INTERVENTION OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE REPUBLIC WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE DAVOS AGENDA ORGANIZED BY THE WORLD ECONOMIC FORUM

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

26 January 2021 · World Economic Forum Davos Agenda

Context
Macron addressed the World Economic Forum's Davos Agenda on January 26, 2021, discussing stakeholder capitalism and the failures of the prevailing economic model.
Main themes
Stakeholder capitalism, inequality and financialization, climate crisis externalities, reform of capitalism, role of the state, social inequalities, democratic crisis, globalization and delocalization, value creation vs. profit, worker displacement, negative externalities, market economy reform
Duration
~27 min
79th percentile
Words
3,270
79th percentile
Sentences
146
80th percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.05
54th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

World Economic Forum · Davos Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%35%
  • Environmental 18%16%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Technological 11%10%
  • Social 10%9%
  • Geopolitical 8%7%
  • Institutional 1%1%
  • Not in focus 9%

146 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. President, I believe that last year you said in a meeting of the OID that capitalism has gone mad, and in the context you mention of a moral economy, what is your conception of the role of the company, of the philosophy of the company? I ask the question because I published a book today called "Stakeholder Capitalism," which means a capitalism of stakeholders. What is your philosophy?

The President of the Republic

I find myself in the formula of stakeholder capitalism, but fundamentally, what is true is that when we look at the evolution of the last few decades, we have a capitalism that, first of all, capitalism and market economy have had real successes in this last decade, because we should not caricature things. It has allowed the opening of economies. Global trade, capitalism has allowed hundreds of millions of people to escape poverty. So that has had a benefit. It has allowed for many innovations, it has allowed us to respond to the demands of the consumer citizen of our economies in an extraordinary way, with access to goods and services like rarely in humanity, we have had access to. So that is the remarkable success of the last few decades. There is a way to all this. It is that all this has gone along with, one, obviously, the creation of inequalities in our societies; that is to say, that the opening and the theory of comparative advantages has allowed people at the other end of the world to escape poverty and other fellow citizens to access production, but at the exit of production and therefore of activity, of social utility, of a real role and access to wages, many of our fellow citizens who have suffered from the crises of delocalization that all developed economies have had to experience. And it was both an economic and social shock for hundreds of millions in the world, in my country hundreds of thousands, even millions of people who had this feeling of loss of utility, who lost their jobs with a real economic and moral crisis. And in a way, this problem has been externalized by the capitalism of the last few decades.

The second issue is the disconnection between value creation and profits. There has been a financialization of this capitalism. Financialization is a very good thing when it allows for faster progress, when it allows for the proper allocation of savings to financing needs. It is a bad thing when it over-allocates in a way remuneration, while there is little risk-taking and therefore allows for enrichments that are not linked to either work or a phenomenon of innovation. And that is what has happened. So, there has been a kind of frenzy that has increased this first phenomenon of inequality. We have seen in all our societies a growing inequality within them.

The third phenomenon, with the acceleration of social networks, has globalized the imagination by also creating an unsustainability, if I may say so, of the systems of comparison, I would say this term, increasingly difficult.

The fourth problem is that it has completely externalized the climate problem for decades, that is to say, we have created a global logistics, global exchanges. We have said, in essence, there are two kings in this system: the consumer and the shareholder, and the system has produced very well for the consumer and the shareholder, but it has adjusted on the worker and on the rest of the planet. And in a way, we have created negative externalities, as we say euphemistically, in climatic terms.

These four phenomena have fueled the crisis of social inequalities, the crisis of democracy, and the climate crisis. And so, the capitalist model married to the open market economy can no longer function in this environment. Why? Because it has historically been the fruit of a compromise that was democratic societies, the free individual, individual freedoms, the progress of the middle classes that have created sustainability in each of our societies. And it is in a way completely impacted, this balance, this consensus that existed, by these four accelerations. And so, I believe very deeply in your Stakeholder Capitalism, among other things, that is to say in the idea of saying that we must put back at the heart of the model the response to these issues.

In essence, over the last few years, we have tried to respond to it through a response from the States. The State alone cannot do it because otherwise we have a problem, which is that the State is the only one correcting negative externalities. And so, it is increasingly indebted to pay alone for the response to climate problems, to pay alone for the response to inequalities. And you have in a way a model where public debt becomes too important and/or it is the taxpayer who comes to pay for all these crises. The taxpayer is in a way the sedentary of this model and one who cannot also reap all the benefits. That is why my conviction is that the capitalist model, because I believe nonetheless that we will build the future of humanity by keeping some fundamentals: private property, cooperation, individual and collective freedoms that have made our societies. And so, all this must simply lead to rethinking our organizations to reintegrate at the heart of the company. Well, the consideration of social inequalities in our countries, inequalities between different geographical spaces, the climatic consequences that we are experiencing, among others.

And in essence, what we have called in recent years the economic, environmental, and social responsibility of our companies, the impact approach of our companies, are innovations that we now need to push much further and we must reform our companies within themselves so that at their core, so that, in a way, all stakeholders, therefore stakeholders, employees, leaders, shareholders integrate into their behaviors, but also into what we measure, well, the impact of their actions in economic, social, environmental, and democratic terms.

Prof. Klaus Schwab

You mentioned that in measurement, I am very happy, Mr. President, to tell you that today, we announced the commitment of the company here virtually, to report regularly according to very precise criteria on the progress they are making in their social, ecological responsibility and also regarding the drop [inaudible]. I would like to return to ecology. I believe with the commitment now of the Government of the new American administration for the goals of the Paris Agreement. My question is, we have certainly made a lot of progress, but I ask you: are you satisfied with this progress? Or would you like a sort of new consensus that goes beyond what we have discussed and decided before?

The President of the Republic

I think several things on this subject. First of all, we have a question of implementation, we have discussed and agreed on many things: a climate agenda, the Paris agenda. And today, we are not all together at the rendezvous, exactly of our actions. And so, I think that the priority of priorities is to do everything in a coordinated manner to meet our commitments. I say in a coordinated manner because in a way, the free rider can destroy the whole system. All this only works if we move forward together at the same pace to avoid creating competitiveness biases. And it is in this that the last few years have been crucial at the moment when the United States of America decided to leave the Paris Agreement in the summer of 2017, there was a great risk. And I still see the years that have just passed as years of remarkable resistance where the house of cards did not collapse because we all held together, we created this initiative of the One Planet Summit on December 12, 2017, with these coalitions. We all held together, Europeans, with many emerging countries, developed countries, with China, it must be said, which cooperated very strongly and with the private sector and the U.S. federal states. And now we have an American administration whose first gesture is to return to the Paris Agreement.

So, my first objective is that we uphold these Paris agreements; raising our 2030 targets, we did it as Europeans last December with the emission reduction as we said, -55%, which is a very important target. The second point, carbon neutrality by 2050. These are the two absolutely decisive points for structuring our behaviors in the coming years. Behind that, we need to break down these strategies at the regional and national levels, and that is the hardest part, that is to say, having a carbon price that is sufficiently high, mechanisms that encourage our companies and our investors to move faster in that direction, mechanisms of support and sanction so that companies and households can go faster and stronger, that we renew our car fleet more quickly, that we change our building renovations faster, etc. etc. So that is the first pillar, it is essential.

The second pillar is to truly engage the entire financial sector and all companies, and that ties into the discussion we had just before. We have very important coalitions in this regard, and I believe a lot in the initiative we set up with the One Planet Summit, sovereign wealth funds, asset managers, and private equity. And we brought them together on December 12 last year in virtual mode. And now, we have succeeded in generalizing, indeed, a common nomenclature. Everyone has committed to the task force for Climate-related financial disclosure, TCFD, which is a real advance in this regard. We have a common methodology and we are moving forward. So investors have committed to a measurement methodology that corresponds exactly to what you just said and which is now being applied to companies. And for example, we obtained last December, on December 12, that the 40 companies of the French CAC 40 integrate this methodology. This means that they will have to report to their shareholders, to the markets, the fact that they are indeed compliant with these commitments and that they are making efforts.

The third pillar of our action is that we do the same on biodiversity. I truly believe that we will only uphold the climate commitment if we manage to engage our companies, our investors, our countries on a biodiversity agenda. This is the whole meaning, by the way, of what we have done with One Health, which is to bring together our issues of human health, biodiversity, combating climate change, and desertification. But I truly believe that we are still only at the beginning on climate, on biodiversity. And this is very important because it involves changes in production in our agriculture, changes in our mode of consumption, in our way of life. And so, this year we need to build the common rules. And so when you say what should we succeed in negotiating more? Well, I think that at the COP in Kunming, we need to succeed in negotiating the equivalent of the Paris Agreement for biodiversity. We gathered a few days ago in Paris and in virtual mode, a One Planet Summit on biodiversity, it was the first of its kind. We took several very strong initiatives: the Great Green Wall, precisely, to succeed in combating desertification in 11 countries of the Sahel and the Horn of Africa; many initiatives in terms of biodiversity. And we launched an initiative, there too, for financial disclosure to integrate biodiversity into these criteria, with a meeting that will take place this summer. And so, that is the key point. Here are the three pillars.

Prof. Klaus Schwab

Mr. President, if we take all these changes, does that also mean a new mode of globalization? Is it also, as they say, a "new normal" for globalization?

The President of the Republic

Absolutely. I will tell you, everything we are discussing converges for me towards three elements. The first is that we must build a new consensus. Last November 11, during the Paris Peace Forum, we tried to bring together heads of state and government, NGOs, international organizations, and intellectuals to reflect on what we very immodestly called the Paris consensus. It is a consensus from everywhere, no matter what, but to say that several decades after the Washington consensus, we need to build a new consensus whose rules are not the reduction of the state, the decrease of the public sector, and the creation of value solely for the shareholder. Therefore, we must build, and this is exactly the discussion we have been having together, a new consensus that integrates all of this and puts it back at the heart of the model. The second point is that we need to find a new mode of cooperation between states, that is to say, to rediscover effective multilateralism. This is what I have believed in for years. It was indeed blocked by an American administration that did not believe in it. I have a lot of hope at the beginning of this year with an American partner, I hope, who will re-engage, and therefore we must build effective multilateralism that will allow us to respond to and implement this new consensus. And then, the third thing is that we need to build these new coalitions, the very ones we tried to construct within the framework of the One Planet Summit. That is to say, fundamentally, to respond to these challenges, the "new normal" you are talking about is an interaction, and I commend the very innovative nature of your forum; for decades, you have thought about this, that is to say, cooperation, but concretely between states, NGOs, businesses, and investors. That is to say, this "new normal" we are talking about, the staging of the consensus, is not just intergovernmental multilateralism; it is coalitions of heterogeneous actors who set the same objectives to achieve results.

Professor Klaus Schwab

Mr. President, this gives me a reason to ask you: I know your interest in all new technologies, in what is called the Fourth Industrial Revolution, but in its entire conception, let’s say, digital plays a very large role.

How do you see the impact of the power of the digital ecosystem on everything you have said?

The President of the Republic

I think there are several. The first is that we are indeed multiplying revolutions when we talk about digital. There are several revolutions in one. We are at the beginning of several technological revolutions that completely change our dimension. We have the revolution of artificial intelligence, which will totally change productivity and even go beyond what is conceivable in many sectors, from industry to health to space. Next to the revolution of artificial intelligence, there is a second one that, for me, is fundamentally important, which is that of quantum technology, which will also, through computing power and the capacity for innovation, profoundly change our industry, changing the sensor industry and therefore what we can do in aeronautics, what we can do in the civilian sector, completely changing the reality of cyber, for example; and our computing power, which also means the capacity we have to solve problems. I take the epidemic we are currently experiencing; artificial intelligence and quantum technology are management tools for transforming the management of the epidemic. That is to say, you will be able to solve problems that today take weeks, in one day. You will be able to solve diagnostic problems, perhaps in a few seconds, thanks to the intersection of medical imaging and artificial intelligence. And so, in the large family of what we call digital, we actually have a convergence between innovations, those of digital, which is fundamentally, when we generically call it, social networks and hyper-connectivity with those of artificial intelligence and quantum technologies.

The marriage of all this means that we are entering an era of acceleration of innovation, of very profound disruptive innovation, and therefore of the ability to commoditize certain industries and create value very quickly. In relation to what I have said, what impact does this have? One, we will continue to innovate and accelerate. That is certain. Two, there will be impacts in terms of social adjustments, and we need to think about them right now. That is to say, the issue of social inequalities will be even more pressing in a world like the one I just mentioned because we will have impacts, adjustments that will be real and that need to be thought about right now. Three, all of this has massive impacts in democratic terms. And so, if you will, for me, these innovations will be accelerators of our problems in social and democratic terms. The American experience of recent weeks has shown this in democratic terms, if it were needed. Four, the good news is that I think we have probably underestimated the contribution of innovation to the resilience of our systems and the response to the climate crisis, and I also think that all these technologies will allow us to respond to climate challenges much more quickly.

And so, if I look at it, if I take two steps back from everything we are discussing, I think our economies will increasingly need to invest in these innovations, and we must go all in. I believe that if we do it right and cooperate with each other, these innovations will allow us to create value, to respond to economic challenges. They will allow us, I hope, I believe it is possible, to respond more quickly to climate challenges. And that is also why I believe in what I call the economy of better, the climate response through innovation rather than by halting activities. But they will pose problems that we have not thought enough about in democratic terms, in terms of public freedoms, and in terms of increasing social inequalities in our different nations.

Professor Klaus Schwab

Mr. President, that was truly a comprehensive vision of our future. But our future will not happen automatically; it must be built. And I am happy, we have seen, through your presentation, that there are people and leaders who have a very clear perspective on what this future should be – what this future we want to build for the good of everyone should be. So thank you very much, Mr. President, and I am sorry that technology, for a moment, with the line between Paris and Geneva, reserved some surprises for us. But I believe it was a great event looking towards the future. Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Republic.

The President of the Republic

Thank you, Professor, thank you dear Klaus, and I thank everyone. Indeed, we are sometimes immersed in the daily grind, but I think it is also important – and thank you for giving me the opportunity – to try to look together at the course and to exchange on these subjects. And your conclusion expresses it very well; I share it, and I will stop there, let us never forget that our objective is always in society to build the good life, with the virtues that go with it and the will to respect others. And I think it is in service of this objective that we must put each of our actions. So thank you very much, all my best wishes, and I hope to see you very soon in person.

Professor Klaus Schwab

See you soon, goodbye Mr. President.

The President of the Republic

Thank you very much, thank you Klaus, thank you Professor.