PRESENTATION OF THE NATIONAL STRATEGY ON QUANTUM TECHNOLOGIES.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

21 January 2021 · Presentation of the National Strategy on Quantum Technologies

Context
Macron addressed researchers, academics, and industry leaders at the C2N centre on the Plateau de Saclay to launch France's national quantum technologies strategy.
Main themes
Quantum technologies strategy, French research excellence, Paris-Saclay innovation hub, interdisciplinarity and cooperation, talent attraction and retention, university rankings and competitiveness, public-private partnership, national industrial strategy, scientific sovereignty, future preparedness
Duration
~50 min
94th percentile
Words
5,945
94th percentile
Sentences
254
93rd percentile
Readability
47
54th percentile
Grade
12.4
50th percentile
Syntax
3.15
67th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
36th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Technological 26%20%
  • Ceremonial 22%17%
  • Institutional 21%16%
  • Economic 15%11%
  • Social 12%9%
  • Geopolitical 4%3%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 24%

254 sentences in 58 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen ministers,

Ladies and gentlemen parliamentarians,

Mr. President of the departmental council,

Mayors,

Mr. Vice President,

Ladies and gentlemen elected officials,

Madam, sir presidents of the university and schools,

Ladies and gentlemen leaders of research organizations,

Ladies and gentlemen business leaders,

Ladies and gentlemen researchers, entrepreneurs, and industrialists,

Ladies and gentlemen,

Dear friends,

I am very happy to be with you today. Very happy, because we are in a period where, as everyone has noticed, the constraints of daily life are strong. Nevertheless, we must not, in these moments, cease to continue looking towards our future and preparing for it, and that is what you are doing very concretely, not only in this wonderful center - and congratulations, really, I am very happy to have been with you and to be addressing you here from C2N - but also what you are doing in your research laboratories, at universities, and organizations throughout the year. I believe that we must all, students, researchers, entrepreneurs, public and private actors, continue to stay the course and prepare our future.

I will not have the audacity to try to present to you in detail a quantum strategy. First of all, because I see only faces that know or understand things better and who have tried, some for months, others for days, to explain all this to me. And there are practitioners here on a terribly complicated subject. Nevertheless, I want to share a few convictions with you from where I stand and try to support the collective effort. I believe that is our role.

The first thing is that the strategies, the ambitions we carry, are rooted in places, and it is no coincidence that we are doing this here from Saclay, on the Plateau.

I want to express a word of gratitude before delving into our strategy. If Saclay has become one of the global hubs of knowledge, it is thanks to you and many actors here: researchers, teacher-researchers, students, all the teams, but also all those, Madam President, who agree to turn away from research for a moment to engage, thank you all, really, for this remarkable work. I also thank all the organizations, the elected officials who are very involved on this plateau, and I thank them. Here, I believe I can say that we have collectively succeeded. We are in the process of achieving something unique. And I thank all the state services in the territory, Mr. Prefect, who, under your leadership, support the development of the plateau every day.

Indeed, we must remember the long term, as I said, and a launch at a time when there were almost only fields here, Madam Minister. The progress is immense, and I modestly remember where we were a little over three years ago, when, in the fall of 2017, I came to address you, and fundamentally, we had together made some choices, decided to structure around two major university entities, the site, the University of Paris-Saclay and the Polytechnic Institute of Paris. And fundamentally, we made a collective choice on Saclay, which I believe was a choice of trust, cooperation, and pragmatism, which was to say: we stop the divisions, we believe in the effect, in a way, of cooperation on a site. But we also do not try to aggregate everything or have a perfectionist mindset that sometimes denies cultures. And we will believe in the capacity of all actors to cooperate. And I tell you, that is what you have done remarkably. I was reviewing the progress yesterday. They are real, and it is the fruit of your work. Really, I thank you infinitely.

Today, the first objectives have been achieved, even if I cannot say that everything has been achieved, because there is still a lot to do collectively. But the University of Paris-Saclay brings together nearly 13% of French research. It has risen to 14th place in the Shanghai ranking, has climbed to the very top of the podium in mathematics. There are 275 laboratories with our research organizations, a spirit of openness, 48,000 students, 9,000 teacher-researchers, and so on. It is organizational innovation since the beginning of 2020 that has truly enabled these results. France now ranks third in the world among the most performing nations and has 5 institutions among the top 100. These are results that reflect a French university tradition of excellence that has never wavered.

But fundamentally, what you have collectively done here is create more synergies, succeed in going further in terms of interdisciplinarity, and also give visibility in a world where it matters so much, to attract or retain talent. The Polytechnic Institute of Paris also embodies the best of our French engineering tradition and can boast, as we mentioned yesterday, excellent rankings, a remarkable vitality in terms of startup creation, and excellence as well. I believe I can say that the cooperation strategy you have adopted has shown that the engineer, the doctoral student, and the post-doc are not mutually exclusive. And we have, I believe, also consolidated here the best of what France has trained in engineers, has produced in scientific developments, which goes hand in hand with our entrepreneurial capacity, this remarkable ability to create startups and numerous institutes in very varied fields that you have managed to develop with great agility.

For me, Saclay is truly the illustration of what we can collectively succeed in doing when we put in the means, when we attract the best, and when the best decide to cooperate together, freeing themselves from any logic of ego. Saclay is the result of a very strong commitment from local authorities, an investment of nearly 2 billion euros from the State over more than 10 years, and a capital endowment definitively acquired of nearly 1 billion euros for the University of Paris-Saclay. It is the involvement of the public development establishment of Paris-Saclay that has supported the development of the site, created new neighborhoods, and ensured mobility networks. We all know the shortcomings that still need to be addressed collectively. We must continue to improve, particularly the connection, and I know how much you care about it. I am speaking to our elected officials. The modernization of the RER B, the arrival of line 18 of the Grand Paris Express by 2026, an automatic line that will connect the Saclay plateau to Versailles on one side, and to Orly airport on the other, in connection with the RER B at Massy-Palaiseau, are priorities. And the issue of the stations will be resolved with a lot of pragmatism, once again, so that we can meet this excellence. And when I see the progress made over the past 3 years, I am extraordinarily confident about what we can do and continue to accelerate. And so, thank you infinitely for that, because it is you who have done it.

The second message, before I delve into the quantum strategy, that I wanted to mention very briefly: to tell you how I consider, even more in the moments our nation is experiencing, that research is a capital element of our nation for today and tomorrow. First of all, because I believe in the ambition of a country; when I say a nation, it is typical of the vision I defend, that is to say, an open nation. Research only exists in an open world where we cooperate with a community that is always international.

But the ability of states to finance ambitious strategies, to finance a research ambition, is decisive in a strategy, an approach of public-private partnership, to build a destiny and a future on our territory. This is what we have done, I will come back to it, what we believe in with the multiannual programming law for research, and I thank the ministers and parliamentarians who have been very involved in it and all the actors in the research world present here who are deploying it.

But we need our research even more. Why? Because our global challenges show us this. The COVID-19 pandemic reminded us of the necessity of research, and let us never have the obsession with the most applied and most perceptible research in these moments, but of this continuum, of this permanent dialogue between technological research and fundamental research on all the global challenges we face: climate, health, artificial intelligence, or quantum. Let us continue to invest, to develop.

Secondly, we need to continue to be the best in all cutting-edge research strategies, to continue, sometimes, to make mistakes, to feel our way, but to invest massively in the ambitions that can be ours and that are carried by several of the great researchers here present and their teams. And above all, I believe that there is no free country without a real mastery of its ability to produce free, open fundamental research, to continue to finance it freely and openly, and also to continue to master the strategic technologies that shape its future. I believe that this also falls under a true French and European sovereignty to have this absolutely decisive research ambition.

The quantum strategy has, in this regard, capital importance. Indeed, like artificial intelligence, microelectronics, health technologies, energy, or space, quantum technologies are part of those few keys to the future that France must absolutely have in hand. I believe I can say that we have the capabilities, as we speak, and there is no, if I may say so, a form of idyllic vision or any kind of naivety.

But we have the capacity to be the best or among the very best as we speak. This is not true in all areas, we know that very well, but here, we can do it if we give ourselves the means, we, French and Europeans. We know the Chinese and American competition, but given the disciplines that are key in quantum, given what has already been done by our scientific community, given the involvement of our fundamental research actors and industrialists, we have the recipes today to succeed and be among the very best in this battle. Quantum physics has already given us, especially since the mid-20th century, applications that we obviously cannot do without today: the transistor, lasers, GPS, LEDs, which structure the internet itself and computing. But we know that we are now at the heart of a second revolution where everything is accelerating and where, fundamentally, key problems can be solved through quantum, where quantum computing will allow us to solve problems that are insoluble with classical computing, as we mentioned a moment ago with the Pasqal teams, where computation times will be dramatically reduced, quantum sensors will allow navigation without GPS. And there is also everything that we cannot yet imagine but that will be transformed by the innovations that will thus be conducted. These technologies could radically change the game in our fight against climate change, in the sustainable development of agricultural production, with a series of concrete applications, completely invaluable. Similarly, at a time when supercomputers around the world are mobilized to search for treatments to combat the coronavirus, quantum computers could become in the future one of the most powerful weapons ever designed against health crises.

Industry will benefit through this from entirely new simulation or optimization tools. And I am not even mentioning all the implications and applications in the field of security, defense, for our nuclear submarines, or to help us in the fight against cybersecurity. These challenges are immense, and I know they occupy your daily lives, and what you discover or contribute to discovering each day may produce, perhaps in a few months, sometimes in a few years, some of these applications and those that we cannot yet imagine.

Our strengths are numerous, and I want to remind you of them here. Our history, of course. Because science is built on the shoulders of giants and their teams. I will not name them all, but I think of the fundamental research of Alain ASPECT's team, with whom we were just last night – by the way, several of them told me, "we are his children or grandchildren" – research on entanglement that has paved the way for mastering and exploiting this property of quantum objects. The discoveries of Albert FERT's team in spintronics. The teams of Serge HAROCHE in quantum optics. The work of Vincent BOUCHIAT and Daniel ESTEVE's teams, who contributed to the creation of the first superconducting qubits, etc., etc. And through these great names, which I want to recall here, whom I salute and whose faces I recognize even behind masks, I truly want to salute all the teams of researchers, doctoral students, post-doctoral researchers, and teacher-researchers because they are human collectives, every time. And it is also your collective capacity that has allowed us to preserve all these treasures of intelligence with great care. So thank you all for keeping all of this alive over time. We have that, and we must absolutely consolidate it.

Next, the quality of our training is an asset, and we will continue to invest in it. We train talented women and men who sustain our quantum research and innovation system. All over France, here in Saclay, at C2N of course, at the Institute of Optics, at Thales, I also think of Grenoble, at the Néel Institute with mixed teams from CEA, CNRS, and the University of Grenoble, which is carrying out projects in the field of quantum computing based on semiconductor technologies from the microelectronics industry; there too, we know there are cluster effects, with all the teams involved in these subjects.

The third point is that we are in the race for these applications: on simulators, we saw it earlier with the company Atos, for example, whose simulation platform has already allowed, since 2016, to train software developers in radically new languages and algorithms. We are very well positioned in post-quantum cryptography, and American project calls prove it: a quarter of them involve INRIA. And above all, we have a startup ecosystem that is being structured thanks to the support of Bpifrance, which also benefits from the first investment fund in Europe dedicated to quantum technologies, the Quantonation fund, as we saw earlier, and France already has about twenty startups (Quandela, Pasqal, CryptoNext, Very Cloud, Alice & Bob, etc., etc.). And so I was proud and happy to see several former doctoral students or researchers right here who have launched and contributed to building these promising companies. But we have this ecosystem which, if I understood correctly, is still the heart of our ability to succeed, the ability to continue to have the best teams in fundamental and technological research, to have university laboratories and research organizations, these startups and large groups that all work together and precisely drive, foster innovations.

And then we have the global leaders in industry who, tomorrow, will use these technologies (Total, EDF, and several others) and who are involved in this research because they will be the users, just as the State will be and is beginning to be on many of its civilian or military capabilities.

We also have weaknesses, and we must face them, and we need to raise the bar on these.

The first, and we know it is structural, is the fragility we have regarding the attractiveness of scientific careers, especially for young people. At 33 or 34 years old, after more than 10 years of study, is it still acceptable to be paid 1.4 times the minimum wage? I will come back to this, but it is thanks to the strategy that we have been able to stem it, and the LPR will put an end to this system, but it depends on our collective ability to keep the instruments we have created alive and to change the logic in which we had locked ourselves. And if I were to say it in very politically incorrect terms, we had somewhat chosen the subject, well, a strategy, which was the poorly paid status. We need to enter a much broader logic where we must maintain "long careers," protected, that allow for fundamental research that should not be, if I may say so, subject to uncertainties and overly short research projects. But we must also accept to have "surrounded" permanent contracts, as we say in jargon, and therefore much better paid, more quickly, trust more early, be more attractive for certain careers, decide to invest more in teams and equipment, have more evaluation meetings throughout the career, which allow us to enter this international competition. And we must make what were the characteristics of the French model an opportunity, but in a way hybridizing it, if I may say so, with foreign models from which we need to draw the best. But we need to move quickly on this battle because if we lose it, if we delay, the risk is to lose talents who will go to other ecosystems.

Next, our funding for your projects, whatever their fields, is still too low, with, for example, success rates barely above 10% for ANR. Contrary to what I sometimes hear, our research does not suffer from an excess of project calls; it suffers from a generalized lack of funding. It suffers from the fact that, even when there are project calls, there is not enough funding given what is required for a project call. But it would be a mistake to say "we will completely end project calls." We need to choose them better, simplify the administrative process, but fund them much better and provide more visibility.

Finally, I know, because you often bring it to my attention, that the complexity of our current system alienates our best researchers by imposing, as I have mentioned in carefully chosen words, a burdensome administrative load. The legal tools are there, and I know that the implementation of contracts that are sometimes allowed since laws, which today are dated, whether they are called Allègre or Pacte, still takes several months with discouragements and abandonments.

And so, I wish that we could go further, also in simplifying this system. To respond to this, there is first the overall strategy we have put in place for research, with a foundation, which is the law for research, that I mentioned.

We owed the French research a law that restores trust between the nation and its researchers. This is based on an investment trajectory, 25 billion euros over 10 years, set in stone, which allows us to have more than 5 billion by 2030, which is for me a first step. Can we say that this is the final settlement for the coming decade? Certainly not. We must continue to adapt, but this must be the minimum foundation that begins to help us catch up on the shortcomings we had. It is also a great responsibility given to the research organizations present here and to the universities.

Next, we have France Relance and the Future Investment Program, which adds more than 6 billion euros for research and innovation over the next 2 years and acts as an accelerator for this strategy, opening up perspectives for the coming years, particularly the next 2 to 5 years. These elements are set within different timeframes. A 10-year research strategy, PIA over 5 years, and France Relance over the next two years, but all clearly align with our desire to accelerate very quickly to catch up on certain delays, to get ahead on certain subjects, but also, while accelerating, to provide visibility on the decadal plan because the actors need it. Our major priorities within this strategy are to address the few shortcomings I mentioned: to revalue the salaries of research professions, to secure the entry into the careers of young researchers, to attract the best talents, to raise the success rates of ANR, to continue supporting excellence initiatives, to massively fund certain strategic sectors and technologies, and to do so by stepping out, as we have been able to do in Saclay. That is why I mentioned this example earlier, stepping out of our usual divisions. It is not because we make these choices that we abandon fundamental research. It is not because we decide to make some bets and some very deep choices that we must abandon long-term research or the status of researcher and teacher-researcher. Simply, we complement it and also create avenues for opening. And I think we need these flexibilities, these openings, and these cooperation strategies. It is this spirit that I want to carry, this ambition that we want to pursue. We have equipped ourselves with the first tools. We now need to accelerate.

Today, I have mainly come to provide you, in a way, with the concrete proof of these commitments, one of the declinations, with a series of innovations that are somewhat matrix-like for all of French research through the subject of quantum technologies, which illustrate our determination to build France for 2030, even for 2050. I have asked the Government, along with all the actors, and I thank you once again, how much, to develop an ambitious strategy capable of giving France scientific and industrial leadership in these quantum technologies. I truly thank you all for the work done through the reports, by the administrations (DGE, DGRI, DGA, etc.) and by all the actors of the ecosystem that I have mentioned several times, and for having built this strategy. What I have come to do here with all of you is, in a way, to endorse it, to mark both the approval and the commitment of the entire nation behind this work that is yours and that you have produced.

This strategy is based on two main pillars.

The first is a comprehensive and integrated technological development program ranging from fundamental research to industrialization, akin to major long-term technological projects in aeronautics, space, and high-energy physics. The second is the strengthening of the French innovation ecosystem in its European environment, particularly by developing human capital, training, and attracting the best at both the public research and industry levels. It is not about making the State a decision-making master of every detail, but rather about giving you, researchers, entrepreneurs, and industrialists, the means to give your best and to help you accelerate, particularly to consolidate this ecosystem logic that allows for the back-and-forth between fundamental research and technologies, between research laboratories, large groups, startups, and the SMEs that are developing. It is about leveraging all the complementarities that exist in this continuum. And I also say very clearly, the detailed document that is published today shows this very well, without making any choice today of a key quantum technology, but by deciding and somewhat assuming to fund all of them. Because it would be too early to make a definitive choice, and I think it would be a very bad calculation. And in a way, I also say that this strategy has nothing to do with the plans we used to make. It is about the State supporting an ecosystem in a very open innovation logic, with tests that we will conduct, with bets that we will make, some of which we may lose, and others we will win. We cannot say that yet today, and we must accept this part of uncertainty.

This ambition is immense, and to achieve it, we must be among the first countries to master key quantum technologies. For quantum computing, undoubtedly the riskiest object, we will proceed in stages. That is the choice that has been made.

First, we must acculturate ourselves to the use of quantum computer simulators, develop a hybrid computer, particularly for chemistry, logistics, and artificial intelligence, starting as early as 2023. With the national high-performance computing facility, France, the CEA, will host the world's first infrastructure for hybrid quantum computers. And we must also enrich our ecosystem of developers in this field to anticipate future disruptions. For future technologies to find their market, 350 million euros will be dedicated to this first step.

Next, we will need to go further by developing the universal quantum computer and scaling it to an industrial level. France is considered one of the few countries capable of meeting this challenge, and what I was shown earlier gives me confidence in this regard, thanks precisely to the excellence of our theoretical and technological research, thanks to our microelectronics industry, particularly in Grenoble, thanks to the historical achievements that are ours, thanks to the sedimentation of our laboratories, the spin-offs from the CEA that I just mentioned and that have grown well. France could become the first state to have a complete prototype of a general-purpose quantum computer thanks to this investment in our public and private research, but also thanks to industrial partnerships like the one recently concluded between Atos and the startup Pasqal. This would obviously be a major scientific achievement, and we would invest more than 400 million euros in it.

Regarding quantum sensors, 250 million euros in investments will allow us to continue our historical support for this field by facilitating their integration and reclaiming value chains in sensor technology that are imperative for our sovereignty. We saw earlier the excellence of the research between Thales and CNRS, another exceptional laboratory on the Plateau, but to succeed in completely transforming, in this case too, the sensor technology that will change lives: for our civil and military aeronautics, for our submarines, for so many applications, quantum sensors represent a profound transformation.

150 million euros will be dedicated to post-quantum cryptography to secure communications with protocols resistant to the computing methods of future quantum computers. Alice and Bob, Thales, INRIA are decisive players, both private and public, in this field, and here too, these are profound transformations for our national security, for the advancement, precisely, of our research.

325 million euros will go to quantum communications based on the mastery of entangled states at a distance, to develop the components and equipment that will allow the faithful transport of quantum information at room temperature. Two experimental fiber communication networks, one in the Nice region and the other in Île-de-France, will allow us to test and optimize them under real conditions.

The enabling technologies that allow for the deployment of quantum, for example in cryogenics, will not be forgotten either, with a budget of 300 million euros, and here too, with the entire French ecosystem, Air Liquide, for example, with Cryoconcept, will be an important player in securing the value chain, and many actors from our research and industry will also be mobilized. Finally, the strategy must also give a significant boost to training in quantum physics, from undergraduate to doctoral levels.

And I want to reiterate very clearly, the attractiveness of talent is absolutely central to our strategy. That is why we will continue to invest massively in training, all while emphasizing interdisciplinarity and creating new programs. This will represent 100 doctoral scholarships, 50 post-docs, and 10 young talent scholarships in addition, per year, for at least the next 5 years. I emphasize, for at least the next 5 years. We need to give this boost. You mentioned it earlier when we entered this magnificent center together, and you told me, Mr. Director General, "This is what the CNRS also needs, when we look at international competition, to emphasize." This is a tremendous accelerator for the sector, and we take it on. The turning point is here; it is now that we must take it, and we have understood that. 150 million euros are planned for a priority research program. And on this, I really ask the presidents and directors general of CNRS, CEA, and Inria to accelerate the work. This is a mark of confidence that we clearly have in you, which is assumed and done with full knowledge of the facts and competencies.

But now, we need to accelerate the work to finance the launch of concrete projects as soon as possible starting in 2021. I say this because, without betraying any secrets, when I asked yesterday what our risks are, you had the frankness to say: "We are one year behind the German strategy." We will therefore accelerate to move quickly. It starts with our ability to speed up the concrete funding that will go to the laboratories corresponding to this priority research program. A strategy coordinator will be there to alert, to ensure that we have the right responsiveness on research projects, to recruit, retain our doctoral students, and, in a way, to consolidate the ecosystem I mentioned. This action by the state will be complemented by co-financing from industry, and I thank them for that. I want to truly acknowledge, I have mentioned them several times, the industrial players involved in this matter who will massively co-invest in this strategy. Their involvement will be decisive for success. And obviously, all of this will also be complemented by European funding. I will conclude on this note.

Our duty to all is that this strategy be a fully European strategy. Our partners announced their strategy in Germany a few months ago. It is important that we can develop the French strategy for our main ecosystems. This is the one I am presenting today, which is the result of your work. But we must immediately inscribe it in a European dynamic, which is indeed the reality of your research, of your daily activity. We will mobilize our European partners, starting with Germany. A consortium is already in the works between France, Germany, Italy, Spain, Ireland, and Austria to develop the first prototype of a hybrid computer equipped with a quantum accelerator of at least 100 qubits by 2023, at the site of the very large computing center in Bruyères-le-Châtel. Indeed, our departments continue to advance at a rapid pace. This platform will constitute the first step towards a European quantum hub capable of fully exploiting these new computing capabilities. And I deeply believe that through the strength of our ecosystems and, in any case, that of the plateau and its partners, we have the capacity to be one of the major points of consolidation of this European strategy that we will now push forward.

France will do everything to promote European collaborations around the universal quantum computer. The whole challenge is to make Europe the major center of gravity for quantum technologies. By tripling our annual financial effort, we are already joining the top three quantum nations. This is the investment we are collectively deciding today, that is, a public-private commitment of 1.8 billion euros, with nearly 1 billion euros coming directly from the state. This is what I came to tell you: this profound acceleration and transformation of our ecosystem, and the fact that we also decide to rise to the global podium in terms of funding, investment in quantum. We are investing in talent and in the sedimentation of our research and our capabilities. I believe this is the key to being at least among the top three in the world, and by nurturing an even stronger ambition… I think we can do it. That is what I came to tell you.

Ultimately, what is the spirit of this strategy and our meeting today for me? First, in the moments our nation is experiencing, we must always continue to look to the horizon and prepare for tomorrow. Otherwise, we will suffer the crises to come because what we are also preparing is our capacity for innovation and resilience. We can see it clearly; resilience in a crisis is the ability to have innovated beforehand, to have understood it better, sometimes anticipated it, and to react very quickly to it. That is exactly what we are talking about. Next, it is an act of trust. It has been widely documented by many researchers that one of France's problems is distrust. Distrust among citizens towards one another, towards institutions, and sometimes among actors in the same sector towards one another. I believe we can achieve this through trust among us. Trust does not mean naivety; it means we decide that we have a common future. That is what you have done here at Saclay; that is what I want for our research. And so we make massive investments, we trust the actors because there is a logic of ecosystem. And with this logic of trust, we empower the actors that you are, we believe in a logic of cooperation on sites, between organizations, between structures. We believe in the two key elements for success: talent and capital. This is what we will invest in. There is no research without the women and men who conduct it, who do it over time, and who decide to exchange in interdisciplinarity. This is what we want to promote and develop.

But it is also a capital that we invest to sometimes move very quickly, break down barriers, enable acceleration, and take risks. And this strategy also assumes the share of risks and errors. And I say this because what goes along with French distrust is also this kind of relentless pursuit of error. We have become a nation of 66 million prosecutors. That is not how we face crises or move forward. And so everyone makes mistakes every day. The one who does not make a mistake, or the one who does not make a mistake, is the one who either does not seek, or does nothing, or mechanically does the same thing as the day before.

We need to have women and men who seek, who have the capacity to invent what is not yet perceptible and to make mistakes in order to correct as quickly as possible and improve. That is what makes a great nation. And I say this here with great strength in a place of knowledge and science. And so the bet of this strategy is also to accept its share of risk and therefore its share of error. But because we trust, we have said that the actors will quickly see the errors, will adjust, will know how to correct them, but above all, they will have learned from these errors because our mistakes are what teach us the most.

Finally, and I will conclude on this, this strategy has, in its philosophy, the will to secure the entire chain, that is to say, it also assumes its share of sovereignty. Securing the entire chain in terms of research, technological, and industrial matters. We need to retain talent, to retain certain technologies, so as not to depend, in particular, on the two great international powers that compete with us. We need to keep each link of this chain in France and Europe. We mentioned it earlier with Quandela, and I know how important it is for them. But whether it is fundamental research, technological and applied research from the private sector, we will also need to support this strategy with a form of vigilance, a willingness to invest and support, if I may say so, the complete mastery of this value chain. This is absolutely key to both maintaining free research at all times and for our sovereignty in terms of knowledge and industrial applications.

There you go, I will not be longer. These were the few convictions I wanted to share with you, while modestly presenting this strategy, which is fundamentally your work and therefore owes you a lot. And I thank you immensely. In doing so, I mark the trust of the entire nation, the financial commitments that go with it, but I also hope the spirit of ambition and demand that will accompany it.

Thank you, I trust you.