Press conference at the presidential palace in Egypt.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

28 January 2019 · Press conference with the President of Egypt · presidential palace

Context
Macron and Egyptian President al-Sisi held a joint press conference in Cairo on January 28, 2019, during Macron's first official visit to Egypt.
Main themes
Egypt-France bilateral relations, strategic partnership agreements, counterterrorism cooperation, economic cooperation and investment, cultural and educational exchange, human rights dialogue, Franco-Egyptian cultural year, French investment in Egypt, regional security, sustainable development
Duration
~60 min
96th percentile
Words
7,147
96th percentile
Sentences
307
95th percentile
Readability
49
59th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.03
52nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
32nd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

307 sentences in 37 paragraphs

First of all, I would like to welcome Mr. President MACRON, and the official delegation accompanying him, and the dear guests of Egypt, during his first visit as President of the French Republic, and this in light of the friendship and strategic partnership between Egypt and France. It is a bond of friendship that is based on a long history of common interests and human synergies and oscillations between the two peoples for centuries, which has strengthened what the countries have witnessed in terms of relations over the past years of continuous cooperation in all political, military, security, economic, and cultural fields and the high level of coordination regarding various regional and international causes. I reviewed with Mr. President MACRON the various aspects of bilateral cooperation. Likewise, we jointly witnessed the protocol procedures for the signing of a number of agreements and memoranda of understanding for cooperation in various fields such as transport, health, culture, education, communications, youth, international trade, and energy. In addition to memoranda of understanding to establish a strategic partnership with the French Development Agency, from 2019 to 2023, amounting to one billion euros, our relationship today represented an important opportunity to review the most important steps for the implementation of the economic and social reform program carried out by Egypt since 2016 aimed at remedying the structural imbalances that the Egyptian economy suffered from a few decades ago. This is a program that has been praised by various international financing institutions. We agreed on the necessity of giving momentum to cooperation in various economic fields and increasing the volume of trade exchanges and investments to reflect the weight and strategic and political ties between Egypt and France. In this momentum, I emphasized to Mr. President that Egypt welcomes the French companies and their participation in the giant national projects and to take advantage of the promising opportunities in the various sectors of the Egyptian economy. Besides my personal commitment to supporting and promoting foreign investment in Egypt in general and French investments in particular, I drew attention to the business forum between public sector company leaders at the end of this evening, which will lead to positive results that contribute to the common interests between our two countries. We also discussed ways to strengthen cultural and educational cooperation between Egypt and France on the occasion of the celebration of 2019 as the Franco-Egyptian cultural year, and also saw the cultural impact of the heritages of both countries and their impact on the cultural and social life of the French and Egyptian peoples. The Egyptian elite among the current generation has been inspired by the masterpieces of the French Renaissance, just as the French people and Mr. President MACRON are enthusiasts and passionate about Egyptian civilization, and here we cannot forget the contribution of French scholars in deciphering the secrets of pharaonic civilization. But Mr. President, ladies and gentlemen, our discussions today have witnessed an understanding, a convergence regarding the visions to continue the fight against terrorism, the security of both countries and their interests if they represent a direct threat to our efforts to achieve the requirements of sustainable development and the challenge to achieve the prosperity of our peoples. Our discussions addressed a positive dialogue on human rights in our two countries, the Middle East, and the European continent because we emphasized Egypt's interest in these principles and values at the global level, being an essential component of all efforts made so that the people of Egypt aim for and make progress towards progress and prosperity. All institutions of Egyptian society, executive, legislative, judicial, and civil, coordinate their efforts to evolve the human rights system due to a deep understanding of the factors of history, civilization, and heritage that guide the evolution of society in accordance with the degree of essential components that go hand in hand with its historical aspirations. Here, we must deal with the causes of human rights, through their comprehensive concept because all rights are intertwined and cannot be separated: the right to life, the right to security as well as freedom of expression and development, and also access to food, health services, education, and decent housing. These are rights that Egypt gives great priority to due to its responsibility towards its citizens and its commitment to the clauses of the articles of the Constitution that are considered a foundation for the protection of human rights. The Egyptian people have the right to assess the degree of political, economic, and social rights. It should also be mentioned, in this regard, to emphasize the necessity that the challenges we face, whether in the region or in Europe, the issue of terrorism and the high rate of crimes related to discrimination and xenophobia. We must insist on continuing to protect and advance our citizens, and we also reviewed the regional situations of common interest, particularly in Libya and Syria, the Palestinian cause, and the Sahel. Likewise, illegal immigration, in addition to the relations between Egypt and the European Union, and the priorities of the Egyptian presidency of the African Union during this current year, and the opportunities to initiate trilateral cooperation between Egypt and France to promote development efforts on the African continent. I, for my part, emphasized that Egypt supports political efforts aimed at resolving regional conflicts, maintaining national statehood and territorial integrity, and preventing its fragmentation or allowing external forces to continue to destabilize the security of the region to achieve some ideological objectives or their interests. Mr. President, I welcome you once again to Egypt, and we express all our appreciation for the support presented by Egypt and the accelerated and fruitful development that our bilateral relations witness in all fields. Thank you, and now allow me, Mr. President, to give you the floor. Sir, the floor is yours.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Mr. President. Thank you for your welcome and hospitality towards me, my wife, and the entire delegation accompanying me. I received President SISSI in Paris in the autumn of 2017, and we agreed to meet again in Cairo, and between these two meetings, we have multiplied telephone exchanges to discuss many situations, and I will return to that, in the region, as well as the bilateral relationship. This trip to Egypt is very important for me. It is indeed an opportunity to strengthen the bond with an essential partner for the entire region, a partner with whom we have a strong history, mutual respect, with whom we wish to do more. With President SISSI, we have just had long exchanges and in-depth discussions on both regional crises and the bilateral situation, and I believe I can say that on many of these subjects, we have converging views. On regional issues, we have been working together for several months on the situation in Libya, which is a major stability issue for our two countries. The close and trusting dialogue we have maintained for several months on this crisis has allowed us to converge, and above all, to act in concert on the ground. I believe I can say that we have two objectives. The first is the fight against terrorism, and support for all Libyan actors who are effectively fighting against terrorism in their country, and the second is national reconciliation, which alone will ensure the necessary stability. In this regard, we had coordinated before France took several initiatives, starting, indeed, in July 2017 with the conference in La Celle Saint-Cloud. We have constantly exchanged when France brought together all stakeholders in the spring of 2018 in Paris, and I believe I can say that, through our work, we have succeeded in consolidating the beginning of reconciliation on the ground, and we will ensure that the coming weeks and months allow us to advance in this direction. Obviously, our work is done very closely with the United Nations Special Representative, Mr. SALAMEH. We are also working closely to coordinate our actions in response to the Syrian conflict. France and Egypt are indeed both part of the Small Group that brings together 7 countries around the goal of finding a sustainable political solution. And I must say that on this subject, too, our convergences are strong, and we reaffirmed it together this morning, which consists obviously in Syria not only to fight against Islamist terrorism but to ensure that an inclusive political solution will be established on the ground. This is in accordance with Security Council Resolution 2254, which we wish to implement with all our partners. This work will continue, the format we have decided has already shown its strength, and we will continue discussions in the coming weeks both with the United Nations and the regional powers to achieve, precisely, the constitutional and political developments that alone will be able to ensure the stability of Syria. We agreed that in the current context, and while the Syrian regime has given no indication of wanting to engage in a political discussion, the prospect of normalization or trivialization of the situation would be irresponsible. Our position is indeed to continue to work in accordance with what has been agreed upon at the United Nations in a process of constitutional and political transition.

We also exchanged views on reviving the peace process between Israel and the Palestinians. The current impasse is very clearly a concern for us, and I want to commend President SISSI's commitment to the dialogue and the policy we want to pursue. Here too, we are both convinced, and we will have the opportunity to carry out, to work together on multiple initiatives in the coming months, but we are convinced that the solution, which we have been advocating consistently for several decades, is only possible if the discussion is restored on the ground. And I want to commend your commitment to the intra-Palestinian reconciliation process.

We also discussed Africa, which will be an important subject in our common political agenda in the coming months, especially as in a few days President SISSI is set to take the presidency of the African Union. Our two countries have a common African vocation, and we will work together, for example, on issues of African peacekeeping operations, and I reminded the President how last year France continuously acted with and alongside the African Union on many crises on the continent.

Of course, beyond these subjects, the bilateral relationship has structured our exchanges, bilateral relations of which one of today's priorities is the fight against terrorism and the desire to ensure security and stability, particularly on Egyptian soil. Egypt, like France, I hope you can hear, it’s crackling, Egypt, like France, has been severely affected in recent years by the scourge of terrorism. I heard that you could not hear anything. I stopped.

Abdel Fattah AL-SISSI

(untranslated Arabic)

Emmanuel MACRON

Can you hear me? Is it good now? Very well. So, I was talking about, beyond regional issues, the bilateral exchanges we have had: first and foremost, the issue of the fight against terrorism and security. Indeed, both countries have faced terrorism and the scourge of this Islamist terrorism. And I made it very clear to President SISSI that for France, the security and prosperity of Egypt are of the utmost strategic importance, and we have agreed on a new stage in our cooperation on this subject, which is absolutely essential. This is the basis of the strategic partnership and the foundation of what we are conducting together. In this regard, Egypt is truly a regional power whose stability is essential in our eyes: essential for Egypt itself and its 100 million inhabitants, essential for the entire region, and essential for ourselves. And the fight you are leading on this point, Mr. President, as you know, is extremely important to us.

I also shared with President SISSI my firm conviction, which he mentioned, that stability and lasting peace go hand in hand with respect for everyone's freedoms, everyone's dignity, and the rule of law. And the pursuit of stability and security that drives us within the framework of our partnership, which we discussed together in October 2017, cannot be dissociated from the issue of human rights. Conversely, a dynamic, active, and inclusive civil society remains the best bulwark against extremism and a prerequisite for the stability of the country. In this regard, I reminded President SISSI, in the trust and frankness that characterize our relations, of the significance of the actions he could take regarding, for example, the activities of non-governmental organizations in Egypt, including the legislative relaxations that would be introduced to make the NGO law more balanced, or concerning individual cases or blocked websites. In this context, we had an extensive exchange, and I was also able to provide President SISSI with a list of the issues that seemed most obvious and, in any case, most important to us. Beyond this point, I wished for us to establish a dialogue on these matters and informed President SISSI that I would be meeting tomorrow with representatives of civil society. For me, this exchange is part of this desire, this partnership, for the stability and success of Egypt, and that is how I understand it.

President Sissi informed me of his ambitious economic reforms, carried out courageously, and whose initial results have been praised. As Egypt returns to growth, I reiterated to President SISSI France's willingness to support the success of these reforms and to mobilize funding for them. In particular, in the next four years, one billion euros in new funding, notably through the French Development Agency, will be provided. And on this point, the previously signed agreements have demonstrated both the variety and strength of this commitment. I also wish for French companies to contribute and take part in the development of Egypt. I mentioned that with 100 million inhabitants growing by 2.5 million people per year, Egypt faces challenges in education, health, and employment that require industrial partnerships and investments. My message to businesses is simple, and we will have the opportunity to reiterate it at the end of the day: Egypt is transforming, Egypt is modernizing, Egypt is developing, and our companies must seize the many opportunities that arise in all these areas. In this regard, we will have, beyond the signed agreements, important agreements between RATP Dev and the Cairo Metro, which we value greatly and which we discussed with President SISSI. We have clarified many issues concerning French companies that are already engaged. I thank the President for his actions, and we wish to go further in the partnership.

On the one hand, we have reshuffled the official agenda, and we will go together to see the new capital project, which should be both an opportunity for a true economic partnership and infrastructure development, to enhance French expertise in smart city matters, but which should also allow us to develop our cultural partnerships. On the other hand, we will open together the prospect of new industrial cooperation in the automotive sector to launch electric vehicle projects, which President SISSI deeply wishes to commit to, and where France wishes to participate alongside him in this industrial ambition. Therefore, in the coming weeks, we will work on establishing this project for production capacity on Egyptian soil. The third point is in the area of regional infrastructure, railways, and roads. We wish to work together, again, to support Egypt in its national and regional desire to pursue ambitious infrastructure projects. Beyond these points, in health, culture, and education, we have also exchanged extensively on the development and cooperation issues we wish to implement. We have signed an important partnership in the academic field, particularly to train the nation's leaders in Egypt. We have a partnership university. We wish to significantly strengthen this educational partnership, giving much more strength and scope to this Franco-Egyptian institution. It is attractive and recognized, but we need to multiply it. That is why the French University in Egypt is intended to grow significantly in the coming years and must find prospects in the new capital. It is also for this reason that we wished to engage more strongly in the teaching of French in Egypt, through our educational network, and I thank President SISSI as well for his commitment to the teaching of French in Egyptian education, whether in the context of secondary languages or bilingual classes. This educational partnership, along with the significant increase in scholarships we have decided upon, allows for the mobility of students between our two countries. We will continue to deploy these educational, academic, and scientific partnerships, accompanied by a desire to go much further in cultural matters. Culturally, we have a history. Yesterday, we were with our minister in Abu Simbel, which in a way symbolizes this strong alliance between our two countries and the commitment of our experts and enthusiasts. We both wish to continue this work, on the one hand, through the consolidation of the French presence in archaeological and scientific fields and exchanges between our two countries, and on the other hand, through scientific and museographic cooperation between our two countries and the desire to exchange in the fields of Egyptology, Islamic art, and beyond, by fully participating, and we are organized to do so, in the deployment of the two major museum projects that your country is carrying, but also through the presence and partnership we wish to develop within the framework of the City of Arts and Culture in the new capital. All these projects demonstrate how much, in our eyes, the development, stability, and success of contemporary Egypt matter to us. They matter to us, given our history and what binds us, they matter to us, given its democratic and demographic strength and its military role in the region, and they matter to us, given the place that Egypt precisely holds in the region, within the African Union, in a few weeks, and through its role on issues in the Near and Middle East.

Thank you again, Mr. President, for your hospitality and the agenda we have thus defined together.

Unidentified speaker

[Speech translated from Arabic]

Thank you, Mr. President, and allow me to give the opportunity for two questions from each party.

I thank Mr. President Abdel Fattah AL-SISSI and welcome Mr. President of France. Mr. President, the Egyptian people were not the only ones, and the French people were not the only ones, but I believe the whole world admired your image yesterday when you looked at and admired the temple of Abu Simbel. This moment reflects your esteem for this Egyptian nation from the perspective of civilization, history, people, and established facts. We know this because the Egyptian people hold the French nation in the same regard, from the perspective of civilization and history, as well as the people. But allow me, Mr. President, last year when Mr. President Abdel Fattah AL-SISSI was visiting France, there was the joint conference. You clearly stated that you refused to intervene, you refuse that any state intervene in the internal affairs of others. You also clearly stated that you should not give lessons to the Egyptians on what they should do, because the Egyptians know very well what they should do. Yesterday, a few hours ago, we all watched the statements you made that were broadcast by some news agencies and some websites. I would like to ask about the statement, but already, what you just said now about the human rights file emphasized that the statements are 100% meticulous. Now, the question: what has changed in this year for you, for your conviction to change, and why are you backtracking on what you have already stated? Are we facing a new policy that will be adopted by France in the region? I hope to have clarification. Thank you, and you are always welcome in Egypt.

Thank you very much. Thank you for your question, Sir, and you are right to recall the historical link, the mutual respect between our two countries and the consideration we have for one another. France's policy has not changed in any way, and I will explain how. I deeply believe in the principle of popular sovereignty. It is up to the people of a country to decide the future of that country, and that is why, since I have been President of the Republic, France has not pursued policies that consist of explaining to any people what their future should be through excessive interventionism. It is about ensuring that reconciliations take place. It is about ensuring that the people can sometimes express themselves; when leisure does not allow them to do so, that is all the work we are doing in Syria, but it is in no way about wanting to shake up any government or dictate from the outside what the course of events should be. This principle is there; it is at the heart of the international policy that I pursue. The second thing, when I look at our friend Egypt, is the desire for stability. I said it: this is what led me in October 2017 to call for a form of patience, in any case, to consider the difficulties faced by President SISI. The stability of a country like Egypt indeed required that, in the face of intrusions, destabilizations, movements of this or that, in the name of a religion, distorting it, in the name of other interests, the government could be destabilized, which implied a response. And I reaffirm here very clearly this necessity. But we also have values; they are universal; they are not just the values of France, and we have demands for ourselves. Reciprocally, human rights are part of this, and we can speak frankly about these matters. And we can assert them, and that is what I have decided to do today and what I have done with President SISI, without going back on the principles I have laid out, without considering that we come to give lessons or destabilize. Why? In October 2017, we had a long private exchange with President SISI, and I handed him a list. Things have not gone in the right direction since October 2017. There have been bloggers, journalists, activists who have since been imprisoned. This is a reality, and I cannot act, given the respect I have for Egypt, as if nothing has happened. In this context, I believe that having a demanding dialogue on human rights is entirely consistent with the objective that is ours and this dialogue of friendship and respect. First of all, because Egypt's international image can be tarnished. We must be clear-eyed; you commented on today's press, 'imagine that you see the daily press.' When presenters, bloggers are imprisoned, it is not good for the image of a country that is dear to me and that surprises me. And as I am committed to the success of Egypt in the contemporary context, I think it is good to provide a response to this point. The second thing is that the success that President SISI believes in for Egypt depends on the success of the economic, intellectual, and academic world, the ability to attract the best minds and keep them. The best minds need freedom. The best minds need freedom, to be able to express themselves; they need controversy; they need to be able to say, to do. And so I think that enlightened Egypt, and what your president, your country represents, needs this freedom. Finally, because I believe that true stability comes from this vitality of civil society. And as much as I deeply respect all the decisions related to the stability of Egypt, to the will expressed by the president to not be destabilized, to be able to develop tourism and the economy, and I will support Egypt on this path with all my strength, the president knows it, this is the meaning of our exchanges and what we will do, as much on certain specific cases, it has appeared to me that there was no risk of destabilization. And that is the purpose of the exchanges we have and of the list I was able to give to the president. It is also the whole meaning of the reform that can be carried out by the president. So I think that the discussions we have, the expression I can have here, is respectful of Egypt's sovereignty. It is commensurate with the consideration we have for one another. Two great nations whose vocation is to enlighten the world. And it goes through a dialogue that continues, because, on certain specific cases, President SISI may not agree, will tell me the reality of facts that I may not know; on others, I also know that he will be able to make things evolve. But I think it is important, and I would not be a sincere friend of Egypt today if I did not express my true thoughts, being fully aware of all the differences, of everything that makes Egypt today and all its challenges. I do not underestimate any of the security challenges that President SISI faces. I do not underestimate any of the difficulties of rebuilding a state, of developing a tourism economy, nothing. And so I make no shortcuts and I give no lessons. I also see all the efforts being made to ensure that all religions are recognized, that freedom of worship is fully recognized, the freedom to believe as well as not to believe, and I salute them, and I support them. This is one of the reasons why I also want to see the new capital where, a few days ago, the president inaugurated the church and the mosque. But I know all this; I also know what I read, as you do, and hear. That is why we have this dialogue. That is why I have expressed myself in this way.

Jean-Rémi BAUDOT

Hello, Mr. Presidents, Jean-Rémi BAUDOT for Europe 1 in Paris. Can you hear me? We just talked about civil liberties. You wanted assurances from your counterpart on human rights. What have you concretely obtained regarding this list you mentioned? Have any names been cited, with what progress? And Mr. AL-SISSI, President MACRON was concerned yesterday about the arrests; he brought it up again today; NGOs are denouncing an alarming situation.

Abdel Fattah AL-SISSI (translation from Arabic)

I hear you well, I hear you well, I hear you well. Allow me, allow me to thank Mr. President for the interest he shows in the stability and security of Egypt and its progress. And it is normal for France, given its historical ties with Egypt, and this is also appreciated in the person of Mr. President. But I would like to add a dimension that we always talk about here in Egypt regarding human rights. We must recognize and speak clearly: we are not like Europe, we are not like the United States; we are a region that has specificities and its own special nature. And by the way, the plurality between countries and the differences between countries is normal. There is not a single state in the world where we cannot have the same methodology, and we say that this is the ideal methodology. We cannot say that, but we can say that the human diversity that exists everywhere in the world is normal and will persist. And I believe that the attempt to change this (...). But that is one point. The other point is that it is just when we address the issues in Egypt, Mr. President addressed the population of Egypt, of 100 million people; their stability and security are very important. And is the volume of freedoms available to them and how much freedom of expression is available, yes or no, is the freedom of justice available, yes or no, I emphasize this to reassure the one who asked the question regarding freedoms and human rights in Egypt. But do not forget that we are talking about a troubled region; it seems to me a part of this region. There is a great project that should have taken place in this region, and Egypt, Egypt... this project did not achieve success in Egypt, which is the establishment of a religious state in Egypt in the true sense of the word, involving all the challenges for the region and even for the people of Egypt who rejected this. That is another point I would like to add. But I would like to say that, let us talk about the volume of efforts that have been made by the Egyptian state and by President SISI in the framework of human rights as the UN itself sees. When I tell you that I had 250,000 families living in a completely inhumane manner, at all. They lived, because I must not hurt our citizens, but they were in conditions that are not decent at all. When the Egyptian state offers them, and the Egyptian state that has difficult economic conditions, that is facing, fighting against terrorism for five years, taking into account the security, economic, or material cost, that it offers 250,000 furnished housing units, it is to say to these citizens that the state takes into consideration, it will not let you live on the street, you and your family. And because, among the reasons and causes of extremism, we can multiply them if we leave these citizens homeless or without a decent life. That is one point. When I tell you that I have waiting lists concerning sick people in Egypt, and Egypt could remedy just 10,000 people per year and allocate resources in this regard, when Egypt comes in the last 8 months to treat 10,000 patients each month, that is, 120,000 waiting cases to receive treatment, tumors, surgery, major surgery. Is this, when I do this for 120,000 people, to make their families satisfied, does Egypt not take into consideration human rights, from a different perspective than the one you are talking about while valuing it? But, and that of the bloggers too. But Egypt will not live through bloggers, and I tell you this very clearly. Egypt, through work and perseverance, will live. We are making an economic reform, a social reform, a political reform, and a religious reform. I want to tell you that, was there anyone who could, who could talk about the ties between Egyptians one another? Today, in Egypt, if we say a Christian Egyptian or a Muslim Egyptian, it is considered an offense; it is unacceptable for us. It is only Egyptian, who has all the rights of citizenship, even if those who do not believe are taken into consideration. These are practices carried out in fact so that Egypt, we have access to citizenship and brotherhood among people. I want to tell you in Egypt that every year we have a million graduates. You told me, well, you want the rights of bloggers. I ask you the question: how am I going to have access, find jobs for all of this? A million graduates every year. What can I do? I am ready to lend, lend to the hearings, hear your advice, but tell me what I can do? I can provide money for the million who graduate each year and the 2,000, and the 2.5 million who are welcomed each year and who want to have access to education, to food, to medical care.

Tell me, what can I do? How can we solve everything? These are all the questions. I regret that bloggers speak a completely different language from what we live. I speak frankly, we have nothing to hide, not at all, and we fear nothing. Our leaders, our country, through honesty and dignity, to have access to a society that goes hand in hand with Egypt, which has a long history of 5,000 years. When I implement a program that is the largest globally for the treatment of hepatitis C in Egypt, there were millions of citizens suffering from this disease. A country such as an advanced country in Europe can carry out such a program because they have local economic capabilities. But when I, in Egypt, do it, not I, the Egyptian state provides access to treatment for 55 million [00:41:08 INCOMPREHENSIBLE] to ensure their [---] and to remedy the rate that existed in the world. I mention this because if we want to talk about NGOs and civil society, civil societies exceed 45,000 in our country and they play a perfect community role. And when we found that the NGO law was controversial, we brought it back to the table and said, "Tell us what we can add because if we talk about a country, a state of such volume, NGOs play an important role in the shadow of a difficult economic and social situation. So we must listen to them. I mean that we should not limit human rights in Egypt, with all due respect to people's opinions, but people's opinions are one thing and the destruction of the state is something entirely different. I sincerely hope that we are not far from what happened in the region before, in the countries. Egypt should have met the same fate and I believe here that, what could you have done if the Egyptian state had witnessed a civil war? I speak to you frankly and transparently and I said this directly at the first meeting three years ago in Parliament. I said this and I said: be careful that the causes we witness here are completely different from what you think. And you should not look with your own European eyes only [00:42:55 INCOMPREHENSIBLE], that is, you must look at us with your Egyptian eyes and not through European lenses. Because otherwise, you will be unfair to us, and what makes the international reputation are the accusations, and as long as we have not addressed the issue of human rights, I do not want to speak longer, because Mr. President has a busy agenda, but I would like to reassure you and I emphasize once again, from my position, I do not accept that public opinion in Egypt where the majority of Egyptians refuse my presence, and I continue. Perhaps this is the tenth time I say this to Egyptians but I am here by the will of the Egyptians and if this will does not exist, then I resign from my position. Mr. President, the floor is yours. Yes, who wants to ask a question?

Unidentified speaker

Thank you, Mr. President SISSI. Mr. President MACRON, welcome again. In reality, France, always for us, as the Egyptian people, we see it as an oasis of democracy and freedom, and we admire the election of Mr. President MACRON and through this love of the Egyptian people, we have reviewed the media and recent events in France, with the yellow vests. We really suffered when we saw some who committed acts of vandalism in Paris or in other French cities, but we also saw in the streets how the protesters and hundreds of people were treated, not to mention a person who died on Tuesday.

Mr. President MACRON, how will we treat the people who have been arrested, in the context of human rights? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, on the subject, because I do not want to forget your question, I gave a list to President SISSI, and on this list, it will now be up to him to look at the situation on a case-by-case basis. So, I did not expect an answer today. On the rest of the subject, I have elaborated extensively in response to the previous question. I thank you, sir, for your words for France but at least, you will have noted that in France, it is allowed to express oneself freely. Sometimes, people forget this and do not rejoice in it enough. But in France, one can say everything, sometimes a lot against the country itself, I regret it, but one speaks freely against the country, the president, the government. This is the strength of a democracy and so you have had access to images, protests, and all this is good and well. Then, there have been demonstrations, with the expression of a protest anger, indeed several angers that have manifested, and there is in our country a freedom that is constitutionally guaranteed, which is the freedom to demonstrate, and we intend to protect it because we care a lot about it. During these demonstrations, which you have noted have never been prohibited, individuals, vandals, extremists have infiltrated and they have indeed sometimes committed the worst excesses, consisting of vandalizing businesses, public buildings or committing acts of violence against law enforcement or other people, and thus, legitimately, they have been apprehended, not apprehended because they said something, not apprehended because they thought something, apprehended because they were breaking, because they were destroying, because they were attacking other citizens or institutions. They are, in accordance with our law, being judged and thus, the procedures are underway. Some, by the way, have been released pending their judgment. They will be judged so that the law can express itself. This is a good thing. This is how things will be done. But I do not want to confuse or mix here these professional vandals and these extreme activist groups, who will be punished as provided by the law that was desired by the legislator, with the protection of the rights of the defense to which they are entitled, that these latter be confused with French citizens who were expressing their discontent, as they have the right to do, because that has nothing to do with it. Then, like you, I regret that 11 of our French citizens lost their lives during this crisis. I note that they all lost their lives often due to human folly but that none of them, none, was the victim of law enforcement. None. I say this clearly because given the nature of this crisis, what France has been experiencing for several weeks, it is unprecedented. I want to pay tribute to the professionalism of law enforcement in this context. But you see, contemporary societies can exchange everything and speak freely. These exchanges sometimes involve not mixing everything and not wanting to perhaps too quickly bring one reality closer to another.

Mathieu COACHE

Hello, Messrs. Presidents. Mathieu COACHE,

BFMTV.

A question for Mr. MACRON. Have you determined whether armored vehicles or other weapons sold by France to Egypt have been used in law enforcement operations against the Egyptian people, violent operations, and despite these recurring doubts about the conditions of use of these weapons, will France continue to sell them to Egypt and more specifically, have negotiations advanced on the sale of more Rafale aircraft or Patroller drones? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

On your first point, the arms sales you mention are mainly concentrated in the period 2010-2014. They all went through the procedures provided by France and the commission chaired by the Prime Minister, for military purposes. Of 200 interventions, at one point in 2013, the use of such an armored vehicle was identified. It actually led, under the previous mandate, to an exchange and clarification from the French authorities. It is very clear that, for us, the use of these armored vehicles is an initiation that must be exclusively military and that is clear between us. For all other military subjects that are under discussion, which you have also recalled, there is no possible ambiguity: these are subjects to defend, protect Egyptian territory against enemies coming from outside, and they are part of this strategic dialogue that we value and on which we are advancing. There are 24 Rafales that have been signed as part of an order, 23 have already been delivered, and we continue the work, and it will continue in the coming months. There were no other subjects discussed on these points today between President SISSI and myself, except for the requirement of partnership in terms of use, but also in terms of the quality of the partnership, of rapprochement between our forces and the operational partnership.

Abdel Fattah AL-SISSI (translation from Arabic)

Allow me to emphasize that the police do not deal with protesters through weapons or force. You must know this because the demonstration, the demonstration here in Egypt is a right stipulated by law and the Constitution cannot prevent this. But we ask people, if there are demonstrations, to do so within the framework of the rules in this regard. That is one point. The other point I emphasize is that we have not used armored vehicles, not just the armored vehicles provided to us by France, not for deterring protesters: no, we have never done that. We are talking about the period of 2011. Until now, there was a period when anarchy reigned in Egypt in 2011, 2012, and part of 2013, and I hope we remember that. But even there was treatment with extremist or terrorist elements, it was not, we cannot use weapons against an unarmed citizen, except when these citizens raise arms. And these are international rules. I am not talking to you about diplomacy, a political response, no. But precisely, we use weapons against extremist terrorist elements, and I mentioned to Mr. President a number, and I cannot cite it now because to respect the families of the martyrs and the injured in Egypt. We are talking about large numbers that fell during the confrontation: more than 100 people, men or women, or even children, during three strikes in churches. 324 people who were shot in 10 minutes in a mosque. Put this alongside that, we are talking about a situation that is present only in our countries. And despite that, I tell you once again, we cannot use armored vehicles against protesters: impossible. And I hope we will review the past. I am not defending, but I speak of principle: the right to demonstrate is a right stipulated by law. Freedom of expression, the right to demonstrate is stipulated by law and the Constitution. I would like to emphasize this. Any equipment from France before we hold to this regard. The French state itself insists that its equipment be used in the context of the fight against terrorism and the protection of the state. And I would like to remind you that we have 1,200 km of borders with Libya in common. How do we secure them, how do we secure these borders against...? Really, we gather terrorists from all over the world to be there to start and harm us and the neighboring countries, and also harm France and Europe. We must be sure that the equipment, the equipment cannot be exploited against citizens. Thank you and we welcome the president.