at the conclusion of the 5th Ecological Defense Council

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 July 2020 · 5th Ecological Defense Council

Context
Macron's government spokesperson and ministers addressed the press following the 5th Ecological Defense Council on July 27, 2020, outlining climate measures from the Citizens' Convention for Climate.
Main themes
Ecological transition, Citizens' Convention for Climate, housing and mobility measures, thermal renovation of buildings, greenhouse gas emissions reduction, biodiversity protection, land artificialization, citizen participation, legislative roadmap, rail transport, energy consumption control, territorial protection
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,314
88th percentile
Sentences
214
90th percentile
Readability
44
47th percentile
Grade
12.2
48th percentile
Syntax
2.81
23rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
71st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 34%33%
  • Environmental 24%23%
  • Ceremonial 16%15%
  • Social 13%12%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

214 sentences in 80 paragraphs

Gabriel ATTAL, Secretary of State to the Prime Minister, Government Spokesperson.

Hello everyone. We were 10 members of the Government gathered around the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister for this 5th Ecological Defense Council, an instance that was created in May 2019 at the request of the President of the Republic to mobilize the entire Government to achieve the objectives we set for ourselves in terms of ecological transition.

This is therefore an important moment. Important democratically and important in terms of effectiveness. Democratically, since we are here in a concrete translation of the commitments made by the President of the Republic within the framework of the national debate, that is to say, involving French citizens through 150 citizens drawn by lot from the Citizens' Convention for Climate, in the choices we make for the future of our country and therefore of the planet.

And then important in terms of effectiveness, since this Citizens' Convention for Climate, the President of the Republic recalled this morning at the opening of this Defense Council, sets a framework for our action. The environmental question, the question of ecology has often led to tensions in our country for many years between activists sometimes defending causes and between French citizens who have diverse and varied convictions on the subject. And we have, through this remarkable work that was done, I remind you, by 150 randomly selected citizens who dedicated their entire weekends for nearly 9 months to reflect and formulate proposals, we have a framework of reference, a kind of compass for action.

I will now give the floor to the ministers, to Barbara POMPILI and Emmanuel WARGON who will both clarify the modus operandi and the roadmap in terms of method that we have set with the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister and the first measures that are announced and that have been decided at the end of this Defense Council today. And then, of course, the perspectives for the future. We will then be able to answer the questions you may have.

Barbara POMPILI, Minister of Ecological Transition

Thank you very much. Hello everyone. This council is an important first step in implementing the measures of the Citizens' Convention for Climate. We have set a method and we will present to you many initial measures.

On the method, I will be, along with my colleagues from the Government, the guarantor of citizen involvement at all stages. It is very important for us that citizens continue to follow up on their work which required enormous involvement from them for 9 months. Therefore, I will meet with them every month and starting this Wednesday, a series of working meetings is planned at the Ministry of Ecological Transition for citizens to present their measures and the tests to those who will have to support their implementation, namely, of course, the trade unions and employer organizations, the associations of elected officials, since many measures concern the competencies of local authorities and of course, parliamentarians who will have to work on the bill.

Regarding the timeline, we want to move quickly, but we want to move on solid foundations. We need to take the time for impact studies, consultations to support the bill; but also take into account the very large number of texts studied in the fall, including the recovery plan and the budget.

We will therefore set up working groups. These working groups will meet and a first version of the bill will be ready by the end of September, then it will have to undergo the mandatory consultations, including the review by the Council of State. The bill will be presented in the Council of Ministers in November for examination in Parliament in January 2021.

Beyond the method, the Ecological Defense Council focused today on regulatory measures proposed in the themes "housing and mobility" of the citizens' convention. We focused on these initial measures because it is simply necessary to do it step by step. So housing and transport, why did we choose these measures? Because these are the issues that directly affect the daily lives of our fellow citizens and the most crucial sectors for reducing our greenhouse gas emissions and preserving biodiversity. The selected measures fall within the 3 axes identified by the citizens of the "housing" group: the thermal renovation of buildings, the control of energy consumption, and the fight against land artificialization. A measure of support for rail transport has also been validated. It will be announced this afternoon by the Prime Minister.

The Council also allowed us to accelerate our progress towards the goal set by the President of the Republic to place 30% of the national territory under protection. So here we are talking about biodiversity. This was not within the scope of the Citizens' Convention for Climate, but I remind you that we are in an Ecological Defense Council and therefore we address, beyond climate issues, all environmental issues - and you know how much biodiversity matters to me and I would like to acknowledge the presence of our Secretary of State for Biodiversity who will strengthen our team on the subject.

So regarding the measures themselves, concerning the energy renovation of buildings, we must first have in mind the main stakes. They are primarily of a climatic nature: the building sector represents, notably due to heating, nearly 20% of CO2 emissions in our country. In addition, good insulation of homes helps to better combat heatwaves that increasingly frequently hit our country. It is a major tool for resilience against climate change; good insulation allows, for example, in nursing homes to have cool rooms everywhere. The stakes are also social and health-related: we still have around 5 million energy-inefficient homes in France, of which 200,000 are social housing. Behind these figures, there are millions of households struggling to pay their heating bills at the end of the month in winter. It is also estimated that the medical cost of energy poverty is 650 million euros per year for the community.

Finally, the stakes are economic: we have everything to gain by developing a building sector focused on renovation to create non-offshorable future jobs anchored in all territories.

Our goal, through the measures we have taken, is really to involve citizens and professionals in a transition by supporting them. I will now give my colleague Emmanuelle WARGON the floor to present the first measures, and I will return to you for the next steps.

Emmanuelle WARGON, Minister Delegate to the Minister of Ecological Transition, in charge of Housing.

Thank you very much, Madam Minister, dear Barbara POMPILI. Among the main measures on renovation, the first is to combat energy performance deficiencies in what is called decent housing, starting from January 1, 2023.

Tomorrow, to be decent, a home must be well insulated and well heated. This is an ecological and social advance aimed at protecting tenants who are numerous among the least well-insulated homes. This will allow people living in energy-inefficient homes, which are truly indecent with heating costs that can sometimes reach up to 1,000 euros per month, to demand that the landlord carry out work, or even to submit the case to a judge who can decide to freeze the rent or prohibit the rental of the home. This will apply from January 1, 2023, to all homes that consume more than 500 kWh/m² of heating per year, which is extremely important, and it concerns about 120,000 rental homes in France today.

Furthermore, starting from January 1, 2022, we will accelerate the replacement of oil or coal boilers by requiring that the replacement of these boilers be done with less polluting boilers. Today, we have 3.5 million homes in France that are still heated with oil, and an oil boiler is equivalent to the consumption of 3 gasoline cars. Therefore, starting from January 1, 2022, it will no longer be possible to replace an oil or coal boiler with another oil or coal boiler, and no new oil boilers will be allowed to be installed in France. We will obviously support both the craftspeople and professionals in the sector and households, as there are already aids available both with energy savings certificates and with Ma Prime Rénov’ which allow for significant financing for the replacement of an oil boiler with a heat pump, a high-performance gas boiler when connected to gas, or a pellet boiler.

For all these measures, we will significantly strengthen the aid to households for energy renovation. You know that our main measure is a grant called “Ma Prime Rénov’” that we launched just under a year ago, which is working very well. Its budget today, including the grant itself and what remains of the tax credit, is around 800 million euros per year. In 2021 and 2022, we will add 2 billion.

So, we will more than double the budget for household aids for the renovation of their homes by opening it up to owner-occupiers, but also to landlords - because it is important that landlords who rent their homes can also carry out work for the benefit of their tenants. This is a very significant effort from the recovery plan; the envelope for public buildings, which is the other part of the recovery plan envelope for renovation, will be announced more broadly in the announcements of the recovery plan.

Barbara POMPILI, Minister of Ecological Transition

In this part, we will also prohibit outdoor heating in public spaces, on terraces, and require the doors of all heated or air-conditioned buildings open to the public to be closed.

This is about putting an end to practices that constitute ecological aberrations and lead to completely unjustified overconsumption of energy. We cannot air-condition the street in summer when it is 30 degrees and heat terraces at full capacity in winter when it is zero degrees just for the pleasure of having a warm coffee on the terrace. This is a measure that can impact our restaurateurs. Restaurateurs have suffered from the Covid crisis. They have been very hard hit, and so we will meet with them to allow them to organize themselves. Therefore, we will make these measures mandatory by the end of next winter to avoid placing too heavy a burden on them, initially.

Regarding land artificialization, the stakes are also major. The figure is well known: on average in our country, a department the size of Drôme disappears under concrete every ten years, and this trend is accelerating: urbanization is increasing four times faster than the population over the last 40 years. And this is a French specificity; urban sprawl is 50% faster than in Spain over the last 10 years in all territories, including those that are losing population.

The challenge today is therefore to slow this phenomenon and to have a denser city, but also a more pleasant one, by leaving more room for nature in the city. So why are we doing this? Because this phenomenon has many negative consequences. Dependence on individual cars and the increase in travel creates even more greenhouse gas emissions, harm to biodiversity, destruction of natural habitats, reduction of agricultural development potential, reduction of carbon storage potential, and increased natural risks due to runoff. We are increasingly experiencing weather phenomena with heavy rains. Because of this phenomenon, we multiply the risks of flooding with all the harmful effects we have seen elsewhere.

And then, the last problem is the issue of the depopulation of city centers. Measures have already been taken on this subject in the past. We have already taken measures on emblematic projects such as EuropaCity, for example, and Notre-Dame-des-Landes.

Today, we want to shift into high gear; our first measure is to take up the goal of the citizens' convention to halve the rate of land sealing in the next decade. So, one might ask why slow down instead of stopping? Simply because we are talking about changing an urban development model that has structured the country for decades. And that cannot be changed just like that with a snap of the fingers. We need to hammer out a new discourse. We need to make strong decisions and we need to provide the means. It is also very important that our fellow citizens are made aware of the city of tomorrow, more compact, greener, cooler in the summer, with more local shops. They need to take ownership of this model themselves. And to start this change of model, we are going to launch a major competition to invent the city of tomorrow with demonstrators, pilot projects that can be generalized.

Next, because local elected officials are finalizing their urban planning documents, we will help them achieve this goal by engaging in massive urban recycling and applying the principle of circular economy to the development of cities. We will create a fund, as part of the recovery plan, of several hundred million euros to rehabilitate hundreds of hectares of brownfields into what we can call "turnkey" sites for industrial activities and businesses to settle. These are very heavy operations, but they can change the game in cities that are emptying from the center and expanding to the periphery.

Today, we have too many real estate projects that are being carried out by sealing land, because rebuilding on a brownfield often costs much more than building on a field or in place of a forest. With this fund, which will be made possible as part of the recovery plan, we will work to reduce this gap. This will be done through calls for projects that will be co-financed by local authorities.

We will then indicate to project leaders where the available brownfields are located in the country through an online mapping tool that is already ready and called "carto friches." So, there is a first beta version of this platform that has been built by CEREMA, which will be launched today. We are not yet covering all of France. We are on a beta version. But local authorities will gradually enrich the database, and its functionalities will be developed to meet all expectations on this subject.

And finally, we confirm the moratorium on commercial zones that was announced by the President of the Republic and the Prime Minister. France is one of the European countries that already has the most hypermarkets per capita, and commercial vacancy in city centers exceeds 20% in many small and medium-sized cities. This development has distorted our landscapes, trivialized the peripheries of cities. It has contributed to urban sprawl and dependence on individual cars. Therefore, without delay, we will issue a circular to the prefects asking them to scrupulously ensure, in practice, compliance with the principle of combating land sealing in commercial exploitation authorization files. We will ask them to refer, if necessary, to the National Commission for Commercial Development, and then, in a second phase, as part of the Law on the Citizens' Convention for Climate, the criteria for examining commercial exploitation authorizations will be strengthened and made operational in line with the goal of zero net land sealing.

Finally, a parliamentary mission will be launched to review all the mechanisms, particularly fiscal ones, that encourage urban sprawl. The case of peripheral e-commerce warehouses will be examined in this context, and with these first measures, this Defense Council will likely be remembered as a turning point in the urban history of the country. As I mentioned, there are measures regarding rail freight, but those will be announced to you this afternoon by the Prime Minister, and finally, as I mentioned earlier, decisions made during this Council will also allow us to accelerate our trajectory towards 30% of our territory protected in favor of biodiversity.

I remind you that in May 2019, the President of the Republic met with experts from the IBES, which is the equivalent of the IPCC for biodiversity, and following these discussions with these experts, he wished to raise the share of protected marine areas to 30%—of which one-third will be under strong protection—by the end of the five-year term. I just want to remind you that this international goal is set for 2030, so we are indeed ahead and pioneering on these issues. One of the lessons of the current crisis is to remind us of the necessity to rethink the place of nature within our society. Preserving natural spaces, protecting our essential resources, makes our society more resilient, ready to face the effects of climate change.

Therefore, I have countersigned the decrees that allow us to announce, on the occasion of this ecological Defense Council, the creation of two regional natural parks, that of Mont Ventoux and that of the Baie de Somme Picardie maritime, which particularly pleases me, as well as the national nature reserve of Robertsau in Alsace. The creation of these new protected areas, as well as the adhesion area of the National Forest Park, already leads us to reach 30% of terrestrial territory in protected areas. Millions of French people live near this protected natural heritage. It is the implication of the principle of a protected nature, but not under a bell jar. A preserved nature for the French, in which they will take part. Thank you.

Gabriel ATTAL

We will take a few questions. Who wants to start? A question about the ecological Defense Council, of course.

Laurence BENAMOU AFP

Did you talk about 5G and its potential risks to ecology?

Barbara POMPILI

No. It was not on the agenda of the ecological Defense Council, so it was not discussed today. We already had a lot of announcements we wanted to make, and we had decided on a method. The method was to take the proposals from the Citizens' Convention for Climate piece by piece and by theme to try to show a coherent whole. So, it is through the Citizens' Convention for Climate, and that will be part of the next reflections we will have. But it was not addressed today.

Journalist

The other regulatory measures, so the other themes, will they be addressed? In what framework? Still the Defense Council, or will it be a more traditional, classic framework?

Barbara POMPILI

Not necessarily. We will move forward, and in any case, you can see that we will have moments of consultation since there are many regulatory measures that also fall under other competencies, particularly those of local authorities. So, we need a time for consultation beforehand, and that is why a number of measures have not been made to allow for this time of exchange between citizens, local authorities, and the State, so that we can align everything to ensure that it is done as well as possible.

Journalist

The Citizens' Convention for Climate says it’s 146 or nothing; do you think you will achieve that? Well, there is still a bit of work left.

Barbara POMPILI

There is a lot of work, but we will do it together, and I believe it is very important, and Gabriel ATTAL said it earlier, that citizens are involved at all stages so that they can also confront their proposals with their concrete application. Some apply very easily, others require a number of adjustments—and that is why this work must be done together so that they do not feel betrayed if adjustments are made.

Journalist

I will build on that. Citizens will be confronted with elected officials to see what the elected officials respond. If there are totally divergent views, if the elected officials say to them: "that is not possible," it is the Government that will decide. That is the idea, right? It is not about turning them into politicians, so to speak.

Barbara POMPILI

No. The important thing is that all the orientations proposed by citizens can be applied. That is the commitment of the President of the Republic. The President of the Republic has said that he wants citizens to find themselves in the work that will be done. And that is really the work we will do, but it is a work that requires time. That is also why, on the draft law, we want to take the time to do things well and not to create a turnkey solution that would not satisfy anyone and for which we would not have seen all the implications. So all of this takes time. In any case, there is a very strong commitment from the President of the Republic who repeated to us this morning that all this work done over 9 months by citizens, by people who were not professionals, who were not necessarily engaged at the start, but who immersed themselves and managed to propose this product, is not a finished product; it is an intermediate product. That all this work, above all, should not be distorted, and that is our mission. And I can tell you that we are really working on it.

Journalist

But what is the role of elected officials in this?

Barbara POMPILI

Elected officials are there to implement all of this.

Journalist

Yes, to implement; not to decide, then.

Barbara POMPILI

They will be involved, meaning they will talk with citizens. This exchange is important. We will have it on Wednesday with the associations of elected officials, but afterwards, in any case, we will have it with the associations of elected officials, and then it will be seen in a more granular way, territory by territory, because there are measures that really require application according to the territory. But this exchange is necessary because elected officials must hear what citizens are saying, and citizens must hear about constraints that may sometimes simply require a bit more time. You know, sometimes there are measures that have been decided, and we realize that simply to implement them requires a little more time, or perhaps they need to be organized a bit differently. All these things are part of the dialogue. It is a method that the Prime Minister and the President of the Republic defend and to which we are very attached, which is really the method: we sit around the table and implement. Because it is easy to decide things; it is more difficult to implement them. And here we are in this work of implementation.

Journalist

On urban sprawl, the citizens' convention proposed a framework that is a relatively coercive framework. In the regulatory measures you presented, I did not sense that aspect. Should we expect to see it in the legislative phase if there are two stages? Or do you consider it difficult to apply?

Emmanuelle WARGON

Today, we were focused on regulatory measures, and in fact, we should have, across all subjects, a small ten measures that are directly derived from the 146 proposals, which we are taking up in an extremely faithful manner. So to answer the previous question, that also gives a sense of what we will do. There, on urban sprawl, the measures proposed by citizens are more legislative, and so today we focused on regulatory or technical measures: the mapping of brownfields, the creation of the fund, the moratorium on shopping centers, the question of major regulatory standards that will apply to PLUs, PLUIs, so basically, urban planning law is more in the legislative domain, and so it will enter the consultation process that Barbara POMPILI was talking about a few minutes ago, which starts in two days.

Journalist

So it also concerns ongoing shopping center projects, not just new ones? Those currently under examination are affected by this freeze?

Barbara POMPILI

Absolutely.

Journalist

The cost, you evaluated the cost, that is, energy poverty at 650 million euros per year, is that correct?

Emmanuelle WARGON

Absolutely.

Journalist

What does that mean, technically?

In fact, it is always difficult to assess, but basically, when we have abnormal heating expenses, and for the... really the worst thermal sieves that we have in terms of expenses, it can reach 1,000 euros per month, including for very modest households, because we really have homes whose walls are sieves in the literal sense of the term. When we aggregate all this into abnormal expenses, we can arrive at around 650 million euros per year; knowing that we finance, and we have significantly increased it in the previous period, an energy voucher that helps the most modest households pay their energy expenses each year. But here, the goal is not just to finance the bills because in a way, we are not transforming anything, it is to move towards the gradual elimination of these homes. We start with a standard that has a really very high level of consumption starting in 2023. And the next steps will be discussed again in discussions with citizens, elected officials' associations, and social partners, to see what goal we set for ourselves in 2028 as we also improve energy labels. We are in the process of overhauling what we call the DPE, the Energy Performance Diagnosis, which is not currently enforceable and will become so in 2021. And so we will have a more solid basis to know what additional step we are going to take. This is the beginning, but it is the beginning quickly since, as of January 1, 2023, a tenant will be able to turn against their landlord if their landlord rents them an energy sieve.

Barbara POMPILI

One last question, if there is one. Very well.

Gabriel ATTAL

So, this afternoon, as Barbara POMPILI said, you will have an important moment with the Prime Minister's visit to the Defense Council, and announcements will be made by the Prime Minister at that time. And then, on Wednesday, the meetings with the citizens of the Citizens' Convention for Climate to continue to move forward in accordance with the method that was announced by Barbara POMPILI following the Defense Council around the President of the Republic this morning. Thank you all.